Cultural Humility (complete)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ส.ค. 2012
- "Cultural Humility: People, Principles and Practices," is a 30-minute documentary by San Francisco State professor Vivian Chávez, that mixes poetry with music, interviews, archival footage, and images of community, nature and dance to explain what Cultural Humility is and why we need it. The film describes a set of principles that guide the thinking, behavior and actions of individuals and institutions to positively affect interpersonal relationships as well as systems change. These principles are:
• Lifelong learning and critical self-reflection
• Recognizing and changing power imbalances
• Developing institutional accountability
More than a concept, Cultural Humility is a process of communal reflection to analyze the root causes of suffering and create a broader, more inclusive view of the world. Originally developed by Doctors Melanie Tervalon and Jann Murray-Garcia (1998) to address health disparities and institutional inequities in medicine, Cultural Humility is now used in public health, social work, education, and non-profit management. It is a daily practice for people who deal with hierarchical relationships, changing organizational policy and building relationships based on trust.
The film tells stories of successes and challenges, and the road in between for those working to develop partnerships among community members, practitioners and academics. It encourages us to realize our power, privilege and prejudices, and be willing to accept that acquired education and credentials alone are insufficient to address social inequality. The first segment introduces Cultural Humility and features interviews with Melanie Tervalon and Jann Murray-Garcia. The second clip offers the context and setting, poetry readings by San Francisco State public health students and an analysis of privilege and power. The third segment is about Community Based Participatory Research and Education; it features the work of the Chinese Progressive Association academic partners and critical educators/students. The last segment brings closure with a reflection on peace, embodied images of nature and a quote by Audre Lorde.
Audiences who might find this documentary helpful include professionals, students, providers, organizers and policy makers in public health, social work, medicine, psychology, nursing, education and more.
M. Tervalon, J. Murray-Garcia (1998). Cultural humility versus cultural competence: a critical distinction in defining physician training outcomes in multicultural education, Journal of health care for the poor and underserved, Vol. 9, No. 2. (May 1998), pp. 117-125.
Vivian Chavez © 2012, Creative Commons license: Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0) creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
Vivian Chavez was my undergrad professor for Health Education at SFSU! So proud to see her thrive and continue this work. I am now watching this for my Masters In Social Work :)
What a beautiful opportunity you had! I could listen to her wisdom all day. SO much to learn
Cultural humility is such an exciting concept, and requiring that social and legal institutions recognize that people know what they want and respond in such ways would significantly mitigate institutional retraumatization. I personally resonate with this as a survivor of domestic violence who has been greatly traumatized by the court system's lack of discretion in domestic violence situations involving an abuser who does not live in the same jurisdiction as the abused. The institution needs to become more flexible and responsive to the different experiences of survivors of violence, even when personal jurisdiction can not be established.
I am watching this for my Master's in social work class at the University of Chicago.
My diversity and social justice professor showed this in class this semester. I cannot get enough. I've not stopped digging for more on this subject! Shout out to Professor Walton for presenting such rich content all semester long!
Too me cultural humility is knowing and loving yourself so much that you truly can appreciate and value others!
that's right Valerie absolutely I agree.
Hi Professor Chavez! I took your Community Organizing class at SF State 6 years ago. I switched majors and graduated from the Women's Studies program there, but right now I'm in the last semester of my nursing program in Fresno. I'm so glad you posted this video! I really, really needed to see it!
I am 24 years old. When this happened, I was much too young to understand. However, being aware in my 20's, I am shocked at how similar this story is compared to the outrage now from the death of unarmed black men in the USA. This entire issue has been a long time coming.
I had to watch this for my Master's in Social Work and it opened my eyes of how much I do not know about the world around me. I should ask the uncomfortable questions to become familiar. We are always learning.
My name desirre dawn Hayes. Seeing yiur vudeo has literally saved me from depression and unfocused anger, fustration and confusion. Here the majority if the community has issues with hardcore substance abuse and reoccuring history of relapse and emotionioal trauma. As a recivering meth addict i was inspired to use my testimony in my professional life as a beacon of light to others who were loosing hope of having a successful home/school/professional and/or family@life. Did not happen as hoped.
Came across this cathartic film whilst browsing the theme of humility. Thank you so much for the epiphany that you and the contributors have given me.
This video was spot on! The world needs this right now! The world needed for the past 400 years. Thank you!
So inspiring! 🙏Thank you so much - these 28 minutes have planted a priceless seed in my life and I'm already grateful for the fruit it'll bear.
Had to watch this for work, but I'm glad I did. It is sad to think about how similar things are from 1991 to 2021, but this video is well done and offers food for thought and ideas about how to be better.
_What a beautiful practice/philosophy/way of life._ I believe everyone can learn from this and implement in their lives. Thank you so much for producing this. I do think about it a lot. When I was 19 I lived in the Philippines and learned Tagalog. And for the past 11 years, Filipino culture has been so important to me. And listening and adopting certain things from the culture has made me feel more fulfilled and loved as a human being and it has made me a better person too. We all have stories. And when we self-examine and strive for communication and empathy about others lived-in experiences I feel like it broadens is so much.
Thank you so much for this beautiful and intelligent film. I am a teacher for a graduate level service learning project where we are given the priviledge to partner with Cambodian organizations committed to ending violence against women. I will be requiring my students to watch this film. I feel it best describes this "philosophy," than anything I had heard before. Thanks for articulating something that resonates deeply.
Such a great piece of work. Challenging the language we use around culture from competence to humility is so powerful and helpful.
Thank you so much for this video. I continually learn and progress through videos like this, and I appreciate your time and knowledge!
This is a terrific video! Thank you for making it.
This is so powerful! A colleague of mine shared this with a group of social work and nursing students we are supervising. So empowering and challenging!
These are great concepts and as discussed in the program...another tool. I believe that cultural humility, together with the framework of cultural competency, we have a powerful set of tools combined to support more responsive and appropriate engagement. We have to continue to evolve the learning and conversations about how best to serve or work in partnership with diverse and multidimensional individuals, families and communities. Thanks for doing this and putting out for us to discuss or use.
Great video! I hope that this video can help future professionals such as myself be prepared for the challenges and nuances that we face with culture and practicing cultural humility.
Yes, please. The film was produced to teach about Cultural Humility and its application in the fields of Education, Research, Health, Social Work, etc.
What an eye opening and inspiring presentation. I cannot wait to share this with my maternal health nursing students and get their reactions and perspectives on this.
Beautifully done. Thank you!
In my field (Clinical Psychology) the term "cultural competence" is used quite often. I've had a nagging feeling about the term not sitting well with me, and this documentary put words to that feeling in a beautiful and easily understood way. I plan to share it with my classmates. Thank you!
I wonder if you every changed your major or not? I am only asking because I did not learn about cultural humility until I got into the masters of social work program. Many of my class mates came into the program with psychology as their previous major.
This is an awesome video and perfectly explains cultural humility. I plan to use this with my class of undergraduate sociology students this semester! thank you so much!
Thank you for this. It has opened a whole new world that I will add to my teaching, writing and work colleagues. Cultural humility has replaced cultural competence in the ethics section of a textbook I am writing on participatory community organizing. I hope we can become acquainted.
Powerfully beautiful. thank you.
I love this to the moon and back. So powerful!
This is a documentary about Tervalon's and Murray-Garcia's very important work, and discussions among their peers. Well done Health Education student project. More of a grass-roots perspective might have been interesting, but I understand that cultural humility is especially important for people working in the health sector.
Thank you for the reminders. I need to keep learning on loop 🧬🌀💃 🐚 🥀🌱🌘
This is an excellent documentary, a teaching tool for reflection amongst students and institutions. Reflection, and realization of a possibility for understanding. This is a lesson in compassion and connectedness to others who are not the same. We can always assume that someone else is either exactly the same, or that we know what they are going through. Communication is key and wisdom circles.
Thank you, this has been a huge part of my journey of life-long self-education. Thank you so much!
lifted my heart
I am going to use this theory to unpin my upcoming thesis which forces on First-Generation College Students. Excellent.
Just want to challenge the notion that a fearless confrontation cannot also be loving (16:00)- in fact I think love cannot exist in a relationship where either party is afraid to confront the other about what is important.
This is a wonderful film and a great tool for teaching critical self-reflection. Thank you!
This is a touching and informative video. thank you for your work
GREAT VIDEO VIVIAN!
What I dislike most, as it pertains to these ideals, is that certain groups want everyone else to be sensitive to their distinct needs& struggles. However, they are rarely, if ever, concerned about the various issues& hardships of others. If anyone dares calls them out on this glaring reality,, those persons run the risks of encountering serious attacks or harm.
So much to learn...
This relevant and important today.
Thank-you for sharing this powerful and excellent video for all to learn! I would like to share it with nursing students whom I teach as we learn together.
How beautiful is the dancing by the woman
I love this video and I show it to all new employees, but why is the cc only in English?
Bravo! When I grow up I want to be her! It is not the "cultural humility" what are you expressing, what is talking here, is your heart, your Christian heart, expressing our desires, common to all human beings because being a good person, wanting good to everyone and for everything is the most important goal we must pursue! Thank you!
I would add that it is not just a "christian" heart...but also expressive of a Muslim hear, a Hindu heart, a Buddhist heart, a Unitarian heart...I suggest you also bring into your transcultural process a respect for ALL religions and spiritual practices that foster the expression of the human "heart". Ethnocentrism is poison to cultural humility.
Excellent! I would like to use the film for teaching purposes for family medicine residents, medical students and colleagues.
Thank you very much. This is an excellent video for everybody in all places around the world. How can we get this treasure in spanish?
I would like your permission to show this excellent video to a class of students in a Masters Program for Genetic Counselling at the University of British Columbia in Canada. Canadian copyright law requires I have have your written permission in advance of showing this video, even though it is publically available on TH-cam. Let me know if you have any questions prior to responding
Many good thoughts and sadly many labels.
How do you cite quotes from this?
16:20 Cultural Humility in Community Based Participatory Research
This goes back to personal bias. In the world of service (medical, social work, teaching) one must drop biases when servicing the public. Great video, but we need to call a duck a duck instead of a goat.
Im currently Studying human Services at #SRJC and my goal is to get a Social Justice Certificate 🎓
Can someone caption this so that it will be equitable for people who are deaf? Thank you!
click on the cc button on the video
Those are auto-generated captions and are not typically very accurate.
Having just watched the whole video with the auto-generated captions on, I can say that they got over 95% of the dialogue right.
Melanie, if your request is still relevant after the contributions below and if you can wait until approx end of December, please reply, and I'll do you a transcript of the film.
I appreciate the comment about captioning! Let me first clarify that I'm not Deaf, but I do a lot of training and would love to use this video but I make it a point not to use non-captioned videos. I was hoping those who created/posted the video would make it accessible. If I have to, I download videos and create captions so that I can use them in training but it's always nice when the owners do this themselves--so that it's accessible to everyone. I especially expect that topics such as this would be inclusive. So, gnostie, I appreciate your offer, but only if you want to collaborate...if you did create a transcript, I could add the timings and then approach the owner of this video to see if she will upload SRT file so that ALL can have access. Cheers.
EdTalk on handling Ego: th-cam.com/video/PDvnjMzI6v8/w-d-xo.html
Disappointing. It's like the people in the video made the video for themselves. They never actually defined Cultural Humility, never actually taught the audience how to engage in Cultural Humility or showed us an example of it or showed us comparison of it vs Cultural Competency. Huge missed opportunity. Seemed clear their intended audience was themselves and that that is why no concept were actually explained, no transitions or real life connections made.
I think they were trying to say be open to people and their stories, imagine being in their shoes, and do not think you will ever know what everyone is thinking because we all have our own story, we should not make assumptions. It cannot be taught like people thought cultural competency could.
Did you actually watch the same video I watched? Because not only is it dissected and discussed throughout, there is also a brief, direct explanation of the concept at the 9-minute mark that sums it up perfectly.
They actually start defining it from the beginning of the video: "Cultural humility is...love, escuchar (meaning "listen" in Spanish), compassion," etc. Next they give 3 components: Life long learning and critical self-reflection, we must mitigate the power imbalances in service provider to client relationships, and the institutions where we work or get services must model these components. Next they give an example of where comparing cultural competence v. cultural humility when an African American nurse encountered a Latino patient. Etc. The whole video is defining cultural humility. So I don't see what more they could have done or said to define it 🤷🏼♂️ But if this doesn't make sense to you, I'd encourage you to continue looking for more resources about cultural humility that may make more sense to you instead of just rejecting this one. ✌🏻
I would also encourage you to ask yourself what cultural humility means to you. If you don't have a definition, just define "culture" or "cultural" and then "humility" and put them together.
Sir I believe you are experiencing cognitive dissonance. The implicit bias we are all indoctrinated with is blocking you from hearing what they said. The only difference between you and I is I know I have implicit biases and I actively work to identify them and challenge them daily. If you are not able to accept the first part for yourself- you will never see the need to manage it and therefore, will be seated in cognitive dissonance when triggered by your biases. This is why you can see the irrational, insensitive and offensive nature of your comments.
My brother is in jail modern day slavery for a crime he did not commit. Him and everybody else in prison what a joke
I am a Caucasian male, what about my 'Cultural Humility'?? Seems like you forgot this in your video. I am gun toting, Bible carrying white boy from the South. Does that fit your definition of Cultural Competence and Cultural Humility?
Jon Last AMEN
@Rosie: Wow, what an ignorant comment. You obviously haven't spent any time with white people, or any people for that matter.
@@rosiecheekies517 You are a racist.
I am a South Asian, American citizen raised in NYC, Queens.This will backfire politically once again. WWG1WGA Q, kag 2A rights
Let's appreciate white culture too, that is European culture. European culture is also amazingly EXCEPTIONAL!
TH-cam is suppressing my free speech on this thread and platform. This is why President Donald J. Trump will win, again in 2020.