@@claudiacantero515 depends which year of odyssey you are 'obsessed' with. i agree honda tends to over engineering. but they keep improving and improving and pushing forward and don't run away from their problems. will see how the path leads to.
honda has the better interior and exterior, but Toyota has the more reliable powertrain. even though the Sienna is an older design, the mechanical upgrades make it a better choice in my opinion
I would have to say the van with the largest cargo space has the better interior and that would be the Seinna. Isn't cargo space why you buy a van in the first place ?
When you remove the seats, the Chrysler and Sienna have a better thought out floor and seat track system. The Odyssey has unusual humps, pockets and grooves for junk to get caught up in.
@LightningMcQueen4eva! the older Odysseys were better. My mom drives one. After 12 years, it's still performing well. The new Odyssey doesn't look that great from the outside and also consumes more engine oil. I'd go with the Sienna because it has slightly better performance and fuel economy, as well as more trunk space and smaller turning radius. And who cares if the wheels are too small? The smaller the wheels, the easier it is to take off and less space needed for u turns.
I would also note the stowaway jump seat in the Sienna. It fits conveniently into a dedicated compartment in the back without giving up any storage space, which as can be seen in the video is not the case for the Odyssey.
Here in Canada, Toyota's AWD is winner over any other minivans. Even a little push from the rear wheels helps a lot in handling in snow, and most importantly gives you more confidence feeling.
My parents have a 2017 odyssey and I have a 2011 Sienna. There’s many similarities/differences between the functions of this van, it’s very much preferences. The biggest difference between these two is the power train. It’s true when everyone says the Sienna’s power train is bulletproof, with over 200,000km the power is still very linear and smooth unlike the odyssey. My parents would definitely buy a Sienna and I look forward to my next one.
I HATE CENTRAL MONITORING SYSTEMS YOU NEED TO BE ABLE TO CONTROL THINGS WITH JUST BEING ABLE TO FEEL THEM AND NOT HAVING TO TAKE YOUR EYES OFF OF THE ROAD
My 1998 Sienna still going strong..! My uncle's 03 Odyssey had an engine light issue that they never could fix it, even they replaced the transmission.
My criteria for minivan: 1. Reliable, don’t let the family stay at the road side; 2. Space, that’s minivan for, otherwise buy a SUV or wagon; 3. Easy to maneuver, bigger interior space but small exterior, easy parking and turn; 4. Good price... top 3 go to Sienna
If you want less conservative then you can consider the SE trim on the Sienna. It's the same level as the XLE reviewed here, but with a more "sporty" emphasis.
What do you mean not stylish the front actually had good creativity ever since the front design from 2015 and the upgrade is great. The Honda Odyssey still has the same look for idk 3 years!
Abdulaziz Al Saeed 2018+ oddly has class action for the peice of crap 10 speed that burns oil and gas and shuts down to park when driving! Toyota for the win!
Yes Honda has very bad transmission issues I have a Honda pilot and I have replaced the transmission in it looking at buying a van I think I'll go with the Toyota
I agree with you on a few details. Temperature controls are much better designed on the Sienna (as a rule, knobs are ALWAYS better, both on media volume control/tune AND temperature controls). I also agree to another reviewer about the analog gauges, it's a pity that Honda didn't include an option of analog-like gauges on the Odysseys digital display. I disagree with the audio/speaker quality, the Sienna sounds better IMO than the Odyssey, Honda was never good with speakers and always use low quality speaker systems for lower models. You have to step up to the top-of-the-line ELITE trim in order to get an improved stereo system. Remember, this is a family vehicle, not a pickup truck!! People wanna listen to some nice, rich music! Power sliding door is also different, the Sienna has a clever design, one button toggles between open/close, simple! The Odyssey with the open/close button and constant beeps is seriously unintuitive. You didn't mention that the center row middle seat on the Sienna is not suited for an adult, the Odyssey is wider and more comfortable. However, in the Sienna you can slide the seat more to the back, leaving a lot of leg room for middle row. Reliability is a big issue on the new Odyssey, maybe because it's built in the US, I dunno, they used to be better. There are a lot of complains, just do a search. Sienna is still more reliable, especially that it's older. But the review was very nice in general. Thanks.
The Odyssey was built in Alliston Ontario Canada for the first 5 years, then production was transferred to Lincoln Alabama for the 2004 production. They're built in the USA since then. Issues I've had have been with design on my 1st three Odysseys. But they were taken care of to my satisfaction. My 2016 Odyssey EXL NAVI is over 2 years old and has never seen the dealer since I picked it up. Do my own service using Honda genuine parts only.
2nd row middle seat in sienna just doesn't look like a seat for an adult, but have you tried sitting on it? i'll tell you, it sits as comfortably as the rest of the other seats..you wouldn't live for the rest of your life in the middle seat, would you?..just thinking..peace!
Car Confections. The Sienna has the new D4-S V6 engine, with both Direct and Multi-Port injection, this eliminates the intake valve carbon build up problems in Direct Injection only engines, which is what the Honda has.
very true. In addition to carbon buildup on the intake valves, DI also uses up alot of fuel injectors since the injectors are located inside the blast chamber, that is an important thing to consider,its a deal breaker for me.
I must say, that is one of the better comparison videos I've seen between these two minivans. Well done. The only thing I'll disagree with you on is giving the Odyssey a point for the electronic parking brake. I have never been a fan of those things so that would have shifted the numbers a little toward the Sienna and made this much closer if I were making the judgments. Beyond that, I thought you were spot on and very fair. I'm also not a fan of push button transmission controls. I prefer the good ol shift lever like the Toyota has but I wouldn't applied points one way or the other because of it. One other thing that you didn't focus on is the fact that most reliability comparisons these days tend to give the nod to the Toyota by a fair margin over the Honda. My biggest complaint with the Toyota, and I can't believe I'm saying this, is simply the fact that they seem to be so far behind on the technology. For a major player like Toyota to not have Android Auto and Apple Carplay in their app suites is inexcusable these days but it wouldn't be a deal breaker for me.
Agree on the missing android and apple apps. I have a 2013 Toyota Avalon, missing both these app's and they STILL haven't caught up,.. that's nuts. Makes me think they are too cheep to pay the licensing for threes. Hmmm
I like this comparison of the two mini vans, but I go for Sienna due to its reliability in this 2018 model comparing to 2018 Odyssey having 9/10 speed transmission issues + doors + central console malfunctioning issues..etc
I agree. If our 2007 Odyssey gets totaled, the replacement minivan would definitely be this one. Honda doesn't suck, but their larger vehicles don't perform as well as Toyota's
The Sienna does not offer 4WD. However it does offer an AWD option, don't get the twos mix up. As far as " safety " goes, they're about the same. If you're talking about off the line traction then yes, the AWD will have the advantage, but it will have a longer stopping distance compare to the FWD which is more important in term of " safety ". If you live where it doesn't get colder than 40 degree F, a FWD will do just fine. Otherwise a proper set of winter tires will be much safer.
I just bought the 2018 Toyota Sienna for 3 main reasons compare to the Honda Odyssey. Toyota uses timing chain vs Honda uses timing belt(high maintenance long term), Toyota V6 engine with port and direct injection (avoid valve carbon build up long term) vs Honda only direct inject V6, and lastly is the problematic Honda ZF 9 speed transmission.
I like a gas cap (helps keeps the debris out) and a locking gas door. A higher ground clearance (honda is much lowere) and a sliding door that does not bang against the curb, when opening it. Honda door goes out and then slides on the ones I drove.
Excellent points. Hey, I was not aware that Honda still uses timing belts on these. That used to be a 6 hour repair at our dealership. On the other hand, I was not aware when Toyota stopped using a belt on the Sienna. Maybe 2010?
@@CaptainDawg02 Thanks for the info. If the ZF9 made from Chrysler, I'll stay away from Odyssey. Chrysler has poor credit on it's transmission. Till minutes ago I was thinking give Odyssey a try.
Just bought the Odyssey. I have NO idea why you’d buy the Sienna. I drove it home in pour rain and it is silent and our pothole infested loop was almost unnoticeable. Our previous RAV4 sounded like the tires would come off. Extremely comfy for a 6’5” guy and technology that is really useful!
Ok, so you're comparing the noise level in your Odyssey to your Rav4? Apples to oranges? Drive a Sienna in the rain, then tell us how night and day the comparison was.
not sure how honda is but, Ive owned many other brands and have a toyota. When getting an oil change with others, even though they said free oil change, I still have to pay $50 min each oil change. The toyota we have had for 6 years, never paid a dime for oil change, only service. In 6 years we have paid under $500 for 2 services. so ya odyssey maybe new, I will go back to toyota for their servicing
Thanks for the great comparison. I need a minivan since my family is growing. Still very tough for me to decide between the two. I can't afford the new 2021 Toyota, so I have to opt the the best with my budget which is 2018 models. Toyota advantage: - AWD - Timing Chain Honda advantage: - Way better 2nd row bench seat (center seat) compared to Toyota child-like seat that they forgot to add in until after production. - More cabin room for passengers - Apple CarPlay and Android Auto
I had a 99 Odyssey then an 11 Sienna. The Toyota has more room and reliability. I will be getting an 18 soon. So what if the techy screen isn't as good with Toyota. We all need less screen time, especially while driving.
Should have used the Sienna SE in this comparison. 19" wheels and looks WAY better. Also sportier suspension and a nice looking black interior. Sienna is also more powerful and more reliable.
I like the analog gauges in the Sienna better. The Odyssey’s gauge cluster is disappointing, I would have given the point to Toyota there. As far as reliability I’d say it’s a draw. I like Honda products in general, however the AWD availability in the Sienna would make it my choice as far as minivans. Good review by the way.
Would love to see a comparison between 2019 touring elite and limited elite models of these vans. Though your videos are having me lean very closely to picking the odyssey. I enjoyed this video and the in depth one of the 2019 odyssey elite. Thanks!
We have a 2018 Toyota Sienna XLE, which replaced our 2006 Sienna Limited Trim. With the third row seats flat, tucked in, our two huge German Shepherds have plenty of room to comfortably endure long rides. A few safety measures are missing in 2018 that were standard in the 2006: 1. Front parking Sonar sensors. 2. No cruise control if 2.a the wipers were ON, and 2.b you were driving nighttime into the blinding glare of oncoming traffic or at bright sunrise or sunset.
I am an Odyssey fan and own the first two generations. However, I am not excited about the curve look of the Odyssey. It's more soccer mom look to me. I still love minivan for their utility nature. My next minivan will be Sienna XLE AWD for sure.
I like that they carried the lightning bolt theme over from the last Gen. I don't like the fact that they look at just soccer moms as it's a great utility vehicle plus. But I like the look but my 2016 still has appeal for me as well. But I don't buy a vehicle like this based on cosmetics only. Yeah it's nice to have a ride that looks great but it could be a 3 dressed up as a 9 and be lousy overall. Just saying.
Once inside you can't see the outside. In my 55 years of car ownership, I have never had someone come up to me and say, "man you have an unattractive car". What's wrong with you people.
@@alfredo9494 The Honda Odyssey made 5-stars in the following NHTSA** simulations: Overall Front Star Rating Front Passenger Side In contrast, the Toyota only earned 4-stars, and it entirely lacks the Odyssey’s available Road Departure Mitigation System (RDM). I also like that Honda has more room & has a sliding seat on the 2nd row for easy access to 3rd row.
Michelle Vargas yeah, my dad had a 2012 odyssey and around 65k miles, it gave us lots of problems (a/c, bearings, weird noises), my dad didn’t want it anymore and ended up getting a 2019 last fall. We also thought about a Pacifica.
leeozawa I’m speaking about their transmissions as well. I know someone with a 2011 civic with 310k miles, original tranny, regular scheduled maintenance. If you take care of things, they last
I LOVE my Hondas, but because of the transmission issues, I will never buy another. It's not even having to replace the transmission, it's that Honda doesn't manufacture the new ones so you can only get a remanufactured one and they DON'T feel near as good! I will say, to have a 300,000 and 400,000 mile engine in perfect condition is pretty awesome!
Both are great, can't go wrong with either one. The Sienna is a little outdated compare to the Odyssey, but Toyota usually offers great rebates and incentives which will attract more buyers who are on a budget.
Enjoy our comparison on two of the most advanced vehicles on the road: the all-new 2018 Honda Odyssey and refreshed 2018 Toyota Sienna! Also, please LIKE and SUBSCRIBE if you enjoyed :)
Pacifica - love their styling,.. but sorry for your repair bills. ( if even the future ones ). Remember ,.. it's a Chrysler,.. so if bought new,... only good for 4-6 years (on rare occasions a little more) before things start going.
i m still driving sienna 2001 . its great but i feel like they dint done with many thinks in 19 years. today i see sienna 2020 and still looks same and looks heavy. but the odyssy i start to feeling love with it
You could not have done a better job. If you are a car salesman, I would not mess with you ; ) You covered everything and did it in a quick and pleasant way.
both are excellent vehicles. But like Chris inductivo said Toyota has more reliable powertrain.... so my choice is sienna although 2GR-FE engine is loud
love your reviews. I would suggest though you weigh your point system more accurately. for example, the material on the inside door stuff, should not be worth 1 point, when something like reliability and cargo space is also worth only 1 point each. Something like door aesthetics should be worth more like 0.5 points. Like different levels of points depending on importance.
@@CarConfections you should consider adding type of engine criteria, such as between direct injection engine(odyssey) direct and port injection (sienna) and in that crucial department sienna wins. Research these 2 types and you will know which is better.
Test drove 19 Odyssey with 20 Sienna. The seats on Honda are very uncomfortable. The bulge in the mid of the seat causes pressure to the back and the seat feels like it’s closing in on you. Am positive it will be uncomfortable for long rides. I disagree with the leg space in the mid row. In the Sienna you can move the seats a lot back thus giving a lot of leg room. The seats of Sienna are lot better. The Sienna rode a lot smoother, more quieter. Few things worry me about Sienna is that I have heard the tires wear out quickly. Currently the old Odyssey that my parents have had issues with dual climate control in the 4th year and ac went bust in the 8th year. The sliding doors went bust in the 9th year. Also Sienna has a AC outlet where you can charge your laptop.
Good review! Thanks! I'm utterly astounded that the Toyota wouldn't have integrated Apple or Android already - that seriously is a huge fail for me. I see Dickywhatever making a million comments against Honda transmission, but it's hard to take that seriously when it's like basically one person making all the comments trashing the Honda transmission LOL
9 speed is not that reliable but 10 speed on higher trims is better. According to media reports. Honda uses 10 speed on new Accord as well so I suspect it will be more reliable in long run.
The Toyota Sienna’s safety system is standard. And to add to that TSS is standard on majority of their vehicles. Honda will make you purchase that. I was looking to buy a corolla or civic, when I heard leds and safety systems weren’t standard on the civic I went to toyota for sure. LEDs and Safety is the main things for cars.
You nailed it! Awesome video! Keep doing what you doing. In the future would like to see Highlander vs... whatever you decide as compatible.... I really loved this video!
I bought my 18 ody in aug 2017, went through couple non safety problem, no regret although I saw the service dude more than my dad lol. The only reason I bought mine without a second thought is the 2nd row slidable captain chairs! I went test drive the Sienna, driving was superior, but the heck was, simply look at the second row, the middle seat has a metal pole expanding out when you take it out lol. What's going on?
There's not really a comparison if you're comparing the Toyota sienna limited. Toyota last longer and it's cheaper to fix. The entertainment system in the vehicle is also better. Cabin watch is a useless feature and promotes distracted drivers. The Honda Can't beat the Toyotas all wheel drive. I live in Maine the winters are terrible the roads are bad you need to have something like that.
I've owned 2 Toyota vans; one got 254k miles and the second 285k. Had to finally replace the 2nd one in August, before I'd seen this video. However, I'd been looking around for a year or two because of the mileage on my last one--it was still running great, but how long can you drive a 16 year old van? Anyway, the one consistent thing I found was that if you were looking at used models, in my area there were 4-5 available Odyssey's vs 1 Sienna. (My local Honda and Toyota dealers are owned by the same family--between them, they had 17 used Odysseys and only 3 Siennas.) In the end, I bought a CPO'd 2018 Sienna XLE, 2 years maintenance free, plus the mileage I purchased my van at restarted the clock for the 100k warranty, meaning even though I bought it with 37k miles on it, I get powertrain warranty to 137k miles. Get your Honda dealer to do that for you.
Great review with the point system. An important criteria that you should add, is the types of engines. in this case honda used direct injection and toyota uses port and direct injection, and obviously the toyota wins that department. Thats a deal breaker for me considering the cons of direct injection and the pros of multiport injection
Do not buy the Odyssey I repeat do not buy the Odyssey. I have been a 2018 Odyssey EX-L owner since February 2018 and it has been in the shop for half the time for the same problems. The infotainment system is a mess riddled with bugs. The locking system and the power sliding doors are not reliable. Honda keeps changing parts out and nothing fixes the problem. I have called Honda USA and they are looking into it. I have even taken it to two different dealerships and still, no one can fix it. At this point, I am looking at pursuing a lemon law claim on the Odyssey. Honda dropped the ball on this model year and if you want a stress free life, get the Sienna or any other minivan.
That's the point,.. The Sienna is still reliable, cause they didn't tinker with it to a large extent. It's a common understanding you don't buy a new line of a vehicle for at least 2 years till they work the bugs/kinks out. Cheers
Best comparison presentation that I've seen! I like how you deal with "both the big and the small" , and award a point system. The only slight difference I would make with the excellent option of displaying the presentation as split screen, is to allow maybe one or two seconds longer on each item so a person can take a moment to kind of assess the comparisons a little better. Thank you for this comparison video, it happens to be two vehicles that I'm considering buying. Overall from this I'm liking the Odyssey better, although there are a couple of small features that I would prefer that are in the Sienna.
No doubt the Odyssey wins. The Sienna hasn’t gone through a full redesign since 2011 and it’s age is showing. Hell, the Sienna doesn’t even have LED tail lights for goodness sake. It’s 2018 and not even offering LEDs as a premium option is sorta ridiculous.
the odysseys transmission can explode and Honda has lots of issue EDIT: I think the Toyota is better because of my experiences with Honda's transmission, but others could like the Odyssey better.
Erix - so could the Toyota's...they both are components with moving parts. The fallacy of one car having more issues over the other reeks of fanboy. If that was the case, the Odyssey wouldn't have the best resale value...
LeD is an ok upgrade. But led headlights heat up too much and need an exhaust. Regular halogen or xenon doesnt need that. Also, wavelength of gas bulbs work better on foggy roads. Led has shorter wavelength
I just looked at an Odyssey. The AC vents in middle row are in mid door. Any rear facing car seat will block and get no air at all 🤷🏼♂️. Not sure how that is good for families
Love the Odyssey and the Pacifica, but the Sienna's track record for reliability is incredible. We still won't buy a new one. Not paying that kind of money for a vehicle that hasn't been redesigned since model year 2011. Sorry bud, not happening. A used 2018 will do just fine.
growing up my family had an odyssey and now its collecting dust because of transmission slips and it only has a little over 200k miles. if i do end up getting a minivan, im going with toyota. i dont want to risk dealing with the transmission down the road.
Definitely, the Honda for me has the transmission reliability issue/worry. I had the second gen Odyssey and the transmissions failed three times. The dealer replaced the first under warranty @ ~99k, but replaced with a used transmission. Arguments with the dealer for replacement of old instead of new; it failed after ~30k miles. Then the second transmission failed and after arguing with the dealer again since they put in a used transmission when they should have put in a new; I paid half the cost for the dealer to replace with another used transmission. The second transmission began to fail @ ~180k miles. No more Honda automatics for me.
Should have mentioned that there is an assistive seating in the back seats for the Sienna- major decision point for taking my elderly parents out and/or strapping a kid in a carseat!
Nope I have a 2016 Odyssey EXL NAVI. 4th Odyssey and it's unbelievable no tranny probs because I change the AT fluid religiously and do a complete change with Honda AT fluid . Check out the best selling vans in the USA that will tell the story. But I'm not going to badmouth the Toyota as thats just childish. But who created this class of vans Chrysler in 1974. In 1999 Honda introduced the full size Odyssey version and the rest is history. But a Corolla is the number one selling automobile in history and it's reliable, but as all manufactured mass production vehicles it's had it's troubles. The No. 1 selling vehicle of all time is the Honda Cub or super cub. 100,000,000 and counting. So that's where I come from but that's me.
Excellent video! Very smartly portrayed. You sound young, but very smart!
Thank you so much! I appreciate that :)
Odyssey Looks cooler but the reliability ain't there
SP FromNY914 ur right, but at least it isn’t a Chrysler van
Great video
Thank you
As a mechanic and not a soccer mom, I have to go with Toyota.
A Man that knows cars!
same
AWD + Better Transmission you can’t go far with a nice design and cute little button Toyota looks 3-5 years behind but still better!
@@claudiacantero515 depends which year of odyssey you are 'obsessed' with. i agree honda tends to over engineering. but they keep improving and improving and pushing forward and don't run away from their problems. will see how the path leads to.
Joseph Pae So is Odyssey lol
honda has the better interior and exterior, but Toyota has the more reliable powertrain. even though the Sienna is an older design, the mechanical upgrades make it a better choice in my opinion
WRONG. Honda just has a better Front Grille. Everything else is a wash.
I would have to say the van with the largest cargo space has the better interior and that would be the Seinna. Isn't cargo space why you buy a van in the first place ?
@@muddyriverdogz largest cargo space no. If thats the case then id buy a bus.
The Honda Odyssey has one of the ugliest side profiles I've ever seen on a vehicle. The odd, fucked up body lines are real head scratchers.
When you remove the seats, the Chrysler and Sienna have a better thought out floor and seat track system. The Odyssey has unusual humps, pockets and grooves for junk to get caught up in.
I would go for the Sienna.
@LightningMcQueen4eva! the older Odysseys were better. My mom drives one. After 12 years, it's still performing well. The new Odyssey doesn't look that great from the outside and also consumes more engine oil.
I'd go with the Sienna because it has slightly better performance and fuel economy, as well as more trunk space and smaller turning radius. And who cares if the wheels are too small? The smaller the wheels, the easier it is to take off and less space needed for u turns.
Odyssey transmissions are not as good
I would also note the stowaway jump seat in the Sienna. It fits conveniently into a dedicated compartment in the back without giving up any storage space, which as can be seen in the video is not the case for the Odyssey.
Two major factors for me...1 an AWD option and 2 a timing chain engine. You decide!
Here in Canada, Toyota's AWD is winner over any other minivans. Even a little push from the rear wheels helps a lot in handling in snow, and most importantly gives you more confidence feeling.
My parents have a 2017 odyssey and I have a 2011 Sienna. There’s many similarities/differences between the functions of this van, it’s very much preferences. The biggest difference between these two is the power train. It’s true when everyone says the Sienna’s power train is bulletproof, with over 200,000km the power is still very linear and smooth unlike the odyssey. My parents would definitely buy a Sienna and I look forward to my next one.
The price though 😞
I HATE CENTRAL MONITORING SYSTEMS
YOU NEED TO BE ABLE TO CONTROL THINGS WITH JUST BEING ABLE TO FEEL THEM AND NOT HAVING TO TAKE YOUR EYES OFF OF THE ROAD
Apple Tree Did you scream this comment into your phone while driving?
My 1998 Sienna still going strong..! My uncle's 03 Odyssey had an engine light issue that they never could fix it, even they replaced the transmission.
Honda transmissions are no good I have a pilot replaced the transmission I'm looking at buying a van I think I'll go with the Sienna
My criteria for minivan: 1. Reliable, don’t let the family stay at the road side; 2. Space, that’s minivan for, otherwise buy a SUV or wagon; 3. Easy to maneuver, bigger interior space but small exterior, easy parking and turn; 4. Good price... top 3 go to Sienna
The Honda Odyssey looks awesome! The Toyota Sienna looks conservative.
Ethan J Torres The Toyota Sienna.
I meant what does conservation mean
If you want less conservative then you can consider the SE trim on the Sienna. It's the same level as the XLE reviewed here, but with a more "sporty" emphasis.
Ethan J Torres Conservative means not very stylish.
What do you mean not stylish the front actually had good creativity ever since the front design from 2015 and the upgrade is great. The Honda Odyssey still has the same look for idk 3 years!
SIenna for sure; without the worry of transmission issues?
If you have a 7-year, 100,000 mile powertrain warranty, what are you worried about?
John Lillyblad He is worried because transmission issues start at 150K for the Odyssey.
Abdulaziz Al Saeed 2018+ oddly has class action for the peice of crap 10 speed that burns oil and gas and shuts down to park when driving! Toyota for the win!
@Joseph Pae You just wait buddy.
Yes Honda has very bad transmission issues I have a Honda pilot and I have replaced the transmission in it looking at buying a van I think I'll go with the Toyota
Why didn't the Sienna get a point for the 110 household outlet? We use that plug all the time. It is very convenient and useful.
You only get it on the XLE trim for the Sienna, in the Odyssey if you take the next trim (with rear DVD) you also get one.
@@samdovels1234 this is helpful.
My mom has a Honda for 15+ years with no problems.. I got a Honda touring 2016 which is great, I just wish the Honda had all wheel drive.
i have an 05 odyssey touring and still looks and runs like new
Great review.....you can’t go wrong with either....press the button and go, practical, high tech....slight edge to the HONDA...I’d drive either !
Thanks!
I agree with you on a few details. Temperature controls are much better designed on the Sienna (as a rule, knobs are ALWAYS better, both on media volume control/tune AND temperature controls). I also agree to another reviewer about the analog gauges, it's a pity that Honda didn't include an option of analog-like gauges on the Odysseys digital display. I disagree with the audio/speaker quality, the Sienna sounds better IMO than the Odyssey, Honda was never good with speakers and always use low quality speaker systems for lower models. You have to step up to the top-of-the-line ELITE trim in order to get an improved stereo system. Remember, this is a family vehicle, not a pickup truck!! People wanna listen to some nice, rich music!
Power sliding door is also different, the Sienna has a clever design, one button toggles between open/close, simple! The Odyssey with the open/close button and constant beeps is seriously unintuitive.
You didn't mention that the center row middle seat on the Sienna is not suited for an adult, the Odyssey is wider and more comfortable. However, in the Sienna you can slide the seat more to the back, leaving a lot of leg room for middle row.
Reliability is a big issue on the new Odyssey, maybe because it's built in the US, I dunno, they used to be better. There are a lot of complains, just do a search. Sienna is still more reliable, especially that it's older.
But the review was very nice in general. Thanks.
The Odyssey was built in Alliston Ontario Canada for the first 5 years, then production was transferred to Lincoln Alabama for the 2004 production. They're built in the USA since then. Issues I've had have been with design on my 1st three Odysseys. But they were taken care of to my satisfaction. My 2016 Odyssey EXL NAVI is over 2 years old and has never seen the dealer since I picked it up. Do my own service using Honda genuine parts only.
Knob controls and INDEPENDENT of each other is important.
2nd row middle seat in sienna just doesn't look like a seat for an adult, but have you tried sitting on it? i'll tell you, it sits as comfortably as the rest of the other seats..you wouldn't live for the rest of your life in the middle seat, would you?..just thinking..peace!
Car Confections. The Sienna has the new D4-S V6 engine, with both Direct and Multi-Port injection, this eliminates the intake valve carbon build up problems in Direct Injection only engines, which is what the Honda has.
very true. In addition to carbon buildup on the intake valves, DI also uses up alot of fuel injectors since the injectors are located inside the blast chamber, that is an important thing to consider,its a deal breaker for me.
I must say, that is one of the better comparison videos I've seen between these two minivans. Well done. The only thing I'll disagree with you on is giving the Odyssey a point for the electronic parking brake. I have never been a fan of those things so that would have shifted the numbers a little toward the Sienna and made this much closer if I were making the judgments. Beyond that, I thought you were spot on and very fair. I'm also not a fan of push button transmission controls. I prefer the good ol shift lever like the Toyota has but I wouldn't applied points one way or the other because of it. One other thing that you didn't focus on is the fact that most reliability comparisons these days tend to give the nod to the Toyota by a fair margin over the Honda. My biggest complaint with the Toyota, and I can't believe I'm saying this, is simply the fact that they seem to be so far behind on the technology. For a major player like Toyota to not have Android Auto and Apple Carplay in their app suites is inexcusable these days but it wouldn't be a deal breaker for me.
Thank you! We appreciate that! And also thank you for your feedback!
Agree on the missing android and apple apps. I have a 2013 Toyota Avalon, missing both these app's and they STILL haven't caught up,.. that's nuts. Makes me think they are too cheep to pay the licensing for threes. Hmmm
I like this comparison of the two mini vans, but I go for Sienna due to its reliability in this 2018 model comparing to 2018 Odyssey having 9/10 speed transmission issues + doors + central console malfunctioning issues..etc
I agree. If our 2007 Odyssey gets totaled, the replacement minivan would definitely be this one. Honda doesn't suck, but their larger vehicles don't perform as well as Toyota's
Both van are awesome, but I would go with the sienna because it's the only van with 4wd. So safety come first before looks 😁
KanJi Vang Yep...as much as I love Odysseys, I'm gonna have to go with Siennas, Toyotas last forever...😂
The Sienna does not offer 4WD. However it does offer an AWD option, don't get the twos mix up.
As far as " safety " goes, they're about the same. If you're talking about off the line traction then yes, the AWD will have the advantage, but it will have a longer stopping distance compare to the FWD which is more important in term of " safety ".
If you live where it doesn't get colder than 40 degree F, a FWD will do just fine. Otherwise a proper set of winter tires will be much safer.
glad u chose sienna I have a sienna from 2011
AWD doesn't do much for safety, snow tires make a bigger difference.
KanJi Vang but Honda actual safety ratings are better.
I just bought the 2018 Toyota Sienna for 3 main reasons compare to the Honda Odyssey. Toyota uses timing chain vs Honda uses timing belt(high maintenance long term), Toyota V6 engine with port and direct injection (avoid valve carbon build up long term) vs Honda only direct inject V6, and lastly is the problematic Honda ZF 9 speed transmission.
I like a gas cap (helps keeps the debris out) and a locking gas door. A higher ground clearance (honda is much lowere) and a sliding door that does not bang against the curb, when opening it. Honda door goes out and then slides on the ones I drove.
It's not a Honda transmission...the Honda transmission is 10 speed. The ZF9 is made by Chrysler.
Excellent points. Hey, I was not aware that Honda still uses timing belts on these. That used to be a 6 hour repair at our dealership. On the other hand, I was not aware when Toyota stopped using a belt on the Sienna. Maybe 2010?
@@CaptainDawg02 Thanks for the info. If the ZF9 made from Chrysler, I'll stay away from Odyssey. Chrysler has poor credit on it's transmission. Till minutes ago I was thinking give Odyssey a try.
Johnny Zheng - Honda has their own 10 speed transmission in the Touring and Elite trims. Phenomenal transmission. Super smooth!
Just bought the Odyssey. I have NO idea why you’d buy the Sienna. I drove it home in pour rain and it is silent and our pothole infested loop was almost unnoticeable. Our previous RAV4 sounded like the tires would come off. Extremely comfy for a 6’5” guy and technology that is really useful!
transmission problems. great reason
Mister Berzins - nope. Honda built 10 speed transmission on the top two trim levels. Works flawlessly. Stop spouting incorrect statements.
Ok, so you're comparing the noise level in your Odyssey to your Rav4? Apples to oranges? Drive a Sienna in the rain, then tell us how night and day the comparison was.
not sure how honda is but, Ive owned many other brands and have a toyota. When getting an oil change with others, even though they said free oil change, I still have to pay $50 min each oil change. The toyota we have had for 6 years, never paid a dime for oil change, only service. In 6 years we have paid under $500 for 2 services. so ya odyssey maybe new, I will go back to toyota for their servicing
Thanks for not being helpful.
Would have liked a demo of how to remove and re-install the 2nd and 3rd row seats
Thanks for the great comparison. I need a minivan since my family is growing. Still very tough for me to decide between the two.
I can't afford the new 2021 Toyota, so I have to opt the the best with my budget which is 2018 models.
Toyota advantage:
- AWD
- Timing Chain
Honda advantage:
- Way better 2nd row bench seat (center seat) compared to Toyota child-like seat that they forgot to add in until after production.
- More cabin room for passengers
- Apple CarPlay and Android Auto
I’m in the same boat.
I had a 99 Odyssey then an 11 Sienna. The Toyota has more room and reliability. I will be getting an 18 soon. So what if the techy screen isn't as good with Toyota. We all need less screen time, especially while driving.
my 2005 odyssey touring still runs like new
me too
My 07 Odyssey Touring is dead due to timing belt failure.
@@TheVitalishe had timing done 96 thousand miles and 185 thousand miles
mine broke at 170K miles
@@TheVitalishe that sucks mine got crashed 3months ago total loss
Rather than complicated and rather unreliable electronic screens, it sure would be nice to have simple twist knobs for the HVAC and radio.
I agree 100%. It's something I don't like about my 05 sienna van.
Should have used the Sienna SE in this comparison. 19" wheels and looks WAY better. Also sportier suspension and a nice looking black interior. Sienna is also more powerful and more reliable.
I own a 2019 sienna se and it's awesome 👌. Odyssey don't have a chance on my van
I like the analog gauges in the Sienna better. The Odyssey’s gauge cluster is disappointing, I would have given the point to Toyota there. As far as reliability I’d say it’s a draw. I like Honda products in general, however the AWD availability in the Sienna would make it my choice as far as minivans. Good review by the way.
Thanks!! Glad you liked it! And yeah, some of the points were pretty close, but at the end of the day the choice is yours!
Actually driving both vans would have made it a good review.
Great video, thanks. Sienna all the way. My 2004 sienna is 440,000 kilometres - the performance is AWESOME!
Would love to see a comparison between 2019 touring elite and limited elite models of these vans. Though your videos are having me lean very closely to picking the odyssey. I enjoyed this video and the in depth one of the 2019 odyssey elite. Thanks!
Thanks! We're glad you enjoyed it and found it helpful! And we appreciate you watching!
Sienna the best
We have a 2018 Toyota Sienna XLE, which replaced our 2006 Sienna Limited Trim. With the third row seats flat, tucked in, our two huge German Shepherds have plenty of room to comfortably endure long rides.
A few safety measures are missing in 2018 that were standard in the 2006:
1. Front parking Sonar sensors.
2. No cruise control if
2.a the wipers were ON, and
2.b you were driving nighttime into the blinding glare of oncoming traffic or at bright sunrise or sunset.
Very interesting perspective. The side by side comparison was enlightening.
Glad you liked it!
I am an Odyssey fan and own the first two generations. However, I am not excited about the curve look of the Odyssey. It's more soccer mom look to me. I still love minivan for their utility nature. My next minivan will be Sienna XLE AWD for sure.
agree, i don't like the new look of the Odyssey
This is my favorite looking model to date.
I like that they carried the lightning bolt theme over from the last Gen. I don't like the fact that they look at just soccer moms as it's a great utility vehicle plus. But I like the look but my 2016 still has appeal for me as well. But I don't buy a vehicle like this based on cosmetics only. Yeah it's nice to have a ride that looks great but it could be a 3 dressed up as a 9 and be lousy overall. Just saying.
Once inside you can't see the outside. In my 55 years of car ownership, I have never had someone come up to me and say, "man you have an unattractive car". What's wrong with you people.
I like the sienna, but odyssey won my heart. I bought a 2019 odyssey because of its NHTSA’s 5-Star Safety Ratings. Safety first before anything else.
@@alfredo9494 The Honda Odyssey made 5-stars in the following NHTSA** simulations:
Overall Front Star Rating
Front Passenger Side
In contrast, the Toyota only earned 4-stars, and it entirely lacks the Odyssey’s available Road Departure Mitigation System (RDM).
I also like that Honda has more room & has a sliding seat on the 2nd row for easy access to 3rd row.
Turns into a pumpkin at 60k miles. No thanks.
Michelle Vargas yeah, my dad had a 2012 odyssey and around 65k miles, it gave us lots of problems (a/c, bearings, weird noises), my dad didn’t want it anymore and ended up getting a 2019 last fall. We also thought about a Pacifica.
Technology=Odyssey
Reliability=Sienna
How is the Honda not reliable? 😂
Gryazev-Shipunov is that why all the Honda owners I know have their cars with 300k miles on it?
I agree even if I used both models
300k on engine. NOT the transmission. ie. My odyssey has 204,000 on engine. On 4th transmission!
leeozawa I’m speaking about their transmissions as well. I know someone with a 2011 civic with 310k miles, original tranny, regular scheduled maintenance. If you take care of things, they last
I like the odyssey better. Especially with the touring headlights. you also need to do a review on the 2018 Kia Forte EX
Dicky Ball inferior? You mean interior?
Dicky Ball my uncle has 240k miles on his odyssey and it never had a problem, 2006
Alexziah Estrada once they reach 60k miles, there will be problems. At least with the 4th gens.
I'd go with the Honda Odyssey for me bro.
did a good job of comparing this two nice van
Nice detailed vid. I just wish they offered the Odyssey in AWD.
They do now!
I LOVE my Hondas, but because of the transmission issues, I will never buy another. It's not even having to replace the transmission, it's that Honda doesn't manufacture the new ones so you can only get a remanufactured one and they DON'T feel near as good! I will say, to have a 300,000 and 400,000 mile engine in perfect condition is pretty awesome!
All through the years my YOTAs did well!! thanks for the review looking forward to get 2020 AWD Sienna! ( year of the virus)
Both are great, can't go wrong with either one.
The Sienna is a little outdated compare to the Odyssey, but Toyota usually offers great rebates and incentives which will attract more buyers who are on a budget.
Dicky Ball you own one?
Hybrids Vader - he doesn't. He is a Toyota fanboy.
Hybrids Vader id pick a 2004 sienna over a 2018 oddysey. Toyotas built like rocks.
Come on, be fair.
Dicky Ball Honda’s do not have transmission problems my mom has one and she never had transmission problems so you are wrong
I have this Honda. No complaints. Very good minivan.
Love the side by side take. Best comparison yet
Enjoy our comparison on two of the most advanced vehicles on the road: the all-new 2018 Honda Odyssey and refreshed 2018 Toyota Sienna! Also, please LIKE and SUBSCRIBE if you enjoyed :)
I have a Pacifica and after this video I like the sienna more than the odyssey
yes , over all
Pacifica - love their styling,.. but sorry for your repair bills. ( if even the future ones ). Remember ,.. it's a Chrysler,.. so if bought new,... only good for 4-6 years (on rare occasions a little more) before things start going.
i m still driving sienna 2001 . its great but i feel like they dint done with many thinks in 19 years. today i see sienna 2020 and still looks same and looks heavy. but the odyssy i start to feeling love with it
You could not have done a better job. If you are a car salesman, I would not mess with you ; ) You covered everything and did it in a quick and pleasant way.
Thanks, Megan! We appreciate it!
both are excellent vehicles. But like Chris inductivo said Toyota has more reliable powertrain.... so my choice is sienna although 2GR-FE engine is loud
love your reviews. I would suggest though you weigh your point system more accurately. for example, the material on the inside door stuff, should not be worth 1 point, when something like reliability and cargo space is also worth only 1 point each. Something like door aesthetics should be worth more like 0.5 points. Like different levels of points depending on importance.
Thanks! We are actually doing the half point thing in more recent comparisons!
@@CarConfections you should consider adding type of engine criteria, such as between direct injection engine(odyssey) direct and port injection (sienna) and in that crucial department sienna wins. Research these 2 types and you will know which is better.
Test drove 19 Odyssey with 20 Sienna. The seats on Honda are very uncomfortable. The bulge in the mid of the seat causes pressure to the back and the seat feels like it’s closing in on you. Am positive it will be uncomfortable for long rides. I disagree with the leg space in the mid row. In the Sienna you can move the seats a lot back thus giving a lot of leg room. The seats of Sienna are lot better. The Sienna rode a lot smoother, more quieter. Few things worry me about Sienna is that I have heard the tires wear out quickly. Currently the old Odyssey that my parents have had issues with dual climate control in the 4th year and ac went bust in the 8th year. The sliding doors went bust in the 9th year. Also Sienna has a AC outlet where you can charge your laptop.
Good review! Thanks! I'm utterly astounded that the Toyota wouldn't have integrated Apple or Android already - that seriously is a huge fail for me. I see Dickywhatever making a million comments against Honda transmission, but it's hard to take that seriously when it's like basically one person making all the comments trashing the Honda transmission LOL
9 speed is not that reliable but 10 speed on higher trims is better. According to media reports. Honda uses 10 speed on new Accord as well so I suspect it will be more reliable in long run.
Thanks a lot. The most in depth and practical comparison I saw.
Glad you liked it! Thanks!
The Toyota Sienna’s safety system is standard. And to add to that TSS is standard on majority of their vehicles. Honda will make you purchase that. I was looking to buy a corolla or civic, when I heard leds and safety systems weren’t standard on the civic I went to toyota for sure. LEDs and Safety is the main things for cars.
You nailed it! Awesome video! Keep doing what you doing. In the future would like to see Highlander vs... whatever you decide as compatible.... I really loved this video!
Thanks! :)
I bought my 18 ody in aug 2017, went through couple non safety problem, no regret although I saw the service dude more than my dad lol. The only reason I bought mine without a second thought is the 2nd row slidable captain chairs! I went test drive the Sienna, driving was superior, but the heck was, simply look at the second row, the middle seat has a metal pole expanding out when you take it out lol. What's going on?
There's not really a comparison if you're comparing the Toyota sienna limited. Toyota last longer and it's cheaper to fix. The entertainment system in the vehicle is also better. Cabin watch is a useless feature and promotes distracted drivers. The Honda Can't beat the Toyotas all wheel drive. I live in Maine the winters are terrible the roads are bad you need to have something like that.
I've owned 2 Toyota vans; one got 254k miles and the second 285k. Had to finally replace the 2nd one in August, before I'd seen this video. However, I'd been looking around for a year or two because of the mileage on my last one--it was still running great, but how long can you drive a 16 year old van? Anyway, the one consistent thing I found was that if you were looking at used models, in my area there were 4-5 available Odyssey's vs 1 Sienna. (My local Honda and Toyota dealers are owned by the same family--between them, they had 17 used Odysseys and only 3 Siennas.) In the end, I bought a CPO'd 2018 Sienna XLE, 2 years maintenance free, plus the mileage I purchased my van at restarted the clock for the 100k warranty, meaning even though I bought it with 37k miles on it, I get powertrain warranty to 137k miles. Get your Honda dealer to do that for you.
Honda is not bad though, I already bought 2019 Honda Odyssey EX-L.
Great review with the point system. An important criteria that you should add, is the types of engines.
in this case honda used direct injection and toyota uses port and direct injection, and obviously the toyota wins that department. Thats a deal breaker for me considering the cons of direct injection and the pros of multiport injection
Do not buy the Odyssey I repeat do not buy the Odyssey. I have been a 2018 Odyssey EX-L owner since February 2018 and it has been in the shop for half the time for the same problems. The infotainment system is a mess riddled with bugs. The locking system and the power sliding doors are not reliable. Honda keeps changing parts out and nothing fixes the problem. I have called Honda USA and they are looking into it. I have even taken it to two different dealerships and still, no one can fix it. At this point, I am looking at pursuing a lemon law claim on the Odyssey. Honda dropped the ball on this model year and if you want a stress free life, get the Sienna or any other minivan.
James Calderon 🚀🚀
Honda has put in effort to fix those problems!
Even the best cars have their lemons
Did you get any resolution yet? American Honda is very good at resolving troubles. Hope you sorted it ou. Like to hear one way or the other.
Thanks for the info ,I've had many Toyota very reliable
I feel you should have mentioned engine reliability more in depth.
Excellent video. I will say it’s not 100% fair to compare both vehicles as the Sienna is not updated yet for 2018 yet the odyssey is.
That's the point,.. The Sienna is still reliable, cause they didn't tinker with it to a large extent. It's a common understanding you don't buy a new line of a vehicle for at least 2 years till they work the bugs/kinks out. Cheers
Very carefully completed work like a project. And very thoughtful from customer point of view. Excellent and thanks.
Thanks for the kind words!
The savings in price on the Odyssey will not even begin to pay for the transmission you will have to replace. It's Sienna all the way!
I was thinking the same thing
@Car Confections. You forgot to mention that the sienna can be had with 19 inch wheels on the SE trim
Best comparison presentation that I've seen! I like how you deal with "both the big and the small" , and award a point system.
The only slight difference I would make with the excellent option of displaying the presentation as split screen, is to allow maybe one or two seconds longer on each item so a person can take a moment to kind of assess the comparisons a little better.
Thank you for this comparison video, it happens to be two vehicles that I'm considering buying. Overall from this I'm liking the Odyssey better, although there are a couple of small features that I would prefer that are in the Sienna.
So glad you liked it!
Believe it or not I’ve seen more Odyssey in the junkyard than the Sienna, but I gotta say honda did a very good job 👍🏼 still go for the Sienna tho
Yep. Plus those very old 12-13 year old Honda 3.5L V6's had VVT problems as well.
I'm trying to convince my mom to get a Sienna. She wants an Odyssey or a Pacifica. Sienna is more reliable than both!
No doubt the Odyssey wins. The Sienna hasn’t gone through a full redesign since 2011 and it’s age is showing. Hell, the Sienna doesn’t even have LED tail lights for goodness sake. It’s 2018 and not even offering LEDs as a premium option is sorta ridiculous.
Sean Mangubat don't forget, the grand caravan had led tail lights since 2011
the odysseys transmission can explode and Honda has lots of issue
EDIT: I think the Toyota is better because of my experiences with Honda's transmission, but others could like the Odyssey better.
Erix - so could the Toyota's...they both are components with moving parts. The fallacy of one car having more issues over the other reeks of fanboy. If that was the case, the Odyssey wouldn't have the best resale value...
LeD is an ok upgrade. But led headlights heat up too much and need an exhaust. Regular halogen or xenon doesnt need that. Also, wavelength of gas bulbs work better on foggy roads. Led has shorter wavelength
Especially when you consider the price of replacing LED lights, few buyers on the fence would consider this the deal maker/breaker.
I got 2018 awd sienna month ago. Love it so far
I just looked at an Odyssey. The AC vents in middle row are in mid door. Any rear facing car seat will block and get no air at all 🤷🏼♂️. Not sure how that is good for families
Sieena is a minivan with great top speed
Love the Odyssey and the Pacifica, but the Sienna's track record for reliability is incredible. We still won't buy a new one. Not paying that kind of money for a vehicle that hasn't been redesigned since model year 2011. Sorry bud, not happening. A used 2018 will do just fine.
Should've just reviewed both top of the line models. Lots of features were missed on the Sienna.
how nice is that side-to side- 2nd row seat movement, eh parents with fighting kids?
growing up my family had an odyssey and now its collecting dust because of transmission slips and it only has a little over 200k miles. if i do end up getting a minivan, im going with toyota. i dont want to risk dealing with the transmission down the road.
All Wheel Drive Minivan = LOVE!
Nice review and comparison. Thanks.
Glad you liked it!
I needed this and honda here I come
A replacement FOB for the Toyota is over $400.00. I was shocked.
The sienna is looking older and older every year. It needs a new refresh soon!
Anthony Fajardo I think it’s going to get one in a few years.
Thanks you for your video.
I like it.
Great video! very informative
Thank you!
Toyota Vienna 2018! I love Toyota sienna
Definitely, the Honda for me has the transmission reliability issue/worry. I had the second gen Odyssey and the transmissions failed three times. The dealer replaced the first under warranty @ ~99k, but replaced with a used transmission. Arguments with the dealer for replacement of old instead of new; it failed after ~30k miles. Then the second transmission failed and after arguing with the dealer again since they put in a used transmission when they should have put in a new; I paid half the cost for the dealer to replace with another used transmission. The second transmission began to fail @ ~180k miles. No more Honda automatics for me.
Excellent review!
Has Honda fixed the 9speed on the 2019? I’ve always owned Honda’s, but the new odyssey was rated the least reliable minivan.
The Toyota Sienna is easier to understand.
I have a 2016 Honda with 102k so almost 35k miles a year thank God no promblems so far
Should have mentioned that there is an assistive seating in the back seats for the Sienna- major decision point for taking my elderly parents out and/or strapping a kid in a carseat!
We have a 2016 Odyssey EXL it beats the 2016 Sienna across the board!
only on paper.
Nope I have a 2016 Odyssey EXL NAVI. 4th Odyssey and it's unbelievable no tranny probs because I change the AT fluid religiously and do a complete change with Honda AT fluid . Check out the best selling vans in the USA that will tell the story. But I'm not going to badmouth the Toyota as thats just childish. But who created this class of vans Chrysler in 1974. In 1999 Honda introduced the full size Odyssey version and the rest is history. But a Corolla is the number one selling automobile in history and it's reliable, but as all manufactured mass production vehicles it's had it's troubles. The No. 1 selling vehicle of all time is the Honda Cub or super cub. 100,000,000 and counting. So that's where I come from but that's me.
Yeah good luck with it not passing any tests (:
Give it time....reliability over long run wil become a reality? Peace.
Best looking Odyssey = 2005 -2010 Best Looking Sienna = 2011-2017. Best Looking Hearse = Odyssey 2011-2020
Have both these vans very good
This was SO helpful!!!!!
Awesome video, I loved well done the review... now I know which one to buy!😍😍
Thanks! Glad it was useful for you!
Please do a 2020 comparison