विशाल साम्राज्य और स्थिर शासन के बावजूद ज्ञान-विज्ञान के विकास में फिसड्डी थे Mughal
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 มิ.ย. 2023
- जिस दौर में भारत में मुगल शहंशाह और दूसरे राजा-महाराजा तलवार भांज रहे थे, शिकार कर रहे थे, मुजरा देख और सुन रहे थे और अपने लिए महल और मर चुके परिजनों के लिए मकबरे बना रहे थे, तब यूरोप पुनर्जागरण के बाद धर्म को शासन से अलग करने में जुटा था. यूरोप के लिए वह वैज्ञानिक क्रांति और औद्योगिक क्रांति का दौर था. वह पूरा दौर भारत को छुए बिना गुजर गया.
इस बारे में आप ये लेख दिप्रिंट पर पढ़ सकते हैं- hindi.theprint.in/opinion/why...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Member benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our TH-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
![เกิดใหม่ทั้งทีก็เป็นสไลม์ไปซะแล้ว ซีซั่น 3 - ตอนที่ 58 [ซับไทย]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TgNEbYSTY0Y/mqdefault.jpg)
Best analysis ever seen in today’s context on Indian history.. well done sir
Mughal period was golden age of India
Mughal period was the golden age of Mughals.
@@adma7298 no
@@ud1976 India is identified by Mughals. West idealized Mughal India
@@adma7298 no
Mandal bhau pure secular aadmi hai, har taraf se galiyan khate hain.
sahi baat..haha
Asli wale Secular🙏👍
Nahi keval aasmani kitab walo se gali khate hai.
Kyuki aasmani kitab valo ke liye terk vigyan bahut door ki Kodi hai.
@@sameergautam4053 Thoda padh likh lo, kaun sa vigyan kis ne kab kiya hai sab pata lag jayega. Kitne padhe ho?
Not only Mogul , none of of Muslim dynasties of world during that period and now also did anything significant in science and technology . It is something to do with religion than people.
Agreed. Even Arabs earlier had scientific temper was destroyed because of Islam. Vaishskya shastra by Rishi Kanad had mention of atoms and molecules
You think you know about it? Entire history graduate here! haha...Get some education on this matter..muslim socieities advanced science when europe was in dark ages. Search "muslim contributions to science". You will find more material than you can read in an entire year
Hello is a member of bjp it cell, he never come here reply for you , he have only one propaganda against muslims.@@tauheedahmad6115
Lol they all were Iranians islam has nothing to do lol even radical lslam was the reason of their destruction😂😂😂@@tauheedahmad6115
Mr Dilip Mondal you always say things against brahmins that they did lot of atrocities against lower cast of hindus. but you never say anything about atrocities done by Muslims on dalits. Can you also share what do you think about opinion of Dr. BhimRao Ji Ambedkar on muslims. Also are you against casteism or hinduism ?.
Iska dhandha bnd kregaa kya 😂😂
Baba Sahib had adopted the surname ( Ambedkar) of his teacher who was a Brahmin.
Only these neo Ambedakarites are anti Brahmins
These Mandal bots too are manufactured in Oxford, Cambridge, Stanford, Rutgers university sociology labs. Another western peg into another Indian faultline.
Brahmins have not any authority over citizens. Rulers have authority to implement law and discipline and equality. Perpetrators will be punished
kyu muslim ki burai sunke dil ko sukun milta h ky 🤣🤣🤣 jb tumhre ghar me tumhri pitai ho to tum ye bologe ki pdosi bhi peet rha h to chalne do
This is by far the most logic explanation of why we should not consider the Mughal rule as a Great historic period. This narrative of Mughal being great is painted by Nationalist historians as they wanted to establish the Indian history as a Delhi besed and north centric. Mughal rule was one of the darkest period of Indian history. The rule was only focus on elitism and completely ignored the common masses.
Absolutely right and I want to correct one thing that it wasn't Nationalist historians but communist and leftist who gave that much exposure to Mughals and always tries to glorify their mediocre rule.
@@vibhutisrivastava2789 true. Left historians always gave a extra importance to mughal rule and didn't gave enough space to regional powers such as maratha rajputs and south indian kingdoms.
This shows your biased approach... The ruling class in India was always based on exclusivness... And history has always been from the perspective of elite... No doubt that in scientific progress tha mughals remained behind and same is true for all Asian monarches.. Remember that the first Asian country to modernise was Japan which only modernised in early 20 th century... The china under ming dynasty didn't modernise... Still they are considered great as they contributed in cultural and political fields... The mughals contributed immensly in cultural, agriculture, administeative, fields.. Remember dahsala, zabti system, chera dagh system, rahat wheel, great sanskrit and persian literature, GT road, modern currency,... Can i ask which scientific and cultural contribution the marathas made😊
@@yameenulhaq280 certainly maratha did not made much modern scientific progress but maratha rule was short live and during that period they build a modern Navy and excellant administration during Chatrapati Shivaji s rule. Plus one more Marathas never tried to convert people of other religion like Muslims did. Marathas always ensure inclusive administration and success story of Maratha Empire itself was a huge success story of Vertical mobility within cast system as Marathas were shudra and they went on to rule large part of India. But i don't know my Indian Muslims consider Aurangzeb as their father and they defend him and his Dynasty 😂😂😂😂 like u r defending him now. Mughals were mangols and not Indian.
@@aaibhagwati 😂😂😂. How can u lie like this... What was the condition of sudras during maratha rule, they could not enter city during day time... If they were sudras then why did sudras align with british against them in battle of bhuma koreagaon... If shivani was so shudra then why did ghaga bhat had to fake his ancestors from kshatriya clan called sisodiya... Why coudnt a dalit become king... If mughals had forced others to convert thrn why at the centre of mughal empire around delhi there are less muslism. But in states like assam and kerela thr percentage of Muslims is higher... And 33 percent of aurengzebss nobles were hindus.... Raja todarmal, jaisingh, birbal ,tansen held high...positions, ..
This is very good explanation and pretty much sum up the Mughal Era! However I have few things to add!
1) Mughal didn't convert a lot of people into Islam because non Muslims used to pay jizya and was significant revenue for them.
2) I think in sanatan dharma we had a scientific temperament. But I guess it got lost and idea of karma got convoluted. Before 12th century all the scientific discovery was made in India. After santan dharm became Hinduism we lost our way.
3) India was champion in capitalism and free market economy. It was the English that came and destroyed it. Lets not forget EIC needed kings charter to trade, where as to trade in India they seldom required any permission.
4) Varna system imposed in mediaeval India was the biggest disaster that could have happened to India.
Matlab kuch bhi.... Jaziya was not even a minimal source for income as it was not less, than 2 percent moreever poor women, children and old, we're excluded.. Land revenue was the only major source of income apart from foreign trade.. Moreever Muslims paid zakat and rate was more than jaziya.
And who told u that varna system orginated in medical india... Was manusmriti written in medical india, was arthshaastra written in medival india where kautilya talks about superior brahmans and dehimanises shudras... Perhaps u would have read it in what's app forward
And who told u that before 12 th century all scientific discoveries, we're made in India... Scientific advancement stopped in India after end of gupta rule in ssith century... Moreever other civilissations like egyptian, Chinese, mesopotamia, greec, romans also made great advancements, ever heard about precision of Chinese calander, the scientific acymen of egyptians in building pyramids, invention of gumpowder by chinese😅, the aduadaqts, and collosium of romans, the roads of roman empire... Don't be so arrogant...
@@yameenulhaq280 we should stop green washing these things. Jaziya is an example there are more tax that Hindus had to pay and Muslim were exempt of them. You can be naive in thinking it didn’t affect hindu. Paying a tax to follow your belief is most brutal form of torture. Plus it’s not just 2 percent. Jaziya was Levied on a per year basis, 12 dhiram per person per year. Even with a population of 10 million you can collect a significant money with it
@@abhishekadile1270 so u agree with all my points and now are only confused about jaziya.... So Muslims paid zakat and hindus were excluded... So why we have to pay tax to follow our religioous beliefs... And jaziya rate, was around 5 percent... Moreever it was abilished by akbar in 1564 but reintroduced by aurengzeb in 1679..and again abolished in 1712...so while Muslims always, paid zakat... Hindus for most part of mughal rule didn't pay any jaziya... And people who took tax from lower caste women to cover their brests should not worry about a small tax😉
@@yameenulhaq280 Jiziya was not 5%. During Allahudin khalji's rule it was 55%. And other sultans imposed a tax between 25-35%. It's not the only tax on Hindus. Hindus paid house tax, crop tax (33% during Mughal rule), Grazing tax etc. Stop spreading misinformation.
That is why babasaheb accepted Buddhism, we are very thankful
I am simply amazed by the novelty of prospective and Depth of the aurgument on the contributions of Mugals in development of science and tech in India. I would loved to hear your view on the effect of contemporary political systems in furthering the field of science and technology in India.
A very good perspective in looking at history. It can be argued that the plentyfullness in India became the reason people didn't move towards science and reason.
मुगलों के सलाहकार तो भारत के ब्राहमण ही थे। जिन्होने मुगलों को अपनी बहन बेटी देके रिश्तेदारी क़ायम की व अपनी वरण वयवस्था बनाई रखी।
Kaun se Brahmins ne mughals ko beti di bhai??????
Isliye Mughals achhe hain? Bolna kya chahte ho? Pura goalshift karke brahmans ko responsible bana Dena chahte ho? 😅 Behenchod, tumlog sudhroge nhi😅
Pagal bhag yaha sa ak du ku chod kar baki sab peesian tha
अम्मी के यार की एक लफ्ज बुराई सुन नही सकता तू... कवर देने के लिए तुरंत ब्राह्मण की बुराई चालू😂😂
भारत ने मनुस्मृति के रूप में दुनिया का सबसे बड़ा रिसर्च किया है । इससे बड़ा आज तक कोई रिसर्च नहीं हुआ है।
Brilliant hypothesis and exposition!
मै आपको शंभू जी से ज्यादा बहुजनो यानी sc , st, obc का अदरणीय मनता हु 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
@SAGARKUMAR , यह तो बनिया है। फर्जी दलित चिंतक बन के नाम कमाया। अब माल के लिए संघ ( बनिया बक्काल का संगठन ) के फेवर में बेटिंग कर रहे हैं। 😅 बुजुर्गो ने सही कहा है कि बनिया बनी का नहीं तो मां की टनी का। 😂
मण्डल जी मनुवादी विचारधारा का समर्थन करने लगे हैं
One important point which is not talked about much is the banning of printing in 1458 in the Ottoman Empire which was a bridge between Indian subcontinent and Europe. Since in order to travel from Europe to India you have to pass through Arab states and Turkey which was under Ottoman empire during that time. This resulted in stopping the flow of new knowledge and ideas to India from Europe which was spreading like a wild fire and each country was competing and learning form each other. In these 200 years there was a huge difference which was created in the capabilities of Europe and India and due to which Europeans bypassed the Ottomans and travelled around Africa through sea to India and East Asia and established their colonies here.
Mughals was the best thing happened to India
@@adma7298 don't talk bullshit
@@adma7298 no they are foreigners
@@Peaceful_World130 all foreigners are best thing happened to India
@@adma7298 Since the time of Aryans who came from Greece hundreds of foreigners have come to the subcontinent! Kushans, Sakas, Scythians, Indo-greeks, ... and finally, Arabs, Turks, Afghans, Mughals/Mongols, British ! All of them have left imprints on the subcontinent! Before 19th century, even the concept of 'India' and its extent was not clear! So, who is a foreigner and who is a native, has different meanings! A large no. of such outsider-insider debates are communal, fanatic-driven hate-mongering!
Thanks
Dear Ram,
Thank you for contributing towards ThePrint's journalism.
Blessed to hear such journalism.
Bahut hi shaandaar aur informative peshkash.....
Dilip sir is one of rare journalist who brings facts. I may not like some of his opinions but that's acceptable, everyone has their opinion and they're entitled to that.
This is indeed a new explanation and a new narrative to see the entire Mugal periods.
Thanks sir
This is a historical narrative to see the historians to rewrite the history.
Why, there was no renaissance took place , eht there was no any revolutions started, why there was no industrial revolution.
There are many issues you have raised in this episod
Doing justice or tagging the Past with the eye of present time, I don’t think can be a best approach.Every empire,every king/queen/PM etc etc tries to do what the people majority of people demands and what is required to keep the administration continued. The meaning of development,growth,societal development,prosperity,power etc etc have been different in different in different time period of history..what’s important is To learn from the past what is good for this time and the future. 🇮🇳
सर,बहुत अच्छा और सहज भाषा से भारत का इतिहास समझाया.
जय भिम जय संविधान
मण्डल जी संघी हो चुके हैं हिन्दू और मुस्लिम राग अलापने लगे हैं ❤ सावधान
The regions where Mughal ruled in India are still among the least developed, it seems still facing after-shocks.
😂😂😂. If u had studied modern india and read that how british drained the resources through zamindari, ryotwari, mahwalari systems... U won't have asked such stupid question
@@yameenulhaq280 gandu, Brits got these systems from The Mughals itself
This is absolutely brilliant true analysis bye great Indian bahujan journalist Mr. Dilip C Mandal sahib salute 🫡
Excellent incisive point brought out, especially about the Hindu rebirth concept.
जब विदेशों में नये-नये आविष्कार हो रहे थे, तब भारत में "ढ़ोल, गंवार,शूद्र,पशु, नारी" लिखा जा रहा था।
Isliye Mughals ne science pe dhyan nhi diya😂 Aise nhi to wo bade scientist log the😅
Aaj bhi muslim countries ka yehe haal hai.
🙏🙄👌😊एक कम्युनिटी जो बोलती 800 साल हिंदुस्तान राज किया,जिसके अपने मजहब के आधार देश बनाया (पाकिस्तान,फिर बांग्लादेश), जिसके पर्सनल लॉ,🤭🙄3 सबसे बड़ी देश जमीन वक़्त बोर्ड (अधिनियम SC कुछ नहीं कर सकता),माइनॉरिटी यूनिवर्सिटी (OBC, SC, ST को सीट भी नहीं देते)जिसके 57 देश, स्टेट इस्लाम अनुसार 🤭🙏उसकी तुलना OBC,SC,ST,वचित, आदिवासियों करना गलत हजारों साल पीड़ित है ❤️👍🙏🙄मनमोहन जो बयान दिया आपिसमेंट, वोट बैंक दिया था कांग्रेस OBC अलग 27% हिस्सा उस ला रही है 52% लोग उसमें है (ममता OBC जाति मुसलमान सभी नोकरी दे दी SC उसे गलत बताया)🙄🙏SC, ST साथ यही होगा मुस्लिम, ईसाई इसी लाया जायेगा.... मुसलमान आगे बढ़ाना ठीक "वक़्त बोर्ड जमीन गरीब मुस्लिम क्यू नहीं दी जाती जो कुछ परिवार के पास है ❤️🤭🙄
Thanku professor mandal for giving your prospective.
This is creative stuudy .
Excellent analysis sir keep it up sir. Well done
Like most things, the truth is always somewhere in between.
बहुत अच्छा लगा, ज्ञानवर्धक
Interesting topic and very good observation. What happened during Maratha and Sikh Empire? How was the science or technology in their regimes?
Science was centered around Ujjain and Ujjain only if we speak about the north. Jantar Mantar is one of the best examples.
इस देश के सत्ताजीवियों के लिए मुगल का ज्ञान रखना जरूरी। है
A very good research .
🎉🎉 relevant topics.
Great information 🎉Sir
Good analysis!!
Wow! Great insight
Very nice sir
Mr D Mandal you are great Nice presentation you are One And only
Super
Behatrin sir
मंडल सर🙏 मै आज आपसे पहली बार सहमत हूं
Very bold and very original, all the best
शानदार विश्लेषण, मंडल साहब 👍👍🙏
बहुत सही विश्लेषण मण्डल साहब
Really Good video
❤❤❤❤❤ जब विदेशो में अविष्कार हो रहा था तब भारत में महान अविष्कार हो कर ब्राह्मण साहित्य लिखा ❤❤जे वरणाधम तेली कुम्हारा सुपच किरात कोल कलवारा लिखा जा रहा था
Nahi sir narazagi kesi ?
From both sides of narrative we have listened them. We r glad with your third narrative. History is one of the most liberal subject that allows for so many narratives to survive unlike other social sciences where they imitate science and claim for only 1 truth only to be existing.
Namo style😊.great
Pro.saheb aapne bahut mahatvpurna jankari di Thanks 🙏🙏🙏❤❤❤
मे मोची जाति से हूं, पर यह सच है , ब्राह्मण ने विज्ञान मै काफी योगदान दिया है
Great journalist mandal sir ko Jai hind
war requires use of sophisticated equipment & technology. Like Cannons or guns. These empires - did they invest in innovation & technology. Would like to hear more from you on this topic.
Awesome 👏
👍🏻
"0" Diya Mere Bharat Nai. Yoga, Meditation, Ayurveda, We have knowledge of Rotation of Moon, earth, Sun and other planetary objects, Hinduism is Philosophy based on Science or So to say Atma Manthan, from which we have identified that Our life is connected with Previous births, Yeah I do agree that Hinduism may have caught some impurity as it is thousands of years old. See our temples in different parts of India, which were constructed based on Science and Engineering, they are incredible standing tall from thousands of Years
Sir you have read geet ?
Jaibheam sir saandaar vaktabya karte hai aap❤❤❤❤❤
Good👌
Reminded me of OSHO
Very important information 😢
मण्डल जी मनुवादी पत्रकार हो गए हैं ❤❤ ❤❤❤❤
Sahi
Well done sir
Apna book k nam batyee sir
How so much scientific progress was made till 1200
Sir i support you
Mujhe ab pata chala is trah ka article koi exercise in intellect nahin balke apki boli lagi hai us ke package ka part hai- mandal ji
Even in discussion on Mughal he criticised hindu religion...
Europe enters into the dark as it adopted Christianity in the 3rd century and comes out only after the great plague devours one third of Europe in the 13th century and the ottoman push....
Hindu India has great universities all over the country which got destroyed in islamic invasion.
Even here mandal ji evaded islamic questions of otherisation of non Muslim and their otherworldlyness.....did't say a single word that Mughal were islamic...
He simply blamed Hindus for their ancient religion and compared them with other world when they were enslaved and fighting hard( heavy militarisation of Mughal)...it was the inability of mughal to convert natives that they adopted another way to secure their rule........
Absolutely right
मुगल शासकों के विजन में विज्ञान, तकनीक व सामाजिक विकास नहीं था। उनके विजन केवल एशो आराम और मुहब्बत का मजाक उङाना था स्कूल, कॉलेज और विश्वविद्यालयों खोलने की क्या जरूरत है।
जरूरी विमर्श!
अलग लेवल के है ये जनाब
sahi jawab h ki mughal londiyabaaz the. unhe kya matlab padhne likhne se. tabhi to brahmano ko maarte the aur library jalate the
Sahi bola
Dr. Sahab, please take care of BSP also. Please create some videos in favour of BSP. Regards
India supplied all the prerequisite knowledge of that progress of Europe, number theory , concept of negative number, zero, geometry of sulvasutra, trigonometry, calculus etc was developed by Indian mathematical genius much before Islam started its destruction and killing in india
In 1737 bajirao sacked delhi in return mughals gave everything beyond chambal river to marathas. In 1752 maratha peshwa nanasaheb imposed unilateral protectorate. After that it was marathas who were ruling most of india who lost their rule after third anglo maratha war in 1818. So marathas are also to blame for indias loss.
I think u r the most ignorant person on the earth
Bajirao did not sack Delhi. There are letters from Bajirao to his brother Chimajiappa saying specifically why it would be wrong to sack Delhi and his reasons for not doing so even though it was easily possible for him to do it. No such consideration was given by Nadir Shah two years later, nor by Ahmed Shah two decades later.
👍🏻👍🏻🌹
True this period led India to atrophy in science and technology
For the same reason, the Mughals started giving concessions and trading rights to the British East Indian Company, French East India Co, Dutch etc. to start trading with them and to bring in their European technology to India
A new perspective…🤷♂️
U have shown urs color to bahujan. Like u r the sleeper cell of forward.
किसी भी विषय पर वामपंथी और दक्षिणपंथी नजरिए की खूब चर्चा होती है लेकिन अब मध्यमार्गी (सम्यक मार्ग) का भी विचार विमर्श होना चाहिए
Sara dhyan hawas mitaane, dharamaantaran or aasmaani kitab ko maanne me tha.
Hamare me to hm bhagwan ved sb pr swaal utha dete h par inki kitaab me dharti chapti jaisi baat pr aaj tak koi ni bolta ki galt likha gya h.
पहले ये तो बताओ लिखा कहा गया है , दम है अगर तुम्हारे जवाब देने तो मेरे सवाल का जवाब दो की किधर धरती चपटी लिखी है , बुक नंबर , लाइन नंबर पूरा रेफरेंस दो , वरना अपनी व्हाट्सएप यूनिवर्सिटी के ज्ञान की बनाओ लुप्पी और पिछवाड़े में घुसेड़ लो, और इधर दिखना मत,
फुल रेफरेंस लेकर आना तब दिखना इधर ओके ?
I am agree with you
Jay bhim nmobudhy sir
Bjp rss evm hatao desh bachao jaybhim namo bhudhay
main bhi aksar yahi sochta hun jab mughal rulers itne bade raja the is desh mein aur muslim ka bol bala tha tb uska maximum generation aaj gareej kaise h aur adhiktar muslim gareeb h,koi puncture lga rha h to koi plate.
@hulagukhan-we3fw so can we say Muslims didn't rule India but they were just at the centre while the powerful Hindus hoard and accumulated the power just by putting the gun on those soldiers, it's is utter stupid and laughable when these puncture wala say we ruled India but they didn't know their real aukat,They were beggar and are beggar
I don't understand why our intellectual keep looking for European to describe our culture. Don't get me wrong but i think most of the time the European/ western historician try to understand things according to their prospective so that it can become easier for their people to understand. That's what i think.And as for the concept of birth and rebirth i think the birth of a person into whatever forms depends upon your previous life karma, but the current life depends on the karma that you do in this lifetime and its consequences i.e, what you do makes your life.
Chup kar science and technology wins
I was thinking what the other kings were doing when Renaissance was happening in Europe and mughala were sleeping...
Hare krishna 🎉
Life enjoying
Dilip Manda at its best...
it is true that mughals & Muslims were indifferent to education specifically towards what requires logical & rational thinking and observation.
But how would you explain development & progress in math, algebra, geometry & Ayurveda during Hindu period ( before invasions)
it was buddhist period (shraman culture) not your brahmanism okay. hindu period was after muslim invasion.
Mai jay Bhim wala hu ham log Mauryan Empire aur Maratha Empire ko manata hu kyuki ye dono yaha ke local ruler the
India was not pichada before Islam came. Before Islam came China considered India has land of knowledge and belived it was Heaven. India was center of scientific studies before Islam entered. Indians during Gupta empire had developed advanced Mathematics concepts, Medical science here was the best in the world, Indian knew about Sun (look at how scientifically sun temple in Konark is built) and planets relation (just visit any navagruha temple its shows Sun in center and planets around it, this were built 1,000 year before Galileo's birth ) . Gupta empire was the true Golden period of India. Brahmagupta, Aryabhata, Sushruta, Patangali are just few examples who lived during this period. Had our great universities not been destroyed by ignorant Sultans and Badshahs we could have been most advanced society today. Indians had also developed methods which accurately tells the location any planet (just look at any Janam Patrika). India gave most Scientific language Sanskrit and Also most Scientific religion such as Buddhism established 300 years before Jesus was born (Not considering Hinduism as religion), While all Abramic religion are Rigid and refer one book believing that anything which is not in that book False (they reject Solar Sytem, Evolution etc but Indian religion openly accept it).
😂😂😂😉haunty and arrogant... The gupta empire ended in 6 th century... What was the contribution of india in next 500 years before Muslims came... And naland awas already in ruins by 7 th century... Read heisun tsang works... And it was muslim rulers who ushered in an era of early modernity... The currency u use was given by sher shah suri ie rupiya. The grand trunk road was built by him, agriculture reforms like zabti, dahsala systems were introduced by them.. Military reforms like chera and dagh aws their contribution, the back bone of medival agriculture the persian wheel called rahat was introduced by them paper, gunpowder iron stirrup canons were introduced, agriculture loans calle..taccavi was introduced bt them... India contributed 25 percent to global gdp during muslim rule... Cities like dacca, baxur, murshidabad, delhi, surat, ahemadabad, daulatabad, aurangabad, lahore, ferozabad, flourished. . . New architecture techniques like dome, pietradura, we're introduced.. So stop reading what's app history
@@yameenulhaq280 what about the years before Sher Shah Suri...
🤣🤣
From 1206 till the time Sher Shah Suri sat on throne, not much had happened.
Delhi Sultanate mismanaged the economy 🤣
@@yameenulhaq280 Yeah you should definitely read Xuangzang ....
He came to Nalanda only for education, and Nalanda wasn't in ruin ...
It was ruined after Bakhtiyar Khilji destroyed it .
By the way, Why are you defending Foreign Muslim Sultans, Indian converts like you wouldn't be preferred anyway .
They preferred High Caste hindus to Indian converts like you .
Excellent analysis that Mughals were not visionary neither in spreading religion nor scientific temperament. In fact to continue their rule they just maintained the status quo not touching the wrong customs such as Sati partha since it was more among rajputs, backbone of Mughals army.
Similar analysis when I do on Ottoman Empire then I found it was very much same there as well although it was very close to Europe and in fact much stronger power till mid 17th century and suddenly both the empires started declining bcoz they could not see beyond their raas leelas, haram and hence were punished by nature
They instead brought tribal backwardness to India plus the hyper religiousness and hatred of Hindus and their places of worship.
Sati Was limited to Upper class Indians only , my Pasmanda friend
Halala, triple talaq ,burka ya sab to science ka according tha
Very conveniently and perhaps deliberately you have ignored to mention scientific contribution of Hinduism including astronomy, algebra, invention of zero, accurate studies of solar system and other stars. You also ignored India being centre of education and Nalanda being worlds largest University. Contrarily you are trying to hotch potch the subject by effectively speaking on the subject for only half the allotted time of episode.
Some renowned analyst need to reaserch in neutrality to find as to why Bharat chose to decline and remain in oblivion rather than to fight back and get their lost glory in these fields. To some extent this is true even today.
Imagine printing press and paper were TABOO evenin Turkey as late as 1900!,,,,,,,!
समझ में नहीं आ रहा है कि आखिर क्यों कागज के पन्नों से मुगल काल को हटकर लोंग क्या साबित करना चाहते हैं।
Mugal to hona chia but original history ka sath rapist, murderer, attackers,
Jai bhim sir
Sacchayi ye hai ki iske buddhism ke wajeh se bhartiya samaj me jati-vadi soch ka vikas hua. Iska Pramann, megasthaneese ki Indica se pata chalta hai, ki Chandra-Gupta Maurya ke time me samajic vyavastha kaisi thi.