The world's ugliest music | Scott Rickard | TEDxMIA
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ต.ค. 2011
- SCOTT RICKARD
Scott Rickard has degrees in Mathematics, Computer Science, and Electrical Engineering from M.I.T. and MA and PhD degrees in Applied and Computational Mathematics from Princeton University. At University College Dublin, he founded the Complex & Adaptive Systems Laboratory, where biologists, geologists, mathematicians, computer scientists, social scientists and economists work on problems which matter to people. He is passionate about mathematics, music and educating the next generation of scientists and mathematicians.
TEDx
In the spirit of ideas worth spreading, TEDx is a program of local, self-organized events that bring people together to share a TED-like experience. At a TEDx event, TEDTalks video and live speakers combine to spark deep discussion and connection in a small group. These local, self-organized events are branded TEDx, where x = independently organized TED event. The TED Conference provides general guidance for the TEDx program, but individual TEDx events are self-organized.* (*Subject to certain rules and regulations) - เพลง
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 62 | คู่เอก "มงคลแก้ว vs อีที"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/q7QuSUtUN94/mqdefault.jpg)
This sounds like when I'm trying to sight read something.
+Kelvin Chau And even after sight reading, you still play like this, because you're playing "The Ping"
+Kelvin Chau me.
+Kelvin Chau Same
True.
+Kelvin Chau for me sight reading is like i do it perfectly than i just mess one rest or so than im like oh fuck were are we and i give up till we start again...
Nobody would even notice if he fucked it up halfway through.
LOL ikr
Joseph Smith they would, it would sound nice.
+Yeetesh Pulstya LOL
Also someone with absolute hearing and good memorie will. If one note is played twice he/she would hear this immediately (I wouldn't though 😜)
at 8:10 and other places i hear an octaves, but it does not necessarily convey any pattern at all.
The only way to 'err ' would be to create a pattern. However, the ear is a pattern-seeking organ and it will probably find a hidden design anyway. Mine, for example, imagines these pitches harmonized, thereby giving them pattern within tonality, and making them more significant, thereby more memorable.
Fun fact: If you listen to the song a hundred of times you'll finally appreciate it because you will hear the repetition of the entire piece itself
That's actually Stockholm Syndrome
@@ArthurAgamenon_ what ? how?
@@lightingstrike7285 I'm sorry bout this kind of music is for a small niche outside the social dogma
Lol..Have u ever listened to REVOLUTION #9 of The Beatles.??
@@hometv4166 ... which is based on the repeated occurence of "number 9"
"A song only a mathematician could write"
*Terrible noise plays*
Me: Hold my beer
Hans Sommer: hold my beer
Justin bieber: hold my baby juice
SCP-012: Hold me!
@@autobotCRSHR that IS a really good one
A song only a bad mathematician could write.
If he hit the wrong note no one would know but him
True, there's actually nothing written on his sheet!
Jack Cooper yes there is
Kind of like jazz...:)
Jaxon Starke No.
All in good fun Mr. McAllister
7:47 for people just here for the music.
Thanks mate
Thomaszeblob this makes me happy :)
thnx
thank you do much I love you
Thank you
“What key is it in?”
*ALL OF THEM*
Sight reading that will be very confusing
*Giant Steps flashbacks*
*Jazz sweating intensifies*
The pianists time keeping ability is incredible that he can play something totally lacking in rhythm and keep track of where each note should go. That's not easy.
the guy playing the piano looks pissed that he has to play such a horrific fucking peice and I can't stop laughig
Kade 1108 yea
I think he's concentrating very hard. Such a piece can't be easy to play. The predictability and rythmn of usual music pieces make them easier to play. But without any pattern to follow, you have to concentrate very hard to find the right keys and press them in just the right time.
I don't think he's pissed. I think that this would require intense concentration. This would be very difficult to play as it defies all musical convention.
trying to keep it in perfect time must be hell
Kade 1108 tbh I need to like the piece I'm playing or else it has no emotional and I look like a blobfish whilst playing it😂
You just think this is ugly because you've never heard me trying to play
You're not the only one.
Badgabr music starts at 7:48
Equiscend thx
Igor Marcos you are a saint
Same lolo
Could make for unsettling atmosphere in the right horror film.
Exactly
That's why I feel like this whole "Ugliest music" project was wrong from the beginning. Ugliness is as subjective as beauty is. For some, beauty in music is rooted in what he said (repetition of motifs) but for others, beauty simply resides in the satisfaction of a music that is fitting to a certain context. If this music was listened to in the right context, it could really be considered beautiful.
@@CosmicTeapot it could be the worst music in the world
@@CosmicTeapot nah art is not fully subjective , maybe with abstract art but not in storytelling , films , most music and video games (if you do count that as a art)
The Lighthouse comes to mind.
There are actually some parts of the composition that did make "melodic sense" to me...
There are intervals here and there that makes some harmony, for a brief moment.
Also, our ears (if you've grown up and lived your life exposed to western tonal music) are constantly looking for a key center, so when you finally hear something that has some harmony, you latch unto it.
Those intervals come in triplets, huh?
I give it 3 out of 12 mathematicians.
@ Have you ever heard somethin' uglier?
which part it's interesting to hear that
It was ok.
Yeah, I can see how they could get a copyright claim if they re-uploaded Jake Paul's music.
Frank Liao England is my village
Good one
Frank Liao Disney World is my uncle
*HILARIOUS AND ORIGINAL*
911 likes... Illuminati Confirmed
If it comes to playing ugly, I'm the master, and I ain't no mathematician.
SpartanFunnyProject you're not good at grammar also
Jaso Ander you don't have good grammar either*
"Ain't no mathematician"? So you are one? Interesting.
Well, so I ain't a mathematician? how do you say that? (I speak Spanish dude, give me a break).
SpartanFunnyProject To help avoid double negatives, I'd personally try not to use 'ain't' at all. Plus, it sounds more proper without it.
9:05 And of course, the obligatory cough during performance.
Thats the first thing i noticed bro
*claps inbetween movements*
Coughs during the rests so you dOn'T RuIn ThE MuSiC........
Underrated comment
what if the WHOLE time he didn’t even bother playing the right notes?
therelatablepianist You would have heard some repetition ...
To be fair, if you were to make a mistake, almost no one would be able to tell.
CubicLugion im hearing a pattern of mistakes here
CubicLugion unless it was a consonant interval
Yeah
@@Bronsteino
They didn't say consonant intervals weren't allowed tho. They just can't repeat notes, intervals, or rhythm structures
If it doesn't sound terrible you know he made a mistake.
y'all they wrote a music piece about me
omg same tho
Amanda the Panda stfu
hhhhhhhhhamiltonnnnn
ur username thooo yess
May I say, I Love Love Love your profile picture!!!
it sounds like what my back has felt since the quarantine started
My crush: Oh, a piano, play something beautiful for me.
Me: 8:45
music starts at 7:43
rlly he was talking for that long...
Kid why you copying my comment
Your the real mvp
+Δημητρης Μπεκιαρης No problem. It's my job.
I enjoyed his discussion about mathematics tbh
Without a pattern of some kind, even an expert piano player struggles to play this weird tune...
PlasmaMongoose it is true. we are minds of repetition and patterns, after all
Did you see him struggling? I didn't.
It's like my friends that screw around with my piano keys when they can't play, just evolved into hideous pranksters.
Xyluss Nelms Probably because he practised it a fuck-tonne because this piece is impossible to play. Do you think this was the first time he had played it?
TheNikolaki8 Well, I guess he just... repeated it enough times then ;)
9:16 - 9:21 there is twice a minor third (F# - A) once as third in the same register, then immediately after a decima interval of the same two notes.
Yonatan Ron I caught that one too! I hoped I wasn’t the only one.
please speak english XD
Preston Le it is English. Maybe go to the time stamps they put and see what they’re talking about.
@@benstephens34 I know im just not that experienced at music as u guys kinda can play piano but not good
@@pkl-yt what I believe they're trying to say, is that the first time at 9:16, the pianist plays notes that go up a minor third, which if you look at a staff, is one space or line apart with the higher note flatted. (Think G to Bb, or C to Eb) The specific minor third in question is F# to A, then it happens again immediately after, but at a higher interval, it's at a higher pitch, but the notes are the same space apart. You'll notice that they sound very similar, as they are both the same type of chord. Hope this helps!
This is highly structured sound. With regards to his justification for why this would be the world's "ugliest music", there are a lot of underlying assumptions here about how we perceive patterns, how we perceive sound, and how we perceive music that are not quite right. Among other things, we hear direction (up/down) as patterned, and the x3 structure creates quite a few directional patterns, particularly near the beginning of the piece. It's not a surprise that many of the commenters are hearing this as beautiful. The piano itself is sonorous, and the pedaling and dynamic choices of the player bring out musical lines and harmonic elements.
You can see the clear pain in the pianist's face.
That's the face a person makes when they hate their job but are waiting to quit until their last pay day to submit their resignation.
You can also tell that he's trying to articulate the notes, but it's difficult to articulte without proper phrasing. Poor guy, that'd kill my head.
Compromising art, again, for the sake of the masses (or maths).
The longest most convoluted preface to a drunk guy banging piano keys.
Best comment ever
+thewu1313 Well no, a drunk guy banging piano keys would still have some sort of "pattern" mechanism in the subconscious, he might come back to the same key over and over, or he might just be banging right, left, right, left and that's some kind of repetition in the "random" drunk banging. The talk is specifically about how randomness can NEVER produce this kind of music.
+Sa kak well aren't you fun at parties?
+Sa kak weeeeellll actually....randomness would guarantee that this arrangement would occur once
+VerticalHorizon9 Actually I have board game and discussion evenings. So yes?
"First Pattern-Free sonata"
Sonata form inherently involves repetition.
I think "free sonata" in itself means free of repetition.
THANK YOU.
Look up Boulez' 2nd Piano Sonata, 'cause it inherently tries to destroy any semblance of "sonata form;" p cool tbh
The thing is, once you get into atonal music, the thing that most people notice are pitch relations and octave relations.
There are certain patterns repeated, especially in the beginning, where those relationships hold true and are more important than actual pitch. The piece has a sort of pattern where this is true.
They should have taking into account music theory
The highlight of this mans career.
Playing non sense while hundreds watch.
lol but it's very carefully constructed nonsense.
Surely not the highlight of his career, just another gig, but hopefully a decent-paying one.
He is literally a member of the new world symphony
Starzoid Starzoid dang, are you his best friend or did you do some heavy research on him???
The guy speaking literally says this right before he plays the piece... Guess you weren't listening...
Sims 3 piano level 1
So true.
pytox
Ahaha 😂. Great example.
pytox I
pytox lol it does really feel and sound like it
hahahahaha
Kid at store: “Mom I want to get Beethoven!”
Mom: “We have Beethoven at home”
Beethoven at home:
Don't diss Beethoven like that!!!
Damn that's rough 😂
@•{MOMREDO 555}• It is I
@@davisatdavis1 Beethoven has a lot of sfs in his pieces though
8:52 start of The Godfather theme
why down there sir you deserve mvp
if my life was a song it would be this one
Perfectly repetition-free? I'd like that life...
better than doing the same depressing shit every day
Ireth Vespie hahaha
Bradly Fray breathing, heartbeats, etc are repetition. a repetition fre life couldnt last for more than one breath or heartbeat or any other repeating bodily function
IT IS a song. By Billy Joel. Pretty cool too.
The actual music starts at 7:47 btw
Blue Oak ayyyyyy phandom
Blue Oak Of course it started just as I scrolled down to this comment
had I seen this earlier...
"music" ;-)
Blue Oak thanks
I mean, you could do uglier. That piece is still subject to the timbre of the piano and the relationships of 12 tone equal temperament.
Could always try microtonality.
This. Also they only cared about the distance (at the piano) between an Note X at music score and an note X+1 at music score always being different. They didnt cared about the distance between note X and note X+2 being different and X+3........
As some example a song that start with those piano keys in order 9|3|7|5|....., the distance between 9 and 3 is 6 notes, the distance between 3 and 7 is 4 notes, the distance between 7 and 5 is 2 notes. But, the distance between 9 and 7 is two notes apart, the same distance between 3 and 5. So when you compare an note N (as some example the note 9) with a note at position N +2 at music score (at this case is note 7), you can have situations where the distance between the note N and note N +2 at other areas of music sheet are the same.
I actually did manage to locate a bit of repetition. At 9:16, you will hear a minor 3rd interval (Gb to A, if I'm not mistaken). Immediately following that you will hear a Gb in the higher octave followed by the A located a minor 10th above it. Not technically repetition in the strictest sense, but (musically) the effect is that you hear the same Gb to A minor 3rd interval twice in a row.
My mum always complains that my original composed music pieces have too many repetitions, so I have just given her this video to watch. She is now nothing to say.
r/ThatHappened
Whenever I try to compose something even just a simple melody it turns out to be so repeatative.
I’m the inverse for whatever reason, I can keep a running melody going for very long without shifting
Yeah true but maybe she wants u to extend for more and try to do something different bcuz other ppl who don’t study music look at music differently from actual musicians/artist.
*AND NOW I'VE FOUND MY NEW RINGTONE!!!*
David Hickling i was thinking the same thing
8:44 it looks like his shadow is sitting next to him
This is a horrible name for a wonderful talk.
Working on the internet, I refused to click on this till I was compelled by my friend, and am SO happy I did.
me trying to find the right note
relatable, only been playing 5 or 6 months
Same but I've been playing for like 3-4 year's a ND I still can't find the right note
@@jessicawang8303 TRUE
I laughed😂 but yeah I can relate.
And I’ve been playing the piano for 7 years...doing some advanced Beethoven stuff rn..ya think finding a note is hard
The guy in the piano be like " I don't get paid enough for this shit "
Ariana Garcia How did he get inside the Piano?😲
Ariana Garcia lol
😂
@@unicockboy1666 he himself probably didn't.
LOL!!
its actually kind of cool sounds like it could be played in a horror film
Honestly, i kinda like it. It feels like there's something chaotic, anxious yet at the same time feels peaceful and orderly. And there's this sense of twistedness, darkness and beauty to it. And the sudden abruptness of the last note before stopping feels like how death is.
Think the same!
100% agreed. It doesn't sound bad to me. In fact I think it sounds fairly good!
It gives me dark, eerie forest at night in a heavy mist/drizzle vibes
Grade A horror/ psychological thriller music
Because you're delusional and religious
Could be worse.
I could do worse.
Katime same though
Katime i would put this song in a horror game or film, i guarantee that this would be a perfect match for it
As I said at one comment, looks like this one just cares about the distance between the notes N and N+1 at the piano (with N being note currently playing and N+1 being the next note you will play) being always different. To make this even uglier, he could also care about the distance between N and N+2 being always different, also N and N+3, N and N+4 and this goes on.
spaceman00 I have no clue wtf you just said and I'm too lazy to figure it out 😂
AstroKittyKiki Yasss I think he's trying to say that the piece could not allow patterns like (taking all notes as numbers) 1,3,2,6,3 as there is a repeated pattern in that both the 1st and 3rd notes and the 3rd and 5th notes have a relation of going up by 1, and the difference between them is the same (3-1=5-3). Similarly, 1,4,3,7,2,9 would also be not allowed because it goes up by 2 between both the 1st and 3rd notes and the 4th and 6th
Normal ppl: Wow, that's just noise
Producers: I can sample that shit!
I might sample it. :P
For real.
sampling a piano... dope af bro
aren't producers normal people then?
Sample that shit and add an 808 bass with shitty lyrics about women with big bums - Trap music 2k16
Wtf, this is literally what I did on the piano as a kid
Captivating. Simply enjoying the sounds of a grand piano, waiting for the one or two high notes - contrasting with the low notes - gave it dynamic that made it exciting.
Still better than a band that isn't in tune
Blaze Nelson It Would Be Even Uglier If All The Notes Were The Same Length (Especially Excluding Ties)
Edit: I Just Changed My Profile Pic. So It Took Me A Few Seconds To Realize This Comment Is Mine
riight
Charlotte Kim but the sun is eclipsed by the moon
Charlotte Kim 😂
_ DonutMaster56 _ Why Is Everything Capped
Pianist : *Playing*
Pianist : *Finished Playing*
Audiences : *Clap Clap Clap*
Pianist : *Smile*
Pianist : *I didn't even read the music LOL*
he missed a note tsk tsk
So funny 😂😂😂😂
9:16 - 9:21 included a split minor chord, so there is harmony even in the ugliest music! 😇
👍I couldn't name it but I felt the beauty of that part. It was like "Wait a minute! That was nice!"
Every jazz musician: WTF he's talking about ?
I thought they were gonna play sweatshirt by Jacob sartorious
omg that's perfect 😂😂
+Mitchell Slaughter why the derogatory statement? we all know jacobs music is epitome of crap and his fanbase is shit infested
darude - sandstorm
Natalie Moreno same here
Natalie Moreno fuck you jacob is a god
Jacob Sartorious can do worse.
Paul Leal this was ugliest music BEFORE he was a thing
I know it's a joke, but for real his songs can be sung better by someone else so the SONGS aren't worse than the piece shown in this video. Only the singer is terrible (jacob)
Asto Done triggered much??
Paul Leal sir, u are a fucking legend of this comment section
Paul Leal yòoooooooòoooooooooòoooooooooooooooooooooo
Bravo.... so much research and thought must have gone into this presentation. Enjoyed the authors clarity on the topic. Cheers
"In the future, music will be randomly generated" -Mozart, Johannes Chrysostomus Wolfgangus Theophilus, 1791, deathbed quote
Where did you find that quote?
@@valayagaudet7182 He did not say it actually; instead, this is a reference to an episode of VeggieTales which features a future where humour is "randomly generated".
@@danielchan1668 OK, thank you for the clarification. I must have sounded really gullible!
My cat seems to quite enjoy it.
is your cat's name Justin Bieber?
Myo Pyae Sone HAHAHAHA
No its lady gaga....you're such an imbecile.
Michael Payne I just showed it to my cat and he fell asleep to it
Oh wow
I've heard worse.
Jacob Sartorius?
Tony Nejlepši Who ?
search him up on youtube
Tony Nejlepši Hu. Well that sucks, big time. Although, it's kinda funny to see that a 14 year old kid is litterally making music of the same quality as most of the pop-crap going on the radio. Auto-tune does make everything sound the same ...
True, people these days unfortunately don't what kind of beautiful music there is out there. Thank you, modern music producers
finally,an alarm that will wake me up
I am both a music lover and a maths lover. I didn't know what to say when I was hearing the music... And now, three letters come out of my mind. That's O-M-G.
Man, when dat beat dropped I was like "whoa!".
Ikr? It lined perfectly with the build-up.
The bassline really got it well with the drumpattern. And the smooth beat!
i cant find it. where?
random music with random rhythms must be a pain in the ass to read
O'HALLORAN Might be why he looked so displeased
Yeah that prob be why he be mad
its not random its pattern-free
randomness still has patterns
There is no need to follow the musical score. Who could tell if you played a note wrong? I could sit there and play it with my feet and still get applause.
lol
3 years of Contemporary Music Festivals at Indiana state university, the oldest, and I love this piece. That it's also useful makes it terrific.
jokes on you i actually liked it
me too
+0 Subscribers I know cuz your mom wants
Same
+McCaptainBlaze just because you liked it doesn't make it 'good' lol
+Madison Healey Yes it does. "Good" is in the ear of the listener, not in the music theory or composer history books. :-)
Me: Yo pass the aux cord
Friend: You better not play trash
Me:
*whips*
Chris Patel 😂😂😂
did someone call me
Cupcake Pooper lol❤
lol❤
Proof that you can play as bad as you want and still get applause... all you need is the right introduction
sounds like two cats fighting on the piano in slomo
Imagine this music playing in an alien world and the aliens there would be jamming to it
Haha
just like dubstep to us
what's wrong with dubstep?
J3LLYF1SH nothing bro
Its a pretty amazing genre tbh
I am particularly a huge dubstep fan
That wasn't too bad. Possibly less stressful than randomness, since randomness constantly begins to set up patterns then doesn't follow through.
Humans have trouble creating true randomness, we end up making everything less random but trying to make it "seem" random if you follow that. There would be more patterns, yet still what you're saying is relatively correct, but true randomness would look less random than anything human generated. You're correct, this is more informal than critical, kind of... random.
That's one weird paragraph...
Basically, your perception of randomness is something like 1748452648091373759 - a number with a lot of different digits, no immediate repetition, and no clear pattern. Real randomness looks like this:
1195712432266473
Note that some numbers are 'clumped'. When you shuffle a pack of cards, if you draw three consecutive cards in a row, you might say it was shuffled badly. However, that sequence of cards is just as random as, say, Aclubs 7hearts 3spades. You recognise patterns as not ever occurring randomly, but they happen surprisingly often.
Randomness it's the enemy no. 1 in the creation
That might just drive me over the edge, I get stressed just thinking about it.
I made it 666 likes. You’re welcome.
A relative lack of repetition can be incredibly powerful when it is done right;
for example, the track "Forest Temple" in the video game "The Legend Of Zelda: Ocarina Of Time" deliberately avoids exact repetitions of several parts, and this creates a haunting and unpredictable atmosphere.
I find it an interesting exercise to try to meditate to this. I need to find a long version of this. Although I fear that, mathematically, the longer the song is, the harder it'll be to calculate. Who has the link to the 10-hour version?
There aren't enough notes on western scales to make a 10 hour version. Not audible ones, anyways.
7:49 is when they play it.
Nicholas Bloxxer doing God's work
MVP
Nicholas Bloxxer thank you extremely much
0:00 Is when the video starts.
Nicholas Bloxxer
Thank you xD
me- hey i wrote a piano piece!
Person- oh cool what key is it in?
Me- yes
Chromatic.
Potato Gaming that's more a scale than a key
My music is not bound to your primitive "keys"
Actually, its in "No"
who cares what it's in...😂😂😂
6:20 The captions are wrong there, the comment about Schoenberg was not that he wanted to free music from "total" structure but that he wanted to free it from "TONAL" structure, which is the musical structure of having a relationship of tonality between notes (a tonic, a dominant, sub-dominant, etc.) He wanted each note to be as important as the others, without tonal anchors.
after all these years, I've finally come back to what I think was the first TedTalk I've ever seen.
i love whistling this song on the way to work
I can understand why - it's so catchy.
isn't it funny how he tried to play it with passion? ROFL I died!
Why is that funny?
+Badatstuff because it's "The world's ugliest music" and he plays it passionately. Not that it's a bad thing, but it's just funny.
+FesliyanStudios I thought it was funny too - I wondered if anyone else would even notice...
+Erick Briceño Chávez Haha maybe, but I think he was trying to perform. Either way, super funny to me :)
+FesliyanStudios It's still technically a musical piece so most professional musicians would respect it and the composer by playing at as perfectly as possible. But yeah it's entertaining lol.
lmao “Thank you” is not what I’d say after subjecting an audience to this. I think an apology is more appropriate
7:47 for my future reference. I keep coming back to this video for some reason! Must be bec of pianist's dedicated expression.
Well... I wasn't disappointed in how disappointed I was.
I was disappointed by my disappointment
+Tamar Mack TØP!! :D
Allsmiles29 CP |-/
+Tamar Mack |-/
I am glad you didn't like it
Don't you just wake up in the morning then say to yourself
"I'm going to make the ugliest music"
Every morning... It's the first and last thought on my mind.
(turns out the actual reverse is true but close enough)
Yeah, and I don't even play the piano, so it's especially wierd.
I bet that's what Taylor Swift does as part of her morning routine.
. YEET
**procedes to play her violin and fail miserably**
I could hear repetition in the high notes. Repetition is more than copying of exact notes. There is repetition in other ways. A few notes reminded me of some memories of minute moments of Beatle songs.
This is what the piano would sound like if it was having a stroke
When I read the title I thought Lil Wayne was going to come out and rap
rza
Afro samurai I was thinking 2 chainz
HAHAHAHAHAHHAHAAAHAHAHAAHA
Dayum! 32 likes already on my original post, So many Lil Wayne fans on here LOL
I thought it would be Black Veil Brides.
When a sim is trying to learn the piano skill
He was actually just trying to chase Jerry who was running around inside the piano.
Realmente es muy frustrante, no logras encontrar nada de relación entre sus notas. Un experimento muy bien logrado
Would fit amazingly in a n psycho horror movie, sounds nice
I was thinking the same thing.
lol isn't it crazy how this piece is the most random shit ever yet we can still find something to attribute it to? xD
dezzick398 it's not random, that's the point of the video.
stephane Boeltjes he is talking about the composition
+dezzick398
Well, I mean it is kinda scary if you think about it...
Music, something highly emotional, is turned into something coldly calculated. I feel like this would be a pretty smart choice for a musical leitmotiv of a psychopath who kills for opportunistic reasons and has no mercy.
Plus, the thing sounds pretty disturbing...
Honestly, the lack of repetition doesn't make it ugly.
Sure, it creates an off-kilter feel as your brain tries to grab onto a pattern that isn't there, but that just gives it a creepy, haunting vibe that would fit in with a horror movie.
+Just A Dude It's not BAD. It's sounds awful. I find myself a very sensitive person so if you'd ask my opinion about that music I'd say It would gave me a headache. And it really did. It's almost as awful as water dropping in the kitchen in the middle of the night. I hate all those sounds that things make because people somehow can't create unrepeted stuff.
Two days ago I was in pain almost the whole day so he said right: this music feels literally like pain. It hits you, it goes up and gown and makes you lose control over your feelings, and your brain is like wtf and you try to find a pattern (I do this when i'm in pain) and you can't and it annoys you so freaking much you can't bear it anymore. That's how I felt.
+Дарья Минеева Exactly. This music is too smart for human brain to bare, and that is why it sounds horrible. As he said, it could be made only by mathematics so if you are not mathematician and even if you are you cant propably understand it.
True, interesting point I guess that's what makes this kind of music suitable for horrors. Unknown, no order or sense... No logic. Like how we find the dark creepy, we can't get our bearings
Yeah, if i'll make a film about traveling in the hell, that will be a pretty good choice of background music.
+韩光 Try Megadeth Into the lungs of hell, Slayer South of heaven or Dream Theater In the presence of enemies, if you want good music for hell soundtrack
I think the major problem with this is the octave repetitions that happen every once in a while; the octaves sound the same and therefore there is some repetition that the pure numbers cannot solve.
8:35 - You can see the ghost of John Cage. He’s into it.
You, madam, had me dying of laughter
This sounds exactly like when I was a kid and use to just hit random keys on my grandmother's piano. I thought it was majestic xD
i did the exact same thing... and my little cousin does the same thing and says it sounds good.
So, it sounds exactly not like you hitting random keys...
This music is the opposite of random
Good pibts
I mean points
Everyone did my dude 😂😂😂
Thanks a bunch, now I'll be humming this all day.
Haha, best comment I've read in a bit. :)
That would be amazing to watch
Yes, it's very catchy
Tommy Jackman
Seinfeld reference: "Master of the house...🎶"
😆😆
Fascinating talk! Thank you!
I couldn't play the piano, but that's sounds like the sort of thing i would play when i'm alone with a piano when i was younger.
Music still better than the constant squeaking and shifting of the mic.
Where does it squeak?
Im glad someone else here noticed that nightmare.
I'm sorry. A piano will always sound beautiful to me. This only sounds like a confused piano.
lmao i love ur comment
Ali Conradie okay this has to be the best comment I ever read . *Tips hat*
Like.. A piano that fell down the stairs and broke it's strings.
Aren't we all confused pianos in the great scheme of things?
Imagine having a confused piano as a best friend.
This is a genre of music we like to call *JAZZ*
Jazz ROASTED! 😂
You seem to never have heard Jazz.
ya like jazz??????
_Jazz music stops_
It sounds nothing like Jazz. What it sounds like is a three year old thumping the keys.
Sounds like my neighbour's wind chimes while I'm trying to work from home.
there you go 7:47
i
thank you!
Thank you, good sir!
i wish i saw this comment sooner 👌
mynameis bob THANK YOU