ehh to me the older stuff looks better /more effect esp with gigi in my op she went down hill hard compared to the art in the books... the game ehh 50/50...
The art direction for the movie is way better. I like how well told the light novel is, but snippets of art in LNs tend to be quick and simple to make you get an idea of how everything looks a bit better without going into extreme detail. Great editing and visual flair, keep up the good work.
Lane Aim probably has the least of amount changes compared to everyone else. Second would probably be Hathaway himself. The new redesign look overall more realistic in comparison and fits better in our modern world. Gigi looks like an exaggerated galactic 80s sci-fi princess in her older design which is fine for that era, but feels a bit out of place if the design was kept for today. Hathaway like other modern UC series like Unicorn, Thunderbolt, and Origins not just have character fashion change, all surrounding technology beside the Mobile Suits fit our modern perspective of futuristic technology with computer screens being slimmer to the point that you can literally fold it like paper as seen in Unicorn instead of the 0079 perspective where is more like the Jetson in which they keep the box television of the time and put wheels on it.
Minor correction: The RX-104FF is just Penelope, not Penelope Gundam. That's because it's a combination of the RX-104 Odysseus Gundam and the Fixed Flight unit.
@@FuruHataNinzaburo-w8z I recall Penelope was just that in the novel, then later expanded to being a combination of Odysseus Gundam and the Fixed Flight Unit
I really like what theu did with the Xi-G and Penelope. When it comes to their designs, you can tell that they are related suits. But unlike the Penelope which is just the Odyseus with a bunch of stuff piled on, the Xi is way more streamlined and looks like something thats entirely new. This kinda reflects the differences and simularities between Mafty and the Federation. Both are monsterous behemoths, but they are monsterous in their own ways. The Penelope has dark and menacing colours and a silhouette that barely resembles a ms. The Xi has lighter, almost angelic colours but has the proportions of a beast.
Really hope Hathway gets the soft Kamille development. I remember watching Zeta and absolutely hating Kamille, but as the series went and Char took him under his wing, he became one of my most favorite Gundam characters. This is also my favorite Char arc. As for Kusi Gundam - I love the classic, sharp and angled look typical of Katoki. Though he is not as sleek as Zeta, Hi - Nu R92 v2 or Nu Gundam, he is still one of my favorite designs. Also, is it me or does Gigi look like a Russian fashion model lol. That being said, I love the redesign of each character.
In my opinion Hathaway is getting the soft kamile development , even though this is just the first of three movies it feels like Hathaway has become a fair bit more developed.
I personally love the redesigns and the fact that they are actually keeping pace with the modern UC style. Even the newer redone scenes in the original film trilogy and Zeta films match up as well as the amazing Origins ovas. Makes me wish they would go and remake the original series and Zeta. These days the more serious tones are more accepted and taking out some of the goofiness from the original series and zeta would greatly benefit both stories imo. Plus, newer/younger anime fans would greatly benefit from having a more up to date animation telling such an amazing and heartbreaking tale.
Character designs were definitely an improvement - especially in how much more appealing Gawman looks in 2021 than in his original design. I can also empathize more with new Hathaway's face - something about his first design's face was off-putting, or had some more sinister vibes. The Xi's new redesign is a mixed bag: the overall feel and surface resolutions are much better (original concepts were very interesting but weren't as fleshed out nor felt as practical to make as war machines), but certain areas are a bit overdone, like the central chest area which has a messier read. I also liked the traditional double v-fin rather than the exaggerated curved one of new Xi. The mechanical and functional details for the new Xi are amazing, but Katoki's design is still the best in shape proportions though IMO. Great research and work in putting this together! Also Steven, what kind of design work do you do?
That's like how the things was done on that time, novel Hathaway looks perfect at 90's, the game 2000 was ok at the start but don't taked the age well and the movie design looks how good they matured the art with a new design for future.
I love Hathaway Noa's design in the movies. He closely resembles Bright Noa when he was younger. I wonder, in the second and third movie, will Bright Noa show up to deal his son's shenanigan?
@@janlim0916 spoiler option didn't work lol, it just shows it and I'm not sure how I feel about that ending, this movie made me like noa but staying fateful to the original and the message it gives out is important to maintain
The movie versions are better for me. The novel versions used too much of pre-existing designs as a nod to other tomino characters but since it's now 2020/2021, the fashion sense and the changes is more fitting for the setting.
I personally like the movie version of the Xi a lot. It has a much more neutral color scheme overall, and the bits of color are tastefully used as accents. It gives it a more mature, rebellious kind of vibe, like the Nu gundam
Sunrise took notes from the novel character and mobile suit design language and iterated heavily from there to give it its own distinct anime look and feel, rather than relying on the designs that came from the games as the base.
MS Design WIse, I've always been a Katoki fan ever since early 2000's from Super Robot Wars (and "lul long legz" meme). New character designs seem very typical of recent UC streamlining. All the redesigns move into more realistic features and handsome/beauty look while the game art seems more reminiscent of classic character design (more outrageous). Of course, I'm not saying the older/game style looks better but I can't help but to think Sunrise tends to move into the more serious tone now (except for that goofy Narrative pose from the poster). I personally didn't care much about novel stuff back then so Sentinel, Hathaway's Flash and Gaia Gear weren't very interesting except for the ALICE system, S Gundam and it's line of MS (EX-S and Deep Striker). I really did love Ecole du Ciel, Zeta side story and Tokyo Pop went bankrupt right before revealing the Le Cygne (in volume 7 or 8?). Haruhiko Mikimoto did character art for Hathaway's Flash and was the main artist for the manga, Ecole du Ciel.
I already watched Mobile Suit Gundam Hathaway movie. I love it! So good and so beautiful anime film. I watched your video with a question at the end. I voted all of character and mobile suit designs are best from the movie version!
The original design more closely resemble to Macross while the anime version looks closer to reality (except the Gustav Karl, where the EFF symbol mark like the big "X" and tell everyone please shoot here).
One thing I know on the master grade Wing Zero Gundam Ver.Ka. For whatever reason on my kit the thigh SWIVEL is very tight. Every time when I move it, it feels like I’m gonna break it. And I’m not sure if I’m doing something wrong when I was building it or if it’s a common thing for other kits.
The Realism feeling of The Movie Version is spot on. I like it better than The Other Version. The Person is like actual Person. The Gundam Design also Feel like Down to earth Than Stylized.
@xxnike629xx Speaking of, it will be better too if you talk again about my HGUC kit being *NOT* a P-Bandai. Hope you'll... Do it! Do it! Do it! huehuehue
I loved everything about Gundam Hathaway except the actual Gundam designs. They look so flippin wierd! I would of preferred something a but more traditional looking design wise, like the RX-78 or the Mk-II or even something similar to the Nu Gundam
Davvero complimenti per l'idea. Questo video ci voleva sul serio. Spero seguirete - anche se è un pò complicato - l'evoluzione della trilogia. ( Really well done for the idea. This video was serious. I hope you will follow - even if it is a little complicated - the evolution of the trilogy. )...
I like to believe its because if Bandai were to release the Gustav type 00 as P Bandai All they have to do is to change the head of P Bandai Gustav from Gihreen Greed and add some new decals.
![[#2024MAMA] BIGBANG (빅뱅) - 뱅뱅뱅 (BANG BANG BANG) + FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EQsYfiPR9uM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Alexandros] - Senkou](/img/n.gif)
The new designs are actually better tbh.
Hathaway looks like he's Bright Noa's son this time around.
hathway looks like bright in zeta
ehh to me the older stuff looks better /more effect esp with gigi in my op she went down hill hard compared to the art in the books... the game ehh 50/50...
He has his mother's eyes and hair 😭
@@MarioSupersonic nah you just can't get away from the past and that's cool too you know
@@Asphyx12 Old types are always that way🚬
The art direction for the movie is way better. I like how well told the light novel is, but snippets of art in LNs tend to be quick and simple to make you get an idea of how everything looks a bit better without going into extreme detail.
Great editing and visual flair, keep up the good work.
🙏
Lane Aim probably has the least of amount changes compared to everyone else. Second would probably be Hathaway himself. The new redesign look overall more realistic in comparison and fits better in our modern world. Gigi looks like an exaggerated galactic 80s sci-fi princess in her older design which is fine for that era, but feels a bit out of place if the design was kept for today. Hathaway like other modern UC series like Unicorn, Thunderbolt, and Origins not just have character fashion change, all surrounding technology beside the Mobile Suits fit our modern perspective of futuristic technology with computer screens being slimmer to the point that you can literally fold it like paper as seen in Unicorn instead of the 0079 perspective where is more like the Jetson in which they keep the box television of the time and put wheels on it.
The game version looks like a genderbent Mineva Zabi
Minor correction: The RX-104FF is just Penelope, not Penelope Gundam. That's because it's a combination of the RX-104 Odysseus Gundam and the Fixed Flight unit.
👍👍 you are correct, it’s the FF mode of Odysseus, thanks, oops
Was that setting ever in the novel? I always remembered it to be something they randomly added to the story retroactively.
@@FuruHataNinzaburo-w8z I recall Penelope was just that in the novel, then later expanded to being a combination of Odysseus Gundam and the Fixed Flight Unit
Only 30 secs in and this is really well done!
💪thank you!
I really like what theu did with the Xi-G and Penelope. When it comes to their designs, you can tell that they are related suits. But unlike the Penelope which is just the Odyseus with a bunch of stuff piled on, the Xi is way more streamlined and looks like something thats entirely new. This kinda reflects the differences and simularities between Mafty and the Federation. Both are monsterous behemoths, but they are monsterous in their own ways. The Penelope has dark and menacing colours and a silhouette that barely resembles a ms. The Xi has lighter, almost angelic colours but has the proportions of a beast.
Not to mention the Penelope has those sinister reddish/pinkish eye lenses.
What I notice is that especially the head, the movie version is really close to the novel art of Xi Gundam, when compared to Katoki Ver.
Really hope Hathway gets the soft Kamille development. I remember watching Zeta and absolutely hating Kamille, but as the series went and Char took him under his wing, he became one of my most favorite Gundam characters. This is also my favorite Char arc.
As for Kusi Gundam - I love the classic, sharp and angled look typical of Katoki. Though he is not as sleek as Zeta, Hi - Nu R92 v2 or Nu Gundam, he is still one of my favorite designs.
Also, is it me or does Gigi look like a Russian fashion model lol. That being said, I love the redesign of each character.
In my opinion Hathaway is getting the soft kamile development
, even though this is just the first of three movies it feels like Hathaway has become a fair bit more developed.
Only if tomino don't add the tragic of all times to kamille. Its much worse to live without memory than die on the battlefield
I personally love the redesigns and the fact that they are actually keeping pace with the modern UC style. Even the newer redone scenes in the original film trilogy and Zeta films match up as well as the amazing Origins ovas.
Makes me wish they would go and remake the original series and Zeta. These days the more serious tones are more accepted and taking out some of the goofiness from the original series and zeta would greatly benefit both stories imo.
Plus, newer/younger anime fans would greatly benefit from having a more up to date animation telling such an amazing and heartbreaking tale.
The song is called The Racer by Tristan Barton
Its so nice to see gundam back in action, cant wait for the rest of the trilogy
I just noticed that all the characters in Hathaway are fairly good looking and all of their outfits and uniforms are on point.
they did such a good job on the character designs for the movie
Too good in fact.
Character designs were definitely an improvement - especially in how much more appealing Gawman looks in 2021 than in his original design. I can also empathize more with new Hathaway's face - something about his first design's face was off-putting, or had some more sinister vibes. The Xi's new redesign is a mixed bag: the overall feel and surface resolutions are much better (original concepts were very interesting but weren't as fleshed out nor felt as practical to make as war machines), but certain areas are a bit overdone, like the central chest area which has a messier read. I also liked the traditional double v-fin rather than the exaggerated curved one of new Xi. The mechanical and functional details for the new Xi are amazing, but Katoki's design is still the best in shape proportions though IMO.
Great research and work in putting this together! Also Steven, what kind of design work do you do?
The chest area really does bother me but i really like how huge and bulky the arms are
Old concet want recreate a OYW crews
Hathaway> Amuro
Keneth> char
Gawman> Kai
Gigi > Sela x Lala (i guess)
Emeralda > Sela (i guess)
Mihssia > Frawbow
the movie design is just the novel design im suprise they keep the design i actually like it more than kantoki it just looks powerful
That's like how the things was done on that time, novel Hathaway looks perfect at 90's, the game 2000 was ok at the start but don't taked the age well and the movie design looks how good they matured the art with a new design for future.
I love Hathaway Noa's design in the movies. He closely resembles Bright Noa when he was younger. I wonder, in the second and third movie, will Bright Noa show up to deal his son's shenanigan?
SPOILER:
He shows up at Hathaway's execution, not knowing who Mafti really is.
@@janlim0916 spoiler option didn't work lol, it just shows it and I'm not sure how I feel about that ending, this movie made me like noa but staying fateful to the original and the message it gives out is important to maintain
I wait for all 3 movies out then watch at once
Pretty much know the whole story anyway I hate cliffhangers lol
The movie versions are better for me. The novel versions used too much of pre-existing designs as a nod to other tomino characters but since it's now 2020/2021, the fashion sense and the changes is more fitting for the setting.
?
I personally like the movie version of the Xi a lot. It has a much more neutral color scheme overall, and the bits of color are tastefully used as accents. It gives it a more mature, rebellious kind of vibe, like the Nu gundam
I like that they gave the Gustav Karl and Messer more recognizable designs as being evolutions of the Jegan and Geara Doga
Sunrise took notes from the novel character and mobile suit design language and iterated heavily from there to give it its own distinct anime look and feel, rather than relying on the designs that came from
the games as the base.
The new character designs look good, but I really wish they went with the Katoki design of the Xi Gundam.
@Falcon Hyperion Not sure if Katoki did that design specifically the movie, but I know it's primarily based on the novel design for sure.
the new designs add way more diversity and are way more interesting
they made Gawman look cool in the movie
awesome editing btw!
Gigi had the biggest glow up of all of them, damn.
Exactly what I wanted to see. Thanks
MS Design WIse, I've always been a Katoki fan ever since early 2000's from Super Robot Wars (and "lul long legz" meme).
New character designs seem very typical of recent UC streamlining. All the redesigns move into more realistic features and handsome/beauty look while the game art seems more reminiscent of classic character design (more outrageous). Of course, I'm not saying the older/game style looks better but I can't help but to think Sunrise tends to move into the more serious tone now (except for that goofy Narrative pose from the poster).
I personally didn't care much about novel stuff back then so Sentinel, Hathaway's Flash and Gaia Gear weren't very interesting except for the ALICE system, S Gundam and it's line of MS (EX-S and Deep Striker).
I really did love Ecole du Ciel, Zeta side story and Tokyo Pop went bankrupt right before revealing the Le Cygne (in volume 7 or 8?). Haruhiko Mikimoto did character art for Hathaway's Flash and was the main artist for the manga, Ecole du Ciel.
The movie i feel has the most realistic designs, as in more fitting to the charecters.
This video has made me addicted to your channel. I'm waiting for the next video. haha
To be fair, the game doesn't have a lot of budget so it makes sense they are not that well designed.
Well made comparison video! I like the new look better.
Thanks!
The new designs look more solid honestly, it feels more natural than the manga which has more vibrant colours
The designs and cinematography is wayy more modern and mature in the 2021 movie!!! Wow! 😁😁
I like how the Messer looks like something that was taken from the Titans.
wow most of the mobile suits look identical with minor differences to the novel.
nice video dude , we need more video like this (UC Timeline)
That music was too epic🤤
You know it's 2000's Gundam when every characters have colorful hair colour.
I already watched Mobile Suit Gundam Hathaway movie. I love it! So good and so beautiful anime film. I watched your video with a question at the end. I voted all of character and mobile suit designs are best from the movie version!
movie design all the way
my friend bought the Mechanicore 1/100 Penelope 8 years ago when he was 17y/o
im really diggin the aesthetics of this vid. easily could pass as official quality
💪💪
The original design more closely resemble to Macross while the anime version looks closer to reality (except the Gustav Karl, where the EFF symbol mark like the big "X" and tell everyone please shoot here).
Kinda weird you didn't took some photos from the Mobile Gundam Extreme Vs. MAXI Boost ON
The novel version of the Gustav Karl looks fucking awesome
One thing I know on the master grade Wing Zero Gundam Ver.Ka. For whatever reason on my kit the thigh SWIVEL is very tight. Every time when I move it, it feels like I’m gonna break it. And I’m not sure if I’m doing something wrong when I was building it or if it’s a common thing for other kits.
Hi, may I know what is the music you used in this video? Thanks.😁
I absolutely loved this take on Hathaway, and his flash backs
So was the character named after the young actor who played boxy in the original Battle Star Galactica?
The Realism feeling of The Movie Version is spot on. I like it better than The Other Version. The Person is like actual Person. The Gundam Design also Feel like Down to earth Than Stylized.
New movie design was great. But I love Katoki version of Xi Gundam better than movie.
Thanks for telling the history 😃
I like the modern take on the character design... not bad!
NGL the MS designs in Hathaway have never exactly been my favorites tbh. Hope story in movie can help me appreciate them a bit more.
I love the aesthetics of the movie way more. Not a fan of the game version at all.
The new designs are better.
Way better.
@xxnike629xx Speaking of, it will be better too if you talk again about my HGUC kit being *NOT* a P-Bandai. Hope you'll...
Do it! Do it! Do it! huehuehue
I loved everything about Gundam Hathaway except the actual Gundam designs. They look so flippin wierd! I would of preferred something a but more traditional looking design wise, like the RX-78 or the Mk-II or even something similar to the Nu Gundam
Pls can u put a link in the discription on what music u use
The Racer and Dawn Raider by Tristan Barton
Why Hathaway's hair color changes?
Awesome presentation ! And since I'm a Gundam fan, you gotta sub.
💪 thanks !
Great Comparison.
New sub here. The new designs are better for my opinion
Welcome!
Can i ask about your BGM music ?
1. The Racer, 2.Dawn Raider - Tristan Barton, thử đi bro
Davvero complimenti per l'idea. Questo video ci voleva sul serio. Spero seguirete - anche se è un pò complicato - l'evoluzione della trilogia. ( Really well done for the idea. This video was serious. I hope you will follow - even if it is a little complicated - the evolution of the trilogy. )...
thank you
Nice Editing
Thanks
I love the movie designs more, the game messer looks like a dom to me for some reason
Looks like they un-woked the hairs on many characters.
the only james bond on gundam life time... sad he died in the end the hardway
-the griim reaper wont come when your ready for him
What’s the name of the song you used?
The Racer by Tristan Barton according to shazam
That's right, "The Racer" by Tristan Barton and I spliced in "Dawn Raider" also by Tristan Barton at Gawman.
Love it thx
What music did you use for this?
1. The Racer, 2.Dawn Raider - Tristan Barton, bro
What's the track title for the music in this video?
1. The Racer, 2.Dawn Raider - Tristan Barton, bro
The old school Gustav Karl looks way meaner imo
Poor Lane, his design never changes because no-one gives a shit about him.
name of the music?
1. The Racer, 2.Dawn Raider - Tristan Barton, bro
All the Mafty member movie designs are such a mega downgrade imo. But Hathaway and Gigi’s redesigns are better
bruh movie design looks better gawman looks badass fbh
@@tenkuken7168 it's no.
it looked almost like Amuro
Music ?
1. The Racer, 2.Dawn Raider - Tristan Barton, bro
@@Ozzy-worsttaste tanks
Movie designs are best
They did Mihessa dirty
La película mejoro por mucho los diseños del juego y la novela.
What is this song?
The Racer and Dawn Raider by Tristan Barton
Lane is the only one that looks the same in the game
they turn sleg into jamal
i hate gigi he is the reason why Hathaway die at the end 😭
The picture is too beating, it makes my eyes hurt
what music is this?
The Racer and Dawn Raider by Tristan Barton
Kenneth Sleg turned Filipino
i like character design from the novel better. some of the new designs for the movie to me feel kind off for some reason.
The new designs just look less fun and charming
idk man the design make the movie look realistic
Xi ver ka is the best design
Movie edition bar none.....
Witch game is it. Can anyone tell me
G-Generation, Extreme vs etc
Why they do that to Reymond , sad ......
Digital drawings doesn't have the same feel and hewn of hand drawn
Gustav Karl looks so much cooler in the novel. Then they turned it into an obese blocky jobber of a grunt.
I like to believe its because if Bandai were to release the Gustav type 00 as P Bandai
All they have to do is to change the head of P Bandai Gustav from Gihreen Greed and add some new decals.
I assume that they had to keep it consistent with the design we saw in the Gundam Unicorn OVA
The movie.
I dont like those new desings, they look so inorganic and soulless
novel has the best design
Not for all. Xi Gundam is quite similar, Novel Penelope design is far better that the anime one.
The original art for Hathaway is better
Movie 👍🏽