Roger Waters & Abby Martin on Gaza Genocide
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 พ.ย. 2023
- Legendary Pink Floyd musician Roger Waters joins Empire Files to discuss his longtime advocacy for Palestine and the crisis in Gaza.
Keep Empire Files independent & ad-free (and get exclusive bonus content) at / empirefiles
More content available on The Empire Files podcast: tr.ee/M0wjSo7ey4
FOLLOW // / empirefiles // / abbymartin // / rogerwaters
MERCH // empirefiles.store
MUSIC by ANAHEDRON
![อาจารย์ยอด : ลุงแว่วเล่าเรื่องผี [ผี]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Fd2Qsy4dqpM/mqdefault.jpg)
![LISA - ROCKSTAR (Official Music Video) REACTION [SHE'S BACK!]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QBxE30vavMQ/mqdefault.jpg)
I have been waiting for Empire Files to cover this conflict again, great to see this channel's back alive
The film The Wall has to be one of the best anti-fascist, anti-imperialist works of art in history. Roger and Pink Floyd were a big part of my formative years. Thanks to both Abby and Roger for all they do.
And people all over say the movie is trash. But it's a huge music video. And the messages, imagery, lyrics? Completely fucking sound.
Pink is empty, disconnected, unfulfilled, directionless. So he sits and stares at humanity... arriving at fascism.
When you're so _vacant,_ you allow some scumbags with horrible motives to shape your mind, words and actions FOR you.
he is a grifter and that is all
@@dillpete4122little Zionatzi why did you get triggered boy,truth hurts your pathetic ego!!
@@dillpete4122 you're talking about one of the most respected and famous musicians of 20th century. Literally a living legend.
"Grifter" my ass 😂
@@dillpete4122 yo that's just like, your opinion man... and a pretty lonesome as far as I can see...
When I see and listen to Roger Waters and Abby Martin, at how much they have been doing for the oppressed people of Palestine, and still going strong, I am ashamed of myself that I have been negligent about Palestine for so long. Thank you from the bottom of my heart.
Thank you Roger. It couldn't have been said better. That's what we want.
Abby Martin is the real deal
She's been a real one since the beginning, always fearless and outspoken against injustice. May Allah bless her
Allah? See this is the problem, your religion. You ripped off Judaism and added some more psychotic shit to it then claim it as "the original religion"...... You're children.@@beastvader
propagandist and nothing more
@@dillpete4122says you
@@dillpete4122 yeah proper Ghandhists rather.
Welcome back Abby! your fight to highlight the injustice, cruelty suffered by the Palestinian under the Zionist apartheid state of Israel has been outstanding; and much needed, Thanks so much for the commitment and effort.
ROGER WATERS = LEGEND
Abby has become my go to news source as of late. Her work is absolutely incredible!
Their conversation around the history of the region is quite lazy.
Rashida Tlaib is a Hero speaking truth to power & she's on the right side of history for speaking out against Israel's actions. 💁🏿♂️🙆🏽♀️
Absolutely
Not@@mikebunch3443
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
I want 1947 borders recognized.
Long live Israel.🇮🇱
#SUBHANALLAH
#EUTOMUCHTALK
#UNTOMUCHTALK
#PBBTOMUCHTALK
#CEASEFIRENOW
#THEENDOFKILLING
#ENDTHEGENOCIDE
#STOPTHEGENOCIDE
#STOPTARGETCIVILIANS
#STOPTARGETHOSPITAL
#STOPTARGETAMBULANCE
#STOPTARGETBAKERY
#STOPTARGETJOURNALIST
#NOSAFEPLACEINGAZA
#GAZAHOSPITALCRISIS
#GAZAUNDERDESTROYIT
#WESTBANKUNDERATTACK
#PALESTINECRISISFOOD
#PALESTINECRISISWATER
#JUSTICEFORPALESTINE
#FREEPALESTINE
#STANDWITHHUMANITY
#USMONEYFORWAR
#BLOONONYOURSHANDS
#ISRAELATTACKREFUGEECAMP
#ISRAELINTERNATIONALCRIME
#ISRAELWARCRIMES
#USWARCRIMES
#EUWARCRIMES
#UNWARCRIMES
#PBBWARCRIMES
#ISRAELWARCRIMES
#USWARCRIMES
#EUWARCRIMES
#UNWARCRIMES
#PBBWARCRIMES
#ISRAELWARCRIMES
#USWARCRIMES
#EUWARCRIMES
#UNWARCRIMES
#PBBWARCRIMES
#ISRAELWARCRIMES
#USWARCRIMES
#EUWARCRIMES
#UNWARCRIMES
#PBBWARCRIMES
#ISRAELWARCRIMES
#USWARCRIMES
#EUWARCRIMES
#UNWARCRIMES
#PBBWARCEIMES
#ISRAELWARCRIMES
#USWARVRIMES
#EUWARCRIMES
#UNWARCRIMES
#PBBWARCRIMES
it was freed in 1948
@@DutchmanAmsterdamJews like the Palestinians have a right to live free and independently. Jews like the Palestinians have the right to have a OWN country.
this man standing with humanity he is true human being
Thank you, Abby and Roger. Also love your “Palestine 101” piece too , Abby. Roger, I’m with you on 1 race. Keep up your good work
I'm happy to see you back, and with a legend like Roger Waters.
“Since its establishment, Israel has engaged in brutal oppression of the rights of Palestinians. Thousands of Palestinians are imprisoned, beaten and tortured; children are taken from their beds and beaten by soldiers who are armed to the teeth.”-Miko Peled.
Thank you so much Roger and Abby for standing up for those who need our voices the most, the work that you both do is incredible and will hopefully go in building a btter world for all of us to live in where we can all stand and unite against injustice!! This genocide must stop!!
Freedom to the Palestinians and to all the oppressed people!
So you want all the Israelis dead do you?
Thank you both for making your voices heard and your tremendous support for human rights.
Roger's politics are spot on. Great guest, and one of the greatest songwriters in history.
One of....
@@carefulcarpenter Top 3 I'd say. Bob Dylan, Lennon-McCartney, Waters-Gilmour, Page-Plant. Stiff competition. I'd put Waters above Page-Plant since they relied less on covers, Zeppelin was performance based and really didn't approach music as traditional songwriting.
@@NytronX I wrote on the messageboards of three singer/songwriters. I eventually labeled myself as the first Cyberpoet. Now I can claim to be the first and only Cyberpoet.
I got a fair understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of the world's great creative. (4) visited my community after that.
Coincidence?
@@carefulcarpenter I have no idea what you just said. #FreePalestine
@@NytronX Are you a bot?
Thank you Abby Marti, Roger Waters and Empire Files. Thank you for standing up for justice and humanity against the psychopaths living off of death and Human misery.
The USA does not have the moral latitude to educate the Nazi/Zionist occupying Palestine given USA's treatment of Indigenous Americans. It was the that genocide was committed against native Americans, thus allowing for the occupation of their land. Zionists action in Palestine is a continuation of Caucasians theft and occupation of other peoples land, be it in Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Spain, Italy, Argentina, Brazil just to mention a few. In other words, the Zionists are simply following precedent. What a shame?
Both sides though need to back off, with the ideas. Cannot carry on like this.
Both sides? Compare the both sides, see the development ofvthe both sides please.
Absolutely 100% statement 😢
@@carlywright5127 Learn the history before hosting a naive opinion.
Thank you both for always standing with justice and the Palestinian people. Your work is so important ♥️
A tour de force by Roger Waters! We need many more voices like his. From the river to the sea......
Thank you Roger and Abby for showing your humanity in these very troubled times and standing against the evil supporting the genocide of the Palestinian people.
Abby is correct ! The USA has used Israel as its "useful idiot " for decades. Israel is nothing but a massive arsenal for America to fall back on if ever any of the middle east nations get out of hand.
waltuh
The genocide is against the jews, how blind are people not to see that? Insane.
Palestinians have increased five fold in 50 years. What kind of genocide is that exactly?
Are you insane or what?
yeh and what about the vaxxzionazi genocide didn´t hear woger about that nooo
Abby you’re back, with Roger Waters… this is just what we needed honestly. ❤️🇵🇸
Ehh idk. I lost a lot of respect for her when Russia invaded another country and slaughtered/kidnapped/committed war crimes and she took the invaders side.
@@Dumbledore6969xwhere/when was this take from Martin? I'd like to hear it if this is true
@communismisthefuture6503 wtf are you talking about? She publicly condemned the invasion as soon as it happened on Breaking the Set. This is pretty well known.
@@RegularRegs it was on this channel. I just went back to find the video for you and it’s since been deleted. I don’t think they expected the public to overwhelmingly condemn Russian and there was a lot of pushback in the comments. Glad to see they deleted it but I suspect she hasn’t changed her opinions.
@@vratyasvakyas6022 That’s a lie
Roger epitomises the song “Legacy”. He is not interested in having his name etched in stone; he simply wants to leave a legacy of being a child of mercy and grace. Bless him.
Thank you Mr Roger Waters for staying the course of conscience over the years and seeing through the lies. I've been so disappointed by so many musicians and artists over the past few years and I'm so relieved to find an ally in such an inspired creative spirit as yourself. Thanks strong Abby for hosting this conversation. On the recommendation of Ryan Cristian, I've now seen your most recent documentary on Palestine.
I do not know from where Roger Waters gets this idea that Evangelical Christians want the Jews to die and burn in hell. That is not true, and a terrible thing to say about them.
Brillian conversation by 2 wonderful humans on this very sad occasion! Free Palestine!
I think the US support for Israel shows us that the US is not at all remorseful for all of the crimes it commited, notably the ethnic cleansing of Native Americans, and the war crimes in Iraq. If you are sorry, we wouldn't be doing this again.
It’s heavily lobbied by Jewish pressure groups, so the American system is hijacked
Obviously. it should be obvious by now the psychopaths run the asylum. Are you not paying attention?
Lol be remorseful for premeditated multi generational behavior?
And crimes they have committed against black Americans
Exactly!!
I grew up with Roger Waters hits with PinkFloyd!!! No words in my vocabulary for you guys other than Thank you very much!!! Stay blessed always!!!
Thank you both 🙏✌️🇦🇺
It is rare to see a person that is so passionate about his conviction and eagerness for justice to Everyone!
Admiration and respect to you Sir!
When someone humanitarian like Roger or Norman Finklestein and others speak loudly then ppl with mind and heart should listen.
Thank you for standing up for justice and humanity.
No human should be going through this.
Thank you Roger and Abby for bringing your thoughts to Gaza situation you commented accurately …love to you both…❤
truth be told, go Roger, go Abby! Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Gaza City fire sale! Everything must go! Ample free parking!
you think it would be free? These are capitalists.@@user-xk1sy9pl6z
@@user-xk1sy9pl6z Slow clap.
As a Palestinian I thank you both for your humanity, it should be a given, or so we were raised, but now we see it's a rarity ❤❤❤
Why hasn't the Palestinian people overthrown Hamas?
@@kinjunranger140 because hamas is a resistance group against the 75 years of occupation, don't try to make this all started on 7th of October Israel been occupying Palestine for 75 years, and btw the westbank doesn't have hamas and still has over 150 martyrs and over 500 imprisoned since the 7th only, nevermind a whole 75 years of occupation
@kinjunranger140 why hasn't the European Zionist occupiers gone back to Europe?
@@medoangel8370 Unfortunately, Hamas isn't as simple an organisation. They've been known to work together with the United Ssnakess and Israel itself. Israel profits from their extremism.
@@Olegstuff21986😅 United sneaks love 💕 it !!
Thank you Roger and Abby hearing this gives me hope that ppl will hear the truth about Israel
Wow. Roger you will be remembered forever as an icon of music and freedom supporter. Your name will be forever n Palestinians hearts and minds. YOU WILl NEVER DIE. Thank you..free Palestine 🇵🇸
Thank you Roger! 30 y ago I loved you as "Pink Floyd", now for the human you are❤
Same here; I was breathing Pink Floyd from the age of 12 and I few years back when I found out that Roger Waters was an activist for the Palestinian cause and was a tough criticizer of USA’s invasion of Iraq, I considered myself so lucky that all my love for Pink Floyd and Roger Waters didn’t go in vain
Same!
Free Palestine ✊🏼 🇵🇸
How lol
@@mariojane8188What's funny about it? And what kind of question is even that?! Ever heard of a guy called Malcolm X? The answer is obvious. "By Any Means Necessary".
@@waterbottles4744 Look! A monster laughing about genocide. Smfh!
If the world cared about Gazan refugees, then they would already be relocated in Egypt and Europe. 6 million Ukrainians left Ukraine for Poland and elsewhere, but 2 million Gazans are forced by the Arab world to stay and die to try and win some war Arabs instigated. It's not Israel who decided that Gazans should be cannon fodder. The Arabs, the Americans, and the Europeans decided this, and you haven't polled the Gazans yet to find out if some of them wanted refugee status in Egypt or not.
@@lilaoliva793 You're idea of a freedom fighter is actually a terrorist. That's the big elephant in the room.
Thank you both for your amazing heart and soul for Humanity!
Such an inspiring interview. Thank you Abby and Roger!
I admire you both for your humanity and integrity. You are two of the most influential voices of justice that are exposing Israel’s genocide of the Palestinians that has been going on, not for just 35 days, but for more than 75 years.
SREALS EXCUSES -- are 100 % DISHONEST,,and Criminal,,---- The Facts =
Biden ,Congress is Bought out by Israel ---and the USA Gov. Supports
this CRIMINAL -- Genocide of the Palestine people ( Zionist Israel - Stole their Land )
Forced then into Ghettos/Poverty and suffering.....for Many DECADES,,,,They suffer from abuse from Israel.
This shows How Far GONE and -Dishonest and Corrupted they have become,= USA-UK -EU-Nato Etc...
The SAME with the Ukraine war,,Russia was
--FORCED by the USA and NATO. CIA Overthrew Ukraine elected GOV. in 2014
- and Bombed Ukraine (Russia Residents and killed them).......It was despicable.....
So Nato and Ukraine signed The Minsk Agreements to STOP IT
--- But they had a Hidden plan (were dishonest with Russia)
,,,LATER-,,,UKRAINE+NATO,,,,signed a PEACE Agreement and Broke it'
=''The MiNSK Agreements'
'---- LATER ON After the War Started and Russia invaded Ukraine--
--- Boris Johnson and USA and Nato Sabotaged a- REAL PEACE Agreement
with Russia and Ukraine after the war started -- in 2022,-
-THUS ,THE WEST NATO _USA_UK_EU--They are CRIMINALS !!!!
RUSSIA WAS DRAGGED -- nto this WAR,,,and its Not Their fault,,,Ukraine's GOV+MILITARY
is -Corrupted with - NAZI"S 100 %
- WE are not being told the truth about Gaza or Ukraine,,
By The WEST GOVERNMENTS -
NATO and MSM.-
From 1990 to 2022 the population of Palestine increased from 1.98 million to 5.04 million people. This is a growth of 155.0 percent in 32 years. The highest increase in Palestine was recorded in 1991 with 4.58 percent.
@@Hmm-oc1wg
SSTTFFUU.
@@Hmm-oc1wg What is your point? That it's ok to kill thousands of Palestinians because they still have a net population growth?
@@Hmm-oc1wg ... which teaches us that half the Palestinian population are under the age of 18, making these victims children ...
Amazing how the vernacular keeps changing from ceasefire to humanitarian pause yet the significance of the changes are ever more dark. I have the greatest respect for both Roger and Abby!
Thank you for speaking out
Can't imagine life without Pink Floyd
I can’t either they have got me through the toughest times in my life without them I would be dead long ago
4 months of silence, then this. Worth it!!! Abby, you're a gem.
Thank you Roger and Abby for standing up for truth and humanity.
As long as this doesn't affect us westerners then we can talk about it. Great truth there.
I appreciate all this, but how come no one is talking abut Ukraine anymore? Or Zelenskyy, the WH's war puppet. Or Yemen or the mass migration of muslims out of Pakistan at the moment that far exceeds Gaza? We in the west choose our causes like latte's at Starbucks. The west is falling due to this lack of discernment.
@@angelrojo6466 The West is falling due to a clear lack of concern for sacrificing ANYTHING to promote world peace.
Truth?
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 nice one
Solidarity and love from Midland Texas❤
Abby & Roger and all the free human minds of the world, we love you. #free_palestine
Two heroes willing to speak the truth at any cost!
Tslking of crazed accusations from crazed Jews. Two days after the attack the BBC interviewed a Jewish woman who was on the verge of hysteria. She was shaking and shouting uncontrollably. She was basically making up stories as she went. One particular whopper was that she saw a Hamas trooper grab a Jewish Kibbutz women who was pregnant. She continued to say that the savage brute reached inside her womb, pulled out her baby and proceeded to kill it. The fact the BBC did not edit that deranged woman was a disgrace.
The truth is not black and white. Ever.
how come no one is talking abut Ukraine anymore? Or Zelenskyy, the WH's war puppet. Or Yemen or the mass migration of muslims out of Pakistan at the moment that far exceeds Gaza? We in the west choose our causes like latte's at Starbucks. The west is falling due to this lack of discernment.
What a glorious comeback! With nobody less than Roger Waters. I love his clear insights on the subject and his straightforward stance. From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free.
talk like yours is the reason there will never be a ceasefire....its the 21st century not the 7th century
@@paulrichards6894The fuck does that even mean
From the river to the sea ? There is a state of Israel and then there is the state of Palestine. You are only giving fuel to those saying that Palestinians want to destroy the state of Israel. Stop feeding the main stream media narrative. Maybe the one state solution is indeed the way to go but what do I know..
It is the Sunnis who want a caliphate. Not Shia Iran. I bet you don't even know the difference between the 2 don't you ? By the way, Hamas was maneuvered into power and allowed bank transfer payments from Qatar APROVED by the Israeli government, talk about facilitating their rise to power ! Not me saying it but Israeli politician themselves ! Looks like you need o EDUCATE yourself. Also, Gazans VOTED for Hamas you fool. NO ONE is advocating for the destruction of Israel. NO ONE. Not even Hamas, they revised their charter saying that they believe in the 2 state solution. The attack from Hamas did not happen in a vacuum. 75 years ago Palestinians were dispossessed and thrown out of their land displaced from land they had been living for hundreds of years while Jews had been displaced all over the world for hundreds of years. No one forced the Jews to come. They came and willfully and with enthusiast displaced hundreds of thousands of Palestinians all to create Israel. If my book says that my ancestors lived on your land 3000 years ago will you allow me to come and take half of your house ? I don't think so. Why are you even siding with genocidal tendencies ? Are you mentally sound ? You are sick in the head. Hamas is not the problem here. The problem is the Israeli government that does not even try to resolve the Palestinian question. No effort what so ever. They still occupy the west bank and still Israeli settlers illegally create settlements in the west banks which all countries in the world recognizes as being Palestinian territory. When you treat a group of human beings as sub human and you subject them to daily humiliation, don't ask yourself why they attack you and revolt. You would do the same. Just for fuck sake cant you put yourself in the shoes of the side you don't ;like for a second ? No I don't hate Jews. I love all human beings, just in case you resort to the childish accusation of me being antisemite. @@highcountrydelatite
Equal rights for ALL, from the river to the sea ❤🇸🇩🇸🇩🇸🇩🇸🇩🇸🇩❤🇺🇲
Firstly, Roger and Abby, thank you so very much, for passing on this truthful and extremely important information. You both and many other truth speakers, are the real heros of today in 2023!
I'm American and the way the Palestinians are treated and now being wiped out makes me sick!!
He’s been slandered in the media but he’s a humanist in the truest sense of the word.
Yes he should be alone for his support of Putin
Nothing wrong with supporting Russia 🇷🇺 / or it's president . Don't tell me that the warmongering organisation called NATO did not provoked Russia.
@@wwbuirkle Provide an example of him supporting Putin.
@@KlausBahnhof Look it up genius and also said there was no way Russia was gonna attack Ukraine. Just because you like someone as a artist doesn't mean you have to kiss his ass. LMFAO
@wwbuirkle Several people I greatly respect thought that Russia would not invade. Many were surprised by that.
Predictions are flawed by their nature, so that's nothing to get worked up about.
Without trawling through all of Waters' remarks about the Russian invasion, I suspect he probably acknowledged the historical context, the West's provocations, and Putin's actual stated reasons for the invasion.
Certain people seem to conflate an understanding of the reasons it happened with actual support for the invasion.
You may be engaging in this type of simplistic thinking.
Thank you Roger and Abby for this amazing discusssion
I'm 8 min 30 sec in, and he's dropped about a half dozen wild untruths! At least Abby Martin stays on subject.
It's enough to make you weep.
@@josephinetracy1485 For example?
@@josephinetracy1485For how long exactly, you thought you could still, fool the whole world, with your CONSTANT BLATANT LYING?!! WOW!
An enlightening and enjoyable conversation between two people of conscience.
A poet, a musician, an inspirer.
These two are gems...people like them should rule our world...
We tried having people like them ruling the world - they were called Nazis.
Gosh i am so proud of Roger Watters for standing up
yeh and what about the vaxxzionazi genocide didn´t hear woger about that nooo
Where is the rest of them: Neil Young, Bruce Springsteen, Jay Z... all those rockin' rebels in the "free world"?
Bruce is sided with Dopey Joe on BanderaKraine .
@@pariaheep idk bout bruce other two sell outs sold out big too big kapital
Abby, it's so good to see you on social media again, after many years. You are looking great, as ever! Thank you for your honesty about the Gaza massacre by israel. Greetings from Hungary!
Indigenous people in America from befoe 1700's STAND WITH YOU! I have been traffikkked by police in FL, where my family stood up to AJaxon. I am constantly harassed because of this. I am a descendant of natives, and robertelee. I identify with annfrank. Roger, I was at your SF masterful and gorgeous concert 9/25/2022. Some A HOLES sat behind us in the nosebleed section as they heckled myself, my fiance and you. THANK YOU FOR STANDING UP AGAINST WAR CRIMINALS! Your performance was superb. One Love and again, THANK YOU BOTH for this.
Abby and Roger, everything that you've done for the Palestinian people is just amazing.
I know that some people think that most of what they're doing is talking, but that helps. Everything that they do help and it's very admirable that these dedicated their life for defending the opressed. One day when Palestine will be free I have no doubt in my mind that many Palestinians will look at them as heroes becuase they're already considered as such.
I hope that there will be a future where this oppression of all these people around the world (not just Palestinians) will stop and we can finally live as human beings, the eay that we're supposed to live
They and thousands more will be seen as being on the right side of history.
Abby and Roger ... two great humanitarians willing to speak truth to power! Thank you for your insights.
Thank you so much Mr Walters for your immeasurable courage🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
You are en clear example as humanist the world should follow 👍👍 deep respect , god bless you❤❤
Great interview with Abby Martin and Roger Winters thanks for sharing. PEACE TO All PEOPLES AROUND THE WORLD.
Welcome back Abby. Roger was the perfect guest!
Roger forgot to mention that the American Jewish songwriter Paul Simon not only went to South Africa to perform but made an album about his time there.
Thank you so much Roger for standing up for humanity against this genocide,I'm from Scotland & stand with Palestine 🇵🇸🏴🇵🇸♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Power to Scotland and you dear.
You Should Move There
Aguante la gente como la gente aguante Roger un tipo con buenas pelotas más que muchos cobardes que callan ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Saw your show in Denver,Colorado....Was at Standing Rock....Thank -you for using your platform!!!!! Mad Respect!!!! Mni Wiconi!!!
Another great interview! Thank you Abby and Roger for your courage!
Roger has taken too much acid.
His brain has now gone rotten.
@@victormeidan1062This is your WISE "analysis" of what he said & stands for?! Brilliant!!
@@7arkhwf
Either that or Roger has "rogered" too many sluts. He has caught Syphilis that has damaged his brain.
God bless you for standing up for justice, truth, and humanity.
Two of my heroes of human rights, who are not afraid to tell the truth.. Thank you Abby for your commitment to human rights, and thanks to Roger. Much love to you both.
Respect for both of you! Thank you.
May God bless you both, you good people.
Roger Waters one of the greatest warriors of modern times.
Amazing interview with two legends. Very few left who tell the truth , no matter what.
What truth He hasn't a clue Little nazi spreading HAMAS PROPAGANDA
My favorite musician… Fell in love with Pink Floyd’s music way before I knew about Roger’s Pro palestine activism but finding that was cherry on top.
Thankyou Roger & Abby for saying these things.I agree with what you say wholeheartedly.
My heart is in Palestine and Gaza and I feel ashamed because of the silence here in Germany. Thank you for your courage and engagement. We pray for you, for Palestine and all the victims of war.
Yep, on wrong side of history. Again.
Me too 😢💔
yep...true...wrong side of history, IDF shot their own people LOL what a bunch of idiots @@katmag8
There is no Palestine, there'll never be a Palestine.
Thank you both for an adult and reasonable discussion
I am hurt I can’t help it
I dislike Biden he is a war monger
Not only a musical legend but a REAL LIFE Legend as well
I have so much admiration for Abby. She is so courageous and relentless fighting for the voiceless and the helpless.
Roger, a good man.
Wow, my two favourite people about Palestine!!!! All we needed was Noam Chomsky. Love this!!!
Peace from Ireland 🇮🇪 ✌🏼🇵🇸💚
The dream team ❤
The world is in need of more people like both of you!
God bless you both🤲🏻🤲🏻🤲🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Truth to power. Always your forte, Roger, and always integral to your art.
Just love Roger's fire - great job guys!
Amazing guys. Free Palestine
from who....their religious masters who want to drag the world back to the dark ages
Thank you so much Roger and Abby for your incredible efforts in supporting the Palestinian cause! Keep up your brilliant work ❤️🇵🇸
I am proud of Roger Waters. Thank you so much
WONDERFUL!
🎉🎉🎉
This is who we are, we are humans and we take care of eachother❤❤❤
I am glad this interview happened!
In 2001 for a college class on multicultural psychology I decided on a whim to privately interview both Palestinian students and Jewish rabbis without telling either of them who all I was interviewing. My goal was to be able to understand each of them so as to reflect back to them in my own words what their view was of the conflict. It opened my eyes quite to my surprise. I had no idea how it would change me when I started. But at the end of that project I was no longer pro Israel.
Tell us more.
@@meganbaker9116 He probably just figured out that Zionists are genocidal because they think they're God's chosen people or some nonsense. While Muslims aren't the most tolerant either, no religion really is, they're still more tolerant than Zionists who are basically the worst people to ever exist on Earth. Met an old guy who used to be soldier with NATO and the UN and stuff, he had worked with both Israelis and Muslims, and he said the Muslims soldiers where great people, very welcoming and friendly, while the Israeli soldiers where the worst people he ever met. Norwegian guy, so he was raised on the whole Christian propaganda off Jews being great, but meeting them definitely changed his mind.
Tell us more please. Do you have this documented in any form? It'd be eye opening to other people for sure.
@@metwalymagdy264 I would suggest that people do something similar on their own. Just start communicating with various individuals from both sides.
So what was it that persuaded you to no longer be pro-Israel? There must have been a specific revelation or something that resinated from the interviews you did.
Abby I watched your film on the "march of return" here in Bogota on a publc channel..I was really impressed for what is shown on it,since then I follow you ..this conversation has been just fascinating,thank you..keep on standing for justice and truth....❤
Roger you're my hero. I like you for your honesty and the truth you always tell us.
Abby Martian your amazing human being As always standing against injustice
Is Abby from Mars?
@@panchosvillos yeah such a soul.
Nice to hear from Roger and Abby again
I totally understand Rogers frustration about all this. It makes you feel utterly insane to hear the rhetoric of the UK and US government. Makes you feel utterly bonkers to hear "It's complicated", or to hear that October the 7th is somehow surprising and more terrible than how the Israelis have been treating the Palestinians for the last decades...and getting away with it! No world wide outrage at their horrific actions!
.....sends you absolutely insane. We're utterly doomed if people are this easily lead.
I always think, ‘surely they won’t fall for this one?’ but the majority do, every time. And if you don’t,,,western society has become so dumbed down, it’s hard to live a normal life anymore.
Roger always defended the opressed, fragile and unsaved People, he is a great voice for peace in the World
Thankyou so much to you two, you are angels.
I’m from Québec and i stand with Palestiniens.
Merci.
“Hey Israel… leave those kids alone”
Edit: Sorry, I feel bad for even attempting to be lighthearted in this moment. I hope to God that the world will stop turning a blind eye to the Palestinian plight and make Israel treat them as equals. Stop this genocide
Hey Israel stop building thise walls.
😂😂😂 I know, it really is not a laughing matter but that was funny AF
@@den264Yes, in the west Bank. It's 439 miles long . They also installed wall around Bethlehem .
don’t apologize, is kinda genius. pythagoras said “the highest use of philosophy is music.” your comment is a wise extension.
th-cam.com/video/1sDZlo_hllI/w-d-xo.html
Courageous Roger! Love the guy.
God bless you both