Creality Halot Mage PRO Review - CAN'T BE FIXED!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 พ.ค. 2023
- Update: I have been in a conference call today with Creality who have acknowledged all of the points on the email I show in this video - they have advised that they will address all of them with software updates.
However, there is one issue that they are limited on what they can do because of the hardware. So in this video when I say “this printer can’t do it”, that’s correct. It can’t.
I was so excited about the Creality Halot Mage Pro, but as this review will show. But as you will soon see, a clunky and often inoperable UI coupled with some questionable design choices. take this feature-rich unit and turn it into a mess. Yes, it will work, and if you have one, I'm sure it's fine for whatever you chose it for. For the most part, it delivers incredible quality prints. but in 2023 it should not be this hard to do it.
Get any printer working easily with the Photonsters XP Range Finder - www.thingiverse.com/thing:602... (watch my video for full instructions • How to Print Perfect M... )
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @fauxhammer
Buy WARGAMER - The best Resin for Miniatures yesthats3dprinted.com/pages/w...
Photonsters XP Range Finder - www.thingiverse.com/thing:602...
3D Printer Cleaning Mat: geni.us/3DPrinterCleaningMat (This and all Amazon links in our video description are affiliate links. Clicking these and making any purchase will earn us a commission from Amazon at no cost to you)
This Video is part of our series looking for the Best 3D printer for Miniatures; www.fauxhammer.com/top-10/the...
Special thanks to the following Creators who provided models
TheLion's Tower - thelionstower.com/fauxhammerblog
Wolverine Bust - Drafnir Studios - cgtrader.sjv.io/3eJyqv
Wasteland Reavers - Creature Caster - www.myminifactory.com/object/...
Grey Fox - H3LL Creator - cgtrader.sjv.io/6ek1gb
Roman Miniature Components - GreyTide Studios - www.myminifactory.com/users/g...
Big Boss - Jonatas Praxedes - joupraxedes.artstation.com/pr...
For Glory (Samurai from Thumbnail) - CA Sculpts - www.casculpts.art/product-pag...
Artis Opus FauxHammer Essentials Set: store.artis-opus.com/products...
FauxHammer Patreon - / fauxhammerblog
FauxHammer Facebook Group - / painthub
FauxHammer 3D Printing Group - / 3dprintedminiatures
FauxHammer Discord - / discord
Best Airbrush For Miniatures: www.fauxhammer.com/top-10/bes...
Beginner Airbrush: www.fauxhammer.com/featured/b...
Affiliate Links to support us.
Element Games - elementgames.co.uk/wargames-a...
Wayland Games - affiliates.waylandgames.co.uk...
Forbidden Planet: forbiddenplanet.com/catalog/?...
Amazon - www.amazon.co.uk/s?k=Warhamme...
Website: www.fauxhammer.com/
Facebook: / fauxhammerblog
Twitter: / fauxhammerblog
Instagram: / fauxhammerblog
Pinterest: www.pinterest.co.uk/fauxhammer/
Video Editing by VidPros: app.vidpros.io/r/J50Z26
00:00 - Intro - บันเทิง
Get any printer working easily with the Photonsters XP Range Finder - www.thingiverse.com/thing:6023738 (watch my video for full instructions th-cam.com/video/Gm0-z971tgY/w-d-xo.html)
Join this channel to get access to perks:
th-cam.com/channels/_9Jsf3SP8aMJgn0xv5jHjA.htmljoin
Buy WARGAMER - The best Resin for Miniatures yesthats3dprinted.com/pages/wargamer?ref=FauxHammer
Photonsters XP Range Finder - www.thingiverse.com/thing:6023738
3D Printer Cleaning Mat: geni.us/3DPrinterCleaningMat (This and all Amazon links in our video description are affiliate links. Clicking these and making any purchase will earn us a commission from Amazon at no cost to you)
This Video is part of our series looking for the Best 3D printer for Miniatures; www.fauxhammer.com/top-10/the-best-3d-printer-for-miniatures-models/
ive watched it twice, I cant find the place in the video where you mentioned “this printer can’t do it” I wished you had just mentioned that in the description.
@@genin69 pardon?
@@FauxHammer in ur description u wrote that they eventually replied to ur email and sad they will fix everyhting except one thing thats hardware related. What was that one thing? Also u need to re loom at this printer as theyve fixed almost all the issues u had. Manual build plate control. Slow moving plate. Just remove the auto resin thingy. 2 click print function with a preview of sliced file..no more forced cloud things. Much updated UI. Fep film etc etc. Unless youve already done a video..
Keep up the honest reviews, I'm so sick of the "influencers" who are nothing more than shills for hire. You are the only 3d print channel I subscribe to. You are stopping people from making expensive mistakes and providing an invaluable service. THANKYOU
Thanks so much, I will keep it honest always. I get so much sh!t off people when I do a positive review. When I like a printer, I love it!!! And will scream about it as loud as I can.
But these are the videos that prove my credibility as a reviewer - but hardly anyone watches a review of a bad printer, because they just don’t sell
@@FauxHammer This was a thorough review, and you were being very moderate - the MajikHarlot is a right POS, unfortunately. Use this thing for fast prototyping? What, with the watered-down fast resin so one can make a bunch of crumbly prototypes that don't stick to the plate _blazing fast_? F*k no, LOL
The shame of it is it did look good on paper, but when the paper's rice-paper we know how that usually turns out.
Excellent review mate. You've just saved me a fair chunk of change.
These are the best kind of reviews. Of there's something that bothers someone, it's probably going to bother me.
but this dude shills for Elegoo
Yup. I wish I saw this video before I bought this printer. I had a print fail the other day. Didn’t think much of it, threw the pieces away and decided to come back another day. Turns out the bed tore, resin got underneath and cured and over time resin has just been leaking out. Not very happy. I’ll keep the washing and curing station but I might have to just get rid of it.
I am new to 3D printing. It's been 2 months since I started doing it. I focused my mind and spirit on the art of 3D printing. 3D printing has been occupying all my free time and beyond as I learn and experiment. I'm following nearly 50 TH-cam channels. Thank you for maintaining honesty in your videos. I began with a FlashForge Adventure 3 FDM printer. Nice printer, but it wasn't for me. I moved on to the Elegoo Mars 3 resin printer and tore up on my 3rd print and I returned it.
So, I bought the Halot Mage (not the pro version). To me, it outdid the other two printers. But the more I tried to tweak it to get better results, the more I realized how restrictive the printer was. Back to the drawing board. I popped off well over two dozen decent prints with the Halot Mage before returning it for the pro version. Then, I saw your video of the disaster you had. Jumping onto Amazon, I tried to return it, but the printer had already shipped.
Deciding to try it since I have 30 days to return it, I opened it up. Thanks to your video, I avoided several pitfalls. First of which was the spout on the pump. If you put the vat in without paying attention to the pump spout, it can be out of place and catch the build plate. Giving it a nudge in with a finger as you put the vat on and rechecking it after installation will ensure you don't break it. The spout needs to be tight against the back of the vat for it to be seated correctly. If the spout moves, you need to reinstall the vat.
The video also helped me navigate the Cretan Labyrinth of the on-screen menus. Thanks to you, I loosened the screws prior to bed leveling, and I knew which buttons to push to level the bed.
You also helped me out when downloading my files to print. The scrolling screens were dizzying. A tip to help with trying to find the actual print: Remove the flash drive after downloading, and it will be the only one available on the screen (courtesy of The Outer Circle channel on TH-cam).
While I don't possess the Creality fast resin, I have the 8k high precision resin. 1.2 second exposure times per layer are resulting in excellent outcomes. At 1.6 seconds per layer, I get better outcomes.
A few more things (apologies for the length). The June 19th, 2023, update fixed some issues. None of my prints have locked up, and I can slow the bed down. Go back and give the Halot Mage Pro another try. I think it is turning out to be a great printer for miniatures even with the quirks, like trying to install the vat and the crazy menu navigation.
Last thing, you have helped me decide on my next printer. As soon as I save up my pennies, GKTwo here I come. I will be keeping the Halot Mage Pro.
Well done. Glad to see all the quirks of this promising printer. It does look good on paper but all these annoyances add up. Thanks for covering this so thoroughly.
Thanks, I’m glad you found this informative
Great, real life experience review! Been shopping around for my first resin printer, this helps enormously. Cheers mate!
Happy to help
dont listen to this confused man. i bought the halot mage pro 8k and its perfectly fine. works out of the box, with normal resin. i dont know what he is doing, but if you not like 5 year old, and take a little bit care, you wont destroy anything, i dont know how this can happen. also the filter fits well, and everything is in place. so if you are not a no-hands, this product is perfectly fine! and maybe dont use 5 year old resin, thats broken anyways lol. or the cheap one from aliexpress is propably also not the best choice. this video makes me angry, to think that ppl will not buy this super printer, just because he is disabled.
Honest review, amazing print speed, looking forward to see review 2.0
I have the replacement Pump, still waiting on Resin, and they have released a few firmware updates.
Good job mate, I'm dreading your M5S review, you really are one of the few brutally honest reviewer out there.
I’ll be fair, it looks good, I just think it’s the wrong innovations. We’ll see when I get to play with it I guess
@@FauxHammerplease try to test the antialiasing. They keep releasing printers with non working antialiasing and I’m tired of them getting away with it
@@JustTryGambling I always test AA. I should say it more... Ooops
@@FauxHammer haha all good. Have you had any Anycubic machines with fully functional AA? Seems to be a big issue with that company and lots complaining in their communities
Thank God you made this video because when I originally saw this on the OC i was sold and about to order it but after watching some of your other videos I could see youre very honest thank you.
Happy to be of service
Thank you for honest reviews!
Glad I ran into this review. I was getting ready to buy this printer next month but not now!
Glad I could help!
wow, barely seen such an honest review and i am so thankful for it! keep up the honest work
Solid work my brother! I will let you know how my new pump works as soon as I test it. I was hopeful to test it today, but I was way busier than I expected.
Thanks man and thanks for letting me use your footage
I like your reviews, I've seen so many where any criticism has obviously been downplayed. I hope that you'll continue to get review units.
Thanks i hope so too. but I guess I'll see with Creality. I've asked for a K1, lets see what they say.
dont listen to this confused man. i bought the halot mage pro 8k and its perfectly fine. works out of the box, with normal resin. i dont know what he is doing, but if you not like 5 year old, and take a little bit care, you wont destroy anything, i dont know how this can happen. also the filter fits well, and everything is in place. so if you are not a no-hands, this product is perfectly fine! and maybe dont use 5 year old resin, thats broken anyways lol. or the cheap one from aliexpress is propably also not the best choice. this video makes me angry, to think that ppl will not buy this super printer, just because he is disabled.
Brilliant video. Honest and clear.
Thanks for posting.
I think the real test of any company is how it deals with something when things go wrong if they take on board your issues and go back and look at them and rectify them, even if it is just a case of you've got a dodgy Printer and send you a different one to test (it happens ) or updating the software to improve the UI and freezing. then its shows that they want to improve and be the top brand to buy. hopefully, you'll find out soon .
That’s right, and they have said they want to do that. I’ve promised a follow up review when they do
It looks like a lot of the bugs are the advanced features being poorly integrated. I have a standard halot mage and it has been great so far. Build plate moves at a standard speed, no auto fill things to worry about, and on my UI I can step the build plate up and down and home it just like any other msla printer I use. Also I think the flipped zero reference is because they have the optical limit switch on the top, unlike the elegoo machines which have it at the bottom. Thus in the code the top is now the zero ref. Also my UI has not been buggy or glitchy, although I have only been using the USB to print. I also seem to have images along with the files and my printer does not copy files over, which I don’t think I would really care for anyway. Just writing this post to say to people looking at the pro, maybe just look at the standard one that doesn’t try to incorporate all these flashy features that all come with new failure points and complexity
Creality are absolutely horrendous to deal with. Had issues with fdm and their new halot printers and it's many many weeks wait for a response before finding out they won't honour warranty anyway.
I know jack about resin printers but they sent me one to review. Looking forward to this video as I haven’t seen much about them yet.
Thank, I hope you find it helpful
I'm feeling lucky, my Halot One works like a dream.
Same, I got it on such a deal with 3L of Resin that it was basically a steal. Working very well.
There should be 0% chance of a component getting caught on the print plate. That is flat-out poor design.
They say it was damaged in transit
@@FauxHammer the design of the printer was damaged in transit? That's a new one!
@@Le_Petit_Lapin yeah, that was my thought too, but in kindness I did not lress the issue, they said they are redesigning
@@FauxHammer really tempted to get one of these new Saturn machines they have coming out, as my first resin printer. Have elegoo offered you one to review? Seems to me like they have sent out very few review samples of it.
@@Le_Petit_Lapin yes but I’m on a later phase than the big guys. So I just ordered them.
Thanks for the honest review.
Hopefully Creality will keep letting you review their products.
They said they will, I hope that’s true, we’ll see. I’ll buy the next one if they don’t, just to see
@@FauxHammer i would trust a company that is willing to accept critics, admit their faults, and make improvements, rather than a company that do a lot of marketing mambo jumbo snd sweep problems under carpet.
* I am thinking about getting the non pro version of this printer.
Wow, this was one I almost bought! Looks so good on paper. Looking forward to see if those firmware updates fix any of the issues.
That’s crazy. I had none of these issues not a single one. I made sure to prepare the build plate and vat carefully before I leveled and sure it was mental fast but it wasn’t any issue. And my nozzle has never broken I made sure to click it in place when I replace the vat. Also I didn’t have a single failure on that machine I was given the fast resin though. And the details I got were fantastic for the speeds it prints. I printed a whole 1/6th scale spiderwoman standing on a traffic light… in less than 5 hrs. Printed 10 minis in an hour and a half. Yes the ui could be a bit less clunky but I’m an idiot with computery things and I managed to deal with it fairly easily. I think you were a bit harsh on this one to be honest. But my experience was very different, I actually really enjoyed that machine and wish I had more fast resin to use in it as that is what it’s meant for in my opinion. Smash models out stupid fast for those who are impatient.
I agree with you that if I had the fast Resin, this would have been a different experience. I feel like it was harsh, whxoh is why the video is so long, I tried to justify every point
dont listen to this confused man. i bought the halot mage pro 8k and its perfectly fine. works out of the box, with normal resin. i dont know what he is doing, but if you not like 5 year old, and take a little bit care, you wont destroy anything, i dont know how this can happen. also the filter fits well, and everything is in place. so if you are not a no-hands, this product is perfectly fine! and maybe dont use 5 year old resin, thats broken anyways lol. or the cheap one from aliexpress is propably also not the best choice. this video makes me angry, to think that ppl will not buy this super printer, just because he is disabled.
Thank you for this review super helpful! What was the printer you used to print that big wolverine bust?
That was the Neptune 3 max
thanks for making this video, was going to get but decided not to and find a different printer instead
Wish I watched this before buying it. I hope these issues were resolved. I am setting it up now
Interesting, the polar opposite of my experience with it, I was printing miniatures for weeks with different brands of resin on mine and had few hardware issues. Either you got the dud, or I got a premium package!
You have no issues with the UI? What other printers have you used?
@@FauxHammer I have used 4 creality SLA's so I'm used to their Halot UI, I also have a Saturn S, had an Anycubic Photon Mono X and original Photon, and a Sonic Mega.
The UI never froze up on me during use or gave me grief and I printed a lot with the Mage Pro the last few weeks. So maybe I got lucky, or maybe you got unlucky. I do take it for granted that I understand the UI, but I've used so many poorly optimised machines in real workplaces that maybe I am immune to poor UI these days and just accept them? lol
Mechanically, your nozzle problems were probably the lesser evil, that tube in the back without a clip and the refill function, as well as no vat-feet didn't make me too happy and were my big negatives.
@@TheOuterCircle yup, no real trouble with the machine.
@@FauxHammer When the filling nozzle breaks, it is due to human error or machine design!
@@danielramostrejo5720 Creality admitted it was a design issue.
WTH !!! I'm gonna have to wait a couple more years, before pulling the trigger. I do FDM printing and I don't have situations like these scaring the s%#* out of me. Resin is not something to play with and Mr. FauxHammer I really appreciate your honesty and time and work. Just Subbed.
Thanks so kindly
Can you help me with a decision Ross i went to go get the saturn 3 ultra today and told it's coming in around the 25th September and saturn 3 red one is October! The m5s is out now what would you do if in this situation wait for
Saturn 3 ultra or is the m5s actually good enough to pick over
The saturn 3? I just don't know what to do lol i have 2 smaller anycubics the 4k and mono 2 but when i got my saturn 2 8k the build quality its just unbelievable compared to anycubics and its so smooth the motor's and the weight i love it makes it feel more premium aswell than a light empty box with a bulb! Genuine question though as needing a second larger printer to
Replace these smaller anycubics
Great video, unfortunately can't say the same about the 3d printer at the moment :(
The same printer? Are you having a better experience? I’m curious to see other views
thank you for your honest review.
I was looking for a printer and this model was offered to me as a super printer.
I started to browse information about it and thanks to your video I saved some money.
Maybe in a new version of it or other better model.
Cheers from Brazil.
Apparently the normal version is ok. But I haven’t tested it
I would like to say. I had ordered the halot mage 8k and couldn’t get it to work. Creality were very helpful in troubleshooting and even sent a return label to send it back. I know I’m in the US so the customer service may be different than in the UK. Honestly though I was very happy with their customer service.
That’s great to hear, I wish I had a similar experience
Hi Ross, i was watching an anycubic m5s video yesterday and in the comments there was some guy saying if you want the speed go for this Halot printer he is comparing it better to the m5s and saturn 3 but if you cant get it to work easy with your experience its something best left alone just now!
I bought anycubic m3 premium this week. Do you think is the right choice or elegoo, phrozen is a better choice?
M3 premium is the best built 10” 4k Springer, I did a video comlarinvnall 3 you just mentioned
@@FauxHammer hello, which slicer program do u use , and what is the ideal setting anycubic m3 premium or which video is a about that.
after watching your video and some other posts on FB i was a thinking i ordered the wrong printer.
Turn up to me in Australia this week. No damage in transport, UI is same as the Creality Halot one.
Did a few test prints with the phrozen XP Finder and did couple of prints with no fails with siraya tech fast.
the only problem i had is when the test prints finished it lifted out of the resin fast and put resin all over the lid, other then that im happy with the printer.
Im printing 1/87 scale things ive designed for my model railway.
Lmao the “go to zero” got me too 17:00
Apparently Z=0 is not zero… I guess it means go to home? Like where the limit switch trips
What did you use to do the 1:1 Wolverine bust man? That is awesome. Did you cut it up in LuBan or what?
nope, just printed it on the Neptune 3 Max
@@FauxHammer awesome! That is my next printer then! Lol!
I don't know about the Mage Pro, but the regular mage levelling paper was included in a pouch with an extra FEP film sheet. So far, 1 month in I have had no issues with the regular Mage. I did find that slicing with Lychee printed 2X faster than with Chitubox.
A lot of people have said this. yeah the normal mage seems great from what I hear
@@FauxHammer i bought a pro, couldnt find the leveling paper, was in the envelope with the extra fep. Also, for the leveling process if you watch the tutorial they tell you to remove the tray, its not supposed to be there when you level, and the nozzle from the pump will be out of the way
@@SecapIII you may not realise but that video was created after they saw all the issues I've had.
Also, they all tell you to use a levelling paper
Most of us resin printers have progressed beyond that to skipping the levelling paper and just levelling it with the VAT in, since the point of the paper is to emulate the thickness of the FEP - Just Use the FEP that's already at the bottom of the vat.
Regardless of whether the vat is in or out, the Build plate still needs clearance to lift without touching the Nozzle and breaking it.
And since this, I'm not the only one to have the issue. Creality just ship replacement modules when it happens...
The Halot One has the same UI problem that you can't clearly see which file is highlighted, but it has a simply solution built in, and that is to change the layout scheme to the colorful one, then the copied file is always in another color
I like that you can change the UI in this, just wish they gave us some options and made it sensible first
I too was really disappointed in your review about this printer (not your actual review) as I had planned on getting one of these. Think you have saved me a lot of money. Glad you were honest and I hope Creality do resolve some of the issues.
Lots of new printers coming from Elegoo over next few days. Hope you get to review one of the new Saturn 3s. Now here's my two pennies worth. Are we getting to hung up on all this 8k, 12k cr*p. From normal viewing distances can you really see a difference with the naked eye or do you need a macro lens and an UHD screen to see the difference. Basically are people, myself included, just getting caught up in all the hype? As part of my job as a delivery driver for John Lewis we have to set up tvs for customers. Loads of people a year or two back were buying 8k tvs. We were setting them up and they would ask to see 8k content. Then there's a bit of an awkward silence when we had to tell them that there isn't anything broadcast in 8k yet. We then have to go onto TH-cam to find some to demo it.
I think you are dead on, I can’t see much of a difference between a 35um printer and a 22um printer.
I can’t see much of an improvement will be made here. But let’s see
Are you going to be doing a video on the Anycubic M5s anytime soon? Seems like an interesting printer 12k screen with rectangular pixels and has auto leveling.
He has one already
Yep, it arrived t my home today but I’m in Kos, will start using it next week
Sad to say that I looked for negative reviews of this printer before purchasing it. TH-cam only threw this video at me after I purchased it. Great, thanks guys.
Sorry to hear that
I already have the regular mage and it’s has been amazing (with right exposure settings) I also have the pro on order. Hopefully it’s not that bad…
I've heard good things about the other one, not tested it
You got any feedback on it for negatives, I'm about to get that over the new Mars 4 Max on Friday as it's a little better spec and not that much more cost wise, and there's precious little on TH-cam about it :)
@@FauxHammer Honestly beside my touch screen dying after 3 prints the normal Mage doesn't seem to suffer from any of the speed related issues and the ux is stripped down and surprisingly this makes it so much better. I just slice the files is chitu walk it over to the printer and just choose the file on the usb drive and its off to the races.
@@FauxHammerUpdate now that I've got mine: the test prints came out amazing, but I've just been having so many issues with prints sticking. Like I got a few successful prints at 20 seconds exposure but like it's ridiculous. I wasted at least 1 and a half bottles of phrozen aqua grey 8k resin. I'm going to return it and buy the Saturn 3 ultra if I have any more failures.
@@QEElevators Honestly, print;s not sticking is more likely your prrint settings rather than the printer. even now it's warm I'll print aqua grey 8k at 25+ seconds. For this printer I had to overexpose bbecasue even at it;s slowest it was so fast that it yanks the resin off the plate. So try 30 plus
Totally unrelated question if you don't mind - I've been watching a bunch of your stuff over the last few months as I finally get tempted to dip my toes into the murky and seemingly very complex and hazardous world of using very toxic and explody things to make little miniatures for me to paint, and I recall on some of your vids you showed a model of some larger size with fine detail of a vampire lady with a goblet and bats perched everywhere or something which looked ace - but I don't know where it came from - assuming it was you, can you point me in the right direction as to where to get that as I fancy giving that a go and likely spending months slowly painting it to a poor standard :D
Thanks, I remember that vampire lady, it is Isobel - The Matriarch from CA sculpts. It’s not amazingly presupported but is a beautiful model. One of my faves ever
Sold my anycubic printers to upgrade to something newer. Glad i found this review. I was looking at this printer. I wonder if the non- pro version is the same way? Looks like i might be better off with the elegoo saturn 2.
I dunno about the non pro version, I’ve heard it’s better. But not tested myself
I’d get a Saturn 2 over this any day.
I have the non pro version. I've had none of the problems he addresses in the video.
I have the Halot One and i didnt have nearly the problems you had although my model is the base model. Maybe it wasnt available when u reviewed but the first thing I did was update the firmware with no problems. I also am able to adjust the z speed, yours obviously could not. Maybe you got a lemon. Still there customer service is very lacking. One feature i love is the cleaning feature witch you didn't show. It cures the bottom layer and lets you peel the failed prints without emptying the fill tray. Still ..good review
Thanks, I did t show that feature because it’s a standard feature, I didn’t really consider it as standout…
This actually makes me think about canceling the Halot Mage Pro I have on order. Hopefully they fix these issues before they go shipping them all out because if it can't put out the high level of detail for miniatures and busts then sadly it's a no-go for me. Great video showcasing the printer! Super glad I watched!
They sent me a new firmware the morning after this went live, I’ve not tested it yet though, I won’t until I get some fast resin
dont listen to this confused man. i bought the halot mage pro 8k and its perfectly fine. works out of the box, with normal resin. i dont know what he is doing, but if you not like 5 year old, and take a little bit care, you wont destroy anything, i dont know how this can happen. also the filter fits well, and everything is in place. so if you are not a no-hands, this product is perfectly fine! and maybe dont use 5 year old resin, thats broken anyways lol. or the cheap one from aliexpress is propably also not the best choice. this video makes me angry, to think that ppl will not buy this super printer, just because he is disabled.
Good video thanks
I've a few questions I just bought the same model and is there a way to put a flex tube to the feed and I see what you mean about the small details missing on quick prints but have you tried bigger prints
Your issue with the exposure might be due to the power of the uv lamp. I’ve noticed on several printers coming out that the uv lamps get more and more powerful. And it’s gotten to a point where they’re just trying to flash cure the resin which doesn’t really work right as I’ve found it needs to “cook” so to speak to get proper adhesion and exposure. I’m working on a device to override uv power values on these proprietary boards that they won’t let us modify.
Nope, it's the speed. Reducing light I density would require longer exposure times and soften the detail of the print, but it would still lift far too fast
@@FauxHammer Yes, the speed of the printer is a function of movement speed and cure time among other things. We might be talking about two different issues here as I also think the shear speed of this printer is an issue as well. I have found that a high intensity light does in fact cure faster, but increases the effect of light bleed and blooming. This effect can be seen in less pigmented resins the easiest. Perhaps its also an effect of the type of light source used and it's linearity. I'm not exactly sure yet. Coming from a lower power creality machine to a more powerful anycubic machine has meant disastrous results for me in regards to light bleed and dimensional accuracy and I see the same sort of effect in other similar printers. The creality machine needed longer cure times and produced a more dimensionally accurate print with less of a glossy "bled" surface and more of a matte finish. The anycubic machine cures in half the time but the prints are not dimensionally accurate and have intense bleed through the rear of the object on thin walls and has a more glossy "bled" surface due to heavy blooming. Perhaps I'm wrong but everything I've tested seems to support my theory. It would be nice if someone bigger than myself with more resources could test with multiple resins including translucent. So far I have added UV blocking pigment to mitigate this effect, and it has improved significantly, but it has not fixed the issue.
Hey @FauxHammer, I see they said it was damaged in transit. Did they replace the part or the whole machine? I just had the same issue, trying to see what to expect from support.
EDIT: Update, Creality got back to me that that night, shipped a new pump. It seems like the issue was my spout was honestly already broken off at the other end. Either that or another piece flew off somewhere... either way I'll be backing the build plate off 1 or 2mm from center to be safe.
been waiting for this
Hope it was all you hoped for
Was really hoping this was just gonna be "mod this here and here" ah well.. thanks for saving me some money
yeah, sorry. I guess. umm, rip the resin feeder out altogether and hope for the best.
the leveling paper is in with the replacement FEP.
That movement speed on a resin printer is terrifying.
With no visible resistance detection to boot
My M3 Max lowers very slowly and has cracked 2 screens, one of them was due to a little bit of cured resin on corner of build plate....when I say little I mean about 2 layers of flat resin , less about speed and more about how strong the motor is set.
I got the non pro version and will say it's miles better than the pro according to your experience. 10 minutes to level (most was realizing the paper that explains leveling is the paper to level) then it was print. None of the issues at all. Just starting minis and trying to figure out a good resin to use
The auto refill nozzle popping off like that was a major issue. I mean, surely they do QC and stuff like that before they do mass production. I can't wait for the review 2.0 for this one.
They said it was damage in transit
@@FauxHammer I mean it's all a bit Sus right lol, their going to say something like that.
I just hope they are actually going to take the suggestions you made onboard. But I guess we'll have to wait and see right 😂.
Actually the UI is just Halot OS that is same or very similar in other Halots that you've mentioned to be good and the first downloaded model gets a different icon than files on USB stick. It's just very different from standard chitu firmwares. I've sent feedback regarding lack of incremental Z movement options already in few surveys 😂 The "not so smart" motor algorithm looks quite scary though.
Oh, by the way I had Halot-One in preorder and it was buggy as heck after release too. In fact it came without WiFi connection which was one of its main features and its first update was bricking it. Yet, after about a year it was one of most praised printers like you've mentioned. Hopefully Halot Mage Pro will also mature like a good wine despite a rough start that's appears to be typical there
Good to know, so they’ve always been a bit borked then…
chitu is closed source and wants you to only use chitubox no other slicers this is why creality and other good brands beware the Open source Factor! for new inovations 3d Print was 30 years to late only cause of closed source and Patents
PASS!! Thank you for such a great and honest REAL world use review. Thank You!
Thanks kindly
Product Designer here, looking to get a 3D Printer & Resin looks like the best finishes for a more intermediate level of printing. Do you have a reccomendation or a video on a 3D printer that has reliable UI/UX? Many thanks & very informative video.
Either Uniformation GKTwo, or, Watch my next video on Tuesday!!! 😉😉
My first 3D printer 4 months back, was an Ender 3 S1 Pro. Don't get me wrong, I can get great prints from it. Though, I'll be going with another brand when I buy my next one/three. Probably Sovol. They seem to take Creality parts and make better FDM printers. 😂
Resin wise, I've been told the Photon is a great started printer. What would you say? Auto level would be great, who all has that?
I do like Creality FDM printers that I have used
Were they able to address the issues with the July firmware update?
i Love it, mine comes at saturday and i love such Videos, now o know what i must look after...
Jeah maybe i would buy an Anycubic 5s but now its to late, and i will print big things with this thing and hope all of this eraly problems are Firmware fixable.... Otherwise i have 30 days and a little stress with the return process and then it will be definitly an Aycubis 5s
you may wanna watch my 5s shorts. but in summary. i;m having a much better time with the 5s. but I thin the Anycubic M5 is the better choice for most people.
Incredible
For me , the only issue its the prints stuck in vat. Just changed FEP for NFEP and all good. Really great resin printer.
Thank you so much! I was going to buy it but once watching this video I just see no use in trying it
I’m here to help you make the right decision for you, if I’ve done that. I’m glad
I’m looking for a good 1st resin 3D printer
That is disappointing. I was thinking of getting this one as I have a K1 Max and for multiple parts it takes way too long.
What reliable printer would you recommend for regular parts? as I'm not looking to print figures like you do.
Yeah Creality are an FDm company, not a Resin company. I have a video on the best printers of 2024, I’d check that out
@@FauxHammer thanks I'll take a look
well i ordered one of this printers last week xD. lets hope it works for me :)
I hope so too!
@@FauxHammer well i was looking into anycubic printers, but then i asked a 3D print shop where i also buy stuff, and the recommended this crealyti printer. so i did some research and was thinking well this sounds nice. and now i saw your review xD
I have been doing FDM for a very long time, but have also felt an an itch towards trying resin. Not that I have a particular need to reproduce super heroes, but more usable stuff... I have watched numerous viedoes and so far rejected the topic for stink and other inconviniencies. I guess the various manufacturers have meanwhile recognized the nuissance and they do their best to fix it. The Halot Mage Pro seems like a good candidate, but I need a little more than Creality telling me that this is a good printer.
Starting watching this video, I at first thought of just another guy letting off steam. But, I meanwhile believe that Mr. Fauxhammer exposes a whole lot of common sense, and a true practical understanding of the matter. So, not ignoring a current sale, I am going for this printer.
I love this video, so very helpful. Fauxhammer, keep it up.
I got the normal mage printer and after 2 months the UV light has stopped working. Whole screen lights up, but just won't cure. That same resin taken straight from the vat cures fine with a UV torch. So strange, it completed the print before this issue with no problem and after sitting switched off for a few days it's just given up for no reason.
I find it interesting that no company really does both FDM and SLA good enough to be considered in the top choices.
FDM is Prusa, Creality, and Bambu, while SLA is Phrozen, Elegoo, and Anycubic.
Elegoo, Anycubic, and Creality do cross over, but seems they are better known for one lineup than the other.
Elegoo urinate from a great height on anything that Creality do in the FDM space.
Elegoo is pretty damn good on both and have great customer service in my experience with them.
Elegoo and Anycubic are doing pretty well with their FDM models lately
Yea not sure I'd put Creality in the same category as Prusa and Bambu.
Prusa do a very nice resin printer....although it is a tad expensive
well i like the idea of a lid hinge at least.
Me too
Canceled my order adn went with a M5S after seeing the shorts you made and trying (and returning) the non-pro version.
I'll have my m5s review up asap
@@FauxHammer YES PLEASE! :)
I, unfortunately, got swayed by the speed of printing and the 8K resolution.
Two days ago I received the printer I ordered.
The detaching resin dispenser filler looks quite frightening and the lack of possibility to reduce the print speed does not sound optimistic.
The print speed and print resolution at the promotional price of 2999RMB seemed like an unbeatable product.
I received a precision resin with the printer.
I haven't tested the printer yet, perhaps my printer will have improved software and a more intuitive interface.
I can share my experience with you.
I would love to heard your feedback
I saw nothing but good reviews until I bought this printer. It isn't even to my door yet & I am already learning about its issues.
Good luck,
Jeezzzzz, I'm now worried about my Anycubic Pre-order. Maybe I should get the Saturn 2 instead, if this is what the future is to bring.
I’m sure the M5s is fine, it’s not my choice fir innovation, but it will likely be a decent anycubic.
One of the problems that I see here is the improper attitude of the manufacturer to the material. Such high speeds require not only the correct exposure ratio but also a special resin formulation for printing. You can't just take the same resin and print several times (or dozens of times) faster. For such high-speed printers, Creality must develop the appropriate material!
In any case, thanks for the honest and informative review of the new Creality machine!!!
It's even worse. A customer can not be forced to only use those resins. The software must allow to print other resins as well, if only for different colors and transparency options. It's just having settings for a slower speed than 60mm/min!
14:00 Printing Titanic & hears a loud 'pop'
Wow… too soon man, too soon 😓
I own several Creality printer(including LD-002R which is working well). But the main FDM CR-10S Pro it was an absolute failure, starting with high amperage relay, proximity sensor and finishing with firmware(unusable). After replacing all that hardware the only way to use it was by updating firmware which was built by an US distributor (tinymachine3d). Without them all the money I've spent were for nothing. Needles to say the Creality support was useless. It seems to me they have no clue about the technical aspects of their products.
I got mine in March and have been waiting for the resin to go on sale. I emailed them and they responded. They said they don't know when the resin will go on sale. So annoying. By the time i get resin and test it out the warranty will probably be expired. My only other printer is a cr10 ver1. Its been great. But the halot mage is wrecking my good opinion of creality...
were any of these issues resolved? I'm considering buying this printer. Should I get the Halot One instead?
No, not even nearly resolved. Creality are not a resin brand, they are an FDM brand who made some resin printers.
Check out Elegoo
@@FauxHammer Thnx, I think I'll go with ELEGOO Saturn 3 Ultra + Anycubic Wash & Cure Max
This video seems to line up perfectly with what I would expect from Creality after buying my Ender 3 S1 Pro that somehow managed to print one really awesome print, and hasn't laid down a decent first layer since, despite hours of tweaking. I will never own another Creality product again. They just slap parts together with hopes and dreams, and seem to have a QC goal of "we're not in business to waste money on making sure products work for customers, all that matters is milking that name we created when we were almost the only game in town"
They are more the tinkerers machine. But having their app give you a 5s unskippable ad every time you open it screams if so much corporate greed that it ruins their whole appearance as a company
@@FauxHammer The whole "for tinkerers" was the general opinion that made me figure I would be fine, because I am a hard core tinkerer. But the problems I've had come down to the machine being inconsistent. Their QC is atrocious, but I guess at least their support is willing to basically ship you an entire printer one part at a time until the ones that shouldn't have ever left the assembly line eventually get replaced, lol
@@FlesHBoX wow, I do t know as I focus on covering the core functionalities, but that sounds atrocious
@@FauxHammer Yeah, the worst part is that I really only have myself to blame. I read through all of the posts talking about "we should stop recommending creality as a first printer" and all of the qc issues, and just figured I'd get lucky, lol
But I'll call it a slightly expensive learning opportunity. The next FDM printer I'll be buying is going to be along the lines of a Bambu X1C or Voron, or something, lol.
@@FlesHBoX we need to see something like the Bambu or the AnkerMake M5 in resin. So user friendly
한국에서 저프린터 구입해서 운용중입니다. 저도 저 영상처럼 레진주입기 팁이 부러져버렸는데 어찌 수리하나요..
I was planning on the saturn 2 and this model didn't help me change my mind
Your mind is on the right track IMO
I have one of these not the pro though , never used a resin printer before had absolutely no problems with it .
Apparently the non pro is ok
Its the same printer without the pump and a couple of extra’s
great machine , great review, i want to buy one too
if you think this is a great machine, I don't think you watched the review.
hi does anybody know if the firmware updates resolves some of mentioned problems ?
im stuck on chooosing Eleggo 4 Max or Creality Mage ( im big fan on creality fdm printers still using the cr10s )
Just dont know if Creality is a good company to start resin prints as mentioned in videao the are after all fdm company
the specs are tempting
This was my second printer and I have not had a successful print on it yet. Can’t figure out if it’s the resin, lvling, slicer or me.
I understand where you are coming from, I still don’t understand how the resin nozzle snaps off to identify exactly how it happens based on a certain sequence of events. I have seen a number other reviews of this printer did not have this issue, so there is obviously either a design defect or a workflow defect to cause the issue.
I would recommend you try the standard mage, it has all the features for menu layout that you are more used to with anycubic and Elegoo as it’s based on chitubox firmware, whereas the mage pro has the same firmware creality created and layout as the Halot one, which I have but get on with, but unfortunately you find it hugely frustrating in the pro.
I also level build plate with vat in place as I find it gives the most reliable printing results. With the pro print speed, a reviewer of the anycubic m5s discovered that he had layer separation and build plate adhesion issues until he counted the number of layers of the raft and increased the base layer number in the slicer to the same number of layers of the raft. This gives a slower start when max suction/adhesion with the raft can cause issues. This means you need to add a raft to your calibration models to get valid results. Crazy .
The filter must be broken on the printer you have as the mage I had for a short while suffered no such issue and it was held in place with no issues, and my printer had a huge dent and broken leg from being dropped in transit.
I think you’ll hate the mage pro as it doesn’t gel with your needs and I get that plus you say that at the beginning, but I really believe you will love the standard mage as it’s not as psychotic as the pro which is a rapid prototyping/development printer and creality are notorious for launching a printer with unfinished firmwares and software support which I found with the mage but it’s closer to what you are used to and will meet your needs and meet them well.
I’ve heard a lot of good things about the basic mage
I was pricing the Halot Mage and was tempted by the Pro, despite it being $200 more expensive where I can buy it. Now with this review of course it's not worth all the trouble just for speed, but the question is, does anyone have experience with the simple Halot Mage? 70mm/hr for the same resolution seems fine to me, plus it doesn't have resin pumping so that nozzle wouldn't be a problem.
Is the non pro version better.
Ok I subscribed to your channel. I like your in depth unbiased reviews. I LIKE THIS PRINTER. However I will not buy it
until they fix these problems. I would like to see what they do to fix the issues with yours. I am going to wait until november ish
before I pull the trigger on a printer so I hope they come back with a fix. These companies are in such a hurry to get the next
model out that they don't care if it works or not. Keep up the good work.....and maybe wear a helmet the next time you spin that exhaust tube....
dont listen to this confused man. i bought the halot mage pro 8k and its perfectly fine. works out of the box, with normal resin. i dont know what he is doing, but if you not like 5 year old, and take a little bit care, you wont destroy anything, i dont know how this can happen. also the filter fits well, and everything is in place. so if you are not a no-hands, this product is perfectly fine! and maybe dont use 5 year old resin, thats broken anyways lol. or the cheap one from aliexpress is propably also not the best choice. this video makes me angry, to think that ppl will not buy this super printer, just because he is disabled.
Not confused in the least. Bought the anycubic M5s. Makes great prints. I was only going off of what fauxhammer put out. So good luck with yours
THE LEVELING CARD IS IN THE SPARE FEP PACKET, NOT REALLY IDEAL AS YOU HAVE TO OPEN THE PACKET TO GET IT OUT
I'll be on the plane when it starts :(
I’ll keep it live for you when you land, safe flight
OMG. I didn't expect that. My brain exploded. It's like throwing all previous resin printing experience out the window. It's as if they were designing and building a 3D printer for the first time.
Thanks for the great material. I probably won't buy this model.
PS. Richard Dean Anderson, despite being 73 years old, still manages to do it. At the convention I managed to get a photo and an autograph.
I am one of the people disappointed in my Halot Mage printer. My touch screen died after 3 prints and it took two weeks of emails just to get to the replacement part start and they now say it will take 15 business days to receive it but have not given me any tracking info.
The LD-002H really feels like it's their most solid printer. Wish they didn't scrap all that for the Halot One
dont listen to this confused man. i bought the halot mage pro 8k and its perfectly fine. works out of the box, with normal resin. i dont know what he is doing, but if you not like 5 year old, and take a little bit care, you wont destroy anything, i dont know how this can happen. also the filter fits well, and everything is in place. so if you are not a no-hands, this product is perfectly fine! and maybe dont use 5 year old resin, thats broken anyways lol. or the cheap one from aliexpress is propably also not the best choice. this video makes me angry, to think that ppl will not buy this super printer, just because he is disabled.
@@Validity_TN Well that was a nonsense comment. Mine came out of level 'out of the box'. One side wasn't staying adhered. Leveled it, it printed fine until the final few layers it snagged the spout just like the reviewer and snapped off. Sure, if you get one that doesn't self destruct I imagine it's a great printer. But because *you* lucked out it MUST mean all these people with more experience than you had an issue because you know something they don't...
Mechanical issues happen and vary from item to item from the same assembly line. Get off your cross, wood's expensive
And here I thought Phrozen's Sonic Mini 4K was the best engineering trainwreck........ nope, this one takes the cake. Software Engineering Trainwreck, UX trainwreck, Firmware Trainwreck, and physical engineering trainwreck.. This one is... crazy. Known has "how to fail at everything, all at once".
Fair
So how do I keep from breaking the fill/drain nozzle
Prayer 🙏
So what’s crazy is I have the halot mage n the u.I. Looks way different n the build plate doesn’t seem to move that fast so maybe it’s just the pro?
seems so based on other comments too. I never had the basic.
I am on my 2 nd halot mage. Did not get the pro. on the first was one, a screw that mounts the bed bracket too the linear bearing blocks came out and fell in the tray during a print. It didn't break the screen but put a home in the film and resin ran out everywhere. My other issue is on the creality slicing software all the buttons and text is so small I can't read it on a 17in. Laptop. Adding supports is really confusing and I usually just push buttons until I get what I need.
ouch! sounds like not the best time with that one either then!
Ok, maybe this is a WELL KNOWN thing but why do you pour the resin over the build plate?
Only well known to viewers of other videos.
Because it’s more cinematic, that’s it
@@FauxHammer oh OK. I thought maybe there was a technical reason. 👍
@@Desmo904 nope, it’s my salt bae move