It would be cool to see everyone’s Replica’s in rank from favorite to least favorite. I will start with my list… 1) Whispers in the Library 2) Jazz Club 3) At the Barbers 4) By the Fireplace 5) Music Festival 6) Under the Lemon Tree 7) Sailing Day 8) When the Rain Stops 9) Coffee Break 10) Autumn Vibes 11) Beach Walk 12) Bubble Bath 13) Springtime in a Park
I get why "everyone" says Jazz Club. But, By the Fireplace. 😘👌. Instantly transports me to cabin by the woods. Pretty daring and unique. Haven't really smelled anything like it so far.
Just got a blind buy and I’m amazed by how well it smells like autumn. My gf was a little disappointed that it didn’t smell like pumpkin spice coffee. 😂
I really like autumn vibes. I have several of the replica scents and so far have not been disappointed by the scent of any of them. Longevity on a couple of the scents is an issue. Under the lemon tree I lucky if I get 2 hours out of it and same with coffee break. Other than the longevity on those 2 I pretty much like the replica line.
Did you see my comment on this fragrance when asking about best fall/winter fragrance? lol this and by the fireplace are my favorite fall and winter fragrances. I layer them both almost everytime and it’s awesome. You should try it out. Maybe give this a few wears also
I bought Autumn Vibes when it first launched last year. I was expecting it to be more of a “little brother” to By the Fireplace. I like the scent and it projects more when layered with Molecule 01. I regulate it to Fall and early spring. Out of the 13 Replica fragrances that I own, this is in the top 10.
Kinda easy to get in the top ten when there’s only 13 to compete with. But I appreciate your insight on it. Havnt smelt it yet. But hoping to get it soon.
To me it's one of those fragrances that's executed really well, but I would consider it more a work of art as opposed to something I'd really want to wear.
Autumn Vibes for me is soooo smoky when you first spray it, I can’t imagine why people wouldn’t spray By the Fireplace if they like a fragrance like this? After the smokiness dies down it’s a little better, but it’s a little sharp for me and even when it dies down I think it just smells like a generic Autumn/ winter masculine scent
In Tommy's defense I've had a few boxes that just would not open so you basically get your thumb in the crease, smash in and up and pray nothing tears. I think it's most a problem with that coarser stock.
For city people this smells like autumn season. For someone who lives and works in a forest, it just smells like the forest. Man scent for sure! Like a real man who builds stuff for a living.
Please ash try jazz club i’m really thinking about pulling the trigger but i would be amazing to know what you think about it before doing it😅😅. Ps you are amazing💪💪
I really want to like the Replica line, but find most of them underperformers. Jazz Club and Music Festival are outstanding exceptions. I own Autumn Vibes, but really never reach for it.
Hey Ash! Off topic but if u wanted to round out your winter collection and had your choice between Noir Argent, or Encens, or Polaris.. which do u go with? Def value your opinion
I get what Tommy went through with that box. Margiela's 30ml boxes are a b*tch to get into without tearing. They fold/tuck the flap in too far and too tight. I started opening them from the bottom because its a bit easier, plus if it tears, you won't see it.
Can't take the channel seriously until I get the jazzy intro. Also Ash...PLEASE TRY OUT "BLACK STEEL" by Victorinix. Amazing stuff for next to nothing.
I did a blind buy and I’m amazed on how much is smells like autumn. I love it. My gf likes it too, but she was a little disappointed that it didn’t smell like some pumpkin spice coffee. 🙄 I’m actually amazed on how Starbucks has brainwashed so many people to think that their autumn coffees are what autumn/fall is supposed to smell like 🙄
If I’m being real, I’ve always been deterred from buying Replicas frags due to their appallingly simple design. It’s like a cheap Chinese knock off bottle of fragrance advertised as niche. Just my opinion though 🤷♂️
Agreed. If someone visits your place who’s not into fragrances and sees a tacky bottle saying “REPLICA” on it, it hardly looks niche and impressive 😅 paying that money I’d expect a better presentation for sure.
So this guy is prob the reason Fragranticas “reminds me of” section shows Santal 33, sorry but this in no way shape or form smells anything close to Santal 33 😂
I'm terrified by the lack of music
🤣🤣🤣
@@paigeofstylez expecting someone to lurk up behind Ashton and off him!
Maison Martin Margiela Sinister Vibes
@@flightgravity7483 _shivers_
Ash has to get a couple 100 more subscribers for the Extra Gents Scents to get a soundtrack in the budget 😂😂 JK.
I love Autumn vibes, so fresh and crisp, I mix with fireplace for a sweet warm smoky mix. Delish. More wearable than jazz club for me.
Maison margiela boxes are always impossible to open properly. Also in Europe the 100ml of autumn vibes is 50-60$
I love Autumn Vibes, wearing more than Jazz Club this Fall. Both are totally my jam.
It would be cool to see everyone’s Replica’s in rank from favorite to least favorite. I will start with my list…
1) Whispers in the Library
2) Jazz Club
3) At the Barbers
4) By the Fireplace
5) Music Festival
6) Under the Lemon Tree
7) Sailing Day
8) When the Rain Stops
9) Coffee Break
10) Autumn Vibes
11) Beach Walk
12) Bubble Bath
13) Springtime in a Park
I get why "everyone" says Jazz Club. But, By the Fireplace. 😘👌. Instantly transports me to cabin by the woods. Pretty daring and unique. Haven't really smelled anything like it so far.
I tried this today and tried on a date and autumn vibe drew me in. I’m gonna pull the trigger and buy it
Just got a blind buy and I’m amazed by how well it smells like autumn. My gf was a little disappointed that it didn’t smell like pumpkin spice coffee. 😂
I really like autumn vibes. I have several of the replica scents and so far have not been disappointed by the scent of any of them. Longevity on a couple of the scents is an issue. Under the lemon tree I lucky if I get 2 hours out of it and same with coffee break. Other than the longevity on those 2 I pretty much like the replica line.
First Replica I purchased, and it makes me want to try the others! I love the maple in here 😍
i was just looking at that fragrance on fragrantica, so cool you did a review today
I just picked up Jazz Club. Been waiting for that one. I should try this one too.
the first video I saw in a long time from Ash with no background song
This is my favourite from the house. There is nothing better on my skin, just signature.
I tested that today at Sephora and the opening was ok. The dry down was pleasant and it reminded of Molecule 01.
I’m surprised you haven’t done a review on By the the fireplace
Did you see my comment on this fragrance when asking about best fall/winter fragrance? lol this and by the fireplace are my favorite fall and winter fragrances. I layer them both almost everytime and it’s awesome. You should try it out. Maybe give this a few wears also
I bought Autumn Vibes when it first launched last year. I was expecting it to be more of a “little brother” to By the Fireplace. I like the scent and it projects more when layered with Molecule 01. I regulate it to Fall and early spring. Out of the 13 Replica fragrances that I own, this is in the top 10.
Kinda easy to get in the top ten when there’s only 13 to compete with.
But I appreciate your insight on it. Havnt smelt it yet.
But hoping to get it soon.
Yes! It reminds me of Santal 33 also but without the depth and sweetness that Santal has.
This fragrance really spoke to me. Very cosy, warm. ♥ Side note: I got pickles smell with Jazz Club - I was heart broken. Didn't work on my skin.
I found Whispers in the Library much more interesting than Autumn Vibes. That antique lacquered/polished wood note is unique and interesting.
Autumn Vibes 8/10. Whispers in the Library 10/10
Tommy has a really good channel. Great content from both of you guys.
To me it's one of those fragrances that's executed really well, but I would consider it more a work of art as opposed to something I'd really want to wear.
The vibe you dscribe I get with Bentley For Men Absolute
I actually like it without the sound, more relaxing. Keep it that way
Am I the only one that likes this better than jazz club? I got the samples online and I was suprised how mid jazz club is
Jazz klub is not mid lol
Autumn Vibes for me is soooo smoky when you first spray it, I can’t imagine why people wouldn’t spray By the Fireplace if they like a fragrance like this? After the smokiness dies down it’s a little better, but it’s a little sharp for me and even when it dies down I think it just smells like a generic Autumn/ winter masculine scent
In Tommy's defense I've had a few boxes that just would not open so you basically get your thumb in the crease, smash in and up and pray nothing tears. I think it's most a problem with that coarser stock.
Hey Ash. I would love it if you’d review the Replica’s ‘At the Barbers’ 💈
For city people this smells like autumn season. For someone who lives and works in a forest, it just smells like the forest. Man scent for sure! Like a real man who builds stuff for a living.
Please ash try jazz club i’m really thinking about pulling the trigger but i would be amazing to know what you think about it before doing it😅😅.
Ps you are amazing💪💪
I really want to like the Replica line, but find most of them underperformers. Jazz Club and Music Festival are outstanding exceptions. I own Autumn Vibes, but really never reach for it.
how does music festival smell
In my top 5 from Replica
Hey Ash! Off topic but if u wanted to round out your winter collection and had your choice between Noir Argent, or Encens, or Polaris.. which do u go with? Def value your opinion
Tommy must have been really excited about getting this one…
I agree. I really like the scent but i don’t wanna smell like it. I want my house to smell like it
I get what Tommy went through with that box. Margiela's 30ml boxes are a b*tch to get into without tearing. They fold/tuck the flap in too far and too tight. I started opening them from the bottom because its a bit easier, plus if it tears, you won't see it.
I need it in my life
I get the dill pickle smell from Dolce and Gabbana K but not from this?
Yesterdays video had really loud music, and this has none at all? Feels weird.
Can't take the channel seriously until I get the jazzy intro.
Also Ash...PLEASE TRY OUT "BLACK STEEL" by Victorinix. Amazing stuff for next to nothing.
Review jazz club!!!
Jazz club is at Costco for $116
"With autumn vibes, I get a little pickle action"
You should try oman luxury perfumes 🤨
Maybe the person who open this box will go slower next time. I enjoy getting a good box and will keep certain ones.
I did a blind buy and I’m amazed on how much is smells like autumn. I love it. My gf likes it too, but she was a little disappointed that it didn’t smell like some pumpkin spice coffee. 🙄
I’m actually amazed on how Starbucks has brainwashed so many people to think that their autumn coffees are what autumn/fall is supposed to smell like 🙄
Where’s the music!!
In your imagination
If I’m being real, I’ve always been deterred from buying Replicas frags due to their appallingly simple design. It’s like a cheap Chinese knock off bottle of fragrance advertised as niche. Just my opinion though 🤷♂️
Agreed. If someone visits your place who’s not into fragrances and sees a tacky bottle saying “REPLICA” on it, it hardly looks niche and impressive 😅 paying that money I’d expect a better presentation for sure.
@@bassacoustic1549😂 in sure most people who see the bottle outside of fragcom couldn't care less about the bottle.
Smells like the lumber section of Home Depot tbh
The real 1st lol
🤘
So this guy is prob the reason Fragranticas “reminds me of” section shows Santal 33, sorry but this in no way shape or form smells anything close to Santal 33 😂
This is so strange lol
1st
🫡
@@RichMitch I can't see the emoji as I'm a samsung user but thanks i guess 🤷♂️
@@sulaimanaljabari it was a salute my g
@@RichMitch 🤝
@@sulaimanaljabari 🤝