30 Day FREE Drumeo Trial ► www.drumeo.com/andrewrooney/ Make sure to SUBSCRIBE! th-cam.com/users/RooneyDrums REACTION PLAYLIST ► th-cam.com/play/PLqspKksRqaUURy8K34sBSKvuGo3ApmLC2.html DONATE! | REQUEST a Reaction via PAYPAL ► www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=QV8HUB7A8Z7DG SUPPORT ► Join My Community and hit the PATREON! www.patreon.com/AndrewRooneyDrums Get My 'Drums & Coffee' COFFEE MUG! ► andrew-rooney-drums.creator-spring.com/listing/drums-coffee-5809?product=658 Buy Me a Coffee! ► www.buymeacoffee.com/AndrewRooney (to keep the Drums & Coffee mug full) Love you 🥁☕🙌
Come on you can do some more research to about the songs and when they were released. Google around 10-15 minutes, i love your content and reaction videos but sometimes it's like, come on dude, 2-3 google searches and you've made some research. Jay was already in the band when they wrote this song. No hate just feedback
Pretty much. I was super cynical and pessimistic about Jay at first but dammit, he grew on me. It’s hard to compare the two because there’s different reasons for why I enjoy their drumming.
Sadly Joey had a rare degenerative neurological condition that hit him so bad he lost control of his legs. He literally could not drum anymore and the band was forced to replace him. Joey eventually recovered enough to move on with other bands. Jay was a slipknot fan since he was a child and he idolized Joey. It was very poetic that he got to be in his favorite band. He has nothing but love and respect for Joey.
He didn't know he had it for a bit too. He dealt with the pain in ways that caused other problems in the band which also lead to him being replaced. As far as his other bands go, he primarily played guitar because the condition was far worse after he was finally diagnosed. Luckily, he and the rest of Slipknot were able to mend their friendships back together and were brothers once again before his passing. At least that was able to happen.
Wasn't it like Corey's first or second mask even? He was real young. Wasn't Jay's dad a drum tech for them? I'm new to drumming so I'm not very versed yet lol.
Unsainted is a Jay piece, he’s been with the band since 2014 and recorded both .5 The Grey Chapter (Devil in I, Negative One, Killpop, Custer, etc.) and We Are Not Your Kind (Unsainted, Nero Forte, Solway Firth, Orphan, etc.) as well as the All Out Life single. Note: listed well known releases
For .5 the grey Chapter i'm not sure but i think they said that Clown wrote the drum parts cause Jay wasn't quite here at the beginning ? Compare to WANYK.
@@kingonking1 Perhaps he was the one to record them? I've heard something about Clown writing the pieces as well, but I'd imagine that Jay was the one that recorded it.
There's a video where Jim states slipknot haven't written anything since AHIG.... they're are just refining already written material. Jay is a great drummer, but these are Joeys songs
@@NC2871926 this is not true lol, they are absolutely do not just have a pile of Joey drums he wrote and they’ve just been having Jay record them lol. Jay did the drums for WANYK, Joey had absolutely nothing to do with them.
One of my favourite things i've ever seen Jay do, is during a performance of All Out Life, he drops his left stick whilst playing, continues playing just with his right keeping the beat on both cymbals and snare for a bar or two whilst getting a new stick with his left, and he doesn't miss a single beat! I'm sure it's something most drummers can do, but seeing Jay headbang, play, keep time and reach for a new stick all at once made me appreciate him just that little bit more!
Had the pleasure of seeing these guys live right before covid. :] Got to front row!! IDK if anyone mentioned it but slipknot was his favorite band as a kid and he became their drummer when he grew up! There is a picture of him meeting them as a kid.
I love Joey. I idolized him in a sense growing up and he gave me the passion to want to own a kit and start drumming. That being said, Jay is a fantastic drummer and addition to slipknot. I’ve loved slipknot for about 15 years now. He doesn’t take anything away from the band but fills it perfectly with what we need as a Joey “replacement”
I've been a Slipknot fan from the very beginning and I completely agree Justin. My understanding is Jay seeing Slipknot on Conan got him into drums, so I have to assume he was enormously influenced by Joey. I see that Joey flavor in Jay's drumming, so I can't think of a better person to step in. He does his own thing, but I still see that nod to the great Joey Jordison. That's way better than a total outsider. R.I.P Joey. 👼🤘
Talent wise he can definitely be replaced, Jay is just as talented and there are drummers out there better than either of them. Both kick ass tho and Joey is a legend but he definitely isn’t the most talented drummer every like a lot of People act and he often played stuff too fast live. The drums on the last slipknot album were awesome, Jay does a great job and has awesome presence behind the kit.
He uses e-drums for gig rehearsals and composition too. His setup uses two VAD506/Td-27 kits to emulate his acoustic kit. There are some Roland promo vids showing him giving those drums and cymbals a right pounding - and they seem up to it!
His breakdown in Negative One set the new direction of Slipknot for me. Before I knew who their new drummer was, I honestly thought it was Chris Adler that recorded Negative One because of how unique the drum part was.
Jay is extremely good much respect for is incredible talent, Joey was a pioneer and will will have a special place in any of our hearts. RIP Joey jordinson the best future to you Jay.
I saw one of the E Street Band shows with Jay playing. He knows his dad’s work inside and out: he was tremendous. I’m not really into his other stuff but, ya, clearly talented.
The reasoning for joey being replaced is because from my understanding he had a condition that affected his legs and he couldn’t drum for a while. Later on joey recovered and joined a new band called vimic.
@@kylebatteson9572 the thing is that his condition came from drugs and later on he had a relapse (they didn't say it officially but they gave some hints). That was a little bit problematic for the band because all of them sobered up and that could have affected the band, that's why he had to leave in the end. the cause of joye's death could also have to do with health issues due to him starting drugs again. please note, i'm not trying to sell "the truth" here, that's just what i came up with after watching a ton of interviews where they sometimes gave himts but never did any official statements
As you've figured out from your joey reactions, he was beloved and many see him irreplaceable. Tbh, Jay was the best possible replacement. He met the band in the early 2000s through his dad and listened to them so he knew all about them, so his personality (as well as his playing) fits right in with the band by this point.
@@saadesigner07 Ya we’ll probably never ever know what really happened, but considering that the band hasn’t explained why he was fired, his family hasn’t explained his cause of death, and the fact that joey’s disease is closely related to heroin usage, it’s likely that the band fired him due to heroin usage. He then got clean and re-learned how to walk and play the drums again, but later fell back on drugs and probably died due to an overdose ;(
Jay has so many drum cams I recommend watching his Get This! drum cam from Germany! Jay and Joey inspired me to improve my playing tenfold. SlipKnot are truly blessed to have 2 of the best drummers ever to grace the industry!
Any real slipknot fan knows Joey will never be replaced but jay has Completely met our expectations and then some, he’s an awesome fit and so glad the bad found someone like him to keep joeys legacy going
As soon as I heard Jays last name I was like holy shit that Max Weinbergs kid...Wow just wow was totally blown away! Shout out to Max and his wife for letting Jay be Jay behind the kit!
Joey was exceptional, no doubt . . . But I do think Slipknot actually found one of only a handful of drummers who could match Joeys raw talent whilst bringing their own creativity to the newer songs, putting their own stamp on it. This song is from 'We are not your kind' which is the latest Slipknot album to date and Jay's own work. I would juxtapose this with Lamb of God. Art Cruz is undeniably a very talented drummer and he can play Chris' parts very, very well. But the stuff he's written with the band? Personally I don't think it has the same flare and creativity that Chris did when he was writing with them.
Had the pleasure of seeing Joey play live. Would love to see Jay play. The energy of Slipknot’s live show is unmatched. Joey’s drumming reminds me of chaos. Jay’s drumming has incredible groove. Both are fantastic and being different, but amazing, things to the table.
Unsaited is indeed from their 2019 album with Jay recording. Joey was sadly let go after his session after “All hope is gone” album. Reason why is somewhat of a mystery to some. When rumors started popping out, Joey did many interviews that he wasn’t leaving the band, but sadly those rumors were true. Joey unfortunately had an acute case of Transverse myelitis (TM); which is a rare neurological condition in which his spinal cord is inflamed. It caused him to loose the ability to use his legs properly. You should maybe see the speech he gave in the 2016 metal hammer gods awards. It is honestly the most passionate, yet saddest moment in his life. In our lives as a fan, think he would beat this… 😢
Glad to see you get around to Jay! I love Joey, but it would be inauthentic for someone to try to be exactly like him. Jay is himself, and I think he's awesome!
I found his tom angles and positionings to be interesting as well as his ride. The ride was tilted forward and really downward. The snare had a nice pop to it. Really stood out in this mix.
There's a video of Max & Jay Weinberg doing a drum duet I think you'd love. It's on the guitar center channel. Absolutely amazing watching the difference between the father & son combo. Hopefully see your reaction to this soon. Both have completely different styles & are both incredible at what they do!
Unsainted is off their newest album We Are Not Your Kind, and it’s Jays drum creation. I’d suggest you get a drum cam of Jay playing something from the early days, you can absolutely tell a difference between him and Joey but, there’s no comparison to Joey. Joey as technical as he in my opinion he’s the master of speed, and Jay is the technical more precise drummer without Joeys speed. (Again both very worthy) Joey is the total package. RIP JOEY… but I do like Jay a lot as well
Jay did a interview where he wanted to change the sound, if you notice the kick drums are tuned different, as in each kick dum is tuned different. This is his song
He’s set up with drum triggers that’s why you don’t see mics…tone is computer generated so he gets the same tone every hit no matter how hard he hits. Almost all bands that tour use them
It's to prevent cymbal bleed through the tom mics. As you can see his cymbals are really close to his toms. That's a soundman decision and a smart one.
@@ranman1708 yeah. I saw some interview with jay about it. Bound to he great for jay to not have to compromise his set up. And as you say for the sound to not be bleeding all over the place.
yeah joey used to play with paiste remo heads pearl drumset and signature snare tama iron cobra and a head drumsticks, now jay uses zildjian evan heads sjc drumset dw 9000 pedal sjc signature snare and vater drumsticks
I seen a post on jays instagram the other week and he said one of the reason his snare sound is so unique is he actually punches his leg most of the time
From the other few reactors that have reacted to Jay drum cams, I’ve seen mostly seen disasterpiece and duality. One cam I think that’s underrated is Jay playing vermilion. Distastepiece: th-cam.com/video/uX1GzoDkWkg/w-d-xo.html Duality: th-cam.com/video/qHLQWjs9rTE/w-d-xo.html Vermilion: th-cam.com/video/ysSV8N7HvYw/w-d-xo.html Solway Firth: th-cam.com/video/wN-6R92bxf0/w-d-xo.html But if you want to see another song that Jay wrote, then I would suggest the Solway firth cam.
As far as Joey’s departure. He had a health problem that effected the use of his legs. He recovered however was fired. It was never released as to actual reason why. Wether it was because of the health or suspicion of drug use. Which he denied. It’s speculation
Joey was fired shortly before Slipknot’s 2014 album .5 The Gray Chapter. When their bassist Paul Gray died the band agreed anyone who couldn’t get clean of drugs would be fired, Joey developed a nervous system condition that left him in poor health, he would have to be carried to and from his kit during their shows. At the time, the condition hadn’t been diagnosed, Joey didn’t know why he was in that shape and the band thought he was back on drugs. Slipknot fans seem to have taken Jay in well. He plays Joey’s songs perfectly and his own style he brought to the band is refreshing. Unsainted is one of Jay Weinberg’s songs.
The difference in the Snaresound of Joey to Jay may be the Size of the Snare. Joey used 13x6,5" Snares and Jay uses a "standrad" 14" Snare, if I'm right.
Well Joey became paralysed and beat it. He always thought they would bring him back they even lead him on about at one point. Joey founded Slipknot so when only ONE of the band members visited when he was hospitalized and found out he was kicked out through the media and an email... Just awful. There's alot of pain here and bad blood here about how this broke apart. Joey saw a headline saying he left Slipknot and he couldn't believe what he was seeing.. imagine being booted without even a visit to the hospital from anyone but one of them after he gave them this band. He was the heart. He was number 1. You don't treat people like that. I only saw Slipknot with Joey.. at least a dozen times... Joey was self taught. I feel bad for Jay... He can't fill those shoes. He just can't. This IS my favorite band. Always has been since I was 10... I can't say it enough Joey created entire songs like lyrics and all... So I love them to the end but I won't see them without Joey. Not after what they did to him... He beat paralysis and then came back and played with vimic sinsaenim scar the martyr etc. How I feel is: I'm pissed. Jay is fine but he is not Joey.. I'm upset about the members who kicked Joey out not Jay.
Yo what??? Which member actually visited Joey??? What are your sources??? Please tell me dude I love Slipknot. If they really treated him like that I swear I won't ever see them live....
Take a look at David Diebold. This guy does single pedal blast beats. Correct me if I am wrong but he might be doing 16th notes with his right foot but technicality, he is amazing to witness on the kit....
It's okay to compare, joey was absolutely fantastic and probably a top 4 metal drummer of all time. But Jay brings a whole new flavor, mixes some blues and country tones within the fast and groove beats. Love this vid!!
Jay brought his own style to Slipknot while maintaining the changing directions of the band. Jay is a fantastic drummer and he continues to pay homage to Joey by playing the early greats as if Joey was playing himself. The entire meaning of the masks is to focus on the music, atmosphere, and feeling instead of the person. Jay continues that.
On the subject of replacement drummers, art Cruz with lamb of god. I was mad about it for awhile but he’s a great drummer and brings a new flavor to one of my all time favorite bands
Reason why he was replaced by Jay, was, as Jordison revealed in June 2016 that he suffered from transverse myelitis, a neurological disease that cost him the ability to play the drums toward the end of his time with Slipknot.
Jay has said that his custom snare from SJC is so loud that, the first time he hit it, he scared the shit out of himself. The tone difference is a 13x6.5 metal snare (Joey) vs. and a 14x6.5 48-ply would snare. Cymbal tone, aside from brand, also might have to do with stick size. Joey used a Promark 5A stick, and Jay’s Vater signature is slightly bigger than a Vater 9A.
This goes outside of drumming but as a fairly old fan and collector of the band I couldn't have thought of a better PERSON to replace Joey. Jay is super humble and kind to the fans and lives and breaths his craft in art. (he's a very talented oil painter and everything visual in addition to his music career) he's been a fan of Slipknot since he was a kid and Joey is his hero. Overall just a very cool, polite and down-to-earth guy who gives tons of energy and excitement to the band! No one can ever really truly replace Joey but I think Jay is the best possible person to honor his legacy and also give his own twist to modern Slipknot. (I had the honour to see Joey playing live three times, I've seen Jay four times so far and I think he is one of the best, if not THE best, part of their live show right now)
I got back into listening SlipKnot after Weinberg joined the band, as it came back into my consciousness. I started to listen to old stuff and new stuff and you can clearly hear out the different styles from Jordison and Weinberg. Jordison was a speedmachine. He was pretty fast and endurant at that. Weinberg tends to get somewhat sloppy on the doublebass parts but excels at complex fills and rythms. The part in unsainted, where he leads with the lefthand on the snare and puts accents on the china with the right hand is unthinkable for Joey. The otherway around: The insane blast beats and studidly fast double bass patterns from older songs like heretic anthem or people=shit are clearly not the style of Jay. They are obviously different drummers, each with their own style. SlipKnot changed with their drummer, but I like the change and it doesnt make the old albums undone and I can enjoy both of them.
Love it! As far as slipknot fans, all of the ones I've talked to respect Jay for doing what he's done. I'd love to see a comparison video purely for your thoughts on styles!
30 Day FREE Drumeo Trial ► www.drumeo.com/andrewrooney/
Make sure to SUBSCRIBE! th-cam.com/users/RooneyDrums
REACTION PLAYLIST ► th-cam.com/play/PLqspKksRqaUURy8K34sBSKvuGo3ApmLC2.html
DONATE! | REQUEST a Reaction via PAYPAL ► www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=QV8HUB7A8Z7DG
SUPPORT ► Join My Community and hit the PATREON! www.patreon.com/AndrewRooneyDrums
Get My 'Drums & Coffee' COFFEE MUG! ► andrew-rooney-drums.creator-spring.com/listing/drums-coffee-5809?product=658
Buy Me a Coffee! ► www.buymeacoffee.com/AndrewRooney (to keep the Drums & Coffee mug full)
Love you
🥁☕🙌
Andrew, You gotta watch this th-cam.com/video/KW86Vr9Engg/w-d-xo.html
Come on you can do some more research to about the songs and when they were released. Google around 10-15 minutes, i love your content and reaction videos but sometimes it's like, come on dude, 2-3 google searches and you've made some research. Jay was already in the band when they wrote this song.
No hate just feedback
This guy just fits perfectly. Huge love for him.
Joey stays in our hearts
Pretty much. I was super cynical and pessimistic about Jay at first but dammit, he grew on me. It’s hard to compare the two because there’s different reasons for why I enjoy their drumming.
Love it Giuseppe
Sadly Joey had a rare degenerative neurological condition that hit him so bad he lost control of his legs. He literally could not drum anymore and the band was forced to replace him. Joey eventually recovered enough to move on with other bands. Jay was a slipknot fan since he was a child and he idolized Joey. It was very poetic that he got to be in his favorite band. He has nothing but love and respect for Joey.
He didn't know he had it for a bit too. He dealt with the pain in ways that caused other problems in the band which also lead to him being replaced. As far as his other bands go, he primarily played guitar because the condition was far worse after he was finally diagnosed. Luckily, he and the rest of Slipknot were able to mend their friendships back together and were brothers once again before his passing. At least that was able to happen.
The original reason due to loss of control due to the medical issue they stated it was “drug use” which in interviews Joey talked about
@@OdokuroYT They mistook his condition for drug use because they didn’t know joey had it and neither did he
He also had problems in his hands I think…
Partly right
Slipknot cut him before Joey knew what was going on
There’s a cool pic out there of Max introducing Jay to Slipknot when he was a child. Jay in mask already!
Where this pic?
@@matyizagyi5370 just look up max introducing jay to slipknot, will show jay in a old Corey mask
Wasn't it like Corey's first or second mask even? He was real young. Wasn't Jay's dad a drum tech for them? I'm new to drumming so I'm not very versed yet lol.
@@blueberryskyline Jays dad is the drummer for Bruce Springsteen
@@Dylansventures_42 thank you. My mistake I heard wrong.
Unsainted is a Jay piece, he’s been with the band since 2014 and recorded both .5 The Grey Chapter (Devil in I, Negative One, Killpop, Custer, etc.) and We Are Not Your Kind (Unsainted, Nero Forte, Solway Firth, Orphan, etc.) as well as the All Out Life single.
Note: listed well known releases
Thank you Wyatt!
For .5 the grey Chapter i'm not sure but i think they said that Clown wrote the drum parts cause Jay wasn't quite here at the beginning ? Compare to WANYK.
@@kingonking1 Perhaps he was the one to record them? I've heard something about Clown writing the pieces as well, but I'd imagine that Jay was the one that recorded it.
There's a video where Jim states slipknot haven't written anything since AHIG.... they're are just refining already written material.
Jay is a great drummer, but these are Joeys songs
@@NC2871926 this is not true lol, they are absolutely do not just have a pile of Joey drums he wrote and they’ve just been having Jay record them lol. Jay did the drums for WANYK, Joey had absolutely nothing to do with them.
It’s just a shame Joeys drum cam vids aren’t this good quality ☹️
Yeah right!?
They just are what they are.
I know right? Now days everyone has a movie quality camera in their pocket. Think about seeing John Bonham and others greats with that quality.
But they have soul.
One of my favourite things i've ever seen Jay do, is during a performance of All Out Life, he drops his left stick whilst playing, continues playing just with his right keeping the beat on both cymbals and snare for a bar or two whilst getting a new stick with his left, and he doesn't miss a single beat! I'm sure it's something most drummers can do, but seeing Jay headbang, play, keep time and reach for a new stick all at once made me appreciate him just that little bit more!
AWESOME!
And props to the drum tech for retrieving the stick and putting it back into the pouch with the other backups.
th-cam.com/video/tAVMDzGxRLU/w-d-xo.html
Gene Hoglan is pretty good at that too😁
Had the pleasure of seeing these guys live right before covid. :] Got to front row!! IDK if anyone mentioned it but slipknot was his favorite band as a kid and he became their drummer when he grew up! There is a picture of him meeting them as a kid.
Yes! 🙌
I love Joey. I idolized him in a sense growing up and he gave me the passion to want to own a kit and start drumming. That being said, Jay is a fantastic drummer and addition to slipknot. I’ve loved slipknot for about 15 years now. He doesn’t take anything away from the band but fills it perfectly with what we need as a Joey “replacement”
Great Justin!
Agreed
Yes to all of that.
I've been a Slipknot fan from the very beginning and I completely agree Justin. My understanding is Jay seeing Slipknot on Conan got him into drums, so I have to assume he was enormously influenced by Joey. I see that Joey flavor in Jay's drumming, so I can't think of a better person to step in. He does his own thing, but I still see that nod to the great Joey Jordison. That's way better than a total outsider. R.I.P Joey. 👼🤘
I have nothing but respect for Jay, but Joey just can never truly be replaced both in talent and just pure stage presence.
Nice one Brett!
Talent wise he can definitely be replaced, Jay is just as talented and there are drummers out there better than either of them. Both kick ass tho and Joey is a legend but he definitely isn’t the most talented drummer every like a lot of
People act and he often played stuff too fast live. The drums on the last slipknot album were awesome, Jay does a great job and has awesome presence behind the kit.
He uses e-drums for gig rehearsals and composition too. His setup uses two VAD506/Td-27 kits to emulate his acoustic kit. There are some Roland promo vids showing him giving those drums and cymbals a right pounding - and they seem up to it!
Yes that popped up when I finished this vid!
Personally I thought that Roland kit sounded well...Not Good!!
Unsainted is from Slipknot's latest album "We Are Not Your Kind" released in 2019 and Jay Weinberg recorded in the album
His breakdown in Negative One set the new direction of Slipknot for me. Before I knew who their new drummer was, I honestly thought it was Chris Adler that recorded Negative One because of how unique the drum part was.
Sounds great Justin!
@@AndrewRooneyDrums Yes! Yes! Yes! Check out his drum cam for that video! It's gnarly Andrew!
Jay is extremely good much respect for is incredible talent, Joey was a pioneer and will will have a special place in any of our hearts. RIP Joey jordinson the best future to you Jay.
I saw one of the E Street Band shows with Jay playing. He knows his dad’s work inside and out: he was tremendous. I’m not really into his other stuff but, ya, clearly talented.
Need to check that out Christopher!
The reasoning for joey being replaced is because from my understanding he had a condition that affected his legs and he couldn’t drum for a while. Later on joey recovered and joined a new band called vimic.
Sounds like I need to check out Vimic!
Slipknot thought he was on drugs.
@@kylebatteson9572 the thing is that his condition came from drugs and later on he had a relapse (they didn't say it officially but they gave some hints). That was a little bit problematic for the band because all of them sobered up and that could have affected the band, that's why he had to leave in the end. the cause of joye's death could also have to do with health issues due to him starting drugs again.
please note, i'm not trying to sell "the truth" here, that's just what i came up with after watching a ton of interviews where they sometimes gave himts but never did any official statements
@@kylebatteson9572 maybe i mixed it up a little bit but this could help to clarify th-cam.com/video/lFH0rdy6VT4/w-d-xo.html
Unsainted is off their latest Record, “we are not your kind”. Which is jays second record with slipknot.
Oh right. Thanks Brandon
As you've figured out from your joey reactions, he was beloved and many see him irreplaceable. Tbh, Jay was the best possible replacement. He met the band in the early 2000s through his dad and listened to them so he knew all about them, so his personality (as well as his playing) fits right in with the band by this point.
Would definitely like to see more Jay, great reaction!!
Can’t wait to see more Joey!
@@AndrewRooneyDrums um he’s dead
Joey developed “Transverse Myelitis”.
Edit : Jay’s recording sessions for WANYK would have been a much better example to showcase his chops.
“It (Transverse myelitis) is most often associated with intravenous administration after a period of abstinence from heroin.”
@@mccarty yep, lots of articles about people becoming paraplegic or even dying after falling off the wagon. So sad.
@@saadesigner07 Ya we’ll probably never ever know what really happened, but considering that the band hasn’t explained why he was fired, his family hasn’t explained his cause of death, and the fact that joey’s disease is closely related to heroin usage, it’s likely that the band fired him due to heroin usage. He then got clean and re-learned how to walk and play the drums again, but later fell back on drugs and probably died due to an overdose ;(
@@mccarty no, no and no.
@@mccarty what the hell are you talkin about 😂😂
I really love Jay.
There's a video out there of Jay playing with his father on a (i think) TV Show, each one with a different style, it's amazing
Thanks Ezequiel. I 'll check it out!
It’s pretty new 2019 of the album we are not your kind
Awesome! Thanks James!
Thanks for watching... please be sure to sub! 🥁+ ☕️ = 🙌
I have seen him play this live. It is amazing.
FINALLY. I’ve been requesting this for months
Great to hear Gabriel! 🙌
Jay has so many drum cams I recommend watching his Get This! drum cam from Germany! Jay and Joey inspired me to improve my playing tenfold. SlipKnot are truly blessed to have 2 of the best drummers ever to grace the industry!
Any real slipknot fan knows Joey will never be replaced but jay has Completely met our expectations and then some, he’s an awesome fit and so glad the bad found someone like him to keep joeys legacy going
Didn’t know that was Max’s kid. His incredible and his dad is a fantastic drummer. Thanks again Andrew 🔥🔥
How? seriously?
@@Phvsics yes!!!!!!
As soon as I heard Jays last name I was like holy shit that Max Weinbergs kid...Wow just wow was totally blown away! Shout out to Max and his wife for letting Jay be Jay behind the kit!
It’s to bad we will never get to see Joey and Jay rip it up together once. How freaking epic would that have been 🤘🏻. RIP Joey, Jay has your six.
If been waiting a long time to see you react to this exact video. Good vid!!!
Appreciate it!!
jay is doing an outstanding job, sounds different and this is cool too
Excellent Luan
Its not just Jay that sounds different the whole bands sound changed..as with most bands there music gets more and more refined.
Jay rocks it just saw them 2 weeks ago live was amazing
Awesome. Great to hear Brian
Joey was exceptional, no doubt . . . But I do think Slipknot actually found one of only a handful of drummers who could match Joeys raw talent whilst bringing their own creativity to the newer songs, putting their own stamp on it. This song is from 'We are not your kind' which is the latest Slipknot album to date and Jay's own work.
I would juxtapose this with Lamb of God.
Art Cruz is undeniably a very talented drummer and he can play Chris' parts very, very well. But the stuff he's written with the band? Personally I don't think it has the same flare and creativity that Chris did when he was writing with them.
Nice one Anthony! Thanks for the input
This song is off of the album We Are Not Your Kind which was released on August 9th 2019
Had the pleasure of seeing Joey play live. Would love to see Jay play. The energy of Slipknot’s live show is unmatched. Joey’s drumming reminds me of chaos. Jay’s drumming has incredible groove. Both are fantastic and being different, but amazing, things to the table.
"Before I forget". Nice reference that you didn't even realise you made! Good vid.
The song is of of a album called we are not your kind
This album was released in 2019
7:16 that was a cheeky reference to the band Andrew 😉 did you even realise you did it?
Was about to comment the same shit
You should definitely check out his Studio recording of Red Flag sometime if you got the time!
Great video, thanks for making it!
I hope to check it out!
Ohhh Red Flag is awesome. Sounds like Iowa era Slipknot
Unsaited is indeed from their 2019 album with Jay recording. Joey was sadly let go after his session after “All hope is gone” album. Reason why is somewhat of a mystery to some. When rumors started popping out, Joey did many interviews that he wasn’t leaving the band, but sadly those rumors were true.
Joey unfortunately had an acute case of Transverse myelitis (TM); which is a rare neurological condition in which his spinal cord is inflamed. It caused him to loose the ability to use his legs properly.
You should maybe see the speech he gave in the 2016 metal hammer gods awards. It is honestly the most passionate, yet saddest moment in his life. In our lives as a fan, think he would beat this… 😢
Glad to see you get around to Jay! I love Joey, but it would be inauthentic for someone to try to be exactly like him. Jay is himself, and I think he's awesome!
His dad played in a TV show, and there is one recording of Max vs Jay playing jazz!! You'll love it
Unsainted was released on the “We Are Not Your Kind” 2019 album so jay wrote and recorded that part
I found his tom angles and positionings to be interesting as well as his ride. The ride was tilted forward and really downward. The snare had a nice pop to it. Really stood out in this mix.
There's a video of Max & Jay Weinberg doing a drum duet I think you'd love. It's on the guitar center channel. Absolutely amazing watching the difference between the father & son combo. Hopefully see your reaction to this soon. Both have completely different styles & are both incredible at what they do!
Great video
Oh yeah, that was pretty sick
They are so good live!
you definitely have to react to the chapeltown rag drum cam. where he came up with it is out of this world
It's on the way Ian!
@@AndrewRooneyDrums when can we expect the chapletown rag jay (zildjian) vid
The mics inside of the toms makes them friggin boom! Whitechapel’s old drummer (Ben) did that and they sounded like perfectly toned canons live!
Awesome. Thanks Rob!
@@AndrewRooneyDrums you don’t have to do a reaction or anything (unless you want to) but check this video out
th-cam.com/video/2ngFIv75XOg/w-d-xo.html
Unsainted is off their newest album We Are Not Your Kind, and it’s Jays drum creation. I’d suggest you get a drum cam of Jay playing something from the early days, you can absolutely tell a difference between him and Joey but, there’s no comparison to Joey. Joey as technical as he in my opinion he’s the master of speed, and Jay is the technical more precise drummer without Joeys speed. (Again both very worthy) Joey is the total package. RIP JOEY… but I do like Jay a lot as well
Jay did a interview where he wanted to change the sound, if you notice the kick drums are tuned different, as in each kick dum is tuned different. This is his song
Thanks, Jay. ....there, no longer thankless.
Jay is good but Joey was even more awesome. A true showman for sure! No one can hold a candle to Joey in my eyes. RIP Joey we miss you.🌹
Well said Amanda
@@AndrewRooneyDrums 😇
I saw a couple of Bruce shows during that 2010 tour. He definitely brought a new youthful energy to the E Street Band
Love how his toms are internally mic'd. Keeps the clean lines of the kit and any clutter away from the player
He’s set up with drum triggers that’s why you don’t see mics…tone is computer generated so he gets the same tone every hit no matter how hard he hits. Almost all bands that tour use them
@@kurtismckague8103 it's not triggered. His toms have wired mics inside the drums.
It's to prevent cymbal bleed through the tom mics. As you can see his cymbals are really close to his toms. That's a soundman decision and a smart one.
Let me listen to the original video
@@ranman1708 yeah. I saw some interview with jay about it. Bound to he great for jay to not have to compromise his set up. And as you say for the sound to not be bleeding all over the place.
“Ohh Before I Forget”..
*asks question*
I see what you did there. Slick!
LOL I realized afterward it's a Slipknot song
yeah joey used to play with paiste remo heads pearl drumset and signature snare tama iron cobra and a head drumsticks, now jay uses zildjian evan heads sjc drumset dw 9000 pedal sjc signature snare and vater drumsticks
Plz check out Jay playing Disasterpieces at BBC1 !
you can see a video from Krimh, its awesome.
Thanks Pablo
I saw them live last week at Tampa and the drums were on point!
I seen a post on jays instagram the other week and he said one of the reason his snare sound is so unique is he actually punches his leg most of the time
Jay got the gig because he was asked to come down and audition if I remember the interview with him. He knew the guys as it was so he fit it
This is a song off the second album Jay wrote and played on
Thanks Justin!
Wow, love that diy play button!, hope you'll get one soon!
From the other few reactors that have reacted to Jay drum cams, I’ve seen mostly seen disasterpiece and duality. One cam I think that’s underrated is Jay playing vermilion.
Distastepiece: th-cam.com/video/uX1GzoDkWkg/w-d-xo.html
Duality: th-cam.com/video/qHLQWjs9rTE/w-d-xo.html
Vermilion: th-cam.com/video/ysSV8N7HvYw/w-d-xo.html
Solway Firth: th-cam.com/video/wN-6R92bxf0/w-d-xo.html
But if you want to see another song that Jay wrote, then I would suggest the Solway firth cam.
Thank you!
As far as Joey’s departure. He had a health problem that effected the use of his legs. He recovered however was fired. It was never released as to actual reason why. Wether it was because of the health or suspicion of drug use. Which he denied. It’s speculation
Exactly what he said rip joey
YESSSSSS!! Finally!!!!!!! Thank you so much.
Sooooo what about Dave Lombardo from Slayer?
Great call Dominick!
Joey was fired shortly before Slipknot’s 2014 album .5 The Gray Chapter. When their bassist Paul Gray died the band agreed anyone who couldn’t get clean of drugs would be fired, Joey developed a nervous system condition that left him in poor health, he would have to be carried to and from his kit during their shows. At the time, the condition hadn’t been diagnosed, Joey didn’t know why he was in that shape and the band thought he was back on drugs.
Slipknot fans seem to have taken Jay in well. He plays Joey’s songs perfectly and his own style he brought to the band is refreshing. Unsainted is one of Jay Weinberg’s songs.
That is so unfortunate.
RIP Joey
The difference in the Snaresound of Joey to Jay may be the Size of the Snare. Joey used 13x6,5" Snares and Jay uses a "standrad" 14" Snare, if I'm right.
Krimh playing Prototype from SepticFlesh. Guy is a machine.
Jay Weinberg All Out Life Drum cam is his best drum cam
It's a must you check out the zildjian performance by evgeny novikov (the drummer to slaughter to prevail) you will not regret checking this dude out
Would love to hear him play without all of the snap to grid, triggers,and whatever else they have at their disposal right now
Duality drum cam is a good one if u want to see Jay playing one of Joeys songs
"i do have a question (Before i forget)"...how appropriate for a slipknot video reaction.
I think this was their best album since Iowa personally. Jay was amazing on it too. Check out him doing Nero Forte on his E Kit.
Would love to see more jay reactions hes great
i'm just here to say that i freakin' love your TH-cam plaque
Check out his Code orange you and you alone cover .. fantastic energy
Well Joey became paralysed and beat it. He always thought they would bring him back they even lead him on about at one point. Joey founded Slipknot so when only ONE of the band members visited when he was hospitalized and found out he was kicked out through the media and an email... Just awful. There's alot of pain here and bad blood here about how this broke apart. Joey saw a headline saying he left Slipknot and he couldn't believe what he was seeing.. imagine being booted without even a visit to the hospital from anyone but one of them after he gave them this band. He was the heart. He was number 1. You don't treat people like that. I only saw Slipknot with Joey.. at least a dozen times... Joey was self taught. I feel bad for Jay... He can't fill those shoes. He just can't. This IS my favorite band. Always has been since I was 10... I can't say it enough Joey created entire songs like lyrics and all... So I love them to the end but I won't see them without Joey. Not after what they did to him... He beat paralysis and then came back and played with vimic sinsaenim scar the martyr etc. How I feel is: I'm pissed. Jay is fine but he is not Joey.. I'm upset about the members who kicked Joey out not Jay.
Yo what??? Which member actually visited Joey??? What are your sources??? Please tell me dude I love Slipknot. If they really treated him like that I swear I won't ever see them live....
Listen to some interviews of Joey. He says all of the things stated above.
@@CaptainPantys Listen to some interviews of Joey. He says all of the things stated above.
Take a look at David Diebold. This guy does single pedal blast beats. Correct me if I am wrong but he might be doing 16th notes with his right foot but technicality, he is amazing to witness on the kit....
I have done one vid on him Jim. But look forward to more 👌
Jay was a perfect fit to step in for Joey R. I. P. 🙏
It's okay to compare, joey was absolutely fantastic and probably a top 4 metal drummer of all time. But Jay brings a whole new flavor, mixes some blues and country tones within the fast and groove beats. Love this vid!!
He paused around 715.... said "before I forget"...
😁🤘🏻🎸🏆
I've just realized that was a Slipknot reference. Happy accident :)
@@AndrewRooneyDrums
Next reaction....
It's kismet!
Jay brought his own style to Slipknot while maintaining the changing directions of the band. Jay is a fantastic drummer and he continues to pay homage to Joey by playing the early greats as if Joey was playing himself. The entire meaning of the masks is to focus on the music, atmosphere, and feeling instead of the person. Jay continues that.
Well said
Max & Jay 2009 Guitar Center Drum-off competition. You will be pleased.
At 49 years old, last year, the Jay, Zildjian Unsainted video caused me to buy drums after 30 years of playing guitar lol.
AMAZING
There is a video online of him playing side by side with his dad
They are both awesome but very different styles
YES THIS IS WHAT I WAS WAITING FOR. REACTIONS TO JAY WEINBERG
Yo! 👊🥁☕️
On the subject of replacement drummers, art Cruz with lamb of god. I was mad about it for awhile but he’s a great drummer and brings a new flavor to one of my all time favorite bands
He’s sensational Timothy
Reason why he was replaced by Jay, was, as Jordison revealed in June 2016 that he suffered from transverse myelitis, a neurological disease that cost him the ability to play the drums toward the end of his time with Slipknot.
That's awful Mika. But thanks for the info
7:23 no its the latest album actually and jay did the drumming for that album
Andrew I think you now need to do a react video to Jay playing The Chapeltown Rag 🤘
100% way overdue on a new Jay vid!
A reason they sound different is because Joey used metal sticks and jay uses wood sticks plus other things
Jay has said that his custom snare from SJC is so loud that, the first time he hit it, he scared the shit out of himself. The tone difference is a 13x6.5 metal snare (Joey) vs. and a 14x6.5 48-ply would snare. Cymbal tone, aside from brand, also might have to do with stick size. Joey used a Promark 5A stick, and Jay’s Vater signature is slightly bigger than a Vater 9A.
The drum sound is a lot different here because what we hear is the sound from the mics that are mounted inside of the drum shells :)
Oh wow. Thanks for that
This goes outside of drumming but as a fairly old fan and collector of the band I couldn't have thought of a better PERSON to replace Joey. Jay is super humble and kind to the fans and lives and breaths his craft in art. (he's a very talented oil painter and everything visual in addition to his music career) he's been a fan of Slipknot since he was a kid and Joey is his hero. Overall just a very cool, polite and down-to-earth guy who gives tons of energy and excitement to the band! No one can ever really truly replace Joey but I think Jay is the best possible person to honor his legacy and also give his own twist to modern Slipknot. (I had the honour to see Joey playing live three times, I've seen Jay four times so far and I think he is one of the best, if not THE best, part of their live show right now)
Undaunted is from the newest album from slipkot we are not your kind.
Sorry unsainted
Thanks Kevin!
I got back into listening SlipKnot after Weinberg joined the band, as it came back into my consciousness. I started to listen to old stuff and new stuff and you can clearly hear out the different styles from Jordison and Weinberg. Jordison was a speedmachine. He was pretty fast and endurant at that. Weinberg tends to get somewhat sloppy on the doublebass parts but excels at complex fills and rythms. The part in unsainted, where he leads with the lefthand on the snare and puts accents on the china with the right hand is unthinkable for Joey. The otherway around: The insane blast beats and studidly fast double bass patterns from older songs like heretic anthem or people=shit are clearly not the style of Jay. They are obviously different drummers, each with their own style. SlipKnot changed with their drummer, but I like the change and it doesnt make the old albums undone and I can enjoy both of them.
That's fantastic. Glad you dig both players!
Jay is tight. He brings his own dynamics to it.
This is from Slipknot’s newest album “We are Not Your Kind”
Love it! As far as slipknot fans, all of the ones I've talked to respect Jay for doing what he's done. I'd love to see a comparison video purely for your thoughts on styles!
oh, also, unsainted is from a new album that joey wasn't there for. it's from we are not your kind