Fact is Indian 2 and 3 are one film... Go_back_indian scene suppose to come in interval right before senathipathi start to tell his flash back . After interval, senathipathi flash back, big climax fight and conclusion... BUT Shankar decide to use big scissors ✂️ SUJATA WOULD NEVER ALLOW THIS MADNESS
yep. and same happened in bahubali. why kattappa killed bahubali is interval and bahubali 2 should have been second half. If you notice closely bahubali 1 and 2 first half had lot of filler scens bahubali 1 - multiple times trying to climb the mountain, pra bhas and thamannah escaping in ice boat etc. bahubali 2 first half - that entire krishna song, killing 3 pigs and making subba raju from coward to veeran by giving motivational talk, how to use 3 ambu and teaching that to anushka etc.. Except kgf 1 and 2, and singam 1 and 2, all others were just to mint money. But Indian 2 avalo mosam illa. all they could have trimmed is that monowheel chase and train chase and then ambulance etc. For me, I prefer a movie that provides a solution and giving hope than calling things as reality and fate. 1 change out of 1000000 problems is still a change.
@@LetsBeHuman i agree with you on indian 2 but in bahubali 1, there are some time takes to enter whole world like maghizhmathi, i don't think they are fill up scenes, even in bahubali 2 there is nothing i found filling up
@mahinkhan3721If “I” was a masterpiece, why it didn’t do well in box office? The producer Aascar Ravichandran went bankrupt after that movie. Vikram acted very well. But story and screenplay didnt sit well with audience
@mahinkhan3721 when were you born? In 2008 or 2009..then you have no idea who Shankar was before I. He was like double edged sword with sujatha writer. Even had some illiogical scenes and granduer but when it came to deliver sharp content like in mudalvan, anniyan and even robot , I cudnt meet that bar set by shankar himself. I had nothing as a story you can invest in.. Vikram hard work was wasted. Villian was obviously known in the first scene Itself, nothing surprise. Then all about torturing people with weak dialogues.
Shankar lost it in 2015 when he marketed Vikram's "I" getup as a beauty and the beast concept...and making Vikram do the makeup in audio launch also...whereas in reality it was just for a song in the movie
'I' had no soul. I couldn't care less about vikram and Amy Jackson's love angle. It was not convincing and the whole thing was such a bore that I didn't even bother to finish watching the movie.
Exactly bro..I felt the same ..I was having a lot of expectations seeing vikram getup in audio launch ..booked fdfs and watched that it is only for a song is shocking to me...Shankar scam started from there 😮
I felt like Shankar made a comedy spoof of the brave Senapathy(Indian Thatha). Even Senapathy didn't do this much actions 28yrs ago!! The first one in 1996 was very suttle and engaging. I think Shankar wrote a script for 'Anniyan 2', & when he didn't get the dates of Chiyaan Vikram he proceeded with Kamal sir and gave the name 'Indian 2'. It has Vasantha Balan and Chimbudevan as second unit directors where we can pointout their portions. Varmam parts wre the most comical things in the entire movie!! Anirudh already said "Thatha vararu katharavida poraru".. Now everyone who watched the movie is feeling the katharal!!!
@@AK-mf9ho since he is a part of the movie he won't observe the faults. Even if he does, there would have been some critical circumstances to unsee them and move on.
It's because of the mindset of the movie maker. They don't want to share the credits and fame., with some random reviewers... For them, it's their movie...and they won't prefer to get viewers feedback like "Reviewers are the main reason for success"
Manorama achi scene dha main starting connect in Indian1. Senapathi go to repair his belt to aachi husband where he was killed. Andha connect eh rmbo nala irukum
Who's that dialogue writer who wrote the line for Bobby simha " APPA ENNA ASIRVANDHAM PANNUNGA NA INDIAN THATHA PIDICHU JANATHIPATHI KITTA GOLD MEDAL VANGA PORIEN" soothula Gold medal..😤
3 writers nalla op adichurukaainga..jeyamohan, kabilan vairamuthu, lakshmi saravanakumar..Antha common man animation pesura dialogue laam etho first time short film edukra amateur eluthura dialogue maathiri padu kevalama irunthuchu
As a True Shankar Sir Fan, Shankar Sir need Good and Young Screenplay writers. Could be a Good Film but Screenplay is very Poor. Wish Shankar Sir would understand and see to it.
@@thamaraik1773 I too can't believe it's a Shankar Film but actually, the message that, people who put one person on top how at next moment they put them down this concept is not bad. The emotional scene at the end and the stunt was good but the problem is, just after Senapathy entry part the scenes where the people turn into Feminine, Horse etc. these can't be Shankar Sir's or any mature person's work that too by a serious character like "Senapathy". That part feels forced. I think it's true as people are saying, the climax should have been it's interval and Indian 3 should have been 2nd half. I think all these happened because of Handling two Projects together. Some people are saying that this was not even directed by Shankar Sir but his ADs. And after watching it, it's not very hard to believe that for me. The part where people starts misunderstanding Senapathy was actually Good and it could have turned into a Better Film but execution was very poor. I think he needs young and good screenplay writers. Maybe, he understands somewhere that's why he chose Karthick Subbaraj for "Game Changer". Let's see. Some people are blaming "Lyca Productions" and saying they forced Shankar Sir to make Indian 2 otherwise Shankar Sir left that project and started "Game Changer". People are saying they forced to make Indian 2 into two parts. Now I am getting, why Kamal Sir at first said that there's no need to split into two parts and why he is more interested in "Indian 3". Let's see.
it reminds of The Amazing spiderman 2 (2014) 😂 that film is the biggest budget, most good looking, best colour-graded, biggest scale spiderman film. But WITH NO SOUL & emotions... 😅😅 also a punching bag for the critics
Problem with Shankar is, he is full of himself and thinks whatever he do is a trendsetter but the reality is he's outdated and his direction style and template is so 2000.
@@SubaashNair TRUE.. his recent films are Full of self indulgence, he thinks whatever he finds fascinating and quirky audience will feel the same, he is living in his own bubble. Before he used to design his screenplay according to the writer, but now since he WRITES & DIRECTS. HE Adds all the childish stuff into it and thinks we'll find it amazing..,😕☹️
“ naazhigai” was one of the units of time in ancient Tamil Nadu. Twenty four minutes were equivalent to one naazhigai. Three and three fourths naazhigai made one muzhuttham ( 90 minutes). Two muzhutthams made one yaamam ( 180 minutes) and eight yaamams made one day (1440 minutes or 24 hours ) .
Another problem is that they wanted to make the 100+ year old Indian Senapathy into a super human.. they could have tried something like Liam Neeson .. of the Taken series. Instead we got something like T-1000/ Terminator -Anniyan
Varma Kala killed the movie! Instead movie would have been directly connected to Part-3 story (Senapathy explaining value of Independence) after Chitra A and team confronted Senapathy, with self exposure of corruption by family members.
Regarding that 7.5 mins - it was not 7.5 mins but basically he says 7.5 nazhigai (நாழிகை). நாழிகை is an ancient measurement existed in Tamil culture, where 1 நாழிகை= 24minutes. So he says he would be alive for 7.5 நாழிகை which means 168 minutes that equals 2.8 hours !
The guys who are telling this movie is semma super must be 2k kids those who hav not watched Indian1 and other Sankar sir, Sujatha sir, Crazy Sir Arr movies..... We are always blessed proud 90s kids cherished those
I think this review is really good by BR. 👍 But today is Sunday, so maybe some people will go watch the movie today and change their minds after this review. 👀🍿 And they're making this video with an advertisement for Indian 2 too. #Indian2 #MovieReview
What about the scenes in the hospital operation theatre, where rakul preet brother doing operation and patient daughter witnessing twice. It's a complete letdown. It seems theese scenes shot by Shankar's assistant. Because he is busy shooting gamechanger as well
Every review is negative. Feeling very bad to see an ace director of our times getting roasted this way. I still feel Sankar would come back with a strong, successful movie.
This is not Shankar version of Indian 2 , he fully written the scripted during admk time,but after DMK arrival he caught in fear to go ahead and changed the sequence to as many other state corruption issue,which largely diluted connectivity to local audience, which is unreal Shankar movies,with Kamal and udhayanidhi in back..he cannot dig anything in Tamilnadu to connect with audience,sad for him...being committed to movie during admk period he compromised everything to udhayanidhi
True even though Indian 2 is releasing in DMK period if Udhayanidhi hasn't joined Indian 2 as one of the partner shankar would have kept all scenes attacking tamilnadu government and making connect to the audience more interestingly that's missing Movies based on Corruption is a Shankar's play ground he failed in it because of DMK Joining hands with The movie team also he extended 1 movie into 2 parts thats why it is so dragging hope Indian 3 will be a Bang Movie like Indian (1996) 🔥🔥 I think senapathy will become Prime minister of India think so
The main reason this movie INDIAN 2 took nearly 7 years in making is because,...It all started with that Massive indoor shooting accident, in which shooting Staff and assistants died. Next day in the media, Kamal blamed the producer Subashkaran for not providing proper infrastructure and lack of involvement from producer Subhashkaran side. Subhashkaran shot back and responded to kamal stating that he(Subhashkaran) residing in a foreign country, cannot come and check each and everything in production, when the movie is being made,..the Indian 2 movie making responsibility was given to the director shankar and kamal and so they are completely responsible for that shooting set accident. THAT'S IT !..All hell broke loose, both the sides (kamal and producer) were in loggerheads and by the time their dirty EGO was about to get evaporated, DMK won 2021 Elections in TN and thus Red Giant got inside and made a truce, thus paving the way for the Indian 2 to resume shooting.
Shankar never give any credits sujatha that he deserved.apart from this main mistake of shankar is he never take time to observe and study or think he just always shoots without proper screenpaly..shankar should take rest for 3 year and observe whats happening around..then we can hope he may come up with something good..
I will tell you , Indian thatha should have come in the same last scene get up in continuation of Indian I , instead of so many disguise , also rethink new corruption short scenes , same corruption skits didn’t work
My assumption is the core idea was to have a single well developed sequel including the flashbacks but considering the delays, accidents, COVID must have stressed the producers and financiers to rush whatever was shot to be released and then release a 3rd sequel.
Hmm... I guess two cents of my view.... 1. People are so much used to corruption these days they see everyday and are like ok we saw this and know this it's part of our life... so be it I don't see anything new... 2. The story is fully about corruption within every family and what if every one becomes like Senapati and people are expose their own relatives and parents what are the consequences and the after effects ot that is shown very high and detailed in Siddharths house his girlfriends house and his friends house... and because of this the whole public is turning towards Indian Tatha... This seems like dragging but in my view Shankar is trying to show what is in everyone's house today as we all may have government servants and bribe takers in our own houses too.... and this movie is also a lead to part 3 as how Senapati is going to handle a whole world who is against him
Usually comedians do spoof od anniyan and indian. Shankar sir this time made a complete spoof himself . But marvel will use singke tyre vehicle near future
Hi BR, I agree to your understanding on this movie and mentioning the places where and all , the movie didn't work well with Audience. Especially, on the " Meow " mannerism, vfx of making thatha a body builder could have been avoided. the long dialogues on stats, which went as if news channel. Let me tell my POV, i see this movie has 1st half of one story. So, we have left with all these questions on Senapathy character valuation, the emotional connect and so many. It is the interval block, which has created these questions. We have to wait for the second half of the story as Indian 3, which may or should convince and support the making of Indian 2.
I don't think ageing of the hero in a movie is an issue. While there are many potential aspects to discuss, i dont know why all the critics discuss about this. This is a movie after all, should the hero get aged as the sequel progresses?
There's a promo released by LYCA which wasn't in the movie. In that promo, Bommy Simha character is seen explaining how is it possible for a 100+ year old man to be fit, strong and healthy still@@AbdulRahman-gb8wz
Focusing more on package and leaving the actual product un attended to a large extent is the major cause. Where as Sankar films in his prime will have a good content supported by sujatha sir, and then Sankar the crafts man mount it in huge scale which makes movie a visual spectacle. .
Dear BR, If you look at the credits of Indian (1996) movie , it clearly states வசனம் -சுஜாதா and திரைக்கதை உதவி - பாலகுமாரன் If it’s collaborative work, then there is no need or reason to put one person’s name under the credit. Sujatha sir’s dialogue contribution is one of the backbones of Shankar sir’s movies. Everyone know it. Period. And, Sujatha sir’s strength is not only Short stories as you blatantly stated! Besides a successful engineer, Sujatha sir was an intellectual writer, a seasoned novelist. Some of his novels which later came as movies are Gayathri, Vanam Vasappadum, Karaiyellam Shenbagappoo, Anandha Thandavam( Pirivom Sandhipom) and Priya.
“Y” kadaisiyilla mottai kadhara vittutanga….😅😅😂. Shankar sir ku “mirugha dhosham” irukku…Rajini “meow” in endhiran…kamal “meow” all bites him in the back😂😂😂
Should have skipped (or made the first 15-20 minutes Indian 2) and just gone straight to the story is Indian 3. There was no reason to break this into 2 three hour movies. This sequel feels like a ‘bait’ for Gen Z & Gen Alpha, so they’ll have a larger audience for Part 3!
Now im not looking forward to Indian 3 at all. Indian 2 was a terrible waste of the producer’s money. I really pity the producer Subaskaran. So disappointed after all that hype. I was just waiting for the movie to end. I felt like crying. Shankar shouldnt have taken Indian 2 at all. Indian 1 was such a fantastic movie. Now it has been blemished because of the crappy Indian 2 movie. How did KH allow this movie to be screened? As a movie technician himself, he should have seen all the flaws in the movie. I think we should just go and support the good small budget movies.
I'm hundred percent agree with u.maharaja and 12th fail for example.this kind of people still thinking the audience are stupid.we should stop watching this kind of rubbish.im a Kamal Hassan die hard fan.but I'm really angry and disappointed.
11:20 Please understand difference between minutes and naazhigai. Bobby simha climbing up by himself which is there in film Unicycle is not down because of battery empty, he took his leg off the pedal. everything was clear. I too dint like the film at all. But the points discussed in this conversation is similar to what shankar did. No depth.
Absolutely perfect analysis. Such huge talented team (Kamal ji, Sankar ji in particular), not delivering is really sad. Unable to think how Ulaganayagan involvement, esp in screenplay, picturisation is lacking / missing. Music is another key factor impacted a lot.
No Cap. Writer Sujatha was the backbone of Dr. Shankars Screen play. Its not like Dr. Shankar don’t have stuff. But at this stage, he should retire or break his pattern and come out new. Neither seems to be happening.
Siddarth realising then again will realize sacrifice has to done.... Plus all of us and our great grandparents realized already, nothing new on what you guys saying now.....
I like the movie ..from start to end it is not boring but .....the major drawback is each killings there is no proper justification, the scenes of scam involved with calendar guy or other business man are not shown so the killings are not justifiable , ,audience should get the feel to show vengeance against villain which is missing ..best example is nillgal Ravi scene in indian 1 ..next is in high secured area indian thata enters just like that ..
That's not a 7.5 minutes.. Hear properly That's 7.5 NAZHIGAI that means 3 hours... 1 NAZHIGAI means 24 minutes For ONE HOUR 2.5 NAZHIGAI 7.5 NAZHIGAI TOTALLY 3 HOURS HE MENTIONED
இந்தியன் படம் வெளியாகும் போது ஒரு கோடி மக்களில் 95 லட்சம் மக்கள் நல்லவர்கள் 5 லட்சம் மக்கள் தவறு செய்பவர்கள் இந்தியன் 2 வெளிவரும்போது ஒரு கோடி மக்களில் 95 லட்சம் மக்கள் தவறு செய்பவர்கள் 5 லட்சம் மக்கள் தவறு செய்யாதவர்கள் பிறகு எப்படி படத்தை நன்றாக இருக்கிறது என்று சொல்வார்கள்
We talk about lag in the movie, BR is keen on knowing how Bobby Simha rescues hanging from the flyover! OMG that was not a life threatening sequence to know how he escapes
![30 ชั่วโมงคนเดียว บนรถไฟชั้น 3 โซเวียต [Around The World Ep. 2]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MlE9boAVqDA/mqdefault.jpg)
![ค้างคืนโรงเก็บกระสวยอวกาศร้างกลางทะเลทราย [Around The World Ep. 3]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/E5bWZQhABJE/mqdefault.jpg)
One thing you missed sir in Part 1 Indian Thattha never speaks a lot but in Part 2 he speaks a lot 😮😮😮
Adhu 90s thara...idhu 2k kids thata
@@KawinAhamedpodaangothaa😭🚶🏿♂️🚶🏿♂️
He mentioned that in his review
That's Indian Thatha, This is Chandru
😂 true!
Fact is
Indian 2 and 3 are one film...
Go_back_indian scene suppose to come in interval right before senathipathi start to tell his flash back .
After interval, senathipathi flash back, big climax fight and conclusion...
BUT Shankar decide to use big scissors ✂️
SUJATA WOULD NEVER ALLOW THIS MADNESS
#COMEBACK AR.RAHMAN #INDIAN 3
yep. and same happened in bahubali. why kattappa killed bahubali is interval and bahubali 2 should have been second half.
If you notice closely bahubali 1 and 2 first half had lot of filler scens
bahubali 1 - multiple times trying to climb the mountain, pra bhas and thamannah escaping in ice boat etc.
bahubali 2 first half - that entire krishna song, killing 3 pigs and making subba raju from coward to veeran by giving motivational talk, how to use 3 ambu and teaching that to anushka etc..
Except kgf 1 and 2, and singam 1 and 2, all others were just to mint money. But Indian 2 avalo mosam illa. all they could have trimmed is that monowheel chase and train chase and then ambulance etc.
For me, I prefer a movie that provides a solution and giving hope than calling things as reality and fate. 1 change out of 1000000 problems is still a change.
@@LetsBeHuman
Kalki also
They put Prabhas intro scene like 20 minutes....
Sumathi abduction scene should happened in interval...
@@LetsBeHuman i agree with you on indian 2 but in bahubali 1, there are some time takes to enter whole world like maghizhmathi, i don't think they are fill up scenes, even in bahubali 2 there is nothing i found filling up
Well said
Shankar spoiled I, 2.0 , now indian2.. Always foucssing on songs grandiose locations, loosing focus on the real content
@mahinkhan3721If “I” was a masterpiece, why it didn’t do well in box office? The producer Aascar Ravichandran went bankrupt after that movie. Vikram acted very well. But story and screenplay didnt sit well with audience
2.0 kevlam dhane ana Wikipedia said highest grossing than bahubali I think. Such a boring movie 2.0 lam first larundhe bore
@@PandianNandhiniyes highest collection in Tamil cinema and more than Bahubali 1 .....
@mahinkhan3721 when were you born? In 2008 or 2009..then you have no idea who Shankar was before I. He was like double edged sword with sujatha writer. Even had some illiogical scenes and granduer but when it came to deliver sharp content like in mudalvan, anniyan and even robot , I cudnt meet that bar set by shankar himself.
I had nothing as a story you can invest in.. Vikram hard work was wasted. Villian was obviously known in the first scene Itself, nothing surprise. Then all about torturing people with weak dialogues.
@@HarishG-ik1kg ena koduma Saravanan idhu🤦
6:09 - same thing in sivaji also. Out of nowhere fight. Sivaji climax scene fight is absurd. basically Sanker is average from beginning.
Shankar lost it in 2015 when he marketed Vikram's "I" getup as a beauty and the beast concept...and making Vikram do the makeup in audio launch also...whereas in reality it was just for a song in the movie
#COMEBACK AR.RAHMAN #INDIAN 3
True
ஐ படத்தை தியேட்டர் ல பாத்துட்டு வாமிட் பீலிங் வந்து பிறகு சங்கர் படத்துக்கே போறதில்ல
'I' had no soul. I couldn't care less about vikram and Amy Jackson's love angle. It was not convincing and the whole thing was such a bore that I didn't even bother to finish watching the movie.
Exactly bro..I felt the same ..I was having a lot of expectations seeing vikram getup in audio launch ..booked fdfs and watched that it is only for a song is shocking to me...Shankar scam started from there 😮
I felt like Shankar made a comedy spoof of the brave Senapathy(Indian Thatha). Even Senapathy didn't do this much actions 28yrs ago!! The first one in 1996 was very suttle and engaging. I think Shankar wrote a script for 'Anniyan 2', & when he didn't get the dates of Chiyaan Vikram he proceeded with Kamal sir and gave the name 'Indian 2'. It has Vasantha Balan and Chimbudevan as second unit directors where we can pointout their portions. Varmam parts wre the most comical things in the entire movie!! Anirudh already said "Thatha vararu katharavida poraru".. Now everyone who watched the movie is feeling the katharal!!!
Subtle
💯 agreed... nonsense horse varma kalai
Which scenes do you think were handled by the second unit?
@@randomviewer779.1 those scenes of Thambi Ramayya and wife, Manobala scenes and scene of bank recovery agents in the village etc
@@rakeshkb2363 What made it stand out as not made by shankar?
Why can't movie team hire a reviewer with them and ask his honest opinions throughout the making and during post production?
Kamal has been in this industry for 60+ years. Ideally he must know better than the reviewers but he has messed up too often.
@@AK-mf9ho since he is a part of the movie he won't observe the faults. Even if he does, there would have been some critical circumstances to unsee them and move on.
It's because of the mindset of the movie maker.
They don't want to share the credits and fame., with some random reviewers...
For them, it's their movie...and they won't prefer to get viewers feedback like "Reviewers are the main reason for success"
Bcoz many reviewers criticized films becomes hit like Aranmanai 4
Ego.
Manorama achi scene dha main starting connect in Indian1. Senapathi go to repair his belt to aachi husband where he was killed. Andha connect eh rmbo nala irukum
Worst film of decade
Proves Shankar is time waste . Disaster films. I was irritating. 2.0 was waste of money . This was shit .
#COMEBACK AR.RAHMAN #INDIAN 3
Ole
😅
Who's that dialogue writer who wrote the line for Bobby simha
" APPA ENNA ASIRVANDHAM PANNUNGA NA INDIAN THATHA PIDICHU JANATHIPATHI KITTA GOLD MEDAL VANGA PORIEN"
soothula Gold medal..😤
I felt excited about that dialogue,and Bobby simha the cop is stylish looking, award winning actor🎉🎉
If Indian 3 works out all this will be gone.
@@rajeshrajappan2446 coz of his presence the film lost all seriousness.. He looked like a comedy piece..
3 writers nalla op adichurukaainga..jeyamohan, kabilan vairamuthu, lakshmi saravanakumar..Antha common man animation pesura dialogue laam etho first time short film edukra amateur eluthura dialogue maathiri padu kevalama irunthuchu
Hahahahahahahahhahahah soothula gold medal 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 just cracked me up bro
As a True Shankar Sir Fan, Shankar Sir need Good and Young Screenplay writers. Could be a Good Film but Screenplay is very Poor. Wish Shankar Sir would understand and see to it.
Not just the writing, the screenplay itself was really flawed. I wondered if this was really Shankar’s movie
@@thamaraik1773 I too can't believe it's a Shankar Film but actually, the message that, people who put one person on top how at next moment they put them down this concept is not bad. The emotional scene at the end and the stunt was good but the problem is, just after Senapathy entry part the scenes where the people turn into Feminine, Horse etc. these can't be Shankar Sir's or any mature person's work that too by a serious character like "Senapathy". That part feels forced. I think it's true as people are saying, the climax should have been it's interval and Indian 3 should have been 2nd half. I think all these happened because of Handling two Projects together. Some people are saying that this was not even directed by Shankar Sir but his ADs. And after watching it, it's not very hard to believe that for me. The part where people starts misunderstanding Senapathy was actually Good and it could have turned into a Better Film but execution was very poor. I think he needs young and good screenplay writers. Maybe, he understands somewhere that's why he chose Karthick Subbaraj for "Game Changer". Let's see. Some people are blaming "Lyca Productions" and saying they forced Shankar Sir to make Indian 2 otherwise Shankar Sir left that project and started "Game Changer". People are saying they forced to make Indian 2 into two parts. Now I am getting, why Kamal Sir at first said that there's no need to split into two parts and why he is more interested in "Indian 3". Let's see.
it reminds of The Amazing spiderman 2 (2014) 😂 that film is the biggest budget, most good looking, best colour-graded, biggest scale spiderman film. But WITH NO SOUL & emotions... 😅😅 also a punching bag for the critics
Problem with Shankar is, he is full of himself and thinks whatever he do is a trendsetter but the reality is he's outdated and his direction style and template is so 2000.
@@SubaashNair TRUE.. his recent films are Full of self indulgence, he thinks whatever he finds fascinating and quirky audience will feel the same, he is living in his own bubble. Before he used to design his screenplay according to the writer, but now since he WRITES & DIRECTS. HE Adds all the childish stuff into it and thinks we'll find it amazing..,😕☹️
The Baddy I missed for a long long time .. The Baddy whose Indian Express columns were we fav
Daiii daiii inthaa padathuku TH-cam title la spoiler alert ahaa daa ......😂😂😂😂😂😂
Yen, potta enna ippo?
Chill.. you can't take a joke?
@@aswinbio1 podalam thappu illa adhuku movie la story nu one irukanum yaa...🥴😭
why so much hype about an average director?
“ naazhigai” was one of the units of time in ancient Tamil Nadu. Twenty four minutes were equivalent to one naazhigai. Three and three fourths naazhigai made one muzhuttham ( 90 minutes). Two muzhutthams made one yaamam ( 180 minutes) and eight yaamams made one day (1440 minutes or 24 hours ) .
Another problem is that they wanted to make the 100+ year old Indian Senapathy into a super human.. they could have tried something like Liam Neeson .. of the Taken series. Instead we got something like T-1000/ Terminator -Anniyan
Varma Kala killed the movie! Instead movie would have been directly connected to Part-3 story (Senapathy explaining value of Independence) after Chitra A and team confronted Senapathy, with self exposure of corruption by family members.
Regarding that 7.5 mins - it was not 7.5 mins but basically he says 7.5 nazhigai (நாழிகை).
நாழிகை is an ancient measurement existed in Tamil culture, where 1 நாழிகை= 24minutes. So he says he would be alive for 7.5 நாழிகை which means 168 minutes that equals 2.8 hours !
Brilliant !!
The guys who are telling this movie is semma super must be 2k kids those who hav not watched Indian1 and other Sankar sir, Sujatha sir, Crazy Sir Arr movies..... We are always blessed proud 90s kids cherished those
I think this review is really good by BR. 👍
But today is Sunday, so maybe some people will go watch the movie today and change their minds after this review. 👀🍿
And they're making this video with an advertisement for Indian 2 too. #Indian2 #MovieReview
What about the scenes in the hospital operation theatre, where rakul preet brother doing operation and patient daughter witnessing twice. It's a complete letdown. It seems theese scenes shot by Shankar's assistant. Because he is busy shooting gamechanger as well
Should have been only 1 movie ...no two parts..
Dude why showing the advertisement that Indian 2 is running successfully
True! 🤣
Caste paaka matomnu solra political leader channels la vanniyar or Nadar matrimony Ad podra madrithan
ticket la vitta kasa eduka than😂
padatha criticize pannikittu adhey padathuku Advertaisment podra paathiya Galatta😂😂
Every review is negative. Feeling very bad to see an ace director of our times getting roasted this way. I still feel Sankar would come back with a strong, successful movie.
Shankar's thought process is itself wrong, how is a man who behaves like a woman after varma kalai is funny or a punishment, it's nonsense
This is not Shankar version of Indian 2 , he fully written the scripted during admk time,but after DMK arrival he caught in fear to go ahead and changed the sequence to as many other state corruption issue,which largely diluted connectivity to local audience, which is unreal Shankar movies,with Kamal and udhayanidhi in back..he cannot dig anything in Tamilnadu to connect with audience,sad for him...being committed to movie during admk period he compromised everything to udhayanidhi
True even though Indian 2 is releasing in DMK period if Udhayanidhi hasn't joined Indian 2 as one of the partner shankar would have kept all scenes attacking tamilnadu government and making connect to the audience more interestingly that's missing
Movies based on Corruption is a Shankar's play ground he failed in it because of DMK Joining hands with The movie team also he extended 1 movie into 2 parts thats why it is so dragging hope Indian 3 will be a Bang Movie like Indian (1996) 🔥🔥 I think senapathy will become Prime minister of India think so
The main reason this movie INDIAN 2 took nearly 7 years in making is because,...It all started with that Massive indoor shooting accident, in which shooting Staff and assistants died.
Next day in the media, Kamal blamed the producer Subashkaran for not providing proper infrastructure and lack of involvement from producer Subhashkaran side.
Subhashkaran shot back and responded to kamal stating that he(Subhashkaran) residing in a foreign country, cannot come and check each and everything in production, when the movie is being made,..the Indian 2 movie making responsibility was given to the director shankar and kamal and so they are completely responsible for that shooting set accident. THAT'S IT !..All hell broke loose, both the sides (kamal and producer) were in loggerheads and by the time their dirty EGO was about to get evaporated, DMK won 2021 Elections in TN and thus Red Giant got inside and made a truce, thus paving the way for the Indian 2 to resume shooting.
10:57 I think they said 7.5 naaligai. 1 naaligai = 24 mins
Shankar never give any credits sujatha that he deserved.apart from this main mistake of shankar is he never take time to observe and study or think he just always shoots without proper screenpaly..shankar should take rest for 3 year and observe whats happening around..then we can hope he may come up with something good..
I will tell you , Indian thatha should have come in the same last scene get up in continuation of Indian I , instead of so many disguise , also rethink new corruption short scenes , same corruption skits didn’t work
8:00, 9:06, I dont think I have seen anyone sipping their coffee with their tongue out...i tried myself just to confirm 😆🤣
Cat bro avaru😂😂
Sema observation.felt funny
well said..sad that director shankar once was celebrated greatly for his movies now seems to have lost his touch when it comes to the story
My assumption is the core idea was to have a single well developed sequel including the flashbacks but considering the delays, accidents, COVID must have stressed the producers and financiers to rush whatever was shot to be released and then release a 3rd sequel.
Yeah but you can't take the audience for granted.
Shankar spoiled kamal sir’s growth
10:58. It is not 7.5 mins. It is 7.5 naazhigais. 1 naazhigai is 24 mins. So it is 3 hrs.
AR rahaman music ah ANI repeat podrudhukku ar podavachikkallam
correct me if i'm wrong, its not 7 and half minutes it's 2 and half hours.
I think it's 7 days
bro its 7 naaligai it means 7 hours
Andha anchor 7 naaligai na 7 nimisham nu nenachutanga
ezharai naaligai (7.5 naaligai ). 1 naaligai = 24 mins . 24*7.5 = 180 minutes = 3 hours
Hmm... I guess two cents of my view....
1. People are so much used to corruption these days they see everyday and are like ok we saw this and know this it's part of our life... so be it I don't see anything new...
2. The story is fully about corruption within every family and what if every one becomes like Senapati and people are expose their own relatives and parents what are the consequences and the after effects ot that is shown very high and detailed in Siddharths house his girlfriends house and his friends house... and because of this the whole public is turning towards Indian Tatha...
This seems like dragging but in my view Shankar is trying to show what is in everyone's house today as we all may have government servants and bribe takers in our own houses too.... and this movie is also a lead to part 3 as how Senapati is going to handle a whole world who is against him
This interview was hard to watch, you could have edited out when he says .....See......
Good interview. Connected 100% with BR’s thoughts 👍🏻
Excessive footage was made into 1st part.... That's wat dint work out in Indian 2
11.00 7.5 naazhigai... 1 naazhigai = 24 minutes
Usually comedians do spoof od anniyan and indian. Shankar sir this time made a complete spoof himself . But marvel will use singke tyre vehicle near future
Hi BR, I agree to your understanding on this movie and mentioning the places where and all , the movie didn't work well with Audience. Especially, on the " Meow " mannerism, vfx of making thatha a body builder could have been avoided. the long dialogues on stats, which went as if news channel.
Let me tell my POV, i see this movie has 1st half of one story. So, we have left with all these questions on Senapathy character valuation, the emotional connect and so many. It is the interval block, which has created these questions.
We have to wait for the second half of the story as Indian 3, which may or should convince and support the making of Indian 2.
They should establish this movie as Indian new world,than Indian 2
I don't think ageing of the hero in a movie is an issue. While there are many potential aspects to discuss, i dont know why all the critics discuss about this. This is a movie after all, should the hero get aged as the sequel progresses?
It's really important becoz they have shown the year.
Logically we would think how can this Oldman can even walk.
There's a promo released by LYCA which wasn't in the movie. In that promo, Bommy Simha character is seen explaining how is it possible for a 100+ year old man to be fit, strong and healthy still@@AbdulRahman-gb8wz
Oz that's what Tamil Nadu all about
Love watch conflict movies ,
Pichaikarans which that the development they have in their country !!
Kamal and Shankar become DMK somboooos 😅😅😂😂
That's why this movie is a scam😂
No cant say coz a lot is in the line, huge money and market , it's a tactic, even tmrw if BJP Or admk anyone is in power its the same situation
A more relevant question is why Maharaja didnt worked for you?
It didn’t work for anyone 😢
It'll be very interesting to see Bharadwaj Rangan come up with a story and direct it.
Bgm scored not matched
Focusing more on package and leaving the actual product un attended to a large extent is the major cause. Where as Sankar films in his prime will have a good content supported by sujatha sir, and then Sankar the crafts man mount it in huge scale which makes movie a visual spectacle. .
Anniyan works, main reason is Sujatha Sir dialogue writer.
8:35 to 9:00
Should save some money . No need nonsense setup like the gold palace all or the space setup all
Dear BR,
If you look at the credits of Indian (1996) movie , it clearly states வசனம் -சுஜாதா and திரைக்கதை உதவி - பாலகுமாரன்
If it’s collaborative work, then there is no need or reason to put one person’s name under the credit. Sujatha sir’s dialogue contribution is one of the backbones of Shankar sir’s movies. Everyone know it. Period.
And, Sujatha sir’s strength is not only Short stories as you blatantly stated! Besides a successful engineer, Sujatha sir was an intellectual writer, a seasoned novelist. Some of his novels which later came as movies are Gayathri, Vanam Vasappadum, Karaiyellam Shenbagappoo, Anandha Thandavam( Pirivom Sandhipom) and Priya.
If I want to advice me shankar, Don’t ever do any part 2 or 3 for previous movie esp muthalvan. Let it be as good as that. Don’t spoil own creation
Dexter is simply Outstanding
Suits you all when Says naigalah !
“Y” kadaisiyilla mottai kadhara vittutanga….😅😅😂. Shankar sir ku “mirugha dhosham” irukku…Rajini “meow” in endhiran…kamal “meow” all bites him in the back😂😂😂
very good analysis...hopefully indian3 should bounce back
Oru naazhigai is equal to 24 minutes so 7.5 naazhigai is equal to 180 minutes ie., 03 hrs..
Siddhars have lived with such physical strength... But could have been portrayed well.
இந்த படமே ஊழல் தான்.சேர்ககைய பார்த்தாலே தெரிஞ்சுக்கலாம்😂
Main miss are Koundamani Sir and Senthil Sir
Should have skipped (or made the first 15-20 minutes Indian 2) and just gone straight to the story is Indian 3. There was no reason to break this into 2 three hour movies.
This sequel feels like a ‘bait’ for Gen Z & Gen Alpha, so they’ll have a larger audience for Part 3!
Dialogued by sujatha ❤
Many forgotten 😢
Sad thing is both kamal and Shankar killed their own classic product :-/
Now im not looking forward to Indian 3 at all. Indian 2 was a terrible waste of the producer’s money. I really pity the producer Subaskaran. So disappointed after all that hype. I was just waiting for the movie to end. I felt like crying. Shankar shouldnt have taken Indian 2 at all. Indian 1 was such a fantastic movie. Now it has been blemished because of the crappy Indian 2 movie. How did KH allow this movie to be screened? As a movie technician himself, he should have seen all the flaws in the movie. I think we should just go and support the good small budget movies.
I am also wondering the same how KH doesn't act on it..
I'm hundred percent agree with u.maharaja and 12th fail for example.this kind of people still thinking the audience are stupid.we should stop watching this kind of rubbish.im a Kamal Hassan die hard fan.but I'm really angry and disappointed.
The same kind of scenes are in the Boys movie also
Shankar is badly missing Mr Sujatha
Interviewer ke inteeview aa😂
Movie is not so bad as said by our genius reviewers
11:20 Please understand difference between minutes and naazhigai.
Bobby simha climbing up by himself which is there in film
Unicycle is not down because of battery empty, he took his leg off the pedal. everything was clear.
I too dint like the film at all. But the points discussed in this conversation is similar to what shankar did. No depth.
Absolutely perfect analysis. Such huge talented team (Kamal ji, Sankar ji in particular), not delivering is really sad. Unable to think how Ulaganayagan involvement, esp in screenplay, picturisation is lacking / missing. Music is another key factor impacted a lot.
25:13 athe than venom kum eddie solluvan... naatula thappu panravanga athigam ah irukanga.. shop lah oruthan ah apdiye muzhungiduvanga...
No Cap. Writer Sujatha was the backbone of Dr. Shankars Screen play. Its not like Dr. Shankar don’t have stuff. But at this stage, he should retire or break his pattern and come out new. Neither seems to be happening.
is there a part 2 to this discussion, felt like it ended abruptly.
Very well pointed out the execution and film is disastrous not even close to part 1 🤘🏻💯🎥🎬🎞
Same feeling sir. Saaaaameee feeling ❤❤😢😢😢😢
13:44 very true 💔
Siddarth realising then again will realize sacrifice has to done.... Plus all of us and our great grandparents realized already, nothing new on what you guys saying now.....
I like the movie ..from start to end it is not boring but .....the major drawback is each killings there is no proper justification, the scenes of scam involved with calendar guy or other business man are not shown so the killings are not justifiable , ,audience should get the feel to show vengeance against villain which is missing ..best example is nillgal Ravi scene in indian 1 ..next is in high secured area indian thata enters just like that ..
That's not a
7.5 minutes..
Hear properly
That's
7.5 NAZHIGAI
that means
3 hours...
1 NAZHIGAI
means 24 minutes
For ONE HOUR
2.5 NAZHIGAI
7.5 NAZHIGAI
TOTALLY 3 HOURS
HE MENTIONED
Yeah.. movie olunga paakama review solaradhu correct ah nu theriyala 🤷♀️
இந்தியன் படம் வெளியாகும் போது ஒரு கோடி மக்களில் 95 லட்சம் மக்கள் நல்லவர்கள் 5 லட்சம் மக்கள் தவறு செய்பவர்கள் இந்தியன் 2 வெளிவரும்போது ஒரு கோடி மக்களில் 95 லட்சம் மக்கள் தவறு செய்பவர்கள் 5 லட்சம் மக்கள் தவறு செய்யாதவர்கள் பிறகு எப்படி படத்தை நன்றாக இருக்கிறது என்று சொல்வார்கள்
I read the subtitle. It said 3.5 hours. Yeah I guess reviewer didn't see the movie with subtitles.
Indian 2 is a solid lesson to shankar
Bhardwaj sir ah vida....... Anchorr mam Correctah pesuranga script and scenes ah pathi ....... Well done mam............
Most important thing is…… we missed Kamal’s fabulous screenplay
If sujatha sir there may be it will work.
We talk about lag in the movie, BR is keen on knowing how Bobby Simha rescues hanging from the flyover! OMG that was not a life threatening sequence to know how he escapes
Well said Anna...
Lovely Interview Dear Sweetie Tara... Great
💌
#COMEBACK AR.RAHMAN #INDIAN 3
@@SOONAPAANA_ yes same pinch... Shocked...
Indian 1 will always be the best.
TATA VARRARU KATEREH UDEH PORARU ...anirudh gave hint beforehand but you all went despite the warnings ....
First time whole cenima lovers kazhuvi utharanga da intha padamtha
Baradwaj must work with Shankar
This movie is "Counter-hegeminic"
The main reason Shankar is failing in the screenplay is Sujatha is not alive
Do u saw her writings before 🌚
Is she not alive 🌚
😀He is a male and he’s a genius in writing screenplays and dialogue .his real name is rangarajan ..please google it
@@rockey4631 Sujata is a guy da venna mavane
I watched india-2 . It's a great and fantastic movie
Because only "Star" kind of films work for him
Sujatha wrote only dialogues in Indian. Not the story and screenplay
Why should it work for you???