0:30. "Nothing you can do?” I have square bars. Wrapped with a thin cord in spiral. Not hearing any noise from roof rack now. I think this breaks up the vortexes into smaller ones, that cancel out.
same principle as communication towers mounted vertical , which also have these spiral ridges. that's exactly what they do, break up the air flow around the tube.
I really enjoyed your great video. Clear explanations. Great graphics! Loved the detail in them. Did you (or team) do them yourself? Reason # 2 made me laugh. Well done!!!
I agree: very useful advice! @Camperghini: Such a shame. Swop it out for a "Ludicrous Rack": no noise when driving my Tesla, even upto 240Mph, except for something that sounds like police sirens behind me. Sounds familiar?😂
Thank you for this! I just purchased a pre-owned vehicle, and it's making a lot of wind noise. At 2:27, I paused the video and went to check. Sure enough, the previous owners installed the roof rack bars backwards.
Very informative video! I'm wondering if you have any empirical findings using a varied diameter paracord with the wrapping method? I'm currently using 1/8", which has helped, but I'm considering increasing it to 1/4"... Will this further reduce noise? Thank you!
Thank you for the nice video! It's so reassuring so see that you basically have confirmed all my theories and current practices, though I didn't manage to make such a nice video and share it with the world as you did, many kudos to you! :)
Constant low pitch whistle from the JEGS cross bar while driving about 60 mph. I'm in process of adjusting it. About to install a JEGS box and thinking of installing a deflector
Thanks. It worked for me. But if I'd read the manual in the first place and followed the instructions, I would have got there sooner. But who does that?
Great video thanks. I have the Thule Edge black WingBars package - 7204, 7213B, 7212B - and use this with the Porsche performance roof box. I get loud whistling noise at 655-60 mph. Is this an issue with the installation or the combination of the Thule bars and Porsche roof box - Porsche have advised I use their roof bars as they are taller and this could be the reason but I can't believe Thule would have designed theirs to not be performant. Any advice you can offer? thanks
I used to have a Ford Aerostar with factory aerobars, with a slit on the top without a cover. The howling it made was really annoying, and it took me a while to figure out what the heck was causing it. It didn't occur to me that the aerobars might be missing a cover over the slit. The solution that was a very easy fix, once I thought of it, was to put a piece of rope in the entire length of the slit in each cross member. This disturbed the airflow enough to where the howling (whistle) never happened again, and the rope simply sat in there without moving for the rest of the life of the car.
Thanks for the video. I have a new VW electric SUV and the dealer installed roof cross bars on the factory installed roof rails. Wind is setting up a sympathetic vibration between 30 and 40 mph that makes passengers think they are inside a bass fiddle with someone playing long, low notes. It's way beyond what anyone would call a hum or a whistle. I'll try the solutions you suggest. Anyone else have this problem and found a solution?
Also have an Id4, however i just got the new yakima sightline fx aero bar and running into issues as well. As for your stock one a wind deflector will work, or running a rope around the bar as others in the forums have done. Hope this helps!
Thank you very much it helps me to understand why we should always install only recommended roof tracks and bars, i was thinking to install a diy basket but now I'll not. I can't handle the more noises from my car. Thanks again ❤
Generally roof rails are considered to be the ones that go along the length of the car, as in the bars along the sides fitted from factory, and can be used to mount roof racks, which go across the car.
Rails are parallel with the car, rack generally refers to perpendicular bars aka crossbars, and roof basket is the actual basket often mounted on crossbars.
Great that you could understand at least half of it! You've probably learnt a lot. I did too! She made herself understood, so cudos (compliments) for sharing some very useful tips! 🎉
Thank you. I moved my front bar back a little and it made a huge difference.
Remove the bars...wow wish I had thought of that
😂
😂
Scary how many don’t!
😂 but how many people keep em on the roof when not in use… not so stupid after all
only use them when needed... whou would thouth about that one
0:30. "Nothing you can do?” I have square bars. Wrapped with a thin cord in spiral. Not hearing any noise from roof rack now. I think this breaks up the vortexes into smaller ones, that cancel out.
same principle as communication towers mounted vertical , which also have these spiral ridges. that's exactly what they do, break up the air flow around the tube.
Now.this is.some very smart physics. Wonder why the producers don't apply this for the design.
Roof Racks are such a cool accessories!
I really enjoyed your great video. Clear explanations. Great graphics! Loved the detail in them. Did you (or team) do them yourself? Reason # 2 made me laugh. Well done!!!
Thanks very helpful to my Lamborghini rack design, although it’s fairly loud past 120 MPH
I agree: very useful advice! @Camperghini: Such a shame. Swop it out for a "Ludicrous Rack": no noise when driving my Tesla, even upto 240Mph, except for something that sounds like police sirens behind me. Sounds familiar?😂
Well explained, straight forward, excellent graphics. 🤜🏼🤛🏼
Thank you for this! I just purchased a pre-owned vehicle, and it's making a lot of wind noise. At 2:27, I paused the video and went to check. Sure enough, the previous owners installed the roof rack bars backwards.
really usefull video...the graphics and the explanation so concise... thanks so much
Clear to even a beginner. Thanks
thank you! i noticed i did not put the rubber seals in my crossbar, big help thanks a lot
Great video. You can minimize the noise but it is always there. As you said rather remove it when not in use.
Funny, informative and visually clear.
Very informative video! I'm wondering if you have any empirical findings using a varied diameter paracord with the wrapping method? I'm currently using 1/8", which has helped, but I'm considering increasing it to 1/4"... Will this further reduce noise? Thank you!
This was actually very helpful. Thanks!
Thank you for the nice video! It's so reassuring so see that you basically have confirmed all my theories and current practices, though I didn't manage to make such a nice video and share it with the world as you did, many kudos to you! :)
If the rack has an opening slit in the bottom. Cover with duct tape. ❤
I am going to try this and see if the whistle noise still coming out.
simple and very effective video :) very helpfull. I am a student of automobile eng, found this video, helped a lot.
Great video to understand. I have a near square bar. It gives noise around 80kmh. Most generic ones are square. Unless get thise expensive ones.
Great video and very well explained. Thnx
Try some surfboard pads, especially on rectangular profile bars. These can reduce wind noise, and fix harmonics as well.
I bought a pair of aero bars...5g3 funny thing is that doing highway speeds the noise us minimum... But around town they howl a bit...strange no!?
Excellent explanation skills
Constant low pitch whistle from the JEGS cross bar while driving about 60 mph. I'm in process of adjusting it. About to install a JEGS box and thinking of installing a deflector
Thanks for the video. which softwares did you use to 3D modelling?
SketchUp
good video this was .. very informative and brill visuals .. well done
Thanks. It worked for me. But if I'd read the manual in the first place and followed the instructions, I would have got there sooner. But who does that?
Very good video. (mature adult here).
Very informative video. Thank you
Thks &;
Every time I use tie-down straps on my roof rack , they vibrate in the wind & make noise.
???How do I eliminate this sort-of-thing???
Put a twist in them. If they are flat, they will vibrate, but a twist removes this.
Great video thanks. I have the Thule Edge black WingBars package - 7204, 7213B, 7212B - and use this with the Porsche performance roof box. I get loud whistling noise at 655-60 mph. Is this an issue with the installation or the combination of the Thule bars and Porsche roof box - Porsche have advised I use their roof bars as they are taller and this could be the reason but I can't believe Thule would have designed theirs to not be performant. Any advice you can offer? thanks
Thank you best one I have seen
I used to have a Ford Aerostar with factory aerobars, with a slit on the top without a cover. The howling it made was really annoying, and it took me a while to figure out what the heck was causing it. It didn't occur to me that the aerobars might be missing a cover over the slit. The solution that was a very easy fix, once I thought of it, was to put a piece of rope in the entire length of the slit in each cross member. This disturbed the airflow enough to where the howling (whistle) never happened again, and the rope simply sat in there without moving for the rest of the life of the car.
Brilliant explanation, thanks
Excellent instruction. Thank You
Great video, this is super helpful and the visuals are cool
Thanks for the video. I have a new VW electric SUV and the dealer installed roof cross bars on the factory installed roof rails. Wind is setting up a sympathetic vibration between 30 and 40 mph that makes passengers think they are inside a bass fiddle with someone playing long, low notes. It's way beyond what anyone would call a hum or a whistle. I'll try the solutions you suggest. Anyone else have this problem and found a solution?
Also have an Id4, however i just got the new yakima sightline fx aero bar and running into issues as well.
As for your stock one a wind deflector will work, or running a rope around the bar as others in the forums have done. Hope this helps!
Great explanation. Thanks
Great video❤
Thank you very much it helps me to understand why we should always install only recommended roof tracks and bars, i was thinking to install a diy basket but now I'll not. I can't handle the more noises from my car.
Thanks again ❤
Great work!
I have aero bars, have filled all holes, tried the spiral thing, and yet my rack whistles at speed! D:
Great vid btw
Helpful indeed! Cheers
Great video. thanks.
So helpful! Thank you
Wrap paracord around them looped about 2 inches apart
Very helpful
Great info.. thanks!
Drove with my wingbars on the weekend 217 km/h. Yes there is some noice but I can still talk while driving
I have a mitsubishi outlander 2023, original cross bar are installed and make noise. Anyone with a solution??
Very cool video. Thanks
good ideas!
So, the higher the worst?
i like the visuals
I installed one on Hyundia Tucson, and the whistle is very Hight over 40 km
Thanks for this!
Hello how thick is the rope?
let's say a bit thinner then your smallest finger
Well done and thanks
My car make noise at 60km/h what can i do to stop them ?
thanks 4 the video
I just installed the racks on my van and noticed the noise and now in the same day I see this video!??
Whelp, I have my cross bars on wrong. Time to turn them around
What is the second mistake, when you showed us the incorrect bar installation?
front bar moved to much to front of the car
Subaru Outback has a factory installed solution
Add roof rack pads. Shld use anyway when placing things on roof like a paddle board, etc!!!!
Oh no. My bars are on back to front. No wonder they make noise 😮
thank
Thank you. AWESOME.
So the best is not install it
Yes)
Thanks!
slava Ukraini
Rack it baby! 🤓
Damn my cheap shitty square-ass Sportrack crossbars
How mazda5
🇵🇬,,,
These are roof rails, not a roof rack
Generally roof rails are considered to be the ones that go along the length of the car, as in the bars along the sides fitted from factory, and can be used to mount roof racks, which go across the car.
Rails are parallel with the car, rack generally refers to perpendicular bars aka crossbars, and roof basket is the actual basket often mounted on crossbars.
If you could speak English, it would be great. You need to practice more because half of the words I can’t even understand.
So what other languages do you speak?
Great that you could understand at least half of it! You've probably learnt a lot. I did too! She made herself understood, so cudos (compliments) for sharing some very useful tips! 🎉
what about round crossbars on a custom-made application?
Good video. Thank you.
great video, thank you