It would've been so good if, like, we think spencer is dead, but it's actually like an allison type situation where she's buried alive and she's been in hiding for years with the help of mary which is why mary tells the police about Alex to help spencer and the girls and when in hiding , spencer is keeping an eye on Alex so she doesn't hurt the girls at all exactly how alison was with the whole house fire with the girls and shanna etc like she's keeping track of Alex to make sure the girls are okay and when alex is chasing the girls through the forest with a gun and yk killed wren and is about to kill the girls , spencer comes out and knocks her unconscious and we see how long and how traumatized and exhausted she is
I always thought that A should have been Aria. But It would have been cool if Spencer’s twin was in Radley and heard the story of the girls from Mona (instead of Cece). Spencer didn’t know she had a twin but her parents and Melissa knew. It would have been cool if she was A since season 3 and throughout all of the seasons, some of the scenes we had of Spencer were actually Alex. When Ezra was doing his research, he found out about Alex. He doesn’t know she’s A though. I don’t know, that’s something I have thought of.
I love this rewrite!! Another way that I came up with that would still keep Spencer alive is when her and Alex argue back in the dollhouse and Alex "kills" her it wouldn't actually be effective and she actually knocked spencer unconscious causing Alex to presume she killed Spencer. Then when the liars and Alex escape, Spencer would wake up and stumble out of the dollhouse then go into hiding to do more research on Alex leading to her finding out who Alex really is. This way we can keep Spencer alive but also see how she navigates life while being in hiding.
My reaction to this entire video is that Olivia Wilde's nodding clip. Like, yep this is finale we deserved! And honestly, I like the idea of them killing off Spencer. She's my ult favourite character and yes, it's dark af, but imagine how GAGGED the whole fandom would've been. It could've been the most shocking revelation of ANY teen drama and just as bold as Ned Stark's being decapitated.
people who make 30+ minutes videos are god warriors. I live alone and honestly, sometimes I put long videos on the background (like this one btw 🥺) just to hear another voice. Thank you for your content, PLL stuff in 2024 makes my heart really happy 💗
I actually love this! That ending scene you proposed about the camera spanning throught the empty Hastings house gave me actual CHILLS. I personally would have been so upsset if Spencer was dead the whole time so I do the the kidnapped version better but the version of the ending if Spencer did die is also so cool so I can't choose 😄 Also, a I agree it would have been so much cooler if Alex took over Spencer life seasons earlier. It would also explain the weird Spaleb situation on S7 as well...😬
It's so fun because the other day I watched an old interview of troian during the last season of pll before the big reveal and of course she couldn't spoil the surpris and also had a completely different attitude towards the finale, but of course I get that and how she couldn't say that she didn't agree with the finale lmao. She gave me the same vibes of Emilia Clarke when they ask her if she's satisfied with the last season of game of thrones and she goes "mhh..yeah..."
i love this idea so much. if i could have rewritten anything it would’ve been changing season 4b and alison staying alive but staying away from rosewood. i think it would’ve been better if ravenswood would’ve been the story of alison after she went missing instead of the story with supernatural aspects and the power of five. she went back to grunwald after she met up with mona that night, instead of driving far away. we’d get to know what she was doing, hidden away in ravenswood, watching the girls be tormented by mona and then cece but not being able to do much at the risk of her own safety. the mid season mark of ravenswood would’ve actually taken place around grave new world, where ali still comes back the girls to let them know she’s alive, but she never fully returns to rosewood. she just comes back like she did before, in her red coat to save the girls when they were in trouble. that’s how the girls ultimately get saved from the dollhouse in this case also, by alison always keeping an eye on them and trying to keep up with A to protect them, grunwald is able to locate the dollhouse and her and alison get the girls out before anyone can see alison is indeed alive
I love your idea, and I think the version where the liar who's been replaced dies could go well with Emily's character, I've heard people saying they wouldn't mind it if Emily died at some point, but also I don't know if Shay could pull off a british twin as good as Trojan did
All the current longer videos that channels have started doing makes me so happy I can do my make up or like play the sims without having to switch videos or I can put it on 2x speed
I haven't watched the video yet, don''t have time for now, but I actually liked Alex as a villain. If only she had been introduced a little bit earlier - at least before the whole time jump thing, he story would have made more sense. She could have pretended to be Spencer as well, it's very on brand anyway. But we have what we have.
This channel got recommended to me the other day and I’ve been binging your content since 😂 you have a new viewer I love it 💅 hello new bestie 💅 also the swapping of Alex with Spencer in the dollhouse is such a slay of an idea from u and would explain so much
I was so upset with the AD reveal…I felt like I’d wasted so much time watching it like Mona was iconic, Cece didn’t make sense but I could deal but Alex was just like “for goodness sake”
The amount of suspense we could've felt if we knew about her. Every time one of the girls is alone with Spencer, we could worry if it's Alex or not. We could worry that whatever Spencer says might ve Alex misleading them. Spencer could be like oh when did you guys figure out this, and they might be like,"You figured it out yesterday," eventually leading to her having a mental break. Finding out on the last episode when you know Alex will get her butt kicked isn't fun. Feeling suspense throughout the season would.
the MOST important thing about an A reveal has always been the BETRAYAL FACTOR and I wish Alex Drake could’ve been revealed as A sooner to the audience, but not the characters, to change up the algorithm. like we see two spencers and realize wait… what?? like WAY sooner, possibly even the end of 6A or B, so we sit on that until the next part came out like WHY TWO??? then we find out slowly as the characters do the details, already knowing there’s a twin they don’t know about. that would’ve been my pick.
spencer is my favorite liar n to be completely honest I would’ve loved it if she got killed off the way you pitched it. I’m mostly a horror fan so a shitload of my favorite characters are dead anyway (one of my favorite characters Of All Time is amanda young from the saw series. she dies 3 movies in (the original intended stopping point) n that death is my favorite scene throughout all 10 of them), which has given me the perspective of really valuing narratively compelling deaths that highlight the character n story’s themes a lot more than happy endings where everyone gets away safe. storytelling should be less so about giving everyone the endings they deserve n more about giving everyone the endings that make the most sense n are the most interesting, even if that ultimately means them dying in a really cruel manner
It would've been so much better if they went the book way and I'll never understand why they didn't with so many things. Alex, ezra, Allison and adding so many things that just didn't make sense like whyyy but I will still rewatch it lmao Plus being so obsessed with all the older men going for the teenage girls why did they do that
It would've been so good if, like, we think spencer is dead, but it's actually like an allison type situation where she's buried alive and she's been in hiding for years with the help of mary which is why mary tells the police about Alex to help spencer and the girls and when in hiding , spencer is keeping an eye on Alex so she doesn't hurt the girls at all exactly how alison was with the whole house fire with the girls and shanna etc like she's keeping track of Alex to make sure the girls are okay and when alex is chasing the girls through the forest with a gun and yk killed wren and is about to kill the girls , spencer comes out and knocks her unconscious and we see how long and how traumatized and exhausted she is
I always thought that A should have been Aria. But It would have been cool if Spencer’s twin was in Radley and heard the story of the girls from Mona (instead of Cece). Spencer didn’t know she had a twin but her parents and Melissa knew. It would have been cool if she was A since season 3 and throughout all of the seasons, some of the scenes we had of Spencer were actually Alex. When Ezra was doing his research, he found out about Alex. He doesn’t know she’s A though. I don’t know, that’s something I have thought of.
I wish they did a Courtney from the books type situation
I love this rewrite!! Another way that I came up with that would still keep Spencer alive is when her and Alex argue back in the dollhouse and Alex "kills" her it wouldn't actually be effective and she actually knocked spencer unconscious causing Alex to presume she killed Spencer. Then when the liars and Alex escape, Spencer would wake up and stumble out of the dollhouse then go into hiding to do more research on Alex leading to her finding out who Alex really is. This way we can keep Spencer alive but also see how she navigates life while being in hiding.
My reaction to this entire video is that Olivia Wilde's nodding clip. Like, yep this is finale we deserved! And honestly, I like the idea of them killing off Spencer. She's my ult favourite character and yes, it's dark af, but imagine how GAGGED the whole fandom would've been. It could've been the most shocking revelation of ANY teen drama and just as bold as Ned Stark's being decapitated.
people who make 30+ minutes videos are god warriors. I live alone and honestly, sometimes I put long videos on the background (like this one btw 🥺) just to hear another voice. Thank you for your content, PLL stuff in 2024 makes my heart really happy 💗
this is so cute omg 🥹🥹 appreciate you the most !!!
I absolutely adore video essays, they keep me such a good company while I workout
I actually love this! That ending scene you proposed about the camera spanning throught the empty Hastings house gave me actual CHILLS. I personally would have been so upsset if Spencer was dead the whole time so I do the the kidnapped version better but the version of the ending if Spencer did die is also so cool so I can't choose 😄 Also, a
I agree it would have been so much cooler if Alex took over Spencer life seasons earlier. It would also explain the weird Spaleb situation on S7 as well...😬
It's so fun because the other day I watched an old interview of troian during the last season of pll before the big reveal and of course she couldn't spoil the surpris and also had a completely different attitude towards the finale, but of course I get that and how she couldn't say that she didn't agree with the finale lmao. She gave me the same vibes of Emilia Clarke when they ask her if she's satisfied with the last season of game of thrones and she goes "mhh..yeah..."
i love this idea so much. if i could have rewritten anything it would’ve been changing season 4b and alison staying alive but staying away from rosewood. i think it would’ve been better if ravenswood would’ve been the story of alison after she went missing instead of the story with supernatural aspects and the power of five. she went back to grunwald after she met up with mona that night, instead of driving far away. we’d get to know what she was doing, hidden away in ravenswood, watching the girls be tormented by mona and then cece but not being able to do much at the risk of her own safety. the mid season mark of ravenswood would’ve actually taken place around grave new world, where ali still comes back the girls to let them know she’s alive, but she never fully returns to rosewood. she just comes back like she did before, in her red coat to save the girls when they were in trouble. that’s how the girls ultimately get saved from the dollhouse in this case also, by alison always keeping an eye on them and trying to keep up with A to protect them, grunwald is able to locate the dollhouse and her and alison get the girls out before anyone can see alison is indeed alive
I love your idea, and I think the version where the liar who's been replaced dies could go well with Emily's character, I've heard people saying they wouldn't mind it if Emily died at some point, but also I don't know if Shay could pull off a british twin as good as Trojan did
My idea for Alex:They should’ve killed off Spencer before the last season,Alex takes her place & everyone thinks that she is Spencer.
All the current longer videos that channels have started doing makes me so happy I can do my make up or like play the sims without having to switch videos or I can put it on 2x speed
the way i’m playing the sims rn 😭 i loveeeee the longer vids !!!
by the way you look specially gorgeous in this video!!!! AND THE 1989 VINYL??????? my bestie got taste!
OMG STOPPPP!!! REALLY??? THANK YOUUUU!!!!!! YESSS COUNTING DOWN TO MY ERAS SHOW!!!
You should do a video of ranking or just discussing all the 7 season finales of pll !!
I haven't watched the video yet, don''t have time for now, but I actually liked Alex as a villain. If only she had been introduced a little bit earlier - at least before the whole time jump thing, he story would have made more sense. She could have pretended to be Spencer as well, it's very on brand anyway. But we have what we have.
you look especially beautiful in this video ❤ i love this look on you!
This channel got recommended to me the other day and I’ve been binging your content since 😂 you have a new viewer I love it 💅 hello new bestie 💅 also the swapping of Alex with Spencer in the dollhouse is such a slay of an idea from u and would explain so much
oh my gosh hi bestie!!!!!
I love the way your mind works
my best subject in school was english/creative writing and i joined the library when i was 3…wonder where this creative view came from 😭🧍♀️
the way you described it so well i could imagine it in my head pls go back in time and rewrite it 🙏🏼
Lucy for president!!!!
so true i will take votes NOW
I love this so much. I really loved your Wren as A video and now this - Amazing!
Tysm for all the long-form PLL content you do! 💜
Couldn’t sleep so went to watch some TH-cam and this was uploaded ! Excited
enjoy!! hope you’re able to sleep well soon!!!
such a good video !! your pll videos sustain me
If only the writers put half the time you put into this video for the final season!
I was so upset with the AD reveal…I felt like I’d wasted so much time watching it like Mona was iconic, Cece didn’t make sense but I could deal but Alex was just like “for goodness sake”
yay new videooooo, gonna listen to it like a podcast, while I’m cooking dinner😌
omg 🥹🥹🥹 ENJOY THE FOOD!!!!!! (and the vid hehe)
@@LucyDudgeon23 THANK YOUU!!😚🤭
The amount of suspense we could've felt if we knew about her. Every time one of the girls is alone with Spencer, we could worry if it's Alex or not. We could worry that whatever Spencer says might ve Alex misleading them. Spencer could be like oh when did you guys figure out this, and they might be like,"You figured it out yesterday," eventually leading to her having a mental break.
Finding out on the last episode when you know Alex will get her butt kicked isn't fun. Feeling suspense throughout the season would.
Excited for this one ❤
enjoy!
the MOST important thing about an A reveal has always been the BETRAYAL FACTOR and I wish Alex Drake could’ve been revealed as A sooner to the audience, but not the characters, to change up the algorithm. like we see two spencers and realize wait… what?? like WAY sooner, possibly even the end of 6A or B, so we sit on that until the next part came out like WHY TWO??? then we find out slowly as the characters do the details, already knowing there’s a twin they don’t know about. that would’ve been my pick.
Great idea. Have you don any other re-write videos for the sow, suc s the dollhouse, maybe?
I just love you videos I’m currently rewatching pll and you’re videoed are just the best ❤
you should honestly write moviess !!
spencer is my favorite liar n to be completely honest I would’ve loved it if she got killed off the way you pitched it. I’m mostly a horror fan so a shitload of my favorite characters are dead anyway (one of my favorite characters Of All Time is amanda young from the saw series. she dies 3 movies in (the original intended stopping point) n that death is my favorite scene throughout all 10 of them), which has given me the perspective of really valuing narratively compelling deaths that highlight the character n story’s themes a lot more than happy endings where everyone gets away safe. storytelling should be less so about giving everyone the endings they deserve n more about giving everyone the endings that make the most sense n are the most interesting, even if that ultimately means them dying in a really cruel manner
It would've been so much better if they went the book way and I'll never understand why they didn't with so many things. Alex, ezra, Allison and adding so many things that just didn't make sense like whyyy but I will still rewatch it lmao
Plus being so obsessed with all the older men going for the teenage girls why did they do that
Yes ours basically match!!!🤫❤️❤️❤️
I’ll pretend this is what happened thanks I’m delulu🩷🩷🩷☺️