mich verwundert das eher. Selbst beim Heer in Österreich kommuniziert man in Englisch? Immerhin, besser als das Denglisch, was ich mir jeden Tag anhören muss... i was rather confused of the english slides. In the meantime i realized, there is an english spoken version of the clip. In my job, everybody communicates in a german-english mixture. English vocabulary is mainly used so give a professional appereance, and to hide lack of content. Simply awful, i hate it.
I agree with your comment! I would advise you to listen to: "The New Atlas" (not as technically detailed, a tad shewed against Ukraine but broadcasted by a former US Marine) "Scott Ritter News" (famous US weapons inspector, some hyperbole but better than the average). "The Duran" (Political analysis paired with some military assessments, mixed bag).
Many thanks Colonel, to you and your team in producing this video- and for producing it in English. As far as I'm aware, your videos on the Ukrainian conflict are the most objective and informative sources of information in English available today. Thanks again, sir.
@@Gary-Seven-and-Isis-in-1968 do you really think your cut&paste Russian bot, actually influences anybody? You're part of the reason most people support Ukraine. 😂
There's a few good sources. Each has a different speciality and bias. But without a doubt the videos made here have been exceptional, the guy absolutely knows what he is talking about (as one should expect from a Major), and the bias has been kept to a minimum. It's nice to see it correlates well with other good sources I've seen so that always helps inspire confidence.
@Манька Облигация You have ZERO proof that the Maternity hospital was being used as a Army HQ. You saw the video of the blood soaked beds and killed women. But you continue to support Putin's narrative. I hope you enjoy your life under Putin's regime while you still can.
@CtrlAltDelicious69 I'm one of those guys CtrlAltDouche. But hey, any day now Russia is going to finish taking Sievierodonetsk, a city Gucci boot general Kardyrov said Russia took on May 28th. And it only took them regrouping all of their forces, so I could be totally wrong.
The only serious presentation from an official source. No sensationalism, sob stories and fearmongering. Excellent work! Also as a Greek I have to give you thumbs up for using the correct plural form of the word ''dilemma''.
as a Russian anti-fascist, it’s unpleasant for me to look about Ukrainian Nazis and terrorists, but I must pay tribute to the fact that there is a rather high level of information for a Western source.
@Манька Облигация of all the pro-russian liers on internet media you are by far the biggest liar of them all. Personally, in Syria I was quite happy to destroy the incompetent Russian forces. So very many burning in hell..You are a troll.
All these sounds like russian government channel. "Don't supply any weapons this is usless". Proofs are 20 captured rpgs in winter time and 1 destroyed howitzer. + bot comments + video slides on russian )
@@nibi144 all this sounds like ur Ukranian fanboy. "Proofs are 20 captured" . Russian telegram channels publish captured javelins, stingers and etc every day, it’s not only 1 howitzer, they publish destroyed Australian armored vehicles, Norwegian artillery systems and i even dont talk about Ukranian vechiles. You just don’t see them because you watch Ukrainian twitter
The presentation made by the Austrians is literally a University class. The material, presentation and methodology is giving a class to the rest of the world on how wars should be documented and archived. The format is flawless. Everything is in exhaustive detail. In these 12 minutes you collected and provided precise information more accurate than many other sources. The level of intelligence is high. This is exactly what allies does. They support each other and they throw in the harshest critique to the allied forces. Only this way we stop committing mistakes. This is a luxury that DEMOCRACY has.
Austria's military is NOT an ally, they are NOT part of NATO."Only this way we stop committing mistakes"??? Dude this basic OSINT briefing does nothing, nor do the civilians who watch this "prevent """committing"""" mistakes" because they are at home sitting on their asses, watching this does not make you a general. OMG!?!??
Thanks for making more videos in English! Your videos are the best and the clearest analysis about the war in the entire internet. Austria must be very proud of you!
Yes I agree. The presentation is concise, logical and credible, and perhaps most importantly it is delivered in such a way as to make it easily understood by the layman such as me.
From a country that hasn't ran a military operation since ww1 and isn't a part of any military alliance or joint training drill. 🤔 I'm not sure he knows what he's talking about...
@@First-Last_name It is just not true! Just as Switzerland or Finland until recently, Austria has an army which isn't great, but it there are good people there, at least one ;). Your argument is meaningless, because war is won by strategy not by individual battle prowess.
@@vt2788 how can they test their strategy if they are in their own little bubble and have no real world experience. It's all theory and idealism in an echo chamber. Finland has been part of joint training exercises with NATO and has been a major non member NATO allie since like 2000. Switzerlands military is also a joke 🪖 Austria has no experience and no clue in military matters. Might as well ask a guy from the Paint ball battle field his opinion on strategy and tactics.
Thanks so much for taking the time to provide this information in English without sensationalism. The only channel that is sober assessment of the situation. Always a pleasure to watch your videos!
You guys have some truly outstanding material, literally University quality. I did not know about the Theresian Academy before finding these videos about Ukraine. Thank you for making this content available!
as a Russian anti-fascist, it’s unpleasant for me to look about Ukrainian Nazis and terrorists, but I must pay tribute to the fact that there is a rather high level of information for a Western source.
@@ruthlesstruth8639 dont get me wrong mate you dont seem stupid and obviously both sides use propaganda But do you truly think Russia is innocent and fighting the good fight in this war? these guys are your brothers, I cant imagine fighting against Germany as an Austrian, no matter our differences it would be like fighting my own brother And nazis, do you realize what a nazi is? killing rebels is bad, dont get me wrong - but nazis? last time I checked the ukrainians didnt gas jews, minorities nor did they build labour camps If killing rebels in your own country makes you a nazi what is Russia then? Do I have to remind you what happened in chechnya?
Another great video from Dr. Reisner! Not just detailed and packed with important information, but succinct and fun to watch as well (short videos, diagrams, etc.) Due to his in-depth knowledge, professional demeanor, good English, and profound presentation skills, it is hard not to like the Colonel and his lectures. Keep up the great work! 👍👏
I'm very happy to see the Austrian military contributing to my understanding of current events in Ukraine! You're doing what many news outlets aren't reporting, Col. Reisner!
@@Gary-Seven-and-Isis-in-1968 do you really think your cut&paste Russian bot, actually influences anybody? You're part of the reason most people support Ukraine. 😂
Normally it's well done, but in this case please have attention to 3:22 and 11:25. There is a huge informational/source mistake that shouldn't be. Especially not for a military academy nor for the austrian standard. I would say this is not the normal case. And this is not the requirement case for the academy.
Colonel , your English information videos on the Russian invasion of Ukraine are one of the most informative available on the Internet, keep up your vital Work , Slava Ukraini
Excellent detailed presentation of the battle. Thanks for taking special efforts to give the world this incisive information. Keep up the great work. May God bless ya.
I’m learning a lot from this Colonel. I had no idea War was this complicated and complex. War is a game of Strategy and if you commit your pieces in the wrong places you won’t win. So someone has to coordinate the War Strategy. In order to win.
Perun youtube channel gives fascinating long lectures without much illustration - treat like a podcast. I recommend an early one (his first ones are gaming, then he switched recently to war: one of the first or the first war ones) about 'how are volunteers helping the Ukrainian army', or - very interesting in fact - the recent one on Poland. The volunteers & reservists one is very interesting on what you need
Your videos with analyzing war in Ukraine are the best, I've never seen anything so precise and objective. I tell you that as Ukrainian citizen, who watch and read different sources and experts all the time. Thank you, colonel.
I would like to say that your assessment of the War in Ukraine is by far the best delivery of information there is. I would also like to say that there is no updated information what so ever as what you present here. I am looking foward to more upadates of the War in Ukraine. Thank you so much
I really am enjoying your videos. I’ve shared with my friends that don’t have military experience so they understand a little more. Please keep the videos coming👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Best military information about what really is happening. Propaganda has it's place, nothing beats pure cold hard facts about the overall situation and not being emotional about the evaluation. Thankyou for this information Colonel
Colonel, your series is without at doubt the best presentation of its type I have found. You break things down into easy to understand pieces and show very well how they all relate. Please keep up the great work. Best of luck to you on your new command of the honor guard. They are in capable hands.
I eagerly await English language briefings.Your explanations are highly valued for their clear exposition of all those pertinent aspects dealing with the complex and complicated realities of modern warfare.Thank you sir.
First, outstanding briefing. You are a professional. Being an old cold war Fulda Gap cavalryman, I value your insights. The war in Ukraine is the one that didn't happen to me. This is a very large request, but please produce more of the briefings in English unless there is a way to have the translation in closed captioning. Thank you for your service to your country and the information you provide.
on TH-cam you can translate the German briefings using the TH-cam auto translate and its actually pretty solid - click on the gear symbol on the bottom right of the video player and you'll see it
All these sounds like russian government channel. "Don't supply any weapons this is usless". Proofs are 20 captured rpgs in winter time and 1 destroyed howitzer. + bot comments + video slides on russian )
My father was stationed at the Fulda Gap with the U.S Army in 1951-52. He participated in "Exercise Northwind " which was meant to simulate our reaction in the aftermath to a limited USSR nuke strike on our troops.
@@nibi144 Ahh yes, the Notoriously pro-Russian Austrian Military Academy... Maybe, just maybe, hearing anything other than the propaganda tales of glory and victory by Ukraine is just too hard to process for some.
Now many ukroids are saying that this is a russian propaganda channel and Austria is a puppet russian state. Everything that doesn't kiss their @ss is russian apparently
I think it's quite up to date. There's more stuff promised, but that's not present on the battlefield yet. There are two things this Austrian colonel got wrong: 1. Poland has promised to send 200 T-72. 2. The Netherlands has promised to deliver 6 PzH2000 together with the Germans. The Dutch ones will be delivered 100%, it's up to the Germans if they do their part.
This man has a pointed head for one reason, he is a Russian agent so please take everything he says like you heard it from Putin himself. Austria is pro German who in turn are pro Putin. Quite obvious isn't it. BTW have fun in trying to recognise the pro Russian comments here. Yeah, the ones swearing undying admiration for this Austrian guy.. You got it... 😂
@@evazampa1237 Hm die Frage ist was er gesagt hat :D Ja ich hab das Video gesehen, nur wer ist am gewinnen? Btw ich kenn die Antwort die Frage ist ob sie sie kennen oder aus diesem Video ableiten können.
Thanks for the great video. Just a small clarification/correction: Those 36 km for the PzH 2000 mentioned there are achived using the old DM121 Boattail ammo. CAESAR's 40 km of range are achieved using a newer basebleed round. With a M1711 Basebleed round, the PzH 2000 can achieve 47km and with a M2005 V-LAP round 67km.
@@roryross3878 First a mix of DM121 and DM131, eventually they can get any 155mm shell they want if they decide they want to continue using this system and order more. It's probably going to take half a year until Rheinmetall's consortium can ramp up the production, but after that everything is possible.
@@neilreynolds3858 Appreciate your note. Quick question: Do you know the last time US forces faced mased fires like this? I've polled friends with Vietnam, Bosnia, sandbox, etc. experience, but haven't heard about anything comparable to Ukraine. In any case, all the best
@@danapeck5382 Good question. WWI? The Bulge in WW2? It says the Germans had 1900 to 2600 tubes there. They also had Stgs and Panzers. That sounds hellish. The guy in my family who was at Bastogne didn't talk much but I don't think Bastogne was even the worst thing he'd seen.
I don't know if it's only the media but so far it seems like the 4 pieces of HIMARS have made a huge impact on the battlefield since they achieve objectives easily.
Always great to see your analysis, thanks for taking the time to film them in English. One issue with holding the reinforcements back is that Russia is constantly targeting the depots of foreign weapons. Trying to amass a bigger force of foreign weapons anywhere inside Ukraine territory will probably mean they'll be destroyed before even entering any sort of combat mission.
Did you see that video yesterday of Ukraine's absolute demolition of Russians artillery depot behind the Russian lines? Here's a video th-cam.com/users/shortsnYcreDbk_hU
Member when Russia said they destroyed the Ukrainian airforce, and yet Ukrainian SU25s were flying combat missions on 6/16/2022 (sorry, videos are on Twitter/Telegram not TH-cam)? I member 🍇🍇🍇🍇th-cam.com/video/hHJhu15f-hg/w-d-xo.html
Also is Ukrainian army coordinated and competent enough to do successful counter-attacks? why not just grind down Russia and force them to retreat by death by a thousand cuts.
@@camus83489 they will not able ever to counter attack, to be able to counter attack you will need to have more forces that the enemy in ratio like 4:1 or 3:1 and ukrainians will never had that, all teritory that russian captured is never going to taken back and that is huge problem
Colonel, you are a very dynamic speaker with an incredible grasp of all things military. Austria’s armed forces should be proud that you are one of their leaders! Thank you for the presentation!
Thank you Colonel, for your excellent brief! I imagine that the Ukrainian command is aware that using heavy weapons in "penny packets" is not an ideal employment of resources. But if I was them, I would prefer to lose a few heavy weapons if it meant saving a battalion of good soldiers. And these heavy weapons are trickling in, rather than flooding in. So it may take considerable time-perhaps months, to accumulate sufficient, well equipped forces for operational level counter-attacks, and Ukraine might not have that long, although they are conducting a superb defence so far. Besides, without air superiority, dense masses of equipment could be subject to considerable attrition from the air.
@@iche9373 Rank doesn't matter. What matters is what and how he speaks about the situation in Ukraine. I've seen much higher officers talking nonsense.
Please check characteristic of the Polish Krab howitzer (18 delivered and already used on the front). They are very modern and one of the best in his class. 40 km range. Additionally please notice that as far as I know Poland already delivered over 260 tanks.
@@Gary-Seven-and-Isis-in-1968 You see a Cyrillic message & you automatically think it's an OrcBot? Translate the message first, THEN maybe shoot after!🤔
Dear Dr. Markus. It is a true opportunity for us operators to hear the professional analysis presented by you and your excellent academy. Sometimes we forget the science behind our craft. I look forward to each and every one of your excellent interventions. Truly yours, Alfredo Cara. Telecom. Eng.
Latest numbers (17 June 2022) about the losses of the Ukrainian armed forces according to the MoD of Russia, take it as you will: - 205 airplanes - 131 helicopters - 1,233 unmanned aerial vehicles - 342 anti-aircraft systems - 3,587 tanks and other armoured combat vehicles - 539 multiple launch rocket systems - 2,013 field artillery and mortars - 3,658 other military ground vehicles Even if only half of these were true (I guess most of them are) the western supplies Ukraine has received so far are not making any real difference in the grand picture. But of course those deliveries will have to be replaced eventually, and that will make some people very... $atisfied. The numbers shown at 1:13 are the ones "combat ready as of 24.02.2022", and does not include equipment in storage or deliveries since then.
As for the MLRS and Missile Forces of the Russian Federation, to be more precise: Depending on the type of ammunition (in brackets () types of shells): 1. BM-21 "Grad" caliber 122 mm - 33-40-42 km; 2.9K57 "Hurricane" caliber 220 mm - 13-34-35 km; 3.9K58 "Smerch" caliber 300mm - 70km (9M55F) -90km (9M528, 9M534) -120 km (9M542); 4.9K720 "Iskander" - 480 km (9M723) - 500 km (9M728); 5.3K55 "Bastion" - 300 km ("Onyx") -800 km ("Onyx-M"); Rockets 3K55 "Bastion" can fire at surface and ground targets. What else is being fired at Ukraine: 6. Tu-160, Tu-95MS - 2000 km (X-55) - 3500 km (X-55SM) - 5500 km (X-101);
MLRS are great at shooting at the rough enemy area, but since the first MLRS are deployed Ukranian civilians lament that they now are also being shot from their own country. I also don't understand why those people didn't flee a hot zone when every european neighbour promised them free living. Man, old people can be stubborn. MLRS have great range, but are very inaccurate, Russia still can target the western Ukranian area by firing 20 rockets in a general direction. In the end advanced artillery and drones are going to win this conflict and here I am with Ukraine (although western shippments arrive in the next weeks), training Ukrainians with western weapon systems should have happened in March
@@fatalityin1 is there any way of preventing NLAWs & Javelins from falling into enemy hands? Can't they be fired or destroyed before withdrawing? The manufacturers should design an "auto destruct" feature that can be triggered remotely. Excuse my ignorance on the subject as I have no military expertise.
I don't think russia uses much precision weapons as they just flatten & destroy anything. Also the cruise missiles fired at Ukraine are often shot down now, not "seldom" as the colonel said. Heard even manpads can shoot them. russia will be running out of that kinda of precision missiles too.
@@jacqdanieles Javelin isn't a cheap weapon (178.000$ and 78.000$ for each replacement missile). Adding a self-destruct feature will only make it even more expensive and risky to operate. By laying it on the ground and putting an ordinary hand grenade under it and removing the safety pin you can make a simple mine-trap.
@@bekeneel , Too stupid statements about shooting down cruise missiles, despite the fact that they are fired at several dozen a day every day from the beginning of the war and to this day. And the fact that they are shot down a lot, so this is nonsense! Either give me statistics on the areas under fire and the number of Ukrainian air defense crews and their types of air defense in their composition, or you are just an idiot. As for the types of modern ammunition, the Krasnopol projectile (laser-guided reactive ammunition for a 152 mm cannon), which was shown even on British channels, was shown 40 times on the video of howitzers of the Russian Federation leaked by the crews themselves. They showed firing anti-radar missiles, TV-guided missiles (and also on British channels), they showed the work of Onyx-M, dozens of calibers arrive at the target every day (frames from local residents of Ukraine, which they send to their Ukrainian channels in a telegram). The Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation showed footage 5 times of firing 9M542 tornado projectiles at targets and their destruction. The fact that you see little does not mean that it does not exist, take into account the economic saturation of the reserves of the Russian Federation due to sanctions, which fully pays for the costs of the war in Ukraine and allows you to switch to increased production rates.
Am extremely happy about the information you are giving us, we pray that all these weapons will be utilised efficiently and accurately to change the tide of the battle. I am extremely grateful for sharing this information. This message has shed more light on the issue of weapons, engagements and safety of the Ukrainian warriors. I am absolutely sure that General Zelensky will try to provide more defensive driving Artilleries missiles systems in the nearest future. Thank you. I am enjoying this beautiful information about the situation of the War in Ukraine. God bless. W.B.A
3:27 take a note at the 4th picture, these tanks are already captured by Russians, that last picture is actually picture that Russians shared on Telegram, it's the serial number of a tank that was delivered from West
Many thanks for the update. It gives a good picture of how the situation is in Ukrain. And sadly we dont get this anymore on a daily base in the Netherlands. The conflict has moved from the headlines wich makes it harder to get good information
4:40 Poland supplied not M109 howitzers but 18 pieces of much more modern (and better) polish made AHS Krab self propelled howitzers, the info is there written but for whatever reason (?) you grouped those. What's important Krab does not need rocket propelled shells (like M109 do) to reach 40 km distance.
@@comayhem Exactly. Not only no mention about "Gozdzik", also amount of T-72's already delivered is wrong. I wonder if it's simply lack of professionalism or a matter of realising some kind of political agenda.
100 is the approximate number of T-72M1R. The so-called "modified" T-72M/M1. Around 120 pieces of the T-72M/M1 tanks were transferred to Ukraine. These are not yet on the front line since Ukrainians fit it with their own MGs and ERA array. 2S1 Gvozdika SPGs sent in a number of 20+. BM-21 20+ as well. BWP-1s from Poland are already in use in Ukraine - 40 pieces. 18 pieces of KRAB artillery, a modern 155mm SPG that can shoot 4-5 rounds in fast reload mode, so the shells get into the target in the same exact second. At that time, the KRAB is already changing its fire position. Further 50x will show in Ukraine very soon. These numbers are not symbolic, but the most important thing is that the equipment went to Ukraine fast. Just when most needed. It took a few days from the talks to delivery.
@@HanSolo__ To be more precise Poland send 80 T-72M1R which after "R" mod are quite decent asset, and importantly have refreshed service life - those are practically new tanks. The rest of T-72 send by Poland (~150 of those) are unmodified, used T-72M1. By mentioning BM-1 you meant BM-21 Grad MLRS?
Excellent. You have encapsulated what every open-minded person knows, and have articulated it very clearly. This is the reason why Ukraine continues to be pushed back. I don’t see it changing…but it could.
All these sounds like russian government channel. "Don't supply any weapons this is usless". Proofs are 20 captured rpgs in winter time and 1 destroyed howitzer. + bot comments + video slides on russian )
@@nibi144 Lol wut. The presentation was about how the Ukrainians need more equipment, and how the weapons delivered so far are not enough to turn the tide of the war. Far from arguing that supplying weapons is "useless," the presenter is saying that the West needs to provide Ukraine with much more weapons if they want to help them win the war. One slide was in Russian, which is a language that is also used extensively in Ukraine, including by millions of people opposed to the Russian invasion, and many who are actively fighting for Ukraine. At no time are "20 captured rpgs" shown in this video, nor does it appear to be winter in the clip. It shows five captured Javelins, and a handful of other anti-tank weapons that are difficult to identify. The vast majority of comments on this video are positive, and pro-Ukraine. So basically pretty much every point in your comment is wrong in some way. Next time, actually watch the video and try listening to what is being said.
@@zvexevz presentation is match more about "useless" (do it on purpose?). Author said that it is useless to send equipment unless ukraine stop to lose it, forgetting (do it on purpose?) that is not a counter terrorist operation it is real war with huge losses of people and equipment and russia for example lost cruiser moscow and losing much more equipment. Russian language military slides make only russian military. And its very old video from february or march about capturing 20 Javelins, nlaws and Panzerfaust 3 (see winter clothes). Orlan 10 drop granades near howitzer - not very impressive. Now 4 months have passed and west continue to bla bla bla. On place of ukranians i won't fight at all with such treatment.
@@nibi144 Oh yeah. The old good "don't report bad news from Ukraine, if you say that Ukraine is not crushing the Russian army you are a russian bot". Mate, have a look at reality, Ukraine getting smaller by the day. Slowly, but steadily. Russia has not even declared general mobilisation yet. If the Russians really start having problems at the battlefield it will show. For the moment they're just sitting back at shell Ukrainian troops from a safe distance.
@@wforweed665 there is mobilization in donbas (poor people with no choice). mobilization in russia is very dangerous for russia because a lot of people dont support this war. T 62 and BMP 1 - are modern russian equipment really no problem?
The only way around a slow and hugely costly defeat (in terms of human lives lost) is for NATO to supply the levels requested by Ukraine, but they won’t because (a) they don’t want to risk the possible consequences of such massive escalation, and (b) frankly NATO weapons stockpiles (especially of artillery ammunition) are simply too low, and countries would diminish their own defensive capabilities too much.
Another problem is the logistical tail. People have to be trained to supply and repair gear. Russia's logistical tail is so short that Russians have had to abandon gear that broke down for a variety of reasons. The U.S. has stopped using its tanks so M1A2 tanks plus older M60 tanks could be sent to Ukraine, but then hundreds of Ukrainians would have to be trained to use and repair the tanks while yet another logistical line has to be sent to arm and refuel the beasts.
@@orlock20 There is no way that M1A2 Abrams will be sent to Ukraine. If it gets destroyed it won't look good or even worse - if it gets captured by Russians. That would be a disaster.
@@Bee.Holder The M1A2 is old technology. The U.S. Marines aren't even using it. Even if the Russians were to get one, there isn't much the Russians and Chinese can do with it since Russia and China have the gun stabilizer and neither can afford putting thermal sights on their tanks.
Germany's military is in the dumpster and has been for years. Those artillery pieces probably had to be repaired and the ammunition made before the Ukrainians could train on them.
Today, the commander of the logistics of the ground forces of Ukraine, Volodymyr Karpenko, said that the Armed Forces of Ukraine lost 50% of heavy weapons ..... I think that in reality the losses are more than 70%. Kyiv officially acknowledged the loss of 2,500 heavy weapons. This means that Western assistance with weapons is very small, and will not help Ukraine.
Russia is in bad shape too and has been forced to use civilian vehicles to move men and supplies around. These vehicles aren't powerful enough to move artillery. Most of Russian's aircraft are paperweights in hangers. Once those trains are targeted, Russia's supplies will ground to a halt.
@@orlock20 I live on the border of the war zone with Ukraine, I constantly see the traffic of the Russian army. These are special combat vehicles and in most cases new ones. I have never seen the use of civilian transport. Also aviation, there hasn't been a minute in the last 3 months. so that planes do not fly over our city, and planes are in the air day and night, we are already used to their roar. These are SU-30 and SU-27 or SU-35 (they are similar) sometimes IL 76 or AN 125, I don't think that old planes are capable of such intensive flights.
I’m a bit suprised that you got mixed up M109 from Norway with Krab from Poland, which are completly different systems with rather different characteristics (range included). Missed part about the contract for over 50 of Krabs as well. Also, are those lower numbers on tanks from Poland verified?
Talk is cheap activities on ground is what matters, you can have all the best sophisticated equipment but if you have a rag tag outfit like Ukraine your equipment is useless. Seconly, Ukraine is not a superpower there lies the difference even nazi Germany took on the whole world
@@zcomme It's not that I want to nitpick on some gun or whatever, all in all it's very good presentation in terms of long term effect of deliveries. Especially piecemeal use of new eqiupment is important, although it's hard to discuss "piecemeal vs. strategic reserve", when whole delivery is 7 or 12 guns. There ARE categories though, where deliveries were significant - i.e. Poland and Czech tanks (250+ total) or incoming Krab delivery (with the ones delivered, it's over 60 modern long range, very mobile artillery), so I'm curious, what will be the use of those.
Der Freund wird bald ein weibliches Genitalorgan haben, aber das weiß noch niemand. Der russische kann nicht mit dem Wort gewinnen. Ich denke, die Pindos werden es schaffen. Die Allerhöchsten kamen von der anderen Seite. Russisch wird alle langsam ficken!
that was uncomonly informative and understandable for the layman. this really makes me genuinly concerned about the amount of help the military vehicles sent by other counties to the ukraine will actually be. i'm not sure itll be enough at all, despite whatever good intentions may be. most news ive seen in the past few weeks has been optomistic about the ukraine, but now i'm not so sure. IF russaian forces were so poor in terms of equiptment, supplies and training as i had been led to believe (due to systemic corrpution, poor maintance, and other factors) then i dont see how they'd have been able to hold on this long, much less make further gains no matter how slowly. i would really like this matter cleared up, if that was possible.
You’re not sure it will be enough??? It’s getting destroyed faster than it can be used and is pointless wasting any more tax payers money on this senseless war.
The news are optimistic for Ukraine since they are still resisting. That is a miracle in itself. The Russian army is plagued by corruption, incompetence and poor equipment. However, it's still a far larger and stronger force. If they were competent and professional they would have taken over the Donbas months ago. They are still slowly advancing by virtue of being such a powerful force and literally leveling whole cities with artillery and bombing. The positive news doesn't mean Ukraine's winning but rather that they are not getting crushed. And that in itself is a win. Every day that they are resisting is a win.
@@alexwallachian7720 of course the news outlets are optimistic for the "good" side. stands to reason. doesnt mean i believe the retoric. i believe in facts.
@@davidtal523 well it's not really about good or bad side but rather david vs goliath. It's like in the Finnish-Soviet war. The Finns won lots of victories and kept the Soviets back for a lot longer than anyone expected but they were never going to defeat the USSR. Same with Ukraine. They held back the Russians a lot more than anyone would have ever dreamed and even managed to push them back from their capital. Hence the optimistic news. But I don't think anyone expects Ukraine to actually defeat the Russian army.
![ไปอยู่ไสมา - ช๊อปเปอร์ โตเกียวมิวสิค [ OFFICIAL MUSIC VIDEO ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/sWuVNbRTJbc/mqdefault.jpg)
Thanks so much for publishing these in English, you guys are the best commentary I can find so far so please keep doing them!
Thank u
mich verwundert das eher. Selbst beim Heer in Österreich kommuniziert man in Englisch?
Immerhin, besser als das Denglisch, was ich mir jeden Tag anhören muss...
i was rather confused of the english slides. In the meantime i realized, there is an english spoken version of the clip.
In my job, everybody communicates in a german-english mixture. English vocabulary is mainly used so give a professional appereance, and to hide lack of content. Simply awful, i hate it.
Thank you. All we get in America is retired generals saying whatever CNN wants them to say.
@@rlambo4817 ... you guys get to hear what Raytheon and Lockheed Martin want them to say. As do we in Europe.
I agree with your comment!
I would advise you to listen to:
"The New Atlas" (not as technically detailed, a tad shewed against Ukraine but broadcasted by a former US Marine)
"Scott Ritter News" (famous US weapons inspector, some hyperbole but better than the average).
"The Duran" (Political analysis paired with some military assessments, mixed bag).
Many thanks Colonel, to you and your team in producing this video- and for producing it in English. As far as I'm aware, your videos on the Ukrainian conflict are the most objective and informative sources of information in English available today. Thanks again, sir.
You mean propaganda to serve every level of easily fooled?
@@Gary-Seven-and-Isis-in-1968 do you really think your cut&paste Russian bot, actually influences anybody? You're part of the reason most people support Ukraine. 😂
There's a few good sources. Each has a different speciality and bias. But without a doubt the videos made here have been exceptional, the guy absolutely knows what he is talking about (as one should expect from a Major), and the bias has been kept to a minimum. It's nice to see it correlates well with other good sources I've seen so that always helps inspire confidence.
@Манька Облигация You have ZERO proof that the Maternity hospital was being used as a Army HQ.
You saw the video of the blood soaked beds and killed women. But you continue to support Putin's narrative. I hope you enjoy your life under Putin's regime while you still can.
@CtrlAltDelicious69 I'm one of those guys CtrlAltDouche. But hey, any day now Russia is going to finish taking Sievierodonetsk, a city Gucci boot general Kardyrov said Russia took on May 28th. And it only took them regrouping all of their forces, so I could be totally wrong.
The only serious presentation from an official source. No sensationalism, sob stories and fearmongering. Excellent work! Also as a Greek I have to give you thumbs up for using the correct plural form of the word ''dilemma''.
Indeed, he said 'dilemmata'. Well done Sir
as a Russian anti-fascist, it’s unpleasant for me to look about Ukrainian Nazis and terrorists, but I must pay tribute to the fact that there is a rather high level of information for a Western source.
@@betasgr Correct Greek, but incorrect English
@@ruthlesstruth8639 As an American anti-fascist, I agree wholeheartedly.
@@NuisanceMan what would be correct English for that?
Delighted to watch this dispassionate account of the war in the Ukraine. Thanks very much Colonel...
Go live is Russia.
@Манька Облигация of all the pro-russian liers on internet media you are by far the biggest liar of them all. Personally, in Syria I was quite happy to destroy the incompetent Russian forces. So very many burning in hell..You are a troll.
Sir, it's not Colonel, it's Captain Austria.
@@iche9373 I stand corrected...thanks...!
@Манька Облигация маня не неси єрунди , а покажи відео якщо зможеж , але тине покажеж бо його не існує
The internet has lack of this kind of professional analysis. Please continious this your hard work.
There are bits and pieces that one can put together in a package.
All these sounds like russian government channel.
"Don't supply any weapons this is usless".
Proofs are 20 captured rpgs in winter time and 1 destroyed howitzer.
+ bot comments
+ video slides on russian )
@@nibi144 all this sounds like ur Ukranian fanboy.
"Proofs are 20 captured" . Russian telegram channels publish captured javelins, stingers and etc every day, it’s not only 1 howitzer, they publish destroyed Australian armored vehicles, Norwegian artillery systems and i even dont talk about Ukranian vechiles. You just don’t see them because you watch Ukrainian twitter
@@nibi144 All the news that you don't want to hear is always "Russian bots and russian government control channel" for you
@@KappaClauss twitter in russia doesn t work). Ukraine shows destroyed russian war ships )
The presentation made by the Austrians is literally a University class. The material, presentation and methodology is giving a class to the rest of the world on how wars should be documented and archived.
The format is flawless. Everything is in exhaustive detail. In these 12 minutes you collected and provided precise information more accurate than many other sources.
The level of intelligence is high. This is exactly what allies does. They support each other and they throw in the harshest critique to the allied forces. Only this way we stop committing mistakes. This is a luxury that DEMOCRACY has.
Austria's military is NOT an ally, they are NOT part of NATO."Only this way we stop committing mistakes"??? Dude this basic OSINT briefing does nothing, nor do the civilians who watch this "prevent """committing"""" mistakes" because they are at home sitting on their asses, watching this does not make you a general. OMG!?!??
Someone totaly ignored capabilities and numbers of Krab artylery. Anti-Polonism still strong on the west.
Thanks for making more videos in English! Your videos are the best and the clearest analysis about the war in the entire internet. Austria must be very proud of you!
Yes I agree. The presentation is concise, logical and credible, and perhaps most importantly it is delivered in such a way as to make it easily understood by the layman such as me.
We are proud and surprised too ;) . We are definitely not a military power, maybe only an intellectual one
From a country that hasn't ran a military operation since ww1 and isn't a part of any military alliance or joint training drill. 🤔
I'm not sure he knows what he's talking about...
@@First-Last_name It is just not true! Just as Switzerland or Finland until recently, Austria has an army which isn't great, but it there are good people there, at least one ;). Your argument is meaningless, because war is won by strategy not by individual battle prowess.
@@vt2788 how can they test their strategy if they are in their own little bubble and have no real world experience. It's all theory and idealism in an echo chamber.
Finland has been part of joint training exercises with NATO and has been a major non member NATO allie since like 2000. Switzerlands military is also a joke 🪖
Austria has no experience and no clue in military matters. Might as well ask a guy from the Paint ball battle field his opinion on strategy and tactics.
Thanks so much for taking the time to provide this information in English without sensationalism. The only channel that is sober assessment of the situation. Always a pleasure to watch your videos!
The Duran
The new atlas
Patrick Lancaster
Perun channel
You guys have some truly outstanding material, literally University quality. I did not know about the Theresian Academy before finding these videos about Ukraine. Thank you for making this content available!
as a Russian anti-fascist, it’s unpleasant for me to look about Ukrainian Nazis and terrorists, but I must pay tribute to the fact that there is a rather high level of information for a Western source.
@@ruthlesstruth8639 dont get me wrong mate you dont seem stupid and obviously both sides use propaganda
But do you truly think Russia is innocent and fighting the good fight in this war? these guys are your brothers, I cant imagine fighting against Germany as an Austrian, no matter our differences it would be like fighting my own brother
And nazis, do you realize what a nazi is? killing rebels is bad, dont get me wrong - but nazis? last time I checked the ukrainians didnt gas jews, minorities nor did they build labour camps
If killing rebels in your own country makes you a nazi what is Russia then? Do I have to remind you what happened in chechnya?
Another great video from Dr. Reisner! Not just detailed and packed with important information, but succinct and fun to watch as well (short videos, diagrams, etc.) Due to his in-depth knowledge, professional demeanor, good English, and profound presentation skills, it is hard not to like the Colonel and his lectures. Keep up the great work! 👍👏
Best analysis on youtube, straight to the military facts with no politics. I love this channel, thank you so much from Latin America!
It's like taking a class taught by Arnold! Thanks for uploading these... your accent is amazing!
^^)) Dey vill be pack!
I'm very happy to see the Austrian military contributing to my understanding of current events in Ukraine! You're doing what many news outlets aren't reporting, Col. Reisner!
World class intel brief. Very professionally done, and I appreciate you having them in both English, and German.
Anglo-Saxon
Incredibly well prepared and presented with commentary and visuals that serve every level of audience. Well done.
You mean propaganda to serve every level of easily fooled?
@@Gary-Seven-and-Isis-in-1968 do you really think your cut&paste Russian bot, actually influences anybody? You're part of the reason most people support Ukraine. 😂
@@gregwilliamson3001 I'm with you. USN Gulf War vet. Slava Ukraini!
Normally it's well done, but in this case please have attention to 3:22 and 11:25. There is a huge informational/source mistake that shouldn't be. Especially not for a military academy nor for the austrian standard.
I would say this is not the normal case. And this is not the requirement case for the academy.
@@maas2198 please enlighten the rest of us. You've quoted the time stamp without pointing out the "mistakes"
Colonel , your English information videos on the Russian invasion of Ukraine are one of the most informative available on the Internet, keep up your vital Work , Slava Ukraini
Thank you for the overview, Markus. Keep them coming.
One of the best sources of information I've seen about the war in Ukraine. Thanks, and Subscribed to your channel.
Excellent detailed presentation of the battle. Thanks for taking special efforts to give the world this incisive information. Keep up the great work. May God bless ya.
I’m learning a lot from this Colonel. I had no idea War was this complicated and complex. War is a game of Strategy and if you commit your pieces in the wrong places you won’t win. So someone has to coordinate the War Strategy. In order to win.
Perun youtube channel gives fascinating long lectures without much illustration - treat like a podcast. I recommend an early one (his first ones are gaming, then he switched recently to war: one of the first or the first war ones) about 'how are volunteers helping the Ukrainian army', or - very interesting in fact - the recent one on Poland. The volunteers & reservists one is very interesting on what you need
Thank you, Colonel! Wow, I find your channel very enlightening and detailed. More power to you and your team, sir! Respect from Taiwan!!
Sir, it's not Colonel, it's Captain Austria.
Thank you, I really enjoy this channel. I appreciate the extra work to make this in English! Love from the American South
Great insight from a professional and doesn't seem to be bias, thanks for doing twice the work and speaking in English as well
Fantastic presentation and one of the clearest I can recall in many years of military and government service. Danke!
"Dilemata" - now this is a man of culture and learning
It sounds very distinguished. It's wrong nevertheless. Plural of dilemma is dilemmas
How many languages are you able to speak without error?
@@genes.3285 I was not being sarcastic. 'Dilemmata' is the correct plural of 'Dilemma' in ancient Greek.
@@mrplease66 And in german, which is his mother language
@@MrJakie You think so .
Good on you Austria .. these videos are so good and without exaggeration... well done from Australia.
Excellent. Clear and descriptive without overdoing the technical parts. Thanks for this.
Sir, 12:10 - Polish KRAB is also capable of firing at 40km range, and even 70km with rocket propelled munition. It's a very modern new system.
Your videos with analyzing war in Ukraine are the best, I've never seen anything so precise and objective. I tell you that as Ukrainian citizen, who watch and read different sources and experts all the time.
Thank you, colonel.
I would like to say that your assessment of the War in Ukraine is by far the best delivery of information there is. I would also like to say that there is no updated information what so ever as what you present here. I am looking foward to more upadates of the War in Ukraine. Thank you so much
By far the best breakdown I have seen yet. Please translate more of your excellent videos. Thank you very much for your time.
I really am enjoying your videos. I’ve shared with my friends that don’t have military experience so they understand a little more. Please keep the videos coming👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Excellent coverage and analysis. Very informative and impartial. Thank you
Best military information about what really is happening. Propaganda has it's place, nothing beats pure cold hard facts about the overall situation and not being emotional about the evaluation. Thankyou for this information Colonel
ITS
Colonel, your series is without at doubt the best presentation of its type I have found. You break things down into easy to understand pieces and show very well how they all relate. Please keep up the great work. Best of luck to you on your new command of the honor guard. They are in capable hands.
I eagerly await English language briefings.Your explanations are highly valued for their clear exposition of all those pertinent aspects dealing with the complex and complicated realities of modern warfare.Thank you sir.
First, outstanding briefing. You are a professional. Being an old cold war Fulda Gap cavalryman, I value your insights. The war in Ukraine is the one that didn't happen to me. This is a very large request, but please produce more of the briefings in English unless there is a way to have the translation in closed captioning. Thank you for your service to your country and the information you provide.
on TH-cam you can translate the German briefings using the TH-cam auto translate and its actually pretty solid - click on the gear symbol on the bottom right of the video player and you'll see it
All these sounds like russian government channel.
"Don't supply any weapons this is usless".
Proofs are 20 captured rpgs in winter time and 1 destroyed howitzer.
+ bot comments
+ video slides on russian )
My father was stationed at the Fulda Gap with the U.S Army in 1951-52. He participated in "Exercise Northwind " which was meant to simulate our reaction in the aftermath to a limited USSR nuke strike on our troops.
We also had tactical nukes fired from Sheridans in 72-73. Came close to break them out during the Israeli war in 73.
@@nibi144 Ahh yes, the Notoriously pro-Russian Austrian Military Academy... Maybe, just maybe, hearing anything other than the propaganda tales of glory and victory by Ukraine is just too hard to process for some.
This channel is underated! Outstanding research !
For an outdated with atleast 2 month's old information that is.
Now many ukroids are saying that this is a russian propaganda channel and Austria is a puppet russian state. Everything that doesn't kiss their @ss is russian apparently
I think it's quite up to date. There's more stuff promised, but that's not present on the battlefield yet. There are two things this Austrian colonel got wrong:
1. Poland has promised to send 200 T-72.
2. The Netherlands has promised to deliver 6 PzH2000 together with the Germans. The Dutch ones will be delivered 100%, it's up to the Germans if they do their part.
@@hendrikdependrik1891 No it is not up to date, far from that.
This man has a pointed head for one reason, he is a Russian agent so please take everything he says like you heard it from Putin himself.
Austria is pro German who in turn are pro Putin. Quite obvious isn't it.
BTW have fun in trying to recognise the pro Russian comments here.
Yeah, the ones swearing undying admiration for this Austrian guy.. You got it... 😂
This channel and organization needs more funding and exposure. This is incredible work. Respect from Canada.
Piggy backing off the previous comment. Thank you for publishing this in English. This is by far the best commentary there is on the Ukraine war.
These presentations are really well done and interesting
Gute sachliche Informationen, danke sehr.
ich bin immer wieder begeistert von seinen klaren auch für Laien verständlichen Erklärungen!!!!
@@evazampa1237 Hm die Frage ist was er gesagt hat :D Ja ich hab das Video gesehen, nur wer ist am gewinnen? Btw ich kenn die Antwort die Frage ist ob sie sie kennen oder aus diesem Video ableiten können.
@@hansjorgkunde3772 gas ist ja garnicht seine Aufgabe/Ziel er erklärt nur und hat höchstwahrschendlich auch keine Glaskugel zur Befragung
Thanks for the great video. Just a small clarification/correction: Those 36 km for the PzH 2000 mentioned there are achived using the old DM121 Boattail ammo. CAESAR's 40 km of range are achieved using a newer basebleed round. With a M1711 Basebleed round, the PzH 2000 can achieve 47km and with a M2005 V-LAP round 67km.
Whithout aircover they are just practice target...
And which rounds do you think Ukraine will end up with?
@@roryross3878 First a mix of DM121 and DM131, eventually they can get any 155mm shell they want if they decide they want to continue using this system and order more. It's probably going to take half a year until Rheinmetall's consortium can ramp up the production, but after that everything is possible.
@@roryross3878 There's now a picture on ua weapons tracker on which you can see the DM121 rounds.
@@roryross3878 Now they'll receive VULCANO rounds from Diehl with 70km of range.
Thank you , great , unbiased reportage.
Unbiased... 😂😂🤡🤡😂😂🤡🤡😂😂👆
Thanks! Sent this to an active duty US artillery friend who circulated it to counterparts. All found your brief invaluable. All the best
Thanks from an old artillery man
@@neilreynolds3858 Appreciate your note. Quick question: Do you know the last time US forces faced mased fires like this? I've polled friends with Vietnam, Bosnia, sandbox, etc. experience, but haven't heard about anything comparable to Ukraine. In any case, all the best
@@danapeck5382 Good question. WWI? The Bulge in WW2? It says the Germans had 1900 to 2600 tubes there. They also had Stgs and Panzers. That sounds hellish. The guy in my family who was at Bastogne didn't talk much but I don't think Bastogne was even the worst thing he'd seen.
@@neilreynolds3858 Thanks for the followup, tracks with my best guess. My dad and uncles were the same, no WWII stories, ever. All the best
Russia shots 50K shells per day. so all these 40K shells from western support is not really makes any difference.
I don't know if it's only the media but so far it seems like the 4 pieces of HIMARS have made a huge impact on the battlefield since they achieve objectives easily.
Instant subscribe. Finally a channel with facts and figures from a credible source, thank you.
Thanks a lot for making these available in English too!
The official language of NATO and the world
Austria is not NATO.
Always great to see your analysis, thanks for taking the time to film them in English.
One issue with holding the reinforcements back is that Russia is constantly targeting the depots of foreign weapons. Trying to amass a bigger force of foreign weapons anywhere inside Ukraine territory will probably mean they'll be destroyed before even entering any sort of combat mission.
Did you see that video yesterday of Ukraine's absolute demolition of Russians artillery depot behind the Russian lines? Here's a video th-cam.com/users/shortsnYcreDbk_hU
Member when Russia said they destroyed the Ukrainian airforce, and yet Ukrainian SU25s were flying combat missions on 6/16/2022 (sorry, videos are on Twitter/Telegram not TH-cam)? I member 🍇🍇🍇🍇th-cam.com/video/hHJhu15f-hg/w-d-xo.html
Also is Ukrainian army coordinated and competent enough to do successful counter-attacks? why not just grind down Russia and force them to retreat by death by a thousand cuts.
@@camus83489 they will not able ever to counter attack, to be able to counter attack you will need to have more forces that the enemy in ratio like 4:1 or 3:1 and ukrainians will never had that, all teritory that russian captured is never going to taken back and that is huge problem
@@btrswtluvltr how can we know that is russian artillery?
Best Channel for pure information. Thanks Austria !
Colonel, you are a very dynamic speaker with an incredible grasp of all things military. Austria’s armed forces should be proud that you are one of their leaders! Thank you for the presentation!
Best and serious source with a lot of facts as always. Thank you very much Colonel Reisner, i hope there will come more from you. I love Austria!
Thank you Colonel, for your excellent brief! I imagine that the Ukrainian command is aware that using heavy weapons in "penny packets" is not an ideal employment of resources. But if I was them, I would prefer to lose a few heavy weapons if it meant saving a battalion of good soldiers.
And these heavy weapons are trickling in, rather than flooding in. So it may take considerable time-perhaps months, to accumulate sufficient, well equipped forces for operational level counter-attacks, and Ukraine might not have that long, although they are conducting a superb defence so far.
Besides, without air superiority, dense masses of equipment could be subject to considerable attrition from the air.
it's not Colonel, Sir, it's Captain Austria.
@@iche9373 Rank doesn't matter. What matters is what and how he speaks about the situation in Ukraine. I've seen much higher officers talking nonsense.
@@Bee.Holder Yea, especially the supreme commander of the Russian army.
Thank you very much. Very professional overview, but clear for no military personal.
This is the best channel on Ukraine war. Please keep posting more frequently
vielen Dank, dass Sie dies auf Englisch zur Verfügung stellen und danke für den sachkundigen Bericht, Gottes Segen, Amen. 🇦🇹🇺🇸
Please check characteristic of the Polish Krab howitzer (18 delivered and already used on the front). They are very modern and one of the best in his class. 40 km range. Additionally please notice that as far as I know Poland already delivered over 260 tanks.
Thank you for the scientific view of warfare and Ukraine. Very well done!
Thanks for your work. These presentations are always well done.
Ребята, вы молодцы, продолжайте в том же духе и выпускайте брифинги почаще
Pro Russian BOT shame on you.
@@Gary-Seven-and-Isis-in-1968 You see a Cyrillic message & you automatically think it's an OrcBot? Translate the message first, THEN maybe shoot after!🤔
@@joerosen5464 You Buffoon.. Open your eyes and turn on your brain before commenting.
I already stated that I translated it.
Thank you, Herr Oberst Reisner. Excellent briefing.
Sir, it's Colonel Dr. Reisner, lol.
Dear Dr. Markus. It is a true opportunity for us operators to hear the professional analysis presented by you and your excellent academy. Sometimes we forget the science behind our craft. I look forward to each and every one of your excellent interventions.
Truly yours,
Alfredo Cara.
Telecom. Eng.
Thankyou very much for a very informative video ,many questions answered, slava ukrani
Thank you Colonel, these videos are very helpful and informative!
Latest numbers (17 June 2022) about the losses of the Ukrainian armed forces according to the MoD of Russia, take it as you will:
- 205 airplanes
- 131 helicopters
- 1,233 unmanned aerial vehicles
- 342 anti-aircraft systems
- 3,587 tanks and other armoured combat vehicles
- 539 multiple launch rocket systems
- 2,013 field artillery and mortars
- 3,658 other military ground vehicles
Even if only half of these were true (I guess most of them are) the western supplies Ukraine has received so far are not making any real difference in the grand picture. But of course those deliveries will have to be replaced eventually, and that will make some people very... $atisfied.
The numbers shown at 1:13 are the ones "combat ready as of 24.02.2022", and does not include equipment in storage or deliveries since then.
what a crap. Ukrainians lost 204 airplanes? How is it possible if they had 120?
@CtrlAltDelicious69 nope, we still have anti air defence even in Donbass region. A few days ago it shot down a rocket 10 km outside my hometown
thank you for taking the time to make these videos.. like how you break things down and explain things..
Excellent briefings. I hope it becomes a weekly thing; useful & informative.
Krabs can also reach 40kms. Their barrel is the same length as Caesar and pzh2000, not M109.
As for the MLRS and Missile Forces of the Russian Federation, to be more precise:
Depending on the type of ammunition (in brackets () types of shells):
1. BM-21 "Grad" caliber 122 mm - 33-40-42 km;
2.9K57 "Hurricane" caliber 220 mm - 13-34-35 km;
3.9K58 "Smerch" caliber 300mm - 70km (9M55F) -90km (9M528, 9M534) -120 km (9M542);
4.9K720 "Iskander" - 480 km (9M723) - 500 km (9M728);
5.3K55 "Bastion" - 300 km ("Onyx") -800 km ("Onyx-M");
Rockets 3K55 "Bastion" can fire at surface and ground targets.
What else is being fired at Ukraine:
6. Tu-160, Tu-95MS - 2000 km (X-55) - 3500 km (X-55SM) - 5500 km (X-101);
MLRS are great at shooting at the rough enemy area, but since the first MLRS are deployed Ukranian civilians lament that they now are also being shot from their own country. I also don't understand why those people didn't flee a hot zone when every european neighbour promised them free living. Man, old people can be stubborn.
MLRS have great range, but are very inaccurate, Russia still can target the western Ukranian area by firing 20 rockets in a general direction. In the end advanced artillery and drones are going to win this conflict and here I am with Ukraine (although western shippments arrive in the next weeks), training Ukrainians with western weapon systems should have happened in March
@@fatalityin1 is there any way of preventing NLAWs & Javelins from falling into enemy hands? Can't they be fired or destroyed before withdrawing?
The manufacturers should design an "auto destruct" feature that can be triggered remotely.
Excuse my ignorance on the subject as I have no military expertise.
I don't think russia uses much precision weapons as they just flatten & destroy anything. Also the cruise missiles fired at Ukraine are often shot down now, not "seldom" as the colonel said. Heard even manpads can shoot them. russia will be running out of that kinda of precision missiles too.
@@jacqdanieles Javelin isn't a cheap weapon (178.000$ and 78.000$ for each replacement missile). Adding a self-destruct feature will only make it even more expensive and risky to operate. By laying it on the ground and putting an ordinary hand grenade under it and removing the safety pin you can make a simple mine-trap.
@@bekeneel , Too stupid statements about shooting down cruise missiles, despite the fact that they are fired at several dozen a day every day from the beginning of the war and to this day. And the fact that they are shot down a lot, so this is nonsense! Either give me statistics on the areas under fire and the number of Ukrainian air defense crews and their types of air defense in their composition, or you are just an idiot.
As for the types of modern ammunition, the Krasnopol projectile (laser-guided reactive ammunition for a 152 mm cannon), which was shown even on British channels, was shown 40 times on the video of howitzers of the Russian Federation leaked by the crews themselves. They showed firing anti-radar missiles, TV-guided missiles (and also on British channels), they showed the work of Onyx-M, dozens of calibers arrive at the target every day (frames from local residents of Ukraine, which they send to their Ukrainian channels in a telegram). The Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation showed footage 5 times of firing 9M542 tornado projectiles at targets and their destruction.
The fact that you see little does not mean that it does not exist, take into account the economic saturation of the reserves of the Russian Federation due to sanctions, which fully pays for the costs of the war in Ukraine and allows you to switch to increased production rates.
Thanks for explaining in plain, common day to day language what corresponds to complex military subjects.
I like this dude, he makes me want to join the Ostrich Army.
Many people have forgotten that Austria has a deep experience and understanding of war. Such videos, in these unfortunate times, remind.
Austria shares a great deal of its glory with Hungary and its slavic neighbors.
They love to goose step all over Europe too.
This may be why they were constantly beaten in History ! 😂
@@antoinemozart243 "tu felix Austria nube" was the much better tactic.
@@antoinemozart243 The history of Austria-Hungary in a nutshell: Austria took the credit, Hungary got the blame.
Pro-ukraiaine couch generals hitting the dislike button like crazy.
This has got to be the top source of info on the Ukraine war.
Am extremely happy about the information you are giving us, we pray that all these weapons will be utilised efficiently and accurately to change the tide of the battle. I am extremely grateful for sharing this information. This message has shed more light on the issue of weapons, engagements and safety of the Ukrainian warriors. I am absolutely sure that General Zelensky will try to provide more defensive driving Artilleries missiles systems in the nearest future. Thank you. I am enjoying this beautiful information about the situation of the War in Ukraine.
God bless.
W.B.A
3:27 take a note at the 4th picture, these tanks are already captured by Russians, that last picture is actually picture that Russians shared on Telegram, it's the serial number of a tank that was delivered from West
The trading of tanks. That's a new one.
Yeah saw those too, many of these are already captured and or destroyed.
Good one, thanks for your good work. Keep them coming. The videos, ... not the tanks.
Finally a neutral, unbiased report.
Many thanks for the update. It gives a good picture of how the situation is in Ukrain. And sadly we dont get this anymore on a daily base in the Netherlands. The conflict has moved from the headlines wich makes it harder to get good information
4:40 Poland supplied not M109 howitzers but 18 pieces of much more modern (and better) polish made AHS Krab self propelled howitzers, the info is there written but for whatever reason (?) you grouped those. What's important Krab does not need rocket propelled shells (like M109 do) to reach 40 km distance.
OSINT is getting better than professional military intelligence services these days. What a time to be alive!
He does not mention 2S1 howitzers that were delivered by Poland either, numbers are all over the place, contradicting other sources. Poor effort.
@@comayhem Exactly. Not only no mention about "Gozdzik", also amount of T-72's already delivered is wrong. I wonder if it's simply lack of professionalism or a matter of realising some kind of political agenda.
100 is the approximate number of T-72M1R. The so-called "modified" T-72M/M1.
Around 120 pieces of the T-72M/M1 tanks were transferred to Ukraine. These are not yet on the front line since Ukrainians fit it with their own MGs and ERA array.
2S1 Gvozdika SPGs sent in a number of 20+.
BM-21 20+ as well.
BWP-1s from Poland are already in use in Ukraine - 40 pieces.
18 pieces of KRAB artillery, a modern 155mm SPG that can shoot 4-5 rounds in fast reload mode, so the shells get into the target in the same exact second. At that time, the KRAB is already changing its fire position. Further 50x will show in Ukraine very soon.
These numbers are not symbolic, but the most important thing is that the equipment went to Ukraine fast. Just when most needed. It took a few days from the talks to delivery.
@@HanSolo__ To be more precise Poland send 80 T-72M1R which after "R" mod are quite decent asset, and importantly have refreshed service life - those are practically new tanks. The rest of T-72 send by Poland (~150 of those) are unmodified, used T-72M1. By mentioning BM-1 you meant BM-21 Grad MLRS?
Greetings from Brazil 🇧🇷, you guys are great!
Brazil, I know you guys support Russia. Do not let the West fool you.
Great break down of the situation with no propaganda. Only a strategic point of view
This is very informative. I wish Colonel Reisner put out more videos.
Accurate and thoughtful analysis, thanks.
Excellent. You have encapsulated what every open-minded person knows, and have articulated it very clearly. This is the reason why Ukraine continues to be pushed back. I don’t see it changing…but it could.
All these sounds like russian government channel.
"Don't supply any weapons this is usless".
Proofs are 20 captured rpgs in winter time and 1 destroyed howitzer.
+ bot comments
+ video slides on russian )
@@nibi144 Lol wut. The presentation was about how the Ukrainians need more equipment, and how the weapons delivered so far are not enough to turn the tide of the war. Far from arguing that supplying weapons is "useless," the presenter is saying that the West needs to provide Ukraine with much more weapons if they want to help them win the war. One slide was in Russian, which is a language that is also used extensively in Ukraine, including by millions of people opposed to the Russian invasion, and many who are actively fighting for Ukraine. At no time are "20 captured rpgs" shown in this video, nor does it appear to be winter in the clip. It shows five captured Javelins, and a handful of other anti-tank weapons that are difficult to identify. The vast majority of comments on this video are positive, and pro-Ukraine. So basically pretty much every point in your comment is wrong in some way. Next time, actually watch the video and try listening to what is being said.
@@zvexevz presentation is match more about "useless" (do it on purpose?). Author said that it is useless to send equipment unless ukraine stop to lose it, forgetting (do it on purpose?) that is not a counter terrorist operation it is real war with huge losses of people and equipment and russia for example lost cruiser moscow and losing much more equipment. Russian language military slides make only russian military. And its very old video from february or march about capturing 20 Javelins, nlaws and Panzerfaust 3 (see winter clothes). Orlan 10 drop granades near howitzer - not very impressive. Now 4 months have passed and west continue to bla bla bla. On place of ukranians i won't fight at all with such treatment.
@@nibi144 Oh yeah. The old good "don't report bad news from Ukraine, if you say that Ukraine is not crushing the Russian army you are a russian bot". Mate, have a look at reality, Ukraine getting smaller by the day. Slowly, but steadily. Russia has not even declared general mobilisation yet. If the Russians really start having problems at the battlefield it will show. For the moment they're just sitting back at shell Ukrainian troops from a safe distance.
@@wforweed665 there is mobilization in donbas (poor people with no choice). mobilization in russia is very dangerous for russia because a lot of people dont support this war. T 62 and BMP 1 - are modern russian equipment really no problem?
Please keep going guys, was very nice and interesting to listen an opinion of specialists about present war.
Thank you Colonel
The only way around a slow and hugely costly defeat (in terms of human lives lost) is for NATO to supply the levels requested by Ukraine, but they won’t because (a) they don’t want to risk the possible consequences of such massive escalation, and (b) frankly NATO weapons stockpiles (especially of artillery ammunition) are simply too low, and countries would diminish their own defensive capabilities too much.
Another problem is the logistical tail. People have to be trained to supply and repair gear. Russia's logistical tail is so short that Russians have had to abandon gear that broke down for a variety of reasons. The U.S. has stopped using its tanks so M1A2 tanks plus older M60 tanks could be sent to Ukraine, but then hundreds of Ukrainians would have to be trained to use and repair the tanks while yet another logistical line has to be sent to arm and refuel the beasts.
those weapons simply don't exist in Europe unless the European armies strip bare, those numbers are pure fantasy Ukraine is demanding
@@orlock20 There is no way that M1A2 Abrams will be sent to Ukraine. If it gets destroyed it won't look good or even worse - if it gets captured by Russians. That would be a disaster.
@@Bee.Holder The M1A2 is old technology. The U.S. Marines aren't even using it. Even if the Russians were to get one, there isn't much the Russians and Chinese can do with it since Russia and China have the gun stabilizer and neither can afford putting thermal sights on their tanks.
@@orlock20 Nevertheless, I tell you that it won't happen. You don't have to believe me, time will tell.
Very informative balanced information. Thank you for putting in the effort to make this available
Excellent briefing report.
Why does it take Germany four months to move 7 artillery pieces to Ukraine?
Germany's military is in the dumpster and has been for years. Those artillery pieces probably had to be repaired and the ammunition made before the Ukrainians could train on them.
Today, the commander of the logistics of the ground forces of Ukraine, Volodymyr Karpenko, said that the Armed Forces of Ukraine lost 50% of heavy weapons ..... I think that in reality the losses are more than 70%. Kyiv officially acknowledged the loss of 2,500 heavy weapons. This means that Western assistance with weapons is very small, and will not help Ukraine.
If it kills Russians it helps Ukraine.
Russia is in bad shape too and has been forced to use civilian vehicles to move men and supplies around. These vehicles aren't powerful enough to move artillery. Most of Russian's aircraft are paperweights in hangers. Once those trains are targeted, Russia's supplies will ground to a halt.
That counts western aid that was lost too. Much of it is destroyed before it can reach the battlefield..
@@orlock20 Prof or didn't happened
@@orlock20 I live on the border of the war zone with Ukraine, I constantly see the traffic of the Russian army. These are special combat vehicles and in most cases new ones. I have never seen the use of civilian transport. Also aviation, there hasn't been a minute in the last 3 months. so that planes do not fly over our city, and planes are in the air day and night, we are already used to their roar. These are SU-30 and SU-27 or SU-35 (they are similar) sometimes IL 76 or AN 125, I don't think that old planes are capable of such intensive flights.
Thank you Oberst, in supplying detailed and subjective view of the ongoing conflict.
Excellent, professional, informative and unbiased. Bravo!
I LOVE this guy! Very good intel.... The hills are alive with the sound of music!
I’m a bit suprised that you got mixed up M109 from Norway with Krab from Poland, which are completly different systems with rather different characteristics (range included). Missed part about the contract for over 50 of Krabs as well. Also, are those lower numbers on tanks from Poland verified?
forget it the main issue is that Col didnt mixed to point the most effective game changer: The French Caesar! ^^))
Talk is cheap activities on ground is what matters, you can have all the best sophisticated equipment but if you have a rag tag outfit like Ukraine your equipment is useless. Seconly, Ukraine is not a superpower there lies the difference even nazi Germany took on the whole world
@@zcomme It's not that I want to nitpick on some gun or whatever, all in all it's very good presentation in terms of long term effect of deliveries. Especially piecemeal use of new eqiupment is important, although it's hard to discuss "piecemeal vs. strategic reserve", when whole delivery is 7 or 12 guns. There ARE categories though, where deliveries were significant - i.e. Poland and Czech tanks (250+ total) or incoming Krab delivery (with the ones delivered, it's over 60 modern long range, very mobile artillery), so I'm curious, what will be the use of those.
Der Freund wird bald ein weibliches Genitalorgan haben, aber das weiß noch niemand. Der russische kann nicht mit dem Wort gewinnen. Ich denke, die Pindos werden es schaffen. Die Allerhöchsten kamen von der anderen Seite. Russisch wird alle langsam ficken!
Krab has range up to 40 km
Thank you Colonel M Reisner for a very interesting & enlightening video ..well presented!
Thank you very much! Profound analysis!
that was uncomonly informative and understandable for the layman. this really makes me genuinly concerned about the amount of help the military vehicles sent by other counties to the ukraine will actually be. i'm not sure itll be enough at all, despite whatever good intentions may be.
most news ive seen in the past few weeks has been optomistic about the ukraine, but now i'm not so sure. IF russaian forces were so poor in terms of equiptment, supplies and training as i had been led to believe (due to systemic corrpution, poor maintance, and other factors) then i dont see how they'd have been able to hold on this long, much less make further gains no matter how slowly. i would really like this matter cleared up, if that was possible.
You’re not sure it will be enough??? It’s getting destroyed faster than it can be used and is pointless wasting any more tax payers money on this senseless war.
"most news ive seen in the past few weeks has been optomistic about the ukraine" Fake new and Elensky propaganda my friend
The news are optimistic for Ukraine since they are still resisting. That is a miracle in itself. The Russian army is plagued by corruption, incompetence and poor equipment. However, it's still a far larger and stronger force. If they were competent and professional they would have taken over the Donbas months ago. They are still slowly advancing by virtue of being such a powerful force and literally leveling whole cities with artillery and bombing. The positive news doesn't mean Ukraine's winning but rather that they are not getting crushed. And that in itself is a win. Every day that they are resisting is a win.
@@alexwallachian7720 of course the news outlets are optimistic for the "good" side. stands to reason. doesnt mean i believe the retoric. i believe in facts.
@@davidtal523 well it's not really about good or bad side but rather david vs goliath. It's like in the Finnish-Soviet war. The Finns won lots of victories and kept the Soviets back for a lot longer than anyone expected but they were never going to defeat the USSR. Same with Ukraine. They held back the Russians a lot more than anyone would have ever dreamed and even managed to push them back from their capital. Hence the optimistic news. But I don't think anyone expects Ukraine to actually defeat the Russian army.