The Edge of Democracy is simply a masterpiece. Thanks Democracy Now for the interview with Petra Costa, and the amazing coverage of Lula's overdue freedom.
Maybe a nice speech, and also you may cry a little as well, but if you know how much this has been stilling from the Brazilians you may cry for the rest of your life.
@@franck05silva No one here believes your fascist bullshit. Go somewhere else. Unless you actually believe Bolsonaro and Moro's bullshit - in which case it's sad that you've been played that hard.
thecaveofthedead Exactly, just fascist BS. These ppl freak out about any move that Lula does. However, they are not a bit shocked about Bolsonaro being involved in Mariele Franco assassination. They give 100% permission for Bolsonaro to do what he wants and 0% permission to the Worker’s party.
I agree CT, so many good people are persecuted for standing up for the rights of others, and doing something about making this a better world for everyone. What the heck is going on?
Bernie is the only candidate on the stage that has the sense to not declare war on the global intelligence apparatus until he has the mandate to win that war. Try just a little harder to read between the lines Staad, you’ll see it.
Congratulations to Lula and the people of Brazil People power and justice must prevail. No more corruption. Things will not get better only if people are united not divisive Get rid of the mafia thug Bolsonado and his gang Doing evil job for the super rich and corporations.
@@silenenetto5641 nem adianta rebater com esse povo, sao cabecas duras por falta de apanhar mais na vida. Mais Bolsonaro nao eh o melhor presidente pois ate o lula fez bem nos primeiros 4 anos. Eu acho que o vai definir bolsonaro eh o segundo mandato dele no qual ele vai ter mais chance devido a esse absurdo do stf que foi uma vergonha contra nosso combate a corrupcao para fvorecer o lula
@@Henriquecer88 Os caciques do psdb estão envolvidos com o tráfico. Aecinho do pó é só um exemplo. O pcc foi criado durante o governo do psdb em SP. Em vários estados o pcc não conseguia entrar por causa da oposição de outros grupos de traficantes. Nos estados em que o psdb chegou ao poder, o pcc se tornou facção dominante após os governadores do psdb ordenarem que a policia iniciasse ações contra os os traficantes rivais do pcc, mas não contra o pcc.
@@ericomartins9794 @Érico Martins querido, moro em sp e eu conheço ex-integrante do pcc, o PSDB é tão lixo quanto o PT, foram omissos com a integridade dos presidiários e de dentro da cadeia eles foram crescendo e crescendo até chegarem o que é hoje, independente se foi o PSDB ou PT no governo daria na mesma, as politicas publicas para conter as facções de dentro da cadeia nunca tiveram exito nem no governo do PSDB nem com o PT, foram quase 20 anos com esses dois lixos de partidos e nada melhorava, e a violencia só aumentou nesses dois periodos, para de tentar apontar o dedo para um partido, sendo que todos tem culpa. Dá pra ver claramente que você é defensor velha guarda do PT, o que o pt fez nesses 13 anos para combater a criminalidade? NADA.
Yes- I have been living in this country for 20 years now!!! Brazil has too much violence,corruption,social division and ecocide. It could have been a decent country, but I truly believe that is no longer possible. This country will explode into anarchy and chaos,maybe it is best to give it back to the Indians. Comments Welcome!!!
Her documentary is a lie! I'm a brazilian I lived that period and know that all she said is a big lie! She is connected to all the corruption that destructed my country!
@@danielseiti4598 you made your point but people do know the truth, and it is not a long history, we remember it too. If I knew nothing about Brazil, between you and her version of history, I was always trusting her more than you. You judge, claim with no evidence,... She backs whatever she says with real facts that happened. If you sure that she is wrong, provide the evidence. Please convince us, how she is a part of that "Corruption" or so, before we start thinking of you as another Nazi Fascist who is lying to change the image of Nazi Bolsonaro, who is a Corporate and Billionaires' Puppet, and believe in colonization... He boosts the destruction of Amazon...
@@amania9254 1º Nazi Fascist don't exist in Brazil this is a leftist lie. I know I live here. 2º She don't back up nothing she just give a reality distortion. I know because I saw how it happens. The democracy here is normal our lives are better now. Left stolen our money to keep the power. I saw and Petra is just another lie that the Left want to trick the worl to believe. 3º She is the grand daughter of one of the thief's and all her staff worked for the thief's. 4º Amazon is not being destruct this is a lie. I live here and I can tell that. I have friends that live on Amazon and they see the reality and tell us the truth. 5º Stop sayng that people are nazi or fascit this a great stupidity. What you call nazi or fascists are the people who don't agree with the left. 6º Bolsonaro was elect by the people of Brazil no Nazi or other crazy thing the leftist want to say about him just to make look bad. 7º The same person who say someone is nazi fascist are the ones who support communist/socialist dictators in Venezuela, North Korea, Bolivia and other countries. With that if you think that just beacuse she made a movie is true I'm really sorry you are being manipulated all your life.
@@danielseiti4598 now you proved that you are a shill for the Nazi Bolsonaro, the same way it happened in 1930s,... How many millions of people lefted from poverty in Lula's time?!!! And how many in Fascist Racist Bolsonaro's time?!!! It is stupid to say that communism /socialism /amperialism /... Works or not, it is about the people how they make the system work for them. Health-care for everyone is in socialism, is that wrong?!!! I am not a socialist, and I don't like many things in socialism, and I don't care which -ism is there, I just see what happens to the people and society. You are standing on one side, that's selfish.
Sorry Ms. Costa but the 1964 movement was never a "golpe". It was just for the same reason we, "the People", are on the streets again and demanding our Armed Forces to help us on the fight against COMMUNISM in BRAZIL, that was and it is now.
The fate of the indigenous working classes in all Latin America to overthrow their respective oppressive oligarchs, cartels, and military dictatorships, is, unfortunately, in hands of people who have not awakened to the realization their economies, lifestyle and their consumption patterns perpetaute the exploitational relationships of capitalism in Latin America. If not for the direct support the Latin American states preferred by the congress in Washington recieve in military, moral and economic support, services and products the Canadian and American people produce out of dependence and necessity, the indigenous working classes would have long ago overthrown their ruling classes.
Deplorable documentary. PT party of lula and Dilma deixou o Brazil with 13 millions citizen unemployed. It is horrifying to see a video praising Lula the worst president Brazil ever Had in it’s history.
@@areader2253 you mean, great because he just gave free stuff to the poor, on credit while bankers get the biggest of interests for brazil to pay in debts. Sure, he was good in the first term since his work was continuation of the president before him, but you know how the human greed surpasses even his love for his country
@@fernandocombr both left and right have done this kind of thing, both to their own and to others. Currenly right wing movements are by far the most frightening and Nazi-like. There are so many angry fanatics on the right at the moment, and they're the one who like guns.
Better call this movie as a fantasy. This is not a documentary job at all: its director is the daughter of one of the biggest involved in PT government corruption scandals: Mrs. Costa is the daughter of the owner of Andrade Gutierrez. This indication is a fallacy from progressives showing how deep corruption is organized at an international level. The film goes on very tangentially, when trying to see Manichaeistically outlaws and good guys, due to the fact that almost all the characters, scammers and victims, have already exchanged strokes of a lot of intimacy and walked, formulated policies and lay in a collective orgy during all these years. Many are even part of the current government. In other words, the real wealthy and ashamed elite knows that the only thing that keeps the masses away from the portals is an economy running at full throttle. The 'edge' of the film's title, as an adjective of this democracy that is in danger, is very much focused on the suffragette aspect of democracy. Since the vote was not, which I think is correct in that sense, it was always respected after the 1988 Pact. However, the script could have inserted a little bit of Collor de Mello in the context, for example, because it would be important in this pedagogical aspect. Those in power will strike and drop a thousand on the left and 10,000 on the right, the correct numbering in the Bible. Another point is the almost total absence of the military in the film. They, who are now gray eminences of protagonism both in the background and in the deep background, demonstrate that much democracy was rooted in that country. It is worth mentioning, once again, that many characters considered to be coup makers were defenders of the democratic order - under this prism of the vertigo of suffrage. Even Eduardo Cunha, months before the facts got out of hand, peremptorily affirms, in the scene of the film's archive, that it would be absurd to think of removing Dilma from the presidency. The main actors in the heterodox collapse of the PT were a Legislature that had already been his, and a Judiciary with many appointments of his own, including to the Supreme Court. In other words, I do not speak here of necessary self-criticism, which is so much requested of the PT. I speak of absurd administrative and political ineptitude, as well as a ruinous and fanciful management of the economy, coupled with the blind eye with flagrant cases of corruption. That started to bother the mass. A moralistic scum that rose thanks to the PT. The now damned "poor of the right".
This piece of shit Lula stole billions of dollars from the taxpayers, his administration had corruption everywere, in a real Country he wold be executed.
Lula is a modern day Tiradentes. He is a true revolutionary for the people. He is unaffected by corrupted judicial imprisonment. Yang and Tulsi for POTUS.
![LAVROV's interview with Tucker CARLSON 😁 [Parody]](/img/n.gif)
The Edge of Democracy is simply a masterpiece. Thanks Democracy Now for the interview with Petra Costa, and the amazing coverage of Lula's overdue freedom.
Wow, Lula's speech made me tear up a little. What a powerful speaker. Seems like Brazil's version of Bernie Sanders.
Uh uh James. Sanders just has a hint of what Lula has.
Maybe a nice speech, and also you may cry a little as well, but if you know how much this has been stilling from the Brazilians you may cry for the rest of your life.
@@franck05silva No one here believes your fascist bullshit. Go somewhere else. Unless you actually believe Bolsonaro and Moro's bullshit - in which case it's sad that you've been played that hard.
thecaveofthedead Exactly, just fascist BS. These ppl freak out about any move that Lula does. However, they are not a bit shocked about Bolsonaro being involved in Mariele Franco assassination. They give 100% permission for Bolsonaro to do what he wants and 0% permission to the Worker’s party.
@juliano caldas yes, Karma will put a corrupt drunk back to his cell in Curitiba
Thank you “ DEMOCRACY NOW ! “ for your flawless international journalism 💋😍👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
And now a COUP in Bolivia. Sounds familiar?
I agree CT, so many good people are persecuted for standing up for the rights of others, and doing something about making this a better world for everyone. What the heck is going on?
Lula and Bernie together will lead us into a new era of the people and by the people!
TAKE LULA FOR YOU, STUPID MAN. HE'S THE BIGGEST THIEF THAT EVER ENTERED BRAZILIAN PRESIDENCE! GO YOU TO HELL WITH HIM!! 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
Same is happening in India
Bernie Sanders 2020 🙏💙💜✌
Bernie thinks Maduro is a brutal dictator. I must ask Which side is he on?
Bernie is the only candidate on the stage that has the sense to not declare war on the global intelligence apparatus until he has the mandate to win that war. Try just a little harder to read between the lines Staad, you’ll see it.
Yes
People of Brazil, the time is now for a revolution for anarchy, ecology, and anti-capitalism.
Naw. Later I'm sleeping
Your anarchist friends fouth side by side with the fascists against the workers party in the street. The anarchists will get the bullet too
@@MinusMaximusXX Death to the state, death to tankies
AND ALSO IS THE TIME FOR IDIOTS LIKE YOU !!??
Congratulations to Lula and the people of Brazil
People power and justice must prevail. No more corruption.
Things will not get better only if people are united not divisive
Get rid of the mafia thug Bolsonado and his gang Doing evil job for the super rich and corporations.
lol..dont be stupid, Lula's release was thanks to corruption coming from our judicial ministers.
Lula o maior ladrão do Brasil 🇧🇷 bolsonaro o melhor presidente da história
@@silenenetto5641 nem adianta rebater com esse povo, sao cabecas duras por falta de apanhar mais na vida. Mais Bolsonaro nao eh o melhor presidente pois ate o lula fez bem nos primeiros 4 anos. Eu acho que o vai definir bolsonaro eh o segundo mandato dele no qual ele vai ter mais chance devido a esse absurdo do stf que foi uma vergonha contra nosso combate a corrupcao para fvorecer o lula
The dead Squad = Milicianos
Hahaha, shame on you. Lula is the biggest thief that ever entered Brazil's presidence. Brazilians just ignore this COMMUNIST trash!
Stop imperialism stop military backed coups stop tyranny! Democracy will live on!
A great defeat to the milicomaniacs in Moema and Barra da Tijuca.
kakakakaka, a soltura do lula é vitoria para o PCC
@@nicolasceresoli9121 PCC é franquia do PSDB sua trouxa.
@@ericomartins9794 não viaja.
@@Henriquecer88 Os caciques do psdb estão envolvidos com o tráfico. Aecinho do pó é só um exemplo.
O pcc foi criado durante o governo do psdb em SP.
Em vários estados o pcc não conseguia entrar por causa da oposição de outros grupos de traficantes.
Nos estados em que o psdb chegou ao poder, o pcc se tornou facção dominante após os governadores do psdb ordenarem que a policia iniciasse ações contra os os traficantes rivais do pcc, mas não contra o pcc.
@@ericomartins9794 @Érico Martins querido, moro em sp e eu conheço ex-integrante do pcc, o PSDB é tão lixo quanto o PT, foram omissos com a integridade dos presidiários e de dentro da cadeia eles foram crescendo e crescendo até chegarem o que é hoje, independente se foi o PSDB ou PT no governo daria na mesma, as politicas publicas para conter as facções de dentro da cadeia nunca tiveram exito nem no governo do PSDB nem com o PT, foram quase 20 anos com esses dois lixos de partidos e nada melhorava, e a violencia só aumentou nesses dois periodos, para de tentar apontar o dedo para um partido, sendo que todos tem culpa. Dá pra ver claramente que você é defensor velha guarda do PT, o que o pt fez nesses 13 anos para combater a criminalidade? NADA.
Marielle vive
Marielle está morta
MARIELLE está morta. Enterrada. Morta por um petista, ao que tudo indica...
Hey world, finally, welcome to another world called Brazil - what a ride...
Yes- I have been living in this country for 20 years now!!! Brazil has too much violence,corruption,social division and ecocide. It could have been a decent country, but I truly believe that is no longer possible. This country will explode into anarchy and chaos,maybe it is best to give it back to the Indians. Comments Welcome!!!
she should start the second documentary
Isso é uma vergonha para o Brasil !!!
O Cara roubou, deixou o país falido foi condenado e agora isso ....
....Justiça Brasileira jogada no chão !!!
Roubou o que prove até agora não apresentaram provas
Petra Costa is an amazing person, she made this amazing documentary, love to watch it.
Her documentary is a lie! I'm a brazilian I lived that period and know that all she said is a big lie! She is connected to all the corruption that destructed my country!
@@danielseiti4598 you made your point but people do know the truth, and it is not a long history, we remember it too.
If I knew nothing about Brazil, between you and her version of history, I was always trusting her more than you. You judge, claim with no evidence,... She backs whatever she says with real facts that happened. If you sure that she is wrong, provide the evidence.
Please convince us, how she is a part of that "Corruption" or so, before we start thinking of you as another Nazi Fascist who is lying to change the image of Nazi Bolsonaro, who is a Corporate and Billionaires' Puppet, and believe in colonization... He boosts the destruction of Amazon...
@@amania9254 1º Nazi Fascist don't exist in Brazil this is a leftist lie. I know I live here.
2º She don't back up nothing she just give a reality distortion. I know because I saw how it happens. The democracy here is normal our lives are better now. Left stolen our money to keep the power. I saw and Petra is just another lie that the Left want to trick the worl to believe.
3º She is the grand daughter of one of the thief's and all her staff worked for the thief's.
4º Amazon is not being destruct this is a lie. I live here and I can tell that. I have friends that live on Amazon and they see the reality and tell us the truth.
5º Stop sayng that people are nazi or fascit this a great stupidity. What you call nazi or fascists are the people who don't agree with the left.
6º Bolsonaro was elect by the people of Brazil no Nazi or other crazy thing the leftist want to say about him just to make look bad.
7º The same person who say someone is nazi fascist are the ones who support communist/socialist dictators in Venezuela, North Korea, Bolivia and other countries.
With that if you think that just beacuse she made a movie is true I'm really sorry you are being manipulated all your life.
@@danielseiti4598 now you proved that you are a shill for the Nazi Bolsonaro, the same way it happened in 1930s,...
How many millions of people lefted from poverty in Lula's time?!!! And how many in Fascist Racist Bolsonaro's time?!!!
It is stupid to say that communism /socialism /amperialism /... Works or not, it is about the people how they make the system work for them. Health-care for everyone is in socialism, is that wrong?!!!
I am not a socialist, and I don't like many things in socialism, and I don't care which -ism is there, I just see what happens to the people and society.
You are standing on one side, that's selfish.
this documentary does not correspond to the reality of the facts that occurred in Brazil at the time of Lula and Dilma
\o/🇧🇷Lula Livre !!!
||
Sorry Ms. Costa but the 1964 movement was never a "golpe". It was just for the same reason we, "the People", are on the streets again and demanding our Armed Forces to help us on the fight
against COMMUNISM in BRAZIL, that was and it is now.
Democrat as stalin, Fidel Castro, Hugo Chavez, maduro!
The fate of the indigenous working classes in all Latin America to overthrow their respective oppressive oligarchs, cartels, and military dictatorships, is, unfortunately, in hands of people who have not awakened to the realization their economies, lifestyle and their consumption patterns perpetaute the exploitational relationships of capitalism in Latin America. If not for the direct support the Latin American states preferred by the congress in Washington recieve in military, moral and economic support, services and products the Canadian and American people produce out of dependence and necessity, the indigenous working classes would have long ago overthrown their ruling classes.
Petra is Amazing!
no.
Lula Livre✊
This film is the same as if Pablo Escobar's daughter produced a documentary called "The Edge of Justice".
Thanks to Mr 🎺
Lula livre!!! ✊
Lula, the greatest political leader we have!!
Never
What a sheep! Following a leader instead of wanting freedom ..
Fuck lula and fuck bolsonaro!
Lula livre
Era melhor preso, pelo menos era considerado
O CERTO É "PRESIDIÁRIO SOLTO"!
CUIDEM DE SUAS CARTEIRAS E CELULARES!!
Lula for president of the world!
sure, because the world is already fucked, let us fuck it up just a bit more. Maybe aliens will truly never visit us
Muita maconha
I don't know any democrat communist!
That is not a documentary. It's political propaganda.
I’m not a scholar on Brazil, they threw the guy in jail months after his wife died, now there plundering the country, good luck with that.
You've bought into the far-right bullshit as usual. Typical Trump/Bolsanaro fan boy
Deplorable documentary. PT party of lula and Dilma deixou o Brazil with 13 millions citizen unemployed. It is horrifying to see a video praising Lula the worst president Brazil ever Had in it’s history.
Mentir aqui , não adianta ...
That's the way this show works. Anything left is "good" no matter what. Anything remotely brown is "good" no matter what
Adriana Bonita Aziz boa kkkkk
Deplorável é teu presidente miliciano
@@adrianabonitaaziz7393 Bolsonaro tem uma milícia digital que está comentando em todos os vídeos relacionados a entrevista sobre o documentário
Some of us will survive. Take care of yourselves DM!
Lula good man
Lula um verme, ele destruiu o Brasil com Dilma e temer, o maior ladrão do Brasil
Igual o diabo
Very corrupt too
Lula foi o melhor presidente da história do Brasil
@@aura3990 Diabo é teu presidente Bolsonaro
This film is amazing!
Happy but tired of the same stories. 👍
Lulas speech was one of the best political speeches I ever heard. Wow.
Bolsonaro is the worst don't get me wrong and Lula's imprimsoment was fishy as hell. But Lula isn't Bernie Sanders, he's quite tainted
That maybe true, but Lula was a great president for Brazil (when you compare him to other Brazilian presidents).
@@areader2253 you mean, great because he just gave free stuff to the poor, on credit while bankers get the biggest of interests for brazil to pay in debts. Sure, he was good in the first term since his work was continuation of the president before him, but you know how the human greed surpasses even his love for his country
LULA, THE "LOOSE PRISONER"!
TAKE CARE OF YOUR WALLETS AND CELL PHONES!! 🇧🇷🇧🇷
I think Lula is going to have an accident I'm sorry to say.
Not an accident, they just shoot politicians in broad daylight.
I think the same about bozo
This kind of crime is committed BY leftists, not TO leftists.
@@fernandocombr both left and right have done this kind of thing, both to their own and to others. Currenly right wing movements are by far the most frightening and Nazi-like. There are so many angry fanatics on the right at the moment, and they're the one who like guns.
Obrigado Lula Gracias “
Por nunca parar la lucha 🤗🇧🇷
lie lie lie lie lie lie lie lie lie lie......
You've bought into the far-right bullshit as usual. Typical Trump/Bolsanaro fan boy
Better call this movie as a fantasy. This is not a documentary job at all: its director is the daughter of one of the biggest involved in PT government corruption scandals: Mrs. Costa is the daughter of the owner of Andrade Gutierrez. This indication is a fallacy from progressives showing how deep corruption is organized at an international level.
The film goes on very tangentially, when trying to see Manichaeistically outlaws and good guys, due to the fact that almost all the characters, scammers and victims, have already exchanged strokes of a lot of intimacy and walked, formulated policies and lay in a collective orgy during all these years. Many are even part of the current government. In other words, the real wealthy and ashamed elite knows that the only thing that keeps the masses away from the portals is an economy running at full throttle.
The 'edge' of the film's title, as an adjective of this democracy that is in danger, is very much focused on the suffragette aspect of democracy. Since the vote was not, which I think is correct in that sense, it was always respected after the 1988 Pact.
However, the script could have inserted a little bit of Collor de Mello in the context, for example, because it would be important in this pedagogical aspect. Those in power will strike and drop a thousand on the left and 10,000 on the right, the correct numbering in the Bible.
Another point is the almost total absence of the military in the film.
They, who are now gray eminences of protagonism both in the background and in the deep background, demonstrate that much democracy was rooted in that country. It is worth mentioning, once again, that many characters considered to be coup makers were defenders of the democratic order - under this prism of the vertigo of suffrage. Even Eduardo Cunha, months before the facts got out of hand, peremptorily affirms, in the scene of the film's archive, that it would be absurd to think of removing Dilma from the presidency.
The main actors in the heterodox collapse of the PT were a Legislature that had already been his, and a Judiciary with many appointments of his own, including to the Supreme Court.
In other words, I do not speak here of necessary self-criticism, which is so much requested of the PT. I speak of absurd administrative and political ineptitude, as well as a ruinous and fanciful management of the economy, coupled with the blind eye with flagrant cases of corruption.
That started to bother the mass. A moralistic scum that rose thanks to the PT. The now damned "poor of the right".
Aaaaand Brazil is still a democracy
People celebrating a very very very corrupt politician? WTF people? Freedom isn't celebrating a corrupt politician! You are duped!
This piece of shit Lula stole billions of dollars from the taxpayers, his administration had corruption everywere, in a real Country he wold be executed.
Lula na cadeia, o maior ladrão do Brasil
Lula is a modern day Tiradentes. He is a true revolutionary for the people. He is unaffected by corrupted judicial imprisonment.
Yang and Tulsi for POTUS.
Anyone who thinks this is good is oblivious about the reality