Hey FROM fans! This theory got so massive and mind-bending that I had to split it into two parts! 🤯 -PART 1 (Today): We exploring into the trees as frequencies, those mysterious numbers, the Greek messages, and Victor's drawings. Plus, I'll show you the evidence that proves this isn't just speculation! -PART 2 (Tomorrow): how to break the curse, and the hcildren. And how ALL of this connects to Season 3! Let me know your thoughts on Part 1, and share your own theories about what else we might uncover tomorrow! This is just the beginning... 👀
@14:34 you said some buildings get sucked in... remember in the most recent episode the DAD asked. Where is the Motel? Why does it say motel but there's none here !!!!!!! ......... 🤯🤯🤯
I mean, there was only **one** mystery in LOST that went unsolved throughout the entire show-and it was tiny in comparison to the others. Everything else was wrapped up in a bow.
Unlike the Bottle Tree that Tabitha used to go to the lighthouse, the one found in the woods by Boyd and Sara wasn't a farway tree. So not all bottle trees are farway trees. The numbers in the Lighthouse were only seen in Tabitha's dream, but there were no numbers when Tabitha climbed the stairrs in the actual lighthouse. Before Dale went into the tree, what do all travels through farway trees had in common? The Boy in White. - The BIW guided Victor and Ethan to the farway tree when Victor made the stone demonstration to Ethan. - The BIW guided Victor to take Julie to the farway tree the night of the Colony House mas... - The BIW guided Sara to the farway tree when Boyd ended up in the dungeon well. - The BIW was expecting Tabitha in the Lighthouse when she went into the "special" farway Bottle Tree. So it's palusible to conclude that the BIW controls the farwasy trees (not numbers), and as Martin told Boyd, "they" (other forces) may caught you on the way after entering into a farway tree. Most likely this special farway Bottle Tree indeed takes you to the Lighthouse only, but it's not meant for anyone and for any purpose due to the lighthouse is a way out. So Dale wasn't suposed to get into this particular tree, and the BIW or other forces sent him to the pool so that all people in town could see it and receive the message.
It's worth noting that the BIW told SARAH to go through the Farway Tree and she had Boyd go instead because he was hurt. What if Sarah was intended to meet Martin- NOT Boyd?
So much to think through and go over after your theory breakdowns on the numbers. Crazy amount of work you put into that. Excellent job. The idea of things being random comes to mind when one of the newer people to the town asked where the hotel is. I thought this was too specific to be a random statement. He said there’s a sign for a hotel but there’s no hotel.
I'll be absolutely shocked if this show ends up making any sense. I'm loving it, but primarily because it just seems so off the rails, and the writing basically refuses to answer any questions at all. I wouldn't be surprised if S3 ended and there was no real answers to anything lol
I assume they just make it up as they go along (as they did with Lost) except in today's industry there is a much bigger chance of getting suddenly cancelled and not being able to wrap much up.
The writers said they hid clues in episode 1 in plain sight. So my theory is that the top of that billboard where the "Star Magic" sign was originally (We saw it in Victor's flashback of the massacre) is actually a secret portal similar to a faraway tree. Where it goes is anyone's guess, but it might be where the children are being locked away. We only ever hear about them being locked in a tower (they weren't at the lighthouse so it has to be somewhere different). I think if you climb through that empty billboard sign at the top, then the "motel" will appear to you similar to Boyd finding Martin in the ruins. If you rewatch Episode 1 at :37 mark- Boyd is ringing the bell walking down the street, the camera zooms in on the bell and the sign is directly behind the bell blurred in the background. 1:28 mark- Closeup shot of the pool as "We got to get out of this place" starts playing on the radio. Slowly zooms up and to the left until the top of the billboard is directly centered... Then quickly changes to next scene. 2:35 mark- Zoom in on the bell once again with the billboard again centered directly behind it. The wires hooked to the inner corners of the Billboard form an X.... X marks the spot? We know that the billboard once had a "Star Magic" sign at the top cause we saw it in Victor's flashback... Which means at some point between then and present day someone went up there and removed both sides of the sign (it's visible from each side). It wasn't something weather related IMO cause the rest of the Billboard is still perfectly in tact. I could be completely wrong, but my theory is the top of that billboard acts similar to a faraway tree where you can climb through and be transported. I believe that place is where the children are being imprisoned. The 1st episode that sign is shown a bunch more... 4:31 mark- Behind Boyd and Kenny 5:49 mark- As Frank's wife and daughter look across the street 6:21 mark- Overhead shot zooms in with sign visible 12:22 mark- Frank walking down the street 21:37 mark- Matthews driving into town 26:43 mark- Matthews driving back into town 26:59 28:50 29:04 They showed the Billboard like 15 times in the 1st episode.
@@joshs9857 this is great! Have been wondering since the first episode why there was a sign and no motel and about the car in the pool lol to piggyback on the first episode theme, don’t forget the cromenackle and her best friend (Nate? Nathan?) that was almost the first scene. I think it’s important
That's an incredible observation! Love how detailed you got with all those timestamp connections to the billboard. The Star Magic sign theory definitely feels like it could be onto something! 🤔
I've always wondered if julies tshirt that says "Illusions" is a hint to any of it. Also they mentioned the lake of tears. And elgin is drawn to the water. I wanna know if there's somthing important about the Brundels. Like where does it connect to. Or what's in the water
awesome awesome breakdown, only thing im afraid of is that we as insanely deep dive lovers are overthinking some things like man in yellow jacket and color on the website, i wouldnt be surprised that its just a coincidence
@@BEYONDPREMIERE numbers are definitely plausible, but watching recent episodes made me think... how the heck did Victor survive 30+ years alone as a kid amongst all the monsters? they were definitely aware of him and must have been looking every single night for him, no way he could survive that long without amulets, unless hes hiding some unexpected secret
@@bartasSM good question. Maybe the theory that monsters feed of hope is correct. Then they would want to keep Victor alive as he was their only source of food.
@@bartasSM I honestly do not think the monsters were interested in killing Victor. I think they viewed him as a scared child without anyone else around to care about him. When they kill, they like to inflict pain. They kill on purpose. With no one around to care for Victor, killing him off and not having a horrified audience would be useless to the monsters. Now that he is amongst people, there are so many less knowledgeable people to kill then for them to go after Victor. He was able to live there, learn from the boy in white , and know how to stay alive. That is much more knowledge than the regular person coming into town not knowing anything.
Remember when Father Khatri said in the first season that the Bible has never turned up in Fromville and he had to write out the pages from memory. That could not have been for no reason!
Father Kathri was no ordinary priest though- WHY would he officiate the obviously pagan Choosing Ceremony? He also said he felt peaceful and meditated inside the white stones of the circle where the Choosing Ceremony altar/table is located- between the town and Colony House.
The Faraway Trees and Bottle Trees evoke the concept of Yggdrasil, the World Tree in Norse mythology, connecting different realms. Similarly, in many African-American traditions, Bottle Trees are believed to trap spirits or provide protection.
I think the houses are all from a real town in the real world that was pulled into Fromville via a catastrophic event. The year was 1971 like the calendar on one of the house walls.
@@nicelol5241they are human before, i think they do some ritual to immortal or maybe the creature is tried to be human but somethings stop them and sealed them in the twon
The town appears to be an old "Company Town" like a mining town- the buildings lined up along a "Main Street" where the workers live (though there should be far more homes and shops for this to be the case) and a big Mansion nearby where the mine/plant/factory owner lives (Colony House). But everything seems taken from random times- maybe only snatched on the dates on the Lighthouse? That might explain how there's a Diner and a Motel pool and sign but no motel. Also, no motel would have it's pool right at the roadside - pools are always to the rear- away from roads and parking (and there's no motel parking either).
I think these theories are amazing and would work really well in a book. But if it’s the explanation it’s so over complicated for a tv show. It would need a massive exposition dump to explain it.
No shade whatsoever I love these theories and I think show writers how are paying attention to every detail of a shot because they know us nerds are going to freeze frame every scene hehehe sadly writers have to appeal to everyone but it’s nice they give us those little crumbs of extra content to go off down our own trails. Keep it up!
I still don't believe Tilly is/was a mere human. Too many coincidences with her redirecting people away from asking questions (like stopping Jim from investigating the flickering lights which seemed like a pattern in the school/medical building). Then she seems unconcerned when the crow first hits the glass window and not too freaked out after it breaks the glass, flies around and kills itself. She also has obviously bullshit answers when Jim was asking her where she was going to.
Maybe the bottles take you to your desired destination? For instance you grab a bottle and go into the tree and it takes you to a certain place instead of random
Rendez-move is a play on words for the French word Rendezvous. That word means one person meeting with another person or business anything. Getting together at a certain date at a certain time
I belive your are right about sacrefice part, when Martin died the trees started to lose their leafs. So I belive that forest/city run on sacrefices...
What i haven't seen is digging into the guy chained on the wall. That is someone currently in the show but much older. I think it's Randall. I think he finally goes back to the chamber and gets captured again. They are using his beard to cover his face where the scar is hidden. This is why he knows Julie and knows she shouldn't be there.
Sounds very interesting. I still find some things a little too thin, like connecting yellow website to man in yellow jacket, but numbers representing Greek words is very interesting. My leading theory, that is actually compatible, with what you said so far, is that we are in a broken repeat of the cycle. I think there was a cycle, that played out almost exactly the same, since it all started (perhaps when Europeans arrived to America, but that's just a wild guess). Cycles start, they play out and at the end everyone, without exceptions, dies. But there are some little details that can differ one cycle from another, little changes, that might persist from one cycle to the next. Those little changes accumulated in the last finished cycle with Victor being saved. Maybe those little changes were clues, that made Miranda hide Victor, maybe those clues showed her how to hide him, but at the end Victor survived, and that's why the cycle that we are seeing is so strange. It isn't exactly the same as what Victor remembers, and that's exactly because of his actions. Maybe Victor survived this long there, because monsters deactivate until the next cycle begins? Maybe Victor made preparations for this cycle, even unknowingly, following the Boy in White instructions. We even see one of his interferences on screen; he told Tabitha what to do, what his Mother plan was. If Tabitha is playing the same role as Miranda in the last cycle, she went completely off track because of this, discovering things, that she shouldn't know yet. So my theory is that everything is changing because the cycle is off it's rails, and the entity that controls it all desperately tries to get it back on track.
Boyd, Jade, Jim, and Tabitha are unknowingly releasing spirits from the mysterious bottle trees. Could their actions be responsible for the strange events and nightmares plaguing the town?
Love the theory. I realized the town is a potemkin village it was visited by Catherine the great in 1787 and if I follow your theory with the Greek meaning it translates to ἐντός (entos) -- within, among
My theory is that the town is a time loop, Tabitha is Miranda (victors mom) and Jim is Henry (victors dad). Ethan is Victor. Remember Victor talked about himself and his sister.
I think The script writers should have made it clear Who was the first to get there and amongst the existing Residents what are their order by arrival..
Demeanors of monsters changing fast and abrupt since Smileys/HowdyDoody demise. Beginning to think they see new crop of people more determined and smarter to escape with more hope in seeing it "possible." Think they want to escape, too. Right behind them on the trail. If electricity/power comes from ground maybe they need to regenerate in tunnels. Don't have much of a life. They know town folk are not going to help them escape.
I noticed that ghost children often use the word "anghkooey", which here in Bulgaria frequently use to mean coward, a person without dignity, or someone weak in character.
There has to be time travel, the well that Boyd goes to when he finds Martin is the same one that Randal, Julie, and what's her name go to when they all go comatose. It's the ruins in current day. It's destroyed usually, until they go into it those times.
1. You have to pull the numbers from the bottles as coordinates for where you wanna go. 2. Everyone in town is so caught up on Tabitha getting out that no one’s asking why she got sent back
This. Or the fact the she told someone about the town and SURPRISE SURPRISE,,, her (and the person she told, along with the paramedics and cop she tried to tell) ALL ended up in Fromville
I've been speculating that the numbers were coordinates and removing them from the trees is like removing code from a computer. In this case, it moved the destination of the Tree from near the lighthouse to near and in the pool. The numbers probably accounted for elevation- which is why Dale was in the pool wall, below ground level.
Boyd got numbers "1864" from the bottle trees, and it translates to "mockery" in Greek? Is this a coincidence? Because the monsters are mocking him, saying things like "Thought you said we couldn't break you" and things like this. And the way they made him watch that awful death, but didnt kill him, just forced him to watch.
If you rewatch season 1 episode 1 of from when Jim is driving around with the rv in circles around town look closely when they cross over the railroad each time. The first time there are power lines & and electrical box and the second there aren’t. This may or may not be intentional… just a thought
The link between the town’s cycles and floods or disasters resembles mythological flood narratives, such as the Epic of Gilgamesh or Noah’s Ark, where catastrophic events reset the world, beginning a new cycle. Boyd and his boat love makes me wonder if he is Noah. That drawing of the people on the water leads me to believe that this imagery will feature in the last episode somehow.
Judged by sunlight, unalloyed, pure, sincere> I spit out, disdain, reject, loathe.> A Greek, usually a name for a Gentile> On account of, because of, for the sake of, on account of, on account of which, wherefore, on account of what, why.> Nightly, neut. as adverb by night, in the night.> To contend with or for I contend earnestly for> Above, more than (a) adv: on the top, above, (b) prep: on the top of, above, over, on, above, more than, superior to.> To set (of the sun) I sink, set, set during, go down.> Bearing a mark, notable, notable, conspicuous.
I had this theory last night about the town watching a earlier episode no 8 season 1, I was like the diner was made in the 50's. It seems the towns been around long before the 1950s. Its must cycle into the real world time to time. Maybe those are those cycles. I need to dive into it more but i have had crap for time this week.
@@Father_DanielI keep thinking about Julie’s shirt in the first few episodes of season one that said “it’s all an illusion”. I started rewatching to get my mom onto the show last night and I noticed that on her shirt, wonder if it’s a hint that’s been there the whole time?
This code translation reminds me of the prophet Isaiah 53:3 - He (Jesus) was pierced for our transgressions and crushed for our iniquities. He was lifted up, mocked, and killed to pay the price for those who believe in him. Pretty amazing if they are taking this route! ✝️ Jesus is King!
Interesting connection! Isaiah 53:3 is such a powerful passage. It would be amazing if that’s the direction they’re going with this! Jesus is indeed King! 🙌
17:30 In the Bible, this word can be found in verses like Philippians 1:10, where it describes the quality of being "sincere and without offense." The idea is that something or someone is transparent and true, without hidden flaws or ulterior motives.
the numbers in the bottles represent how many times the cycle has currently repeated and continues to. as for the bottles on diffrent branches thats just what it is and represents, the branches represent different dimensions/universes where fromville is taking place
Think about it. Remember those wild dogs in Season 1? They're always circling, always coming back. Just like how Miranda's soul keeps returning as Tabitha. The show literally gave us a metaphor for reincarnation right under our noses! Dogs in various mythologies are often associated with the afterlife and rebirth. Just look at Egyptian mythology with Anubis, or Greek mythology with Cerberus. They're using this ancient symbol of death and rebirth.
In season 3 episode 4 or 5,. I heard a dog in the background barking.. not sure if it was bad editing or supposed to be there. I’m @2:57 rn and I just remembered that I rewinded the part about 4 times to make sure it the tv and not outside! It was in fact, the SHOW.
My main theory is: this is a cursed town, cursed by someone who cared about one or all the children who were most likely sacrifices for some ritual that most people of the town believed was necessary. This people then became immortal monsters (we know they were human before and they also behave like humans today, as Randall explained recently) and the town began to capture people all over the country - people probably related to the children somehow, reincarnations or something alike - to try and put an end to the children's souls suffering by releasing them - as the curse probably imprisoned not only their bodies but their souls as well - and the monsters "need" to keep protecting the town so the souls of the children are not freed. There's some holes in this theory but I feel like it's simple enough to be executed. This show isn't Dark or Mr Robot, feels way more like Lost. And Lost ended in a very simplistic way and I think we'll see the same here.
ALSO, about the show's name "From" I guess some of the people we watch are actually FROM that city somehow - related to the children's parents, for instance. Not everyone, since some of them got there with a lot of other people - these people are meaningless. That'd explain why some people can hear and see things and others just die randomly like the girl who was shot by the police lady.
@@Henrique.Souza0601yep think your exactly right tbh makes sense Given the show is called from like there blood is from there just not everyone and probs don’t even realise there ancestors first settled there and did some bad shit and are cursed Maybe like the show fear street
What about the complete blood circle symbol on the computer monitor in Tabitha's hospital room? Or her recurring head injuries? Or Boyd's recurring shoulder injuries- ALWAYS in the same place? And then there's the overt references to everything being a dream or nightmare? Fatima tells Julie "From this high, even a nightmare looks like a dream" which was entirely repeated through a flashback this season? Or Tabitha's dream of the little girl- obviously not her and from a far older time by the dress she has on? Or Boyd's flatly asking Abby's grave "maybe I'm in a hospital room and you and Ellis are trying to wake me up?" Or Abby saying it was all like a dream she had as a little girl? Maybe several people are or have experienced the same dreams as something we call "Fromville" tries to communicate or ask for help? Certainly there's a force trying to save the children and resolve whatever situation is keeping things in a repeating cycle.
The numbers inside the bottles might be the number OR the address of houses. For example if there is a paper with the numbers 1472 the house which has that number the people living in that house have a high chance of getting stuck in the town. Remember the monsters know everyone's name in the town, if all the numbers in the bottles aline with the numbers of houses in the real world they have planned already who gets stuck in town. sorry for my bad English
@@megs4193 thanks megs 👍my theory isn't great but if the numbers aren't years they are more likely house numbers and that's how the entity knows who is gonna be stuck in the town and if he controls the monsters then that's how the monsters know people's names 🤷 in episode 6 the lady said to Trudy "we know all of your names "
I definitely think the numbers are connected to the people that end up there. I was curious if it was birthdays or the date they came there. House numbers is a great one and one I didn't think of
@@wkeon they might be unless they are in the same car or bus with the person that is supposed to arrive there.( But also they might die cause they are not supposed to be there )Remember people who arrive into Fromvile are from different states of America Kansas Detroit etc. So 4 numbers could make sense because they don't arrive from the same place there is no limit like they can only come from one state no they can come from multiple states so they have more houses with 4 numbers.🤷
I think you are on to something because remember in the last episode when Victor father was talking to Ethan and he noticed the hotel and said why is there a hotel sign but no hotel...ok crazy theory but suppose this was related to Lost, meaning no island but Fromville represents something between the world we live in and somewhere else like a portal or a black hole on earth. And one last thing doesn't the cop look like she could be related the monster Smiley....hmmm..she is there for a reason and she knows more than what she is letting on
I’m going to have to watch this a couple of times! Christian & his beautiful mind! Hope you are working on a book or screen play of your own using what you’ve researched since this show. Unsure if the creators are this deep! Think about it-with all you’ve learned and been able to imagine since From-I can see you creating a masterpiece!
My theory, this place is a cage for those monsters. They are dead so they cant escape. But the people and the town are in quantum superposition (alive and dead) so they cant leave because when they try it registers them as dead when it tries to determine what state they are in. Thats why they cant escape yet.
Personal theory that's kinda dumb, but idk could be something Maybe the town is like a garden of Eden type situation, it's ancient (hence the existence of the monsters, and the fact the monsters either choose not to leave or can't leave) and it's designed to prevent humans from leaving, but still having someone guiding select people to the flaw that can let them escape
What is From isn’t in a set location? Faraway trees could have their destinations changed by this with the boy in white knowing this could advise residents when it is safe to go through?
@@BEYONDPREMIERE that might reinforce the theory that it could be entered from anywhere but cannot be found because it’s continually moving… Probably not correct but thought provoking nonetheless…
For all the commenters posting that some theories are just too far out there or that people are overthinking and many things are just coincidences rather than a key piece of the puzzle, etc., all I have to say is did y'all not watch Lost? 😂
Yes our theories are too complicated. I doubt the writers know where they are going cause they are throwing in too many elements. Monsters, cicadas, spiders, angkoee kids, BIW, dead ppl Jade & Boyd see, the Kimono lady, dreams/ visions etc. At the end they will saupy it some stupid dream of Victor's or alien/ give experiment or worse Limbo.
I think what is happening is that it's a place between multiple dimensions. Different creatures came and they are stuck here, but there is only one portal open, and that portal is the human realm.
Wery thorough and in depth theory. The only thing is, I think it is way to complicated. After all they have to somehow put that whole explanation in certain number of episodes. This is too much to include imo.
Explicitly. People are starting to overthink it. It’s not that deep. Some stuff are Easter eggs and some stuff you should ignore. Like the 2659, she just said it randomly from a stack. Meaning she had about ten others on her lap. Also connecting numbers on a wall carved to paper in a bottle on a tree is wild. Just because it’s four digits lol
@@cmasterson I agree people are overthinking it. The solution must be easy enough to be explained in very simple terms in the course of a few episodes,or even one whole season. I also think some things were just there to add to the mystery and to confuse characters, and us, and are not going to be explained at all as they are not crucial for the plot.
This reminds me of all the theories with game of thrones and how that will play out and some theories was so good it made peoples expectations so high. Odds are they all dead and that's it like lost and Manifest and they just need to lose hope to accept there fate like his wife said.
I already seen a theory like this but it added to it saying that the motel ended up underground and thats where the monsters live but I have no idea at this point all I know Is Fatima is not pregnant she's turing into a monster we will see next episode that Fatima is not pregnant with the ultrasound machine
@@JamesTTrott idk why but I have a feeling that the massacre Viktor witnessed coming out of the cellar will be recreated with Fatima becoming a monster and murdering alot of people just like how Viktor said Christopher stopped making people laugh my theory is Christopher turned into a monster but that just a theory
@@randomnugget7750 I honestly am hesitant to say that the massacre that happened when victor was little was done by monsters because there shouldn’t have been that many people outside first of all and the people that were dead had like nothing left inside of them which we see the monsters now don’t cut the people open as much as that
Strong's Concordance didn't exist until 1890, and his numbers were assigned to the words in the KJV Bible. It's a study aid for the Bible. But it's an interesting theory, that the bottle numbers represent words somehow. We've considered dates, and coordinates, but it could be something else somehow
@forzaazzurri1471 where did that come frome?? One of first motion pictures was of Battleship Potemkin. Russian. Decades ago, maybe 70s that I saw. Not sure of significance but the clips were not very interesting. I can Google later but won't tell me of importance then.
Very interesting with the numbers leading to words written in Greek. I said it before and I'll say it again and even with the new theory and the hidden code, "For the sake of (1752) higher understanding (1978) a Greek (1672) cries out in astonishment (1608) to the Master. Despite facing mockery (1864) and being lifted up (3333) to suffer harm, even until death (1931), this occurs to fullfil a greater purpose." This almost describes a "Christ" like fugure being crucified in the cross calling out to God after being mocked and made to suffer eventually fulfilling the prophecy of dying for our sins. I still believe Boyd is the Christ Figure.
I have a theory that this has something to do with African tribes who worship the forest and they have trees like this. This is about slavery and your mind's subconscious.
I think the numbers are a message. I think it has to be translated in Strongs Greek like you said. I think the kids are telling her to cut the trees down, I don’t think they need to go through the faraway trees, I think they need to be destroyed in order to free the children.
They didn't need the trees. There were no talismans back then so even the houses weren't safe at night. The monsters could just come through the front door.
@14:34 you said some buildings get sucked in... remember in the most recent episode the victors DAD asked Ethan Where is the Motel? Why does the sign say motel but there's none here !!!!!!! ......... 🤯🤯🤯 Crazy.. connecting idea. in season 1 episode 3 The preacher said 20 minutes 34 seconds... the people who live in Fault Line believe the ground can just open up and swallow them at any given moment ???
At this point I think that everyone has to die in order to escape because if the place needs to feed off their suffering and if there no one alive it sustains it self that’s why victor was left alive to feed of the suffering that he will never get home
I have a very basic question about this number theory; instead of leaving numbers that represent letters or words, why didn't those inhabitants just write in words?
S3 E5 made it clear Donna is mole, she cut off Henry in diner when he was gonna talk about park, she wants out more than anyone but still seems to fight every idea that might lead them out. She definitely talks to the monsters in the cut.
@@wkeon and her last name is Raines. Water is an underlying theme in this show. The Matthews camp site was known for flooding and Acosta told Boyd there was a huge flood that happened in her town last year and it was raining the night the Matthews and the bus came into town. Hints of boats throughout the show.. She also cut off Victor after she tells him his dad is there. He was about to say "that's impossible. He-" and cuts him off.
My thoughts are: Numbers are very significant in this show. For example: the number 12 (Devilied Egg Plate from Mrs. Liu’s funeral, Jim’s response to Tabitha, when Jim was trying to solve an equation was, the answer is twelve. 12 represents time, order and governance. All these themes are clearly portrayed in this show. (12 months in a year, 12 hours in day and night, 12 Zodiac signs, 12 disciples of Jesus). The number 78 is also significant in From! 1978 (the year Victor survived the massacre in the town), there are 78 Tarot cards in a deck (Tilly offers read the Tarot for Fatima) and ALL of the main characters we have been introduced to in this show, mirror Tarot archetypes. (Questions for discussion - Re: Bottle trees) Could the four digits be like an old school locker combination? 🤔 Meaning the combinations, unlock different destinations? 🤔 Could they be coordinates like those of a map? 🤔 Could they be addresses to specific houses/places? 🤔 The Jewish Kabbalah practice of Gematria may also be worth researching for its potential link to this show.
Hey FROM fans! This theory got so massive and mind-bending that I had to split it into two parts! 🤯
-PART 1 (Today): We exploring into the trees as frequencies, those mysterious numbers, the Greek messages, and Victor's drawings. Plus, I'll show you the evidence that proves this isn't just speculation!
-PART 2 (Tomorrow): how to break the curse, and the hcildren.
And how ALL of this connects to Season 3!
Let me know your thoughts on Part 1, and share your own theories about what else we might uncover tomorrow! This is just the beginning... 👀
Awesome u absolutely did your homework Nice research!
@14:34 you said some buildings get sucked in... remember in the most recent episode the DAD asked. Where is the Motel? Why does it say motel but there's none here !!!!!!! ......... 🤯🤯🤯
Is the tree that everyone see's before entering Fromville appear normal???
Or is it the first type of faraway tree that snares them.
But if the former residents were trying to help the future ones why put the clues in codes???
@@EzeAdiele only Tabitha and jade are chosen but why
3:33 "nothing in this show is without any reason"
People who suffered through Lost would like a word.
hahahah
I was looking for a comment loke this because, same. 🙃
I'd love every single minute of loss and still go and watch theories on TH-cam it's awesome what are you crying about patience is a virtue
Everything in lost did, too.
I mean, there was only **one** mystery in LOST that went unsolved throughout the entire show-and it was tiny in comparison to the others. Everything else was wrapped up in a bow.
I just hope and pray this doesnt take a LOST route
Yh me too, lost last episode was awfull....fuckin ghosts
I have no faith in the Lost writers. And they are the ones writing this show.
These are phenomenal breakdowns. Even if they end up incorrect, I appreciate the deeper thought and this is the reason I enjoy these types of plots.
I'm glad you're enjoying them, I try to leave no stone unturned haha!
Unlike the Bottle Tree that Tabitha used to go to the lighthouse, the one found in the woods by Boyd and Sara wasn't a farway tree. So not all bottle trees are farway trees.
The numbers in the Lighthouse were only seen in Tabitha's dream, but there were no numbers when Tabitha climbed the stairrs in the actual lighthouse.
Before Dale went into the tree, what do all travels through farway trees had in common? The Boy in White.
- The BIW guided Victor and Ethan to the farway tree when Victor made the stone demonstration to Ethan.
- The BIW guided Victor to take Julie to the farway tree the night of the Colony House mas...
- The BIW guided Sara to the farway tree when Boyd ended up in the dungeon well.
- The BIW was expecting Tabitha in the Lighthouse when she went into the "special" farway Bottle Tree.
So it's palusible to conclude that the BIW controls the farwasy trees (not numbers), and as Martin told Boyd, "they" (other forces) may caught you on the way after entering into a farway tree.
Most likely this special farway Bottle Tree indeed takes you to the Lighthouse only, but it's not meant for anyone and for any purpose due to the lighthouse is a way out. So Dale wasn't suposed to get into this particular tree, and the BIW or other forces sent him to the pool so that all people in town could see it and receive the message.
It's worth noting that the BIW told SARAH to go through the Farway Tree and she had Boyd go instead because he was hurt.
What if Sarah was intended to meet Martin- NOT Boyd?
So much to think through and go over after your theory breakdowns on the numbers. Crazy amount of work you put into that. Excellent job. The idea of things being random comes to mind when one of the newer people to the town asked where the hotel is. I thought this was too specific to be a random statement. He said there’s a sign for a hotel but there’s no hotel.
@@guninkdesigns3838 thanks for the support! I appreciate the feedback 🙌🙏
I'll be absolutely shocked if this show ends up making any sense. I'm loving it, but primarily because it just seems so off the rails, and the writing basically refuses to answer any questions at all. I wouldn't be surprised if S3 ended and there was no real answers to anything lol
Haha yeah it definitely keeps you guessing!
I assume they just make it up as they go along (as they did with Lost) except in today's industry there is a much bigger chance of getting suddenly cancelled and not being able to wrap much up.
The writers said they hid clues in episode 1 in plain sight. So my theory is that the top of that billboard where the "Star Magic" sign was originally (We saw it in Victor's flashback of the massacre) is actually a secret portal similar to a faraway tree. Where it goes is anyone's guess, but it might be where the children are being locked away. We only ever hear about them being locked in a tower (they weren't at the lighthouse so it has to be somewhere different).
I think if you climb through that empty billboard sign at the top, then the "motel" will appear to you similar to Boyd finding Martin in the ruins.
If you rewatch Episode 1 at :37 mark- Boyd is ringing the bell walking down the street, the camera zooms in on the bell and the sign is directly behind the bell blurred in the background.
1:28 mark- Closeup shot of the pool as "We got to get out of this place" starts playing on the radio. Slowly zooms up and to the left until the top of the billboard is directly centered... Then quickly changes to next scene.
2:35 mark- Zoom in on the bell once again with the billboard again centered directly behind it.
The wires hooked to the inner corners of the Billboard form an X.... X marks the spot?
We know that the billboard once had a "Star Magic" sign at the top cause we saw it in Victor's flashback... Which means at some point between then and present day someone went up there and removed both sides of the sign (it's visible from each side). It wasn't something weather related IMO cause the rest of the Billboard is still perfectly in tact.
I could be completely wrong, but my theory is the top of that billboard acts similar to a faraway tree where you can climb through and be transported. I believe that place is where the children are being imprisoned.
The 1st episode that sign is shown a bunch more...
4:31 mark- Behind Boyd and Kenny
5:49 mark- As Frank's wife and daughter look across the street
6:21 mark- Overhead shot zooms in with sign visible
12:22 mark- Frank walking down the street
21:37 mark- Matthews driving into town
26:43 mark- Matthews driving back into town
26:59
28:50
29:04
They showed the Billboard like 15 times in the 1st episode.
Love this.
@@joshs9857 this is great! Have been wondering since the first episode why there was a sign and no motel and about the car in the pool lol to piggyback on the first episode theme, don’t forget the cromenackle and her best friend (Nate? Nathan?) that was almost the first scene. I think it’s important
@@joshs9857 oh and the billboard is the last lingering shot in the opening credits
That's an incredible observation! Love how detailed you got with all those timestamp connections to the billboard. The Star Magic sign theory definitely feels like it could be onto something! 🤔
I've always wondered if julies tshirt that says "Illusions" is a hint to any of it.
Also they mentioned the lake of tears. And elgin is drawn to the water. I wanna know if there's somthing important about the Brundels. Like where does it connect to. Or what's in the water
awesome awesome breakdown, only thing im afraid of is that we as insanely deep dive lovers are overthinking some things like man in yellow jacket and color on the website, i wouldnt be surprised that its just a coincidence
@@bartasSM how about the messages using numbers
@@BEYONDPREMIERE numbers are definitely plausible, but watching recent episodes made
me think... how the heck did Victor survive 30+ years alone as a kid amongst all the monsters? they were definitely aware of him and must have been looking every single night for him, no way he could survive that long without amulets, unless hes hiding some unexpected secret
@@bartasSM good question. Maybe the theory that monsters feed of hope is correct. Then they would want to keep Victor alive as he was their only source of food.
If they found clothing from the 80s I don’t think he was alone alone for all those years. He had no one but people were still coming in.
@@bartasSM I honestly do not think the monsters were interested in killing Victor. I think they viewed him as a scared child without anyone else around to care about him. When they kill, they like to inflict pain. They kill on purpose. With no one around to care for Victor, killing him off and not having a horrified audience would be useless to the monsters. Now that he is amongst people, there are so many less knowledgeable people to kill then for them to go after Victor. He was able to live there, learn from the boy in white , and know how to stay alive. That is much more knowledge than the regular person coming into town not knowing anything.
Remember when Father Khatri said in the first season that the Bible has never turned up in Fromville and he had to write out the pages from memory. That could not have been for no reason!
Interesting 🤔🤔
Father Kathri was no ordinary priest though- WHY would he officiate the obviously pagan Choosing Ceremony?
He also said he felt peaceful and meditated inside the white stones of the circle where the Choosing Ceremony altar/table is located- between the town and Colony House.
The Faraway Trees and Bottle Trees evoke the concept of Yggdrasil, the World Tree in Norse mythology, connecting different realms. Similarly, in many African-American traditions, Bottle Trees are believed to trap spirits or provide protection.
I think the houses are all from a real town in the real world that was pulled into Fromville via a catastrophic event. The year was 1971 like the calendar on one of the house walls.
That also explains the criatures, but i wonder, how did the creatures take human shape?
@@nicelol5241they are human before, i think they do some ritual to immortal or maybe the creature is tried to be human but somethings stop them and sealed them in the twon
The town appears to be an old "Company Town" like a mining town- the buildings lined up along a "Main Street" where the workers live (though there should be far more homes and shops for this to be the case) and a big Mansion nearby where the mine/plant/factory owner lives (Colony House).
But everything seems taken from random times- maybe only snatched on the dates on the Lighthouse?
That might explain how there's a Diner and a Motel pool and sign but no motel.
Also, no motel would have it's pool right at the roadside - pools are always to the rear- away from roads and parking (and there's no motel parking either).
Kinda like how things from Loki get prunned. Or funny enough Land of the Lost
@Afroriqan Yeah, like the void at the end of time, only much smaller and more deliberate.
This is one of the best from theory videos I’ve seen so far
@@kelsey.targaryen thank you 🥺
@@murdocsmash7784 I love this show so much and I love writing theories 🙌
I think these theories are amazing and would work really well in a book. But if it’s the explanation it’s so over complicated for a tv show. It would need a massive exposition dump to explain it.
Haha, yeah maybe it would be a little much for TV
No shade whatsoever I love these theories and I think show writers how are paying attention to every detail of a shot because they know us nerds are going to freeze frame every scene hehehe sadly writers have to appeal to everyone but it’s nice they give us those little crumbs of extra content to go off down our own trails. Keep it up!
@@kellyzahara9561 thank you so much, I think the reincarnation theory makes more sense.
Tilly's 7 Grandchildren are the 7 children on the stones Jade saw.
I still don't believe Tilly is/was a mere human. Too many coincidences with her redirecting people away from asking questions (like stopping Jim from investigating the flickering lights which seemed like a pattern in the school/medical building).
Then she seems unconcerned when the crow first hits the glass window and not too freaked out after it breaks the glass, flies around and kills itself.
She also has obviously bullshit answers when Jim was asking her where she was going to.
Maybe the bottles take you to your desired destination? For instance you grab a bottle and go into the tree and it takes you to a certain place instead of random
Rendez-move is a play on words for the French word Rendezvous. That word means one person meeting with another person or business anything. Getting together at a certain date at a certain time
Another youtuber said the trees moving in S1 is probably why it always takes you to a random place which makes sense
Makes me wonder what else might be moving around in that town...
I belive your are right about sacrefice part, when Martin died the trees started to lose their leafs. So I belive that forest/city run on sacrefices...
What i haven't seen is digging into the guy chained on the wall. That is someone currently in the show but much older. I think it's Randall. I think he finally goes back to the chamber and gets captured again. They are using his beard to cover his face where the scar is hidden. This is why he knows Julie and knows she shouldn't be there.
Remember the priest literally said something about “what if we are the next book of the Bible?” Could be something related to that…
rewatching season 1 now and he spent an amazing amount of time talking about that with Sara when she was tied up. Missed all of this the first time.
Sounds very interesting. I still find some things a little too thin, like connecting yellow website to man in yellow jacket, but numbers representing Greek words is very interesting.
My leading theory, that is actually compatible, with what you said so far, is that we are in a broken repeat of the cycle. I think there was a cycle, that played out almost exactly the same, since it all started (perhaps when Europeans arrived to America, but that's just a wild guess). Cycles start, they play out and at the end everyone, without exceptions, dies. But there are some little details that can differ one cycle from another, little changes, that might persist from one cycle to the next. Those little changes accumulated in the last finished cycle with Victor being saved. Maybe those little changes were clues, that made Miranda hide Victor, maybe those clues showed her how to hide him, but at the end Victor survived, and that's why the cycle that we are seeing is so strange. It isn't exactly the same as what Victor remembers, and that's exactly because of his actions. Maybe Victor survived this long there, because monsters deactivate until the next cycle begins? Maybe Victor made preparations for this cycle, even unknowingly, following the Boy in White instructions. We even see one of his interferences on screen; he told Tabitha what to do, what his Mother plan was. If Tabitha is playing the same role as Miranda in the last cycle, she went completely off track because of this, discovering things, that she shouldn't know yet. So my theory is that everything is changing because the cycle is off it's rails, and the entity that controls it all desperately tries to get it back on track.
Boyd, Jade, Jim, and Tabitha are unknowingly releasing spirits from the mysterious bottle trees. Could their actions be responsible for the strange events and nightmares plaguing the town?
@@FromilyTheory I think that’s part of the cycle, more insane stuff is coming in season 4 👀
@@BEYONDPREMIEREbruh they haven't even announced season 4
I thought season 3 was the last one.. I love this show but I already want to know what is happening!!😫😄
@@RainyBatMed i can help you with 1 thing Fatima is not pregnant and is turning into a monster whatever kriste gave Fatima was not good
The show I think is only getting more popular with more viewers. I think they'll be at least 5 or 6 seasons.
the best explanation out of all the similar explanation from other youtubers
Even though the theory is wrong, I still love the possibility of the secret message.
Love the theory. I realized the town is a potemkin village it was visited by Catherine the great in 1787 and if I follow your theory with the Greek meaning it translates to ἐντός (entos) -- within, among
nice observation! thanks for the comment.
This is such a good show, damn. Only started watching it yesterday lol.
I'm glad you're enjoying it 😊 It’s definitely one of those shows that pulls you in quickly!
Oh to be able to watch so many new episodes again !!! How fun
@@brandall5371 right? I'm jealous haha
Wow this is the best video theory on From I've seen so far. Much love from Serbia ❤️
Thank you so much for the support, glad you liked the idea :D
My theory is that the town is a time loop, Tabitha is Miranda (victors mom) and Jim is Henry (victors dad). Ethan is Victor. Remember Victor talked about himself and his sister.
I think The script writers should have made it clear Who was the first to get there and amongst the existing Residents what are their order by arrival..
It was Victor
Demeanors of monsters changing fast and abrupt since Smileys/HowdyDoody demise. Beginning to think they see new crop of people more determined and smarter to escape with more hope in seeing it "possible." Think they want to escape, too. Right behind them on the trail. If electricity/power comes from ground maybe they need to regenerate in tunnels. Don't have much of a life. They know town folk are not going to help them escape.
I noticed that ghost children often use the word "anghkooey", which here in Bulgaria frequently use to mean coward, a person without dignity, or someone weak in character.
i read last week that it means: she's here or something
@kylab8557 That is more probable tbh
Numbers could be coordinates too. Fairy trees do not allow to travel in time since all characters remain in the same historical period
that makes a lot of sense, interesting....
I thought that to I'm a surveyor and those numbers look like coordinate positions.
There has to be time travel, the well that Boyd goes to when he finds Martin is the same one that Randal, Julie, and what's her name go to when they all go comatose. It's the ruins in current day. It's destroyed usually, until they go into it those times.
Whoooaaa ,that was crraaazzzyyyy!!!
Nice job dude
Thanks! I put a lot of work into this video, glad you liked it 🙌
1. You have to pull the numbers from the bottles as coordinates for where you wanna go.
2. Everyone in town is so caught up on Tabitha getting out that no one’s asking why she got sent back
I like that idea
This. Or the fact the she told someone about the town and SURPRISE SURPRISE,,, her (and the person she told, along with the paramedics and cop she tried to tell) ALL ended up in Fromville
I've been speculating that the numbers were coordinates and removing them from the trees is like removing code from a computer.
In this case, it moved the destination of the Tree from near the lighthouse to near and in the pool.
The numbers probably accounted for elevation- which is why Dale was in the pool wall, below ground level.
Boyd got numbers "1864" from the bottle trees, and it translates to "mockery" in Greek? Is this a coincidence? Because the monsters are mocking him, saying things like "Thought you said we couldn't break you" and things like this. And the way they made him watch that awful death, but didnt kill him, just forced him to watch.
I love this theory and tbh I will take it until the show is over, but there's a lot of coincidences haah
If you rewatch season 1 episode 1 of from when Jim is driving around with the rv in circles around town look closely when they cross over the railroad each time. The first time there are power lines & and electrical box and the second there aren’t. This may or may not be intentional… just a thought
The link between the town’s cycles and floods or disasters resembles mythological flood narratives, such as the Epic of Gilgamesh or Noah’s Ark, where catastrophic events reset the world, beginning a new cycle. Boyd and his boat love makes me wonder if he is Noah. That drawing of the people on the water leads me to believe that this imagery will feature in the last episode somehow.
Judged by sunlight, unalloyed, pure, sincere>
I spit out, disdain, reject, loathe.>
A Greek, usually a name for a Gentile>
On account of, because of, for the sake of, on account of, on account of which, wherefore, on account of what, why.>
Nightly, neut. as adverb by night, in the night.>
To contend with or for I contend earnestly for>
Above, more than (a) adv: on the top, above, (b) prep: on the top of, above, over, on, above, more than, superior to.>
To set (of the sun) I sink, set, set during, go down.>
Bearing a mark, notable, notable, conspicuous.
Connects to the symbol jade sees
I had this theory last night about the town watching a earlier episode no 8 season 1, I was like the diner was made in the 50's. It seems the towns been around long before the 1950s. Its must cycle into the real world time to time. Maybe those are those cycles. I need to dive into it more but i have had crap for time this week.
I think this could def be thue. There are a lot of great clues in season 1 when you rewatch with the knowledge we have now
@@Father_DanielI keep thinking about Julie’s shirt in the first few episodes of season one that said “it’s all an illusion”. I started rewatching to get my mom onto the show last night and I noticed that on her shirt, wonder if it’s a hint that’s been there the whole time?
This is amazing. Greek of all languages makes so much sense. Even anghkooey sounds like ακούει. And it’s Greek for “he listens” or “he’s listening”
@@Sarah_is_listening is all theories at this point haha 🤣 but I love exploring the show
This code translation reminds me of the prophet Isaiah 53:3 - He (Jesus) was pierced for our transgressions and crushed for our iniquities. He was lifted up, mocked, and killed to pay the price for those who believe in him. Pretty amazing if they are taking this route! ✝️ Jesus is King!
Interesting connection! Isaiah 53:3 is such a powerful passage. It would be amazing if that’s the direction they’re going with this! Jesus is indeed King! 🙌
17:30 In the Bible, this word can be found in verses like Philippians 1:10, where it describes the quality of being "sincere and without offense." The idea is that something or someone is transparent and true, without hidden flaws or ulterior motives.
Interesting connection to Philippians! Love how you tied that verse to the theme of sincerity 🙏
Insane breakdown, very interesting theories!
I don't think is true, but I'm excited to write a crazy theory haha
@ nah seriously
I subbed to your channel it might not be correct theory but the time you tooo to create and process it was insane in a good way lol !
the numbers in the bottles represent how many times the cycle has currently repeated and continues to. as for the bottles on diffrent branches thats just what it is and represents, the branches represent different dimensions/universes where fromville is taking place
That’s a good observation, I like the idea of different dimensions! 👀
"Dogs represent cycles. Because things change, like dogs" - truly as deep and meaningful as this series itself 🙌
Think about it. Remember those wild dogs in Season 1? They're always circling, always coming back. Just like how Miranda's soul keeps returning as Tabitha. The show literally gave us a metaphor for reincarnation right under our noses! Dogs in various mythologies are often associated with the afterlife and rebirth. Just look at Egyptian mythology with Anubis, or Greek mythology with Cerberus. They're using this ancient symbol of death and rebirth.
In season 3 episode 4 or 5,. I heard a dog in the background barking.. not sure if it was bad editing or supposed to be there. I’m @2:57 rn and I just remembered that I rewinded the part about 4 times to make sure it the tv and not outside! It was in fact, the SHOW.
I still believe in what Abby said in season 1...if I'm not mistaken she said this is all a nightmare so in order to wake up you have to die....
That would be so bad 🤫
Don't think so, in the real world they are missing, they're not just asleep
Ppl who say these ppl are in a coma in hospital forgot that Tabitha called her mom while she was out.
My main theory is: this is a cursed town, cursed by someone who cared about one or all the children who were most likely sacrifices for some ritual that most people of the town believed was necessary. This people then became immortal monsters (we know they were human before and they also behave like humans today, as Randall explained recently) and the town began to capture people all over the country - people probably related to the children somehow, reincarnations or something alike - to try and put an end to the children's souls suffering by releasing them - as the curse probably imprisoned not only their bodies but their souls as well - and the monsters "need" to keep protecting the town so the souls of the children are not freed.
There's some holes in this theory but I feel like it's simple enough to be executed. This show isn't Dark or Mr Robot, feels way more like Lost. And Lost ended in a very simplistic way and I think we'll see the same here.
ALSO, about the show's name "From" I guess some of the people we watch are actually FROM that city somehow - related to the children's parents, for instance. Not everyone, since some of them got there with a lot of other people - these people are meaningless.
That'd explain why some people can hear and see things and others just die randomly like the girl who was shot by the police lady.
@@Henrique.Souza0601yep think your exactly right tbh makes sense
Given the show is called from like there blood is from there just not everyone and probs don’t even realise there ancestors first settled there and did some bad shit and are cursed
Maybe like the show fear street
What about the complete blood circle symbol on the computer monitor in Tabitha's hospital room? Or her recurring head injuries? Or Boyd's recurring shoulder injuries- ALWAYS in the same place?
And then there's the overt references to everything being a dream or nightmare?
Fatima tells Julie "From this high, even a nightmare looks like a dream" which was entirely repeated through a flashback this season? Or Tabitha's dream of the little girl- obviously not her and from a far older time by the dress she has on?
Or Boyd's flatly asking Abby's grave "maybe I'm in a hospital room and you and Ellis are trying to wake me up?"
Or Abby saying it was all like a dream she had as a little girl?
Maybe several people are or have experienced the same dreams as something we call "Fromville" tries to communicate or ask for help?
Certainly there's a force trying to save the children and resolve whatever situation is keeping things in a repeating cycle.
Wow 🤯! All I can say is wow!
@@cqwinton my reincarnation theory is more insane 😂
The numbers inside the bottles might be the number OR the address of houses. For example if there is a paper with the numbers 1472 the house which has that number the people living in that house have a high chance of getting stuck in the town. Remember the monsters know everyone's name in the town, if all the numbers in the bottles aline with the numbers of houses in the real world they have planned already who gets stuck in town. sorry for my bad English
Your English is perfect, and you could be right 🤔😃👍👍👍.
@@megs4193 thanks megs 👍my theory isn't great but if the numbers aren't years they are more likely house numbers and that's how the entity knows who is gonna be stuck in the town and if he controls the monsters then that's how the monsters know people's names 🤷 in episode 6 the lady said to Trudy "we know all of your names "
I definitely think the numbers are connected to the people that end up there. I was curious if it was birthdays or the date they came there. House numbers is a great one and one I didn't think of
So everyone’s adress has 4 numbers? What about those with 3 or 5? Those people are safe from fromvile yay🎉🎉🎉😂
@@wkeon they might be unless they are in the same car or bus with the person that is supposed to arrive there.( But also they might die cause they are not supposed to be there )Remember people who arrive into Fromvile are from different states of America Kansas Detroit etc. So 4 numbers could make sense because they don't arrive from the same place there is no limit like they can only come from one state no they can come from multiple states so they have more houses with 4 numbers.🤷
I think you are on to something because remember in the last episode when Victor father was talking to Ethan and he noticed the hotel and said why is there a hotel sign but no hotel...ok crazy theory but suppose this was related to Lost, meaning no island but Fromville represents something between the world we live in and somewhere else like a portal or a black hole on earth. And one last thing doesn't the cop look like she could be related the monster Smiley....hmmm..she is there for a reason and she knows more than what she is letting on
She’s smiley wife haha
@@BEYONDPREMIERE haha
As twisted as this show is, nothing like that will surprise me lol
The man in yellow look forward to finding out about him, keep the mysteries coming Fromland.
I’m going to have to watch this a couple of times! Christian & his beautiful mind! Hope you are working on a book or screen play of your own using what you’ve researched since this show. Unsure if the creators are this deep! Think about it-with all you’ve learned and been able to imagine since From-I can see you creating a masterpiece!
I think the showrunners are pretty smart, thanks for the comment Lisa. I appreciate the comments.
This is the second time i looked something up and you literally just uploaded 😂
@@HandMeDeals hahaha o wanted to upload at 5 but going to play pickelball haha let me know your thoughts on the secret messages
@@BEYONDPREMIERE do you think the komodo lady could be Miranda
@@HandMeDeals Miranda died 😔
@@BEYONDPREMIERE exactly and komodo lady appears to be an apparition
My theory, this place is a cage for those monsters. They are dead so they cant escape. But the people and the town are in quantum superposition (alive and dead) so they cant leave because when they try it registers them as dead when it tries to determine what state they are in. Thats why they cant escape yet.
3:46 lake of tears and the big spider came down
Personal theory that's kinda dumb, but idk could be something
Maybe the town is like a garden of Eden type situation, it's ancient (hence the existence of the monsters, and the fact the monsters either choose not to leave or can't leave) and it's designed to prevent humans from leaving, but still having someone guiding select people to the flaw that can let them escape
That Garden of Eden connection is pretty interesting! Love the ancient monsters angle......
Just hear me out. You could pull of this convincing out of the box theory right. So imagine how deep the writers will go with their theory 😮😮.
Interesting point! Can't wait to see what the writers have planned for us! 🤔
What is From isn’t in a set location? Faraway trees could have their destinations changed by this with the boy in white knowing this could advise residents when it is safe to go through?
@@randymcmullen538 that’s one of the biggest questions where is the town 🤔
@@BEYONDPREMIERE that might reinforce the theory that it could be entered from anywhere but cannot be found because it’s continually moving… Probably not correct but thought provoking nonetheless…
@@randymcmullen538 like a cloud 🤔
Can’t wait for Tillie to reveal that she was the The Bay Harbor Butcher
@@danceswithsquirrels7106 Tillie is an incredible person she’s not evil.
Lol even here, Dexter references come to life 😂
I have a theory that in the night u can escape thats why the monsters come out in the night so u wouldnt leave
Never thought about the night being a potential escape window... 👀
If you could leave during the night thn you wouldn't come in during the night
Tabitha came back to the town during the night in the ambulance
Lol that would mean you can come and go at night @@apurva000143g
@@apurva000143g yeah but u never know
@@BEYONDPREMIERE in from vilage u have to always think outside the box 👀
Wait. Did I see WINDMILLS that generate ELECTRICITY in the background at one of the frames?!
@@Klopizza maybe a blooper and that’s actually bts footage haha
I missed that! What about electronics placed on a pad to charge, no wires
ur right about the time loop thing since the 3 red stones in culture mean the past/present/future.
also birth, rebirth and death
For all the commenters posting that some theories are just too far out there or that people are overthinking and many things are just coincidences rather than a key piece of the puzzle, etc., all I have to say is did y'all not watch Lost? 😂
Yes our theories are too complicated. I doubt the writers know where they are going cause they are throwing in too many elements. Monsters, cicadas, spiders, angkoee kids, BIW, dead ppl Jade & Boyd see, the Kimono lady, dreams/ visions etc.
At the end they will saupy it some stupid dream of Victor's or alien/ give experiment or worse Limbo.
Finally. A explanation and theory that isn’t actually to stupid to read.
Well done
@@Jp1904lt thank you 🥺🙌
I think what is happening is that it's a place between multiple dimensions. Different creatures came and they are stuck here, but there is only one portal open, and that portal is the human realm.
That’s a good observation, I like the idea of different dimensions! 👀
Wery thorough and in depth theory. The only thing is, I think it is way to complicated. After all they have to somehow put that whole explanation in certain number of episodes. This is too much to include imo.
Explicitly. People are starting to overthink it. It’s not that deep. Some stuff are Easter eggs and some stuff you should ignore. Like the 2659, she just said it randomly from a stack. Meaning she had about ten others on her lap. Also connecting numbers on a wall carved to paper in a bottle on a tree is wild. Just because it’s four digits lol
@@cmasterson I agree people are overthinking it. The solution must be easy enough to be explained in very simple terms in the course of a few episodes,or even one whole season. I also think some things were just there to add to the mystery and to confuse characters, and us, and are not going to be explained at all as they are not crucial for the plot.
Anyone notice the tree pic has the carousel that the boy in white was inviting Victor too when he was young coming out of the cellar
And what does the carousel do? It goes round and round in a circle- just like Fromville.
There’s a yellow house in from town and Henry’s house is yellow.
Grand uniFROM theory 😁
Haha let me know what you think on the secret messages
This reminds me of all the theories with game of thrones and how that will play out and some theories was so good it made peoples expectations so high. Odds are they all dead and that's it like lost and Manifest and they just need to lose hope to accept there fate like his wife said.
That's a fair point about fan theories! Sometimes the simplest explanation could be the right one 🤔
The motel sign without signs of a motel tells me your theory is correct...
Since we know there's no motel, what if the motel used to be there? And the numbers are motel rooms??!!!!
I already seen a theory like this but it added to it saying that the motel ended up underground and thats where the monsters live but I have no idea at this point all I know Is Fatima is not pregnant she's turing into a monster we will see next episode that Fatima is not pregnant with the ultrasound machine
@@randomnugget7750that’s what I’m saying fstima is not pregnant
@@JamesTTrott idk why but I have a feeling that the massacre Viktor witnessed coming out of the cellar will be recreated with Fatima becoming a monster and murdering alot of people just like how Viktor said Christopher stopped making people laugh my theory is Christopher turned into a monster but that just a theory
@@randomnugget7750 I honestly am hesitant to say that the massacre that happened when victor was little was done by monsters because there shouldn’t have been that many people outside first of all and the people that were dead had like nothing left inside of them which we see the monsters now don’t cut the people open as much as that
Wouldn’t make sense
2:16 I commend you for noticing that..your the first person I seen actually notice that
ther'es so much to noice about the show is insane haha thanks for the comment
That was an excellent, well studied theory. Thank you for putting in so much work 😃👍💞💞💞.
I try! haha thank you for the comment :D
Where did you find out about the swirl being a wormhole? Is it confirmed somewhere?
@@According_Door_280 in the drawing we see below the town 🤔
Cicadas have 3 cycles, and they attacked 3 people
That's a fascinating catch about the cicada cycles matching the attacks! Never thought about that connection 🤔
I realised that nobody realise what happened when the old lady start playing that weird card game with the pregnant lady
So Boyd is marked for death, the chosen one
@@HiFiAwardTour that makes sense 🤔
I’m almost certain the show runners aren’t even sure what everything means. They’re making it up as they go along
Strong's Concordance didn't exist until 1890, and his numbers were assigned to the words in the KJV Bible. It's a study aid for the Bible. But it's an interesting theory, that the bottle numbers represent words somehow. We've considered dates, and coordinates, but it could be something else somehow
That's a really good point about Strong's Concordance! Thanks for sharing that historical detail 🤔
I just realized the town is a Potemkin village
For those who don't know, this means the town is an elaborate facade designed to hide an undesirable reality.
@forzaazzurri1471 where did that come frome?? One of first motion pictures was of Battleship Potemkin. Russian. Decades ago, maybe 70s that I saw. Not sure of significance but the clips were not very interesting. I can Google later but won't tell me of importance then.
What if the hole with the three roots is the out
Very interesting with the numbers leading to words written in Greek.
I said it before and I'll say it again and even with the new theory and the hidden code, "For the sake of (1752) higher understanding (1978) a Greek (1672) cries out in astonishment (1608) to the Master. Despite facing mockery (1864) and being lifted up (3333) to suffer harm, even until death (1931), this occurs to fullfil a greater purpose."
This almost describes a "Christ" like fugure being crucified in the cross calling out to God after being mocked and made to suffer eventually fulfilling the prophecy of dying for our sins.
I still believe Boyd is the Christ Figure.
That's a powerful interpretation of the numbers and the code! It's hard to ignore the parallels to a Christ figure. 🤔
I have a theory that this has something to do with African tribes who worship the forest and they have trees like this. This is about slavery and your mind's subconscious.
That would make sense 🤔
I think the numbers are a message. I think it has to be translated in Strongs Greek like you said. I think the kids are telling her to cut the trees down, I don’t think they need to go through the faraway trees, I think they need to be destroyed in order to free the children.
That's such an interesting theory about destroying the trees! Could definitely change everything if the trees need to be cut down rather than used .
The massacre might have happened because the monsters went into the faraway trees and getting transported into peoples' houses.
@@ransomecode good point
They didn't need the trees. There were no talismans back then so even the houses weren't safe at night. The monsters could just come through the front door.
@@rudolfszekernyes2419 yeah you are right 👍
BRILLIANT!!
@@blessedlife8687 thank you 🙌
That was an incredible theory video
Appreciate you piecing that together , i think your onto something
I'm glad you liked it! 👀
@14:34 you said some buildings get sucked in... remember in the most recent episode the victors DAD asked Ethan Where is the Motel? Why does the sign say motel but there's none here !!!!!!! ......... 🤯🤯🤯
Crazy.. connecting idea.
in season 1 episode 3
The preacher said 20 minutes 34 seconds... the people who live in Fault Line believe the ground can just open up and swallow them at any given moment ???
@@JonsonJonsvn superninteresting 🤔🤔🤔
@@BEYONDPREMIERE i kno... watching it over and over again there's so many Easter eggs.. and things said plainly and openly in the 1st season...
At this point I think that everyone has to die in order to escape because if the place needs to feed off their suffering and if there no one alive it sustains it self that’s why victor was left alive to feed of the suffering that he will never get home
Boyd means in Gaelic the man with particular physical trait
I have a very basic question about this number theory; instead of leaving numbers that represent letters or words, why didn't those inhabitants just write in words?
I think when they where taking bottles off the tree it messed up where dale was supposed to go
I think they heed the BIW for it to work.
About the sacrifice theory : the voices also instructed Sarah to kill "the boy" , so that everyone can get home. Maybe he has to be sacrificed.
I think the voice wanted her to kill the boy in white. I think the boy in white is a good entity and the evil entity wants him gone.
S3 E5 made it clear Donna is mole, she cut off Henry in diner when he was gonna talk about park, she wants out more than anyone but still seems to fight every idea that might lead them out. She definitely talks to the monsters in the cut.
@@wkeon maybe she is hanging tight on the somewhat of a "leader" role she has in town. She might be a nobody in the real world.
@@wkeon and her last name is Raines. Water is an underlying theme in this show. The Matthews camp site was known for flooding and Acosta told Boyd there was a huge flood that happened in her town last year and it was raining the night the Matthews and the bus came into town. Hints of boats throughout the show..
She also cut off Victor after she tells him his dad is there. He was about to say "that's impossible. He-" and cuts him off.
@@macsaikrisztina it she’s admitted she’s scared so I don’t think being a leader wets her whistle to beat being safe
I give up guessing. I'll just watch your videos instead 😊. Really interesting
Thanks! I'm glad you enjoy them 😊
My thoughts are: Numbers are very significant in this show. For example: the number 12 (Devilied Egg Plate from Mrs. Liu’s funeral, Jim’s response to Tabitha, when Jim was trying to solve an equation was, the answer is twelve. 12 represents time, order and governance. All these themes are clearly portrayed in this show. (12 months in a year, 12 hours in day and night, 12 Zodiac signs, 12 disciples of Jesus). The number 78 is also significant in From! 1978 (the year Victor survived the massacre in the town), there are 78 Tarot cards in a deck (Tilly offers read the Tarot for Fatima) and ALL of the main characters we have been introduced to in this show, mirror Tarot archetypes. (Questions for discussion - Re: Bottle trees) Could the four digits be like an old school locker combination? 🤔 Meaning the combinations, unlock different destinations? 🤔 Could they be coordinates like those of a map? 🤔 Could they be addresses to specific houses/places? 🤔 The Jewish Kabbalah practice of Gematria may also be worth researching for its potential link to this show.
I think the numbers are coordinates. You think of a number and it takes you to that location
that would be awesome to see also!
Damn. Well done!!
@@Stephaniefarrah thanks 🥺 haha