Drum Teacher Reacts to Jay Weinberg - Slipknot - Unsainted - Episode 48
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 ต.ค. 2024
- #KeepPracticingUntilItsEasy #regaltip #makedrumsmusicalagain
Steve's analysis, initial reactions and hot takes of Jay Weinberg of Slipknot playing "Unsainted".
If you'd like to support the channel you can donate here:
/ junkdrummertv
PayPal.me/junkd...
Please check out my Merch Store
teespring.com/...
Original Video - • Zildjian Performance -...
This song is the copyrighted property of it's owner(s).
Fair use allows repurposing content for educational, critical, and commentative purposes used in accordance with US Copyright Law 17 U.S.C. Section 107 "Fair Use" is allowed for the purposes of criticism, commenting, news reporting, teaching, and or research and is not an infringement of copyright.
I put it this way, Joey was perfect for Slipknot then, and Jay is perfect for Slipknot now. Both are incredible.
it's not the band's problem, it's the self-proclaimed 'fans' is, fans that can't accept the changes are hilarious. felt like they're the ones to prioritize with. lmao. had they thought it's not the band's/Jay's goal to outplay Joey?? i think not, that's what fans think.
jords yeah. It is so childish on how they act as if it is WW3 that Joey was replaced with Jay.
I agree
Brando Da Savage Joey created all drum parts for songs, Jay just plays them, Joey has more creativity, but tbh Jay fits great with slipknot now 😁
@@aleksandarkatic3454 Did Joey create drum parts for new records too? Both are great drummers , but Jay had big boots to step in and did it very well.
I don’t understand how some Slipknot die hards don’t like Jay
I don't either
I guess I kinda get it. People grew up with Joey as their favorite drummer and then he leaves and here's this guy jay. People can't handle change sometimes
@@alo4912 I've been listening to Slipknot since 2001.. I really like Jay. I think the band knew what they were doing when they chose him. His style is really in line with the direction the band was going.
Jay is my favourite drummer.
I’ve never understood any of this sort of thing with metal bands, it’s like KsE with Howard and Jesse, I liked both of them and the same with Jay and Joey! I probably prefer Joey’s style but I’ve never by extension disliked Jay.
Jay grew so much from .5 to WANYK he’s definitely a great drummer
Tyler Dietz 29 or 30 I believe.
@Tyler Dietz He was 24 when .5 came out
This guy, the gojira dude, and Alex bent of trivium are the big 3 imo lol
ATTENTION EVERYONE!! I apologize for the awkward cuts in this video. I was arrested by the TH-cam police and had to delete those segments to be able to keep this video up. Thank you!!! If you'd like to watch the unedited version I've posted it here
www.dailymotion.com/video/x7sloos
Junkdrummer TV really enjoyed this breakdown! Please do one on Brooks Wackerman currently with Avenged Sevenfold!
Have you seen Hideki Aoyama of BABYMETAL? He's a beast. I couldn't find a video that focuses on him other than drum solos. But here's a good song with the drums.
BABYMETAL - AKATSUKI紅月アカツキ th-cam.com/video/K882HXjmxgQ/w-d-xo.html Their drums are very Dragonforce inspired.
the brake up was because joey can't play drums due to a disease
Oscar MARTINEZ yes, brook is awesome, his playstyle is so relaxed yet great, i really like it.
TH-cam police appear........Cease him!!!!
Considering Max took Jay to see Slipknot when he was like 9, he also grew up with Joey's licks while learning their songs, so it was much easier for him to integrate his own style into it when he eventually joined them. Jay really is the fairy tale story of growing up to play with one of your favorite bands.
Jay surprised me a lot, and I thought the same thing: he kept the Slipknot feel but added his twist. Nice one!
A lot of people sometimes give Jay a hard time about timing while not realizing that when he's on top of or behind the beat, its almost always intentional (or at least natural for him) to emphasize certain bits or to give a little separation between his hits and the other percussion to get the bigger sound. You see it a lot in jazz, hitting the ride early to push the song, or rock lagging snare hits to give a bigger feel... or hitting the crash early to emphasize the hit, or lagging it a little to mesh with the other instruments better. As Gandalf said, "A wizard is never late, nor is he early... he arrives precisely when he means to." This isn't prog, it doesn't need to be perfect. Of course exactly how much of it is just his natural feel of it, and how much he consciously controls I don't know, but its important, especially in a 9-person band.
“You can tell that he’s been playing since he was a kid”
😳 he didn’t start drumming until he was 14. The kid has it in his DNA
10:22 Even his gasp's have rythym 🤘
ah eh ahh ba dum tis
You should give gojira's drummer a listen
Mario Duplantier,the heaviest drummer of the universe!
@@Mondragora99 definitely 🤘
Check out "The Art of Dying"
@@midknight2975 🤘💯
@xiphoid 🤘💯
“Metal is recession proof” I am so ready to pay for that T-shirt
Soon
Amazing quote.
Joey had no choice but to leave due to having physical problems with his legs. It got bad enough to where he had to be carried on and off stage
But didn't he make his own band scar the martyr?
@@badplayr4456 yeah. But he played guitar
@@thanoswasright7899 is that later than because I see him pretty good playing the drums in Blood host from 2013 the music video so I believe that's incorrect
@@badplayr4456 looked it up, and jordison had transverse myelitis, which cost him the ability to play drums towards the end of his time with slipknot
@@badplayr4456 if I'm not mistaken (and I may be, I looked this up over 6 months ago) the fact he wasn't constantly playing a repertoire as taxing as Slipknot's probably helped him figure out the best methods to stay healthy enough to drum again without hurting himself too much more in the process
Wasn’t really sure what to expect. First time watching one of your videos but it was really entertaining. I really dig the content
The big question here is where is the video about Alex Bent from Trivium?
Bent is a freaking monster ! Especially on the new Trivium Album
Yess
Great video as always. Yeah, baby. Weinberg’s the real deal alright. Sooo hard to really HIT and maintain that super high level of technique. His work on the new album is gigantic.
Solway Firth I would say should have been the first reaction to him but unsainted is good also
Well in my defense this is the one that wouldn't get copyrighted.
@@JunkdrummerTV I think you should be safe from copyright for the most part as long as the video is "educational". But copyright laws fucking suck in general and in my opinion is antithetical to what we as artists aspire to do with our art. We make music for ourselves as artists, but the beauty is sharing that with people and seeing how they interperate it separate from your intentions as the creator. Art shouldn't be the sole property of labels and big ass corporations. It belongs to everyone including the fans and people should celebrate when their works of art inspire someone to wanna talk about it or add on to it instead of viewing it as theft. That's at least how I've always seen it.
I'd like to see Nero Forte personally
@@JunkdrummerTV aaand you got copyrighted
@@Southboundpachyderm Haha. Tell to that any artist I've done on Warner Bros or Sony. They take all my monetization on those videos. Which for a little TH-camr like me has been a significant amount.
Jay has crazy skill saw them in 2015 and his drum set has a beautiful tone tone it hes got insane footwork speed
Best breakdown if this video I've seen yet. great job.
Great video bro love your vids
jay proves it every concert that he is worthy. he actually became my fav member
Love this dude's enthusiasm for sure.
When I started to listen to Slipknot. Joey was still in the band. But in November of last year I saw Jay perform a few Slipknot songs. And he was amazing. And I was able to meet him after the performance.
This was such an awesome video thanks for this
I am pretty sure Joey had a nerve condition that started to affect him physically. Not the way you want to see one of the best go through.
he suffered from transverse myelitis, a neurological disease that cost him the ability to play the drums toward the end of his time with Slipknot that’s why they let him go
Love your accent and the positivity in the review. You said you don't wanna compare and you didn't!
Hey Steve, found yr channel about a month ago and have seen a ton of yr video's (love the way you go about every video) great to see a drum teacher and "gigger" that 100% gets it! You're 1 cool dude n yr students are truly lucky to have you! From 1 Drummer to Another 🤘
Aaahhhh man. Thank you so much. That made my day.
Keep Keepin Real Brother😎🤘
What i love about Jay is, just that pure energy and the way he is feeling the music/rythm.
This is the first video I’ve watched of yours. I don’t know if it’s been mentioned before but you should totally check out Matt Greiner of August Burns Red
Also thank you for these - love how you break down these drum parts and especially since Faith No More were one of my fav bands as a kid, reminding people of their style is great!
There's a video here on youtube with Max and Jay playing drums together. It's a duet with them playing Sing, Sing I believe. Guitar Center Drum off I think it's called. You can totally see the different styles.
"and the Metallica that I like" if that ain't just a whole mood in a sentence🤣
Yes.
What kind of Metallica can’t you like??
Ramiro Alejandro st.anger
@@user-se2nn2sn6c I personally loved st anger
@@TVWEEVIE any of it
Loved your analysis - keep up the great work. \m/
"i live for breakdowns" is the sentence that made me sub😂 thats a whole mood!!!
Unsainted is such a great song and the drum track is a key reason why.
That’s awesome. Great channel!!
You have to check out Alex Bent from Trivium. Started playing with them in early 2017. He has his own TH-cam channel where he posted playthroughs of the songs he did off their at that time new album. I would recommend checking out Betrayer, Beyond Oblivion, or Thrown Into the Fire.
I loved Joey when he was still in the band, but I absolutely love the power that Jay has. He definitely deserves all the praise that he gets
This is great. I really enjoy your genuine reactions. Such excitement. Entertaining to watch.
As always. Great Vid!
Good vid bro. Listened to you while i worked on my art. Subscribed
I would highly recommend checking out Billy Rymer from Dillinger Escape Plan
1000% this guy needs some dillinger in his life
Yes
@@therealduckslikerain Chris pennie is better
@@anthonyjones3835 yeah dude i couldnt believe it when chris left Dillinger for Coheed and Cambria. That guy is insane.
You should do some more Jay and Joey
I would love for you to take a look at Thomas Lang. His independence and technique is unmatched on the kit. He really is one of my favorite drummers and I found him because of the dream theater auditions he did.
Razor knows his shit, and I appreciate that for sure, -- I'm a musician and have been reviewing concerts and albums for over 20 years. Put It like this -- my first show was Motörhead opening for Dio. Jay adds some really nasty jazzy half measure eigth fill roll type shit going on with blasts. There's quite a bit of blues fill in there which is more evident in Against Me, but he's only yet begun his career on the big stage. Kid is fucking rad and could probably play anything he wants.
Also, an an addendum -- I'm a Slipknot fan. I saw them my first time at Ozzfest in 1999, and bought their album the next day(only to have Roadrunner send it to me a few weeks later with your standard promo pack, but I didn't complain).
Dude is a hell of a talent and I look forward to seeing how he evolves, if that's at all possible more than simply refining his craft.
I'm sure this has been recommended before; but Mario Duplantier would be another awesome metal pick to check out. Gift of Guilt, The Art of Dying, The Way of All Flesh, and Liquid Fire are probably some of his best work, and damn it's impressive to get some syncopated rhythm with some straight up blast beats and 32nd notes at the tempos they play, for the duration their sets a lot of times go for. He's phenomenal to watch live.
Edit: Wrong brother, like an absolute dolt.
what i love is that it was Max who was the Slipknot fan, and introduced Jay to them at a show when he was like 10.
Jay is such a monster!
I was waiting for that one for a long time!🔥
Hope you liked it
Hope you liked it
I did!
man, jay really keep progressing throughout the times. love it or hate it he is the drummer of SLIPKNOT now.
Greetings !! you should reacting to "Guitar Center Presents: Max & Jay Weinberg
" it really awesome gigs between father & son
Jay is the man. Fucking love slipknot
Definitely need a take on Danny Carey playing “Pneuma”. So much intensity, it’s amazing.
Ended up here via Andrew Rooney. AWESOME VIDEO DUDE 🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻
Just saw this because of how much I follow Slipknot channels. This is awesome!
Love what Jay brought to slipknot! Such a talented drummer! Pleeeease do a video of Chris adler of Lamb of God playing “blood of the scribe”!
I was not very interested in drums. But the video was so cool that I fell in love with it!
Nice👌❤
I’d like to hear your breakdown of their song The Negative One.
Yes! Slipknot did use blast beats before, especially in the albums All Hope is Gone and .3 Subliminal Verses. You can hear the greatest Joey's blast beats in the song "Three Nil". Starts with one and it repeats over the entire song. Is phenomenal.
7:02 Now THAT is the breakdown, baby.
watching this as a hip hop fan I am so confused and impressed at the same time.
Awesome reaction man. It's nice to see someone giving Jay his credit. I couldn't really hear it that well in live version But in the music video just after breakdown Jays drumming is freaking crazy. I heard people say he was off beat. I don't Know anything about drumming but my dad is a musician so i was around music all my life and I could tell it was part of a Style and techniques he was bringing to the song. Don't get me wrong Joey is a monster drummer and gave Slipknot that signature sound but When replacing someone like Joey it's either gonna pass or fail! Joey is just that good. fortunately Jay is too. He took the already killer playbook that Joey left and fused his own style. Both are incredibly talented each with their own style. Lol about to watch your reaction to Joey,that'll determine if i sub or not!🤘😝🤘jokes! i already did!
You should react to Gojira - The Art of Dying
Firs of all thanks for your videos.
I like jay.He is great but,I'm diehard fan of joey.He has cool style and great technique and it was fun to watch.
Also I like slipknot's drum sound when they were with joey so much more than how it sound with jay.It doesn't feel slipknoty anymore.
i love watching videos like this makes me appreciate there talent even more. i have no music talent.
8:34 he has actually only played since he was 15
Tomfson 14
@@wj17013 13.9
@@jayw900 13.8
Proof that all this "you need to start at 3 or 4 to become really good" is bs.
This video is a great showcase of why I like your channel: I prefer Jay for Slipknot over Joey but I couldn’t explain why. I thought maybe Jay plays with more heart and Joey was more technical. But your breakdown of Jay’s playing helped me understand more of what I was hearing
2:57 The first person I ever heard using this pattern in this way was Aaron Gillespie on "Breathing in a New Mentality" in 2008.
What was that old metal thing you told us to check out? Can you post a link to it? I'm lazy.
Was wondering what you think of the original drummer for Napalm Death, Mick Harris?
I liked Joeys energy and vibe, but Jay has good technique and he is extremely accurate, very good drummer.
Great reaction video mate, have a sub from down under.
Hey man! Love the video! For that China part in the beginning wouldnt it be easier to think of it as triplets?
Sorta kinda. It's not really triplets. It's every third note of a grouping of 16 16th notes which is sort of triple feeling but it's not triplets
@@JunkdrummerTV I think it would be a good way to get in the ballpark of how to "feel" that rhythm. When done with quarters it ends on one. May just be one of those "tomato" &"tomato" ....just a different way of saying it 👌👌👌
Thanks for the hasty reply! Got a sub from me!
let's put it this way, i like both jay and joey are amazing drummers in their own right. similar to the argument of "which metallica bassist was the best?" all of em were good and have their own styles.
That fill before the 1st verse is...just wow!
Such a cool video man
There was indeed a lot of blast beating in Slipknot's songs before. The song Three Nil from Vol. 3 The Subliminal Verses
Suggestion for future review: Sting's drummer on the song "Seven days". The original video shows quite a bit of him as it's a studio recording, it's an UNBELIEVABLE drum part, pure perfection start to finish with so many dynamics and the timing is gorgeous.
1:05 Probably had something to do with Murder Dolls scheduling conflicts...but then again, Corey makes time for Stone Sour...
Hey nice video man. I absolutely love jay he’s super skilled.
at 8:32 in the video you actually were wrong, jay is self taught at around 14 he first played and learned over a year period. young but not a kid and definitely a lot of advancement on his own accord, great video happy you made it keep metal drum reviews coming. \m/
GREAT VID MAN!!
That quick question asking about if they had utilized blast beats so obviously before: a great example is older, but The Devil in I has a couple of great blast sections towards the middle/end
Two great and inventive drummers worth checking out that are sometimes overlooked are Steve Judd of Karnivool and Dave Turncrantz of Russian Circles. They do some cool stuff.
The first time I ever hear "funk" inserted into more metal tunes was Will Calhoun of Living Colour. I absolutely LOVED it. It was such a departure from the "straight" feel that I had come accustomed to in metal. If you haven't already, check out ANYTHING but Sean Reinert. He unfortunately passed away too young recently but he is hands down my favorite all-time drummer.
That's an excellent point
As a guitarist your channel intrigues me 😂 jkjk you remind me of the music teacher that got me into music 🤘🏻 subscribed
I dunno how the fuck I ended up on your channel but I like it
hey can you tell me from which song the intro drums are? self played? love it
th-cam.com/video/RyrLHHUozo0/w-d-xo.html
You had a sub at "i live for breakdowns" .. i would also buy that t shirt.
You have an aussie fan my friend 🤘
Funny you should say that....
I love Jay's playing
I believe the drumming hip hop influence was introduced by bands from the west coast before slipknot. Deftones drummer Abe Cunningham has a huge hip hop influence in their music. Fieldy brings the hip hop to Korn on the bass.
I believe that Jay joined Slipknot in 2014/2015 to record .5 The Gray Chapter-He, along with Alessandro Venturella joining as Bassist in place of the deceased Paul Gray haven't been attributed numbers. Slipknot no longer incorporate numbers on their uniforms and it really adheres to the evolution of their identity. They now also have Tortilla Man in place of the departed Chris Fehn.
Joey jordinson was diagnosed with MS had a rare form of it which caused his legs to almost quit working all together. Pleased to say he has came back and touring again since. Takes a lil bit to recover from such thing like that trust me i know
I’m not a drummer but a guitarist and this was really cool to learn about
I love them both, Joey and Jay for completely different reasons. The guy below was exactly right, Joey was the best for them then, Jay is now
I don't even play drums, but it's so entertaining the way you analize the video... Jay is living the dream that all musicians have play for your favorite band, i'm still waiting the call from Metallica hahahaha i'm kidding
I've been listening to slipknot since the early days, and Joey was and is to this day one of my biggest reasons for playing drums. When I first saw he left and jay joined because I didn't see how a punk drummer would be able to play in the style of slipknot, I was really fucking bummed, but after watching him play I immediately changed my mind and fell in love with him. it was clear that joey was struggling really badly with his health issues and the last album with him really showed it. Joey lost a lot of his energy and stamina through all the back shit and it sucks ass that he had to leave in the end because he was the life of slipknot for so fucking long. In my opinion you can't compare Jay to Joey. They're completely different in how they approach drums. Joey is and always will be one of the best drummers to ever play in metal, but Jay has brought back the energy to slipknot in his more modern metalcore/rock (the really powerful rim shots) influences that give him more groove than joey had. Joey's greatest asset was his speed and precision in his fills and blasts, and Jays biggest asset is his groove and experience outside of metal. What I would like to see is both of them playing drums together and seeing what kind of awesomeness comes out of it. Jay earned his spot in slipknot more than almost any of the other members, and thats why I like him so much. He grew up listening to them just like all of us and it shows how much he loved their music in the way he plays with them. He brings so much fucking energy and power to the new album.
The best part of old Iron Maiden was their first vocalist. His vocals were badass raw punk/bluesy hard rock. He was somewhere between Iggy and Bon Scott.
Look at jay on solway firth
Jay Weinberg is a bad, bad boy. Nice Video. Nice explained.
Pretty sure jay joined in 2014. Not 100% sure though. His first album was .05 the grey chapter. (if im wrong someone please correct me)