Classical Musicians React: Red Velvet 'RBB (Really Bad Boy)'
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 พ.ค. 2019
- For the 73rd reaction video of Season 3 of this series, classical musicians react to Red Velvet's RBB.
(Eng subs will be added soon)
Watch RBB here: • Red Velvet 레드벨벳 'RBB (...
Watch Umu's and Isaac's reaction to RBB here: • Red Velvet 'Really Bad...
See whats new with CMR Season 3 here: • What's New With CMR Se...
*CMR Reaction Schedule:
docs.google.com/document/d/1u...
*Will not react to list:
• Will not be reacting to
*Support us on Patreon and get extra access to videos you’ll never see on YT: / reacttothek
Send us things!
P.O. BOX 14933
ROCHESTER, NY 14614-1119
---------------------
~Channel instagram: @reacttothek_official
~ Channel twitter: @reacttothek
~ Channel tumblr: / reacttothek
~ Channel Facebook: / reacttothek
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Video edited by Colton (YT: Lazy Ace Dia)
Filmed by Jordan Moore (TH-cam: / euphoniumplayer21797 ) and Umu
Script written by Erin Peters (twitter: @eireaine)
Intro design by Alex Chen (website: www.acchen.com/)
Thumbnail by Nozomi Murayama (insta: @nonchanyuzuru)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Follow the ReacttotheK squad and keep up-to-date with our lives:
(PD) Umu:
IG: @_emcha_
Tumblr: attack-on-dango, omg-horns, kpop-favs
Hugo:
Instagram: @hugohumbility
Jarod:
Instagram: @jarod_lau
Collin:
Website: www.collinholloway.com
FB page: collinhollowayguitar
Fiona:
twitter: @fiona_stout
IG: @fionaastout
Aaron:
Insta: @aaronlee753
Isaac:
IG: @Isaac.jr.li
Kevin:
Twitter: @nerdymusicks
TH-cam: nerdymusicks
IG: @nerdymusick
Elizabeth:
Insta: @ElizabethReacts
James:
Insta: @jamesfhorn - บันเทิง
Our unedited reaction playlists for all our Red Velvet videos are available on patreon! Pledge $5 and choose 3 different playlists to gain access to or pledge $14.99 and gain access to over 250 reaction playlists: www.patreon.com/reacttothek
ALSO today is the day (5/10)!!! Charlotte and Umu will run a fun & quick Kpop Trivia Game Show on the (free) TallyTV app at 7pm EST! If you want to participate in the fun (and maybe win some $), sign up as a player before we start the live stream: tallytv.app.link/g3gNjBEWzW
After signing up, download the TallyTV app on your phone to participate :) see you then!
Please react to g idle hann and latata
are you gonna react to WayV Take Off?
Could you please react HI SUHYUN 'I'M DIFFERENT (ft.BOBBY)' ?
Can they react to , eunha GFRIEND the masked singer one , and rose BLACKPINK's masked singer pleasee❤❤💖😊
Please do Love Tonight by Hong Jinyoung!! ❤️❤️❤️
‘Kpop’s most musically interesting Girl Group’ - Billboard
Truer words have never been made facts until now ;)
which in turns gives credits to their producers more than the group itself tbh
And producers can only produce those songs & give them to the rightful singers who are actually capable to pull them off like what the producers want. So yeah, Red Velvet is really one of the most musically interesting groups to ever exist!
@@eitsukun Yeri, Wendy and Seulgi write for their songs. Yeri and Wendy compose. Your opinion makes no sense
@Squishy Hoshi you didn't know yeri is a songwriter? Yeri and wendy wrote a lyrics for close to me remix
“I don’t even know what it was but it was resembling a scream but it was a very well produced high high note” Irene the underrated vocalist of our generation.
Irene honestly deserves more chances to shine. Like she's never thrown a bone for any comeback despite having so much potential to make RV even bigger than they already are.
Ikr
RV doesn't really have any weak links vocally. Yeri and Irene are both very good at harmonizing, and their singing often works as a great contrast to the rest of the group's singing.
actually irene is really popular than others, u dont have to worried
Mariah Carey is shaking
Intellectuals appreciate RBB
only red velvet could pull this off
Yep! True Intellectuals always love RV's discography bcoz they know how good it actually is when u hear it without being biased to just 'Visuals and Oppas'
When I show someone Kpop for the first time I give them a Twice song, a Blackpink song, and a Red Velvet song...then I judge accordingly lol
yup, when the other....said that RBB is so messy and etc....
but, actually is very great and has some hard high note...
Vocals - A+
Melody - A+
Lyrics - C (more aimed at the English version. The lyrics for the prechorus are made more repetitive than the Korean one)
Choreography - A+
Production - A+
Concept - A+
Visuals - A+
Lolll i thought it's just me who loved this song since the first heard
Wendy went off with her riffs in this song, I'm glad they appreciated it, very coll ly
Can we take a moment to recognize how amazing wendy is. i might just be biased becausr im from cancada and shes from canada
How the fuck your comment says "2 days ago" when this video was released literally a few minutes ago??? 😣???
슬기Seulgi 😂😂
@@ereh4582 patreon privilege
@@ereh4582 it's creepy i'm shocked too
wendy said so herself that this was the hardest song they have recorded and that after the recording, her throat was in pain... you can definitely hear why but a lot of people brand rbb as rv's worst song like,,, your preference sure but if you look at rbb in a musical lens one can't deny the quality and excellence of it
celestialvelvets and she said herself their new song is their hardest song... i can't imagine how hard is it when rbb existed
@@emptyaccnt they're gonna transcend thats for sure as expected from the summer queens!
@@emptyaccnt this is what I'm gonna to say 😁
Yeah, vocal wise it is a hard song to sing. There are a lot of rifts and a very high pitch in the song example is the scream part and what Wendy did in 3:57 and 3:59, the chorus was hard too but they did slay the song still. I didn't like this song at first though but I appreciated this more now that they made this reaction.
666like..
Can't believe that people think this is one if RV's worst songs...
I think has something to do with the over use of the lyrics "He's a really bad boy", and also the fact that they released it 1 month after Holloween. And mayble because the way they choose the title is kind of lazy. (Don't worry, I'm a reveluv, I'm just thinking outside the box and try to justify others' opinion)
Because several minutes of riffs alone do not a song make
LSP_ 1308 I hated it first because I thought it had no wit at all, like the chorus was so simple... but as I listened to it, with the time, I started to think it's really cool the way they play with their voices and the rhythm is soooo nice and groovy lol I love it now
@@Drewski217 uh have you actually listened to the song? It's not just riffs. I get that there are a lot of them which is uncommon but nothing's kept the same with RV
@@daniquintero5951 maybe because they already had a song called bad boy a long time
Raise your hand if you like Really Bad Boy, if not, Raise your standard!!
And knowledge
I was honestly in shock when I heard people didn't like this song. It's one of my top fave RV songs
L C
I’m shocked 1st time listening to the track. Never think Kpop would have this kind of song.
2nd listen: thank god for good music
**Raises hand** Yass, queen! Only intellectuals appreciate Really Bad Boy. lol
Oops
"Who? Who can do that?"
Irene's scream is freaking iconic. Definitely a queen.
Irene's extreme talents always get pushed aside and ignored. So happy she gets to shine here because her screams were one of if not THE most iconic parts of the song.
@@avani9347 ikr. I hope everyone appreciate her talents and hardwork more.
Red Velvet remains the most musically interesting girl group!
Like a more commercially successful f(x).
Blackpink comethru 👀
@@heyitskel2225 bp who? Their music is good but it's for mainstream purposes only lol. Red velvet ftw 😂
Syahid Hadi i agree with you Haha
@@syahidhadi578 only a fool wouldn't agree with you, blackpink is basically following the yg music style, nothing new really
Only intellectual likes RBB. That's why most people can't appreciate this masterpiece.
They wanted a vocal slayage? There, they have it. They lead this entire song with their vocals instead of the song leading them.
Koreans don't really like red velvet everytime i say to them do you know red velvet and they always squint or give me dirty looks
@@estelaangeles2346 They do like Red Velvet. But lots of them only stan for concepts like Bad Boy. And knetz are kind of...
But i believe Reveluvs koreans have the biggest fanbase thooo more than international
Let's not forget that netizens were continuously calling out RV for unprofessional dancing during performances but in RBB they went in and just gave the netizens a big nope xD
@@bdzmru8489 They hate literally everybody. First they call RV flops, then call them pig velvet, then hates on yeri, burns Irene's photocards then call them out for lazy dancing and crying at a funeral.
Next thing we know, they bash rv for breathing...
"So much *talent* in this group"
Red Velvet did *THAT*
abigail van cloak preach
I love when people praise and recognize rv's talent
Riteeee
I see Classical Musicians. I see Red Velvet. I see RBB. I CLICK ASAP!!
We're such simple and awesome people!
Same here!🤗
same
Omg HAHAHAHAHA I DID THE SAME THING
Same 🤘
JUSTICE FOR RBB! fans really did this song dirty :((
Yeah they wanted a song like bad boy but if we got a bad boy 2.0 they would be called lazy and uncreative 🙄 fans are never satisfied smh
If they're not appreciated than they're not a fan.. We stand the right group😉
Then don’t call them fan lol, I was afraid that RBB would be just BB 2.0 but I was surprised that this wasn’t and I appreciate this bop, which showcase their amazing harmony and vocals
i think reveluvs love rbb... its the korean gp who didn't like this. so it's not charting well in korea music platform = no wins in music shows
actually only knetz because rbb did so well on itunes charts especially in the states
"This scream again.. Who? Who can do that?" Huhuhu. National Beautiful Leader Irene
finally got my answer on that one because I thought about between wendy and irene and I'm impressed with irene
@@stormnajaire8505 When fans realized it was Irene screaming, they were Shook 😂 I was Shook as well
Snow Jin watch them live, Irene simulates doing the scream
Wait don’t they both do the scream
@@MrRyan10005 i think the three of them do thsat first is wendy more loud second is seulgi the last is irene they said.
The fact that Kevin pointed out that BB and RBB were both connected in D major and the D minor was like the Yes! moment for me. This is why RBB and BB are masterpieces. I learn so much from this channel.
RBB is so underrated! QUEENS right there❤
RBB serves some of the best Kpop vocals, instrumentality and musicality of all time. Point. Blank. Period. If RBB had its male counterpart it would be EXO's Tempo.
RBB's written so creatively and the percussion line is so intricate and interesting. While lyrically simple, it's vocally AND RHYTHMICALLY really, REALLY challenging, powerful and deeply groovy.
King Irene oh shit I was thinking the same thing, all the time I was like why this is so Tempo
The "aye-yeah eh-yeah eh-yeahs" and "ah ah ah ah ha ha huhs" were done by Seulgi. *yeah, she's good* She did amazing on those parts, but I'm sad she never sang those live, obviously because they're hard to sing and they're HARDER to sing while dancing.
And Irene did the screaming, our main vocalist. Lmao, kidding. And yeah, Wendy is freaking amazing in this song. The best female vocalist of this generation's K-Pop.
Aye-yeah eh-yeahs is Wendy, the ah ahs is seulgi
@@devakibhagwat6146 uhm, nope. The first *eh-yeah-yeahs* before the *ah ah ahs* came in the first chorus were done by Wendy, but the rest were by Seulgi.
I've seen a lot of Wendy stans saying that all *eh yeah yeahs* were done by Wendy, but no, that's definitely not her voice. I know how Seulgi's voice sounds like, the same thing for Wendy.
i think its Wendy's a yeah yeah although wenseul sound pretty similar! I did think it was seulgi at first but what makes it recognizable that its wendy is because the ending of the ayeah yeah where she slowly tone the note down, I immediately recognize Wendy's voice color! Our girls are definitely amazing singers and they shine their own ways!
Nah. That was Seulgi's. I'm her fan and been listening to her voice from the very first she was introduced to the public. That's definitely her part
슬기Seulgi
Preach❤️
Red Velvet always offers something great and different! ❤
I'm happy when people praise red velvet
who doesnt lol
@@sulgom9603 idk, maybe haters?
Me with every group i stan, i just feel so proud ya know and be like yas dats ma girls/boys arent they so talented
Kevin's joy for explaining the things we don't understand is really pleasant
Red velvet is the queen of this generation, fight me!
mamamoo too
@@subliminallytrying4046 imo mamamoo excels in talent but not so much for creativity. Red velvet has both equally strong.
@@arfdpprk2000 yeah i agree too.. all sm artist are versatile and creative.. but if you stan talent go stan mamamoo.. their vocals are no joke.. huhu
Agree, sm really puts all in when it comes to quality.
@@subliminallytrying4046 if I stan talent I would stan only wendy (which I already am) Because wendy is technically in a different level than all of mamamoo's members. Wendy is indeed the best female vocalist of 3rd gen girlgroup. As a group mamamoo is the best vocally but considering dance is a talent too, red velvet is better for me since mamamoo is not really dancing, not as much and as hard as most group anyway.
red velvet's superior title track, we love experimental queens !!!
Red Velvet's superior title track is Peek-A-Boo
@@Drewski217 for me its bad boy
@@Drewski217 nah, peek a boo is great but it's a safe title track compared to rbb. if you love peek a boo that much though you can go comment on that MV lmao
8:03 "And it's just so pleasing to react to something where there's so much talent in the group, but also so much creativity, and so many awesome choices being made" Never felt so proud being a reveluv. Thank you for appreciating Red Velvet.
This is the only reaction channel that matters.
Just saying.
I donno yo that form of therapy reaction is also valuable since it takes on another aspect of the comeback
Form of therapy is quite good too. PD-nim often also mentions ReacttotheK as well
@@Kata_Rin Yea they're confirmed friends haha
@@Kata_Rin Form of Therapy is okay. He's not nearly as informed as he likes to think he is, though.
A great one who doesn't seem to be active anymore was "MRJKPOP."
Really knowledgeable dude.
^^^^^^^^
RED VELVET IS THE BEST GIRL GROUP OF 3RD GEN! DON'T @ ME.
I will @ you because I agree like totally
Totally fully agree. They really cut above the rest
Queens of diversity
Definitely
yeah i think because sm water taste like water
I feel like crying right now since everyone says this one is a flop..RBB's really underrated in korea..doesnt even won an award in music shows in its whole promotion.RBB deserves the best. We believe in our girls and I love them.They deserved so much more.Im happy you finally give reaction to this.Thank you 💓
No doubt that SM have a taste for music
Love me my ReVeluv Issac praising Red Velvet 🤗😻
Finally a Red Velvet reaction 😍
Imagine what’s their new song will be like.. Wendy said it’s their hardest song to sing till now 💀
Alaa A zimzalabim?
Probably Psycho
@@lccode4972 Pshyco is more easier then RBB i think:v
I love how RBB is the hated RV song of many because of how "messy and repetitive" it is but for critics and classical musician, they loved it. Even for some that says "there's too much screaming" ,critics is saying "it is skillfully-produced note,not screaming". It really takes a skillful musician to say RBB is a good song.
As a learning musician this channel has been a very helpful and fun way of learning new tearms. Thank you for reacting, editing and posting💪🏼
For me this is the best RV song, this is a masterpiece seriously !
2:59 He’s is legitimately me when that part comes on 😂
Honestly, most of joys shining moments in their songs I get excited and react like that 💕
This song was released same date Thriller (Michael Jackson)
There is a werewolf in both songs :))
*I JUST WANT THEIR REACTION TO WENDY'S WHISTLE*
Did you mean the "scream" voice?
That scream is Irene's actually
It's actually Irene's voice
No she meant the whistle note at the end
No it's not whistle it was head voice.
The analysing part from Kevin interested me a lot, even though i don't understand any of them 😁😁😁
so many people criticized RBB and i’m glad to see actual intellectuals appreciate the masterpiece that this song is!
Red Velvet is honestly the best, they can change from ballads to high note, rap, dance incredible and take new challenges like it was RBB, no matter what they do, they do great and always do more than before, stan red velvet people ♡
I usually like weird sounds and songs so when this came out I was quite impressed with red velvet for bringing us another type instead of sticking with the usual sounds most groups have well I can't say much if people don't like this everyone has different taste.
Those who said RBB was a flop are the flops themselves. Red Velvet is the best girl group among the big 3 companies. Seriously. They are fearless of changing concepts. That's what makes them interesting every time. Twice being cute is great and all but the more they keep being cute, they start to stagnate which is why they gradually are changing into sexy hence 'Fancy' was born. Blackpink started as balladic and mellow on their debut song but after that, everything was just bad girl hiphop bop. Honestly, BP's best comeback is probably As if it's your last. Their better songs are actually not even the title tracks. Red Velvet slays every track no matter. It's pretty bad though that they don't receive good attention. Also SM is badly promoting them. They were one of the pioneer 3rd Gen girl groups and the successors of SNSD and F(x). They deserved better.
Castor Pollux PREACH! So true! Only intellectuals know!
Agree. RV is just superior. They are my fave among the Big 3 3rd gen gg. However for me, Twice is kinda fine as I like some of their songs. And I think their concept is normal for Kpop (cute transitioning to sexy). Meanwhile, BP is the one stagnating, seriously. I guess YG fears taking a risk to experiment in BP's sound.
이거 나왔을 때 주변에서 찾을 수 있는 반응이랑 많이 다르다.. 대부분 비명소리 거슬린다는 얘기 되게 많았고. 그리고 레드벨벳의 보컬 실력을 알아채고 얘기하는 사람은 많이 없었는데 그런 부분 알아줘서 반가웠다. 불협화음의 비명이 아니어서 난 좋았는데 싫다는 반응이 많아서 아쉬웠는데 ㅜㅜ 레드벨벳 스타일 알것 같다는 사람들 반갑다 ㅎㅎㅎ
You know,as always Red Velvet will not go with the norms,they just keep on surprising us everytime
I see the 'Stan Form of Therapy' 7:01
I see you umu
lol
here you can see that only intellectuals like rbb.
rbb is one of the best rv songs (in the areas of production/composition and vocals) and you can't change that fact.
SM proving once again that vocally and musically wise, they own it. SM, home of powerful vocals.
Sorry, im just a proud SM stan tho the company management is shitty..
OKAY NOW U GUYS NEED TO REACT TO FEEL MY RHYTHM
Finally rbb gets the appreciation it deserves. Really I can't understand people who said it's shitty song while it blew my mind once I listened to it. I just was so impressed and proud of the girls taking their vocals to a totally different level. Every part of the song is a challenge.
P. S Joy's part is my favorite too
Ikr?? It feels like on a roller coaster ride whenever i heard this kind of experimental music that SM produce.
I can not believe that people prefers Power Up more than RBB. The other one it's really basic compare to this one. I love RV but I didn't like Power Up at all and I was so mad because people bash them for RBB, this was amazing. Thank you for saying, those people can't recognize art when they hear it.
DearInsanityx I agree! With Power Up I think they focused more on creating a catchy hook (the banana part) and it's great when I first heard it from the teaser, but the rest of the song is bland. It's lacking something. I can't bop to it so I don't listen to it much.
They dont care about the MV (but one of them said it was Unique), They only appreciate their Vocals, their funky instrument, WHAT AN INTELLECTUAL. When Knetz only blamed the clothes, concepts, and Irene’s scream (actually a HIGH NOTE) that were strange and unfamiliar in their eyes and music taste. And honestly Knetz's music taste were pretty boring and monotonous. Criticust is the best judges for RV, their Daesangs said that.
Thank you classical musician. So stand versatile, stand Red Velvet guys
*sorry for my bad english
I'm really glad that both RV's daesangs were 100% from critiques and not from votes, sales and views. One day, I hope contemporary music lessons will be based with RV's music since their discography is so unique.
Literally just was listening to their RBB full album, and then logged into TH-cam and saw this! Never clicked so fast!
YAAASSSS IM BEEN WAITING FOR THIS
We love that you love the fabulous Red Velvet
Simpletons will never appreciate this kind of masterpiece
Irene is the one who does the scream note
Been waiting for these reaction.....
RedVelvet Fighting!
I fuckin love RBB era. The style and makeup was top notch. All of their visuals popped out. Vocals and song was incredible. MV set design and lighting was amazing. And that purple background?! So sad this didn't get the much deserved love. The variety and the delivery of this group every new comeback is amazing and unlike any other 💗
Im glad intellectuals appreciates this masterpiece :')
Finally!!!! Been waiting this for five months
I TOLD YOU THIS SONG IS ACTUALLY REALLY GOOD!!! STAN TALENT STAN RED VELVET❤
I'm early for the 1st time(relatively) :D on CMR series videos... I mean it's Red Velvet we're talking about :)
RBB is one of my fav RV songs... I play it every alternative day on my RV playlists !
I've also commented this on another video, but this reaction and analysis really really really makes me appreciated this song so much. They pointed out lots of things I've taken for granted.
THIS !!! "It's just so pleasing to react to something when there's so much talent..."
im basic.. i see Red Velvet, i see Reaction i click
I was waiting for this reaction! The queens of this gen never disappoint in experimenting with their sound
Thanks for this reaction, I loved it
that's why the reason, why i love red velvet. their vocals so incredible!
Watching your videos made me more aware of the music production of the songs rather than the idols themselves.
While form of therapy i can find myself being more aware of the production of the mv rather than the visuals.
These two reaction channels are the only reaction that matter. And thats the tea ☕☕
6:00 Red Velvet just has their own style. And it's more enjoyable the more I listen to them. 👌👍
Really been waiting for this reaction!!! 😍✨
Red velvet 😍😍😍 Thanks for reacting 😘 love your channel so much 😘😘😘😘😘😘😘
"Musically excellent". These words are perfect to describe Red Velvet.
this is something i never knew i needed
YASSSS BEEN WAITING SO MUCH FOR THIS!! Thank youuuu >.
oh my... I was totally waiting for Red Velvet reaction!! Thank so much T.T
Waiting for this since forever
Thank you for appreciating RV's music esp RBB .. Since I love hearing your words here, rip replay button . Hahaha
I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS 😭💕🙏 I LOVE THIS CHANNEL 🎶
Finally! I have been waiting forever for this reaction
I like this review because for me RBB is a great song that's very catchy yet sounded so well in the ear, music-wise.
This video is justifying my love for this song. The fact that people seem to hate RBB absolutely kills me. RBB is easily one of my top RV songs.
Its like you read my mind! I just watched your videos yesterday and thought that it would be great of they react to RBB and i woke up to this!!!
OMG YAS THANK YOU FOR REACTING TO RBB I'VE BEEN WAITING FOR THISSSS
Omg omg yessss my beautiful talented girls 💖
YAAASSSSS I LOVE RBB!!! RED VELVET HAVE NO BAD SONGS.
I'm so happy when people praise Red velvet musically , I feel like crying (of joy) 😭💘
so glad they reacted to this! i always wanted to hear what they had to say about the vocals especially. THE YERI APPRECIATION!!!! this song was a spooky banger we love
Thank you for the reaction. I really love the music of this girl group. Very interesting!
With Red Velvet releasing RBB, they clearly stepped a bar ahead
I'm so happy you react to this song, I really love it, thanks 🙏🏼😘
!!!! I was SO excited when i saw this on your to react list, while many ppl found the song messy at first i rlly liked it
한국어 자막러님 항상 감사합니다
Sunrise and time for the moon night reaction would be so nice😭😍
They did do a sunrise reaction
legends reacting to legends!! so glad you put this out
Omg how much i love y'all ! I appreciate you so much for appreciating other channels too (stan form of therapy)(but also stan reacttotheK)💜💜✨
Thank you for reacting to this! This is one of my favourite songs by red velvet. ❤️❤️❤️
Love from a small TH-camr
Irene’s going to one day prank Joy by screaming in the mic while In a live performance for RBB!
OMG I’VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS
Watching this and i feel overwhelming, thankyou so much for the appreciate!