Your review reminds me of the OG TH-cam days when people did full reviews and wear tests! I wanted to see if the Cosmic Black was darker than Blackest Black and it looks like its not--mostly just clumpier and more wet. Thanks for the review!
Im so glad you posted this video🥰🥰 you are truly amazing!! I was really hoping you would like the cosmic black one a little more but it is different for everyone atleast for me I rarely ever experience flaking or smudging with the cosmic black one. However, I’m glad you atleast liked it❤ I can’t wait to see if you try the colored sky highs I feel like the burgundy or blue one will look good with your eye color
I’m definitely going to keep trying the cosmic black one off camera!! I’m hoping once it dries down a little I’ll like it more.❤️ but yes I’m so excited to try the colored ones! I’m going to order burgundy now!! Thank you for supporting for channel!!!
@@katecartermakeupatleast for me it does dry down a little it is pretty wet when you first open a new bottle you are right about that but after you use it for a little bit the formula gets better! I’ll be looking forward to that video🥰! Also, of course thank you for always replying and liking my comments you are my favorite TH-camr that reviews mascaras and honestly the only account I comment on I normally never do😊
@@paolaruiz9261 omg thank you so much I appreciate you!!! But yes I’ll definitely do some type of an updated video. I’ve been wanting to do updates but I’m not sure what I would title them or how I would format them. Maybe once a month I’ll start doing an update on mascaras I’ve tried.💕
I have been subscribed to you for awhile...saw the Maybeline Sky High Vs. Maybeline Lash Sensational in the fat pink tube...you wore the fat tube one for thickness and did second coat for the Shy High Punk Tube.....I loved the combo.i was actually in the store buying more and a lady asked me what kind of false eyelashes I wore!!!! I am 70! I told her about you and the mascara's and your application process, ( you were blinking it on lashes instead of swiping the applicator up from base to tip) another lady joined the conversation...repeated it to her they all bought the same and we're going to see your video!!! I still use the same stuff.i thought the black tube of Sky High was just a darker version and also noticed it did not seem to lift the lashes up on the top and it did clump more. I didn't realize it was a changed formula....going back to original Sky High. Is this still your favorites?
omg no way I love that!!!! I’m so glad my application was helpful. I appreciate you telling people about my videos so much! It means the world to me❤️ and yes!! The original sky high is still my favorite! Nothing has beat it for me!
I really hated the cosmic black ! It felt like it's a totally different mascara, so wet and hard to build besides it doesn't hold the curl at all and starts smudging immediately, I was hoping it would get dried with time, but it didn't
I’m glad I’m not the only one who felt that way! I was hoping it was going to dry down too, I guess I’ll keep trying it off camera to see if my opinion changes.
Your review reminds me of the OG TH-cam days when people did full reviews and wear tests! I wanted to see if the Cosmic Black was darker than Blackest Black and it looks like its not--mostly just clumpier and more wet. Thanks for the review!
omg I love that, I miss OG makeup TH-cam videos!! I’m glad my video was helpful💕
Im so glad you posted this video🥰🥰 you are truly amazing!! I was really hoping you would like the cosmic black one a little more but it is different for everyone atleast for me I rarely ever experience flaking or smudging with the cosmic black one. However, I’m glad you atleast liked it❤ I can’t wait to see if you try the colored sky highs I feel like the burgundy or blue one will look good with your eye color
I’m definitely going to keep trying the cosmic black one off camera!! I’m hoping once it dries down a little I’ll like it more.❤️ but yes I’m so excited to try the colored ones! I’m going to order burgundy now!! Thank you for supporting for channel!!!
@@katecartermakeupatleast for me it does dry down a little it is pretty wet when you first open a new bottle you are right about that but after you use it for a little bit the formula gets better! I’ll be looking forward to that video🥰! Also, of course thank you for always replying and liking my comments you are my favorite TH-camr that reviews mascaras and honestly the only account I comment on I normally never do😊
@@paolaruiz9261 omg thank you so much I appreciate you!!! But yes I’ll definitely do some type of an updated video. I’ve been wanting to do updates but I’m not sure what I would title them or how I would format them. Maybe once a month I’ll start doing an update on mascaras I’ve tried.💕
@@katecartermakeup You’re so welcome 🥰🥰 and you should thats a good idea! I’ll be looking forward to your next video ☺️❤️
I have been subscribed to you for awhile...saw the Maybeline Sky High Vs. Maybeline Lash Sensational in the fat pink tube...you wore the fat tube one for thickness and did second coat for the Shy High Punk Tube.....I loved the combo.i was actually in the store buying more and a lady asked me what kind of false eyelashes I wore!!!! I am 70! I told her about you and the mascara's and your application process, ( you were blinking it on lashes instead of swiping the applicator up from base to tip) another lady joined the conversation...repeated it to her they all bought the same and we're going to see your video!!! I still use the same stuff.i thought the black tube of Sky High was just a darker version and also noticed it did not seem to lift the lashes up on the top and it did clump more. I didn't realize it was a changed formula....going back to original Sky High. Is this still your favorites?
omg no way I love that!!!! I’m so glad my application was helpful. I appreciate you telling people about my videos so much! It means the world to me❤️ and yes!! The original sky high is still my favorite! Nothing has beat it for me!
I really hated the cosmic black ! It felt like it's a totally different mascara, so wet and hard to build besides it doesn't hold the curl at all and starts smudging immediately, I was hoping it would get dried with time, but it didn't
I’m glad I’m not the only one who felt that way! I was hoping it was going to dry down too, I guess I’ll keep trying it off camera to see if my opinion changes.
fr
It was helpful.. thank you
❤️❤️
The black one was awful, had so much expectations because of good reviews and it hurt my eyes so bad
omg really that’s terrible! I had high expectations for it too :/
Is it washable tho
I’d say it removes similarly to the original Maybelline sky high. The original can be hard to remove, id recommend a waterproof makeup remover!