these two were just born to sing together. they're like the Kate Winslet and Leonardo DiCaprio of the musical theater world. they bring out the best in each other. I love it when they work together
There is something transcendental in Ramin and Sierra's performances, true and rare beauty, admiration, respect and friendship. They inspire love so sincerely that It on easily brings tears to us. Pure beauty.
I don't know but it felt like Ramin and Sierra were born to sing for each other. Their voices just complement each other so perfectly. My favorite beautiful iconic duo.
@SoHardToBeMe - they set him up with Anna O'Byrne for Korea Phantom reading. What a mistake. No chemistry. He's also touring Oz with AO. Such a mistake. He and Sierra are a power singing couple.
Oh my gosh the sound of their voices together makes my heart fill with such joy! I'm not even ashamed to say I cried all the way through this piece. They are so amazing together, and I can't get over the passion they have with one another.
Maria Potter I know, right? I would have bought it for two reasons. 1. It is The freakin Secret Garden. 2. It has my two favorite actors, the ones I want to be a couple in real life so bad- Ramin Karimloo and Sierra Boggess. I know it is wrong of me to want them to be a couple because Ramin is married and all that but I don’t care.
LILY: How could I know I would have to leave you? How could I know I would hurt you so? You were the one I was born to love! Oh, how could I ever know? How could I ever know? How can I say to go on without me? How, when I know you still need me so? How can I say not to dream about me? How could I ever know? How could I ever know? Forgive me Can you forgive me And hold me in your heart And find some new way to love me Now that we're apart? How could I know I would never hold you? Never again in this world, but oh Sure as you breathe, I am there inside you How could I ever know? How could I ever know?
Sierra Boggess and Ramin Karimloo are wonderful on stage together. Their voices blend together beautifully. It would be fabulous if one day they starred in a movie musical together.
The long pink dress Sierra was wearing gave me such a Love Never Dies feels in Beneath a Moonless sky. But this time she kinda is the phantom as she is the one asking for forgiveness and he is the one hurt. So beautifeul! These two were born to act together. I'm so happy they found each other!
My heart has been healed! Now its full of happy emotions that i wanna share with you all! I care less of i get dumped,if i get dumped or rejected then ill jusy listen to Ramin and Sierra sing. (With ice cream)
They performed this again at Carnegie Hall last month for Manhattan Concert Productions' Broadway Classics series. It was every bit as heart-stopping. Watch for that series, Secret Garden is one of the musicals featured along with Ragtime, Parade and more. If you see Boggess and Karimloo on the bill, they'll do this for sure.
This is literally like an LND sequel Christine's ghost goes to meet Erik because she misses him and she sees he can't live without her. And the Phantom follows her to never be apart from his Angel Of Music again And Christine is wearing a pink long dress when she dies just like Lily Coincidence? I think not!
She is amazing. I saw this on Broadway wit(h the original case. She honors the original with such strength. It as good. This is an emotional song and pivotal point in the story. This duet does it justice. And I’ve always thought the female was the lead. And she carries it!
[LILY] How could I know I would have to leave you? How could I know I would hurt you so? You were the one I was born to love! Oh, how could I ever know? How could I ever know? How can I say to go on without me? How, when I know you still need me so? How can I say not to dream about me? How could I ever know? How could I ever know? Forgive me Can you forgive me And hold me in your heart And find some new way to love me Now that we're apart? How could I know I would never hold you? Never again in this world, but oh Sure as you breathe, I am there inside you How could I ever know? How could I ever know? [ARCHIBALD] How can I hope to go on without you? How can I know where you'd have me go? How can I bear not to dream about you? Oh, how can I let you go? [LILY] How could I ever know? [ARCHIBALD] All I need... [LILY] Is there in the garden! [ARCHIBALD] All I would ask... [LILY] Is care for the child of our love! Come, go with me, safe I will keep you [ARCHIBALD] Where you would lead me There I would [LILY] There I would, there we would [ARCHIBALD and LILY] There we will go Oh! How could I know? Tell me how could I know? Never to know you would ever leave me! How could we know? [ARCHIBALD] How could I ever know?
This song just makes me tear up every single time and Ramin and Sierra sing it (dare I say it?) better than the original. Absolutely beautiful! Do you have the full recording of the concert or only several songs? I would love to have the full recording of the concert!
How could I know I would have to leave you? How could I know I would hurt you so? You were the one I was born to love Oh, how could I ever know? How could I ever know? How can I say to go on without me? How, when I know you still need me so? How can I say not to dream about me? How could I ever know? How could I ever know? Forgive me, can you forgive me? And hold me in your heart And find some new way to love me Now that we're apart? How could I know I would never hold you? Never again in this world But oh, sure as you breathe I am there inside you How could I ever know? How could I ever know? How can I hope to go on without you? How can I know where you'd have me go? How can I bear not to dream about you? Oh, how can I let you go? How could I ever know? All I need is there in the garden All I would ask is care for the child of our love Come, go with me, safe I will keep you Where you would lead me, there I would There I would, there we would, there we will go Oh! How could I know? Tell me how could I know? Never to know you would ever leave me How could we ever know? How could we know? How could I ever know?
LILY] How could I know I would have to leave you? How could I know I would hurt you so? You were the one I was born to love! Oh, how could I ever know? How could I ever know? How can I say to go on without me? How, when I know you still need me so? How can I say not to dream about me? How could I ever know? How could I ever know? Forgive me Can you forgive me And hold me in your heart And find some new way to love me Now that we're apart? How could I know I would never hold you? Never again in this world, but oh Sure as you breathe, I am there inside you How could I ever know? How could I ever know? [ARCHIBALD] How can I hope to go on without you? How can I know where you'd have me go? How can I bear not to dream about you? Oh, how can I let you go? [LILY] How could I ever know? [ARCHIBALD] All I need... [LILY] Is there in the garden! [ARCHIBALD] All I would ask... [LILY] Is care for the child of our love! Come, go with me, safe I will keep you [ARCHIBALD] Where you would lead me There I would [LILY] There I would, there we would [ARCHIBALD and LILY] There we will go Oh! How could I know? Tell me how could I know? Never to know you would ever leave me! How could we know? [ARCHIBALD] How could I ever know? [LILY] Come to my Garden
@FullmetalandtheFlame hehehe im doing fine. Enjoying the fact that quarantine is over here. How about you? How you doing? Btw i saw you on an Ant and Dec video 😂 Good to find out you are a fan of them aswell cuz i love them too lol. And youre welcome
@FullmetalandtheFlame oh thats so cool. I live in Albania ( pretty sure you havent heard of it 😂) But our gov took very strict measures so we had very few infected people. Yeah i have been studying from home too cuz we had a looot !
@FullmetalandtheFlame thats weird that someone has heard of our country lol. We are just in opposite side of Italy. We are neighbour country with Greece, Turkey Oh if you are from Canada then you must have seen Ramin live ? Or not?!
Omg there is absolutely no way I am a massive poto fan and 25th anniversary is my fav I'm doing this song in my singing class and this was the first version to pop up its like fate
My highschool was gonna do this show for their spring musical. I was going to play Colin. Then Corona happened. We never even got to block the first scene. Our cast was perfect. Too perfect I guess. I miss this show with all my heart
If you've lost a spouse, regardless of the circumstances, this song will always bring you to tears, especially if you see Secret Garden live in stage. As heartbreaking as it is, it's a beautiful song from a wonderful show.
Just saw Rierra’s LND and this kinda heals my pain in their LND ending tho😅 It’s like the reversal😂 Her being the “phantom” now asking for her Angel of Music’s forgiveness for leaving him after their confession of love and reconciliation. I know this is sooo not related to POTO and LND but hey, it’s Rierra. And the scenes kinda connected to LND somehow specially with the lyrics of the song😅 and come on! Not to mention, Christine, before she died she was also wearing a long pink gown/dress just like Lily. And also Phantom onced leave Christine a son and now she leave him their son to love and protect but instead did the opposite😂 It’s like a closure for both me and Rierra’s LND hahahahahaha sorry to all the “The Secret Garden” fans but I just need this for a moment😁
![Megan Thee Stallion - Neva Play (feat. RM) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TpYTyAaTRts/mqdefault.jpg)
these two were just born to sing together. they're like the Kate Winslet and Leonardo DiCaprio of the musical theater world. they bring out the best in each other. I love it when they work together
I was thinking the same thing, their chemistry is painfully beautiful.
Couldn’t have said it better myself 😁
Cierra I agree so much! 🖤 I just posted a video of them singing ”Once Upon Another Time” in London, everyone should see it, they’re so amazing!
They not jack and rose from titanic gread butter and Emmy rossum is more like Leo and Kate
Ramin Karmiloo and Sierra Boggess, 25th anniversary
Me: .....I'm sensing a pattern here
hahahahah
Ramin played in Les Mis 25th anniversary on Broadway(Enjolras) i think and Sierra on the 25th Les Mis 25th West End(Fantine) :)
@@NOONE-cd4gu Also they were both in Phantom 25th anniversary at Royal Albert Hall, as Phantom and Christine
@@johnjungkook2721 yess.
There is something transcendental in Ramin and Sierra's performances, true and rare beauty, admiration, respect and friendship. They inspire love so sincerely that It on easily brings tears to us. Pure beauty.
It's like this is what happens after Love Never Dies. My heart.
Oh my gosh, I thought I was the only one who thought of it that way!
Nope, me, too.
YESSSS OMG
Omg no
why did u have to do this to me
I don't know but it felt like Ramin and Sierra were born to sing for each other. Their voices just complement each other so perfectly. My favorite beautiful iconic duo.
Dear broadway gods,
All I want is these two in the upcoming Broadway revival.
All. I. Want.
Pleaseohplease.
That's all we ask of you
Broadway
That’s all we ask of you!
Yes please
Or just like release a studio version of them singing this song...
@@CandyDiababa
YESSSSSSSSSS
This show should be revived
Bring these two together again please 😭😭😭😭😭
@SoHardToBeMe - they set him up with Anna O'Byrne for Korea Phantom reading. What a mistake. No chemistry. He's also touring Oz with AO. Such a mistake. He and Sierra are a power singing couple.
Oh my gosh the sound of their voices together makes my heart fill with such joy! I'm not even ashamed to say I cried all the way through this piece. They are so amazing together, and I can't get over the passion they have with one another.
It's such a shame this wasn't professionally recorded!
Maria Potter I know, right? I would have bought it for two reasons. 1. It is The freakin Secret Garden. 2. It has my two favorite actors, the ones I want to be a couple in real life so bad- Ramin Karimloo and Sierra Boggess. I know it is wrong of me to want them to be a couple because Ramin is married and all that but I don’t care.
Whenever I come back to this video, I watch, and I just cry and cry. The child of our love and I will never stop missing you, precious Julie…❤
LILY:
How could I know I would have to leave you?
How could I know I would hurt you so?
You were the one I was born to love!
Oh, how could I ever know?
How could I ever know?
How can I say to go on without me?
How, when I know you still need me so?
How can I say not to dream about me?
How could I ever know?
How could I ever know?
Forgive me
Can you forgive me
And hold me in your heart
And find some new way to love me
Now that we're apart?
How could I know I would never hold you?
Never again in this world, but oh
Sure as you breathe, I am there inside you
How could I ever know?
How could I ever know?
Omg it really DOES fit right into the LND finale!
I fancast them in these roles back in like 2012 when I was still in high school. I guess sometimes dreams do come true.
Can you fancast them again in a Broadway revival please ? 😂
Sierra Boggess and Ramin Karimloo are wonderful on stage together. Their voices blend together beautifully. It would be fabulous if one day they starred in a movie musical together.
If LND had an extension, this would be the song Erik and Christine would sing maybe two years later?
The long pink dress Sierra was wearing gave me such a Love Never Dies feels in Beneath a Moonless sky. But this time she kinda is the phantom as she is the one asking for forgiveness and he is the one hurt. So beautifeul! These two were born to act together. I'm so happy they found each other!
How come everyone was looking for this video for months and now it just suddenly falls out of the sky 😂
There need to be a TH-cam video called how to sing like Sierra boggess
Samantha Moon there be a vid called How to Not Die of Pure Perfection Because of Sierra Boggess's Everything I really need to know
If only it worked like that...I'd sign up immediately!!
I dont care anymore cast this two in any musicals please 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
YES 😩😩😭😭
YES!! I would start by casting them in Jekyll and Hyde with Ramin as Dr. Henry Jekyll/Edward Hyde and Sierra as Emma Carew
Yas Sierra. I see you. Grace that six pack. Get it gurl.
You literally made me laugh lmaooo same
@@cosmicash7 this message also has 69 likes ;-)
Christine and Erik together again. Just lovely.
@Ramin and Sierra: This is indeed an unparalleled delight! You have truly made my night!
My heart has been healed!
Now its full of happy emotions that i wanna share with you all! I care less of i get dumped,if i get dumped or rejected then ill jusy listen to Ramin and Sierra sing. (With ice cream)
the sound of their voices matches perfectly to a hauntingly beautiful song...it affected me so much...how could i ever know 😢
Can't. Stop. The. Tears. 😭😭😭
They performed this again at Carnegie Hall last month for Manhattan Concert Productions' Broadway Classics series. It was every bit as heart-stopping. Watch for that series, Secret Garden is one of the musicals featured along with Ragtime, Parade and more. If you see Boggess and Karimloo on the bill, they'll do this for sure.
YAS RAMINS HEAD SHAKE AT 3:56 HAS ME WEAKKKKK😍😍
Same 😩
This is literally like an LND sequel
Christine's ghost goes to meet Erik because she misses him and she sees he can't live without her. And the Phantom follows her to never be apart from his Angel Of Music again
And Christine is wearing a pink long dress when she dies just like Lily
Coincidence?
I think not!
This song is so perfect for Christine and Eric aka the phantom so beautiful and magical
Wooooow!! These two are magical together! The chemistry between Ramin and Sierra is so wonderful 💕💕
3:44-3:49 the best moment to me...❤
She is amazing. I saw this on Broadway wit(h the original case. She honors the original with such strength. It as good. This is an emotional song and pivotal point in the story. This duet does it justice. And I’ve always thought the female was the lead. And she carries it!
I watch this once a week and it makes me cry every time.
Oh fuck, why did I think I was emotionally prepared for this...
Another great Broadway singers introduced this duet Rebecca Luker and Mandy Patinkin;
[LILY]
How could I know I would have to leave you?
How could I know I would hurt you so?
You were the one I was born to love!
Oh, how could I ever know?
How could I ever know?
How can I say to go on without me?
How, when I know you still need me so?
How can I say not to dream about me?
How could I ever know?
How could I ever know?
Forgive me
Can you forgive me
And hold me in your heart
And find some new way to love me
Now that we're apart?
How could I know I would never hold you?
Never again in this world, but oh
Sure as you breathe, I am there inside you
How could I ever know?
How could I ever know?
[ARCHIBALD]
How can I hope to go on without you?
How can I know where you'd have me go?
How can I bear not to dream about you?
Oh, how can I let you go?
[LILY]
How could I ever know?
[ARCHIBALD]
All I need...
[LILY]
Is there in the garden!
[ARCHIBALD]
All I would ask...
[LILY]
Is care for the child of our love!
Come, go with me, safe I will keep you
[ARCHIBALD]
Where you would lead me
There I would
[LILY]
There I would, there we would
[ARCHIBALD and LILY]
There we will go
Oh! How could I know?
Tell me how could I know?
Never to know you would ever leave me!
How could we know?
[ARCHIBALD]
How could I ever know?
This song just makes me tear up every single time and Ramin and Sierra sing it (dare I say it?) better than the original. Absolutely beautiful! Do you have the full recording of the concert or only several songs? I would love to have the full recording of the concert!
Paola Rivera same here!
me too...
I'm 2 years late but if you're still looking for it, there is a recording here th-cam.com/video/5Zyjo3NgpKM/w-d-xo.html :)
Go ahead and say it it's the truth!
One of the most moving performances of any duet in musical theater. Absolutely stunning, and so painful.
Simply one of the most beautiful songs ever written for the stage.
Sing my angels of music!
That end bit is so love never dies haha the way he holds her had then she tilts her head and walks away 😍😍
Team Rierra forever! This is sooooo beautiful. I am crying so hard from watching this.
I've been waiting for this since February of 2016. This is all I needed in life. Thank you so much for this.
YES!!! IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS FOR THE LONGEST!!!!! 😀😀😀😀
This is heartbreaking and beautiful. I could t imagine seeing this live, because I’m crying watching it here.
I miss them :( so glad I finally got to see this video :D
The applause right after....I feel the same. I could feel this through my screen
I like how the 2001 version changes her line to "Now you must let me go." I always miss it when it's not used.
How could I know I would have to leave you?
How could I know I would hurt you so?
You were the one I was born to love
Oh, how could I ever know?
How could I ever know?
How can I say to go on without me?
How, when I know you still need me so?
How can I say not to dream about me?
How could I ever know?
How could I ever know?
Forgive me, can you forgive me?
And hold me in your heart
And find some new way to love me
Now that we're apart?
How could I know I would never hold you?
Never again in this world
But oh, sure as you breathe I am there inside you
How could I ever know?
How could I ever know?
How can I hope to go on without you?
How can I know where you'd have me go?
How can I bear not to dream about you?
Oh, how can I let you go?
How could I ever know?
All I need is there in the garden
All I would ask is care for the child of our love
Come, go with me, safe I will keep you
Where you would lead me, there I would
There I would, there we would, there we will go
Oh! How could I know?
Tell me how could I know?
Never to know you would ever leave me
How could we ever know?
How could we know?
How could I ever know?
I wish I could purchase a recording of this performance. I love listening to this song with these two.
Aw they are both amazing, and amazing together! I so wish they could do a show, Ramin mentioned Bridges 🙏🙏🙏🙏
I THOUGH THERE WAS GOING TO BE A KISSSSSS😭😭😭
Kissing ghosts is a bit difficult. ;)
It’s too bad though, in other videos I’ve seen Archibald and Lily kiss ;(
ㅠㅠ 볼때마다 눈물 나ㅠㅠㅠ 진짜 시에라랑 라민 정말 사랑합니다 죽기전에 시에라 공연 한번만 보고 싶다
these two.....i swear to god
It always feels right with these two ❤️
I feel healed from every sorrow. They are so wonderful together ♥
Rips my guts out every time…
When she sings she reminds me of wonderful Rebecca Luker rip
LILY]
How could I know I would have to leave you?
How could I know I would hurt you so?
You were the one I was born to love!
Oh, how could I ever know?
How could I ever know?
How can I say to go on without me?
How, when I know you still need me so?
How can I say not to dream about me?
How could I ever know?
How could I ever know?
Forgive me
Can you forgive me
And hold me in your heart
And find some new way to love me
Now that we're apart?
How could I know I would never hold you?
Never again in this world, but oh
Sure as you breathe, I am there inside you
How could I ever know?
How could I ever know?
[ARCHIBALD]
How can I hope to go on without you?
How can I know where you'd have me go?
How can I bear not to dream about you?
Oh, how can I let you go?
[LILY]
How could I ever know?
[ARCHIBALD]
All I need...
[LILY]
Is there in the garden!
[ARCHIBALD]
All I would ask...
[LILY]
Is care for the child of our love!
Come, go with me, safe I will keep you
[ARCHIBALD]
Where you would lead me
There I would
[LILY]
There I would, there we would
[ARCHIBALD and LILY]
There we will go
Oh! How could I know?
Tell me how could I know?
Never to know you would ever leave me!
How could we know?
[ARCHIBALD]
How could I ever know?
[LILY] Come to my Garden
@FullmetalandtheFlame hehehe im doing fine. Enjoying the fact that quarantine is over here. How about you? How you doing?
Btw i saw you on an Ant and Dec video 😂
Good to find out you are a fan of them aswell cuz i love them too lol.
And youre welcome
@FullmetalandtheFlame oh thats so cool. I live in Albania ( pretty sure you havent heard of it 😂)
But our gov took very strict measures so we had very few infected people. Yeah i have been studying from home too cuz we had a looot !
@FullmetalandtheFlame thats weird that someone has heard of our country lol. We are just in opposite side of Italy. We are neighbour country with Greece, Turkey
Oh if you are from Canada then you must have seen Ramin live ? Or not?!
Only word I can say at this point..
Tears.
they won't stop flowing.
Omg there is absolutely no way I am a massive poto fan and 25th anniversary is my fav I'm doing this song in my singing class and this was the first version to pop up its like fate
Just absolutely stunning...
Oh man, this song! And these two singing it! 😭
My highschool was gonna do this show for their spring musical. I was going to play Colin. Then Corona happened. We never even got to block the first scene. Our cast was perfect. Too perfect I guess. I miss this show with all my heart
I am so sorry that your production never happened. The Secret Garden is a wonderful musical.
Sierra and Ramon are a dream pair :) in Phantom too
RIERRA IS PUR MAGIC
If you've lost a spouse, regardless of the circumstances, this song will always bring you to tears, especially if you see Secret Garden live in stage. As heartbreaking as it is, it's a beautiful song from a wonderful show.
This is my favourite song since stumbling upon it. Hope this cast will come to Malaysia
Thank you, thank you, thank you!! ❤
She is so damn amazing. And both of them together are spectacular 😭
The best the best the best the best the best
WOW....
Who comes here after POTO and LND and imagine what it would be like to have Christine becomes the real “phantom”
ME!!!! with tears
THIS IS SO PAINFUL I CRIED 😩😩😭😭💔💔
It couldn't be more perfect! ♥♥
Sequel of love never die....
Ramin!
I MISS THEM YOUR HONOR
so beautifull!
Beautiful duet, beautiful production ... and these two performers are just brilliant. Thank you for posting this!
My heart shatters.. this song.. 😥
I would buy this album right now.
Just can´t stop crying. This is so beautiful. Thank you so much for this.
Just saw Rierra’s LND and this kinda heals my pain in their LND ending tho😅 It’s like the reversal😂 Her being the “phantom” now asking for her Angel of Music’s forgiveness for leaving him after their confession of love and reconciliation. I know this is sooo not related to POTO and LND but hey, it’s Rierra. And the scenes kinda connected to LND somehow specially with the lyrics of the song😅 and come on! Not to mention, Christine, before she died she was also wearing a long pink gown/dress just like Lily. And also Phantom onced leave Christine a son and now she leave him their son to love and protect but instead did the opposite😂 It’s like a closure for both me and Rierra’s LND hahahahahaha sorry to all the “The Secret Garden” fans but I just need this for a moment😁
This is probably the most romantic Rierra song on stage??
Amazing performance, beautiful song.
It made me cry it’s so beautiful
That is so beautiful!
OMG RIERRA FOREVER!!!
I'm. Crying.
I'm not crying your crying
That was absolutely beautiful!
Chills.🤍
Wow!!!!!!!
Wow!
*IM CRYING TBH RIGHT NOW* 😭😭😭😭😭
THANK YOU SO MUCH, THIS IS ALL I WANTED IN LIFE
Been looking for this for months! Thank you!!!!
3:47 -i wonder what it feels like to have someone hardcore sing in your face lol i imagine it must be a lot like getting punched
THANK YOU!