Sara really stepped up to have Boyd’s back. I respect that!! I wish they could make every episode at this same pace…I kept thinking the music would be connected because of those backward numbers and Jade’s very beautiful talent///didn ‘t realize he’s a world class violinist.
If they just talked as normal people, then the story continued faster and more logically. There is just to many padding in this season 14:45 If Jade just talked with other persons, like Jim, then this could have happened earlier. 13:00 I have to disagree how 'powerful' the scene is. If Jade and everyone just talked, then Tabitha could just told Jade this earlier. The show is just padding and in the final episode there are like: 'here is the answer' I am done with this show (not your channel though ^^ )
Despite this being the weakest season the finale was probably the best episode of the entire series. It really had my heart racing the entire time. Good stuff
Jim is the one who really cracked the code...even when the man in yellow comes he constantly trying to protect julie...he loves his family from the bottom of his heart... don't know why people hate him....
People hate him because he always argue with tabitha. I mean the man in yellow already warned him 😅 that's why he try to stop tobatiha from her mission, to protect her and his family!!! But tabitha is a stubborn. The yellow didn't like it and killed jim.
The moment Tabitha told Jim that her and jade had a kid before, I knew Jim was done lol Man in Yellow = Night creature that can walk in daylight. Yikes!
I think He's probably the entity itself, how does he know about Jim on the radio and that his wife was digging a hole, He's definitely more powerful than monsters too
@@ItsMe-jz5wb yeah he's definitely the big bad behind it. Still don't explain the thing walking outside by the cabin, or what dragged Sara and Boyd's tent...but damn.. this was a good episode
The Man in Yellow says, "Knowledge comes with a cost". Ig the man in yellow appeared cause Jade and Tabitha remembers their past now. And Jim was the sacrifice for this knowledge.
@@SBzKillFrenzy Trueee but ngl despite all the flaws seeing Jim die was kinda sad but I dunno why I was expecting it because of the way he was acting, he was starting to look like a side character or not very important character but whatever
I thought there was no way they'd answer enough questions in one episode but I was so, so wrong. S4 will definitely be worth the wait! We found out so many things. 1. Tabitha and Jim are reincarnations of Victor's mom and Christopher 2. Monsters are former town inhabitants who sacrificed their children 3. Creepy kids are the children who were sacrificed 4. The voice Jim heard on the radio at the end of S1 was the guy in yellow 5. Julie can time travel to revisit certain parts of the story 6. Elgin was manipulated by the kimono chick and Fatima was never really pregnant, she just helped Smiley get reincarnated There's a few more minor revelations and theories too, but those above are HUGE for the story!
If she could this entire fucking season wouldn't have happened. Julie can't change anything you'all. It's already established. The only thing she can do is get information from the past. It will help to get a way out of this town.
also a fact that Julie hair is short is prove she is time traveler, and she wear fresh new jacket, my guess she probably go to ruin and then go to faraway tree and next to lighthouse
Jade also mentions how the energy from people’s souls lingers there. I have said from the beginning: the electricity in the town runs on trapped human souls! This might mean that even if you die in Fromville, you can’t get out! Randall said that dying wasn’t the worst thing that could happen to you there, after all!
The man in yellow, just like the King in Yellow. For those who don't know, it's a mysterious and malevolent supernatural and gothic entity known as the King in Yellow. Nice, so maybe he's the big dog or the main antagonist-or the entity that controls the whole town. Now, I can't wait for Season 4! But i personally hope Season 4 is about when Miranda first came to this town and how the cycle repeated itself again. The fact that this future Julie that tried to warn jim means that it has happened before, so she saw it coming already and tried to warn him.
@@PYNKGENIE yes!!! It was a good episode. We didn't get all the answers, but enough to hold me over. My question to you is do you think Elgin is redeemable?
Sara is the MVP of the finale. Atta Girl! ❤️ This season has been tiring, felt like they dragged the band way too much without giving enough answers. Finally, They did reveal key details connecting all the way back to S1 itself. Coming to the episode itself, it was beautifully woven. The scientific concepts, Musical notes and that music was so soothing. Excellent episode 10/10 for S03E10 🎼🖤
Sara already killed her brother. That's what she meant with 'I've already given [my soul] to it.' It being the town. Hurting Elgin was way easier for her. Boyd did hurt him, but he was not on the same level.
Yup indeed. This season felt a bit more like drama series without a lot of action and horror bits of the monsters...from the moment the main guy killed the smiley monster with his mixed blood and until this episode it was all a massive stall I bet this series will be at least 10 seasons or 20 thanks to these stalling techniques of the directors
They made a deal with the man in yellow for immortality, sounds like a deal with the devil to me, man in yellow is the devil, and by the whole town making that deal, it made the town into a literal hell on earth.
I think the reason all of this is happening to Jade and tabitha is because the ritual to be immortal worked for them too. It is strange to have so many rules in that place. The talisman, Julie's abilities, other monsters. It was exactly like the scene in battlestar gallactica. Even the same word: "remember".
It didn't work on them but more so they held on to hope so strongly that it embedded into their soul thus allowing them to reincarnate so many times until they are successful
Boy in white is good. The man in yellow is evil. The key to ending this curse is to stop the children from being sacrificed. The boy in white sent Tabitha back so she could remember. If Tabbitha and Jade dies, the cycle starts over. The man in yellow killed Jim because he said there were consequences to remembering. What a better way to way to punish Tabbitha than kill her husband.
Did playing the song make the man in yellow come out ? Or was it because smiley was reborn? Man in yellow possibly slaughtered the old townsfolk? Jim too prideful for me. Julie said run so you run. Julie looks way different this is not the Julie you know. Ugh. Julie should have said you’re going to DIE if you don’t leave.
I think you’re right the slaughter was because they were closer than ever now they’re going deep again, when jade played the song now he’s going to go slaughter the town now aka season 4
Man in yellow was free he spoke to Jim before in radio. Because Jim came with the music idea he killed him he said “knowledge comes with cost” he came back because Maranda and Cristopher are back and he trying to stop them from stoping to sacrifice.
@@Mogahid-wu8nlokay makes sense but where has the man in yellow been ? Why do the monsters know everyone name? Because of man in yellow? Has he also been going through this cycle over and over again ?
I dont think Eloise is dead, he said he found pieces only, not confirming that its hers. And remember Eloise is really good at hide and seek. I think they will introduce her to us next season. Cant wait!
Cuz Jim is the second worst and most Annoying character in the shower. Right after Acosta, I litterally cheered when Jim died, oh god I hate him so much 😂
@@Steventremblay89 For me, it's a bit sad that he died and yes, we all know he could have done more to uncover the mysterious truth about the town, but in the end, he was a husband and a father.
I disagree with the "confirmation" that Eloise is dead. I don't think the show confirmed it. Victor literally said, "I THINK." because he couldn't really tell.
@@borisgraell I guess we are watching two different shows. The entire season has been him being faced with new challenges and circumstances that he has to navigate as the “protector” of the town and not being able to. Other major character storytelling and major side stories that ties into the mystery does not change that he’s facing the town wanting to break him. They’re all important the sequence of events leading up to full story. He’s still an important character.
How can someone fix slitted neck that deep 😅😅 only thing possible to save him is that what we saw in final moment was a pre dejavu for upcoming jims death and Julie can choose different path to run rather than bumping into jims place
I hope this episode will finally quiet the complainers about stuff not being revealed… This episode was awesome! My only complaint is I wish season 4 started next week!
@@GobigOrange901 You think? I'm not sure about that. Didn't seem like they were interested in her at all. They were just waiting for Smiley to return.
I think the man in yellow is either the ringleader of the original child sacrifice participants (the monsters), or possibly a servant of theirs like the kimono lady, but as an enforcer. But more likely he's one of them. In any case, he's trying to keep everybody in line, and if two of the original sacrifice participants are figuring too much stuff out, he needs to either distract them into losing the thread, or perhaps turn them into monsters themselves through their guilt. But it's obvious that Tabiranda and Jadeopher were sacrifice participants who then dissented and became convinced they could change the story. What's confusing is why the other sacrifice participants are in this pocket dimension place and why they're inclined to go around killing everyone they can, not to mention why they don't come out during the day, why they turn into scary monster creatures for killing (but not just hanging out in the tunnels), and how the different time periods of the town relate.
that village with vegetables and wooden hoots had three totem stones painted red, from tabitha's dream, maybe they devoted each to something like man in yellow is smth of a highest level, kimono woman is from monsters ilk, but also higher level than monsters and boy in white
I believe the creature Fatima gave birth to will play a significant role in the next season. It seems likely that the darker forces will gain the upper hand, especially since the town’s inhabitants have been relatively lucky for a while. This creature might have unique traits-like the ability to move freely during the day-setting it apart from the others. I also think Jade and Miranda will play a protective role throughout the series, possibly as part of a larger plan. There’s clearly a reason why the man in yellow doesn’t directly affect Tabitha and Jade. Instead, he seems to focus on breaking them emotionally by targeting their loved ones or inducing hallucinations. I feel Boyd might also be connected to this circle, perhaps tied to whatever links Tabitha and Jade. We’ll likely see Tabitha’s husband return, but as a hallucination meant to torment her daily. The man in yellow might have a backstory where he was once a close friend of Tabitha and Jade. However, his obsession with immortality drove him to make extreme choices, like sacrificing children. While this may have been influenced by the sinister pull of the town (similar to how Eldin was affected), he may not have realized it was a trap. His actions could have led to his current cursed state or being trapped in the town. It’s possible that Jade and Tabitha escaped this fate because they refused to take part in the ritual, which might have involved sacrificing their own child. Over time, their story may be about trying to find a way to save their child, who was either forcefully taken or sacrificed due to their resistance to the ritual.
Most of all characters are similar to lost. let me explain - 1. Boyd and michael...same confused and very disturbed character who can mess with anyone for family like in lost. He lost his wife in both series because of him. 2. sara and sayid....both torturers.....do their work when it is needed most. Fck....that screwdriver in eyes.of elgin...he perfectly deserved that shot. 3. John locke and that victor guy....again the same mysterious....believer of faith...can't tell a simple thing to anyone. Makes things complicated. 4. Desmund hume ( lost) and julie ( from) both are a failsafe of time travel. Both are time travellers. 😮 5. son of michael ( lost) and son of tabitha......always a fear of being killed or captured. 6. Sara and his brother....shannon and boone from lost...same overprotective brother who died for nothing. 7. Man in yellow and monsters are like the ultimate villain of the show. Like man in black...that was villian in lost. 8. That hatch in lost led to other people like in from that underground hatch led to other people in from. 9. People were stuck on an island and here in a village. can't escape without dying 99% of all people. Just 3 or 4 people will be able to escape at the end. 10. Only tabitha and jade feels like new and original characters. can't say that sawyer and kate but yeah its different. 11. Jin and sun....lover boys...like here fatima and the son of boyd. 12. same time travel, supernatural, hallucinations, fate, faith, supposed to do 😅😅😅 elements are here. 13. Men in yellow ( IDK ) = Men in black ( lost) 14. Father khatri here and Father yemi there. 15. last but not the least....producers are also the same. Tell me the differences....i told similarities. By the way i have seen lost recently. That's why I'm so detailed and obsessed with that. Thanks ❤
That’s a fascinating breakdown! If Fatima’s creature plays a major role next season, and the Man in Yellow’s backstory ties him to Tabitha and Jade, it would add so much more to the story. The ritual idea and their resistance could explain so much!
I think if jade and Tabitha are reincarnations, the. Everyone else is also they are the monsters reincarnated feeding there former selfs,since the town repeats itself
FROM is beyond brilliant. so many subtle, creepy and somewhat random things woven back to story soo incredibly perfectly. wish i could find the time dungeon so i could get to S4 asap
We did NOT get confirmation Eloise is dead. He said he wasn't sure. And they were just little pieces. He basically said the pieces were unrecognizable. The writers have purposely let a a possibility exist that she isn't dead. Otherwise, it would have been way more clear that she was 100% dead.
i mean, she was 4-5 years old little girl, dead or alive doesn't matter she couldn't do much for the story overall, like what are your possible hopes for her to do?
Did anyone notice the Julie that came to Jim was wearing different clothes and different hairstyle from the Julie we last saw at the Diner?? was she a different Julie...are there 2 Julies now...she never left the Diner...
@@lexidenise1073 yeah, and like her little brother told her..she can't change what has already been written..she tried to change Jim's fate but couldn't
Smiley is going to wear Jim’s clothes. This is sad. Evil is taking over all over again. Those things were actually losing the war since the people were picking up clues. And now they’ll be hyped by the return of Smiley and That duche in yellow.
I think the civil war vet was trying to warn them about Elgin because they both ended up with a missing eye and the vet drank blood just like Elgin made Fatima
I think I have a theory which might explain a lot actually. So apparently the creators have stated at one point or another that if you figure out what the monsters are, you figure out what is happening in the show, regardless of if this statement has actually been said I think I've just came to a revelation of sorts. So as of the finale of season 3 Fatima says that she knows what the monsters are, people who have sacrificed their children at the offer of immortality, but that of course came with a twist, the monsters don't exhibit any human traits, no empathy, a desire to kill, whilst also just acting in a strange, almost in a robotic way and also the fact that they are shapeshifters who lack blood, have claws etc. Im now convinced more than ever that Fromville is just some purgatory, stasis or hell itself for unsuspecting victims. People don't die to enter from ville but instead a force brings them in. So what I believe happend is that when this town was 'born' the inhabitants who since became the monsters were perhaps manipulated by the man in yellow (who I believe is the devil) into killing their own children in order to not be killed by the man in yellow and be granted immortality at the feat of the man in yellow to forever punish those unlucky enough to he lured into town. I dont believe the monsters when they were human knew that they would become these monsters, they could have but I like the idea that the devil lied to them in a sense and whilst he did grant them immortality, he also took away their humanity and quite literally turned them into vessels to carry out the devils torture for him. Since then, any who have entered the town have just been tortured by the monsters, being hunted and stalked and mentally drained all because the devil wants to see them punished and broken before death, it's not clear what the devils motives are other than just wanted to hurt people and torture them, he might feed off hope but not in the literal sense, he might just gain pleasure from seeing people trying to escape his prison. Something I also find interesting which somewhat supports this is that before Miranda entered the town, she had visions of the man in yellow, as we know the recreation theory is now true, this means a past self of Miranda had contact with the man in yellow and likely offered the trade of a child for immortality, since that past self of Miranda must have died in order for Miranda to be reincarnated, we know that the past self must have declined and was likely killed by the man in yellow which supports the idea that he tricked people into killing their children and those who didn't he just killed. Im not fully sure what this means for the future of this show as now the puppeteer has made his appearance, I feel like he is here to stay and I'm not sure what this would mean for the people of Fromville, I think there's a chance that one of our characters might get the offer of killing a child for immortality which could be a really cool thing to see. It also leaves me uncertain into the Boy in whites roll, using logic of this is a hell they are in, white is considered pure meaning that the boy is angelic and here to help but yet I'm still inclined to believe the boy is not what he seems and has his own agenda. Since the reveal of the man and yellow and his likely stay in fromville it will be interesting to see if he talks to any of the characters, tries to manipulate them into doing his bidding. Another thing I've just thought of is the slaughter that Victor managed to survive, what I think is that after the devil reveals himself, the slaughter happens in order to keep his identity a secret, so since he has now revealed himself and I imagine Julie will easily get back to the town, his identity is revealed, indicating that now the slaughter will begin, I think season 4 could be the last season where it is one last push to uncover as many secrets they can to escape before this slaughter happens. Ive been trying my best to figure out what the title means as the lead writer won't even tell any of the cast the answer, that means it has to be something big which reveals a lot of stuff, my leading guess is that it might mean something like 'where did I come from?' As every character might be a reincarnation of a past character that has died in fromville. Basically meaning that there were x amount of people in fromville at the very beginning and everytime they die they are reincarnated to forever repeat the loop of being tortured by the devil, maybe because the originals who entered this town did something that angered the devil, making him want to punish them for eternity by resurrecting their souls after death with the soul purpose of luring them back into the town to be punished again, theory over
And I believe you may be correct, this show does exhibit Christian traits, this explain when randall mentions “ i dont think the worse thing that can happen here is death”
If you really think about it Jim is actually a genius, Jade wouldn’t be able to solve the year number if it wasn’t for Jim. I believe that the Man in Yellow is The Boy In White Dad if you compare their names it so similar and I believe that The Boy in White is working against The Man in Yellow
The connection between the Man in Yellow and the Boy in White being father and son is wild. If they’re working against each other, it changes everything!
They need to write all of this down and put it everywhere in case they don’t make it so the new people will know what to do right away. And write musical notes on those pieces of paper.
Anyone else play Fear and Hunger termina? In the game there is a man in yellow as well. Additionally, the game is about the ritual of turning a chosen into a God through the sacrifice of others. Maybe this is a ritual where the man in yellow or the boy in white will ascend based on how the ritual is conpleted. Maybe, the completion of the ritual is based on who succeeds, and the Man in yellow knows that Jade and tabitha will never give up on their children. Because of that, it aims to prolong and continue the status quo forever, while the boy in white only needs Jade and Tabitha to succeed once. Within this ritual, they are only allowed to interfere so much which also gives a corresponding opportunity to the other side. So the more that you interfere the more the other side gets an advantage as a consequence which is why the boy and white is reluctant to directly help. It might also be why smiley was able to be in the right spot to catch Miranda before she could get to the tree. Yeah, I think it's all just a ritual to obtain godhood and the people in the souls in town are just pawns, the monsters are eternal pawns of the Man in yellow... I think because the boy in white didn't give them the answer and they came to the answer organically the cast will have an advantage in season 4 because the man in yellow directly interfered... Maybe the powers that Julie has is also a direct consequence to direct interference the man in yellow has done in the past like collapsing the house, rain storms, or rotting food.
Man, glad i stumbled across your page man! Its been a frustrating season, but well worth the wait imo. Definitely dont want to wait for answers or action in the futre though. Once was enough!
Nahhh I'm going to say that this is the best eps of all s3, although in s3 it feels long but if we don't go through that, then in eps 10 you won't feel it. Thanks a lot for all From videos Man, keep it up! ✨
1. Sarah is a freaking savage and my new fav. 2. It kinda sorta makes sense now that the BIW is Tabitha and Jade's son that they tried to save, which explains why he protected Victor his brother. 3. Ethan can also see the BIW because that's also his half-brother, just like Victor's. 4. Julie looks different with shorter hair. I guess Ethan was right about not being able to change the story. 5. The MIY is way worst than the creatures in the tunnels, Martin literally warned Boyd about it plus he can walk in daylight unlike the other creatures.
2:27 😮 What if the BIW is an accumulation/collection of all of Thabitha/Miranda/Her past reincarnations's d3ad son's. As in, if Victor or Eathan di3, they'll become part pf BIW? That will explain why the BIW was drawn to both Victor and Ethan, they're all brothers via the shared soul of their reincarnated mothers, and Ethan and Victor are destined to be part of BIW.
This show is just brilliant imo, and this episode just took this show to another level. So many possibilities and speculation of what to expect in season 4, with still not really knowing exactly what's going on, we may know some more stuff, but really don't know all. The thrill and suspense is just amazing, and the producers being the same from the hit tv show Lost, just showed how brilliant they are. If I was to compare it to Lost even though it's completely different, it would be similar to when they found the Hatch in Lost, and it changed the whole show, imo, that's exactly what this episode just did here for its viewers.
so everyone is excited about the reveal of The Man in Yellow and think of him as the big bad entity. Martin's talk about the tip of the spear has me thinking, what if the immortal villager monsters are the spear tip, the part that does the damage, what if The Man in Yellow is the shaft of the spear, trusting the villagers forward to kill, and we still haven't seen the person holding the spears who actually stands far away and is the one who targets the specific townsfolk to kill.
Elgin did it to himself. They tried to talk to him. If they didn't make him talk Fatima might of died and they would not have known that Smilely had returned as well as the extra information Fatima had. Elgin was at this point an agent of the town that rebirthed smiley through the ritual. Sara situation was different as everyone thought the monsters were the big bad. After Sara situation everyone now knew including Elgin about the power of what the Town could do. Elgin reasons for trusting was very weak whereas Sara and everyone back in season 1 was none the wiser.
You make a great point about Elgin and Sara’s situations being so different. Elgin should’ve known better, but it’s like the town was pulling the strings all along.
this season only answered a few questions but give hundreds more new questions, i hope next season is more action than this mystery after mystery, it's so confusing
Im going to say this 1. This is was good season. 2. Boyd did the right thing with Elgin. Acosta is going to get got in season 4 and im here for it. 3. Yeah, there was supposed to be 3rd point but im actually done lol
In one of your previous videos, i left a comment saying that Tabitha was either Miranda then i preceeded to make the assumption that maybe it was the case that something else was being reincarnated over and over. My gut feeling was right The only thing i was wrong about was assuming that the boy in white is sus but he actually isnt ( unless he is being manipulated somehow ). But now I'm starting to think that maybe the Boy in White might be the Son of the actual Evil entity or have some kind of relationship. But whats funny is how season 2 told us part of the story through the cave painting. In the middle of the drawing was a big red entity ( probably the man in yellow ). To the left of the entity shows the kids being sacrificed along with their parents ( white stick figure ). To the right shows the parents of those kids now becoming monsters ( red stick figures ) because that was the price of immortality, but we see 2 stick figures that are still white most likely Tabitha and Jades' past selves seeing this ritual and trying to save the kids along with their's. They get killed by the townsfolk monsters but they hold on to hope that they can save their kids and their souls wander around the world seeking the perfect vessel to be born in to try save the kids. Everyone else in the town is there by chance because the Entity's reach goes further than the town whilst Tabitha and Jade have no choice but to go there. Their souls drag them there whereas everyone else was just unlucky ( unless they were part of the village people who first voyaged to the town via the boats on the rivers) . The reason why I believe that those town people ( currently residing in fromville) are reincarnations either is because they werent directly cursed so theres nothing to tie them to the town. Only the land was cursed along with the parents of the Angkhooey kids. Smiley killed Miranda coz he knew who she was and has probably BEEN killing the reincarnations of the Angkhooey kids' mom. The dream that Tabitha had of being a kid running in the forest was also just a memory of the Angkhooey kids' mom as a child when they first came to the land Also I think Jim isn't dead as of yet but kinda is.
Interesting note to add: Sara said she wouldn’t let the town take Boyd’s soul reinforcing he will remain true to himself to a degree. Jim, on the other hand, completely changed and that led to his death
I cracked the story! So Jade is Link, and Tabby is Zelda! As they learn the song of remembrance, they both remember reincarnating in the land of Hyrule, and Ganon is back with an army of undead cave monsters! everything makes sense now!
There are still alot of unanswered questions but I would say this episode answered some of them. We still have to wait for almost 2 years for the remaining questions to be answered.
I think the Boy in White is the Man in Yellow! The way he is growing, the way only he can appear in Daylight! The part he manipulates Tabitha to go back because her being in From Ville will only hamper with his goals. He never ever does anything constructive, at least the Anghkooey Kids ask Tabitha and Jim to remember!
i think when julie came to tell jim “this is where it happens” she was from future, because she already knew this was to happen and she came from future to tell him the same but as she couldn’t change anything, it happened! her hair looked short as well!
If you use Lost as a reference The Man in Black (Antagonist) vs The Man is White (Protagonist) the true forces pulling the strings behind the scenes. From is doing the same thing the Boy in White is going against the Man in Yellow.
Julie is the Cromenockle. Victor is the Lonely Dragon, and his truck hiding place is the Cavern of the Lonely Dragon. Julie needs to go on a quest and Ethan is the key to understanding the story. Ethan and Julie needs to see the map in Victor´s truck. The faraway trees and the ruins will be portals in time and space for Julie to try to break the cycle. Ethan, being a child (the only surving child) is the key to the story. He has been telling them since S1 that they need to piece together the story (all the drawings) to save someone on a quest. The lake of tears is where Elis realises Elgin has Tabitha. The need a boat to escape.
Season 4 premiere prediction: Julie will time travel back to when Jim was killed and finally get it right, she will convince Jim to go back to town and he will live. That will make it an epic season finale for season 3!
The man in yellow is the boy in white grandfather, he asked his son to sacrifice his son, and did it and the boy in white is simply the soul of the boy sacrificed. Also, the son of the man in the white suit is or could be smiley making the boy in white his son, notice how smiley and the man in yellow come out, like father like son.
The question that keeps lingering on my mind is what the purpose of the child sacrifices is for the evil entity? The entity must already have had significant power to persuade the parents to make the sacrifices. So aside from having a few extra monsters roaming around, not much seems to have been gained from this bargain. Given the revelation that one couple refused the bargain, this leads me to suspect that the ritual is not yet complete and that the evil entity is still one sacrifice short of achieving whatever its goal is. What’s also interesting is that the ritual appears to require the willing sacrifice of parents, as opposed to the evil entity simply killing and then taking a child. This might also explain why the voices that Sara hears asked her to kill Ethan and suggests to me that the voices were, in fact, genuinely trying to prevent the ritual from being completed, since killing Ethan would have eliminated him as a candidate for willing sacrifice. It also explains why Victor was allowed to stay alive following the massacre, since, without his parents present to sacrifice him, he held no utility for the evil entity. The evil entity needs one more child, willingly sacrificed, to complete its endgame. Ethan seems an unlikely candidate given that Tabitha will not likely acquiesce. So either the entity needs a new child, or perhaps the entity will try to use Julie and her storywalking abilities to influence the past and to get the original parents that refused the sacrifice to give into the bargain after all.
It's so messed up that anyone would consider sacrificing their own children to live forever. It seems weird to me because parents will do so much to keep their children safe, and they often love them very deeply🤔
I agree. Not everyone is meant to be parents though and a lot of people are terrified of the afterlife & what comes next. I couldn’t even imagine doing something like that. Because once your children are gone, it’s almost hard to go on & live at all.
My biggest question is what the hell the lady in the kimono is... it is not a regular monster, i think... shes some kind of ghost... idk regular monsters cant get in if there is a talisman, but she can materialize herself in daylight, i thought the boy in white would grow into the man in yellow, maybe he would...
yo even I think the boy in white is man in yellow! He is growing and not really helping anyone lmao!!! Maybe even he can time travel! He has just decided to appear in his final form!
I think the BIW can change his appearance based on who he’s speaking to, to gain their trust. Victor and Ethan always see the little boy, cause they’re children at heart, they want a friend. Boyd first sees the BIW as Martin, he was an old marine to give Boyd that tie to him, he’d help a marine. It’s why Martin knew everyone and Boyds wife’s words, Julie saw him as Martin because she just went to where Boyd was, the story wouldn’t change for her.
No. This is Julie from the future, probably from season 4 or 5 to save his dad from killed. But I think that man in yellow came out due to Jade's music.
![BOWKYLION - วิงวอน (ex-change) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cLdnZWDaO-w/mqdefault.jpg)
![[#2024MAMA] BIGBANG (빅뱅) - 뱅뱅뱅 (BANG BANG BANG) + FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EQsYfiPR9uM/mqdefault.jpg)
📌 A huge THANK YOU to everyone who's been on this incredible journey analyzing FROM! I really appreciate all the support, see you later tonight.
Welcome ❤
Sara really stepped up to have Boyd’s back. I respect that!! I wish they could make every episode at this same pace…I kept thinking the music would be connected because of those backward numbers and Jade’s very beautiful talent///didn ‘t realize he’s a world class violinist.
You are welcome ❤😅 been a wild ride
@@wellmanfarms9855 Totally! Sara really showed up for Boyd, and it made such a difference. But her soul tho
If they just talked as normal people, then the story continued faster and more logically. There is just to many padding in this season
14:45 If Jade just talked with other persons, like Jim, then this could have happened earlier.
13:00 I have to disagree how 'powerful' the scene is. If Jade and everyone just talked, then Tabitha could just told Jade this earlier.
The show is just padding and in the final episode there are like: 'here is the answer'
I am done with this show (not your channel though ^^ )
Despite this being the weakest season the finale was probably the best episode of the entire series. It really had my heart racing the entire time. Good stuff
This was my favorite season
@@ashley.taylor174 I loved it too.
the weakest was S2 imo
Me too. Like I want to skip some part😅
The acting in this season was some of the best we've seen so far. I look forward to the middle and end of this story.
Jim is the one who really cracked the code...even when the man in yellow comes he constantly trying to protect julie...he loves his family from the bottom of his heart... don't know why people hate him....
his death is aad part in series 😢
People hate him because he always argue with tabitha. I mean the man in yellow already warned him 😅 that's why he try to stop tobatiha from her mission, to protect her and his family!!! But tabitha is a stubborn. The yellow didn't like it and killed jim.
So NPC reason to hate the best character in series
because hes white same with tilly
When Victor tells him that his wife fell, he rushes inside leaves Ethan outside and then when he comes inside doesnt even acknowledge Julie 😭😭😭🙄
The moment Tabitha told Jim that her and jade had a kid before, I knew Jim was done lol Man in Yellow = Night creature that can walk in daylight. Yikes!
Hopefully he can't just go inside of houses tho
I think He's probably the entity itself, how does he know about Jim on the radio and that his wife was digging a hole, He's definitely more powerful than monsters too
@@ItsMe-jz5wb yeah he's definitely the big bad behind it. Still don't explain the thing walking outside by the cabin, or what dragged Sara and Boyd's tent...but damn.. this was a good episode
The Man in Yellow says, "Knowledge comes with a cost". Ig the man in yellow appeared cause Jade and Tabitha remembers their past now. And Jim was the sacrifice for this knowledge.
@@SBzKillFrenzy Trueee but ngl despite all the flaws seeing Jim die was kinda sad but I dunno why I was expecting it because of the way he was acting, he was starting to look like a side character or not very important character but whatever
I thought there was no way they'd answer enough questions in one episode but I was so, so wrong. S4 will definitely be worth the wait! We found out so many things.
1. Tabitha and Jim are reincarnations of Victor's mom and Christopher
2. Monsters are former town inhabitants who sacrificed their children
3. Creepy kids are the children who were sacrificed
4. The voice Jim heard on the radio at the end of S1 was the guy in yellow
5. Julie can time travel to revisit certain parts of the story
6. Elgin was manipulated by the kimono chick and Fatima was never really pregnant, she just helped Smiley get reincarnated
There's a few more minor revelations and theories too, but those above are HUGE for the story!
When did they say former town residents where monster?
And tabitha and jade are reincarnation
🙏🏾💯
Amazing finale. All people needed was patience; the writers knew what they were doing with THEIR show.
I agree. @@shalinalewis2957
@@zenin09. So u just watch with no brain huh 😂😂😂😂😂😂
When Julie met Jim she said "This is where it happens, we need to run". I guess that confirms that she actually can alter the past.
She didnt changed anything, her dad died (again), she cant change a story that has been already told 💀
@@avilchiiswait... that's every time traveler who's trying to change the past
If she could this entire fucking season wouldn't have happened. Julie can't change anything you'all. It's already established. The only thing she can do is get information from the past. It will help to get a way out of this town.
@@veenasudheer8532 true , bruh its so obvious ,when ethan himself said that its like the director is spamming on to your face .
also a fact that Julie hair is short is prove she is time traveler, and she wear fresh new jacket, my guess she probably go to ruin and then go to faraway tree and next to lighthouse
Key takeaway is that don't watch season 4 until all episodes are out
facts.
Agreed
Jade also mentions how the energy from people’s souls lingers there. I have said from the beginning: the electricity in the town runs on trapped human souls! This might mean that even if you die in Fromville, you can’t get out! Randall said that dying wasn’t the worst thing that could happen to you there, after all!
nice catch!
Martin said so similarly & seems like they are reincarnation of each other
That’s such a haunting theory, trapped souls powering the town would explain so much!
that is the shittiest fate one can have
this makes so much sense heres a like
My jaw dropped when I saw the man in yellow.
That thing was fucking terrifying.
He was a myth for so long. Seeing him was surreal
Who is he?
SAME, WHEN I SAW THE MAN IN YELLOW, MY JAW DROPPED, 😞
THINGS ARE NOW WORSE TO MORE WORSE 😭😭
Freddie Fazzbear @@jsmm7973
The man in yellow, just like the King in Yellow. For those who don't know, it's a mysterious and malevolent supernatural and gothic entity known as the King in Yellow. Nice, so maybe he's the big dog or the main antagonist-or the entity that controls the whole town. Now, I can't wait for Season 4! But i personally hope Season 4 is about when Miranda first came to this town and how the cycle repeated itself again. The fact that this future Julie that tried to warn jim means that it has happened before, so she saw it coming already and tried to warn him.
She came too late. She should go to herself
@@lumkamsomi2836maybe she did? Who knows if it was her first attempt
I want at least 5 seasons dedicated to the past residents and how they failed over and over again!
She literally had different hair. Time works differently there. She had to go somewhere/some place/some time to try and stop it.
UGH I FEEL U, I NEED SEASON 4 😭😭🙏 NOW, IM HOPE THAT MAIN CHARACTERS DON'T D*E
Julie time travelled, tried to save her father and failed. I'm excited we will get to see more of time travelling in season 4
I wonder how far in the future she was from.
@@krbcan1569good question! Me too!
When the smiley boy was born again it gave me the chills. There is no scarier smiley than him
I was also sooo shocked to see him coming back
he's the only scary creature out there
There was a lot of chemistry between Jade and Tabitha!! This is why!!!!😂
Lol 😂 and smiley is now boyds grandson....
@ 😂
@ I get the feeling smiley can’t kill certain people now.
@@veenasudheer8532😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😅😅😅😅😅😅
Hahhaa For real😂
is anyone like me still trynna process WTF!!!! just happened??!
Definitely a lot to processs
@@PYNKGENIE yes!!! It was a good episode. We didn't get all the answers, but enough to hold me over. My question to you is do you think Elgin is redeemable?
@@SBzKillFrenzyi mean just like everyone else he too was manipulated so maybe however i believe sarah should’ve been more
lenient.
I don't get why everyone wants all the answers right away. It's a show not a movie. @SBzKillFrenzy
Lmk if you need a shoulder to process on
We were correct about tabitha being miranda
Not really. Miranda and Tabitha are both just vessels of someone in the past🤷♂️😂
@@downtoearthproductions you’re thinking of the show Agatha All Along
Even though way too many people assumed she was Eloise 🤦🏼♀️
Not sure but Boyd made himself made to give birth in fatimas womb by saying ' my blood is your blood motherfucker in season-2'😢😢😢
@@indigochild3700ye I was one of them
Sara is the MVP of the finale. Atta Girl! ❤️
This season has been tiring, felt like they dragged the band way too much without giving enough answers. Finally, They did reveal key details connecting all the way back to S1 itself. Coming to the episode itself, it was beautifully woven. The scientific concepts, Musical notes and that music was so soothing. Excellent episode 10/10 for S03E10 🎼🖤
Sara is like the audience that doesn't have patience enough😂
Sara already killed her brother. That's what she meant with 'I've already given [my soul] to it.' It being the town. Hurting Elgin was way easier for her. Boyd did hurt him, but he was not on the same level.
TO BE HONEST,
I DON'T HATE SARA ON WHAT SHE DID
Yup indeed. This season felt a bit more like drama series without a lot of action and horror bits of the monsters...from the moment the main guy killed the smiley monster with his mixed blood and until this episode it was all a massive stall I bet this series will be at least 10 seasons or 20 thanks to these stalling techniques of the directors
@@meetdtruth5600
Naaa I think it will end within season 5 or 6.
No one wants to make a flash show.
They made a deal with the man in yellow for immortality, sounds like a deal with the devil to me, man in yellow is the devil, and by the whole town making that deal, it made the town into a literal hell on earth.
That’s a cool theory! If the man in yellow really is the devil, it explains why the town feels so messed up. Immortality definitely doesn’t come free!
or illuminati modern day satanic clubs that's what they say they do drink the blood of babies
I have soo many new questions lol but wow, that finale was intense!!
I think the reason all of this is happening to Jade and tabitha is because the ritual to be immortal worked for them too.
It is strange to have so many rules in that place. The talisman, Julie's abilities, other monsters.
It was exactly like the scene in battlestar gallactica. Even the same word: "remember".
I don't think it did, I think the reason they're not monsters like others is because they refused to sacrifice their baby?
It didn't work on them but more so they held on to hope so strongly that it embedded into their soul thus allowing them to reincarnate so many times until they are successful
sacrificing kids requires ritual, so yeah, that place has many rules
Does Battlestar charater said "Angkoeey" too??
We still can’t be sure it was Eloise because Victor wasn’t sure since all he could find was pieces
noooo 2 more years with Eloise theory haha
Boy in white is good. The man in yellow is evil. The key to ending this curse is to stop the children from being sacrificed. The boy in white sent Tabitha back so she could remember. If Tabbitha and Jade dies, the cycle starts over. The man in yellow killed Jim because he said there were consequences to remembering. What a better way to way to punish Tabbitha than kill her husband.
A better way to punish Miranda would have been to kill her instead of Jim. LOL
Eljin will become Big boss since he lost an eye
Wait so Jim is died fr?😮
Isn't that the plot of dark 😂😂😂
@@krbcan1569 🤣
Did playing the song make the man in yellow come out ? Or was it because smiley was reborn? Man in yellow possibly slaughtered the old townsfolk? Jim too prideful for me. Julie said run so you run. Julie looks way different this is not the Julie you know. Ugh. Julie should have said you’re going to DIE if you don’t leave.
I think you’re right the slaughter was because they were closer than ever now they’re going deep again, when jade played the song now he’s going to go slaughter the town now aka season 4
Man in yellow was free he spoke to Jim before in radio. Because Jim came with the music idea he killed him he said “knowledge comes with cost” he came back because Maranda and Cristopher are back and he trying to stop them from stoping to sacrifice.
I think it was a Julie from a different time period who was trying to save her dad.
@@greenytaddictyes it was the Julie who is going back in time trying to change what happens or like Ethan says a “story walker”
@@Mogahid-wu8nlokay makes sense but where has the man in yellow been ? Why do the monsters know everyone name? Because of man in yellow? Has he also been going through this cycle over and over again ?
If Ep 5-9 could have been compiled into a single episode the season would've been a banger
or remove episode 7 all together :/
I dont think Eloise is dead, he said he found pieces only, not confirming that its hers. And remember Eloise is really good at hide and seek. I think they will introduce her to us next season. Cant wait!
I'm guessing the yellow guy is the boss of those monsters, and if Julie can time travel, we can assume that Jim's death is a premonition, right?
Cuz Jim is the second worst and most Annoying character in the shower. Right after Acosta, I litterally cheered when Jim died, oh god I hate him so much 😂
@@Steventremblay89 For me, it's a bit sad that he died and yes, we all know he could have done more to uncover the mysterious truth about the town, but in the end, he was a husband and a father.
His role definitely diminished over the years. Not sure if that was what the actor signed up for...
Because Tabitha and Jade would f**k
@@whereistheonering Yes I thought the same
I disagree with the "confirmation" that Eloise is dead. I don't think the show confirmed it. Victor literally said, "I THINK." because he couldn't really tell.
100% Agree
But where is she then?
@@BEYONDPREMIERE trapped in limbo
@@dominicj7977 interesting
What if Julie is the reincarnation of eloise?
I bet still Tabitha or Julie or even jade says nothing to Boyd about what happened 😂
😂😂😂
boyd does not seem to be as relevant as he used to be before... i thought he was going to be killed in this episode lol
@@borisgraell I guess we are watching two different shows. The entire season has been him being faced with new challenges and circumstances that he has to navigate as the “protector” of the town and not being able to. Other major character storytelling and major side stories that ties into the mystery does not change that he’s facing the town wanting to break him. They’re all important the sequence of events leading up to full story. He’s still an important character.
@@borisgraell Why would they kill the main protagonist? lol
@@joshmcjosh375
I think Tabitha has always been the main protagonist.
The finale was probably the best episode of the entire season.
You know why? Because they *finally talked to each other* to move the plot forward
as a Chinese fan，i was so sad that jim throat has been ripped，he is my favorite role in the serie，i hope he could be healed in the next season😢
How can someone fix slitted neck that deep 😅😅 only thing possible to save him is that what we saw in final moment was a pre dejavu for upcoming jims death and Julie can choose different path to run rather than bumping into jims place
Jim will go back to life after Julie alters the story.
ethan saying "maybe Kristi can fix it"
😂😂😂@@BEYONDPREMIERE
What does being Chinese have to do with anything ?
I hope this episode will finally quiet the complainers about stuff not being revealed… This episode was awesome! My only complaint is I wish season 4 started next week!
haha same here :D
I feel Julie gone be a time traveler and try to change past events. It seems like she was trying to do it at the end but failed
From is an amazing show top tier
So Elgin is the civil war soldier and skull soup bowl dude reincarnated
What? How?
@@addytv18cause Elgin now has only one eye just like the solider and skull soup guy
@@rohanbhandari5773 Also the body in the root cellar
Wow! You're right! 💯🤯🤯
What 😮😮😮.. you're right that makes sense
Sara is a darker version of Siyadd from Lost!
Sarah is a fucking gangsta those monsters would’ve killed Fatima had she not been found in time
Because of Sayid's past as an interrogation expert?
@@lordvisionz Sayid tortured prisoners to get answers. He tried to torture Sawyer but wanted to grow as a person.
@@GobigOrange901 You think? I'm not sure about that. Didn't seem like they were interested in her at all. They were just waiting for Smiley to return.
I think the man in yellow is either the ringleader of the original child sacrifice participants (the monsters), or possibly a servant of theirs like the kimono lady, but as an enforcer. But more likely he's one of them. In any case, he's trying to keep everybody in line, and if two of the original sacrifice participants are figuring too much stuff out, he needs to either distract them into losing the thread, or perhaps turn them into monsters themselves through their guilt. But it's obvious that Tabiranda and Jadeopher were sacrifice participants who then dissented and became convinced they could change the story. What's confusing is why the other sacrifice participants are in this pocket dimension place and why they're inclined to go around killing everyone they can, not to mention why they don't come out during the day, why they turn into scary monster creatures for killing (but not just hanging out in the tunnels), and how the different time periods of the town relate.
it seems that monsters reincarnate in the same body, unlike miranda and chris they start a new life outside town
that village with vegetables and wooden hoots had three totem stones painted red, from tabitha's dream, maybe they devoted each to something like man in yellow is smth of a highest level, kimono woman is from monsters ilk, but also higher level than monsters and boy in white
I believe the creature Fatima gave birth to will play a significant role in the next season. It seems likely that the darker forces will gain the upper hand, especially since the town’s inhabitants have been relatively lucky for a while. This creature might have unique traits-like the ability to move freely during the day-setting it apart from the others.
I also think Jade and Miranda will play a protective role throughout the series, possibly as part of a larger plan. There’s clearly a reason why the man in yellow doesn’t directly affect Tabitha and Jade. Instead, he seems to focus on breaking them emotionally by targeting their loved ones or inducing hallucinations. I feel Boyd might also be connected to this circle, perhaps tied to whatever links Tabitha and Jade.
We’ll likely see Tabitha’s husband return, but as a hallucination meant to torment her daily. The man in yellow might have a backstory where he was once a close friend of Tabitha and Jade. However, his obsession with immortality drove him to make extreme choices, like sacrificing children. While this may have been influenced by the sinister pull of the town (similar to how Eldin was affected), he may not have realized it was a trap. His actions could have led to his current cursed state or being trapped in the town.
It’s possible that Jade and Tabitha escaped this fate because they refused to take part in the ritual, which might have involved sacrificing their own child. Over time, their story may be about trying to find a way to save their child, who was either forcefully taken or sacrificed due to their resistance to the ritual.
It wasn't a new creature tho,
It was Smiley who just got rebirth through Fatima since he was promised to live forever
@ItsMe-jz5wb yes it was him but he might have like an upgrade or something
Most of all characters are similar to lost. let me explain -
1. Boyd and michael...same confused and very disturbed character who can mess with anyone for family like in lost. He lost his wife in both series because of him.
2. sara and sayid....both torturers.....do their work when it is needed most. Fck....that screwdriver in eyes.of elgin...he perfectly deserved that shot.
3. John locke and that victor guy....again the same mysterious....believer of faith...can't tell a simple thing to anyone. Makes things complicated.
4. Desmund hume ( lost) and julie ( from) both are a failsafe of time travel. Both are time travellers. 😮
5. son of michael ( lost) and son of tabitha......always a fear of being killed or captured.
6. Sara and his brother....shannon and boone from lost...same overprotective brother who died for nothing.
7. Man in yellow and monsters are like the ultimate villain of the show. Like man in black...that was villian in lost.
8. That hatch in lost led to other people like in from that underground hatch led to other people in from.
9. People were stuck on an island and here in a village. can't escape without dying 99% of all people. Just 3 or 4 people will be able to escape at the end.
10. Only tabitha and jade feels like new and original characters. can't say that sawyer and kate but yeah its different.
11. Jin and sun....lover boys...like here fatima and the son of boyd.
12. same time travel, supernatural, hallucinations, fate, faith, supposed to do 😅😅😅 elements are here.
13. Men in yellow ( IDK ) = Men in black ( lost)
14. Father khatri here and Father yemi there.
15. last but not the least....producers are also the same.
Tell me the differences....i told similarities. By the way i have seen lost recently. That's why I'm so detailed and obsessed with that.
Thanks ❤
That’s a fascinating breakdown! If Fatima’s creature plays a major role next season, and the Man in Yellow’s backstory ties him to Tabitha and Jade, it would add so much more to the story. The ritual idea and their resistance could explain so much!
I think if jade and Tabitha are reincarnations, the. Everyone else is also they are the monsters reincarnated feeding there former selfs,since the town repeats itself
FROM is beyond brilliant. so many subtle, creepy and somewhat random things woven back to story soo incredibly perfectly. wish i could find the time dungeon so i could get to S4 asap
We did NOT get confirmation Eloise is dead. He said he wasn't sure. And they were just little pieces. He basically said the pieces were unrecognizable. The writers have purposely let a a possibility exist that she isn't dead. Otherwise, it would have been way more clear that she was 100% dead.
i mean, she was 4-5 years old little girl, dead or alive doesn't matter she couldn't do much for the story overall, like what are your possible hopes for her to do?
Did anyone notice the Julie that came to Jim was wearing different clothes and different hairstyle from the Julie we last saw at the Diner?? was she a different Julie...are there 2 Julies now...she never left the Diner...
She timed traveled from the future
@@lexidenise1073 yeah, and like her little brother told her..she can't change what has already been written..she tried to change Jim's fate but couldn't
Yeah, that was pretty obvious.
This episode so so fast, Its hard to believe it finished soo quickly. I hope they stick with this pace for season 4!
Tabitha definitely the town's girl 😂
assumptions 😂
Yessirski everyone got a turn 😂
@@beasley_unborn6729 OMG hahah
Ohhhhhhhhhhhh she’s been passed around😂
Smiley is going to wear Jim’s clothes. This is sad. Evil is taking over all over again. Those things were actually losing the war since the people were picking up clues. And now they’ll be hyped by the return of Smiley and That duche in yellow.
Goodbye to my fromily fans we will see each other again in 2 years when season 4 is coming 😅😂
i cannot wait for S4, this has been absolutely a mind fu#ker of a finale, finally getting some answers but also having more questions than before.
PEAK LONG TERM STORY TELLING 🔥
Absolutely. Setting things up really well for the end
omg a game of patience also
I think the civil war vet was trying to warn them about Elgin because they both ended up with a missing eye and the vet drank blood just like Elgin made Fatima
This episode made me cry, laugh, frightened and excited all at the same time, woha
Every episode needs to be like the 10th episode. Every single one! And give them an HBO budget! I mean damn it’s owned by Amazon!
Totally agree! The 10th episode set the bar so high, imagine what they could do with an HBO-level budget! 👀
I think I have a theory which might explain a lot actually. So apparently the creators have stated at one point or another that if you figure out what the monsters are, you figure out what is happening in the show, regardless of if this statement has actually been said I think I've just came to a revelation of sorts. So as of the finale of season 3 Fatima says that she knows what the monsters are, people who have sacrificed their children at the offer of immortality, but that of course came with a twist, the monsters don't exhibit any human traits, no empathy, a desire to kill, whilst also just acting in a strange, almost in a robotic way and also the fact that they are shapeshifters who lack blood, have claws etc. Im now convinced more than ever that Fromville is just some purgatory, stasis or hell itself for unsuspecting victims. People don't die to enter from ville but instead a force brings them in. So what I believe happend is that when this town was 'born' the inhabitants who since became the monsters were perhaps manipulated by the man in yellow (who I believe is the devil) into killing their own children in order to not be killed by the man in yellow and be granted immortality at the feat of the man in yellow to forever punish those unlucky enough to he lured into town. I dont believe the monsters when they were human knew that they would become these monsters, they could have but I like the idea that the devil lied to them in a sense and whilst he did grant them immortality, he also took away their humanity and quite literally turned them into vessels to carry out the devils torture for him. Since then, any who have entered the town have just been tortured by the monsters, being hunted and stalked and mentally drained all because the devil wants to see them punished and broken before death, it's not clear what the devils motives are other than just wanted to hurt people and torture them, he might feed off hope but not in the literal sense, he might just gain pleasure from seeing people trying to escape his prison. Something I also find interesting which somewhat supports this is that before Miranda entered the town, she had visions of the man in yellow, as we know the recreation theory is now true, this means a past self of Miranda had contact with the man in yellow and likely offered the trade of a child for immortality, since that past self of Miranda must have died in order for Miranda to be reincarnated, we know that the past self must have declined and was likely killed by the man in yellow which supports the idea that he tricked people into killing their children and those who didn't he just killed. Im not fully sure what this means for the future of this show as now the puppeteer has made his appearance, I feel like he is here to stay and I'm not sure what this would mean for the people of Fromville, I think there's a chance that one of our characters might get the offer of killing a child for immortality which could be a really cool thing to see. It also leaves me uncertain into the Boy in whites roll, using logic of this is a hell they are in, white is considered pure meaning that the boy is angelic and here to help but yet I'm still inclined to believe the boy is not what he seems and has his own agenda. Since the reveal of the man and yellow and his likely stay in fromville it will be interesting to see if he talks to any of the characters, tries to manipulate them into doing his bidding. Another thing I've just thought of is the slaughter that Victor managed to survive, what I think is that after the devil reveals himself, the slaughter happens in order to keep his identity a secret, so since he has now revealed himself and I imagine Julie will easily get back to the town, his identity is revealed, indicating that now the slaughter will begin, I think season 4 could be the last season where it is one last push to uncover as many secrets they can to escape before this slaughter happens. Ive been trying my best to figure out what the title means as the lead writer won't even tell any of the cast the answer, that means it has to be something big which reveals a lot of stuff, my leading guess is that it might mean something like 'where did I come from?' As every character might be a reincarnation of a past character that has died in fromville. Basically meaning that there were x amount of people in fromville at the very beginning and everytime they die they are reincarnated to forever repeat the loop of being tortured by the devil, maybe because the originals who entered this town did something that angered the devil, making him want to punish them for eternity by resurrecting their souls after death with the soul purpose of luring them back into the town to be punished again, theory over
How could you write such a long text?
And I believe you may be correct, this show does exhibit Christian traits, this explain when randall mentions “ i dont think the worse thing that can happen here is death”
Why didn't Jim run with that Julie 🏃🏃🏃😢😢😢😢
"There wasn't any way out Jim was sure,
unaware of the fact that his wife was wh-"
Nice episode btw❤
😂😂
Knowledge comes at a High Price 😢❤
Repeating same thing over and over is the very definition of insanity 😂❤
The guy in yellow kinda looks like an older Victor
That would be the biggest plot twist if he is
victor is already old...
It seems like many people can be the man in yellow with the reincarnation theory like Boyd, boy in white or totally different like the monsters
He could be Randall
Let's go, my theory of the music code was right, but the purpose of that code was just a message instead of the key to escaping the town 😔
If you really think about it Jim is actually a genius, Jade wouldn’t be able to solve the year number if it wasn’t for Jim.
I believe that the Man in Yellow is The Boy In White Dad if you compare their names it so similar and I believe that The Boy in White is working against The Man in Yellow
The connection between the Man in Yellow and the Boy in White being father and son is wild. If they’re working against each other, it changes everything!
Trueee
Or the grandpa, the man in yellow, asked his son to sacrifice his son and did it and now the boy in white exists
There is no confirmation that Eloise is dead. If anything, she is alive. Victor just said "he thinks" it was her
Man in yellow was even telling Jim that it didn't have to be this way. Almost like Jim's job was to stop Tabitha from getting this far and remembering
Holy S! That was a crazy good episode!
so glad that finally after freaking 3 season the questions are anwered and now just we gonna wait to see how they are gonna get out
They need to write all of this down and put it everywhere in case they don’t make it so the new people will know what to do right away. And write musical notes on those pieces of paper.
Anyone else play Fear and Hunger termina? In the game there is a man in yellow as well. Additionally, the game is about the ritual of turning a chosen into a God through the sacrifice of others. Maybe this is a ritual where the man in yellow or the boy in white will ascend based on how the ritual is conpleted. Maybe, the completion of the ritual is based on who succeeds, and the Man in yellow knows that Jade and tabitha will never give up on their children. Because of that, it aims to prolong and continue the status quo forever, while the boy in white only needs Jade and Tabitha to succeed once. Within this ritual, they are only allowed to interfere so much which also gives a corresponding opportunity to the other side. So the more that you interfere the more the other side gets an advantage as a consequence which is why the boy and white is reluctant to directly help. It might also be why smiley was able to be in the right spot to catch Miranda before she could get to the tree. Yeah, I think it's all just a ritual to obtain godhood and the people in the souls in town are just pawns, the monsters are eternal pawns of the Man in yellow... I think because the boy in white didn't give them the answer and they came to the answer organically the cast will have an advantage in season 4 because the man in yellow directly interfered... Maybe the powers that Julie has is also a direct consequence to direct interference the man in yellow has done in the past like collapsing the house, rain storms, or rotting food.
2 years for next season?! Say it ain’t so!
Man, glad i stumbled across your page man! Its been a frustrating season, but well worth the wait imo. Definitely dont want to wait for answers or action in the futre though. Once was enough!
Same here! 😔
Nahhh I'm going to say that this is the best eps of all s3, although in s3 it feels long but if we don't go through that, then in eps 10 you won't feel it. Thanks a lot for all From videos Man, keep it up! ✨
1. Sarah is a freaking savage and my new fav.
2. It kinda sorta makes sense now that the BIW is Tabitha and Jade's son that they tried to save, which explains why he protected Victor his brother.
3. Ethan can also see the BIW because that's also his half-brother, just like Victor's.
4. Julie looks different with shorter hair. I guess Ethan was right about not being able to change the story.
5. The MIY is way worst than the creatures in the tunnels, Martin literally warned Boyd about it plus he can walk in daylight unlike the other creatures.
Tabitha and jade had a daughter. So you’re wrong.
Delivered another load of questions successfully 🙂✔️
You called a lot of this stuff before any other YT'er caught on. Awesome videos man.
This show played 4d chess haha
2:27 😮 What if the BIW is an accumulation/collection of all of Thabitha/Miranda/Her past reincarnations's d3ad son's. As in, if Victor or Eathan di3, they'll become part pf BIW? That will explain why the BIW was drawn to both Victor and Ethan, they're all brothers via the shared soul of their reincarnated mothers, and Ethan and Victor are destined to be part of BIW.
OOMMMGGG this is a mind blowing idea, like he is her LOVE
The man in yellow is like the Night King
This show is just brilliant imo, and this episode just took this show to another level. So many possibilities and speculation of what to expect in season 4, with still not really knowing exactly what's going on, we may know some more stuff, but really don't know all.
The thrill and suspense is just amazing, and the producers being the same from the hit tv show Lost, just showed how brilliant they are. If I was to compare it to Lost even though it's completely different, it would be similar to when they found the Hatch in Lost, and it changed the whole show, imo, that's exactly what this episode just did here for its viewers.
so everyone is excited about the reveal of The Man in Yellow and think of him as the big bad entity. Martin's talk about the tip of the spear has me thinking, what if the immortal villager monsters are the spear tip, the part that does the damage, what if The Man in Yellow is the shaft of the spear, trusting the villagers forward to kill, and we still haven't seen the person holding the spears who actually stands far away and is the one who targets the specific townsfolk to kill.
Elgin did it to himself. They tried to talk to him. If they didn't make him talk Fatima might of died and they would not have known that Smilely had returned as well as the extra information Fatima had. Elgin was at this point an agent of the town that rebirthed smiley through the ritual. Sara situation was different as everyone thought the monsters were the big bad. After Sara situation everyone now knew including Elgin about the power of what the Town could do. Elgin reasons for trusting was very weak whereas Sara and everyone back in season 1 was none the wiser.
You make a great point about Elgin and Sara’s situations being so different. Elgin should’ve known better, but it’s like the town was pulling the strings all along.
Calling it now. The man in yellow is based on the King in Yellow (look it up).
Yeah I thought this too
Jim just woke up, cracked the code and disappeared
this season only answered a few questions but give hundreds more new questions, i hope next season is more action than this mystery after mystery, it's so confusing
Im going to say this
1. This is was good season.
2. Boyd did the right thing with Elgin. Acosta is going to get got in season 4 and im here for it.
3. Yeah, there was supposed to be 3rd point but im actually done lol
I can't believe you were right about both the reincarnation & the musical notes!
From is the best show ever made!!!
It would be great, if this is connected to Cthulhu mythos. And Man in Yellow is Hastur himself.
That symbol could be similiar to his actual symbol.
The intro is top tier🔥😂🤣🙌🏾
haha
In one of your previous videos, i left a comment saying that Tabitha was either Miranda then i preceeded to make the assumption that maybe it was the case that something else was being reincarnated over and over. My gut feeling was right
The only thing i was wrong about was assuming that the boy in white is sus but he actually isnt ( unless he is being manipulated somehow ). But now I'm starting to think that maybe the Boy in White might be the Son of the actual Evil entity or have some kind of relationship.
But whats funny is how season 2 told us part of the story through the cave painting.
In the middle of the drawing was a big red entity ( probably the man in yellow ). To the left of the entity shows the kids being sacrificed along with their parents ( white stick figure ). To the right shows the parents of those kids now becoming monsters ( red stick figures ) because that was the price of immortality, but we see 2 stick figures that are still white most likely Tabitha and Jades' past selves seeing this ritual and trying to save the kids along with their's. They get killed by the townsfolk monsters but they hold on to hope that they can save their kids and their souls wander around the world seeking the perfect vessel to be born in to try save the kids. Everyone else in the town is there by chance because the Entity's reach goes further than the town whilst Tabitha and Jade have no choice but to go there. Their souls drag them there whereas everyone else was just unlucky ( unless they were part of the village people who first voyaged to the town via the boats on the rivers) .
The reason why I believe that those town people ( currently residing in fromville) are reincarnations either is because they werent directly cursed so theres nothing to tie them to the town. Only the land was cursed along with the parents of the Angkhooey kids. Smiley killed Miranda coz he knew who she was and has probably BEEN killing the reincarnations of the Angkhooey kids' mom. The dream that Tabitha had of being a kid running in the forest was also just a memory of the Angkhooey kids' mom as a child when they first came to the land
Also I think Jim isn't dead as of yet but kinda is.
Interesting note to add: Sara said she wouldn’t let the town take Boyd’s soul reinforcing he will remain true to himself to a degree. Jim, on the other hand, completely changed and that led to his death
The way jade was just frowzen and heartbroken after notcing he was in another cycle was great acting
I cracked the story! So Jade is Link, and Tabby is Zelda! As they learn the song of remembrance, they both remember reincarnating in the land of Hyrule, and Ganon is back with an army of undead cave monsters! everything makes sense now!
Can you elaborate please
Naah
There are still alot of unanswered questions but I would say this episode answered some of them. We still have to wait for almost 2 years for the remaining questions to be answered.
I think the Boy in White is the Man in Yellow! The way he is growing, the way only he can appear in Daylight! The part he manipulates Tabitha to go back because her being in From Ville will only hamper with his goals. He never ever does anything constructive, at least the Anghkooey Kids ask Tabitha and Jim to remember!
i think when julie came to tell jim “this is where it happens” she was from future, because she already knew this was to happen and she came from future to tell him the same but as she couldn’t change anything, it happened! her hair looked short as well!
In the cave painting, there were 2 people above the symbol. What if that was jade and tabitha
If you use Lost as a reference The Man in Black (Antagonist) vs The Man is White (Protagonist) the true forces pulling the strings behind the scenes.
From is doing the same thing the Boy in White is going against the Man in Yellow.
Julie is the Cromenockle.
Victor is the Lonely Dragon, and his truck hiding place is the Cavern of the Lonely Dragon.
Julie needs to go on a quest and Ethan is the key to understanding the story.
Ethan and Julie needs to see the map in Victor´s truck.
The faraway trees and the ruins will be portals in time and space for Julie to try to break the cycle.
Ethan, being a child (the only surving child) is the key to the story.
He has been telling them since S1 that they need to piece together the story (all the drawings) to save someone on a quest.
The lake of tears is where Elis realises Elgin has Tabitha.
The need a boat to escape.
Season 4 premiere prediction: Julie will time travel back to when Jim was killed and finally get it right, she will convince Jim to go back to town and he will live. That will make it an epic season finale for season 3!
The man in yellow is the boy in white grandfather, he asked his son to sacrifice his son, and did it and the boy in white is simply the soul of the boy sacrificed. Also, the son of the man in the white suit is or could be smiley making the boy in white his son, notice how smiley and the man in yellow come out, like father like son.
The question that keeps lingering on my mind is what the purpose of the child sacrifices is for the evil entity?
The entity must already have had significant power to persuade the parents to make the sacrifices. So aside from having a few extra monsters roaming around, not much seems to have been gained from this bargain. Given the revelation that one couple refused the bargain, this leads me to suspect that the ritual is not yet complete and that the evil entity is still one sacrifice short of achieving whatever its goal is.
What’s also interesting is that the ritual appears to require the willing sacrifice of parents, as opposed to the evil entity simply killing and then taking a child. This might also explain why the voices that Sara hears asked her to kill Ethan and suggests to me that the voices were, in fact, genuinely trying to prevent the ritual from being completed, since killing Ethan would have eliminated him as a candidate for willing sacrifice.
It also explains why Victor was allowed to stay alive following the massacre, since, without his parents present to sacrifice him, he held no utility for the evil entity.
The evil entity needs one more child, willingly sacrificed, to complete its endgame. Ethan seems an unlikely candidate given that Tabitha will not likely acquiesce. So either the entity needs a new child, or perhaps the entity will try to use Julie and her storywalking abilities to influence the past and to get the original parents that refused the sacrifice to give into the bargain after all.
That painting of the red thing was exactly what Smiley looked like when being reborn.
It is even in the theme song "whatever will be,will be. The future is not ours to see..." Julie can see the past but not change it
It's so messed up that anyone would consider sacrificing their own children to live forever.
It seems weird to me because parents will do so much to keep their children safe, and they often love them very deeply🤔
I agree. Not everyone is meant to be parents though and a lot of people are terrified of the afterlife & what comes next. I couldn’t even imagine doing something like that. Because once your children are gone, it’s almost hard to go on & live at all.
This episode was so good ❤But we have to wait another two years 😭 😢 for the next season
My biggest question is what the hell the lady in the kimono is... it is not a regular monster, i think... shes some kind of ghost... idk regular monsters cant get in if there is a talisman, but she can materialize herself in daylight, i thought the boy in white would grow into the man in yellow, maybe he would...
yo even I think the boy in white is man in yellow! He is growing and not really helping anyone lmao!!! Maybe even he can time travel! He has just decided to appear in his final form!
I think the BIW can change his appearance based on who he’s speaking to, to gain their trust. Victor and Ethan always see the little boy, cause they’re children at heart, they want a friend. Boyd first sees the BIW as Martin, he was an old marine to give Boyd that tie to him, he’d help a marine. It’s why Martin knew everyone and Boyds wife’s words, Julie saw him as Martin because she just went to where Boyd was, the story wouldn’t change for her.
This was a wild ride, so Julie hair was shorter and her clothes seem different, did she try and change the story and that brought the man in yellow?
Ok i thought i was tripping
No. This is Julie from the future, probably from season 4 or 5 to save his dad from killed. But I think that man in yellow came out due to Jade's music.