ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ก.ค. 2024
- It's been 75 years since the US, Canada, and Western European countries forged an alliance to defend themselves against the Soviet Union during the Cold War. What began with just 12 members has now grown to an alliance of 32 nations.
The challenges facing them are many. Some old, some new. Supplying Ukraine with what it needs to fight off Russia's invasion is on top of the agenda. But now it's not alone. And the geographic focus has also shifted. Leaders want to push back against Russia, China, North Korea and Iran in the Indo-Pacific region.
00:00 NATO leaders gather for 75th anniversary summit
03:35 Ines Pohl, DW Washington Bureau Chief
06:35 Juri Rescheto, Former DW Moscow Bureau Chief (now in Riga)
09:12 Chris Chivvis, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
Subscribe: th-cam.com/users/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#NATO #Ukraine #Russia
In a Nuclear war every cent you spend on defense is "Up in smoke"
What nuclear war? Putin is suicidal if he use nuclear.
The nuts case's of NATO
Tough questions to be answered at the NATO summit.
not really
Bolton a a sour grape
If I was DW, I would turn off comments..
Then why are you commenting
If Trump wins what they are discussing now becomes irrelevant.
Finished land that is its new name
what they are not saying is that if ukraine is still at war when it officially becomes part of nato, then all of nato is then at war with Russia.
They should allow Ukraine in right now, but they won't. I imagine it will take more than 10 years
Nato don't have the Ballas to join the war they only bark but don't bite
@@Elsuper68 It's a shame, considering how much stronger NATO is.
They are already at war with Russia. The ones not willing to a direct confrontation from the begin are now paniking, because they just accepted a passive participation and are being pushed to more commitment. Nato is spliting either way. If the ones presuring now for a negotiation solution gain their momentum the ones willing for full swing will also slit appart. It seems nobody is still ready to make mea culpa. So the escape goat is being put at Trump. Anyways the probability of a second term for Biden is really small, change with a new admnistration, Trump or otherwise is going to bring change. It is clear NATO is paralized mentaly. This paralisation in my oppinion is extremely danger because the battle field is dinamic. Changes need to be intruduced right now.
Putin may need another Modi hug. 🥺
(9:31) I can’t help but think Chivvis is far right. I hope that I am wrong in that assumption
The 2% is a number that will be taken from elsewhere, and this is problematic in a democracy, as you know. The US already has a huge debt. Peace is most of the time better for the economy. But we now have a slow-running economy, which is why war economic arguments are so loud. Trump's idea of forcing countries to spend more on defense was not because the world was dangerous, but because by keeping the military complexes working around the world, the pressure for new wars would go down. And it did. Trump did calm down all the hot spots around the world, becoming the only US president in a long time who did not start a war.
NATO, which was supposed to be just an alliance pact, is now appearing in all fields of everyday situations. This expansion of the spectrum of action of NATO is worrying. Worrying for democracy and worrying for security. NATO needs to be scaled down. Not all countries are worthy of being allies. Countries whose national policies and foreign affairs use a belligerent attitude that endangers the peace and security of the pact as a whole need to be invited out. The three Baltic countries should be invited out in order to keep the UK, Poland, Finland, and even France, less belligerent.
Russia and their nuke threat
Putin quote - "continued escalation will lead to their use"
Blinken needs to do his job - the boy wonder diplomat
He will not talk, push for it, tell me why?
It becomes clear the devisions within NATO are growing doesn't matter wether what. All made their calculations an they come to the conclusion they don't have industrial capacity to keep this going for much longer. The idea that some countries will go futher in supporting Ukraine more than others createas a danger for the ones that already are stressed about the all situation. This is breacking the alliance. On the other side if the pressure to end the war becomes more predominante those more surportive for a military solution may also breack the aliance apart. There is no easy solutions. But member states have to finally realize that a scenario where Russia fully destroys Ukraine is much worse than a negotiated solution. When will realism and rationality win over ideology and emotional commitment? You tell me.
The Point of NATO Is Peace, Not Endless War | Opinion by Viktor Orban, PM of Hungary.
"It is worth remembering that the most successful military alliance in world history started as a peace project, and its future success depends on its ability to maintain peace. But today, instead of peace, the agenda is the pursuit of war; instead of defense it is offense"
Orban forgot to mention that if Ukraine were accepted to NATO, there would not be no war. You are citing a Russian agent, because this is what Orban is.
Orban and Trump are Putin's paid puppets. Orban should be ousted. He went against the European Union.
Potato troll
Orban is frontline, small and scared shitless. Orban thinks only he knows Russia. Only he can negotiate peace. He will surrender and join RF if Putin raises his voice at Viktor.
Each NATO Member Country spend 2% as a minimum on contributing to NATO fund, or that Nation is to be suspended from NATO until the 2% threshold of spending is met. So simple a rule. No free loader countries active in NATO.
It's not a rule, read the charter. The 2% figure is a suggestion.
NATO fund?.. Sounds like you don't really understand this subject..🧐
The 2% is a number that will be taken from elsewhere, and this is problematic in a democracy, as you know. The US already has a huge debt. Peace is most of the time better for the economy. But we now have a slow-running economy, which is why war economic arguments are so loud. Trump's idea of forcing countries to spend more on defense was not because the world was dangerous, but because by keeping the military complexes working around the world, the pressure for new wars would go down. And it did. Trump did calm down all the hot spots around the world, becoming the only US president in a long time who did not start a war.
NATO, which was supposed to be just an alliance pact, is now appearing in all fields of everyday situations. This expansion of the spectrum of action of NATO is worrying. Worrying for democracy and worrying for security. NATO needs to be scaled down. Not all countries are worthy of being allies. Countries whose national policies and foreign affairs use a belligerent attitude that endangers the peace and security of the pact as a whole need to be invited out. The three Baltic countries should be invited out in order to keep the UK, Poland, Finland, and even France, less belligerent.
@@EscudoPadraoPrata Mama Mia! Another clueless one, dreaming up an alternative reality..🧐🥴😞
@@leifiseland1218 Do you care to give clues then?
Ukraine applied for NATO membership before Putin invaded but NATO appeased Putin instead. Why does this sound so heil-familiar?
Hope they're discussing the recent bombing of a hospital for kids with cancer, by russia.
They gonna discuss US leaving Nafo once Trump gets back to office 😂
It won't be discussed because it is going to be revealed that it was actually a Ukrainian missile.
How about they discuss about Ukraine using cluster ammunition to those kids happily playing sand castles at the beach in Crimea?
@@Yodaploks And Trump will give Lend lease again for Russia🤣
@@Mr.Clownensky the one that clearly got intercepted over a beach? Nice try.
Never Ukeaine stay NATO member 😂
The same way you view SCO summit. LOL
Yes, I just marked your documentary on NATO and the Pacific. It’s actually a report not a documentary, if I’m not mistaken. Love your channel. 👍
Biden 2024. 🇺🇸
Go biden 2024 - 2029.
If NATO accepts Ukraine that will leave Russia with no option but to fight for a complete surrender there will not be much left of the country at that stage, Ukraine should stayed with Minsk
All power to Putin
king russia vs 32 nafo 😂😂😂😂
Sweden and Finland in NATO. Yeah, Biden did that. Biden 2024.
Putin did it if anyone
How Biden did it? He doesnt know where he is or what time is
@@OctPSfever Biden rise US GDP for 1.6 Trillion $, RuSSian GDP is less then 2 trillion $
I’ll begrudgingly vote for Biden, but he has nothing to do with this.
if 1 vote matters, then Biden lost the 2024 election already.
Jehovah hates evil dictators and politicians...Ezekiel 7 : 27....
I watched the 75th Nato ceremony and it brought me to tears but I am so proud of American President Joe Biden and Jens Stoltenberg is someone to look up to and admire; I wish him well.
Your standards must be very low I’m afraid to say if you think Biden is a great president.
Lol 🤡
Axis of Evil Summit 👹
He sure sounds like a trump supporter.
How about the countries pay more in NATO since they are right there 🤔🧐😜
It shows your ignorance. Countries do not pay Nato. The countries spend % on defense for their own country. 🫡
UKRAINE ITS NOT OUR WAR !!!!
Ukraine has been abandoned….
Bull hockey. Ukraine is the focus of these nations' efforts because it's fighting a revanchist soviet monster for them.
Not really.
NATO time is over
It is your time to shine, whatever hole you are coming from.
@@tech477 NATO's hole has been completely damaged by Russia
Biden will be there don't worry
I'm so tired of listen this guy stotengay
How tired are you?
The whole world is viewing NATO as the Titanic after it hit the ice berg. Only a matter of time
Thank God that is only the opinion of your village.
Godley and Creme "cry" could be your theme song...
Without talking about Ukraine what is there for NATO to talk about? Why keep on stirring the turd?
Just eat your potato.
Let them keep stirring the trud eventually Russia will make them all jump into it LOL.
Work with Ukrainian defence forces ? There is hardly any left, they are currently rounding men up off the street to fight and forcing men who have left the county back to fight. NATO will support until the last Ukrainian man and then what ?
Body bags arriving in Europe
Keep dreaming, it's fun to watch the convulsions going on in Russia, as they have now figured out that they are basically a bunch of powerless fools. Russia: "PLEASE, PLEASE, we want peace". Read between the lines dude.
Sure-sure, Ivan, whatever you say.
@@tech477 glad you agree
How insane of an idea is it to have an "Iron Dome" in Ukraine like in Israel?
Why can't Ukraine loss to Russia if NATO can loss Afghan and Iraq?
Russia lost in Afghanistan, Chechnya,,and will lose in Ukraine too
@@Dani-mw2wsagainst usa
Because Ukraine is that good as a fighter. Does it answer your question?
@@kensuz the only Americans I know fighting in Ukraine are fighting in the Ukrainian army. The US has active combatants in Ukraine.
@@ryanthompson1981 Nope, not except for volunteers that are not regular military.
Imagine USA tricks India to give up its nuces, then invades for joining BRIKS
Imagine if you actually had any handle on reality. What makes you think that could happen in any kind of real scenario. It doesn't even make any sense, on any level.
Biden 2024 🇺🇸💙
Biden will stop protect ruzzia?
F J B 🇺🇸🤠
NAziTerroristO
NATO lost the wars in Afghan and Iraq.
Russia also lost in Afghanistan 😂
RuZZia lost in Afghanistan, Chechnya , in 1905 against Japan, in WW1 too, In ww2, USA and UK saved Russia from Germans
@@user-qk9he7se5wso according to that logic Nato = Russia ?🤔
@@Mr.Clownensky Yes Ivan, RuSSian GDP is 30x higher then GDP of NATO states🤣
@@Mr.Clownensky sorry let me rephrase that moscow has lost its war in Afghanistan which resulted in the break up of the soviet union which poopstain is try to rebuild but is failing hard in his little 3 day war
How come ALL these Leaders get to ride in jets 🤔🧐what happened to the climate crisis 🤔🧐🤦🏻♀️🤥🤥
What do you recommend for overseas travel? Row boats?
@derwolfpack3599> 🤣🖕 thank you for that
@@derwolfpack3599 😂😜 how about zoom calls, snap chat etc.. 😂😂😂
Just say it Ukraine never enjoyed to NATO😅
English your is broken very comrade.
2nd WW was won by the Russian strong hold not NATO or any other country! I mean major contribution from the great USSR!
Where did the “great” USSR get its hardware? Who ran the lend lease program that kept the commies afloat?
Putin makes you buy your own vodka on one-way train ride to the Ukrainian front.
@@dammitdan106 history???
NATO has lost its mandate. The alliance should focus on protecting its member states rather than sponsoring an endless war. Despite claiming to be non-aggressive, NATO has pledged to support the conflict in Ukraine indefinitely and is expanding its military alliances worldwide. This behavior reveals NATO as aggressive and warmongering. Call for peace and negotiation instead of for as long as it takes war narrative.
Go to Russian
@looking5050> you are such a run-of-the-mill Pootin bot. 🤣
It is dead on in it's mandate. It was put together to prevent Russia from making the USSR, gen 2, and that is EXACTLY what Russia is doing, You guys started it, q quit whining and just take your licking like real men.
@@nikoschreurs7426 I have and also to over 80 other countries. Maybe you should get out of your basement and see the world, probably can cure your warmongering appetite. The world needs peace not war that is claiming life of young and old for the profit of top 1%.
@@PavlovsDog-kl8mo Well, not brainless or clueless unlike many here that only follow like zombies
🗞️📰🗞️📰 “Been that way for 30 years.” - U.S. Justice Department on the lack of Human Rights in Oklahoma County Jail, 2020 P.S. You get 2 days for every 1 you serve there bc it is so bad.
“Makes me feel human again after this place.” - Oklahoma City Art Museum review after life in the local shelters (20+ years in the making), 2024
“It is said that no one truly knows a nation until one has been inside its jails. A nation should not be judged by how it treats its highest citizens, but its lowest ones.” - Nelson Mandela 🥂🥂
[[Community of Democracies]]
free and fair elections
freedom of speech & expression
equal access to education
rule of law
freedom of peaceful assembly
Enough to know the USA created hells in the 21st century I wouldn’t wish on my worst enemy.
To Iceland w/love, I pledged my allegiance to Monaco. - Me aka Ron Swanson 2.0/Ron Swanson on Snoop Dogg/a nerd
“If we give up on the moral code our country believes in we’re no better than (who we are fighting).” - US Military Code
If USA leaves NATO, can NATO invite China or Russia? Thus replacing USA. NATO will then either China or Russia alliance.
No they cannot because if China or Russia join then all of the other countries will leave.
WTH?
Leave the keyboard alone and eat potato comrade.
Invite Klingons!
@@tech477 🤣🤣🤣😂
NATO's actual leader, the US, in terms of foreign policy, is to be regarded as an imperialist rogue state. The wars and coups the US has initiated or interfered in are countless and millions of civilians have been killed. In almost all cases, it has also involved countries far from American territory that themselves did not threaten the United States in any way. It has simply been about geopolitics and about maintaining US power and influence.
France's presence and military operations in a number of African countries "to protect its interests" is another of many examples of how NATO is not only a defense alliance, but also an alliance consisting of imperialist actors.
BRICS 's, actual leader China do not give a SH, for Russia and India🤣🤣
Wow, an articulate Putin bot BSer. Extra potato for you comrade.
Zelensky 2024 begging tour!
In Nord Korea like Putin🤣
Sorry Ivan. He is just protecting his country and people. You wouldn't understand.
Despot repellant isn't cheap.
Rus.sia has all the right to defend itself against hos.tile elements just like How the US inva.ded multiple countries to defend itself. If the US can do it, so could Rus.sia. Stop the double standard and hypoc.risy.
First time using punctuation?
Is blaming the victim for your crime the best that you Russian trolls can do?
@@ryanthompson1981 needed to type it like that, bc yt always deletes my comments, i wonder why 🤪
Why NATO? Why not include Russia?. Who is aggressor
Include Russia with what?
@@hardstyle8184 you are saying NATO is for attacking Russia
Ukraine lose
Normal people can see it, but Biden will definitely not admit it before the election.
Igor Girkin has to eat food that looks and tastes like chunder. He not amused.
@@maxlevett7474 I thought he just ate pickles.
Russian troll bots love to wear American disguises.
@@PavlovsDog-kl8mo Make your rounds troll this troll that