J Sai Deepak Explains the Value of Sound & Oral Tradition in India | Buddhi
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ส.ค. 2024
- In this J Sai Deepak Latest explains the strength of the living oral tradition and the importance and the power behind sound in India. He also talks about feminism in India.
More videos from J Sai Deepak: • J Sai Deepak
#Buddhi #JSaiDeepak #Bharat
Follow Us on Social Media Channels:
Twitter: / buddhimedia
Instagram: / buddhimedia
Facebook: / buddhimedia
----------------------------------------------------------------
Disclaimer:
All the videos, songs, images, and graphics used in the video belong to their respective owners and I or this channel does not claim any right over them.
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.”
![ว้าว!ลุงบีมแบกทองมารับขวัญหลานกันยกบ้าน [cc] แดนแพทตี้ SS2 | EP.49 |](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Osihq1OAs-4/mqdefault.jpg)
Buy the book: "India that is Bharat" by J Sai Deepak: amzn.to/3FDFZHN
Im a Indian (Bharat) Malaysian. I bought his book in Nov 2021. Great insights, Deepak!
The moment i see J sai deepak I arrive. He is one of the greatest thinker of this generation
AGREE
Agreed
Mind blowing! I'm a 52 year old Armed Forces veteran. I guess Deepak is much younger than me. But evertime I listen to this guy I just wonder. It's like reincarnation of the young Adi Shankaracharya, who defeated the famous Mandan Mishra in debate.
I am in awe of this young man!
Indian civilisation is in dire need of intellectuals like Adv. Deepak who are pointing out the underlying principles behind practices and traditions of our culture. Marxist, liberal, (post)modern narratives have been thrashing our indigenous culture since independence (after centuries of foreign rule) and there has been lack of well articulated arguments, presentation of hard facts which, quite fortunately, can be seen coming to light in recent times, with the effort of thinkers like him.
Instead of protecting our scriptures from the left and the post modernist idiots, we should use it. Lokayata should be our Marxist defence. Vedanta should be our post modernist defence. We need to read them. Learn संस्कृतम् and start reading the 4 million manuscripts that dwarf the 40,000-100,000 Latin and Greek manuscripts.
I feel like crying when I see this latest generation of hindus. They are totally colonized.
The latest generation will burn the left. *The confidence only increases with time.* And this time we have a political unit that is Bharat and the ability to understand who we are dealing with. _Let's show them who they're f ing with._
That right...I feel the same
@@naiyayika don’t get overconfident. People have better thing to do with their lives and than protecting the oral traditions of the 5% of people
@@chandlerminh6230 who are those 5%
@@ganjaya97 He's Dravidian. You get who he's talking about.
It should reach lakhs of hindus. J Sai Deepak has a unique diction while presenting the facts.
He is already reaching lakhs. Kindly check viewership of his videos. He should reach 10s of crores now
Really admire JSD Ji. Each time I listen to JSD, a new thing I would get about our Culture.. Pramans..
Nobody else can convey a extremely important message with such ease & conviction ! Pranam's to JSD !
Goosebumps.. Every time I hear to JSD, one thing I am assured of.
Swami Vivekanand had once quoted, "Give me 100 men and I shall change the world".
If JSD was available then, i think the number would definitely have been lesser.
JSD: I feel blessed to hear you Sir. Thank you.
Goosebumps is the right word
I feel like Swamy Vivekananda was also like this.. so whoever listen to him became his Disciples at that times.. Really mesmerizing speeches JSD
It's recognised by UNESCO. That's why the ontology in the scriptures have survived into the modern age. Now, universalise the knowledge and we will soon have a different perspective altogether. Please, make Brahmin the universal identity. 🙏🙏🙏
Can we please let's just say
MAKE HINDUISM UNIVERSAL IDENTITY
can we please let's just say
MAKE BHARATHIYATHA UNIVERSAL IDENTITY....????
In every episode..... Mr. Sai Deepak.... Is trying hard to explain... to make us understand... to let go of this BRAMHANA, KSHATRIYA, VAISHYA, KSHUDRA.... IDENTITY .....BUT TO STAND UNITED AS ONE ..... ONE NATION....
ONE BHARATH.....
LET'S COME TOGETHER TO BE AS ONE
@@bhagyalakshmipoojam3047 universal. I admire JSD, but I just quoted Swami Vivekananda. And both are in two different leagues.
You can’t make universal something that was the monopoly of just 5% of the population.
Brahmins never had to work all day in the field to get a handful of grains. They had all the time and resource in the world to recite and teach the Vedas. The rest of the society had to do manual labour.
@@chandlerminh6230 recite and teach vedas ...again ...only to the bramhan community... no other community was even allowed to recite ....forget about teaching or learning....even gayathri manthra... we were told that no one else other than brahmin should recite or it would be a shraaap..
@@bhagyalakshmipoojam3047 It is the Vedic texts themselves which describe such rules and regulations. Vedic mantras are not to be dealt with negligence they hold immeasurable potential and a person who is not able to follow the restrictions and purity like Brahmins could follow in the earlier times was advised to stay away from them for his own sake. Wrong pronunciations, impurity, malafide intention etc. could lead to outcomes which run contrary to those which were expected
Hearing J Sai Deepak means increasing our knowledge every time he comes with new things.
I wonder what if the UPSC cse board members come across this guy in the interview session!🔥
he is simply a legend. no words to express my happiness in seeing him
Amazing intepretition. Far beyond the intellectual capacity of so called educated wokes & liberals.
May the force be with him... one of finest brains of modern times..
Yes sai deepak ji.we.hindus in North too had pardah system was passed by my parents and their parents due to these.mughal raj, and due to these outsiders,when will our people hindus know all these reasons and.our marriages rituals hv transformed soo.much we are ashamed that all this had to take over cos.of these outsider atrocities wish I could join yr legal.panel.in helping our culture as I m too a law passed from.bombay law college,but unfortunately couldn't do for our society, we were hand to mouth earning,being North Indian refugees from punjab had to live in crawls in maharashtra,all male heads were slaughterd in our partition time couldn't gain stand in our country to hv better life we in search of jobs here in uae but really miss our roots divine blessings is on u that u are the chosen one pray the divine lightens your path .and u be successful in this tedious path may u be joined by our youth
I am a proud Hindu
Oral tradition...written books....superb ideologies... i like me and our future generations to be english speaking sanatani
Simply Awestruck at this speech.Whoa Sir Take a Bow👐
OMGOD sai deepak. Thankyou for articulating THIS PARTICULAR THREAD OF THOUGHT.
The whole lndia must listen and understand sai. He is one of the most influential person in recent years
Wonderful! Fantastic way of thinking and exposing.
One of the best things in my life is accidentally coming across a video of Sai sir
He touched hearts when he talked of the parda system
Amazing gentleman,J Sai Deepak.Blessings
Wonderful presentation of our tradition and culture 👍
👏👏👏
🙏🙏🙏
We support sai Deepak jai ho India Jai ho 🙏
While Sri Sai Deepak’s compelling argument on ‘Trust’ being the reason for oral tradition, I think we had written documents as well at Nalanda and Takshashila which were lost.
Also, we as a civilisation were not naive is how one feels. Some times even ‘Distrust’ made the scholars not to document as knowledge could have been stolen
Most Beautiful and Brilliant presentation, bringing out to us most Profound truths about the Power of Oral chanting . !!
I say it again and again J Sai Deepak is the revolution. Then it was Savarkar, now it is Sai Deepak , ofcourse savarkar although was an athiest, the objective is the same, to save the civilization of Bharat.
This is gold.
Greatest thinker of our generation.
At 350 am i m seeing ur speech sir i can only say awesome
SAI... needs to be nominated to
RAJYA SABHA ..and made the LAW MINISTER.
Amazing clarity on different issues facing the nation, culture, dharma and heritage.
Young generation must learn from Shri J Sai Deepak.
Finally someone said it🙏
Sai Deepak is an modern Vivekananda 🙏
❤️🙏
Really a great speech.
WOW !! So much in this short clip.
Nice speech 👏🔥🙏❤️💯🕉️👏👏
Hats off to u deepak sir ..god bless
JSD JSD !!🙏🙏❤️🇮🇳
From 4:00 apt 👌
I think this is the reason why my teachers and professors always said....." Patients never lie of their problems"......that's most often true.....,
But due to exposure to other culture ( as u specified)....patients don't trust doctors and vice-versa also is true
Anna, doing great work 🙏
Excellent as usual
U r amazing sir. So so intellectual
To the point 👌
1.45 - 1.55 incredible
First thing everybody should understand that Sanatana Dharma is not a religion it is natural way of living.. Each and every living being in this universe is Sanathani by default Including human irrespective of forcefully implanted belief system by immeture foreign Idilologies. Foreign Idilologies divides Human society into Belivers and Non-believers and have target of Converting Non-believers either by terrorism or by giving some materialistic temptations by encashing difficult situations in life for conversion. Those foreign ideologies promotes narrow minded belief system based on single book single messenger..
Whereas for Sanatana Dharma there is no need of conversion because each and every human being by birth is a sanathani... As per Sanatana Dharma no one is outsider as sanatani we see God in each and every autom of this universe.. We can create our own Ista Deva (Favourite God) there is no restrictions on dress code there is no compulsion to pray... It will never restrict thinking power of human...
As per Sanatan Dharma eachi and every living being or material on this earth has its own special characteristic which is called Dharma for example bird has the power of flying, tiger will hunt, fishes having ability to swim, human being having ability to think, deer can run faster..... Etc This Dharma helps respective creatures to survive in the nature... Each and every living being which comes to the earth should die one day (jatasya maranam dhruvam)...
As per the Karma (action) each and every creature will get Karma phala (results)... So here we can see that Sanatana Dharma is natural way of living it is not a religion based on narrow minded belief system
If one has to recall, in those days kids used to recite along with their teachers, thereby making it easy to remember. The vendors in villages would not have stepped into a school, but can calculate much faster than the current generation kids. Oral education did have it's benefit. Thank you for carrying out such a Herculean task of spreading awareness👏👏.
Brilliant articulation of our great value system 🙏
Current day's Adi Shankarachara. 🙏🌄
♥
Salute to you J Sai Deepak 🙂✌🙂🙂
I can not skip any of your video
Really great
With regards 🙏
👍🏻
🙏
Great Video Sir :)
♥️♥️♥️♥️
Where is the full video of this, it's informative I want to spread this awareness to our ignorant brothers
he always wins my concious
Where can I find the full video ?
Can you please share the full video link
I want this clarity of mind... What should i do?
NoFap. For years. You will get even more clarity
👍
Full talk?
Where can I hear the full talk?
Child marriages were an effective way to make children mentally ready and responsible of a foreknown life partner and avoid kids from trying to replace the partners' position with a new person during the years to come. The child marriage here is not equivalent to Mohammad marrying 9 year old Aisha, it is literally marriage or promise b/w children.
I don't deny that very older men were married to young girls or vice versa here throughout history in the name of ritual but it is true that none of these practices are supported by the philosophies in Sanatana Dharma.
And what about ours is a written Constitution whereas british have unwritten?
What is Hyderabadi Tamilian?
Either you can be a Hyderabadi or Tamilian...after all these years of 3 generations still you have a problem with Hyderabad.
Your identity crisis is like 'Indian Tamilan'.
He is Andhra guy🤣🤣
Oral contract is not worth the paper it is written on, said one Hollywood Mogul 🙄
Thank you= ANDHRA/KERALA/WBANGAL/RAJASTHA/MAHARASHTRA need to come to their SANATINI roots
What is the authencity of oral tradition. ??
What is the source of it
His book has 24 reviews on Flipkart and 1000 reviews on Amazon. You fools are not even really buying his book instead simply reviewing it with 5 stars with out buying because Amazon allow to do so. (flipkart don’t allow to rate without purchasing)
Why are humans not naturally evil?
A Rich man can be a Prime Minister, Was proven by Jawaharlal Nehru
A Honest Poor man can be Prime Minister, Was proven by Lal Bahadur Shastri
An Old man can be Prime Minister, Was proven by Morarji Desai
A LADY can be Prime Minister, Was proven by Indira Gandhi
An Illeterate man can be Prime Minister, Was proven by Chaudhary Charan Singh
A Pilot can be Prime Minister, Was proven by Rajiv Gandhi
A Man from Royal family can be Prime Minister, Was proven by V P Singh
A Scholar can be Prime Minister, Was proven by P V Narasimha Rao
Any man can be Prime Minister, Was proven by H D Deva Gowda
A DIPLOMAT can be Prime Minister, Was proven by the I.K GUJRAL
A Humble Poet can be Prime Minister, Was proven by Atal Behari Vajpayee
A Wise person n a Tea seller can be Prime Minister, Was proven by Narendra Modi
A Prime Minister is Not at all required, Was proven by Manmohan Singh
The country can be ruled without being a Prime Minister,
Was proven by Sonia Gandhi..
** THIS is an TRUE ANALYSIS !! **
Lol... This is exactly what you say when you don't have any written history...'we put faith in honour codes" are you kidding me? How do ppl fall for this
Every sentence has a hidden lie, which is covered with fluent English words , bhakt ko aur jyada pagal banaye. Parda is an inherent part of Hinduism. What about Rajasthan? Waha koyi nizam nahi.no feminist movement in India because it was not required only ,what a logic?😂😂😂 It was not there because read manusmriti about how to deal with women will get to know.
This person is a total windbag. He has only mastered the art of rhetoric and it won't take much effort to deconstruct his arguments and shred them to pieces in a single stroke. He sounds like an updated version of Sambit Patra
LMAO. You hate the resurgence and it's context. So, you use an analogy to say it's just rhetoric. He's not repeating anything he conveys in each sentence. He's an intellectual. You have good point to rebut? Or is it just rhetoric or opinion.
@@naiyayika I did not use any analogy neither did I say he has repeated anything, you need to look up for the meaning of "rhetoric" on Google. And when a person while commenting takes the help of "Lol" or "lmao" in the beginning or the ending of his comments then all it does is that it conveys that this person hasn't really got anything substantial up his sleeves and is simply messing around to waste his worthless time on TH-cam (as is the case with most of the Hindu trollers nowadays). But since you asked me whether I have got an argument to counter anything that this ignoble "intellectual" has said then let me take into consideration his blatant allegation against a certain Muslim ruler from the past ruling the part of India where this "intellectual" happens to come from. He says that Hindu women used to do purdah there just because this ruler and his entourage was in the habit of picking up any woman they liked from the street in order to have their way with her. This fairly tale sounds so funny and childish, first of all, if a ruler is able to wield so much power upon his subjects that he can randomly pick up any woman from the street with the aim of satiating his sensual desires then it would be even more easy for him or his entourage to impose such a ban upon these women that they aren't allowed to do purdah with objective of hiding their beauty from him (as had been the case in certain parts of India where upper caste used to ban women from the lower caste from wearing anything above the waist and used to ogle at those women when out on the streets). And this pseudo intellectual of yours has used this fairy tale as a reason for the practice of purdah system amongst the Hindu women in that particular part of the country (an attempt to appease and apologize to the West of course). Now I am asking if this ruler was only present in a certain part of the country for a certain period of time, then how does his "alleged" perversity explain the fact that almost all Hindu women from almost all parts of India used to abide by the purdah system? I guess this alone is enough to prove that this guy is another shameless individual, participating in peddling lies against my religion and my people in order to reinforce the hatred that has already reached dangerous proportions. He is not an "intellectual" in any sense of the word, he is just an updated version of Sambit Patra and just like him he is most certainly going to end up humiliating himself nationwide. Also, I honestly tried to search about this particular Nizami Ruler but all I could come accross was this
www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.com/news/magazine-24159594.amp
Yet another instance of so called "tolerant" religion's real face, an uninhibited shamelessness in resorting to violence and butchery to steal a piece of land, a carbon copy of what happened recently in Delhi where police personnel participated in the butchery and arson with "tolerant" religion goons. And trust me it won't take much effort to deconstruct his other laughable theories such as "Hinduism relied on oral tradition because they believe in a person's integrity and honesty and therefore this religion is a supreme and honourable religion of all". Take this argument out of India to assert your religion's superiority on such non sensical basis and see the type of laughs and jeers that you are going to get in response. And please don't think that I have cowered away if I don't respond after this, because I am not in the habit of participating in a discussion where the arguments are formed around such banal and non sensical lines
@@Abdurrahman-cv9sc As to why only in one particular part of the subcontinent? Well, historically speaking the south was substantially independent and also the north east and there is part of Rajasthan and other states even Hindu women put on purdah, whereas the Hindu women of the south don't. Even Keralite women have a peculiar attire that don't cover their entire body like a penguin.
And what happened in Delhi recently being a religiously motivated action for land is a new story. I'll tell it to my cousins when they want go to sleep faster.
I won't beat around the bush.
As for his point, yes. Women of Dharmic faiths wore purdah because there's no possibility of knowing when the Nizam or an Islamic ruler or an courtier would pick a woman walking by. Slaves were common as the rule was Sharia and rape was a bonus.
Try and read "Mediaeval India" by Satish Chandra. He says that the practice of keeping women in seclusion came with the Arabs and the Turks and become a widespread practice from 1206, the period of the Delhi Sultanate. The growth of purdah among women is also attributed by him to Hindu women fearing capture by invaders during a time women were treated a prizes of war. This is documented. So I don't where you got the reference to basically this is BS.
@@Abdurrahman-cv9sc And since you said it won't be hard to deconstruct the "laughable" theory of oral tradition do so. And while doing so, I'll give a touch of what it actually is before you try to find info about how this is not the marvel it is so that your ego is satisfied.
The fact is Non-Hindu scholars who have studied Hinduism have been astounded by the sophistication of the techniques used to orally preserve the Vedas. See, for example, Frits Staal’s The Fidelity of Oral Tradition and the Origins of Science (1986), in which he notes that “Prodigious energy was expended by ancient Indian culture in ensuring that these texts were transmitted from generation to generation with inordinate fidelity.” See also Pierre-Sylvain Filliozat’s Ancient Sanskrit Mathematics: An Oral Tradition and a Written Literature (2004), in which he notes that memorization of the Vedas included eleven different styles of recitation of the same text - forwards, backwards, with every other syllable or word swapped, etc., such that each version could be ‘replayed’ and tested against the others, and even a single syllable’s variance would be detected and fixed. And this proves that the fact that more reliance on the character of the individual over and above reliance on books is unique to the Dharmic way. Call me far right for being nativist, I don't care. I'm a proud dharmic. Fact is that's why the Brahmins were revered for being the storehouse of knowledge covering 1,000s of pages and more. I being a Rig Vedic Srauta Smartha Shaivite Iyer focus only the rig vedic Upanishads and Prasthanayi. Yajur vedins and Sama vedins have their respective branches.
@@Abdurrahman-cv9sc PS Sambit Patra is a spokesperson who drags debates, that's his job. How he fits here is something I'll never know. It's not the first time Muslims use BJP and associated elements in almost every debate. Proves they're doing a good job. 🙇 The arrogance is making me sweat.
Toxic atmosphere for sure
Fee hindu temples
A Rich man can be a Prime Minister, Was proven by Jawaharlal Nehru
A Honest Poor man can be Prime Minister, Was proven by Lal Bahadur Shastri
An Old man can be Prime Minister, Was proven by Morarji Desai
A LADY can be Prime Minister, Was proven by Indira Gandhi
An Illeterate man can be Prime Minister, Was proven by Chaudhary Charan Singh
A Pilot can be Prime Minister, Was proven by Rajiv Gandhi
A Man from Royal family can be Prime Minister, Was proven by V P Singh
A Scholar can be Prime Minister, Was proven by P V Narasimha Rao
Any man can be Prime Minister, Was proven by H D Deva Gowda
A DIPLOMAT can be Prime Minister, Was proven by the I.K GUJRAL
A Humble Poet can be Prime Minister, Was proven by Atal Behari Vajpayee
A Wise person n a Tea seller can be Prime Minister, Was proven by Narendra Modi
A Prime Minister is Not at all required, Was proven by Manmohan Singh
The country can be ruled without being a Prime Minister,
Was proven by Sonia Gandhi..
** THIS is an TRUE ANALYSIS !! **