Review: Comica Vimo C dual channel wireless microphone
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ก.พ. 2023
- Here's my thoughts on the Comica Vimo C3 dual channel wireless mic system after using and testing it for a couple of weeks.
If you have enjoyed this video, a tip can be donated at www.ko-fi.com/davidjohns
Buy the mic at geni.us/TS_ComicaVimoC (Amazon affiliate link)
See also my review of the Hollyland Lark M1 at • Review: Hollyland Lark... as well as my review of the Godox MoveLink II • Review: Godox MoveLink...
Web: www.tubeshooter.co.uk
Twitter: / tubeshootermag
Instagram: / tubeshootermag - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
As usual, an absolutely impeccable review covering absolutely everything.
Much appreciated! 😀
wanted to watch a review of this mic and got a nostalgic feeling for my times in England... Thank you for this great video! Greetings from Ukraine!
Thanks for the review. I'm considering these mics.
Thank you. I’ve been looking at this mic but your video is the only one I’ve seen with a distance test. I might be picking this mic up.
Glad it was helpful!
Thank you very much for your detailed review and your valuable comments, which are of great help to our product improvement. 😊
Glad it was helpful!
Thank you sir! Very much underrated!
Much appreciated, thanks 😊
Thanks for the nice and detailed review! 👏 I already bought the set and after your test will make sure not to use the local noise reduction. I recommend my editing software DaVinci Resolve 18 with its stunning noise cancelling tool.
Thank you. I agree, the new NR tool in Resolve is excellent; you only need to use a little of it, maybe 10-20%, to get a much cleaner sound.
I didn’t expect this to be so cheap. Pleasant surprise when i clicked the link.
Yes, it's decent value
I have this same wireless mic system, have had it for several weeks. I don’t use the wind muff indoors and was wondering why you are? Very good and thorough review, one of the best for this item that I’ve seen. 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Thank you. I keep the wind muff on as a pop filter in case of any plosives or in case I breathe heavily downwards!!
@@TubeShooterMag That’s a good idea. 👍🏻👍🏻
Hi Nice Review. Thank you for the nice upload.
Glad you liked it!
Thanks for the review. I wonder if the Comic and Hollyland systems aren't the same system in different cases? You mentioned a number of similarities, so maybe the two are siblings (or maybe cousins). I was also thinking that the noise reduction might be useful in a space that has some annoying but low-level noise . . . like my apartment, where I can't get a clean recording of anything because the heating pipes in the walls are always expanding and contracting. Anyway, I learn a lot from your reviews. Thank you again!
They are very similar in many respects. I'd still choose to apply noise reduction in my editing software as you have more control that way.
As a person with a moderate form of obsession with microphones (“junkie” in America-speak), and now a (still happy) owner of a full dual DJI Mic kit - a much more expensive, better-rounded (pun intended) and versatile system, I have to say that the sound comparison you did between the three systems demonstrated that the guys at Comica seriously progressed since the time of CVM-200/300 system: I actually like the Vimo sound better than Hollyland and RODE - it's deeper and richer (NB: I'm not an audiophile, but I know how to tell good sound from bad sound).
As for DJI vs. RODE WG II - it was a no-brainer for me, even given that where I live a DJI system costs 1.5 times more than RODE WG II. My idea is that folks at DJI just took everything that RODE WG II users are not happy with, compiled a checklist and methodically went over it, ticking all the boxes... and actually updated the firmware twice since release, both updates being useful and important.
In this video I also noticed a signal half-dropout at ≈20:29, after the words ”not really noticeable”. Maybe it was the only dropout like that, but in my line of work even that is usually not quite acceptable.
Given the system price though (£110 where I am if delivered from China, import duties non-existent) and target audience, it is very much tolerable (I would not consider a system without an option of plugging in a proper lapel microphone anyway).
Hmm yes that glitch is odd, I hadn't noticed it before. I'll have to check the edit and see if it's there or some sort of TH-cam glitch.
The noise reduction made it sound like you were under water. However the regular sound sounded great to me. The range was very good too. Certainly considering getting this.
So in your opinion, which is best. The Comica or the Hollyland Lark M1? We have bought the M1 but would prefer to be able to see levels as we are recording.
It depends on your application. If you need to use the noise cancellation then the Hollyland (though even that can be a bit aggressive and noticeable but it's much more usable than the Vimo). The Vimo's audio level indicator is poor as mentioned but the rest of the screen info is good.
They sound pretty good for the price and considering how much more the Rode wireless system costs.
Thanks for the great review mate. Can i charge my smartphone via the usb c port if i use a pass through right angle usb c dongle? Some mics allow to do that
Sorry, I don't know, I've never tried that and don't have a dongle like that
DId you prefer the Hollyland or the Comica? From the sound samples, I thought the Hollyland sounded better but I guess there is a lot more to it than 1 sound sample.
I'm undecided! I think they both do a decent enough job for their price. The Hollyland annoys me in that there's no indication of the output level (though you can set it three ways) so you have to press and assume you've set it right.
Impressive
Sound quality isn't half-bad, and the wind muff is quite effective...but these aren't in the same league as the Rode or DJI offerings which allow for internal recording and external lav mic input. For the price though, I can see these being a hit with the vloggers looking for a cheap wireless. I wonder if Comica will update firmware to address your concerns. My guess is that the 'cheaper' the price point, the less likely they'll devote engineering resources towards it. Nicely reviewed though.
I don't think it would take a huge effort to tweak the noise reduction so I'm hopeful!
@@TubeShooterMag running the NR in post will (almost) always be better, since you have granular control. Same for low-cut filters (the DJI Mics low cut is way too aggressive for my taste).
Oh absolutely but in situations such as live streaming where there's no ability to do post, inbuilt NR could be very handy.
What do you think using this for professional shoot.. like weddings?
I would prefer to use a system with built in recording as a backup rather than rely on a purely wireless device.
That's a nicer sounding mic capsule, great range but are we all microwaving ourselves?
Errr... no. The output power of those mics is so astronomically tiny as to be entirely inconsequential especially in a world where the mobile phones around you are putting out far more power and even that is negligible in actual power terms.
We’ve been since the microwave is introduced. So nothing really new
Hi, I have a macbook air with only thunderbolt and 3.5mm slot. Is there any reason why I can't choose the device (Comica boomXD) in sound "input" ? It doesn't seem to work on my computer in zoom. Can anyone help please ? Thanks!
I'm no expert on that Mac but isn't the 3.5mm a headphone jack rather than a mic input?
Have you tried plugging in the TRRS end to your macbook?
On my mac selecting "built-in microphone" chooses the comica. In some app audio settings it appears as "built-in microphone (external)" and others just "built-inmicrophone"
Now there's another one, even cheaper:
Hollyland Lark M1 Wireless Lavalier Microphone. Might be worth a review.
Already done it
th-cam.com/video/Ni08MQSZVik/w-d-xo.html
Can I connect Vimo C3 with iphone ? Can I connect it via lightning port ?
Not directly with this model; you'd need an adapter (3.5mm to Lightning). They do make a Vimo model with Lightning connector on it but it's not the same as the Vimo C3 (eg it does not have the same screen and I don't know if the audio spec is the same)
Thank a lot.@@TubeShooterMag
he noise reduction made it sound like you were talking into a bucket, however, when you went to turn the NR off, when you were closer to the mike, your voice became much clearer. So to my ears, if you're going to use the sound reduction, put the mic much closer to your mouth, or speak directly into it.
Yeah. My guess is that in bringing my mouth directly above the mic, the ratio of my voice to background sound was much higher so the NR didn’t have to do so much hence it sounded better. It wouldn’t always be practical to have the mic so close though.
How you connect this to IPhone?
You would need some sort of interface that converts a stereo analogue signal on 3.5mm jack, to Apple's Lightning connection.