I recall so called experts in Fox news saying it was over for Ukraine. Just imagine how much trouble Putin would have with NATO. Only if the USA pulls out dose Putin have a chance. Putin may not be done, but he is still failing
@@VictoriaPobiedathey fought with shovels, had to dismantle washing machines for processor chips and had only 10 tanks left.. and according to media Ukraine won already 10 times 😂 the western propaganda is so ridiculous !!
That's kind of true, but judging by history the Russian empire has been shrinking and shrinking, and what Putin has done has precipitated that phenomena. Or in other words: There won't be another Putin in Russia, if Russia doesn't exist...
You mean rhetoric, well its definitely changed coming out of the kremlin this is the second time putin has offered an unacceptable ceasefire, he wasn't doing that 2 months ago, then he was back talking about regime change in kyiv
@@joshuaparrott2458A new F-35A costs something like 85 million dollars. A new F-16 block 70/72 costs about 65 million, without the targeting pods, electro optical systems, and electronic warfare systems that would need to be purchased to provide the same capability the F-35A has by default. That's probably another 7 or 8 million in the F-16 price... The comparison is a 73 million dollar aircraft vs. an 85 million dollar aircraft that's also stealthy and can engage in a sensor fusion network centric warfare that F-16 simply can't handle. A 12 million dollar premium for the capabilities an F-35A has over what the F-16 has seems like a bargain...
@@ВашместныйагентКГБ because Russia's tactics have never been to wipe out Ukraine and just take over. They don't wanna do the American meat wall tactic for a quick win. They've come up with fair deals despite being the only ones in a position to truely define the outcome, now the US is forcing them to go all the way when they already pretty much have what they want territorial wise. Anyone with eyeballs knows this is hurting the West more than it is Russia, and the longer it goes on the more that will be the case.
@@davidthenotorious3600 apparently, hopefully not to their detriment, but we all know russian history. we see many young male russians escaping the conscription. this is up to the russians.
i saw a click bait title, just had to look at the comments. gotta say these guys here are extremely low intelligence people and i feel terribly sorry for them
@@sekour it does make a lot more sense if you think about it like that. It's just such a shame the actual stakes are so high. When commentators say Russia is done, but don't understand Ukraine is in a worse position, it's gross.
They have no such humility or self awareness. They smoke their own dope and start to believe it. Funny how he said nothing about us shooting ourselves in the foot with sanctions everyone is ditching our dollar including Saudi Arabia good luck printing money when no one wants it.
If you actually watch the video, the lad even admitted he had been wrong as well as others in their predictions. But clearly you didn't come here to engage with reality
I enjoy the coverage on this channel, but the titles of the videos are excessively hyperbolic. It really detracts from the professionalism of the channel.
Love this show and peter is amazing so smart and knows every little detail I trust him and especially your channel it's a real news channel without lies and hype and ONE SIDED coverage. Nice there is somewhere where people can get news and trust it.
In a recent interview with the CEO of Ukraine's largest energy company, their goal is to create smaller, geographically displaced smaller energy generation points that will involve a varied mix of diesel, solar, hydro and wind. His company is already securing investors willing to risk this in the middle of a war.
Second largest deposit of rare earth minerals in Europe is beneath the Donbas. The entire reason for the US "subverting" Ukraine in 2014. Source: Meet the Press video on playlist on my account.
Yeah but with Russia losing so many working men in the war and depleting their demographics, how exactly are they going to mine thise uranium deposits and other resources?
Someone, somewhere was due to be correct about a russian invasion year appx. It just happened to be Peter and he's milking it for all its worth lol Can't fault him. Everytime he talks about history or in absolutes, i roll my eyes as he's almost always wrong about something
Peter.... been amazing to watch the commentary from just prior to the start of the war through the present. Appreciate how much work went into tracking the fluid events in what has evolved into a major war, and appreciate the flexibility to continually modify and update the look forward as events unfold.. It's been fluid. Thanks, and keep sharing...
Yep, he has been pretty on point apart from not expecting the invasion. His pick on demographics of Russia seems to be ever true. They are running out of fighting-age men very fast and there is nothing underneath.
@@mortvald please don’t take this the wrong way, but I can tell that English is not your first language so I really don’t know what you were trying to say. But society is not unhinged. It’s just some unhinged people who are in very powerful positions.
@@dri2383 you'd be right, well it's mostly me being too lazy to write properly. But I digress, from what I've seen those unhinged people are a product of their environment and also accepted by the vast majority, if their values were so opposite to everyone else they would've been deposed but so far nothing this tells me that as much as people love to complain, they're content with the foolishness and outright ignorant at best, malicious at worst and trust i've seen plenty of people who hunt humans like ducks, hard to not call them unhinged.
Hows would you know? Have you ever been to Ukraine? Russia? New York? Florida? Tell me what is the basis of your understanding of Putin's war crimes in Ukraine?
Private US dollar/ Euro trading i spickign up pace now. Withdrawl of US/Euro currency was yesterday shut down by the russian government with the "promise" that deposits are safe.
@@austJW The Hryvnia can actually be traded outside of Ukraine. The ruble isn't accepted anywhere on the planet but Russia. Monopoly money is literally worth more.
@@austJW Indian govt cautioning it's citizens from serving as mercenaries to Russia and India wants two of their dead back , over 30 unaccounted for, I'm sure the families want dollars or Rupees not Ruble.
I always hear about meat waves but I havent seen any video of more than a couple tanks or a couple people running... anyone have actual video of waves of people running up?
These don't exist. You can check the channel called History Legends, he has a separate video examining the so called meat waves as a tactic, and what used to be called that in other wars. TLDR: it's usually just propaganda to paint the enemy as completely incompetent, and to exaggerate their losses to boost your own morale.
I appreciate that a hot war is the darkest of subjects but Zeihan is my goto American guy for geopolitics. Kate Gerbeau is a great interviewer and always comes prepared which brings the best of Zeihan. So Times Radio please can we have more of this.
Why? , the guy takes a few facts and spins a narrative. I honestly think he's really bad for our information space. For Ukr specifically, I'd recommend Michael Kofman, an actual expert. From him you can find other quality related experts
@@davidthenotorious3600it's not propaganda, it's his perspective. You don't have to agree with him to value his views. I guess you don't learn critical thinking in Russian schools.
The challenge is that from what I’ve heard is the economy is doing well even with the various economic sanctions. How can we be more effective in shutting down the war.
to be fair putin did dig his own grave 2 years ago to this day. Back then the headlines were nowhere near saying he was done, they were saying what a terrible horrible person he was. Now we are just waiting for that grave he dug to be filled. Invading Ukraine certainly wasn't the success he had hoped it would be.
Its just another hot air propganda interview. Just because you like what he says doesn't make it true. Bookmark this and come back in six moths and see if what he has said is accurate
@@kantemirovskaya1lightninga30 Is that the best you can do? Nothing Peter has said in the last several months has come to pass. Nothing. Yet supposed Putinists have been spot on. Its hard to argue with facts, in fact it must be quite frustrating for you. Perhaps the US should mind their own business re Europe and not attempt to expand NATO towards Russia. The Russians, not just Putin, made it quite clear that a NATO Ukraine would not be tolerated. They were true to their word. But what does the US care its mostly only Ukrainian lives being lost , about 500,000 at this point. Notice how Zehan never talks about this. Never one bit of criticism towards US policy - not one word.
No. Even if the RF does crumble, the culture is what the culture is. They will reform as another warmongering authoritarian nation within a decade, probably far less.
Great interview! Is there any chance that TR would license a version for PBS in the US? The US can use a new source of valid information. I love Kau's background setting and the camera framing used, up close and personable. Your show always seems to choose the best guests to interview. Thanks for all your hard work.
Interesting. Thought provoking. Thank you. There needs to be more direct, sincere, & mediated communication between enemies (ideally with broader public audiences) as an alternative to wars. Meanwhile, active deceit is surely worthy of the title “Public Enemy #1,” wherever it originates. Lies and false beliefs defeat intelligence. Garbage in, garbage out. Perhaps when the cost of deceit rises high enough, its uses will finally fail & fall as they should.
Did you expect he can tell the future? That's not how this works. It's by definition all speculation and if you don't know that you shouldn't complain.
22:47 He claims German elections are in 3 years but they are in autumn next year, 2025. Who knows what else he got wrong. I just noticed that right away because I am from Germany.
After repeated viewings of his other posts, he's a broken record, repeating "catch phrases" and off the wall conclusions (birth rate drop is due to urbanization - duh). Being an eCONomist, he's shilling for the same financial powers behind all wars. Don't believe me - go do the math. Run time value of money equations for future value, etc. For any given interest rate there is a point in time when the aggregate obligation (principal and interest) exceeds the whole set of money tokens. Thus making it IMPOSSIBLE for all to repay their creditors. This is why USURY has been denounced for "only" 3500 years. And Zeihan is shilling for THEM. Ask PZ to explain how the USA can owe $34+ trillion DOLLARS (not dollar bills), when coining all the gold in the world amounts to $134 billion. Who lent WHAT to rack up that impossible debt?
_What did one Russian Su-57 stealth jet say to the other Russian Su-57 stealth jet?_ _Nobody knows for sure, because there was only one, and now it's gone._ 💥 - j q t -
Zeihen seems like a fake expert like Bill Nye, Dr. Oz, and Neil Tyson. Having superficial knowledge about things outside your expertise doesn't make you an expert on everything.
@@hutch1319. No Junior. But if YOU didn't suffer from selective memory syndrome. You would've remembered that it was American Intelligence who did . Biden spent 3 months telling the malignant dwarf not to commit himself to biggest blunder of his life .Junior 😋🫡
@drutter Really Junior. I don't recall Zalensky going round bare chested.Junior . Can YOU remind everyone which of YOUR hero did that . Only to show how Big . & Strong & Virile he WAS and IS .Junior. 😵💫
@@joehowe9532 my comment is semi sarcastic. I’m stating what the media claimed…….. which was not true. Obviously you are just wasting my time as a troll rather than wanting to gave an intelligent conversation. So it is a bit much for you to understand my initial comment
@@goonerboz6023 he's overly optimistic, but more often right than wrong. Predicting the future is tricky business. Watch for trends and movements, not minutia.
@@VladimirPutin-p3t I have watched his channel throughout this war and hes been 100% wrong on everything to do with the war he even played along with one of the maddest story's I ever heard that Russia blew up there own gas pipeline insane
I'm pro-Ukraina, but can you please stop all claims that "Putin is done"? He has been done since 25th of February 2022. There's a difference between realism and wishful thinking.
I think the title is wrong. The main point was that this is Russia's last war, since they'll struggle to repopulate with all the losses they've had during this war.
@@ArbellaGroup I guess lots of them will grow without a Father, living in a country that's kinda hated and slowly growing broke and subservient to China. I don't think the future is that bright for those who choose to stay in Russia. But, I could be wrong.
I love you Kate, you ask all the right questions, and thank you for your complete coverage of the war in Ukraine very informative, I'm at your side, viva la Ukraine!!!!
Zeihan has been saying this for two years. He is rarely right. He's right in the sense of Russia having a poor military future, but rarely on other things.
Often wrong, but never in doubt? Of the top 3 other popular commentators for forecast/predict outcomes, who do you recommend as having a MUCH better track record?
the chess move is that russia wants to "visit/enter" ukraine and ukraine just wants to defend itself... i.e. staying put and repel approaching threats again this doesnt mean make long sling shots even if russians can... russians must have to put boots on ground. Now all ukraine/F16s have to do is take target acquisitions from say patriot batteries and avoid those air ambush traps using an/ale-50 like towed decoys ... and since amraams specially aim-120-c block-5 to aim-120-d and onwards are the gold standard.. when r37 and family were suckling on pacifiers; aim 120c onwards were on hunting-gatherer duty for the families (nations) who had them.. so said towed decoys will be smart enough to lure the r37m ... aim--260 is already developed and spine-chilling SM6 is test fired via F18 and could be rushed to F16 ... air launched SM6 is a game at another level of sublime.... its just for these skirmishes but for taiwan defense..... F16s have lower RCS than SUs and su30/SU-any with twin engine are like light-houses to even aim-120d ..... my guess is F16 wont be lost to r37 but few to serbian style use of s400 ... so again F16s should operate in cover of CRAMs/Phalanx more than Patriots or F16s duck down in their coverage area keeping the towed decoy extended... I am not seeing CRAMs/Phalanx in considerable use yet ...to me because of their more "contained" radar and fire apparatus; it has many merits over soccer field size components placement for Patriot (s400 too though)...
They can't make them now anyway. They have been pulling S-400 systems out of Kaliningrad to make up for the losses in Ukraine. By all accounts it is now completely vulnerable to aerial attacks.
@@cantiaci Please, stop believe in Ukrainian naive propaganda fakes 🤣🤣🤣 Russia produces S500 and S550 anti-satelite defence systems. Unfortunately, the modern Western and Russian Air defence systems can't cover whole territory. Do you remember China's balloon over USA? 😅
@carlharding5311 You can hate Putin and still recognize Russia is going to win this. The biggest reason is that Ukraine needs a draft (not enough Ukrainians are volunteering) and that most of the drafted just dodge and flee. You can't fight a war without soldiers, and Ukraine is a lot worse at recruiting/drafting than Russia is right now, even considering all the losses.
@@Andreas-gh6is Define winning. The stated goal was to prevent Ukraine from joining NATO, but as a result Sweden and Finland joined. Even if Ukraine capitulated tomorrow, that seems like a win for everybody that isn't Russia, but every day the war goes on Russia is grinding its economy into the dust.
Dude he's entertaining but he's full of s*. I read his book. I listened to his interviews. He said Russia will do badly in it's first year and then will start powering through and get to Poland and Romania by now.
@@grixiscontrol All three are nice. I usually say "peace" but instead we have no elections, Zelensky loved by his mom only, and no democracy some of the opposition locked up. Noone really wants peace and democracy in Ukraine. War an dictatorship seems to be in the cards until the ukranians are defeated.
@@PhilisJorben Who cares about Russia. We're talking about Ukraine. The story we're told is Ukraine is fighting for "democracy" when they are clearly not (no more elections, no political parties, no free press)...
tbh I never understand how people can say some 'country' is done when it comes to population, look at WW2, where countries lost litterally half or even more population and they still managed to pull through
The cost was stupendous, and set USSR back competing with other countries. 🤷♀ One has to admire the Slavic will. Finns call it "--the apathetic tenacity of the sacred grey best."
@@mamster233 I'd have to source the first claim, but the Stalinist system did embed during WWII and eventually stagnate the economy, despite a remarkable recovery from 1945 on. It's also likely the dead citizens caused a long term dip in population, with benefits and problems for an economy. The grey animal is from the highly documentary Unknown Soldier, a Väinö Linna novel. *"Pyhän harmaan eläimen apaattinen sitkeys."* an officer states the Soviets have nothing else left.
Depends what you mean by being "done". Russia is going one way street. The moment they demilitarize they will realize that they will never recover economically so they just keep going with the war. Also Russia wanted to annex Ukraine not burn it to the ground the ultimate goal was to get Ukraine to join Russia. The West basicly exploits Ukraine in "Russian civil war"
yeah, sure, Putin is done daily...
I recall so called experts in Fox news saying it was over for Ukraine. Just imagine how much trouble Putin would have with NATO. Only if the USA pulls out dose Putin have a chance. Putin may not be done, but he is still failing
last time they claimed that Putin had cancer and five heart attacks 😂
@@VictoriaPobieda😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂@@VictoriaPobieda
@@VictoriaPobiedathey fought with shovels, had to dismantle washing machines for processor chips and had only 10 tanks left.. and according to media Ukraine won already 10 times 😂 the western propaganda is so ridiculous !!
I’m rooting for Ukraine to keep their country but your channel has been saying ‘Putin is done’ for the last two years.
I actually listened to the interview and I realise he doesn’t say that. It’s just the tagline that’s clickbait.
That expression doesn't mean an immediate end but a process to the end that has started and is irreversible.
@@marviwilson1853wishful thinking
@@Hola_Jesim The evidence supports this outcome as does Russian history!
Done by gaining more territory.
Russia's 35th red line, 48th nuclear threat & 122nd final warning.
Rusha' is the only country that if they draw a red line, they will trip over it.😂
Yet no one's calling his bluff.
@@blehbleh5095everyone is calling his bluff why do you think the red lines get crossed? Nobody scared of pootler
Putin has a huge table. He can put many more lines, threats, and warnings on it.
@@blehbleh5095 I think most people are just laughing at Rusha' nowadays🤭
Peter is always an enthralling watch, coupled with this lady makes for a fantastic interview, thank you.
Judging by history, post-Putin, there will be another Putin.
That's kind of true, but judging by history the Russian empire has been shrinking and shrinking, and what Putin has done has precipitated that phenomena. Or in other words: There won't be another Putin in Russia, if Russia doesn't exist...
Another Putin......or another Gorbachev.
You mean there's a body double Putin?
We need Gorbaczew. But he died
So don't flush the toilet because someone will ...
Things have changed massively ever since the US has allowed Ukraine to strike targets inside Russian territory.
Just one more thing to laugh at Rusha' about 😂
What in particular?
No it hasn't just the rhetoric.
They havent changed at all because Ukraine was already doing that.
You mean rhetoric, well its definitely changed coming out of the kremlin this is the second time putin has offered an unacceptable ceasefire, he wasn't doing that 2 months ago, then he was back talking about regime change in kyiv
So if Putin is done that means Ukraine is winning, right ? Or NATO is winning? Peter when do you expect Ukraine will reclaim Crimea ?
When the cows come home.
Never
of course never.
Russia has absolutely great birthrate.
russia will never run out of soldiers.
In a word.... NEVER
@@Scott_Incognito keep telling yourself what you need to…
Turkey choosing S-400 over F-35 looks like the biggest blunder imaginable.
F-35s ain't cheap
@@joshuaparrott2458 Irrelevant to my point.
@@joshuaparrott2458 Freedom is not cheap either.
f-35 tech would leaked
@@joshuaparrott2458A new F-35A costs something like 85 million dollars. A new F-16 block 70/72 costs about 65 million, without the targeting pods, electro optical systems, and electronic warfare systems that would need to be purchased to provide the same capability the F-35A has by default. That's probably another 7 or 8 million in the F-16 price... The comparison is a 73 million dollar aircraft vs. an 85 million dollar aircraft that's also stealthy and can engage in a sensor fusion network centric warfare that F-16 simply can't handle. A 12 million dollar premium for the capabilities an F-35A has over what the F-16 has seems like a bargain...
I'll add this to Vol 3 of "Putin is Done" Times Radio Greatest Hits.
It's as good as the "Ukraine is finished" greatest hits, isn't it? Can't wait to hear the 2040 release.
@haissem8 Try harder
Wrestling is funny
@haissem8 I rarely even hear pro Russians say Ukraine is done.
@@ВашместныйагентКГБ because Russia's tactics have never been to wipe out Ukraine and just take over. They don't wanna do the American meat wall tactic for a quick win. They've come up with fair deals despite being the only ones in a position to truely define the outcome, now the US is forcing them to go all the way when they already pretty much have what they want territorial wise. Anyone with eyeballs knows this is hurting the West more than it is Russia, and the longer it goes on the more that will be the case.
What's the difference between a Euro and a ruble? One Euro.
Good one
LOL.
It has recently been announced that the Rushin' central bank has changed from a floating Ruble rate to a drowning one.🤭
😂😂 monopoly money, if you pass go you collect 200 rubles
@@dpelpal Finally the sailors on the Moskva get their salary.
Zeihan is my Bellwether for Reverse Outcomes. 💯
Until the Russians get rid of Putin, he is never done.
They like him.
@@davidthenotorious3600 apparently, hopefully not to their detriment, but we all know russian history. we see many young male russians escaping the conscription. this is up to the russians.
@@akosiamarillo Young men are not fleeing on the Russian side that's on the Ukraine side the average age of Ukraine soldier is close to 50.
@@davidthenotorious3600 we have thousands of them in thailand and other countries in SE asia. i can imagine other parts of the world
@@akosiamarillo Like I said it's worse for Ukraine the country is in shambles.
Listening to this program and reading the comments, one must wonder in what alternate reality these people live?
ikr
But I came to understand something:
This channel specializes in political satire (of the serious variety) 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
i saw a click bait title, just had to look at the comments. gotta say these guys here are extremely low intelligence people and i feel terribly sorry for them
It is unreal. If Russians breached Odessa, the shills would still Russia is losing.
@@sekour it does make a lot more sense if you think about it like that. It's just such a shame the actual stakes are so high. When commentators say Russia is done, but don't understand Ukraine is in a worse position, it's gross.
This is the epiphany of blind propaganda!
Looks like I’m done with the media’s history of false predictions. Do you guys ever admit your mistakes?
They have no such humility or self awareness. They smoke their own dope and start to believe it. Funny how he said nothing about us shooting ourselves in the foot with sanctions everyone is ditching our dollar including Saudi Arabia good luck printing money when no one wants it.
Yea right like you would if a camera was in your face.
@youtubezcy yes many do. Wow are you wayyyy tooooo concerned with what people think of you. Do derive your principals based on. What others tell you?
These aren't mistakes since they say these absolutely nonsensical and delusional things intentionally.
If you actually watch the video, the lad even admitted he had been wrong as well as others in their predictions. But clearly you didn't come here to engage with reality
Very good interview, thanks.
6:30 we could have prevented that if we stopped listening to isolationists. Stop letting a dictator tell you what to be afraid of
But that's what conservatives count on.
Without fear mongering, what have they got?
He'll be gone Nov 2.
Stay away from East Europe. Not your turf,, not your people. OUT. AND STAY OUT warmongers and colonizers!
@@VladimirPutin-p3t Well, this war was over in 2014 when Putin took Crimea without any blood shed. And that happened under OBAMA!
@@JSRJS When Trump loses, he'll escape to Russia very quickly to avoid jail time for his crimes.
Yes. Peter is quite entertaining and a little more honest here than he usually is and Kate always has good questions.
"Yes."
-Hiker John
I don't think he's dishonest so much as overly optimistic.
@@VladimirPutin-p3t or *pessimistic* depending on the subject or level of drama he is pushing. Sometimes he's totally doomsday . . .
@@VladimirPutin-p3t He is thoroughly dishonest but people like what he says so he is thought of as truthful
@@VladimirPutin-p3t You can call him DELUSIONAL
I enjoy the coverage on this channel, but the titles of the videos are excessively hyperbolic. It really detracts from the professionalism of the channel.
Completely agree. I hope @Times Radio are listening.
you like it there in the insane asylum ?
What professionalism??
Pulp fiction.
@@HeroyUlitzeThat was my thought.
Propaganda.
Love this show and peter is amazing so smart and knows every little detail I trust him and especially your channel it's a real news channel without lies and hype and ONE SIDED coverage. Nice there is somewhere where people can get news and trust it.
If putin is done, how cup Russia is still fighting in Ukraine ?
And winning
@@kevinmorris9325After two years fighting that poor little country.
Yes 3 years into a 3 day war, idiot @kevinmorris9325
@@kevinmorris9325at what cost? For which gain?
Russia still has enough reserves to keep going, even though there is only rubble left to conquer
@@Jakmak1480 Little? Let me guess, you must be American if you do not realize that Ukraine is the second largest country in Europe after Russia?
In a recent interview with the CEO of Ukraine's largest energy company, their goal is to create smaller, geographically displaced smaller energy generation points that will involve a varied mix of diesel, solar, hydro and wind. His company is already securing investors willing to risk this in the middle of a war.
Another Ukrainian asking for money? Gee what a surprise.
@@mankihonda983 Wars cost money which is one of the reasons the US has it's largest debt in history. The other is political incompetence.
Dream on! F16 is 40 and patriot don't work.
Canada is good at making small nuclear reactors, even our Royal Military College has a working nuclear reactor.
Scammers.
China was also done couple time a year since 2013 according to expert Peter 😅
More like expert PIDOR.
@jurirakewitsch2209 did he really say that?
He graduated from TEMU university. He’s full of s***t.
@@mustaphacham338 what's TEMU university???
@@mamster233it’s meant to be a joke. Temu is a website that sells extremely cheap stuff. 😆
0:08 you said it: " the Russians never stop before they reach a million casualties "
@@lostintranslation1957 Hi Ivan.
@@batrachian149 everyone who is not a Ukr flag slapper is an Ivan! are you with me brother?
So the Russians will stop in 2026?
@@jdoe4548which flag slapper are you?
@@jacqdanieles the pro-peace one
When I read the comments on this channel I feel like i'm in the twilight zone🤣🤣🤣🤣
Heh. Also got caught up on that. Scrolling through desperately trying to stumble on something real
Tee-Dee-Dee-Doo
Tee-Dee-Dee-Doo
Tell me about it!
People acting like we wouldn't be doing the exact same thing russia is if the script was flipped and Ukraine was mexico.😂
why are you in favor of china's biggest ally unjustly annexing it's neighbor?
@@Dillon6767If we did then we'd be evil too.
“Don’t mind the population,there must be a lot of minerals there”.
Second largest deposit of rare earth minerals in Europe is beneath the Donbas. The entire reason for the US "subverting" Ukraine in 2014. Source: Meet the Press video on playlist on my account.
Mineral resources AND agricultural "breadbasket" make Ukraine valuable
Yeah but with Russia losing so many working men in the war and depleting their demographics, how exactly are they going to mine thise uranium deposits and other resources?
@@1101agaoj Have heard the soil in Ukraine is, well that is why the crooked Blackrock be there
And in the meantime, how can Europe send more energy to Ukraine, when it is shutting down its own production?
"All you need is ignorance and confidence, and your success will be assured."
Peter Zeihan in a nutshell.
Someone, somewhere was due to be correct about a russian invasion year appx. It just happened to be Peter and he's milking it for all its worth lol Can't fault him. Everytime he talks about history or in absolutes, i roll my eyes as he's almost always wrong about something
Russian troll says what?
He is a talking head sock puppet, a propaganda shill.
Peter.... been amazing to watch the commentary from just prior to the start of the war through the present. Appreciate how much work went into tracking the fluid events in what has evolved into a major war, and appreciate the flexibility to continually modify and update the look forward as events unfold.. It's been fluid. Thanks, and keep sharing...
Peter is full of lies . He lies about everything always wrong
Yep, he has been pretty on point apart from not expecting the invasion. His pick on demographics of Russia seems to be ever true. They are running out of fighting-age men very fast and there is nothing underneath.
His podcast on joe rogan was atrocious. Maybe he is an expert on some things but he got a lot wrong.
He’s convinced himself he’s good at what he does and correct most of the time. Im not so convinced.
The guy lives in an alternate universe none of what's said is even close.
But yet you are still watching. 😂😂😂😂
@@dri2383 News are boring, an unhinged societies wish list though, now that's entertainment.
@@mortvald please don’t take this the wrong way, but I can tell that English is not your first language so I really don’t know what you were trying to say. But society is not unhinged. It’s just some unhinged people who are in very powerful positions.
@@dri2383 you'd be right, well it's mostly me being too lazy to write properly. But I digress, from what I've seen those unhinged people are a product of their environment and also accepted by the vast majority, if their values were so opposite to everyone else they would've been deposed but so far nothing this tells me that as much as people love to complain, they're content with the foolishness and outright ignorant at best, malicious at worst and trust i've seen plenty of people who hunt humans like ducks, hard to not call them unhinged.
Hows would you know? Have you ever been to Ukraine? Russia? New York? Florida?
Tell me what is the basis of your understanding of Putin's war crimes in Ukraine?
Fantasist. In a way its admirable how someone thats been so wrong over such a long period can be so confident and still influence some sheep.
_Oh I know_ who this guy reminds me of...
Stockton Rush!
Here you are, watching the video....
The rubles being paid for these people to sign contracts and fight is basically worthless now.
Unlike the hryvnia???
Go look at whos doing better Ukraine or Russia?
@@austJW for a country who thought were going to march in Kiev on day 4, Ukrainians are chewing up a dead bear.
Private US dollar/ Euro trading i spickign up pace now. Withdrawl of US/Euro currency was yesterday shut down by the russian government with the "promise" that deposits are safe.
@@austJW The Hryvnia can actually be traded outside of Ukraine. The ruble isn't accepted anywhere on the planet but Russia. Monopoly money is literally worth more.
@@austJW Indian govt cautioning it's citizens from serving as mercenaries to Russia and India wants two of their dead back , over 30 unaccounted for, I'm sure the families want dollars or Rupees not Ruble.
The only point required from this is. Putin's regime appears strong until it isn't.
It doesn't appear strong to me. As a matter of fact, I think Rusha' and the Rushin' army are a complete joke. 🤭
Eventually Putin will run out of Palace Guards who haven't lost a family member in this idiotic blunder
Russian army appears strong, because it is ;)
As the saying goes "it's a slow collapse then it collapses all at once.
People like you have been saying that for 2 years, that Putin is losing. I havn't seen any retreat from them.
Just love these interviews Kate! Keep up the great work.
she is clueless
I always hear about meat waves but I havent seen any video of more than a couple tanks or a couple people running... anyone have actual video of waves of people running up?
These don't exist. You can check the channel called History Legends, he has a separate video examining the so called meat waves as a tactic, and what used to be called that in other wars. TLDR: it's usually just propaganda to paint the enemy as completely incompetent, and to exaggerate their losses to boost your own morale.
If youre waiting to see literal WW1 tactics of storming trenches in this war, you might be a bit dense mate
@@innominatum9906 Def wanting to see more than a couple tanks in a line.
That's because they don't exist, it's a propaganda trope.
If you could figure out how to install Telegram your wishes could materialize.
I appreciate that a hot war is the darkest of subjects but Zeihan is my goto American guy for geopolitics. Kate Gerbeau is a great interviewer and always comes prepared which brings the best of Zeihan. So Times Radio please can we have more of this.
Why? , the guy takes a few facts and spins a narrative. I honestly think he's really bad for our information space. For Ukr specifically, I'd recommend Michael Kofman, an actual expert. From him you can find other quality related experts
I'm just here for the comments.
Angry Russians are angry.
@@StudebYes! There are a lot of Russia trolls here.
This is the worst channel on TH-cam when it comes to this war - total garbage
Sure, you keep telling people what you "want" them to believe...
Next year at this time "Putin is done"
I dont think itwill go that fast dont think this will end before 2026 and likely even longere
@@masteryourkitchen-areyouga7237 Maybe it will be over by Christmas?
This will be Putin's last summer on the planet.
@ronmonks6325 Likely so
Russia is definitely a lot worse off, no matter what. They will never catch up.
Probably one of the best, if not the most interesting interviews. I love Peter and his turns of phrase.
How often are they accurate?
Everything about her shows is somehow perfect 😳 From voice to questions to camera to hair to how she looks to lighting to…
Love when you guys bring Peter on!
He says what we want to hear!
It's nice to be propagandised isn't it.
@@davidthenotorious3600it's not propaganda, it's his perspective. You don't have to agree with him to value his views.
I guess you don't learn critical thinking in Russian schools.
@@VladimirPutin-p3t russia russia russia ahhhhhhhh🤣yeah it is propaganda he's been wrong about foreign policy weather it's russia or china.
@@davidthenotorious3600 yep, ok. Thanks for sharing.
Their bridge will soon be the most expensive pier in the world
Baltimore bridge?
Clever.
😏😏😏
but….that’s a red line
stop envying someone else's bridge =)
Thank you Katie.
The challenge is that from what I’ve heard is the economy is doing well even with the various economic sanctions. How can we be more effective in shutting down the war.
TH-cam pieces two years ago had headlines saying ‘Putin is done’.
to be fair putin did dig his own grave 2 years ago to this day. Back then the headlines were nowhere near saying he was done, they were saying what a terrible horrible person he was. Now we are just waiting for that grave he dug to be filled. Invading Ukraine certainly wasn't the success he had hoped it would be.
Exactly. Putler isn't done until he's done. Putler remains strong and then one day very suddenly he will be gone.
putin is Done has played more than the ravehit "James Brown is Dead" but both still generate clicks from the gullible...
Kate and Peter-always a pleasure to listen to them together!!!1
Its just another hot air propganda interview. Just because you like what he says doesn't make it true. Bookmark this and come back in six moths and see if what he has said is accurate
Kate and Peter. Preeminent western propagandist cheerleaders.
@@rjdebruyn always a pleasure seeing their interviews gaining the attention of the kremlin troll army!
@@kantemirovskaya1lightninga30 Is that the best you can do? Nothing Peter has said in the last several months has come to pass. Nothing. Yet supposed Putinists have been spot on. Its hard to argue with facts, in fact it must be quite frustrating for you. Perhaps the US should mind their own business re Europe and not attempt to expand NATO towards Russia. The Russians, not just Putin, made it quite clear that a NATO Ukraine would not be tolerated. They were true to their word. But what does the US care its mostly only Ukrainian lives being lost , about 500,000 at this point. Notice how Zehan never talks about this. Never one bit of criticism towards US policy - not one word.
Great interview!!
More of that please
More being told how Russia is going to lose but they dont seem to be doing so, why is that?
An excellent interview and valuable information. Thanks Peter
Ur doin' Peter - Algo
Look at this sheep Peterb666
Ha ha you are delusional
I really like this guy, thx
Is this finally the end of the Russian Empire?
An "empire" without toilets🤭
@@dpelpal - All the "right people" in Russia have toilets.
No, its called the rise of Muscovy.
It's just a matter of time. Puttin scare tactics propaganda has backed fired
No. Even if the RF does crumble, the culture is what the culture is. They will reform as another warmongering authoritarian nation within a decade, probably far less.
Great interview! Is there any chance that TR would license a version for PBS in the US? The US can use a new source of valid information. I love Kau's background setting and the camera framing used, up close and personable. Your show always seems to choose the best guests to interview. Thanks for all your hard work.
PBS would never allow this guy on because he lacks qualifications
@@dpelpal Oh how little you know, but thanks for your opinion.
The worst enemy you have to fear is the one you have confabulated..
Interesting. Thought provoking. Thank you. There needs to be more direct, sincere, & mediated communication between enemies (ideally with broader public audiences) as an alternative to wars. Meanwhile, active deceit is surely worthy of the title “Public Enemy #1,” wherever it originates. Lies and false beliefs defeat intelligence. Garbage in, garbage out. Perhaps when the cost of deceit rises high enough, its uses will finally fail & fall as they should.
Kate is incredibly, and I mean incredibly intelligent to engage her guest at his level. She does an amazing good job!!
Excellent Speaker
The Most Excellent
Order of the British Empire
"We can probably have a meaningful counteroffensive this summer"
Sounds like Steiner's counterattack to me.
Outstanding discussion
Book mark this and see how much is true in six moths, as with all his other interviews this is just articulate hot air
Not really
@ganndebei totally agreer1621
Day dream believer
Must have touched a nerve, the trolls are out.
That sentence ""We can actually have perhaps a meaningful counteroffensive this summer." ... "actually"... "perhaps"...
Did you expect he can tell the future? That's not how this works. It's by definition all speculation and if you don't know that you shouldn't complain.
the beard and top knot allude to his righteousness.
@@bened22you should consider cause and effect and probability
Brilliant interview! Great job! Peter Zeihan is an encyclopedia of information and he adds analysis to that data.
22:47 He claims German elections are in 3 years but they are in autumn next year, 2025. Who knows what else he got wrong. I just noticed that right away because I am from Germany.
After repeated viewings of his other posts, he's a broken record, repeating "catch phrases" and off the wall conclusions (birth rate drop is due to urbanization - duh). Being an eCONomist, he's shilling for the same financial powers behind all wars. Don't believe me - go do the math. Run time value of money equations for future value, etc. For any given interest rate there is a point in time when the aggregate obligation (principal and interest) exceeds the whole set of money tokens. Thus making it IMPOSSIBLE for all to repay their creditors. This is why USURY has been denounced for "only" 3500 years. And Zeihan is shilling for THEM.
Ask PZ to explain how the USA can owe $34+ trillion DOLLARS (not dollar bills), when coining all the gold in the world amounts to $134 billion. Who lent WHAT to rack up that impossible debt?
He is articulate but laughably wrong. Go back and look at some of his previous predictions
_What did one Russian Su-57 stealth jet say to the other Russian Su-57 stealth jet?_
_Nobody knows for sure, because there was only one, and now it's gone._ 💥 - j q t -
Lol😂
Rusha' is the only country that draws a red line and then trips over it😆
Must be a Russian joke, because it is a lie, that SU-57's can talk.
Evidence please
LMAFO 😂
Great guest, Times Radio! Zeihan is a very informed and his hypothetical scenarios are confirmed more often than not.❤🎉
Which one has been confirmed so far? Non that I know of
Zeihen seems like a fake expert like Bill Nye, Dr. Oz, and Neil Tyson. Having superficial knowledge about things outside your expertise doesn't make you an expert on everything.
Did he predict russia's invasion?
Yes he predicted the invasion in his first book.
@@hutch1319.
No Junior.
But if YOU didn't suffer from selective memory syndrome.
You would've remembered that it was American Intelligence who did .
Biden spent 3 months telling the malignant dwarf not to commit himself to biggest blunder of his life .Junior 😋🫡
Great interview.....
Putin is not done, far from it. To think that he is done is just magical thinking, and magical thinking doesn't work.
This guy's insight and sensible logic are the best synopsis I have seen on Russian affairs and this war. Much appreciated & great job.
The little man is raging in Kreml now and all the people around him are plotting against him.. 😋
Darwin Award winner: Putin
Not to mention the entire planet laughing at the Rushin' military😂😂😂
Is Putin's Assassination inevitable
The little man? I thought you meant the chubby actor in a green sweatshirt!
@@drutterYou are obviously Russian! Good luck, you’ll need plenty !!!
@drutter
Really Junior.
I don't recall Zalensky going round bare chested.Junior .
Can YOU remind everyone which of YOUR hero did that .
Only to show how Big . & Strong & Virile he WAS and IS .Junior. 😵💫
I am wondering if Putin is starting to avoid large windows.
He also might be avoiding cups of Tea or coffee
He is confiscating all handguns
Given his stature, he should also stay away from small windows.
Yea well, biden avoids having cereal for breakfast, so as to not fall asleep and inhale some of it and choke in the process. Ba-dum-tssss.
Living in fantasies such as Peter here will not help the situation. In fact it will deepen it.
I thought Russia ran out of ammo
at the start of last year ?
Nope they had to beg North Korea for more ammo…deal was signed this week with the powerhouse Kim Jong Un (ruble in collapse lol)
Russia ran out of soldiers, hence the mobilization. The next one of around 300k recruits is just around the corner.
Russia along with the USA is one of the biggest producer of ammunition, I don't know why the West is trying to push that false narrative.
No Richard, you were wrong, wrong wrong wrong. 😅
@@joehowe9532 my comment is semi sarcastic. I’m stating what the media claimed…….. which was not true. Obviously you are just wasting my time as a troll rather than wanting to gave an intelligent conversation. So it is a bit much for you to understand my initial comment
I need to package Peter Zeihan as my own personal AI assistant. This guy's so good at sharing his expertise. Great questions too.
😑 Peter speaks with confidence, regardless of the accuracy of his information or analysis - bit like a palm reader.
@@glenw3814 Can you point to anything he has completely whiffed on?
Hes been 100% wrong throughout this war so if you think being wrong is brilliant you need to see a psychiatrist
@@goonerboz6023 he's overly optimistic, but more often right than wrong.
Predicting the future is tricky business. Watch for trends and movements, not minutia.
@@VladimirPutin-p3t I have watched his channel throughout this war and hes been 100% wrong on everything to do with the war he even played along with one of the maddest story's I ever heard that Russia blew up there own gas pipeline insane
Brilliant interview. Full respect to Kate. Again and again she delivers really really important content.
Great commentary. I hope what he says bears truth.
I'm pro-Ukraina, but can you please stop all claims that "Putin is done"? He has been done since 25th of February 2022. There's a difference between realism and wishful thinking.
I think the title is wrong. The main point was that this is Russia's last war, since they'll struggle to repopulate with all the losses they've had during this war.
@@ArbellaGroup More wishful thinking...
@@ArbellaGroup I guess lots of them will grow without a Father, living in a country that's kinda hated and slowly growing broke and subservient to China. I don't think the future is that bright for those who choose to stay in Russia. But, I could be wrong.
They put Ukraine as a Reference unit of Russia's Power.
To see if they can fight Russia. They are so evils.
Perhaps Putin can think of the number of soldiers, but the talent and expert ones were all gone.
Putin admires Stalin. He doesn't care at all.
As always Kate absolutely brilliant vlog,Peter’s insight to is mind boggling it’s always fascinating to listen to him thanks for getting him on.
Sure...Times Radio's credibility is really top notch..It surely isn't propaganda...surely...
Peter is always a good interview, even if he does a get a bit wide-eyed about his predictions.
He interprets facts and data.if he's right 51% of the time, its better than guessing
How many of his, lolololol, 'predictions' have even been remotely close to being true?
He is like Neil Ferguson, 100% wrong on every occasion.
Don't put the carriage on before you have the horse...
I love you Kate, you ask all the right questions, and thank you for your complete coverage of the war in Ukraine very informative, I'm at your side, viva la Ukraine!!!!
This man should be writing fantasy novels, not analyzing politics
You are absolutely sure. A big liar a that makes no sense.
You're not being fair. Give him some time for his predictions to come true.
He should definitely _not_ quit his day job...cause nobody would read em! 😄
I hope you are not getting paie in rubles for that lie... Of course, that would be fair because due to Putin's stupidity the ruble is worthless.
he dont mind , he get payed to lied his own people , imagie what he else will do for money !!?
Zeihan has been saying this for two years. He is rarely right. He's right in the sense of Russia having a poor military future, but rarely on other things.
He does have an army of fan boys who believe he's right, not sure how that happened
Often wrong, but never in doubt?
Of the top 3 other popular commentators for forecast/predict outcomes, who do you recommend as having a MUCH better track record?
gate keeper for the gop
Just listen the nonsense he is spewing on China. They are done for like 10 years now, but only he can see it, haha.
When I'm in the mood to listen to what the US narrative is supposed to be in this mess, Peter Zeihan is the guy.
Lovely to hear!
Regards from Sweden.🇸🇪
Lol, Sweden...
Judgment is coming on America ! And anyone buying outings done is a lost soul ! Wake up
what? get some sleep.
Peter excused being wrong because 'everyone was wrong'. LOL!! And he said it with a straight face. LOL!
the chess move is that russia wants to "visit/enter" ukraine and ukraine just wants to defend itself... i.e. staying put and repel approaching threats again this doesnt mean make long sling shots even if russians can... russians must have to put boots on ground. Now all ukraine/F16s have to do is take target acquisitions from say patriot batteries and avoid those air ambush traps using an/ale-50 like towed decoys ... and since amraams specially aim-120-c block-5 to aim-120-d and onwards are the gold standard.. when r37 and family were suckling on pacifiers; aim 120c onwards were on hunting-gatherer duty for the families (nations) who had them.. so said towed decoys will be smart enough to lure the r37m ... aim--260 is already developed and spine-chilling SM6 is test fired via F18 and could be rushed to F16 ... air launched SM6 is a game at another level of sublime.... its just for these skirmishes but for taiwan defense..... F16s have lower RCS than SUs and su30/SU-any with twin engine are like light-houses to even aim-120d ..... my guess is F16 wont be lost to r37 but few to serbian style use of s400 ... so again F16s should operate in cover of CRAMs/Phalanx more than Patriots or F16s duck down in their coverage area keeping the towed decoy extended... I am not seeing CRAMs/Phalanx in considerable use yet ...to me because of their more "contained" radar and fire apparatus; it has many merits over soccer field size components placement for Patriot (s400 too though)...
Slavo Ukraine 🇺🇦
Good luck selling S-400's now, Putin. You might as well stop making them.
Do you remember China's balloon over USA? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
They can't make them now anyway. They have been pulling S-400 systems out of Kaliningrad to make up for the losses in Ukraine. By all accounts it is now completely vulnerable to aerial attacks.
They just deployed the only S-500 just a few days ago.
@@cantiaci By all accounts you've been continuously winning since your Hollywood offensive. 🙄
@@cantiaci Please, stop believe in Ukrainian naive propaganda fakes 🤣🤣🤣
Russia produces S500 and S550 anti-satelite defence systems.
Unfortunately, the modern Western and Russian Air defence systems can't cover whole territory. Do you remember China's balloon over USA? 😅
A1 ture information and facts 👍
Peter is great, a bit melodramatic at times, like any fortuneteller.
😂
@carlharding5311 You can hate Putin and still recognize Russia is going to win this. The biggest reason is that Ukraine needs a draft (not enough Ukrainians are volunteering) and that most of the drafted just dodge and flee. You can't fight a war without soldiers, and Ukraine is a lot worse at recruiting/drafting than Russia is right now, even considering all the losses.
@@Andreas-gh6is Define winning. The stated goal was to prevent Ukraine from joining NATO, but as a result Sweden and Finland joined. Even if Ukraine capitulated tomorrow, that seems like a win for everybody that isn't Russia, but every day the war goes on Russia is grinding its economy into the dust.
@@mitchellmartin4580 Sweden and Finland were always NATO leaning so it makes no difference.
Dude he's entertaining but he's full of s*. I read his book. I listened to his interviews. He said Russia will do badly in it's first year and then will start powering through and get to Poland and Romania by now.
Where does this channel get is guests.I saw today on Indian news channel Ukraine lost 2000 soldiers yesterday. Incredible.
Yes, but actually you did not. 2/10 for effort though
Very sensible opinion.
no, it's cheap propaganda and people can see through it
they have been saying Russia is loosing but you cant win without bringing the war to your adversary
For the last time it's losing. Not loosing. Look it up.
How can these super jets make a difference. It takes years to train pilots for those machines.
Ukrainian pilots have been training on F16s for over a year now. F16s are indeed coming very soon...
How about Ukrainian elections and democracy ?
how about to stop war ?
@@grixiscontrol All three are nice. I usually say "peace" but instead we have no elections, Zelensky loved by his mom only, and no democracy some of the opposition locked up. Noone really wants peace and democracy in Ukraine. War an dictatorship seems to be in the cards until the ukranians are defeated.
Democracy is a fake dream bc the workers pay much taxes for all the chit ............................
How about Russian elections and democracy ? 🤣
@@PhilisJorben Who cares about Russia. We're talking about Ukraine. The story we're told is Ukraine is fighting for "democracy" when they are clearly not (no more elections, no political parties, no free press)...
This guy is talking about a Ukrainian counter-offensive this Summer??? Amazing. He is positively giddy in this interview.
Zeihan is a clueless, anti-Russian crackpot
who's functioning at the emotional level of
a 13-year-old girl. Hence, the giddiness.
He always is his predictions are drivel, go and find some of his old interviews. He is just another hot air talking head sprouting propaganda
Nice "click-bait" title Times Radio
tbh I never understand how people can say some 'country' is done when it comes to population, look at WW2, where countries lost litterally half or even more population and they still managed to pull through
The cost was stupendous, and set USSR back competing with other countries. 🤷♀ One has to admire the Slavic will. Finns call it "--the apathetic tenacity of the sacred grey best."
@@FloraJoannaK is that true? where did you see this?
@@mamster233 I'd have to source the first claim, but the Stalinist system did embed during WWII and eventually stagnate the economy, despite a remarkable recovery from 1945 on. It's also likely the dead citizens caused a long term dip in population, with benefits and problems for an economy.
The grey animal is from the highly documentary Unknown Soldier, a Väinö Linna novel. *"Pyhän harmaan eläimen apaattinen sitkeys."* an officer states the Soviets have nothing else left.
Putin being "done" is like Fusion Power being ready, every year we are told the time is almost here, and every year it isn't.
Depends what you mean by being "done". Russia is going one way street. The moment they demilitarize they will realize that they will never recover economically so they just keep going with the war.
Also Russia wanted to annex Ukraine not burn it to the ground the ultimate goal was to get Ukraine to join Russia. The West basicly exploits Ukraine in "Russian civil war"
Thanks for perspective and analysis. Great interview!
Kate Gerbeau is always on point with her questions and with a "Peter Zeihan" your extract some very interesting and broad content. Thanks Kate! 👌👌
Kate is my favorite interviewer!
The West is done. I pity those who don't get it yet.
West was done when Biden took the oath of office. He had 64 executive orders . Changed the way the world was ran.
You should pity the citizens of Ukraine and Russia.
Did you contribute to that at all?
😂yeah😂yeah😂whatever😂
looks like for this guy time has stopped in Autumn 2022