Your health doesn't depend on your weight!! You don't sound overweight to me. I think your height and weight are good so long as you have a good muscle to fat ratio :)
First of all, its not like all knetz like/love her body like that. Second. We all have a different taste,if someone likes their bodies just like lisa so let them be( I, for one likes to have her body coz im fat af.) Who are we to judge on what is beautiful and ugly for someone else other than ourselves,right? Third. No matter what kind of body she has,knetz or haters alike will still bash her. Fourth. For me,it doesnt matter what kind of body she has,as long as she's healthy,then thats enough
Yubi has an ideal BMI, yet she feels bad about it. That's Korean's beauty standard right there. Even Shin Ji at 58 kgs and people call her fat. Like wtf. Kids would probably think that Lisa's is the ideal body.. but 16 for a BMI is scary. And its not just about her, most idols are on that range. IN fact, that's the ideal idol BMI. The goal of idols is to be at 45kgs or less on debut. And to think that their job is to dance all day and keep themselves healthy enough to perform. The physical activity of an idol is not that far from that in the army, yet, what idols consider overweight is actually what's ideal for a soldier. I swear I feel bad for them sometimes. When they are on variety shows and they get so happy when they are given chicken and pizza, my heart breaks for them. And this is mostly also the fault of the fans. If someone starts gaining weight, even if its not even that huge of the difference, they start attacking them online. LIke, people should seriously get a grip of themselves.
소녀팬Hallyuthere! Don’t forget the pressure from the actual company too. They are really strict about diets and lots of idols (and ex trainees) have talked about how their company put them on restrictive diets and weighed them every week or even every day and would get mad at them if they gained any weight through the day/week. Edit: I’m not talking about anyone in particular (I never even mentioned Lisa in my original comment because it isn’t about her), I’m just talking about what a lot of people have said. I don’t know what goes on behind the scenes in anyone’s life but it’s no secret that some people are put on awful diets that really shouldn’t be a thing.
_Issaboll _ @chaerms @Jane Tufuga you know that Lisa is naturally skinny right? Yes there is still a pressure on idols in general to have a certain weight but even Lisa's mum was very slim so it's genetics. Her members and herself have said no matter what she eats she can't gain weight, not to mention she's their main dancer and puts all her energy in dancing and has started to work out. Just letting you know. 😂 since so many thought Lisa is unhealthy and starves herself to fit "standards".
Lol it's so funny here in the comment section forreal 50% saying lisa eats a lot 50% saying lisa's a skeleton/too skinny and shiz. No one's denying she's underweight but she's been skinny ever since she was a child, now you don't go around telling your friend (let's suppose she's been thin her whole life) "OMg you're So SkinNy you'll FaiNt" or shit like that. Sometimes people really do be skinny/underweight whithout doing it purposefully. I'm not implying anything on Lisa's weight may it be the company's putting her on diet or maybe she's really a skinny legend but at the end of the day it's none of my or your fking business. End of the discussion, thanks for being in my TED talk.
Maybe she has been skinny since she was born. I don't know, but I know it's unhealthy. I have studied about nutrition and if your BMI is under 19 you have a problem. The problem gets worse as it goes down, and 16 is very very underweight. As some of you say maybe she was skinny since day 1, but im sure not that skinny. She should gain weight obviously. Don't come in here saying she is healthy, cause she isnt. She might not have the consecuences now, but they will come one day. Probably they will come when she ends her career as BP member and nobody will care cause she will be old. Now keep supporting her diet and saying her ribs look cool when she dances. Thank you for being in my TED talk.
Thank you. Not that long ago Blinks were absolutely screaming at me for being concerned that Lisa’s so underweight and that her BMI wasn’t normal. They were writing big long paragraphs about why BMI doesn’t matter and she’s healthy and she wasn’t underweight. For that group of Blinks, please stop harassing others who are worried about Lisa, this video shows a *certified doctor* saying she’s not only underweight but *very* underweight. I’m not trying to be rude or one of those people but I say it only out of actual concern... ;-;
Honestly, I think it all depends on how she's naturally shaped. A lot of idols are pressured to look that way, but if she was born that way and stays healthy, there is nothing wrong with that
@@jadescalet1639 underweight yes, it's possible to be naturally underweight sometimes, but she is very underweight as the doctor said. From before debut in the dance rehearsal to now it is clear to be seen she's lost weight, to the point where her arms and legs have been gaunt and ribs visible which isn't just from naturally losing a few pounds through exercise. It's deliberate. I'm not trying to shame Lisa's body or attack her, I loved her talent and personality and style it's just it's concerning seeing the difference.
BMI may not specifically tell if someone's healthy or not, but weight defenitely does. If lisa's underweight she's unhealthy. I hope she is ok though.... we've had enough of idols with EDs so let's hope for the best for her... :(
She's wearing jeans too. Jeans can add at least 1kg to the scale. After drinking water and having breakfast can also fluctuate your weight so... ...don't tell me she's under 44kg 😱
even after this health officer said lisa is very underweight still her hardcore fans says her body is ideal type.. haahhahaha her fans gonna killed me for saying this... usually the company put them under diet regime 2 keep idols stayed in shape..
Maybe Lisa does dieting but not to the extreme. Lisa was born with skinny genes you could see from her predebut pictures also she has very high metabolism rate making her skinny
@@__-jo3gn lisa doesn't need a diet.. having a high metabolism is already a gift for the glutton sinners. If she does it herself or the company makes her do it. Thats how sad YG is.
miz fitry lisa & rosé have said that they eat the most within the group. they don't diet most of the time, yg artists are more towards exercising as they have their own personal trainers.
Fyi Lisa is skinny since she was a kid plus she have been dancing for almost her whole life dancing burns a lot of fats. Secondly, in YG ent they dont do things like extreme diet unless you really look very chubby they'll just send you to the YG gym and ask you to do a healthy diet that's all. In blackpink house we can see that all of them eats very healthy and they exercise regularly. I dont think you know much about blackpink. Compare them to their pre debut they never once looked chubby before and their body always looks the same if someone is going on diet that person will have at least one time that they look extremely skinny or chubby. Lastly, even if they really diet i dont mind as long as they're confident and happy bout it and they're healthy.
Lisa Oppa hehe I’ve been following blackpink since yg announce to debut new girl group after 2ne1.. and I know that Lisa n rose have high metabolism..and Iam okey with that but my problem is their fan based put her and rose picture saying “body goals” u know urself black pink followers basiclly a teenager girls and boys that their early age around 11-30 so for me okey for me... Its not okey if u used “bodygoal” for her body since it show clearlly lisa is veryunder weight.. and the teenage girls definitely gonna follow their idol to look like their idol.. do what their idol do, eat, wearing, even some of the fans trying so damn hard to be like their idols.. for some that have the same metabolism as Lisa n rose then it’s okey but if her fans that not in the same condition as her will try so hard to have her body.. u get what I mean... i know what high metabolism body is, me myself have that, my friend have it too.. I have no bad attention towards blackpink.. I love yg family so don’t take my comment the wrong way but please3 dont promotes “underweight” body as a body goals ok Sory to blink if u guys feels offended by my comments
People are praising Lisa's body. When my bmi was similar I was nearly dead. Always freezing, hair falling out in chunks, heart problems. I couldn't even breath. I'm 100% sure she doesn't has her period.
BMI of 16 is concerningly underweight and if she were my patient in England, not going to lie, I’d admit her for treatment or investigation (I’m studying medicine) Edit: BMI is very flawed, I agree. But it acts as an alarm bell to alert healthcare professionals. Malnutrition kills faster than obesity so it’s understandable that ppl may want to safe than sorry.
i have a bmi of 15 0-0 Edit: I'm perfectly healthy and overall feel happy and jolly. Everyone says i don't eat enough but i eat up to my content and just get full easily.
@@koomnies So you're either sick or very, very underweight. I was hospitalized at the bmi of 16 during my anorexia nervosa period, without them going further in details. They just took me in and I'm so glad they did because if not for them I would be dead.
Aww, im glad you're okay now~ Im honestly fine and happy and i don't purposely starve my self, i just get full easily. I feel healthy so i don't think if of much a concern, its good that you got hospitalized though.
@@koomnies You should still contact your doctor, regardless of how you feel right now it might change in the near future. I was also "getting full" easily. Didn't work for me. But thank you for your concern. Unfortunately, anorexia is incurable and it leaves a permanent print on your mind and body. You can have a healthy brain afterwards, but there will always be a red light signaling you in the less wanted moment. Some behaviors also stay with you until the very end (being absolutely unable to eat in public, in my case). That's why awareness on it is so important.
My sister is 167cm and weights 45kg. More or less like Lisa, but she hasn't had her period yet. It happened to me to, but once I had my period I developed and therefore gained some weight. Lisa BMI doesn't come out as a surprise, most idols will have the same problem because they are forced to eat what a 3 year old would while working out as a police officer would. Many idols have talked about this issue, for women is specially harsh, most will stop having their period, their hair will fall due to stress and mental illness can be developed. I know that a lot of you want to defend Lisa because she's someone you admire, but idols don't show that part of their lives, please do not make excuses, she didn't make them for herself because she knows her weight has to do with how she is living.
I beg to differ. I’m short, 147cm and 43kg. Bmi is normal but I look ‘skinny’ to some of my friends. Trust me, I EAT MORE THAN MY FRIENDS. I’m 23 and my weight is constant to 43kg even if I eat more. If you ask some of my overweighted friends, they’ll agree I eat more than them, and I usually take some portion of their meal. One thing us skinny ppl hate to hear is “please gain more weight” ffs WE’RE TRYING BITCH SHUT UP. I’ve only gained like 1kg for months and lose it again for a day after just walking around the neighborhood. I’m not defending lisa because I love her, I’m defending all the skinny girls out there who ARE TRYING ffs. Ps: I know your comment was like 3 months ago, I just had to place it here because I am sick and tired of reading all the comments, thinking you ‘know’ skinny ppl more than they know themselves. Like, shut up.
@@roni9766 48 is very skinny fr youre height as well but still better than lisa 45 kg is very unhealthy fr her height im 160cm im trying to be 48kg youre weight but fr me it is not a danger
“Lisa, you are very underweight.” Did y’all hear sum?? For you immature and unreasonable blinks saying she’s “hEaLthY” are wrong. Being underweight is as unhealthy as being overweight. I’m pretty sure you can still be healthy while being a little underweight, but Lisa is *VERY* underweight. She can’t be 100% healthy. I’m not bashing her or anything, I’m just as concerned about her health.
What do we all know abt being healthy when teenagers nowadays consume fast food and drink coke. They gained weight and also very very unhealthy. The doctor told me that I was under weight too and I ate three meal a day with snack mostly ice cream and toasted bread with Nutella.
Domi sure, but an actual doctor told Lisa that she is underweight and needs to gain weight. Also, Lisa is an adult woman and not a teenager. She is also a dancer, which you need to be strong and healthy to be. I always wondered why Lisa doesn’t have muscles even though she’s a dancer..
eunbiased fan You don’t gain muscles from dancing. Dancer who have muscle probably exercise. This is the evaluation for entering army. That why the doctor told Lisa to gain more weight. And also even though I’m underweight, the doctor only told me to eat more iron and fiber cause I lack in those. That why I said normal people who have normal weight doesn’t always guarantee to be healthy. It’s depend on the food they eat. Eating power food such as meat, healthy fat etc would help Lisa as a dancer. Not necessary abt eating more calories to gain more weight.
True lol... But she doesn't gain weight... She eats a lot but doesn't gain weight because of her fast metabolism and she exercise a lot But she is healthy... But sad thing is... When idols lose weight, Knetz call them skinny, but when Idols gain weight, they body shame the idols and call them fat
Yes. She is 167cm which is quiet tall for a girl. She only need put on around 6kg more to get ideal BMI. Or she will look so fragile. That is not healthy.
The fact that Shinji was in "best" condition and she's considered fat by a lot of Knetz should say a lot about the problems in their society. Being thin doesn't mean you're healthy. It just means you're thin. Lisa has too little muscle, and her body fat percentage is very low, it's no surprise that she got that evaluation to be honest. It's really unfair for celebrities to be honest. The standards they have to follow are unhealthy for them, and if they don't, they get a bunch of criticism.
This comment section my lord! How do you know Lisa eats a lot? Just because they show them on tv eating doesn't mean she eats a lot. Do you know if she went without eating the previous day or two. It is very common and even weird that Korean idols once on tv stuff large amounts of food down their throat almost like they're snuffing in the food and people watching are like Omo! Omo! Omo! She eats really well! You need to do a CF. It is a weird obsession if you ask me. Cause it is mostly a false image they create for diversion. Most normal people don't stuff ramyun with egg and cheese, ice-cream, jajangmyun, crepe with fruits in one sitting. And when that happens, you should be worried about what they do afterwards behind closed doors. I worry more about the one in the group they call squirrel cheeks. Cause her legs and her eating appetite on tv don't match AT ALL.
There are so many other talented groups from other companies. Get that you want to defend the group you love but read through my comment I didn't just talk about one group, I clearly also stated Korean idols. What is your point?
YG definitely cares about looks, what are you talking about. EVERY idol in YG is pretty and slim, and basically made to look perfect. Its the Kpop industry, every company puts looks has one of the top priorities. Just cause BP eat a lot on camera does not mean that they are not scrutinized behind the camera. The industry is very messed up.
FINALLY. I'M TIRED OF ALL OF THESE BLONKS SAYING "Ohhh, Lisa is fine! She eats on camera!" Like no sweetie, just because you eat once on a livestream, doesn't mean you eat everyday! I have a fast metabolism, but the only time I got down to 45kg was when I was deep into my eating disorder! And I'm 163cm!
Lisa is 45 kilograms?? I adore Lisa, but it isn't called being "body positive" if you encourage an unhealthy physique. I'm 157 cm and 45 kg would be borderline underweight for me, definitely underweight for her. I wish she wouldn't have to feel so much pressure from society to be skinny, it isn't healthy. Health comes first, y'all.
How is LISA 167 cm but only 45 kgs? She is too thin, she needs to gain some weight. I am 160cm and 45 kgs and I still get teased for being super thin (I am currently 14 if anyone's wondering) Edit: she's 44.7 kgs, that's even lower that what I had said before Also the ideal weight for someone who is 167 cm tall is 58.7206 kgs
I KNOW RIGHT i'm 159 cm and my weight is 45 kg.. and the skinniest i have ever been was when i was 43kg.. how can she be 44.7kg with that height. i looked wayyy to skinny when i was at 43kg, i cant comprehen her weight and height.. its so underweight...
Then how is she supposed to gain weight if she's naturally skinny?.. If your gens don't allow it, then you can't do much about it until you're in the late 40's.
@@nobodyqwertyu All my life, i've been underweight. At the age of 11 I had a BMI 15.5, and hoovered around BMI 16 till I was 24. After that my BMI was around 16.5 to 17. I'm currently 27 years old with a BMI 17.2. I always eat a lot, even at night. Up to 6 meals a day. Nobody in my family eats as much as I do. I don't have any medical conditions. It's just genetical. My father was also very skinny. He started gaining at the age of 35.
@@nobodyqwertyu I already been to doctors multiple times. Checked my thyroid, metabolism and immune system every year. Nothing's wrong with it. I was always healthy, my blood was always normal, aswell as blood pressure (115-135/75-90). My father is currently 62 years old and he doesn't have any cardiovascular issues or any health problems. My grandma had a BMI below 19 until she was like 45. She got married with 157 cm and 45 kg. She died at the age of 89.
Nice to see a guy applauding women for being BMI 20-25, that's usually where most people's bodies work best at, only a small minority of the population are meant to be BMI 19 or below
Nobody is meant to be at that bmi. It’s literally just always healthier to be in the 20/25 ratio. Always always. Whether your weight is made up of fat or muscle makes a difference in how your body looks, but the weight really shouldn’t ever be too low
2:50 i dont like how she feels so shocked abt it. Whats so bad abt being healthy? Since when did having a BMI lower than the lowest point become a trend..
i am in no way saying that she has one, but people with eating disorders often hate being/looking healthy, when someone tells us "hey you look way too thin you should get help" it doesnt help at all, instead makes us feel worse (or better, depending on the situation) and makes us want to starve/restrict even more than before :/ hope i didnt come off as rude!!
Yes lisa is very underweight look at her stomach we can see a bone😩 I don’t understand when someone says that lisa has an abs but all i see is a bone sorry but she will be so pretty if she gained some weight
Yeah. I even saw a video or so that literally states "Korean idols with the best abs" I was like no, no, no. these people are below the healthy range for their heights and have so little fat the bones and abdominis muscles are showing. There's a difference between a well developed abdominis and malnourished abdominis.
리아 りあLIA how do you know if she had a exercise routine or not ?? Do you know her ?? No. She lost her baby fat already when she was 16-18. ((Most girls lose at 15-16)) So hot wasn't even a era. It was a performance. + did you know that when you eat normally after a strict diet, you'll gain more weight than what you started with. Most idols actually gain weight during promotions because they are on a diet before a comeback but then they'll eat normally ((or even more)) so that they can perform without passing out. The whole point of the one that commented first was that she's underweight and the proof is in this video that she actually is.
리아 りあLIA I know that she has a exercise routine but you said that she didn't have one in boombayah era and that's why I said how do you know if she had one or not. I've had anorexia for 5 years so I know really well what you mean ((+ I'm sorry that you had to go through it :( )). I'm not saying that she's anorexic but she's clearly underweight in my eyes ((like the Doctor I this video said)). Some people look disgusted while eating & some people look like it's the best moment in their life because they can't eat well often. (I was the one who almost cried because I wanted to eat but I couldn't because I thought I would become fat so I pretty much cried everytime I was forced to eat). That's why I'm definitely not body shaming her. I'm just really worried and I hope that she focuses more on eating.
Last year I went through an eating disorder, I’m 3cm shorter than lisa and my lighter weight was 43kg, 2kg lighter than her. I wasn’t able to do normal things like running or jumping. I got drunk with less than two alcohol glasses. I fainted very often and sometimes I couldn’t even feel my own body or move my hands while trying to hold something. Lisa is going through this while being and idol, someone’s gotta do something.
I know that it's the company's responsibility to watch over their idols but shouldn't lisa make an effort too? What do u mean by YG not allowing her to eat more or weight more? If they want her to be underweight then the rest of the members must be underweight too. Or do you mean YG is strict with their diets but for sure YG wouldn't allow her to be underweight. If lisa wants to have a normal bmi then she also have to make an effort to eat not more not less. Y'all always blame it to the company 😂
Just because she's underweight doesn't mean YG make her starve. There are a lot of female singer who can't gain much weight even tho they eat a lot like Dara and Yoona. And I'm pretty sure Blackpink member work out
right, although i'm not that skinny, i'm 5'4.5 and weight 118 lbs people still say i'm skinny and the thing is, i eat a lot and people are always wondering where the food goes. and I don't even exercise.
the people who say lisa is body goals are going by photos of her dolled up and clothes worn to make her look good and suits her, if you see her irl she is frail like alarmingly so. 16 is just outright crazy bmi plus she dances and has hectic schedules this is very concerning.
kelsy ella I’m sorry but being underweight will NEVER mean you are healthy, also she’s very underweight, with that BMI she most probably has amenorrhea, nutritional deficiencies and a weakened immune system
Ampi Cea i have always had a fast metabolism and my bmi used to be around 16.4, and i was fine. i had energy, i was healthy, and i had a regular period every month. everybody’s body is different, and we all have a weight that our body works best at. bmi isn’t that great because it doesnt take into account things like body fat percentage, muscle mass, bone mass. it is not an inclusive body calculator, especially for body builders who have lots of muscle mass but are considered ‘overweight’ or even ‘obese’ in bmi terms. when will society learn that weight is not a one size fits all. our bodies are so different, and it probably sucked for lisa to be told that she needed to gain weight when she probably feels as healthy as ever and has always been smaller than most people. weight does not always determine health, but anyway, that’s just what i think.
@@kaeyaslut3545 exactly, every body is different. So just because you are underweight and feel like your are fine( cuz let me tell you, I've been underweight and never felt anything wrong with me, I was even doing a lot of sports and stuff I was a ball of energy,but when I went to doctor to make some analysis I found out that I was anemic, but that's just me) it doesn't mean that Lisa is. A doctor ( someone specialized) told her that her weight is not healthy and that she should (for her good) put some weight on. So are we really going to contradict someone who studied medicine and human body for so long just because we think that we know everything? I mean he said that for a reason and because he knows what is up. Not like us Just saying
Raluca Holom yeah i understand where you’re coming from, and he does have more expertise in this field, but all he did was calculate her bmi, and anyone could do that. not to say that he doesnt know more, which he probably does, but in this video he simply stated that she was unhealthy due to being underweight, and that means he wouldve said the same to me and many others who are on the slim side. yes, we don’t know the contents of lisa’s diet or if she has issues with her health, but bmi should not be the only determinant of health.
I'm so happy that i live in a country with less beauty standards 😭 Poor koreans for being judge so much! In my country height, weight, and your face shape doesnt matter! If you are pretty, then you are pretty as long as youre healthy (means no obessity or anorexia)
@@evelynannn the answer basiclly is anywhere but Korea (or maybe the entire Asia - which is sad because i'm also asian). Europe is probaly the place tho, since people are more into athletes body.
When some people say that Lisa needs to gain weight some blinks attack them and they say that Lisa eats a lot... HOW DO YOU KNOW THAT LISA EATS? JUST BECAUSE YOU SAW IT ON CAMERA IT DOESNT MEAN THAT IT IS ALWAYS REAL... I'm worried for Lisa... Also the fact that she has a fast metabolism is not an excuse Even if she has a fast metabolism it doesn't mean that she can't gain weight PLEASE THINK ABOUT IT AND STOP BEING RUDE TO OTHERS BECAUSE THEY ARE CONCERNED I hope Lisa is ok❤ (Sorry for the long paragraph)
You should seen her pre-debut photos. She even skinnier than now. And also just because she is underweight doesn’t mean she is unhealthy. What if a person with normal weight eat fast food, drink coke, eat sugary foods, isn’t it also consider unhealthy? Idk why people think weight is the main contributor to being healthy. My doctor told me that I’m underweight, thinner than girls my age but she only told me that I should try eating more iron and fiber cause I lack in those. She didn’t advise me to gain more weigh or anything. She even told me to exercise more and stuff.
There was a person who argued with me that Lisa sings "Born skinny b*tch" in one of their songs so it's a proof the she is naturally very underweight. Seriously tho, i could sing about having a master degree in astropyhsics but it won't make it true...some fans are delusional. Edit: Also, unless someone has a rare metabolic disease, there is no such thing as "fast metabolism".Two female with similar height/weight/age/activity llevel will have about the same BMR, maybe 50-100 kcal difference, wich is basically just a banana or a bite of a chocolate bar. A heavier person would even have higher metabolism compared to an underweight person due to the higher mass (assuming they have similar activity levels). If someone can't gain, they are just simply not eating enough. Same goes for obese people who can't lose weight: either metabolic disease or they are eating too much
It's heartbreaking that the last girl was so shocked to be told she's in good shape. She's probably had to deal with so many people calling her fat. This is the problem with asian beauty standards. My BMI has always been 21-22 and guys used to tell me my ass was too big. Really hope the standards change some day.
I just love Lee yu bi's visual.. Her whole facial structure is just bright!! I saw her in the kdrama pinocchio and I have been startrucked since then..
Idk if Lisa is so skinny because of her metabolism or not, I just wish people didn't say that either "she's the beauty standard" nor "she's too much skinny" cause healthy isn't defined only by BMI and beauty standards are so relative that is a complete nonsense. I'm western and weighing more then 50 used to be my life goal, I just realized how the beauty standards were affecting me after watching kdramas, cause it made me realize how the concept of beauty changes and somehow always oppress someone.
Bubbly tea being overweight is as big of a problem but people don’t complain when someone is overweight and when they do, other people complain and say that we should stop body shaming.
We arent complaining but she is underweight BUT SHES HEALTHY is which is what matters dont get mad when we say shes underweight but shes healthy anyways so its all good
People are saying in the comment section lisa eats a lot. Every time she eats on TV, she looks so happy as if she's not allowed to eat them whenever she wants. I just hope that people understand that idols are humans too, they overwork themselves and then they aren't even allowed to eat properly I get it that even idols themselves want to be skinny(mostly because they are scared they will be bashed by the knetz) but there should be a healthy and proper way. Oh and yeah 50kg, 55kg etc.aint fat, it's thiccccccc.
55 50 kg isn’t even “thicccc” it’s still thin. I guess it depends on the height, but most of the women in the video who were 50-55 kgs were quite tall, which is why they were considered slightly underweight. But even if you were let’s say 5’2 and about 50-55 kgs, you could fit in a US size 2-4 which are considered petite sizes.
guys underweight is not always bad some people are just skinny bmi means nothing ive been underweight all my life but its okay bc its consistent and its just the way my body is
Lisa weighs 97 lbs?!!!!! Wtffffff I haven’t been that weight since elementary school and I am considered very skinny at 120 for 5’4 . Wow how can she be healthy at that weight??? This will effect her joints when she’s older. It’s sad how much pressure idols have to be extremely skinny
i understand yall are concerned about lisa but instead of saying shes extremely underweight just state that you hope she's "happy and heathly" or something. it hurts to be told your very underweight.
I really hate korea's stigma of "if you're under 50kg ya good". Like whatever height of the girl is its seems like to them they should weigh under 50kg.
52 kg for her height is perfect. Not too thin nor too heavy, Koreans set standards too high, like I am in the same height to weight ratio as her and I think I am perfect like this way. Besides, BMI isn't always 100 percent accurate
I love Lisa and it makes me sad she needs to gain weight, but it's true. I think a LOT of kpop stans fail to realize that our girls tend to be forced on diets. Especially considering how important weight and beauty is in Korea, it's probably a huge pressure on them. I've been worried about her & rose being underweight for awhile and this made me sad. I really hope Lisa is being healthy and works hard to become well!
I understand the situation Lisa is in cuz when I was younger I was also underweight for my height and body type. The only difference is Lisa is tall, so her BMI is fine since it’s related to her height, but she’s too skinny for her body type. I also had a super high metabolism and was active in dancing/performing arts back then. So yes, it’s easy for girls like me and Lisa to lose weight fast. I do worry for Lisa though cuz it is true that she is underweight. She needs her protein and carbs in her eating habits. She doesn’t need to go on a complete diet cuz she’s already skinny as it is. All she really needs to do is to eat protein, iron, carbs and to occasionally work out and tone her body. Nothing extreme at all. It’s natural to think she’s tall and skinny..she’s body goals. But even if you’re skinny.. you can also be underweight and unhealthy. There’s a huge misconception about skinny people. 😆
I would like to add that it’s also SKOREA “ideal beauty standards” for decades is female idols has to be “skinny, pale complexion (Snow White), and etc.) “ That’s why some companies (not all) have their female and male idols go on diets..sometimes regular and at times extreme diets. Which is quite sad, why can’t idols be happy with their own bodies?? I mean if idols want to got on healthy diets..that’s their decision and I’m okay with that. But there’s just too many situations especially concerning female idols, where it’s too obvious that these female idols are forced to do diets cuz they are deemed “fat” or “overweight” in SKOREA standards. 😆
i hope kpop girlies can realise what mentality they're pushing on their idols. they're praising unhealthy living habits and creating this facade of perfection for themselves. so many idols are underweight but pressured to keep losing weight by their companies and "fans".
That's healthy, though 🤔 *Edit:* I was actually talking about the last girl (and a couple others), not Lisa. Her measurements are the ones in the title. Her weight is fine for her height, despite the lower BMI. And BMI's really aren't reliable because they don't factor body type, only height. My main point was that she was self concious saying she should have worn shorts rather than pants to weight less, but her weight isn't at all concerning.
Lena Rehmat I’ve been saying this Forever, Something is up with Lisa’s weight I can barely look at a Blackpink stage and Pay attention to Lisa because she’s so skinny it makes me uncomfortable.
JoJo Rivera I don’t think she particularly looks bad even tho she is on the skinnier side. Sometimes it’s hard for some people to gain weight. Lisa is probably one of those people, in fact I saw that she said that somewhere. She’s probably aware she’s very thin, I saw her workouts on blackpink House they look strength based so she might already be trying to gain muscle. It’s probably not easy hearing you’re underweight either who knows how many times she’s heard that even tho she does eat well and workout.
Lena Rehmat All the members weight have gone down drastically since debut if you look at side by side pictures. YG definitely put them on a diet, I’m not so much saying that it’s hard for people to look at her but it is for me when I see rib cages sticking out I know there’s a problem with metabolism, but like you said to the original comment Lisa is under weight for her height some people think it’s normal and Healthy and others call it “Body goals” on Twitter. Gaining weight when it’s not easy is really hard it happens to me and my sister but people cross the line when they say she’s Completely Healthy.
Just cause she's underweight doesn't mean she's fragile. She has displayed acts which require great upper body strength and from other clips in the series, she looks to be the most physically capable among the participants.
Beep Boop i didnt say shes fragile but sometimes such reality show in korea like to display lacks/flaw of foreign idol. Thats why i dont like the idea mostly they like to pick on foreign didnt you notice ? i knew it already her stamina is so excellent and she perform well i like her character too. that the point of my comment
I think they area adding a few cm in their profiles to make them more taller than their actual height..same goes for boy groups.but still love blackpink no matter what their height is.😍
@@eli-oh3oq I don't know where you got those numbers from but 166.5cm is 5 feet and 5.55 inches. So technically 5'6 is correct if you round by the inch. 5'4 is 162.5cm.
A high metabolism is when you struggle to gain weight, even when you eat a lot. It is very hard for someone who is naturally skinny to put on some weight. Trust me, I myself have a fast metabolism.
@Sparkcp exactly. maybe YG put them in a strict diet that no one knows. We dont know them well, so let us not put some fake news about the members to protect them or something.
potato min So you don’t have people around you that as skinny as Lisa. I think it’s normal for asian people actually since most of my friends are like that.
Lee Yu Bi big fan of her her body portion are healthy and the cutest in the girl team she is the bright one and entertaining one love you Lee Yu Bi fighting
I like how Shinji, out of all of them, is a bit more expressive with her face. I just started watching and i will hopefully see more of her facial expressions XD
![The Words are Difficult for Lisa...😭 She was too Scared! [The Real Men 300 Ep1]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2CJSc3L_iew/mqdefault.jpg)
![The Words are Difficult for Lisa...😭 She was too Scared! [The Real Men 300 Ep1]](/img/tr.png)
I'm actually happy that someone told Lisa she underweight, Hope she can have a healthy life!
I guess she needs to gain at least 10kg for her BMI to be normal because she's 167cm
kemo kemo wow you did math
Lol, nah it just happened that we have the same height and my weight and BMI are normal
She does have a healthy life but she was born skinny and prolly has a fast mentabolism
@@Jk-ey7mp still underweight.
I feel bad for them feeling that they need to be below 50kg...please please take care of youtself😭
Ummi amirah afini q
UGH, IKR. im like 62kg and 170 cm (im overweight ya ik) and meanwhile shes like a lil smaller and weighs 10kg less ..
Your health doesn't depend on your weight!! You don't sound overweight to me. I think your height and weight are good so long as you have a good muscle to fat ratio :)
Yeah like wtf that's nothing
namjoon's pet crab you‘re not overweight. Not even near overweight. 😅
Military doctor:lisa you are very underweight
Knetizen:lisa your are body goals for us
And that societies corrupted mindset
(Me being hypocrite)
Havent you guys seen a lot of other knetizens bodyshaming naming her things like only bone body, too skinny?? Not all knetz find her weight ideal.
First of all, its not like all knetz like/love her body like that.
Second. We all have a different taste,if someone likes their bodies just like lisa so let them be( I, for one likes to have her body coz im fat af.) Who are we to judge on what is beautiful and ugly for someone else other than ourselves,right?
Third. No matter what kind of body she has,knetz or haters alike will still bash her.
Fourth. For me,it doesnt matter what kind of body she has,as long as she's healthy,then thats enough
She clearly underweight but her fans support her being this skinny
Yubi has an ideal BMI, yet she feels bad about it. That's Korean's beauty standard right there. Even Shin Ji at 58 kgs and people call her fat. Like wtf. Kids would probably think that Lisa's is the ideal body.. but 16 for a BMI is scary. And its not just about her, most idols are on that range. IN fact, that's the ideal idol BMI. The goal of idols is to be at 45kgs or less on debut. And to think that their job is to dance all day and keep themselves healthy enough to perform. The physical activity of an idol is not that far from that in the army, yet, what idols consider overweight is actually what's ideal for a soldier. I swear I feel bad for them sometimes. When they are on variety shows and they get so happy when they are given chicken and pizza, my heart breaks for them. And this is mostly also the fault of the fans. If someone starts gaining weight, even if its not even that huge of the difference, they start attacking them online. LIke, people should seriously get a grip of themselves.
I agree, we all must change the standarts to be an idol, it's insane.
소녀팬Hallyuthere! Don’t forget the pressure from the actual company too. They are really strict about diets and lots of idols (and ex trainees) have talked about how their company put them on restrictive diets and weighed them every week or even every day and would get mad at them if they gained any weight through the day/week.
Edit: I’m not talking about anyone in particular (I never even mentioned Lisa in my original comment because it isn’t about her), I’m just talking about what a lot of people have said. I don’t know what goes on behind the scenes in anyone’s life but it’s no secret that some people are put on awful diets that really shouldn’t be a thing.
_Issaboll _ @chaerms @Jane Tufuga you know that Lisa is naturally skinny right? Yes there is still a pressure on idols in general to have a certain weight but even Lisa's mum was very slim so it's genetics. Her members and herself have said no matter what she eats she can't gain weight, not to mention she's their main dancer and puts all her energy in dancing and has started to work out. Just letting you know. 😂 since so many thought Lisa is unhealthy and starves herself to fit "standards".
Lol it's so funny here in the comment section forreal 50% saying lisa eats a lot 50% saying lisa's a skeleton/too skinny and shiz. No one's denying she's underweight but she's been skinny ever since she was a child, now you don't go around telling your friend (let's suppose she's been thin her whole life) "OMg you're So SkinNy you'll FaiNt" or shit like that. Sometimes people really do be skinny/underweight whithout doing it purposefully. I'm not implying anything on Lisa's weight may it be the company's putting her on diet or maybe she's really a skinny legend but at the end of the day it's none of my or your fking business. End of the discussion, thanks for being in my TED talk.
Maybe she has been skinny since she was born. I don't know, but I know it's unhealthy. I have studied about nutrition and if your BMI is under 19 you have a problem. The problem gets worse as it goes down, and 16 is very very underweight. As some of you say maybe she was skinny since day 1, but im sure not that skinny. She should gain weight obviously. Don't come in here saying she is healthy, cause she isnt. She might not have the consecuences now, but they will come one day. Probably they will come when she ends her career as BP member and nobody will care cause she will be old. Now keep supporting her diet and saying her ribs look cool when she dances. Thank you for being in my TED talk.
Thank you. Not that long ago Blinks were absolutely screaming at me for being concerned that Lisa’s so underweight and that her BMI wasn’t normal. They were writing big long paragraphs about why BMI doesn’t matter and she’s healthy and she wasn’t underweight. For that group of Blinks, please stop harassing others who are worried about Lisa, this video shows a *certified doctor* saying she’s not only underweight but *very* underweight. I’m not trying to be rude or one of those people but I say it only out of actual concern... ;-;
Same I’m concerned
i agree with you. some blinks are incredibly defensive and hard to reason with
Honestly, I think it all depends on how she's naturally shaped. A lot of idols are pressured to look that way, but if she was born that way and stays healthy, there is nothing wrong with that
@@jadescalet1639 underweight yes, it's possible to be naturally underweight sometimes, but she is very underweight as the doctor said. From before debut in the dance rehearsal to now it is clear to be seen she's lost weight, to the point where her arms and legs have been gaunt and ribs visible which isn't just from naturally losing a few pounds through exercise. It's deliberate. I'm not trying to shame Lisa's body or attack her, I loved her talent and personality and style it's just it's concerning seeing the difference.
BMI may not specifically tell if someone's healthy or not, but weight defenitely does. If lisa's underweight she's unhealthy. I hope she is ok though.... we've had enough of idols with EDs so let's hope for the best for her... :(
What’s scary is that Lisa is skinnier than that, because she has clothes on and she probably had breakfast or drank some water.
She's wearing jeans too. Jeans can add at least 1kg to the scale. After drinking water and having breakfast can also fluctuate your weight so...
...don't tell me she's under 44kg 😱
@@notsobright7257 jeans aren't that heavy
I think she’s around 43.8/49.4 kg..
@@notsobright7257 What kind of jeans are you wearing? I've never heard of jeans that weight 1 kg.
@@mrflip-flop3198 it weighs nearly 1kg, not exactly 1kg
The girl that kept saying the scale was broken because she wasn’t happy with 52kg she’s at a great weight and she needs to accept it
more like underweight
@@somebodythatyouusedtoknow6996 lmao ye
For real I’m the same height and 54 kg and I think my body is so weak and small it’s literally disgusting
@@margaretliang6719 whatttttt i think i look overweight and im the same height and weight?!
@@jajajjaajj2212 same bro i'm 162 cm and 50.5 kg and i still wanna lose like 2 kg but it's my mental problem
even after this health officer said lisa is very underweight still her hardcore fans says her body is ideal type.. haahhahaha her fans gonna killed me for saying this... usually the company put them under diet regime 2 keep idols stayed in shape..
Maybe Lisa does dieting but not to the extreme. Lisa was born with skinny genes you could see from her predebut pictures also she has very high metabolism rate making her skinny
@@__-jo3gn lisa doesn't need a diet.. having a high metabolism is already a gift for the glutton sinners. If she does it herself or the company makes her do it. Thats how sad YG is.
miz fitry lisa & rosé have said that they eat the most within the group. they don't diet most of the time, yg artists are more towards exercising as they have their own personal trainers.
Fyi Lisa is skinny since she was a kid plus she have been dancing for almost her whole life dancing burns a lot of fats. Secondly, in YG ent they dont do things like extreme diet unless you really look very chubby they'll just send you to the YG gym and ask you to do a healthy diet that's all. In blackpink house we can see that all of them eats very healthy and they exercise regularly. I dont think you know much about blackpink. Compare them to their pre debut they never once looked chubby before and their body always looks the same if someone is going on diet that person will have at least one time that they look extremely skinny or chubby. Lastly, even if they really diet i dont mind as long as they're confident and happy bout it and they're healthy.
Lisa Oppa hehe I’ve been following blackpink since yg announce to debut new girl group after 2ne1.. and I know that Lisa n rose have high metabolism..and Iam okey with that but my problem is their fan based put her and rose picture saying “body goals” u know urself black pink followers basiclly a teenager girls and boys that their early age around 11-30 so for me okey for me... Its not okey if u used “bodygoal” for her body since it show clearlly lisa is veryunder weight.. and the teenage girls definitely gonna follow their idol to look like their idol.. do what their idol do, eat, wearing, even some of the fans trying so damn hard to be like their idols.. for some that have the same metabolism as Lisa n rose then it’s okey but if her fans that not in the same condition as her will try so hard to have her body.. u get what I mean... i know what high metabolism body is, me myself have that, my friend have it too.. I have no bad attention towards blackpink.. I love yg family so don’t take my comment the wrong way but please3 dont promotes “underweight” body as a body goals ok Sory to blink if u guys feels offended by my comments
The girl who said that the scale has a problem is so funny 😂😂😂
@Assrol oh my god really?
Yess she is an actress, i saw her in a kdrama called Pinnocchio
People are praising Lisa's body. When my bmi was similar I was nearly dead. Always freezing, hair falling out in chunks, heart problems. I couldn't even breath.
I'm 100% sure she doesn't has her period.
Same, i when i had a bmi of 16 due to my ed I nearly ended up going to hospital and I didn't have my period.
Same i used to be as skinny as Lisa and i didn't get my period for 6 months and everyone was so concerned about me
Ed is bad
Same.
I've always had a BMI range of 18.5-19.5, yet when I became underweight the decline in my health and physical fitness were obvious.
Angela same.
But I’m still 17.1. I’m always cold and my period just stopped. I eat a lot, but I just can’t gain weight.
BMI of 16 is concerningly underweight and if she were my patient in England, not going to lie, I’d admit her for treatment or investigation (I’m studying medicine)
Edit: BMI is very flawed, I agree. But it acts as an alarm bell to alert healthcare professionals. Malnutrition kills faster than obesity so it’s understandable that ppl may want to safe than sorry.
i have a bmi of 15
0-0
Edit: I'm perfectly healthy and overall feel happy and jolly. Everyone says i don't eat enough but i eat up to my content and just get full easily.
@@koomnies So you're either sick or very, very underweight. I was hospitalized at the bmi of 16 during my anorexia nervosa period, without them going further in details. They just took me in and I'm so glad they did because if not for them I would be dead.
Aww, im glad you're okay now~ Im honestly fine and happy and i don't purposely starve my self, i just get full easily. I feel healthy so i don't think if of much a concern, its good that you got hospitalized though.
@@koomnies You should still contact your doctor, regardless of how you feel right now it might change in the near future.
I was also "getting full" easily. Didn't work for me.
But thank you for your concern. Unfortunately, anorexia is incurable and it leaves a permanent print on your mind and body. You can have a healthy brain afterwards, but there will always be a red light signaling you in the less wanted moment. Some behaviors also stay with you until the very end (being absolutely unable to eat in public, in my case).
That's why awareness on it is so important.
__jjkwidow__2 How old and tall are you?
My sister is 167cm and weights 45kg. More or less like Lisa, but she hasn't had her period yet. It happened to me to, but once I had my period I developed and therefore gained some weight. Lisa BMI doesn't come out as a surprise, most idols will have the same problem because they are forced to eat what a 3 year old would while working out as a police officer would. Many idols have talked about this issue, for women is specially harsh, most will stop having their period, their hair will fall due to stress and mental illness can be developed.
I know that a lot of you want to defend Lisa because she's someone you admire, but idols don't show that part of their lives, please do not make excuses, she didn't make them for herself because she knows her weight has to do with how she is living.
I beg to differ. I’m short, 147cm and 43kg. Bmi is normal but I look ‘skinny’ to some of my friends. Trust me, I EAT MORE THAN MY FRIENDS. I’m 23 and my weight is constant to 43kg even if I eat more. If you ask some of my overweighted friends, they’ll agree I eat more than them, and I usually take some portion of their meal. One thing us skinny ppl hate to hear is “please gain more weight” ffs WE’RE TRYING BITCH SHUT UP. I’ve only gained like 1kg for months and lose it again for a day after just walking around the neighborhood. I’m not defending lisa because I love her, I’m defending all the skinny girls out there who ARE TRYING ffs.
Ps: I know your comment was like 3 months ago, I just had to place it here because I am sick and tired of reading all the comments, thinking you ‘know’ skinny ppl more than they know themselves. Like, shut up.
Idk what comparing your sis who hasn't even had her first period yet to a grown ass woman has to do with anything, but ok.
Aimi ur 147 Cm tho that’s not bad she’s fucking crazy underweight even in korean standards
i am 167cm and 48.5kg...i had my period for 2yrs and i am 12🤣
@@roni9766 48 is very skinny fr youre height as well but still better than lisa 45 kg is very unhealthy fr her height im 160cm im trying to be 48kg youre weight but fr me it is not a danger
The fact that the top comment here is praising Lisa’s very underweight body is disgustingly concerning.
“Lisa, you are very underweight.”
Did y’all hear sum??
For you immature and unreasonable blinks saying she’s “hEaLthY” are wrong. Being underweight is as unhealthy as being overweight.
I’m pretty sure you can still be healthy while being a little underweight, but Lisa is *VERY* underweight. She can’t be 100% healthy. I’m not bashing her or anything, I’m just as concerned about her health.
Fact. Pretty sure she's not even having her period.
while they’re both not ideal, being overweight is actually better than being underweight.
What do we all know abt being healthy when teenagers nowadays consume fast food and drink coke. They gained weight and also very very unhealthy.
The doctor told me that I was under weight too and I ate three meal a day with snack mostly ice cream and toasted bread with Nutella.
Domi sure, but an actual doctor told Lisa that she is underweight and needs to gain weight. Also, Lisa is an adult woman and not a teenager. She is also a dancer, which you need to be strong and healthy to be. I always wondered why Lisa doesn’t have muscles even though she’s a dancer..
eunbiased fan You don’t gain muscles from dancing. Dancer who have muscle probably exercise. This is the evaluation for entering army. That why the doctor told Lisa to gain more weight.
And also even though I’m underweight, the doctor only told me to eat more iron and fiber cause I lack in those. That why I said normal people who have normal weight doesn’t always guarantee to be healthy. It’s depend on the food they eat. Eating power food such as meat, healthy fat etc would help Lisa as a dancer. Not necessary abt eating more calories to gain more weight.
There's no way 57kg is "fat". Stay the way you are, shinji
ikr even her bmi is 21 which is normal
I'm also glad she's fine about it
I have exactly the same height and weight as her 😌
Well she's not fat but she is a little chubby for her height but it doesn't really matter if she's happy with her weight
@@steph6955 she is not chubby lol
Lisa's BMI is not normal shes underweight
The stupid thing is people thinks its ugly for her to gain just a few weight the world is toxic
True lol... But she doesn't gain weight...
She eats a lot but doesn't gain weight because of her fast metabolism and she exercise a lot
But she is healthy...
But sad thing is... When idols lose weight, Knetz call them skinny, but when Idols gain weight, they body shame the idols and call them fat
@@johnnypay1473 you're right :(
Yes. She is 167cm which is quiet tall for a girl. She only need put on around 6kg more to get ideal BMI. Or she will look so fragile. That is not healthy.
She is an ectomorph that is why she is so thin (and I may add that she gained a few pounds since debut)
The fact that Shinji was in "best" condition and she's considered fat by a lot of Knetz should say a lot about the problems in their society. Being thin doesn't mean you're healthy. It just means you're thin. Lisa has too little muscle, and her body fat percentage is very low, it's no surprise that she got that evaluation to be honest. It's really unfair for celebrities to be honest. The standards they have to follow are unhealthy for them, and if they don't, they get a bunch of criticism.
I find it strange that anyone would even consider Shinji ”fat” or ”chubby” by any measure. Like she is thin as hell.
@@rainjacketdot54 Chubby I can kind of understand. However, even then I don't understand why anyone would think of it negatively.
@@CottidaeSEA
I dont even see the chubby part personally, I’d say shes pretty thin.
163 cm and 52kg is absolutely *perfect* . I'm the same height and I can tell you that's perfect
Ofunne Nwajei A bmi of 19.6 is not underweight
so true
89kg and 165cm am i that fat?
@@aomochii3277 I think than your weight needs to be lower than your height sorry for my bad english
We are the same!!!
This comment section my lord! How do you know Lisa eats a lot? Just because they show them on tv eating doesn't mean she eats a lot. Do you know if she went without eating the previous day or two. It is very common and even weird that Korean idols once on tv stuff large amounts of food down their throat almost like they're snuffing in the food and people watching are like Omo! Omo! Omo! She eats really well! You need to do a CF. It is a weird obsession if you ask me. Cause it is mostly a false image they create for diversion. Most normal people don't stuff ramyun with egg and cheese, ice-cream, jajangmyun, crepe with fruits in one sitting. And when that happens, you should be worried about what they do afterwards behind closed doors. I worry more about the one in the group they call squirrel cheeks. Cause her legs and her eating appetite on tv don't match AT ALL.
kdrama prosecutor you know YG? The company that don’t care about looks but talents? No you probably don’t know
There are so many other talented groups from other companies. Get that you want to defend the group you love but read through my comment I didn't just talk about one group, I clearly also stated Korean idols. What is your point?
the do have diets, but they said it before that their diet is eating like a normal human being, with snacks in between 😂
YG definitely cares about looks, what are you talking about. EVERY idol in YG is pretty and slim, and basically made to look perfect. Its the Kpop industry, every company puts looks has one of the top priorities. Just cause BP eat a lot on camera does not mean that they are not scrutinized behind the camera. The industry is very messed up.
Eating a lot doesnt always make everyone bigger tho
Lisa is so calm and collected. She is very respectful lady.
I mean they all were really respectful
People find every reason to praise somebody. I'm not saying it's a bad thing, but all she did was sit. She didn't do anything out of the ordinary 😩
they were all respectful
yall just like to overreact
what do you think she would do exept sitting?
@@karlafrancis8471 exactly
She looked dead inside
I was so happy when he said the girl who has been fat shamed is in the ideal shape . This ultra skinny trend is not healthy
Yu Bi has prettiest, cutest almond shaped eyes. She’s so adorable 😍😍😍
FINALLY. I'M TIRED OF ALL OF THESE BLONKS SAYING "Ohhh, Lisa is fine! She eats on camera!"
Like no sweetie, just because you eat once on a livestream, doesn't mean you eat everyday! I have a fast metabolism, but the only time I got down to 45kg was when I was deep into my eating disorder! And I'm 163cm!
Lisa is 45 kilograms?? I adore Lisa, but it isn't called being "body positive" if you encourage an unhealthy physique. I'm 157 cm and 45 kg would be borderline underweight for me, definitely underweight for her. I wish she wouldn't have to feel so much pressure from society to be skinny, it isn't healthy. Health comes first, y'all.
They wear clothes & just ate breakfast, Lisa probably weights even less...
Justine Röseler Yea probably only like 43 kg..
Yes, drinking and eating can add up to 2 kg
How is LISA 167 cm but only 45 kgs? She is too thin, she needs to gain some weight.
I am 160cm and 45 kgs and I still get teased for being super thin (I am currently 14 if anyone's wondering)
Edit: she's 44.7 kgs, that's even lower that what I had said before
Also the ideal weight for someone who is 167 cm tall is 58.7206 kgs
I KNOW RIGHT i'm 159 cm and my weight is 45 kg.. and the skinniest i have ever been was when i was 43kg.. how can she be 44.7kg with that height. i looked wayyy to skinny when i was at 43kg, i cant comprehen her weight and height.. its so underweight...
damn you guys are a lot skinnier than me,, im 150 cm but 53 kg lmao
@@fleureka7991 don't worry. The ideal weight for your height 45-56 kgs
same, i'm 22, i am 160 cm and weight 44 and i'm very skinny...
HyunA and E'DAWN are made for each other
uh what..? i’m 159cm and i weight 41kg, yet i’m considered healthy
Lisa is underweight. The End.
Doesn’t matter if she eats lots she’s still underweight 🤷🏼♀️
Yes. And a certified army doctor told her that.
Ikr ppl see one vid of her eating a lot and think they kno her entire diet
Then how is she supposed to gain weight if she's naturally skinny?.. If your gens don't allow it, then you can't do much about it until you're in the late 40's.
@@nobodyqwertyu All my life, i've been underweight. At the age of 11 I had a BMI 15.5, and hoovered around BMI 16 till I was 24. After that my BMI was around 16.5 to 17. I'm currently 27 years old with a BMI 17.2.
I always eat a lot, even at night. Up to 6 meals a day. Nobody in my family eats as much as I do. I don't have any medical conditions. It's just genetical. My father was also very skinny. He started gaining at the age of 35.
@@nobodyqwertyu I already been to doctors multiple times. Checked my thyroid, metabolism and immune system every year. Nothing's wrong with it. I was always healthy, my blood was always normal, aswell as blood pressure (115-135/75-90). My father is currently 62 years old and he doesn't have any cardiovascular issues or any health problems.
My grandma had a BMI below 19 until she was like 45. She got married with 157 cm and 45 kg. She died at the age of 89.
Nice to see a guy applauding women for being BMI 20-25, that's usually where most people's bodies work best at, only a small minority of the population are meant to be BMI 19 or below
Nobody is meant to be at that bmi. It’s literally just always healthier to be in the 20/25 ratio. Always always. Whether your weight is made up of fat or muscle makes a difference in how your body looks, but the weight really shouldn’t ever be too low
@Kristine Misting woah... wait are u ok? ive never knew that somone's bmi could be 10 :0
2:50 i dont like how she feels so shocked abt it. Whats so bad abt being healthy? Since when did having a BMI lower than the lowest point become a trend..
i am in no way saying that she has one, but people with eating disorders often hate being/looking healthy, when someone tells us "hey you look way too thin you should get help" it doesnt help at all, instead makes us feel worse (or better, depending on the situation) and makes us want to starve/restrict even more than before :/ hope i didnt come off as rude!!
@@winterdal oh okay i see! No u didnt sound rude or anything dw
She's shocked that she got put in the first grade
She was shocked because the weight she had would be considered “fat”
Especially if you look at everyone else who knets would consider the ideal body
Yes lisa is very underweight look at her stomach we can see a bone😩 I don’t understand when someone says that lisa has an abs but all i see is a bone sorry but she will be so pretty if she gained some weight
Yeah. I even saw a video or so that literally states "Korean idols with the best abs" I was like no, no, no. these people are below the healthy range for their heights and have so little fat the bones and abdominis muscles are showing. There's a difference between a well developed abdominis and malnourished abdominis.
리아 りあLIA she actually lost weight..
리아 りあLIA how do you know if she had a exercise routine or not ?? Do you know her ?? No. She lost her baby fat already when she was 16-18. ((Most girls lose at 15-16)) So hot wasn't even a era. It was a performance. + did you know that when you eat normally after a strict diet, you'll gain more weight than what you started with. Most idols actually gain weight during promotions because they are on a diet before a comeback but then they'll eat normally ((or even more)) so that they can perform without passing out.
The whole point of the one that commented first was that she's underweight and the proof is in this video that she actually is.
리아 りあLIA I know that she has a exercise routine but you said that she didn't have one in boombayah era and that's why I said how do you know if she had one or not.
I've had anorexia for 5 years so I know really well what you mean ((+ I'm sorry that you had to go through it :( )). I'm not saying that she's anorexic but she's clearly underweight in my eyes ((like the Doctor I this video said)). Some people look disgusted while eating & some people look like it's the best moment in their life because they can't eat well often. (I was the one who almost cried because I wanted to eat but I couldn't because I thought I would become fat so I pretty much cried everytime I was forced to eat).
That's why I'm definitely not body shaming her. I'm just really worried and I hope that she focuses more on eating.
Its Chan so you are saying she is not pretty already. Also you never know, she might be unhealthily gaining weight in order to stop the hate flow
I love Shinjin's honesty. She has the talent after all
163cm and 52kg are very respectable. It's a shame that Yubi feels like she should weigh 10kg less, she's perfectly healthy and beautiful.
Last year I went through an eating disorder, I’m 3cm shorter than lisa and my lighter weight was 43kg, 2kg lighter than her. I wasn’t able to do normal things like running or jumping. I got drunk with less than two alcohol glasses. I fainted very often and sometimes I couldn’t even feel my own body or move my hands while trying to hold something.
Lisa is going through this while being and idol, someone’s gotta do something.
Yubi looks great at 52kg!!
Lee Yubi is underrated in whatever she does. To me, she’s one of the prettiest celebrity.
Lisa should gain more weight. But YG company wont allow it because she's idol 😭 please allow lisa to eat more
I know that it's the company's responsibility to watch over their idols but shouldn't lisa make an effort too? What do u mean by YG not allowing her to eat more or weight more? If they want her to be underweight then the rest of the members must be underweight too. Or do you mean YG is strict with their diets but for sure YG wouldn't allow her to be underweight. If lisa wants to have a normal bmi then she also have to make an effort to eat not more not less. Y'all always blame it to the company 😂
lovers lisa eat a lot though. She just have a fast metabolism.
Just because she's underweight doesn't mean YG make her starve. There are a lot of female singer who can't gain much weight even tho they eat a lot like Dara and Yoona. And I'm pretty sure Blackpink member work out
No! Fuck you.
right, although i'm not that skinny, i'm 5'4.5 and weight 118 lbs people still say i'm skinny and the thing is, i eat a lot and people are always wondering where the food goes. and I don't even exercise.
the people who say lisa is body goals are going by photos of her dolled up and clothes worn to make her look good and suits her, if you see her irl she is frail like alarmingly so. 16 is just outright crazy bmi plus she dances and has hectic schedules this is very concerning.
I can't believe that some blinks are continuing to say that Lisa's weight is fine and that she is healthy when a DOCTOR just said the opposite.
lol, you can be 'underweight' in scientific terms but still be healthy. she has a fast metabolism, and she has always looked like that.
kelsy ella I’m sorry but being underweight will NEVER mean you are healthy, also she’s very underweight, with that BMI she most probably has amenorrhea, nutritional deficiencies and a weakened immune system
Ampi Cea i have always had a fast metabolism and my bmi used to be around 16.4, and i was fine. i had energy, i was healthy, and i had a regular period every month. everybody’s body is different, and we all have a weight that our body works best at. bmi isn’t that great because it doesnt take into account things like body fat percentage, muscle mass, bone mass. it is not an inclusive body calculator, especially for body builders who have lots of muscle mass but are considered ‘overweight’ or even ‘obese’ in bmi terms. when will society learn that weight is not a one size fits all. our bodies are so different, and it probably sucked for lisa to be told that she needed to gain weight when she probably feels as healthy as ever and has always been smaller than most people. weight does not always determine health, but anyway, that’s just what i think.
@@kaeyaslut3545 exactly, every body is different. So just because you are underweight and feel like your are fine( cuz let me tell you, I've been underweight and never felt anything wrong with me, I was even doing a lot of sports and stuff I was a ball of energy,but when I went to doctor to make some analysis I found out that I was anemic, but that's just me) it doesn't mean that Lisa is. A doctor ( someone specialized) told her that her weight is not healthy and that she should (for her good) put some weight on. So are we really going to contradict someone who studied medicine and human body for so long just because we think that we know everything?
I mean he said that for a reason and because he knows what is up. Not like us
Just saying
Raluca Holom yeah i understand where you’re coming from, and he does have more expertise in this field, but all he did was calculate her bmi, and anyone could do that. not to say that he doesnt know more, which he probably does, but in this video he simply stated that she was unhealthy due to being underweight, and that means he wouldve said the same to me and many others who are on the slim side. yes, we don’t know the contents of lisa’s diet or if she has issues with her health, but bmi should not be the only determinant of health.
It is concerning how yubi was saying that the scale has a problem... Girl you are the most healthy out of all the other girls
Last time I had the same weight as Lisa was when I suffered an illness, spent 5 months in the hospital, and I was 15 at the time.
I'm so happy that i live in a country with less beauty standards 😭 Poor koreans for being judge so much! In my country height, weight, and your face shape doesnt matter! If you are pretty, then you are pretty as long as youre healthy (means no obessity or anorexia)
제니정 Where do you live? I would like to escape from Korea. I came to a point where i feel tired with all these crazy beauty standards
@@evelynannn the answer basiclly is anywhere but Korea (or maybe the entire Asia - which is sad because i'm also asian). Europe is probaly the place tho, since people are more into athletes body.
@@GiangNguyen-sg7hj Westerners are having an obesity crisis now. They're stuck in the other end of the spectrum.
@@afern2053 but westerners mostly refer to american, which is famous for the mayority being fat/obese, but europe is better in that matter i think
Should come to my country, most of us are Obes😜😂
Lisa took her hair extensions out
I personally believe idols should have professionals like this to make sure their weight is healthy not managers that have no idea what healthy is
When some people say that Lisa needs to gain weight some blinks attack them and they say that Lisa eats a lot...
HOW DO YOU KNOW THAT LISA EATS?
JUST BECAUSE YOU SAW IT ON CAMERA IT DOESNT MEAN THAT IT IS ALWAYS REAL...
I'm worried for Lisa...
Also the fact that she has a fast metabolism is not an excuse
Even if she has a fast metabolism it doesn't mean that she can't gain weight
PLEASE THINK ABOUT IT AND STOP BEING RUDE TO OTHERS BECAUSE THEY ARE CONCERNED
I hope Lisa is ok❤
(Sorry for the long paragraph)
You should seen her pre-debut photos. She even skinnier than now.
And also just because she is underweight doesn’t mean she is unhealthy. What if a person with normal weight eat fast food, drink coke, eat sugary foods, isn’t it also consider unhealthy? Idk why people think weight is the main contributor to being healthy.
My doctor told me that I’m underweight, thinner than girls my age but she only told me that I should try eating more iron and fiber cause I lack in those. She didn’t advise me to gain more weigh or anything. She even told me to exercise more and stuff.
There was a person who argued with me that Lisa sings "Born skinny b*tch" in one of their songs so it's a proof the she is naturally very underweight. Seriously tho, i could sing about having a master degree in astropyhsics but it won't make it true...some fans are delusional.
Edit: Also, unless someone has a rare metabolic disease, there is no such thing as "fast metabolism".Two female with similar height/weight/age/activity llevel will have about the same BMR, maybe 50-100 kcal difference, wich is basically just a banana or a bite of a chocolate bar. A heavier person would even have higher metabolism compared to an underweight person due to the higher mass (assuming they have similar activity levels). If someone can't gain, they are just simply not eating enough. Same goes for obese people who can't lose weight: either metabolic disease or they are eating too much
DAMN, YU BI IS SO CUTTTTTTTEEEEEE
“Your very underweight” well that’s one thing I’m never going to hear
You're not supposed to
Good
i love how shinji dosen't care much about her weight
It's heartbreaking that the last girl was so shocked to be told she's in good shape. She's probably had to deal with so many people calling her fat. This is the problem with asian beauty standards. My BMI has always been 21-22 and guys used to tell me my ass was too big. Really hope the standards change some day.
toxic blinks belike: wtf lisa is not underweight its just natural
me: ... ok ?
I just love Lee yu bi's visual.. Her whole facial structure is just bright!! I saw her in the kdrama pinocchio and I have been startrucked since then..
Lee Yu Bi so cute!!!! no change after drama Pinnochio
Lee Yubi is gorgeous 😍
She looks better without makeup
She is prolly wearing no make up make up.
Yesss we need to see that more on Korean shows, I’m glad they said Shinji was the ideal type to be an officer.
Yubi is sooo beautiful!
I’m here for Lisa but Lee Yubi is too adorable.☺️😍😂💕
lee yubi should be the ideal for idols she doesnt look chubby or really skinny
Her BMI is almost in the severe range. I hope she takes care ♡
Im not gonna say that Lisa has to gain weight but you cannot deny the fact that she’s underweight..
Yubi is perfect tho 👌❤️
Idk if Lisa is so skinny because of her metabolism or not, I just wish people didn't say that either "she's the beauty standard" nor "she's too much skinny" cause healthy isn't defined only by BMI and beauty standards are so relative that is a complete nonsense. I'm western and weighing more then 50 used to be my life goal, I just realized how the beauty standards were affecting me after watching kdramas, cause it made me realize how the concept of beauty changes and somehow always oppress someone.
LEE YU BI😍😍❤️
I feel really bad for lisa, she looked so sad when they revealed her bmi. People should respect lisa and stop complaining about her weight ❤️
I dont know, It unhealthy for her and something bad could end up happing to her, they want the best for her.
Bubbly tea being overweight is as big of a problem but people don’t complain when someone is overweight and when they do, other people complain and say that we should stop body shaming.
We arent complaining but she is underweight BUT SHES HEALTHY is which is what matters dont get mad when we say shes underweight but shes healthy anyways so its all good
Yubi is so beautiful
Shinji is rolemodel.
Shinji is my inner soul :))
*Video:*
95% about Lee Yu Bi
5% about Lisa
*Comments:*
99.9% about Lisa
0.1% about Lee Yu Bi
Do you think YG will allow her to gain weight?
I am glad someone told her she is under weight hopefully she will be healthy ❤️❤️
People are saying in the comment section lisa eats a lot.
Every time she eats on TV, she looks so happy as if she's not allowed to eat them whenever she wants. I just hope that people understand that idols are humans too, they overwork themselves and then they aren't even allowed to eat properly I get it that even idols themselves want to be skinny(mostly because they are scared they will be bashed by the knetz) but there should be a healthy and proper way.
Oh and yeah 50kg, 55kg etc.aint fat, it's thiccccccc.
Nope, 50-55kg isn't even thicc
55 50 kg isn’t even “thicccc” it’s still thin. I guess it depends on the height, but most of the women in the video who were 50-55 kgs were quite tall, which is why they were considered slightly underweight. But even if you were let’s say 5’2 and about 50-55 kgs, you could fit in a US size 2-4 which are considered petite sizes.
Lee yubi, you have no problem with your weight girl!! You’re okay!! And beautiful
not only lisa, but there are lots of VERY UNDERWEIGHT idols out there, not bly her. maybe your bias too? duh
Lisa is the most skinny out of all..
littleMschat
she really isn’t
@@iluvmyblackkitty She is an adult woman, you cant use children's standards for that.
littleMschat i think it’s sunmi
littleMschat Lisa isn’t the skinniest idol out there. The skinniest is ELRIS’ Yukyung, who is 157cm and weighs 37 kg (has a bmi of 15.0).
guys underweight is not always bad some people are just skinny bmi means nothing ive been underweight all my life but its okay bc its consistent and its just the way my body is
2:42
You can see her neck bone. If that didn't tell you something wrong with her weight, nothing will. 🙄
I know... And people laugh at her saying it's an Adams apple. No it's simply that she has very little fat coverage in her neck...
Lisa is a sweetest idol awwwww
Lisa weighs 97 lbs?!!!!! Wtffffff I haven’t been that weight since elementary school and I am considered very skinny at 120 for 5’4 . Wow how can she be healthy at that weight??? This will effect her joints when she’s older. It’s sad how much pressure idols have to be extremely skinny
i understand yall are concerned about lisa but instead of saying shes extremely underweight just state that you hope she's "happy and heathly" or something. it hurts to be told your very underweight.
I really hate korea's stigma of "if you're under 50kg ya good". Like whatever height of the girl is its seems like to them they should weigh under 50kg.
Whoa that lee yubi is so pretty
52 kg for her height is perfect. Not too thin nor too heavy, Koreans set standards too high, like I am in the same height to weight ratio as her and I think I am perfect like this way. Besides, BMI isn't always 100 percent accurate
Well.i am underweight too.153 and 40 kg.but my period worked
just fine.
Lisa!!!🌹🌼💓💓💓💓💓💓💓💓
Lee Yubi is so pretty omg
I love Lisa and it makes me sad she needs to gain weight, but it's true. I think a LOT of kpop stans fail to realize that our girls tend to be forced on diets. Especially considering how important weight and beauty is in Korea, it's probably a huge pressure on them. I've been worried about her & rose being underweight for awhile and this made me sad. I really hope Lisa is being healthy and works hard to become well!
Lee yoo bi ♥♥♥
I understand the situation Lisa is in cuz when I was younger I was also underweight for my height and body type. The only difference is Lisa is tall, so her BMI is fine since it’s related to her height, but she’s too skinny for her body type. I also had a super high metabolism and was active in dancing/performing arts back then. So yes, it’s easy for girls like me and Lisa to lose weight fast.
I do worry for Lisa though cuz it is true that she is underweight. She needs her protein and carbs in her eating habits. She doesn’t need to go on a complete diet cuz she’s already skinny as it is. All she really needs to do is to eat protein, iron, carbs and to occasionally work out and tone her body. Nothing extreme at all. It’s natural to think she’s tall and skinny..she’s body goals. But even if you’re skinny.. you can also be underweight and unhealthy. There’s a huge misconception about skinny people. 😆
I would like to add that it’s also SKOREA “ideal beauty standards” for decades is female idols has to be “skinny, pale complexion (Snow White), and etc.) “
That’s why some companies (not all) have their female and male idols go on diets..sometimes regular and at times extreme diets. Which is quite sad, why can’t idols be happy with their own bodies?? I mean if idols want to got on healthy diets..that’s their decision and I’m okay with that. But there’s just too many situations especially concerning female idols, where it’s too obvious that these female idols are forced to do diets cuz they are deemed “fat” or “overweight” in SKOREA standards. 😆
Im happt that the commenr section is respectful. Hope the idols(especially lisa, rosé and msny more underweight idols) are healthy.
i hope kpop girlies can realise what mentality they're pushing on their idols. they're praising unhealthy living habits and creating this facade of perfection for themselves. so many idols are underweight but pressured to keep losing weight by their companies and "fans".
Lee yubi! I really like her since pinocchio 😍
That's healthy, though 🤔
*Edit:* I was actually talking about the last girl (and a couple others), not Lisa. Her measurements are the ones in the title. Her weight is fine for her height, despite the lower BMI. And BMI's really aren't reliable because they don't factor body type, only height. My main point was that she was self concious saying she should have worn shorts rather than pants to weight less, but her weight isn't at all concerning.
No it’s not, for their height they should weigh more especially Lisa. If you look it up, you can see the regular BMI and weight for their heights.
Lena Rehmat I’ve been saying this Forever, Something is up with Lisa’s weight I can barely look at a Blackpink stage and Pay attention to Lisa because she’s so skinny it makes me uncomfortable.
JoJo Rivera I don’t think she particularly looks bad even tho she is on the skinnier side. Sometimes it’s hard for some people to gain weight. Lisa is probably one of those people, in fact I saw that she said that somewhere. She’s probably aware she’s very thin, I saw her workouts on blackpink House they look strength based so she might already be trying to gain muscle. It’s probably not easy hearing you’re underweight either who knows how many times she’s heard that even tho she does eat well and workout.
I think the actress and shinji are the one who is healthy
Lena Rehmat All the members weight have gone down drastically since debut if you look at side by side pictures. YG definitely put them on a diet, I’m not so much saying that it’s hard for people to look at her but it is for me when I see rib cages sticking out I know there’s a problem with metabolism, but like you said to the original comment Lisa is under weight for her height some people think it’s normal and Healthy and others call it “Body goals” on Twitter. Gaining weight when it’s not easy is really hard it happens to me and my sister but people cross the line when they say she’s Completely Healthy.
Am not a blink but am sad seeing lisa almost cried because of her weight it must be devastating for her.
If you knew lisa underweight, why in the first place shes recruited in real men?
Maybe to get her in proper condition? It's military so it's only normal to give soldiers loads food and good exercise. It'll help her get healthier
Just cause she's underweight doesn't mean she's fragile. She has displayed acts which require great upper body strength and from other clips in the series, she looks to be the most physically capable among the participants.
Beep Boop i didnt say shes fragile but sometimes such reality show in korea like to display lacks/flaw of foreign idol. Thats why i dont like the idea mostly they like to pick on foreign didnt you notice ? i knew it already her stamina is so excellent and she perform well i like her character too. that the point of my comment
breathing is for the weak yeah agree on that too. I guess so but sometimes i dont like the idea of pick on foreign idol
So the show can prove to Lisa fans that she is underweight, but also reveal her real face with no makeup. No surgery.
Lisa is gorgeous even without makeup, she is really beautiful
So Lisa's real height is 166.5 cm...
@@ssssssss055 Asians are naturally shorter
I made this account just to comment and subscribe not short average height about 5,6
There are many kpop girls that are above 170+
I think they area adding a few cm in their profiles to make them more taller than their actual height..same goes for boy groups.but still love blackpink no matter what their height is.😍
@@eli-oh3oq I don't know where you got those numbers from but 166.5cm is 5 feet and 5.55 inches. So technically 5'6 is correct if you round by the inch. 5'4 is 162.5cm.
Lee Yu Bi is so beautiful
Yes please I'll been worried about Lisa, let Lisa eat more healthy food she need some weights
I heard she has a high metabolism. But, yes, she REALLY needs to gain weight
A high metabolism is when you struggle to gain weight, even when you eat a lot. It is very hard for someone who is naturally skinny to put on some weight. Trust me, I myself have a fast metabolism.
@Sparkcp exactly. maybe YG put them in a strict diet that no one knows. We dont know them well, so let us not put some fake news about the members to protect them or something.
potato min So you don’t have people around you that as skinny as Lisa. I think it’s normal for asian people actually since most of my friends are like that.
Lee Yu Bi big fan of her her body portion are healthy and the cutest in the girl team she is the bright one and entertaining one love you Lee Yu Bi fighting
"Lisa, you're underweight."
Her company made her work to get that weight; I'm pretty sure they don't want to deal with weight.
ok this made me feel better idk how but it did
Lisa weighs 44.7kg and she had breakfast- that is sooo light wtf
I like how Shinji, out of all of them, is a bit more expressive with her face. I just started watching and i will hopefully see more of her facial expressions XD