The Idea That Every Hierarchy Is Predicated on Power Is an Assault on Competence
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ค. 2024
- Watch the full video - • Jordan Peterson and Ro...
Dr. Peterson's extensive catalog is available now on DailyWire+: utm.io/ueJdK
// SUPPORT THIS CHANNEL //
Premium Podcast - jordanbpeterson.supercast.com/
Newsletter: linktr.ee/DrJordanBPeterson
Donations: jordanbpeterson.com/donate
// COURSES //
Discovering Personality: jordanbpeterson.com/personality
Self Authoring Suite: selfauthoring.com
Understand Myself (personality test): understandmyself.com
// BOOKS //
Beyond Order: 12 More Rules for Life: jordanbpeterson.com/Beyond-Order
12 Rules for Life: An Antidote to Chaos: jordanbpeterson.com/12-rules-...
Maps of Meaning: The Architecture of Belief: jordanbpeterson.com/maps-of-m...
// LINKS //
Website: jordanbpeterson.com
Events: jordanbpeterson.com/events
Blog: jordanbpeterson.com/blog
Podcast: jordanbpeterson.com/podcast
// SOCIAL //
Twitter: / jordanbpeterson
Instagram: / jordan.b.peterson
Facebook: / drjordanpeterson
#JordanPeterson #JordanBPeterson #DrJordanPeterson #DrJordanBPeterson #DailyWirePlus #Path #Pathway #Power #Foundation #Resolution #Concept #ZeroSum #Tyranny #Tyrannical #Distribute #Distribution #Competent #Competence #Hierarchy #Problem #Problems #Solve #Solving #Solved #HighResolution #Responsible #Responsibility #Microcosm #Meaning #Thrive #Thriving #Charm #Human #Humans #HumanBeing #HumanBeings #Patriarchy #Gender #Believe #Belief #Beliefs #Oppressor #Oppressed #Depend #Dependence #Justify #Justification #Authority #Biblical #Manifest #Manifestation #ZeroSumGame #Ideology #Positive #PositiveSum #Position #Lazy #Laziness #Observe #Observation #Relationshop #Relationships #Negotiate #Negotiation #Friend #Friends #Friendship #Friendships #Personal #Reality #Psychopathic
An old neighbor of mine was a plumber… He used to admit that he would deliberately spend hours under someone’s house on a job that took 15 minutes to complete. The customers didn’t know any different and he reaped the benefits. Never got busted. Because the system was legally setup with the loophole in place. Obviously he knew it was illegal, yet nothing could stop him from the behavior. I wonder how many loopholes like this are in politics.
@@ph0522 And or watch/"assist" the plumber as they do the job. May even learn how to do it yourself for next time.
The ultimate loophole. Grandstand every day to get elected, the grandstand some more without changing anything, and run for election again.
@@6alisk vote every n years to elect a person who is just another puppet in a bloody circus of modern politics
@@6alisk True. Would that be considered a political “party”?)
Great analogy!
While it's true that most people who ascend hierarchies are doing so based on competence, there's no denying that those at the top have a tendency to misuse or exploit their positions once they realize that they can get away with it with few consequences because they don't have a superior to keep them in check.
Every hierarchical system in history has been misused or exploited.
So you’d like a larger hierarchy? If you want a superior to delegate then you’re just creating a larger and stronger system capable of more exploitation.
Sadly its a price we most pay to be human and free, would you want to live in a world were a computer overlord watch everything you do and makes sure you never go out side of right thinking?
peterson is trying to fool people by conflating natural hierarchy with socially constructed ARTIFICIAL CAPITALIST HIERARCHY.
the hierarchies of capitalism are /\ pyramid shaped, while every natural hierarchy of competence is a bell curve () with few at the top and bottom and the MAJORITY in the middle.
/\ pyramid hierarchies are artificial and integral to capitalism/profit, there has to be a very large base of low paid workers in a capitalist hierarchy in order for profit to be generated, profit is not possible in a natural bell curve hierarchy because there aren't enough people at the bottom to skim labor value from.
capitalism is UNNATURAL and abusive because of that fact.
/\ = artificial
() = natural.
More wisdom from the master! Love this guy!
It works the other way too. You could have an institution known for competence and absolutely wreck it by having it act with authority but with incompetence, would ruin it. Such institutions naturally dissolve over time unless preserved with force.
Then purge modern love, queerdom, perversion and queer marriage.
Clearly this is out of control and merely studying this from such a narrow angle isn't solving the problem!
And after all, RADICALIZATION aka destroying all relationships in a society with the specific goal of toppling that society IS A TENET OF THE MARXIST CULT RELIGION!
We are seeing EVERYTHING blow up because WE DON'T RESPECT MORALS THAT GOD AUTHORED THOUSANDS OF YEARS AGO.
Molehills WILL ALWAYS become mountains in an immoral society because MASS INSANITY will ALWAYS follow MORAL insanity.
Nothing is ever a zero sum game. Politicians need to be re-educated regarding the dangers and ramifications of power hunger motives. Thank you gentlemen ✝️❤️
6:30 - a lack of internal development, a distortion of the opportunity to develop childhood fellowships on the child's own level by the children themselves,(bullying to learn the physical, emotional and social lessons of "pecking order" they are lost without this experiential development( no one ever wins mean everyone loses)
you win some you lose some and nobody stays on top for more than the challengers allow has vanished as a perspective (safe spaces now instead)
these lessons are structural and used to be formed using their parents and grandparents as their future role models
Jordan B.Peterson is amazing can't wait to read his book 12 rules for life.
The value of competence is power
Spot on Jordan Peterson. Thank you.
Good Talk!
So, my libertarian side agrees with most, but zero sum does happen...monopolies. I'm not against winner take all, but I am against companies like Apple, Google (ironically progressive companies), that have literally destroyed industry or small businesses, without having to compete or intentionally blocking competition. We've all seen the lawsuits, arguments, and we've all seen the minuscule penalties.
Zero sum does happen and its not just those who are constantly getting abused or invite abuse.
I was somewhat distracted watching this so a number of rewinds was required. After a few rewinds, u know, I get it now the vid was very easy to follow. All in all a good production👍
dominance vs prestige
My life is a little bit better because of Jordan Peterson speaking the truth.
7:04 - the desire for surety, need for confidence of current ethos/actions easily entices most people to construct rigid or imagined permanence to their internal hierarchy constructs,
the fewer devices of internal change/perspective they have developed earlier in their lives the more critical it becomes for these anchors of reason/decision not to be changed.
the more flexible, imaginative and temporary these inter-changeable hierarchies of ethos/actions are, the less difficult and even joyful the learning process can be.
if all things are temporary then you had better quickly discover and share the value in it whatever form it may take
“Hitler was unbelievably good at letting the crowd tell him what to say. You know, he was, he was a mirror for the crowd, and he was a good orator. But he paid attention to the crowd, so when he said something that made everyone cheer, you know, their dark hearts would come out in the mob and cheer about something he said that was, say, dramatic or vengeful. Well, then, he’d say more of that... and so the crowd taught him over time exactly what to sell them. And that can be good in some sense.” Jordan Peterson, poppy-wearing neo-Nazi
You're touching on my heart strings , Is there a place, an email or something where I could send some definition and truth and context via testimonies and life story as well as observations and then some revelatory type scopes , where could I connect ?
....Yet "without "chaos can power exist ..a non zero of power is extinction....... ?
The value of competence in a hierarchy is power.
exactly. Competence is just power justified. But it’s power nonetheless. It’s why smart and nerdy guys don’t get laid.
I understand the point. However, what does someone understand for "power"? For instance, Thomas Hobbes defines power as the capacity to achieve a goal. In such definition, "power" is aligned with "competence". On the other hand, some define power as "oppression exerted by force". Therefore, "power" could signify "competence" to some, and to some it could mean "oppression".
Did that last uploaded video get memory holed while I was watching it?
Or did the channel take it down.
Dr Peterson, I’ve never heard you speak much about Tolkiens LOTR. It’s very curious to me that he emphasised man’s obsession with power. Ie. the ring and its allure on men.
Clearly, he was writing before postmodernism, and there’s no evidence he was influenced by Nietzsche at all. I am curious to know why “power” was such an important part of the way he conceptualised human beings?
It’s important to note this doesn’t just apply to male characters either, because there are strong female characters ie. Galadriel etc. who are also tempted by the same will to power.
Many thanks for all your work!
All competence hierarchies are the increasing of power.
Power is the ability to translate intention into reality.
A plumber is someone who has become the power to distinguish and create effective plumbing.
Jordan is unconsciously triggered by power because his emotional development was disempowered by the emotional incompetence hierarchy imposed on him by his severely traumatized father. Jordan has unconsciously internalized and conflated "power" with the disempowering opinions and stubbornness of a father unconsciously run by the decisions of an emotionally trapped and traumatized boy. Walt described his father as "(a conflict) over damn near everything!!"
Well said
I think the psychology of the individuals in power is the scary part!
power is the source of competence just as it is the source of a computer's ability to operate.
I may have mentioned this before in another comment on the same topic. In physics and engineering " power " is not defined as political power nor as power of any other social or administrative authority such as parents, teachers, police officers, managers, etc. Instead in the context of physics power is simply the ABILITY to do work. Without that type of power there could be no competence of any kind. And let's face it in many organizations competent folks are often promoted to positions of greater administrative "power." A popular book some decades ago called THE PETER PRINCIPLE illustrated that trend. Folks are promoted up the organizational hierarchy till they reach a level of incompetence. And there they remain . . . stuck until they quit, retire, are fired, or die.
we want monkeys to be competent as the best and brightest of humans because monkeys represent us at our basest, laziest. our easiest, most cost effective to maintain. and we seem to be under the delusion that this cost will remain as low as it is even if we make it competent as the best and brightest. that passing down this knowledge to the monkeys will be perfect with absolutely no flaws and will be entirely efficient in its own right.
he explains the difficult concepts like they r nothing. when some one with IQ of 80 (me) can understand this it is so strange that so called intellectuals dont...(respect aus Österreich)
peterson is trying to fool people by conflating natural hierarchy with socially constructed ARTIFICIAL CAPITALIST HIERARCHY.
the hierarchies of capitalism are /\ pyramid shaped, while every natural hierarchy of competence is a bell curve () with few at the top and bottom and the MAJORITY in the middle.
/\ pyramid hierarchies are artificial and integral to capitalism/profit, there has to be a very large base of low paid workers in a capitalist hierarchy in order for profit to be generated, profit is not possible in a natural bell curve hierarchy because there aren't enough people at the bottom to skim labor value from.
capitalism is UNNATURAL and abusive because of that fact.
/\ = artificial
() = natural.
Thats why its a mistake to refer so much to “dominance hierarchies”. Most hierarchies are gratitude hierarchies.
Is the lust for power, the doctrine or dogma of evil?
Lust is a sin, to miss the mark.
One ought to ask why the lust? Maybe there's a deeper desire.
@@marsjokes Could it be rebellion & chaos?
@@clearvision4233 if it's rebellion, it could be attached to freedom, motivated by the desire for freedom.
If it's chaos, perhaps it could be freedom too. I mean, if one desired chaos, they must desire the unpredictable. Which means they maybe existing in a rigid, maybe stale, structure?
@@clearvision4233 "chaos"
The idea that society _isn't_ predicated on power is an attack on rationality.
Competence plays a role of course and the two are measured in some capacity but the idea the most competent individual automatically rises to the top irrespective of their initial conditions is risible.
For the majority of history the most competent individual would simply have been tilling grass in a field.
peterson is trying to fool people by conflating natural hierarchy with socially constructed ARTIFICIAL CAPITALIST HIERARCHY.
the hierarchies of capitalism are /\ pyramid shaped, while every natural hierarchy of competence is a bell curve () with few at the top and bottom and the MAJORITY in the middle.
/\ pyramid hierarchies are artificial and integral to capitalism/profit, there has to be a very large base of low paid workers in a capitalist hierarchy in order for profit to be generated, profit is not possible in a natural bell curve hierarchy because there aren't enough people at the bottom to skim labor value from.
capitalism is UNNATURAL and abusive because of that fact.
/\ = artificial
() = natural.
I mean you can just do your own plumbing
Competence is true power as humans are tools of creation. Acting with authority without competence is simply a means to manipulating others therefore tyrannical.
isn't competence a form of power? Isn't there a saying; "knowledge is power"?
Hierarchies aren't based on power. And there are no "western hierarchies". Every hierarchy is built exactly the same from here to Japan.
They are, however, based off of monkey instincts and not all of us are monkeys. If the hierarchy doesn't make room for humans who, don't have to comply because they are human, then it is based off of evil, not power.
Ur wrong babe. Dan Schneider, Jeffrey Epstein, JOE BIDEN
Is it that Jordan doesn't understand that political power is what is being indicted ? Some hierarchies are built on competency, like those of business' where entrepreneurs brought their vision to fruition by taking the risks and delaying their gratification to own their business hierarchy that succeeded and may employ many resources and people. Some hierarchies are built through violent power; Political hierarchies are built through this way. Political power exists by dictate, and by force of military and police. Voting does not confer ruler-ship over those who do not agree on these terms from the beginning. You would assume freedom and property was given to you by government vs. existing with individuals if you thought property was titled only by dictate by government. Jordan is talking past these serious inquiries.
Not if you regard politicians as public servants. Not if you recognize that the power is actually with the people who vote, and not with the politicians.
@@marsjokes That sounds nice in theory, but that's not the reality. I'm not going to have any politicians arrested, but it doesn't take much to get political authority at your home or business if you don't space your tables six feet apart or haven't mowed your lawn. No politician in contractually bound to any voter. More importantly is this presumption that political power is valid because some voting group put forth a majority vote and now has power over everyone; those who didn't want either candidate, and those who lost. This is logically outrageous.
@@ronpaulrevered yes democracy is the worst form of political organization apart from all the other ones.
@@ronpaulrevered I'd say your analysis may be correct in terms of what's been happening for a very long time. But... the beginnings of political structures were not formed by "gangsters", especially not in smaller communities. Each public servant was vetted by the public before being deemed worthy of serving the public, and her interests.
As communities became bigger, the more complex the structures became for the common people, and the easier it was for bullies to use force to take and stay in higher positions of the established hierarchies.
This is a really complex issue, but it's roots still stem from the voters' perception of who's who in the structure.
@@marsjokes I think you should read
what Lysander Spooner had to say about the Constitution. If it wasn't a contractual deal with every individual, then it is not valid. Governments were created not by demand, but by economic conquest in a collusion between large economic powers and governments with armies and a claim to authority.
your lobster analogy is unscientific and blatantly false 😊 actually many of your statements are
You disagree lobsters have hierarchies?
How about lions?
Or monkeys?
No hierarchies?
@@dlg78 peterson is trying to fool people by conflating natural hierarchy with socially constructed ARTIFICIAL CAPITALIST HIERARCHY.
the hierarchies of capitalism are /\ pyramid shaped, while every natural hierarchy of competence is a bell curve () with few at the top and bottom and the MAJORITY in the middle.
/\ pyramid hierarchies are artificial and integral to capitalism/profit, there has to be a very large base of low paid workers in a capitalist hierarchy in order for profit to be generated, profit is not possible in a natural bell curve hierarchy because there aren't enough people at the bottom to skim labor value from.
capitalism is UNNATURAL and abusive because of that fact.
/\ = artificial
() = natural.