Not a single good point was made. She's just trying to change Islam to feel better about herself while breaking rules. The worst and most dangerous type of people are insincere people who instead of admitting their faults, try to change the game. No one is perfect, we all struggle with different rules. But only hypocrites will spend their energy on changing the rules and doing mental gymnastics to justify it, instead of putting that energy to understand and follow them.
I did not find evidence of Khadija (ra) living alone. She was widowed twice, so she lived with previous husbands before. After divorce it was likely for her to live at least very near to her family. As for the Queen of Sheba, she was not Muslim, as mentioned in other comments (meaning we should not consider her example as best). Maryam bint Imran was living a pious life in a temple, not alone. Her journey and the birth of Isa (as) was because she had been kicked out, not really her choice of the matter. There is no evidence of accommodation for her and Isa after that, other then the mention of her going back to the family. The concept of mahram may seem triggering to many people, because they imagine that they will only take advantage of that position. But Muhammad (pbuh) asked if the men to be patient, loving and caring to all their female family members. And these are the qualities on which a decent mahram should act.
Neither was Khadija. Khadija was a Jewish business woman. Mhmd converted to Judaism for her, apostasizing from his grandparents traditional Qureshi faith.
@@miovicdina7706what's Mhmd?😂 And what a load of bs. Khadija was Quraysh. Why do you come here and lie so blatantly as if people can't do their research and find out the truth?
@@j358x7 Do your own research, I agree. What do you think about Jay Smith PhD in Islamic Origins, and the discoveries he shares on the PfanderFilms channel?
well khadija RA was not muslim at that time(also she had kids from her previous marrige I guess. not too sure about it.) she was runnung a business alone but did she actuallly used to live alone?. The revelation of quran started after 15 years of her marriage with prophet muhammad SAW. Mariyum AS was not a muslim too. she was pious but not a muslim. THe queen was also not muslim and ended up getting married to suleman AS. The rulling of allah was gradually introduced according to the needs and time. There is a hadith which says that women should not travel without a mehram, Means there has to be someone accompanying her, which can be anyone of her mahram(women or men). If she is not allowed to travel alone then how can we assume she should live alone. Living alone is not safe for any women. whether muslim or non muslim. please research more sister. It is a humble suggestion.
Traveling is different. Travel is dangerous (especially back then). But living alone is not as dangerous, and its completely halal/fine for women. It would be best if you did your research, actually. There are even fatwas you seek and you'll see this answered. Also according so some madhabs, like in Maliki madhab; a woman can travel alone if she is absolutely safe. And in another, she can go with just a group of friends/women, but if she cannot. But she can also go alone if the travel is less than 3 days, or some follow the opinion that its 1 day.
Of course it’s not safe. Men are monsters. But there are plenty of women who don’t have anyone to trust and are in a situation where they have no option but live or travel but themselves. Yes Islam recommends that but really, each Muslims can live based on their situations, it is between them and Allah. If there is genuine reasoning for things and no other options, Allah the most merciful will understand and forgive.
Each and every rule is written by MEN and they will write whatever suits them. 😂😂 ask the damn women if she wants to do a particular thing then who are we to stop anyone. Just go for it 😂😂😂 its not rocket science
He was not his actual son, But a slave. which was then set free. He was adopted by the prophet. prophet Muhammad SAW married the divorced wife of his adopted son to prove that a adopted son does not has the rights of a actual son. I hope you were genuinely curious and if you have any further questions. feel free to ask.
@fatimarehman6608 if i adopt someone and he is my son. HE IS MY SON PERIOD. The wife of my son is like my daughter. No way I'm marrying my son's wife. It shows that the prophet lacks a basic sense of morality and virtue
@@subhomazumder7559 I'm respectfully asking who forms these morals? In islam a adopted son and a biological son is never same. Also you cannot marry your daughter in law.
@fatimarehman6608 well when we start losing morals in society we start worshipping someone like Muhammad. I guess we as a society failed for encouraging someone like muhamad
but why would the women leave her family if she has them., and honey. men are allowed to move out since in the future THEY will be propsoing and they also need to buy a house, and provide for their wives. EDUACTE URSELF. dont be westrenized.
@@masturah711 a women in islam has her parents to hold her and pay things for her (unless they pass away of course she can move out because where else would she go) the only time she can "move out", you westrenized masturah is when she gets married. americans invented moving out on 18 to move their propaganda of women indpendnce and feminism. which is HARAM. ya masturah. educate urslef. IK danm well what Moving out means I dont need you to educate me.
and btw, khadija didnt go out and do busniness with men. NO, she paid The prophet muhhamad to do her business and she gave him commission. Im saying this just in case some femenist pops to me and be like "uhm women can be business women and work because Khadija didd 🤓 "
@@laagislaag the girl in the video is saying that women should go and work women in islam should be working, as doctors, pharmacist, teachers, and i dont see why u should go live alone work as a wtv idc. Work is a mans job
Good points. I think people mention against it mostly due to it being UNSAFE. People are wild out there so be safe
Not a single good point was made. She's just trying to change Islam to feel better about herself while breaking rules. The worst and most dangerous type of people are insincere people who instead of admitting their faults, try to change the game. No one is perfect, we all struggle with different rules. But only hypocrites will spend their energy on changing the rules and doing mental gymnastics to justify it, instead of putting that energy to understand and follow them.
@@j358x7 she’s no hypocrit if she’s blatantly doing this. Hypocrites hide their bad deeds. But she seems to just be ignorant and still learning Islam
I did not find evidence of Khadija (ra) living alone. She was widowed twice, so she lived with previous husbands before. After divorce it was likely for her to live at least very near to her family.
As for the Queen of Sheba, she was not Muslim, as mentioned in other comments (meaning we should not consider her example as best).
Maryam bint Imran was living a pious life in a temple, not alone. Her journey and the birth of Isa (as) was because she had been kicked out, not really her choice of the matter.
There is no evidence of accommodation for her and Isa after that, other then the mention of her going back to the family.
The concept of mahram may seem triggering to many people, because they imagine that they will only take advantage of that position.
But Muhammad (pbuh) asked if the men to be patient, loving and caring to all their female family members. And these are the qualities on which a decent mahram should act.
But the queen on sheba was not muslim at that particular time
Neither was Khadija.
Khadija was a Jewish business woman.
Mhmd converted to Judaism for her, apostasizing from his grandparents traditional Qureshi faith.
@@miovicdina7706what's Mhmd?😂 And what a load of bs. Khadija was Quraysh. Why do you come here and lie so blatantly as if people can't do their research and find out the truth?
@@j358x7 Do your own research, I agree.
What do you think about Jay Smith PhD in Islamic Origins, and the discoveries he shares on the PfanderFilms channel?
She didn't leave her thrown after accepting islam
@@miovicdina7706 wtf....
She's the first woman to accept Islam
Thank you for this ❤
You're welcome 😊
well khadija RA was not muslim at that time(also she had kids from her previous marrige I guess. not too sure about it.) she was runnung a business alone but did she actuallly used to live alone?. The revelation of quran started after 15 years of her marriage with prophet muhammad SAW. Mariyum AS was not a muslim too. she was pious but not a muslim. THe queen was also not muslim and ended up getting married to suleman AS. The rulling of allah was gradually introduced according to the needs and time. There is a hadith which says that women should not travel without a mehram, Means there has to be someone accompanying her, which can be anyone of her mahram(women or men). If she is not allowed to travel alone then how can we assume she should live alone. Living alone is not safe for any women. whether muslim or non muslim. please research more sister. It is a humble suggestion.
Traveling is different. Travel is dangerous (especially back then). But living alone is not as dangerous, and its completely halal/fine for women. It would be best if you did your research, actually. There are even fatwas you seek and you'll see this answered. Also according so some madhabs, like in Maliki madhab; a woman can travel alone if she is absolutely safe. And in another, she can go with just a group of friends/women, but if she cannot. But she can also go alone if the travel is less than 3 days, or some follow the opinion that its 1 day.
Check Fatwa 120947. And if you want, you can also listen to Sheikh Uthman Al Khamee's opinion on this.
Of course it’s not safe. Men are monsters. But there are plenty of women who don’t have anyone to trust and are in a situation where they have no option but live or travel but themselves. Yes Islam recommends that but really, each Muslims can live based on their situations, it is between them and Allah. If there is genuine reasoning for things and no other options, Allah the most merciful will understand and forgive.
Travelling and living is different. Thats a facy. Also, no where does allah condemn sheba or khadija for living on their own.
Each and every rule is written by MEN and they will write whatever suits them. 😂😂 ask the damn women if she wants to do a particular thing then who are we to stop anyone. Just go for it 😂😂😂 its not rocket science
What happens to women in heaven in islam?
They live the way they want. They pray and enjoy the beauty of heaven. Everyone lives there their own way
❤💐💐🤲
sahih al bukhari 1462 "O women! Give alms, for I have seen that the majority of the dwellers of Hell-Fire were you (women)."
Duh. There is more women in hell AND in heaven, for each man will have 2 wives. So DOUBLE the amount of women. Why? Because there are more women.
Women are also the majority in jannah
But, didn't mohamad marry his son's wife?
He was not his actual son, But a slave. which was then set free. He was adopted by the prophet. prophet Muhammad SAW married the divorced wife of his adopted son to prove that a adopted son does not has the rights of a actual son. I hope you were genuinely curious and if you have any further questions. feel free to ask.
@fatimarehman6608 if i adopt someone and he is my son. HE IS MY SON PERIOD. The wife of my son is like my daughter. No way I'm marrying my son's wife. It shows that the prophet lacks a basic sense of morality and virtue
@fatimarehman6608 from a moral point of view no one would marry their sons wife. Let alone a prophet
@@subhomazumder7559 I'm respectfully asking who forms these morals? In islam a adopted son and a biological son is never same. Also you cannot marry your daughter in law.
@fatimarehman6608 well when we start losing morals in society we start worshipping someone like Muhammad. I guess we as a society failed for encouraging someone like muhamad
Islam still treats people badly. You're talking is BS.
Islamphobes be like
but why would the women leave her family if she has them., and honey. men are allowed to move out since in the future THEY will be propsoing and they also need to buy a house, and provide for their wives. EDUACTE URSELF. dont be westrenized.
Ever heard of the term “moving out”?
@@masturah711 a women in islam has her parents to hold her and pay things for her (unless they pass away of course she can move out because where else would she go) the only time she can "move out", you westrenized masturah is when she gets married. americans invented moving out on 18 to move their propaganda of women indpendnce and feminism. which is HARAM. ya masturah. educate urslef. IK danm well what Moving out means I dont need you to educate me.
and btw, khadija didnt go out and do busniness with men. NO, she paid The prophet muhhamad to do her business and she gave him commission. Im saying this just in case some femenist pops to me and be like "uhm women can be business women and work because Khadija didd 🤓 "
@@opp_HANAHaha such a silly argument, by that token most big business owners are not business men/women, because they pay there staff to do work...
@@laagislaag the girl in the video is saying that women should go and work women in islam should be working, as doctors, pharmacist, teachers, and i dont see why u should go live alone work as a wtv idc. Work is a mans job