Посмотри кем сделан мульт и поймёшь зачем людям вызывать такое негативное впечатление о об определённой группе людей) сейчас рисовать такие мульты - отличный вариант пропаганды.
будем честны. определённой группе людей очень нужно настроить общественное мнение против кого-нибудь. А мультфильм - лишь средство пропаганды. В этом случае авторы мульта выставили в плохом свете "Талибан". Если посмотрите на историю. Америка вторглась в более чем 50 стран после второй мировой войны. Свой терроризм Америка оправдывает тем, что называет оппонента "террористом". Задумайтесь, сколько людей было убито в собственных домах из за Американских нападений? Афганцы встали против Америки и дали отпор. Афганцы настоящие герои и заслужили уважение. Но как я уже сказал. Мультфильм был создан для того, чтобы промыть людям мозги и манипулировать.
@@rinibunny4576 “This quote is by Jalal ad-Din Muhammad Rumi, a Persian poet. It means that one should not raise voice and use bad words no matter how tense the situation is. Instead, raise the impact of your words, let them have a meaning and let them reflect you so that it fills up others heart with love, not hatred.”
6 years ago After reading “The Breadwinner, A girl’s life under the Taliban” I told myself “I hope those dark days never come back again”. My heart aches for Afghanistan and its innocent citizens💔💔
@@sidthemann25 in some countrys god goes over human rights. even if we see it in our eyes like humans riights are important they dont care they just do what they want and when nobody stops them or try to change there view nothing will ever change.
@@shitface7000oh shut up. You have been commenting on this video since forever. You just want to oppress women. Islam is a cancer. You don't own women and nobody can be forced to live by the rules of a religion they dont even believe.
This movie is probably the most underrated movie to come from cartoon saloon. It tore my heart out, because I went in blind expecting magic to show up... but no... just a vividly grounded and poignant tale about what is happening right now.
будем честны. определённой группе людей очень нужно настроить общественное мнение против кого-нибудь. А мультфильм - лишь средство пропаганды. В этом случае авторы мульта выставили в плохом свете "Талибан". Если посмотрите на историю. Америка вторглась в более чем 50 стран после второй мировой войны. Свой терроризм Америка оправдывает тем, что называет оппонента "террористом". Задумайтесь, сколько людей было убито в собственных домах из за Американских нападений? Афганцы встали против Америки и дали отпор. Афганцы настоящие герои и заслужили уважение. Но как я уже сказал. Мультфильм был создан для того, чтобы промыть людям мозги и манипулировать.
" My name is Sulayman. my mother is a writer, my father is a teacher, and my sisters always fight each other. One day I found a toy on the street and I picked it up. It exploaded... I dont remember what happened after that, because it was the end... " 😭
:( No child should be hurt because they just wanted something, they didn't realize it was an explosive and whoever planted it there was a cruel person, bless your heart for telling this
American gave girls college but still sent them to war with other males. Why don't let a country be what it wants to be. what is your concern are they starving them to death like war is bringing to them? Just like America went to destroy Libya America comes like God and makes brothers destroy themselves and their lives silently forsaking those it gave force hope.
@@iamisearojob6549 you are really brainwashed with religion that's why you are too blind to see the horror on the other side, you have no idea what innocent people are going through
@@themercifulguard3971 bro u know women can never work freely under Talibans They are just making some small or fake rules to show others The reality is that not even men can work there freely forget about women
Посмотри кем сделан мульт и поймёшь зачем людям вызывать такое негативное впечатление о об определённой группе людей) сейчас рисовать такие мульты - отличный вариант пропаганды.
I was there- I lived by the role 3 hospital where women would come in all burned up because it was a popular form of suicide. I saw the women destroying a well at night that our provincial reconstruction team built - because it was one of their only opportunities to be away from the abuse. That’s not to say all the men were bad either, but there was certainly a rampant issue with the treatment of their women. The fact that they weren’t allowed to receive any formal education under Taliban rule. Yes, cartoons can be an accurate form of propaganda; that is true. They can also communicate truth as well. What I saw in this movie coincides with what I experienced overseas in Afghanistan and it really hit home.
The "forbidden book" being "مثنوی معنوی" breaks my heart It's just a poem, a masterpiece of iranian culture. It hurts bc in Islam, some ppl take the "no music" policy too hard, and things like this happen.
@@paulandreig.sahagun34no it isnt. reciting Qur’an is a style of art not singing. other religions do this as well. they are not singing, they are reciting.
@@jamshidkarimov1021 Do you know any other movies like The Breadwinner that has the same kind of animation style? I'm really interested to learn more about these movies! And personally I think some are much better than Disney
This movie has touched my heart so deeply. I couldn't stop my tears from falling down while watching it. I am now a college graduate and I cannot imagine the life Parvana is living. I wish they can go outside by themselves without fearing for their lives and also get the education that everyone deserves. It's just so heartbreaking how life can be so harsh because of our fellow humans.
Salam guys, i am a Muslim and I was born in Afghanistan, and ill tell my story. I was in Afghanistan last year at somewhere where school was finish. So.. I was in Afghanistan for a month but then stuff we being suspicious. Ofc.. The taliban camed to our neighborhood. We had to leave Afghanistan sadly. The taliban were so strong bc the Americans gaved up so we had less power. Inshallah, Afghanistan will be better soon 🙏 Also the movie is great
how you could still follow islam?? im from iran you see what islam bring to our countries .. how many lives lost and still suffer how much rape and killing happened in Afghanistan and iran in iran we said that "this is not real islam ,the islam that islamic republic and taliban show is not real islam " but now after 43 years of suffering and silent killing and rape by islamic republic we know this is the real islam don't go this path my brother taliban , islamic republic and hezb-o-allah will remain till we leave islam behind if satan is real islam is his religion in hope of free Afghanistan and free iran
@@rezah8889 i feel like you answered your own question.. no republic or taliban is the “real islam” because it is twisted and turned into something else. In no way should rape and violence be accepted (both using common sense and the religion itself) Those people that try to force and twist it to their advantage and to hurt people think they are God and are only worshipping themselves. I believe the best way to practice islam is to read and decide things for yourself only. It’s not meant to be forced on anyone, especially since everyone practices differently (or chooses not to believe, which is nothing i can control) The literal meaning of islam is “peace”..yet so many Muslims tend to forget that
It’s crazy how I imagined this when reading the book for a school project! Like 5 months later I can still imagine and map out the entire town parvana lived in from my imagination!
I have watched this movie twice with my students.we have cried together. But we need to remember how lucky we are and that we should not give our spoiled life for granted
@@KingTrygon There is a recent comment saying “Western people covering up their crimes in movies like this” To be frank everyone painted the wars in black and white, I don’t know how to say it to be honest.
I seen this a while ago, really powerful movie, it’s a must watch, not the best from the company, I still like Song of the Sea the best but this one is still one is that very interesting and very powerful.
As a arab girl who grew up in america it hurts to see girls who have to go through this prosecuted over gender whether you believe in jesus or allah this isnt what any god would want
Maybe there is something wrong but Hijab is the safest place for a girl and they are making it horrible. Islam is so beautiful how can someone make it so horrible . As a Muslim girl I'm really against it
Maybe there is something wrong but Hijab is the safest place for a girl and they are making it horrible. Islam is so beautiful how can someone make it so horrible . As a Muslim girl I'm really against it
I remember when i was a child, my dad introduced me this film at first I didn’t seem interested wasn’t my cup of tea but growing up seeing how the Taliban occupied Afghanistan reminded me of this film. This movie really makes me feel sad what happening there. Another story I want to tell is once I had driving license with my driving teacher, at one point she told me her experience with two afghani girls she had teaching lessons with, she described the afghani girls to me how they seemed very innocent and naive. It’s actually difficult for afghani women to immigrate or visit a country since the Taliban with there weapon can immediately shoot you brutally and how terrifying it is to be controlled by Taliban! One of the girls entire family was shot in front of her. On the positive side note, the Afghani men who immigrated to different countries, some of them go back to Afghanistan to marry these women and immigrate them to another country so they can start new life (I’m too sure how they do that) which actually is sweet of these guys! However these women are very use to isolation and can be socially awkward at times but it depends how they will adapt different cultures.
I remember the Muslim girls In my class covered their while body once they stepped out of the school gate but in the class room they use to remove their scarf & put it inside the bag since it was a Girls school.& I also remember some Girls suddenly stop coming to school & few months later seeing them carrying baby's & walking with their husbands who looks twice or thrice the age of us ,But still we are schooling .
unfortunatly their are few muslim countries who think like this iam from pakistan a muslim country but here its like 20% girls life is like that in northern areas but fortunatly 80% are safe :)
@@Roma-co3go Women in Northern Areas, both Dardic and Pashtun majority areas, are actually safe, it just happens to be different cultures. Now compare that to what happens if a woman steps outside when one of you Indic Pakistanis are around. Look at Minar e Pakistan incident or the woman that was blamed for parking on a highway after being raped just recently.
Maintain Secularism,else Pakistan will also be Like Afghanistan,Ive seen many videos where Islamic scholars spit venom against non muslims@@Roma-co3go
I saw this in school years ago, then I suddenly remembered it after the Taliban takeover of Afghanistan three years later. At the time I first saw it, it was clearly something of the past, but now it’s back. I hope they’ll be free one day.
I didn't see the movie yet but I like the genteel tone of the story. Whimsical, dispite the dark themes. It does not invite to hate a whole group of poeple by showing the worst they got, it invites to embrace those within who struggle. I m a feminist and arab and i ve often seen demonstrations of the sexism in our societies used, not to raise compassion towards us, but used to endorse feelings of revulsion against us as a whole, the victims included. The sentiment being '' if they don't want to be victims, why chose to be muslims''or something in that vein. It is rare that i find mentions of orientalism nowadays (unlike the long gone fascination of the european colonists with the exotic and with fancies of a' 'one thousands and one nights' ' like world. Even if that too encouraged the colonialism. )
I read the book such a long time ago, but always remembered how I cherished this story. I never knew that there was a movie made based off this book, and it makes me so happy to see 🥹. It was an eye opener reading the book in class during grade 5, especially due to how some people aren’t as lucky as I am. it makes me sad that this is our reality in this cruel world, I just loved this book so much. it makes me wanna cry knowing there was a movie I never knew about for 6 years, but also happy because it brings light to the harsh reality of some people’s lives, which is truly heartbreaking knowing that if i’ve never known about the movie, many people probably haven’t either.
0:16 And you know what? He's right both morally, and in terms of Islam, religiously. Allah tells the men not to nag but rather to lower their gaze and mind their damn business. Care about your own damn problems. Verse 24:30: "Tell the believing men that they should reduce/lower (يغضوا) their gaze/vision and guard their private parts..." Verse 24:31: "Tell the believing women that they should reduce/lower (يغضضن) their gaze/vision and guard their private parts..." Verse 49:3 "It is those who lower (يغضون) their voices in the presence of Allah's messenger and whose hearts Allah has proved to be aware - they will have forgiveness and a great reward." So the Muslim dad over here is right. They should not be looking at her. And to add, the Quran says that a child must care for their parents regardless of anything, generalising it to the point of gender. Yeah. Allah has a drastic difference of how he treats women contrary to how most islamic cultures do. He is not sexist towards them, but even more so like a really protective feminist, or at least that's how I see it.
Feminists don't victim shame and don't tell victims to cover up. Feminists tell women that they can dress how they like because their bodies aren't shameful or sexual.
@@georgeaskeladd742exactly. Tbh who gives a fuck about feminism. Majority of us don't want to be judged for what we wear, what education we take, basically hoe humans live their lives without being controlled.
Person: why would you not bring you daughter home? Father: so she can help me. Person: she could cover herself probably Father: maybe you should stop looking at her
I can’t believe there’s a place in the world like this. It’s so dumb and horrible. They’re just people who want power and they want things to go their way like big babies
The Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) prayed to God: “Lord, if any affairs of my followers are under someone's control (guidance), and this someone will create problems (difficulties) for them [will deliberately treat them unfairly], to that [manager or leader], Lord, create problems (difficulties). And to the one under whose control any deeds of my followers will be [their deeds and prospects will depend on his decision, on his word or recommendation], and he will be kind to them [just and magnanimous], then you too, Lord, be kind to him [no matter who he is, show him Your mercy and Divine kindness]! " (Hadith from Aisha; Ahmad, Muslim Al-Baihaqi).
-"Is it a happy story or a sad story?"
-"Just wait and see"
This. This gets hard.
No, Parvana. This story is neither happy, nor sad. It's a horror one that it's gonna get worse and worse each day from now on! :(
I wread the bookk
it is a story that portrays Taliban as a bad movement
@@GouNH4038 you're making it look like it isn't
@@GouNH4038 taliban is a very bad movement
Oh man. This movie just broke my heart. How tough it is for those girls to live and to dream. Man I can't even what i am feeling right now.
I agree with you and I am a girl💔
Same but everything is okay now!
@@raihankhan8993 Muslim countries are tough places to be a girl
Посмотри кем сделан мульт и поймёшь зачем людям вызывать такое негативное впечатление о об определённой группе людей)
сейчас рисовать такие мульты - отличный вариант пропаганды.
будем честны. определённой группе людей очень нужно настроить общественное мнение против кого-нибудь. А мультфильм - лишь средство пропаганды.
В этом случае авторы мульта выставили в плохом свете "Талибан".
Если посмотрите на историю. Америка вторглась в более чем 50 стран после второй мировой войны. Свой терроризм Америка оправдывает тем, что называет оппонента "террористом".
Задумайтесь, сколько людей было убито в собственных домах из за Американских нападений?
Афганцы встали против Америки и дали отпор. Афганцы настоящие герои и заслужили уважение.
Но как я уже сказал. Мультфильм был создан для того, чтобы промыть людям мозги и манипулировать.
Raise your words, not your voice
It is rain that makes the flowers grow, not the thunder
Yeah. I love that words
How do I raise my words?
@@rinibunny4576 “This quote is by Jalal ad-Din Muhammad Rumi, a Persian poet. It means that one should not raise voice and use bad words no matter how tense the situation is. Instead, raise the impact of your words, let them have a meaning and let them reflect you so that it fills up others heart with love, not hatred.”
@@tsiringgurung3393 thank you🙏 very inspiring words
Rumi
Seeing what’s happening right now in Afghanistan, and immediately I remembered about this film. Very sad and tragic indeed
6 years ago After reading “The Breadwinner, A girl’s life under the Taliban” I told myself “I hope those dark days never come back again”. My heart aches for Afghanistan and its innocent citizens💔💔
💔😢😭
Same here ...
Omg me too , it came to mind and I just wanted to cry
Me too... This is just terrible of what's happening to Afganistan!
I remember reading this book back in elementary school, and seeing this had sent me back. Human rights are universal and are not subject to debate.
I totally agree.
@@sidthemann25 in some countrys god goes over human rights. even if we see it in our eyes like humans riights are important they dont care they just do what they want and when nobody stops them or try to change there view nothing will ever change.
@@Jonyi100 I know, I visited a third world country recently and had to see the unfortunate lives of some people there
No yes they are when the “rights” are stupid and immoral
@@shitface7000oh shut up. You have been commenting on this video since forever. You just want to oppress women. Islam is a cancer. You don't own women and nobody can be forced to live by the rules of a religion they dont even believe.
This movie is probably the most underrated movie to come from cartoon saloon. It tore my heart out, because I went in blind expecting magic to show up... but no... just a vividly grounded and poignant tale about what is happening right now.
будем честны. определённой группе людей очень нужно настроить общественное мнение против кого-нибудь. А мультфильм - лишь средство пропаганды.
В этом случае авторы мульта выставили в плохом свете "Талибан".
Если посмотрите на историю. Америка вторглась в более чем 50 стран после второй мировой войны. Свой терроризм Америка оправдывает тем, что называет оппонента "террористом".
Задумайтесь, сколько людей было убито в собственных домах из за Американских нападений?
Афганцы встали против Америки и дали отпор. Афганцы настоящие герои и заслужили уважение.
Но как я уже сказал. Мультфильм был создан для того, чтобы промыть людям мозги и манипулировать.
I burst out crying at the end, like sobbing, and the ending wasn’t even particularly sad.
It was incredibly moving, hard not to feel emotional
@@Nvwheeler I want to watch it but I can’t find it
Read the book watching the film tomorrow can’t wait to watch it
@@galaxymoonlqght3732 oh no there’s a book? Well I’m going to need that
@@jessicas.6235 yes the book is amazing
Can we just take a moment to appreciate how stunning the animation looks?
Irish animation. The very best in the world!
This should seriously get more views than that
Such movies make people to start thinking and that's not what governments want.
@@baharafghanzad_0093 very true
My favorite underrated movie :)
I want to want it but it's not free.
I just finished watching this film on Netflix Streaming. It's the most powerful movie I have seen in quite a while.
Afghanistan is under taliban rule again
yes in the last my tears came out from my eyes
it aas amazing
@@wilmerbesitan1200
If u liked this, you could watch Persepolis
How can I watch full movie of it?
What is netflix streaming?
@@zarnigormirzayeva8383 yes
" My name is Sulayman. my mother is a writer, my father is a teacher, and my sisters always fight each other. One day I found a toy on the street and I picked it up. It exploaded... I dont remember what happened after that, because it was the end... " 😭
I can’t even put into words how painful that scene was
Prayers for Afghan. 😭🙏
Well I won't touch something that isn't mine from now on
@mojtabarezai8178what's that got to do with anything? Anyways her profile pic is just her face.
:(
No child should be hurt because they just wanted something, they didn't realize it was an explosive and whoever planted it there was a cruel person, bless your heart for telling this
And now Afghanistan is back to this, the dreams of all the girls who grew up with hopes for college and a career are now dead
American gave girls college but still sent them to war with other males.
Why don't let a country be what it wants to be. what is your concern are they starving them to death like war is bringing to them?
Just like America went to destroy Libya
America comes like God and makes brothers destroy themselves and their lives silently forsaking those it gave force hope.
Dude they just passed a policy that allowed women to work but in non-free mixed environment
@@iamisearojob6549 you are really brainwashed with religion that's why you are too blind to see the horror on the other side, you have no idea what innocent people are going through
@@themercifulguard3971 yesss
@@themercifulguard3971 bro u know women can never work freely under Talibans
They are just making some small or fake rules to show others
The reality is that not even men can work there freely forget about women
I very much enjoyed the storytelling, artwork, compassion and wisdom in this little masterpiece. I deeply wish more films could be like that.
Посмотри кем сделан мульт и поймёшь зачем людям вызывать такое негативное впечатление о об определённой группе людей)
сейчас рисовать такие мульты - отличный вариант пропаганды.
I was there- I lived by the role 3 hospital where women would come in all burned up because it was a popular form of suicide. I saw the women destroying a well at night that our provincial reconstruction team built - because it was one of their only opportunities to be away from the abuse. That’s not to say all the men were bad either, but there was certainly a rampant issue with the treatment of their women. The fact that they weren’t allowed to receive any formal education under Taliban rule.
Yes, cartoons can be an accurate form of propaganda; that is true. They can also communicate truth as well. What I saw in this movie coincides with what I experienced overseas in Afghanistan and it really hit home.
The "forbidden book" being "مثنوی معنوی" breaks my heart
It's just a poem, a masterpiece of iranian culture.
It hurts bc in Islam, some ppl take the "no music" policy too hard, and things like this happen.
Whats funny is that poems are considered halal.
:(
@@bayeyyes2608But, they should also Ban the Qu'ran, cause Ironically to speak the "Word" you must sing with it.
There is no too hard, there is only haram and halal, Muslims and kafir, etc. Don’t be so naive
@@paulandreig.sahagun34no it isnt. reciting Qur’an is a style of art not singing. other religions do this as well. they are not singing, they are reciting.
"Maybe you should stop looking" LOVE THAT LINE
Watched it many times,gets me every time.
Its a very sad and beautiful movie.
if you like this film you would probably like animated movie "Bilal: new breed of hero"
i want to download it
but i cant find anywhere please tell me if you have any downloadable links
@@faizansiddiqui4667 me too
@@aminakhatun4936 Maybe you should check 123movies or putlocker
@@jamshidkarimov1021 Do you know any other movies like The Breadwinner that has the same kind of animation style? I'm really interested to learn more about these movies! And personally I think some are much better than Disney
This movie has touched my heart so deeply. I couldn't stop my tears from falling down while watching it. I am now a college graduate and I cannot imagine the life Parvana is living. I wish they can go outside by themselves without fearing for their lives and also get the education that everyone deserves. It's just so heartbreaking how life can be so harsh because of our fellow humans.
Tears rolled on my cheeks watching this.....A gem of a movie
Just finished watching on netflix. I fell very sorry for all brothers and sisters in Afghanistan. May God be with you all.
Рад за афганцев , наконец то они освободились от американской оккупации
We love Taliban atleast they're way better that American assh*les now u f*ck yourself and put your thinking in your ass
@@chechen4338at what cost, the Taliban has returned and is more powerful than ever due to our foolishness in the retreat
Salam guys, i am a Muslim and I was born in Afghanistan, and ill tell my story. I was in Afghanistan last year at somewhere where school was finish. So.. I was in Afghanistan for a month but then stuff we being suspicious. Ofc.. The taliban camed to our neighborhood. We had to leave Afghanistan sadly. The taliban were so strong bc the Americans gaved up so we had less power. Inshallah, Afghanistan will be better soon 🙏 Also the movie is great
Waalaikum Assalam
I'm sorry man. Insha Allah everything will be alright.
Так радуйся, у вас теперь по воле Всевышнего шариат
how you could still follow islam?? im from iran you see what islam bring to our countries ..
how many lives lost and still suffer how much rape and killing happened in Afghanistan and iran
in iran we said that "this is not real islam ,the islam that islamic republic and taliban show is not real islam " but now after 43 years of suffering and silent killing and rape by islamic republic we know this is the real islam
don't go this path my brother
taliban , islamic republic and hezb-o-allah will remain till we leave islam behind
if satan is real islam is his religion
in hope of free Afghanistan and free iran
@@rezah8889 i feel like you answered your own question.. no republic or taliban is the “real islam” because it is twisted and turned into something else. In no way should rape and violence be accepted (both using common sense and the religion itself)
Those people that try to force and twist it to their advantage and to hurt people think they are God and are only worshipping themselves.
I believe the best way to practice islam is to read and decide things for yourself only. It’s not meant to be forced on anyone, especially since everyone practices differently (or chooses not to believe, which is nothing i can control) The literal meaning of islam is “peace”..yet so many Muslims tend to forget that
So you want the americans to rule you? Get out of here dunce
Parvana elder's sister said it will be alright but today's situation doesn't seems like 💔😢😢😢 God saves innocent citizens of Afgan 🙏💔💔💔💔
😭😭😭
The only way for Parvana and for her eldest sister to be saved is for the Americans troops to come back and blow up Talibans' faces!!
My teacher made us read the book last year.
I loved it, it feels like it’s trying to motivate everyone to just keep going.
@ilmarafat0016maybe the name of the movie…🤦♂️
Are you that stupid
This looks like it was extremely faithful to the book, and it goes without saying the animation is gorgeous. Wonderful job!
Why it's so underrated it's been 6 years now 2024 iam having a glance of this Master piece
It’s crazy how I imagined this when reading the book for a school project! Like 5 months later I can still imagine and map out the entire town parvana lived in from my imagination!
I feel the sense to protect them and help to dream and be happy, poor girls my heart is broken.
We are human so let's be worthy this word🌸
I have watched this movie twice with my students.we have cried together. But we need to remember how lucky we are and that we should not give our spoiled life for granted
My entire class did an assignment on this movie and I loved it. 🙂
i remember reading the book and being so moved by it, im so glad to see this animation
I never really stopped to think how someone might make Mulan but modern. This hits it on the head from the looks of it.
Better than the live action remake.
Raise your words, not your voice
It is rain that grows flowers, not thunder
kinda clicked on the ad to see the arguments in the comment section, guess i'm what's wrong with society
I don't think there will be too much of an argument here. It doesn't appear to either deify or demonise the Afghans.
@@KingTrygon There is a recent comment saying “Western people covering up their crimes in movies like this” To be frank everyone painted the wars in black and white, I don’t know how to say it to be honest.
@@KingTrygon they are demonising being independent country from Western culture
I liked how the film portrayed the horrible system being the real villain, and the villain character is a victim of it as much as the protagonist.
So hear touching story. Kudos to those team who portrayed everything throughout this movie.
I seen this a while ago, really powerful movie, it’s a must watch, not the best from the company, I still like Song of the Sea the best but this one is still one is that very interesting and very powerful.
Can't wait to watch this. Love films made by Cartoon Saloon
Its on netflix
@@lilybug1397 It sure is! Thanks for that
i want to download it
but i cant find anywhere please tell me if you have any downloadable links
@@faizansiddiqui4667 Did you find? I wanna download it too
I just finished this movie and it was so so good, and very sad. Definitely watch it if you haven’t
Its the kind masterpiece you recover from. Great feature cartoon thats not for kids
Its not just a movie its its an emotion with a heart touching story ❤
As a arab girl who grew up in america it hurts to see girls who have to go through this prosecuted over gender whether you believe in jesus or allah this isnt what any god would want
Maybe there is something wrong but Hijab is the safest place for a girl and they are making it horrible. Islam is so beautiful how can someone make it so horrible . As a Muslim girl I'm really against it
Maybe there is something wrong but Hijab is the safest place for a girl and they are making it horrible. Islam is so beautiful how can someone make it so horrible . As a Muslim girl I'm really against it
As half afgani and half russian, this is the best movie ive ever watched
Thanks for raising the voice against Talibans through this movie in 2017 itself, whatta beautiful but sad movie
Весь этот фильм это преувеличение, что свойственно либералам и феминисткам , а талибы молодцы
The fact they look like and sound like how i imagined they did when reading the book surprises me
I remember when i was a child, my dad introduced me this film at first I didn’t seem interested wasn’t my cup of tea but growing up seeing how the Taliban occupied Afghanistan reminded me of this film. This movie really makes me feel sad what happening there.
Another story I want to tell is once I had driving license with my driving teacher, at one point she told me her experience with two afghani girls she had teaching lessons with, she described the afghani girls to me how they seemed very innocent and naive. It’s actually difficult for afghani women to immigrate or visit a country since the Taliban with there weapon can immediately shoot you brutally and how terrifying it is to be controlled by Taliban! One of the girls entire family was shot in front of her. On the positive side note, the Afghani men who immigrated to different countries, some of them go back to Afghanistan to marry these women and immigrate them to another country so they can start new life (I’m too sure how they do that) which actually is sweet of these guys! However these women are very use to isolation and can be socially awkward at times but it depends how they will adapt different cultures.
Parvana was in my school library. I read it twice and I loved it. I cried both times at the ending, too
I came back here knowing what's happening in Afghanistan right now :(
@@MuhammadAbdullah-hz6pm bro the women in Afghan after thaliban took over
@@MuhammadAbdullah-hz6pm ur mom
@@jorrosmith164 а что с женщинами ? Если ты привержен к западным ценностям, это не означает что все должны быть такими
@@chechen4338если Бог существует, надеюсь такие как ты попадут в ад!
Just finished watching this masterpiece and I hope that the bffs get to see each other again
Do you know where I can watch it???
Where did you watch it? I couldnot find it anywhere
One of the most powerful movies I've ever seen
Well good too see whoever animated this did their homework.
Such an amazing film. I'm sad I didn't watch it till just this past week, and I fell in love with it.
I get shivers from this. So beautiful
Pervana looks like the popular Afghan girl on the magazine covers
that's true! the afghan girl by steve mccurry
I noticed that too. I think the character design artists took inspiration from her and based Parvana's design off of her.
I remember the Muslim girls In my class covered their while body once they stepped out of the school gate but in the class room they use to remove their scarf & put it inside the bag since it was a Girls school.& I also remember some Girls suddenly stop coming to school & few months later seeing them carrying baby's & walking with their husbands who looks twice or thrice the age of us ,But still we are schooling .
unfortunatly their are few muslim countries who think like this iam from pakistan a muslim country but here its like 20% girls life is like that in northern areas but fortunatly 80% are safe :)
Majority Muslims are not like that
@@Roma-co3go Women in Northern Areas, both Dardic and Pashtun majority areas, are actually safe, it just happens to be different cultures. Now compare that to what happens if a woman steps outside when one of you Indic Pakistanis are around. Look at Minar e Pakistan incident or the woman that was blamed for parking on a highway after being raped just recently.
@Behemoth tell me a reason why Sharia law is bad
Maintain Secularism,else Pakistan will also be Like Afghanistan,Ive seen many videos where Islamic scholars spit venom against non muslims@@Roma-co3go
This should honestly be as remembered as Mulan
I haven't watched this yet but the trailer already makes me cry
I came back here after I learnt of what's happening on Afganistan...
And people are supporting taliban
@@malakmahmoud2439 no
tell me what's happening because you certainly don't know
@@nesi2416 да
I saw this in school years ago, then I suddenly remembered it after the Taliban takeover of Afghanistan three years later. At the time I first saw it, it was clearly something of the past, but now it’s back. I hope they’ll be free one day.
This is so under rated its criminal
After watching the film:
Story 8/10
Animation 10/10
Characters 10/10
9/10
its shit propaganda
@@valtontony826it’s not😊
This is unbelievable. I want to watch this.
Am watching this in my school TOMORROWWWW YEYEEYYEYE
May Ram bless all the people suffering in Afganisthan...My heart shatters everytime I think of ppl specially women living there 😢
Idk why but this feel new to me I can’t wait to watch it
The fact that it didn’t win the oscar 😢
i cried for this and i am 33 this is heart breaking because you know its real
Can’t wait to see it again!
This movie shows that cartoon saloon can create beautiful and magical films, but also can create dark and realistic films
much like the world of anime/manga too.
ashita no joe, kaiji, vinland saga & planetes also comes to mind when it comes to dark or realistic themes
@@tutubism this also reminds me of ghibli and grave of the fireflies, I think the breadwinner is cartoon saloon's grave of the fireflies
This was a really good movie 10/10
Would recommend!
I didn't see the movie yet but I like the genteel tone of the story. Whimsical, dispite the dark themes. It does not invite to hate a whole group of poeple by showing the worst they got, it invites to embrace those within who struggle. I m a feminist and arab and i ve often seen demonstrations of the sexism in our societies used, not to raise compassion towards us, but used to endorse feelings of revulsion against us as a whole, the victims included. The sentiment being '' if they don't want to be victims, why chose to be muslims''or something in that vein. It is rare that i find mentions of orientalism nowadays (unlike the long gone fascination of the european colonists with the exotic and with fancies of a' 'one thousands and one nights' ' like world. Even if that too encouraged the colonialism. )
Sad that many little girls may really have to experience this in Afghanistan now
Me basically after i finish reading the book:
I read the book such a long time ago, but always remembered how I cherished this story. I never knew that there was a movie made based off this book, and it makes me so happy to see 🥹. It was an eye opener reading the book in class during grade 5, especially due to how some people aren’t as lucky as I am. it makes me sad that this is our reality in this cruel world, I just loved this book so much. it makes me wanna cry knowing there was a movie I never knew about for 6 years, but also happy because it brings light to the harsh reality of some people’s lives, which is truly heartbreaking knowing that if i’ve never known about the movie, many people probably haven’t either.
0:16 And you know what? He's right both morally, and in terms of Islam, religiously. Allah tells the men not to nag but rather to lower their gaze and mind their damn business. Care about your own damn problems.
Verse 24:30:
"Tell the believing men that they should reduce/lower (يغضوا) their gaze/vision and guard their private parts..."
Verse 24:31:
"Tell the believing women that they should reduce/lower (يغضضن) their gaze/vision and guard their private parts..."
Verse 49:3
"It is those who lower (يغضون) their voices in the presence of Allah's messenger and whose hearts Allah has proved to be aware - they will have forgiveness and a great reward."
So the Muslim dad over here is right. They should not be looking at her. And to add, the Quran says that a child must care for their parents regardless of anything, generalising it to the point of gender.
Yeah. Allah has a drastic difference of how he treats women contrary to how most islamic cultures do. He is not sexist towards them, but even more so like a really protective feminist, or at least that's how I see it.
Feminists don't victim shame and don't tell victims to cover up. Feminists tell women that they can dress how they like because their bodies aren't shameful or sexual.
@@georgeaskeladd742exactly. Tbh who gives a fuck about feminism. Majority of us don't want to be judged for what we wear, what education we take, basically hoe humans live their lives without being controlled.
I have just found this masterpiece ❤️
this is a heartwarming story ind I've read the book so the movie must be great! I recommend it to everyone.
They need to allow women more rights, they've basically made the worst choice possible to teach children to devalue women and prioritize men.
I read this book. Its really superb. Proud for the pervanna
I read this book as a kid, happy to see that the movie was made
@ilmarafat0016 “The Breadwinner” by:Deborah Ellis
Person: why would you not bring you daughter home?
Father: so she can help me.
Person: she could cover herself probably
Father: maybe you should stop looking at her
So happy to find my grand parents past 😢😢
Highly recommended film. For it’s such a beautiful movie
if you like this film you would probably like animated movie "Bilal: new breed of hero"
This movie was very deep I watch this with my brother and this movie shows a very realistic take on this part of the world
Very sad, its happening again . . .
Than your country shouldn't have funded the taliban and invaded to steal Afghani resources
The music in the movie is just phenomenal!
i like this movie, i wish i had as much courage as them lol
It usually comes with a sacrifice. They had horrible circumstances, I hope you won't get those
Don't worry America wouldn't fund terrorists to kill and steal your natural resources and act hero in the media
In class my teacher read this book to us and it was AMAZING!!
I can’t believe there’s a place in the world like this. It’s so dumb and horrible. They’re just people who want power and they want things to go their way like big babies
Don't worry there's much places worsts
I thought wolfwalkers was easily my favourite from cartoon saloon, but it just doesn't grab a special place in my heart like this movie has
1:44 Oz Films reference
And to think, 10 years earlier, Cartoon Saloon brought us Skunk Fu
very important film.
A very powerful story, animation and direction.
i was really heartbreaking i cried watching this movie..,
love from korea~ ㅠㅠ
This brought tears in my eyes
Incredibly good
Must look
I want to see more cartoons like this. It's better than what Disney is making now.
The Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon him) prayed to God: “Lord, if any affairs of my followers are under someone's control (guidance), and this someone will create problems (difficulties) for them [will deliberately treat them unfairly], to that [manager or leader], Lord, create problems (difficulties).
And to the one under whose control any deeds of my followers will be [their deeds and prospects will depend on his decision, on his word or recommendation], and he will be kind to them [just and magnanimous], then you too, Lord, be kind to him [no matter who he is, show him Your mercy and Divine kindness]! " (Hadith from Aisha; Ahmad, Muslim Al-Baihaqi).
I’m not a religious person and I would watch it
Who is here after Taliban took over Afghanistan again?
What
Is this movie related to afghanistan
@@shaizentertainment yes, and shows life after taliban rule
@@shaizentertainment yes
I need season 2 :'(