Chlöe Swarbrick accuses PM Luxon of climate 'lie' | 1News
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ธ.ค. 2023
- Green MP Chlöe Swarbrick has avoided being kicked out of the House after calling out what she claimed was a "demonstrable lie" told by Prime Minister Christopher Luxon.
-
Check out The Story I’ll Never Forget 👉 • The Story I'll Never F...
Watch more John Campbell in-depth 👉 • John Campbell Investig...
Watch highlights from the 1News Archives 👉 • 1News Archives
-
This is the official channel of TVNZ's 1News, where we deliver and explain the news that matters to Aotearoa New Zealand. Featuring news and current affairs reports from 1News, Seven Sharp, Breakfast, Q+A, Fair Go and Sunday.
---
Subscribe to 1News: bit.ly/1NEWSSubscribe | For the latest news from Aotearoa and overseas: 1News.co.nz
This is the official channel of TVNZ's 1News, where news and current affairs reports are uploaded from 1News, Seven Sharp, Breakfast, Q+A, Fair Go and Sunday.
![[MPD직캠] 베이비몬스터 직캠 8K 'FOREVER' (BABYMONSTER FanCam) | @MCOUNTDOWN_2024.7.11](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ylRx8QOuGXo/mqdefault.jpg)
Glad one news has the brass to allow commenting on their videos so people can speak their mind on what they are viewing. Tired of seeing strategically clipped snippets posted by news hub and not being able to comment or view other people's opinions on these subjects
Hear-hear!
It's very selective brass... In fact I'd go so far as to say that TV 1 has only one nut, when it comes to unreservedly allowing the public to voice an opinion on their media. But hey... perhaps the new government has compelled them to desist from blocking public opinion. It is early days for the squirming lefties of the MSM.
Don’t speak too soon. They don’t allow comments on all their videos.
No comments it's propaganda not worth watching. There is no mainstream media, just propaganda
I note a number of NZ First posts on YT. Got to get that propaganda machine rolling. Unfortunately Winston & a few of his cabal fail to learn from their past failures. Everytime they have been fractious * end up getting booted. Last time into political oblivion
Winston & Jonesy are all about tooting their own horns & dining at the trough.
The irony in Chloe calling PM a liar, and then proceeding to lie about what she just stated on record.
I dont think Chloe could lie straight in bed. Forever destined to be in opposition yelling shit from the sidelines. She couldn't handle being in government
@@ManUnitedNZ-ng5jwvery true. It will be interesting to see her gradual descent into bitterness and irrelevancy over the next 6+ years in opposition as she struggles to maintain her attack dog role necessitated by the paucity of alternatives. I can see some burgeoning traits of Auntie Helen which might flower into full blown resentment when not rewarded.
Keep it up greens 😊
@@ManUnitedNZ-ng5jw she doesn't want to be in government. She doesn't want to solve real problems. Only stay as opposition and as a victim. All while collecting that fat pay cheque.
@@user-mc6js8or3rI love it when the Greens talk, it shows just how out of touch with the real world they are.
James Shaw, leader of this party lied about having a degree from Victoria university. When will he be held to account?
That's a nice deflection there.
And that other Green, the Iranian lied in her CV / profile that she acted as a lawyer in a defense of a case, but was just a junior law clerk.
The Greens are a huge liability to the country.
Quite. Another bunch of media types suppressing information.
@@rod-contracts1616 all frauds.
He cryd like a little girl when he got punched in the head😂 he'd b better off playin soggy biscuit with Kelvin Davies and chrippy
Dang, I couldn't think of a worse job than to be the Speaker of the House and put up with all of these childish actions from all parties.
Brownlee is nailing his role, fair on all accounts and has given the benefit of the doubt a few times now.
Yeah you can tell he was a teacher...
I will concede he is doing his job. Lockwood was a great Speaker as well. Mallard....not so much. (Never voted for the right) Also, Chloe is correct.
He's not landing a 737 at wellington Airport aye
@@rikgell2650 😂
Interested to see he let Winston speack over him, but pulls in Marama for the same thing. Fair on all accounts? Must be ya first Rode-o 😂
Wow Chloe is clearly exposed in the audio and still denying.. funny how she is the obvious lier in this instance
Ohhh the irony 😂
She denied nothing
@@dangerrayy lier lier pants on fire 😜
*liar
Typical of far left Marxists
Chloe needs to understand there is a difference from being an activist and a politician.
She operates from a self-righteous ego.
Yea there is a big difference, activist dont cheat lie and talk shit
@@trex2579 to be honest they both do. The big difference in politics is that you actually have to follow the rules
@@dm45t1n the difference being 1 believes there message with all there heart and the other is paid to believe whatever the dollar tells them to
@@dm45t1n who ever needs laws to be loosened to make prophit mate dont act, e.g drilling someone say luxon give you this cuzzy BUT we need permision from the government to do this over here, ax those laws pretty please my cuzzy
I thought the Greens believed that actions have consequences and you aren't allowed to just say what you want? But the second Swarbrick was about to face said consequences for her comment she tried to weasel her way out of it. The irony of lying about calling someone a liar is not lost on me either. Can parliament stop this childish name calling and just run the country.
clearly you didn't listen to Chloe's justification
@@YiffyStiffyMeow That's the weaselling of which I was referring. Luxon said "We are not weakening our actions on climate change" and Swarbrick interjected "Yes you are. That's a demonstrable lie". She was out of order. It isn't a sign of weakness to own up to things. It's time that politicians behave like adults. The cheeky barbs might make for good television but I really want better from our leaders. Both left and right alike.
@@YiffyStiffyMeow she accused him of lying then lied about it.
@@YiffyStiffyMeow A weasel getting out of her lie - that's for sure - hope they check out the tapes and take action.... dock her pay, she'll have less to spend on her whacky backy... so bad is her addiction that half the time she looks mad and spaced out while other times she is slow and almost asleep.
The combined carbon footprint of a measly population of 5 million kiwis won't make a dent to climate change. China with its 1.4 billion population is the world's biggest emitter of carbon emissions and yet they are still planning to build two new coal plants every week. Chloe needs to shave her armpits and realise that Aotearoa is an ant not an elephant when it comes to climate change, and that there are far more important local issues that need focus such as crime and cost of living.
China is switching to renewables faster than the us
What can be most urgent that maintaining a liveable planet. There will be more poverty, injustice, conflicts, crimes, caused by inaction. Every country, every sector need to reduce their carbon emissions. Every! Doing nothing is suicidal and it's time everyone realised that.
@@myriammarcon9649 are any countries doing nothing?
So tell us all whats the solution??
hundreds of millions going overseas for carbon emisions for who and what ?
Plant more trees ? That money should stay here !No wonder nz is in debt . OHH Thats rite jacinda in the usa spending it . our poor farmers and hard workers of this country
@@myriammarcon9649 Is that you Greta???????
How is anything NZ does
going to change the Climate in any MEASURABLE way?
It’s a scientific question.
By that logic, I assume you will not be voting in the next election? Could you please explain to your friends why their choices and votes carry no weight either.
I’m just putting out there a scientific fact, and possibly those
so let emotion or groupthink to override their judgement, take pause and onboard reality.
I don’t see why I must recuse myself from the ballot for being factual?
It seems wokeness trumps logic?
Brownlee is really good
chloe should be sacked for her bully actions
Lol. Don't be a cry baby the PM can handle those comments and doesn't need Seymour or Winston to baby sit him.
Agreed
@@richardbuttenshaw3569 what are you agreeing with. Let's not become the party of snowflakes over a trivial comment FFS. @kb-bf4zd needs to call a wham-bulance.
Swarbrick is such a waste of space, this woman has no idea about the real world yet thinks she has the wisdom to lecture everyone.
Like the saying goes " It's the empty drum that sounds loudest"
I'm still wondering what it is that you do, James.
@@AnthonyFlack James is a rabid conspiracy theorist- he has never met a conspiracy insane enough that he didn't embrace it. James is a good example of the importance of getting a good education and not spending all your time watching Jordan Peterson and Joe Rogan videos on TH-cam.
@@dipperdog but most of liberal colleges are a scam. They will turn into a leftist zombie.
@michaeltonks4512 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
What a joke our country has become 👏🏾👏🏾
Yep winnies the joke-r, seymours the penguin n luxos the thumb puppet !!
Is a massive joke, glad I'm living outside of NZ
and nz is finally pushing back against the extreme left. The prevailing winds have shifted.
Since 1840
No the joke is TPM and the insane Greens... what's new...they are pushing their luck with a new Speaker of the House... he has to get tough.
This country is devided almost to the point of agression between factions
Selfish boomers and the rest of us
It's the Marxist agenda Labour and the Greens follow.
@@rikgell2650if it were not for baby boomers, you would not be around
Similar in other countries too especially when the economic growth slows. It will be the norm seeing fights between haves vs have nots.
@@rikgell2650 I’m not a “Boomer” but I see it differently….to me it looks like delusional leftists and their racist mates vs the rest of us…..
Get on with running the country.
All this mob have got is climate and maori....no foward movment on cost of living
So it’s the greens way or nothing is that right ?
Poor NZ putting up with stupid Green MP's
I am not interested in climate change, more interested in our country's economy
Please stay away from scissors.
@@albrennan9976 Please seek professional help asap
Nope. Western civilization must be crippled so failing countries can "catch up" apparently lol.
Listening to the hysterical nonsense spouted by the likes of Swarbrick, just reinforces why over 600,000 Kiwis call Australia home.
Chloe is a demonstrable lie.
😂😂😂
She certainly told a demonstrable lie in a twisting clarification for to cover her ass!😂
@1NEWS Thank you for allowing people to comment about TIME.
I am so over the greens and the hairy one
David Seymour playing the nark
The speaker with the classic 'Arsene Wenger' defence of "Did not see, did not hear"
As an arsenal fan 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Hahaha@@packingawoody4554
david seymour ya taddle tale lol
I'm sick of these two women they were voted out
and this is an example of why..
@@dm45t1n what did they get 11 or 12% of the vote
That means around 88% of voters don't want them there.
@@graemethomson5167 - no it doesn't.
@@graemethomson5167 ACT and NZF got even less, perhaps they should go.
I Don't have an issue with that concept
It’s a pity that power stations can’t run on smugness, ignorant or stupidity. The Green Party could then solve the climate, hundreds of times over.
why are the comments open on this video? yet closed on so many? classic media dog crap.
They have been bought by the previous government. They are furious they could not get grease money from this government.
There is no way that that comment could be directed to the policy-it was clear that it was directed at the PM
So weird that the comments are always turned on now that labour are out.
They don't open comments critical with the previous government, I wonder why?🤷
Carbon credits is a con!
Absolutely. What a scam.
Plants and veges are laughing there green arses off!
Whatever Chloe Swarbrick believes...i believe the exact opposite
Same
@ManUnitedNZ-ng5jw & @banksy
I see you haven't evolved then. Oh well.
@@emmett.francis7894 nope...
@@dm45t1n yes that's right. Got it?
@@dm45t1n The world is cooling
Chloe "from the river to the sea" Swarbrick. A peace loving individual
Haha well put - they're all nutters
They all seem to have forgotten their keffiyeh scarves today. Maybe they've moved on to the next big thing 😆
Although nothing peaceful or loving about her, she's bent every which way.
@@rod-contracts1616 exactly..hence my sarcasm
greens about as relevant today as playing bagpipes in a space suit
😂😂😂
Luckily over 10% of the voting public disagrees with you then. I would argue that Act is far less relevant, the polls are already showing that
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@muppetb.lansing8374 act has liberal values they want people to have equal rights, opportunities and responsibilities, pretty relevant and important in this day and age. Greens just want to push their own social issues
Fun imagery! 😂 Mildly terrifying opinion.
Swarbrick should have been booted out of the house for her slanderous interjection.
@robintamihere4550 No. She fails to understand that there is more than one way to peal a banana.
@@socialite1283 No, she was right, so it's not slander. Also, there is only one way to spell 'peel'.
@@dipperdog Disagree. She lacks the insight to see things from any perspective other than her own.
Disagree all you want. It doesn't change the fact that she is correct nor does it change the fact that you don't know how to spell peel.
@@dipperdog I don't agree with you. Your answer is not based on fact.
There is NO climate disaster...
The scientific consensus (97% of all actively publishing climate scientists) says that there is.
Curious to hear what evidence you have to the contrary.
@@T_Armstrong - they have insults and cry-laugh emojis, how much more convincing do you need?
@@T_Armstrong You really need to research how they came to 97%.
Honestly without knowing the truth you're being mislead.
Chloe is a joke and suggesting Marama is honorable is an insult to those that are
Luxons literally a liar what you smokin 😂
I think she has a crush on Marama 😍
Manama isn’t honourable (we spell it with a ‘u’, by the way, we are not yanks), and she is thick, but I don’t think Swarbrick is a joke. I don’t personally agree with these climate goals, at all, especially since New Zealand is not a slightly significant contributor. She is right, however, that the PM should just have the testicular fortitude to be honest about his policies and just pull out of these ridiculous climate agreements. Since he talks out both sides of his face he is a liar, and she was correct.
TVNZ has turned comments off again on most of its new videos, absolute cowards.
Cooked greenies insanity.
Oh no she's a river to the sea gal
If only the likes of Chloe Swarbrick, read ALL the science, and not just one side.😮
If only past n present governments read n understand the true essence of the treaty rather than the corporate take over side😊
The GREENS are historically, and today, the most well informed party on the environment. It is part of their mandate to preserve the planet for future generations. I remember them sharing a peer reviewed study 20 years ago in climate change projections.
@@chrysallis317You do understand projections are not evidence? In order to understand a truth the projections must be measured against observed outcomes, When it comes to projections ( climate models) they have all projected far more warming than what actually occured( the average model 250% more) the only model which comes close to reality is the russian model, That model assumes the climate is insensative to co2 concentration .If you would like to view the difference between climate model predictions and observed outcomes look up John Christie university of Alabama,Huntsville. He is the person (along with Roy Spencer) who developed the satellite temperature recording system. I would also suggest you read 'unsettled' by Steve Koonan (ex chief science adviser to the obama administration) ,or perhaps works by the likes of Judith Curry, Will Happer ,Willie Soon, Michael Shellenberger, Bjorn Lomborg, just to name a few. Lastly I will quote from the IPCC 5th assessment report .'A signal of climate change has not yet emerged,beyond natural variability in the following, Floods,Heavy precipitation,Landslides,Droughts,Tropical cyclones ctc. So whe James Shaw stood in parliament and stated cyclone Gabriel had all the hallmarks of climate change, He lied.
All of the science IS on one side. Climate change is happening, it's easy to see even for simpletons, and it is human created. FOX isn't science, nor are Facebook posts by bots, so you are demonstrably wrong. Try harder.
@@shanecollie5177 just to clarify, I don’t know about the others you named, but shellenberger and Lomborg definitely do think climatic change is real and human induced.
Why are they not aloud to call out lying? I thought that was the point, the public should know what’s true. Doesn’t seem like democracy working properly if your voting for lies
Because it childish and doesn't help. Your assuming she is right which she isn't.
'the public should know what’s true'? where you been the last 3 years? the publics the last to know
Because it is parliament. There are rules. Politicians are meant to be civil and not act like mud slinging children. The election is over. Time to work together and run the country.
There's chloe yelling again
The fact that Swarbick doesnt have the integrity to acknowledge what she effectively said shows her lack of class and the overall class of the Greens. Her histrionics shows her immaturity.
She completely acknowledged what she said. How did you get to that conclusion. Making up these things actually shows where your maturity is.
Get real. She tried to insinuate later that she was talking about one word when she still stated that Luxon had lied. She played with words. And if you actually listen to what Luxon said, he stated quite clearly that they hadnt changed the position, only approaching it differently. Swarbrick called him a lier. So how about she take accountability of her words and actions, as an adult should. If I call someone a lier and Im wrong I apologise for my mistake.@@dangerrayy
@@dangerrayy She did not. She said he lied and then she twisted her own words to the extent that SHE lied. Very childish.
@@robbiegarscadden2311 She didn't take the word lie back, and admitted that she called what he said a demonstrable lie and that if the shoe fits. Is he a lier on this issue? If he is not , she should apologize
Um, exaserpate? What kind of word is that??
I believe the MPs have access to a translation system that can decipher Marama's speeches.
It's a made up word, like half the maori words spoken by Wellington new age maori speakers with all the phantasmagorical transliterations dreamed up to incorporate bureaucratic language into Te reo. Sadly, modern maori is a tenth of the language it was 50 years ago.
didnt she say exacerbate?
She pronounced it as though she'd substituted the B for a P, though obviously meant exacerbate @@thecolombian8909
She said exacerpate. The b was replaced with a p.@@thecolombian8909
This smug woman-child needs to realise that you can't say someone said a 'lie' without calling that person a 'liar'.
if you get called out on calling someone a liar, just lie about it!
demonstrable -- it still is calling or implying that the PM is a liar. Are we going to let her off the hook.
I couldn't be happier with the coalition so far. Commonsense may just prevail although it's going to be a fight when the media are extremely biased.
??? You mean common sense to do something about the climate disaster that we are heading towards? You realise that the current govt is restarting oil/gas exploration, removing clean car discount, building more motorways (I could go on) All of these things are not going to help with combating climate change yet you thing that it's a good idea? Wow. Just wow.
Is it just me or is Winston beginning to sound like trump ?
beginning? trump is his role model. to great effect.
@@eeeatenthat's a great thing
@@winx4930 if you like opportunism, tribalism and right-wing populism then sure
And that cost us 1 or 2 billion dollars and still no work was done.
Id be more concerned in the dropping level of CO2. Once it reaches 150ppm we all dead.
Given the historically low atmospheric CO2 level , earth can afford to double the current CO2 level without serious consequences. Plant growth would improve. CO2 is the gas of life. It's what drives Photosynthesis and produces Oxygen. Sadly the politics and carbon industry has become too entrenched for rational debate and pragmatic action to prevail. Politicians in NZ and Oz simply bow to Europe because of international trade expectations. It has much less to do with the level of actual threat from CO2. .
Maybe one day the politicians and fearmongers will remember the big yellow thing in the sky that actually drives climate. I guess it's hard to see when you wear blinkers.
@@stephenking4170 Spot on
speaking of demonstrable lies, here's a whole bunch more. Somebody alert the entire global scientific community, we've got a couple of scientific geniuses here who are here to explain why the greenhouse effect isn't real.
No chance of that happening while the Greens are around.
@@jameslast7555 wouldn't worry they are just about a debunked organisation
This is the reason why I worry with Chloe leading the Greens Party. You have to check your emotions. David Seymour will pounce on any opportunity he gets to squish this behaviour.
Chloe dripping in deflection.
the females are too emotional
Luxon is the guy who was telling us last week that having fewer tobacco outlets would lead to MORE ram raids. And that he was committed to bringing down smoking rates, while pushing for tax cuts that are dependent on NOT bringing down smoking rates. If that's not a liar, he's a lot stupider than I give him credit for.
I didnt think the smoking rule was good to change back but everyone vapes now anyway smoking is way to expensive
You're confusing him with the other Chris who couldn't tell the truth even if it was printed on a labour letterhead.
@@stellymelly - the point is, Luxon would have to be an idiot to believe the things he's been saying... and I don't believe he's that stupid. By spouting all that guff he's treating the NZ public like gullible fools.
@@jameslast7555 - nope, I know which Chris made the above statements and it wasn't Hipkins. I think you're the one who's muddled up! Try reading it again and come back when you're ready to address what I actually said.
@@jameslast7555what, in the name of all that's holy, are you crapping on about numnuts?
National isn't going far enough. We should be pulling out of all international climate treaties
Chloe thats a demonstabe lie 😂
The green party are always so easily triggered..
Thank you for sharing
Unparliamentary language should be determined by the weight of evidence.. rather than calling someone a liar call a point of order and have the minister be reminded that he needs to act in a honourable manner using the words “half truths” and “falsehoods”
David! stop over re-acting.
No,I dont agree.Chloe is a crank.
Give the New Government time.
Just a personal observation: If we look at most of the hate comments to Green, Labour etc. on these video, they all seem to be targeted towards the person (i.e. personal attack) instead of to what they say, or the points they make.
Conversely, whatever comments Matua Winston make be it correct or incorrect they will always praise him for his charisma🤪
Anyone else feel this way?
Winston, the kupapa!
@@wikitoriasmith1713 & helping lead the country 😂
Yeah because the majority of NZers don’t understand civics!
They have no idea how opposition works or that whether they voted for them or not, the opposition have a responsibility to HOLD THE GOVERNMENT ACCOUNTABLE. Too bad if questioning them makes their voters uncomfortable, because the government doesn’t represent all voters as most moaning here seem to be making a point about.
They’re all pissed at Labour, but it wasn’t Labour’s job to hold themselves accountable, it was the job of the clowns that majority of NZ gave the job of running the country to.
same on both sides if you ever bothered to look at more than one side
@@skovdzschitt3230This isnt questioning it just childish mud slinging. But then a culture that sticks its tongue at people all time I guess gives away their mental capacity.
Importing gas and oil from overseas is dumb. The environmental footprint is enormous. You are from another planet. Lets use our own
Ha ha best comedy show on tv 🤪 Imagen if we act like that at work,or didn't perform our job requirements,yup no pay no job 😂time clock,drug test , review on your work efforts every six months , can't joke , can't be late or you get docked,got to prove your sick ,got to get your approval for time off,yea get that in too you 😅 lol anyways peace to all and good luck ❤
When will Green Party stop objecting exploration of gas/petrol? Even when fully operational, those fields will produce less than the amount of petrol New Zealand uses for its cars. On the other hand, such exploration will help to restore budget deficits and reduce debts amassed by the previous government.
Because it’s never their own money or job on the line..
They will always get paid with our taxes, whether they actually help or hinder the New Zealand economy..
Being given the air time to say, look at me, listen to my “facts/arguments” which have never amounted to anything tangible is doing my head in..
Go plant some trees or pick up rubbish that’s everywhere, would impress me more than all these meaningless speeches.
Clean up the rivers or that have become a national disgrace due to pollution.
Actually proving that something has been fixed for the better can’t be that hard??
“Clean and Green New Zealand?” Yeah right..
Because if every country taps out all the oil fields they have already, without adding any more, we're already doomed.
@@addrock7695 - maybe you should read what Forest & Bird has to say about this new government's policies if you're concerned about things like clean water and pollution.
When gas and petrol stop contributing to climate change (ie never)
If you are going to stick your head in the sand and not call me a liar for saying climate change is real then I'm not wasting my time.
When will the green party stop objecting to oil & gas exploration... Hmmm. If only there was a clue in their name that might hint towards their feelings on environmentally damaging policies...
Lying is lying!
Crazy Chloe at it again.
Green Commi
BS
This coalition Govt seems to be picking fights with a lot from Maori / ASH /smokefree NZ / environmentalists/ Unions with its take no advice trash and burn approach.
Latest out to trash is upgrading the Cook Strait ferries.
Embarrassing completely embarrassing… Both sides and all of them for that matter. Look at the smile on Gerry’s face this is all just theatre folks. Plain an simple
Of course it's theater. All public speaking is, has been, and always will be. Same goes for the legal process when lawyers stand for defense and prosecution. If you don't engage your audience, you won't get through to them. It's called persuasion
Mr speaker says he didn't hear the member. He's pretty hopeless as a Speaker and shouldn't have been given the position. The Speakers position should be from a politically neutral position and employed from outside as a facilitator.
Chloe who welcomed into NZ the first stateless refugee. This refugee, a trans activist went on to physically attack Posy Parker. And another punched a 71 year old grandmother. This is who chloe supports.
I mean Did Posie Parker not deserve it. She is a terrible person.
@@burnitdown5828being a terrible person isnt justification to attack someone. if you cant defend your ideas through words then yours ideas are either shit or you arent well equipped to be defending them in the first place.
posie parker has both good and bad ideas and should be challanged based on the ideas she portrays, not what others portray her as being.
be better.
Posie Parker has a long history of encouraging violent attacks on people. If she can't handle a little juice in her hair, then she should quit encouraging people to beat others. We don't need her in NZ, and if it took a glass of juice to rid us of her, I say that was a glass of juice well spent. Calling that a physical attack is certainly a stretch. Given her ties to nazis, white supremacists, and other right wing extremists, her extreme and overt bigotry for people of other races, religions, and sexual identities, and her own aggressive actions towards people minding their own business, she should be happy she just had a glass of juice poured on her, frankly. So are you saying that you support Posey?
@@burnitdown5828 nope. We don’t assault our guests no matter how much we disagree with their words.
David in his most Rimmer moment ever! what a grass 🤣
I've been trying to think of who he reminds me of! He's totally Rimmer! Perfectly.
Just trying to be a bigger pooh than winnie....
As my dear departed father would say about Seymour. " Complete chinless wonder"
Swarbrick and Willie Jackson ask dumb questions all the time
She needs to apologise to the Christians and the Jews in New Zealand for protesting in a hate march. And New Zealand media need to stop calling the west bank occupied. Who else is gonna sit down to the Christmas dinner and then deny the Jews were in Israel before 1948
Oh no, Chloe lied about her accusations. I don’t know why she has to be rude to others
What lie?
Howard let. If Chloe is rude then she is only following in Winnie's little footsteps
Marxists can never be wrong or rude.
Besides she has so much real world experience to back her up 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@jameslast7555 - what do you do, James?
@@AnthonyFlack James loves crypto, Jordan Peterson and Joe Rogan, is a climate change & covid vaccine conspiracy theorist. and is worried that he doesn't have enough testosterone. He should be worried that he clearly didn't get a very good education instead. He obviously has gotten his 'education' completely from TH-cam videos from QAnon nutters. If James doesn't like you, it just means you are doing something right, and are in touch with reality.
Liar
Could someone please move the Green party to Cuba for life.
Stuff the greens
Theyd send Nz back to the dark ages .
For hardly any emmisions we produce its all smoke and mirrors
Our per-capita emissions are way above the global average. How can we expect any other country to do their part if we refuse to do ours?
The Greens would send everyone but themselves back to the Dark Ages.
@@AnthonyFlack BS
@@jameslast7555 - one more time, let's see if you can cope: NZ average 7.13 tons, global average 4.76 tons. You know how 7 is bigger than 4?
Name calling a generation of people who are transferring more wealth into the hands of future generations compared to any other in history tells one everything about that person.
Sound bites Swarbrick. The question is whether she is beyond redemption. That is her choice.
Maori tribes signed the treaty in defiance of the Crown. It is human to try to get the best deal for yourself or your group. That does not make your actions any less despicable in terms of society. Own that!!
Being generous by handing out wealthy that belongs to others does not make one generous in any way.
This government only cares about passing wealth from the average person to their wealthy friends. How much do you think international tobacco companies paid them to get them to push tobacco so hard as one of their first week priorities? National only ever takes money for their wealthy buddies, and that you haven't noticed that yet doesn't say much for your observational skills. You need to spend more time watching what they do instead of just believing what they say. If you did, you would understand why they keep being called liars.
@@dipperdog you explain to me how the anti smoking law affects smoking rates in NZ in any coherent way and I may consider your opinion.
Smoking rates have been trending down as people make rational decisions on their own trade offs. Better health and more money to use for necessities and lifestyle choices.
This trend preceded the introduction of vaping and would have continued if vaping was not introduced.
The tobacco industry was a declining business until it was resurrected once vaping was made popular by those in authority. The tobacco industry lobbied very hard for the vaping market.
A dying industry was resurrected by those in authority and as Thomas Sowell explains it so clearly, those who stand to lose their jobs in the regulatory business are incentivised to maintain the status quo.
Stupid is as stupid does. Stop looking for a devil where none exist.
@@dipperdog try and respond to this argument…..
COP28 failed.
Big oil is so scared that Nuclear power will shrink their industry ten fold and create a low carbon emissions environment with abundant energy that they will fund solar and wind projects that are reliant on….. you guessed right, fossil fuel…
Who are the main beneficiaries of oil dollars charity?
Answer: Environmental, green transition, sustainability and anti nuclear groups!
At the Cop28 the UAE said there no evidence of fossil fuels causing climate ☔ change?
no vested interest there, surely?
They are right, there is no hard evidence
that the man made CO2 is responsible.
There may be a small signal
but it is drowned in the noise.
Natural variability is the likely
major cause, what ever that is.
@@newtongroves3413 lolz not even shellenberger believes that. you won't find a scientist who agrees with you - why is that?
Parliament is one big demonstrable li-... Oops
😊
What a lot of fuss for calling a lie a lie.
And then lying about saying he was lying
Chloe ,child mutelater
what
Does she know what that word means
exacerpate?
How in the world is Marama Davidson allowed to continue in politics after her childish comments about white men? Disgraceful and shameful as is her party for not acting on her comments some months ago. This isn't the dark ages Green Party, our children are watching and you should be a better example to them. From an ex Green Party supporter. Shame on you.
i think a lot of people vote green then realise who's in the greens and what they actually believe.
Chloe should have got a real job first for at least 20 years before becoming a politician she is nothing but an activist in my eyes and has never lived in the real world.
Chloe reminds me of a smiling protester. Your left politicians don't seem to have manners.
This is a reminder to Maori. NZ First as a political party, by name, infers that they represent New Zealanders. Maori are Maori and certainly not New Zealanders.
Give the pm a chance.he mite make great things happen
Are we still doing the climate thingy then😅😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Ruled by hubris
The greens are clueless.
Mega
And about 10% of the population who voted for them
The. Lies. Begin
Wonder if this government will dope us up on the Jab with new strain