Idk I think even when it came out that was a mid take, Goff has been to a superbowl and won significantly more playoff games. Maybe in a vacuum Dak could be better but he’s the ring of hell that’s is Jerry World
Back then I was a regular on one Texans blog and there was one poster who would post every day how Donald was obviously going to be a beast and begged the FO to draft him. Seems like he was right.
@@SaulGoodman-w2x I remember him being a monster his senior year. I was still on the Jadaveon Clowney hype train. Clowney just wasn't never as good as his sophomore year in college and has coasted on his talent since.
I hate the Pats, I mean HATERADE DRINKING HATE them.....yet I don't even respect the f-ing Falcons since the final quarter of that fiasco... I mean COME ON!!!! a true captain would have audibled into a clock crunching run game...I was rooting so hard for ATLANTA and I saw it crumble so fast...like RUN DOWN A CLOCK!!!!!!!! LOST A LITTLE OF MY SOUL.....and the fuckins ain't even my team!!!
David Carr's problem wasn't that he wasn't good, it was that the Texans' O-line sucked. The poor guy was shell shocked after 2 seasons and didn't have a chance. If he had a line he would have been at least as good as Dereck Carr.
@@michaellamb8924same, I’m a Fresno state fan It made me mad to see people say he was a bust when any quarterback would suffer, Tom Brady or patty mahomes would. If David Carr had a decent team around him, he would have been a superstar
Sad to see here in Houston. I felt bad for whoever was drafted here that year! I knew it would be a bloodbath. When we finally pull out a Super Bowl, he should be the one to deliver the trophy! Hopefully, that is a possibility in the next few years!
JaMarcus also lied about watching film. They gave him blank tapes one week because they suspected he wasn't watching them, and sure enough he claimed he learned what he was supposed to from them... 🤣
This one was actually finished two weeks ago, but since it has an ad we had to tweak some things. Already working on another one though and plan to drop one a week going forward!
I love your content, man. And this was a fun video...but I can't see the Colts NOT taking Anderw Luck in 2012. Even though he walked away from football way too soon (right or wrong, a player's health should always be their primary concern), Luck was incredible for the Colts, and a game away, against TOM FREAKIN BRADY, from taking Indy back to the Superbowl. Russell Wilson is a Hall of Fame Quarterback, but Andrew Luck was a generational talent.
Russell Wilson holds the title of most over rated QB on a list that includes Eli Manning, Tony Romo, Dak Prescott, Colin Kaepernick, Kirk Cousins, and Tom Brady. And to address the inevitable freak outs, Brady is a very good QB. He happens to be the QB of the most SB winning teams, but no way in hell is he best QB in NFL history. But people say he is for that one fact. Hence, he is overrated.
Luck's problem was he was drafted by the Colts with Jim Irsay as the owner and Ryan Grigson as the GM. Look at the draft history of Ryan Grigson and see how many busts he drafted as I think only Luck, Hilton and Kelly were good enough to remain on the team while all the others were traded or completely out of the NFL. Not only did Grigson drafted nothing but busts, he did very little too help Luck as he didn't draft an offensive linemen until the 6th or 7th round. Luck's best RB was also old man Frank Gore. Grigson finally selected an offensive in Ryan Kelly after Luck got hurt.
Love? Huh? Burrow for sure, Tua yeah probably, Herbert has been good but not that good. But love had an awesome half a season and outside of that he's looked mediocre at best
Both Brady and Mahomes landed on teams that had perfect situations in which they could develop perfectly. Brady without those early 2000s Patriots teams doesn’t win all of those SBs. Mahomes without Reid and those weapons doesn’t end up as great as he is 5 years later.
@@Garbgaming Possibly, but I definitely don’t think he’d be as good early on. If he doesn’t land with Andy Reid, the perfect mentor for his rookie year in Alex Smith, and all those weapons, there’s no way he has as much early success.
@@Garbgaming He would have still had an incredible arm, but if he wound up on say, the Texans, I'm sure his decision making would be a fraction of what it is now And if Brady wound up on any other team he would almost definitely be a nobody
@@JB-1996 you'd still need to consider value over replacement, so how much more points would he score than a FA kicker and how many more would a great receiver score than an average FA receiver
@@davidshatto7604 What's even more insane about the take is for another 6 seasons the colts had the literal kicking GOAT Adam Vinetari still, and he didn't even get a mention in that take.
@gold_is_the_best it's not that playing at 35 is an issue. It's that he talked about him not showing any signs of slowing down then he immediately regressed. The reason why doesn't matter, it's just the fact that it happened.
What sucks about the 49ers picks is that TWICE they passed on Hall of Fame QBs who grew up loving them... Tom Brady and Aaron Rogers. Either of those guys would have given their souls to wear the Crimsin and Gold, but they let them slip away.
Assuming they still get all the other players they had in the early 2010’s (and assuming Rodgers developed the same way), we could’ve seen prime Aaron Rodgers and the 49er defense of the early 2010’s on one team
You have to take systems into consideration and sitting behind Bledsoe and Favre...Rogers or Brady anywhere else,would they be the Qbs they ended up being?
And the Niners also got Trey Lance, who has a good shot at being the worst bust in NFL history. The only reason this team isn't totally irrelevant is because they hit on a pick who was supposed to be just that.
Aaron Rodgers has at least six championship rings if he's on the 49ers his whole career.. since he's been drafted they have not won a single Super Bowl. It's safe to say his assertion on draft day turned out correct- the 49ers absolutely regret not drafting Aaron Rodgers
He's won more games for the ravens than any other player in the team's history, and arguably more than any other player on any team of all time. Man sent us to a super bowl, multiple playoffs, and has the records for most accurate kicker in NFL history and also has the longest kick in NFL history. JT deserves it
Tbh he WAS top 3 best players of the entire draft so I can't even say I disagree. Also I just don't want Russell to have gone anywhere other than Seattle
I honestly think if you can guarantee the most accurate kicker in history, that's worthy of number one overall. It's such a huge part of the game. Compare if closing pitchers and kickers are still more important
The only thing I’d argue with this pick is that they already had Adam vinitieri who may only be slightly worse given that he doesn’t have as big of a leg. Otherwise I love this take!!
You got me with the 2020, my jaw dropped, great comedy timing. 2007, I expected you to say "Instead of Jamarcus Russell, the Raiders pick... literally anyone else.
@@StonedApe93 as a lifelong cowboys fine, this is patently false. Defense, for sure. but O line? Dude had one of the best lines in the league at least 5 seasons
This was such a refreshing "redraft" video. You didn't just pick the best player, but also looked into the context (taking them away from division rival, previous redraft, etc). Well done!
Oh, and while I have you, so would Tom Brady and Josh Allen. A great concept as a QB would not stop the inevitable problem of bad coaching. It took Josh three years to be good, meanwhile Baker was pretty good off the bat when we wasn't coached by 1-32 McGee
I have never gone from chill to raging to chill within 3 seconds like I did when you crossed off Burrow before saying "nah I'm just kidding, it's still Joe Burrow". I tip my hat you sir, well played!
I would argue that for 2012 draft, the Colts select Luke Kuechly. I understand your choice as it's a much needed position for the Colts, but Kuechly made every offense tremble with how well he could read the field. Dude was the QB of defense.
2000- Browns: Brian Urlacher (Just cuz Tom Brady wasn’t known yet) 2001- Falcons: Drew Brees 2002- Texans: Ed Reed 2003: Bengals: Carson Palmer 2004: Chargers: Big Ben 2005- 49ers: Aaron Rodgers 2006-Texans: Vince Young 2007- Raiders: Calvin Johnson 2008- Dolphins: Matt Ryan 2009- Lions: Matthew Stafford 2010- Rams: Dez Bryant 2011- Panthers: Cam Newton 2012- Colts: Andrew Luck 2013- Chiefs: Eric Fisher 2014- Texans: Aaron Donald 2015- Buccaneers: Todd Gurley 2016: Rams: Dak Prescott 2017: Browns: Patrick Mahomes 2018- Browns: Nick Chubb 2019- Cardinals: Nick Bosa 2020- Bengals: Joe Burrow 2021- Jaguars: Trevor Lawrence 2022- Jaguars: Aiden Hutchinson
I think what you said about the Texans is hilarious seeing how demeco Ryan’s is now the head coach of the Texans. Being a rams fan living in New Hampshire I would have to see them draft someone other then Bradford in 2010 but another reason why he had so many problems is the fact that their head coach Jeff fisher was trying to turn Bradford into another McNair
I was with you until 2012...yes i know this is done in hindsight but being a Russell Wilson hater no way i'm taking him over Luck even in hindsight...and Justin Tucker is a stud but the Colts had Vinneteri at the time..i think he was pretty good too.
Luck was killed by his lack of an O-line. Russell Wilson would have faced the same situation. Wilson is, or at least was, good, but he's no Andrew Luck. Luck should have gone down as one of the best QBs of all time, instead he'll be looked back as one of the great what-ifs of 2000's football.
@@SeahawkGinger the Colts OL was one of the worst in NFL history. It's still awful 11 years later. Wilson had Lynch to help take some of the beatings. Luck never had a RB. Taylor didn't come along until after he retired.
I truly believe history will show that Brock Purdy should have been a 1st round pick in 2022. I understand people still have their doubts, but its just insane how productive he has been where Jimmy G and Trey Lance couldn't.
@@andrewkelly1337yea after watching Prudy get repeatedly T Bagged against the Eagles in the 2023 NFC Championship game and against the Ravens in that regular season game yea dude isn't it he's literally gonna be another Ryan Tannehill it's a real shame the 49ers are fucking loaded and frankly I think Rodgers regrets not getting picked by them dead ass he would have at least 4 Rings with them So I'm speculating he reaches 2012 Superbowl 2013 Superbowl 2014 Superbowl 2020 Superbowl 2022 Superbowl 2023 Superbowl So yea I'm speculating he reaches 6 Superbowls and wins ? Holy shit he goes 6-0 Brady is stuck on 6 rings not 7 and due to Rodgers beating him in 2012 he's viewed as the Goat Crazy how different that would be What am I basing this on ? You look at those narrow defeats the 49ers had in those 2 superbowls and 4 NFC Championship games they win all of those with Rodgers and seeing how eli Manning beat Brady Kaepernick almost beat Flacco Peyton got shitted on by Russell Wilson Wouldn't have blown a 10 point lead the way Jimmy G did against Mahomes And wouldn't have given up that fumble the Chiefs scored on that hurts did So yea 6x Superbowl Champion in just 12 years
picking dak prescott over jared goff is like picking jared goff over dak prescott. cue the "they are the same picture" meme also, trust me, raw qb prospect like mahomes and allen would not have survived the hue jackson browns. they needed to land in the right spots to blossom, and luckily for them tgey did
Aaron Rodgers had great weapons most of his seasons. Driver, Jennings, Nelson, Cobb and Adam's over his career. Good TEs, solid RBs and elite pass blocking most seasons too. This narrative needs to die.
I suppose at the end of this upcoming season you might be able to have an argument for Jalen Hurts over Burrow if he goes back to the super bowl and the Bengals fizzle out again
Haha you had me with the Joe Burrow fake out in 2020. I was like, sure Herbert could end up having a better career than Joe when all is said and done, but at this point nobody from that draft has had more success than Joey Franchise.
The panthers would be a bit better but still suck, Panthers was just a sorry team. I won’t call Bryce young a bust yet, panthers just hired a good coach, I think Bryce improves next year like Trevor Lawrence did in his second year
Somewhat realistic picks: 2000 - Brian Urlacher 2001 - Drew Brees 2002 - Julius Peppers 2003 - Carson Palmer 2004 - Manning Rivers Switch a roo 2005 - Aaron Rodgers 2006 - Mario Williams 2007 - Calvin Johnson 2008 - Matt Ryan 2009 - Matthew Stafford 2010 - Ndamukong Suh 2011 - Cam Newton 2012 - Andrew Luck 2013 - Lane Johnson 2014 - Aaron Donald 2015 - Amari Cooper? 2016 - Joey Bosa 2017 - Patrick Mahomes 2018 - Josh Allen 2019 - Nick Bosa 2020 - Joe Burrow
I’d really like your opinion on if Jamarcus Russel was more of a bust that Ryan Leaf. That being said, Leaf has become a real nice story as of late, being a guest analyst on NFL Network
When you said the rams take Trent Williams over Bradford it made me think of when we had both of them playing on our team Edit: I am a Oklahoma fan to help clear this up
I will say it's kinda funny watching what you said about the 06 draft not having any crazy elite talent, especially as a bears fan considering that Devin Hester completely changed how people viewed punt returns and how he's in the hall of fame. Though you seem to be addressing team needs more so I get it, but still, gave me a lil chuckle. Love your content!
I think if we drafted Justin Tucker 1st overall after losing Manning and already having arguably the greatest kicker ever, the Irsays would’ve been chased out of Indy by an angry mob
15:41 "WIDE MARGIN" ARE YOU KIDDING ME. Not saying sauce is not great, not even saying he should not have one the award, but c'mon you're saying that Hutchinson who somehow had MORE INTs as an EDGE and still recorded 9.5 sacks and also immediately became a team leader and ancore was a wide margin behind sauce for real? Pls tell me I'm not just being a double homer here as a U of M fan and lions fan.
@@jaydenragsdale120 bro this was like a year and a half ago. and obviously as brandon corrected me he was simply talking about voting where as i was talking about on the field.
@@LevelSkip Wilson wouldn't have been in the league this long if the Colts had drafted him. Had nothing to do with Luck and everything to do with the Colts protecting him. Andrew Luck was obviously the better quarterback.
Your only hope for redemption at this point is making another Superbowl, and winning 28-3, or making a comeback down 28-3. This is your bed, you must lay in it now, lol
I think we have at this point. Yeah, we did still get in the playoffs in 2017, but aside from that, we have never recovered from that loss. We haven’t had any more than 7 wins in these last 6 seasons, lost at least 10 times 4 seasons, and we no longer have a QB. This punishment has gone on for far too long.
As a colts fan I wouldn’t take Wilson over luck any day. I know Wilson won a sb but that was more so because he had a top RB, and the best d for 2 straight years. Wilson was a system qb hence his struggles with the broncos. He wouldn’t have been nearly “as good” as he was with Seattle.
Awesome video. Regarding the 2000 Draft, as we could never know what Brady would have achieved in Cleveland, another possible player that could have been picked instead was Brian Urlacher.
I’m a lifelong Browns fan, Brady would’ve been a nobody backup in Cleveland. They came back in 1999…they were an expansion team, not the NE Patriots with Bill and a defense that had all pro and pro bowl talent everywhere and a pro bowl QB in Drew Bledsoe for him to sit behind and learn from for a year because Tim Couch did in fact go down in 01 and 02 so it’s possible if the Browns took Brady instead of Spergon Wynn that he would’ve seen playing time in Cleveland and there wouldn’t be some miracle run he goes on that sparks his legend, he’d be just another name on that famous Browns QB jersey
@@semp36445yea as a Jets fan once again I'm sorry what Mo Lewis did Point is people forget how insanely lucky Brady entire career was not only almost going undrafted He only played because Bledsoe got hurt dude would have been an irrelevant backup if that didn't happen and would have disappeared years tops but 1 freak injury set everything into motion that probably doesn't happen at the Cleveland Brown's
Fun fact: the Seahawks kicked off the legion of boom in the 2010 draft by picking Earl Thomas 14th overall. Sometimes it’s about picking the right player, not just the best.
8:53 I don't think there was any player at Nebraska on the Defensive Line that was as good as Ndamukong Suh. Even given how dominant Nebraska was in the past.
@@LetThisUsernameNotBeTaken I’m. It saying he doesn’t have the potential, I’m saying he’s not there yet. But I do see the potential and it is very possible for this to happen.
Bran this is cool but I have to disagree on the 2003 Bengals move. Yes Troy Polamalu was technically better but if Cincy took troy then they would have had to keep relying on Jon Kitna as a QB who at best was a joke. So I think they were better off with Carson Palmer and went 8-8 in 2004 and 11-5 in 2005, no way Kitna would have done that.
@@teen_laqueefa 2005 is a year that my dislike for the Steelers turned into complete and utter hatred, dirty scabby garbage team and franchise, then several years later when in an interview the DL Kimo Oelhoffen admitted he was directed to hit low and take Palmer out of the game. "who dey" indeed
@@hommie789 to make it worse Kimo was a former Bengal, we were running it up on those guys all year, and poof Kitna stood NO chance... that was OUR year
If Vick never gets into dogfighting, I think he's worth the number 1 pick. Even when he came back to Philly, he was a great QB. Didn't have the full longevity of Brees, but would've been the franchise QB for an entire decade at least.
I found out today I still have Vick’s Jersey! It’s awkward looking at it now though because I got that jersey literally right before he got thrown in jail for the dogfighting. This also made me glad that Matt Ryan came to Atlanta because boy was I nervous someone else was gonna scoop him up!
Michael Vick was always a bigger threat as a runner than passing. Drew Brees was the more accurate passer their rookie year; he just didn't make highlights in college being on a lousy Perdue team compared to Virginia Tech which Vick took to the BCS national championship game. In the NFL great pocket passers always beat run first quarterbacks in the playoffs.
i think it's hilarious that people now tend to think that aaron rogers wasn't surrounded by weapons basically his entire career. he had probably 2 season where he didn't have a top weapons in the league. dude played with Greg Jennings, Randall Cobb, Jordy Nelson, Davante Adams, Jermichael Finley, along with some really good RB's over the years.
I am by no means a Texans fan, but the issue with the 2002 Texans was they had a horrific O-Line. David Carr probably would have worked out to be a good staring QB at the very least if he had gone to almost any other team. Carr was sacked 76 times during that season, which set a league record. I don't have a problem with the new pick being Ed Reed, but Carr never stood a chance on that team.
With the first pick in the 2024 NFL draft, instead of Caleb Williams, the Chicago Bears select Jayden Daniels. This is my prediction after 5 regular season games but there's still time so I might change the comment later.
crazy that the Raiders' head coach at the time repeatedly tried to convince the GM to draft Calvin Johnson instead of Jamarcus Russell, including literally on draft night, and the GM then proceeded to not only draft Russell, but blame the coach for Russell's failures
Dak #1 overall is wild. Give me Tyreek, Ramsey, or even Chris Jones any day of the week. Yes, Dak gives you more than Rams-era Goff, no doubt, but you simply can't call him the best player from that draft -- and if the point of a re-draft isn't to get the #1 guy, then why bother?
“With the first pick on the 2023 NFL draft, instead of Bryce Young, the Carolina Panthers select C.J. Stroud.” I can just hear him saying that
@@JufHouse that’s what i was thinking this whole video
I know hindsight's 20/20 and all but that was a massive fumble by the Panthers
@@catloverplayz3268 it depends on the team around the young qb
In the 2024 NFL draft, the Chicago bears select Jayden Daniels
@@Strive4GreatnessPOP that'd be preferable
-Eagles fan
Taking Dak Prescott over Jared Goff is kind of hilarious seeing how the two players have played since this video was posted.
I was thinking the same thing
Idk I think even when it came out that was a mid take, Goff has been to a superbowl and won significantly more playoff games. Maybe in a vacuum Dak could be better but he’s the ring of hell that’s is Jerry World
Devin Hester has a gold jacket that he didn’t buy
At the time is was the right take though
Goff is playing with a much better team lmao
The Texans getting Aaron Donald and JJ Watt in their primed together would’ve been insane
Indeed 😳
I think that would be highly illegal
Back then I was a regular on one Texans blog and there was one poster who would post every day how Donald was obviously going to be a beast and begged the FO to draft him. Seems like he was right.
@@SaulGoodman-w2x I did this for the cowboys too
@@SaulGoodman-w2x I remember him being a monster his senior year. I was still on the Jadaveon Clowney hype train. Clowney just wasn't never as good as his sophomore year in college and has coasted on his talent since.
Dak over Goff is laughable.
Yeah Dak chokes in the playoffs and Goff doesn’t soooo laughable.
Seems I misread your comment bud.
@@ThatGreenGuy85 neither has won a superbowl
Taking either over Derick Henry, Joey Bosa or Jalen Ramsey is ridiculous
This was a year ago fool
“Why was 19 afraid of 20, because 28-3. “ that had me laughing
I hate the Pats, I mean HATERADE DRINKING HATE them.....yet I don't even respect the f-ing Falcons since the final quarter of that fiasco... I mean COME ON!!!! a true captain would have audibled into a clock crunching run game...I was rooting so hard for ATLANTA and I saw it crumble so fast...like RUN DOWN A CLOCK!!!!!!!!
LOST A LITTLE OF MY SOUL.....and the fuckins ain't even my team!!!
@@teen_laqueefaImagine how us Falcons fans feel
@@lucaspowell2980 I'm not sure I could do it. Respect for you...
@@lucaspowell2980 as a seahawks fan i can relate
@@teen_laqueefa I have looked at my Matty Ice jersey many a time
It's crazy that the Chargers offense could've had Brees at QB, LT at RB, Fitzgerald at WR, and Gates at TE.
Chargers had brees
@@NAT-turners-Revenge they also had LT ? They’re saying with added talent that offense would’ve been even scarier
And they still wouldn’t have won anything.
@@pawrestlingchampConsidering one year they had the #1 offense and defense in the league, and missed the playoffs, that’s probably true…
My face when he said “instead of joe burrow”🤔😯🤯
David Carr's problem wasn't that he wasn't good, it was that the Texans' O-line sucked. The poor guy was shell shocked after 2 seasons and didn't have a chance. If he had a line he would have been at least as good as Dereck Carr.
As a Fresno State fan, that was so sad. David Carr was just a punching bag back there
Exactly that team had so many holes any qb would have failed
He was Mac jones in New England today.
@@michaellamb8924same, I’m a Fresno state fan
It made me mad to see people say he was a bust when any quarterback would suffer, Tom Brady or patty mahomes would. If David Carr had a decent team around him, he would have been a superstar
Sad to see here in Houston. I felt bad for whoever was drafted here that year! I knew it would be a bloodbath. When we finally pull out a Super Bowl, he should be the one to deliver the trophy! Hopefully, that is a possibility in the next few years!
2016 there’s 0 chance it should be Prescott over Tyreek, Ramsey, Chris Jones or Derrick Henry.
I think teams were trying to avoid tyreek hill because of some at home issues
6:57 To have a Life Coach give up on you is some serious type of crazy 😂
JaMarcus also lied about watching film. They gave him blank tapes one week because they suspected he wasn't watching them, and sure enough he claimed he learned what he was supposed to from them... 🤣
As a Lions fan, after you said “the lions still select Matthew Stafford” I audibly said “thank you!” 😂
Yessss. Would have cried if he took stafford away
The Lions are probably superbowl bound this year. Something I never thought I'd say.
@@melanatedgod5337 One week later............
Who else would you give them?
As a panthers fan I feel the same way about 2011 😂
Petition for more long form Bran content 👇
The hand is pointing to the dislike button lol
This one was actually finished two weeks ago, but since it has an ad we had to tweak some things. Already working on another one though and plan to drop one a week going forward!
Signed
@@benchwarmerbran let’s go
Yes pls
The fact that this man snuck a 28-3 joke in like that is how you know he's a pats fan lmao
It's the sneakiness of it lol
Timestamp?
I love your content, man. And this was a fun video...but I can't see the Colts NOT taking Anderw Luck in 2012. Even though he walked away from football way too soon (right or wrong, a player's health should always be their primary concern), Luck was incredible for the Colts, and a game away, against TOM FREAKIN BRADY, from taking Indy back to the Superbowl.
Russell Wilson is a Hall of Fame Quarterback, but Andrew Luck was a generational talent.
Russell Wilson holds the title of most over rated QB on a list that includes Eli Manning, Tony Romo, Dak Prescott, Colin Kaepernick, Kirk Cousins, and Tom Brady.
And to address the inevitable freak outs, Brady is a very good QB. He happens to be the QB of the most SB winning teams, but no way in hell is he best QB in NFL history. But people say he is for that one fact. Hence, he is overrated.
despite his play rn russ is a generational talent and one of the best dual threat qbs of all time …
Luck's problem was he was drafted by the Colts with Jim Irsay as the owner and Ryan Grigson as the GM. Look at the draft history of Ryan Grigson and see how many busts he drafted as I think only Luck, Hilton and Kelly were good enough to remain on the team while all the others were traded or completely out of the NFL. Not only did Grigson drafted nothing but busts, he did very little too help Luck as he didn't draft an offensive linemen until the 6th or 7th round. Luck's best RB was also old man Frank Gore. Grigson finally selected an offensive in Ryan Kelly after Luck got hurt.
Dang the 2020 class was freaking loaded at qb. Burrow, Tua, Herbert and Love. Along with others too. That was just a dang good class
Love? Huh? Burrow for sure, Tua yeah probably, Herbert has been good but not that good. But love had an awesome half a season and outside of that he's looked mediocre at best
Both Brady and Mahomes landed on teams that had perfect situations in which they could develop perfectly. Brady without those early 2000s Patriots teams doesn’t win all of those SBs. Mahomes without Reid and those weapons doesn’t end up as great as he is 5 years later.
Great take but Mahomes would still be great
Browns gonna brown
@@Garbgaming Possibly, but I definitely don’t think he’d be as good early on. If he doesn’t land with Andy Reid, the perfect mentor for his rookie year in Alex Smith, and all those weapons, there’s no way he has as much early success.
They would both still end up great tho
@@Garbgaming He would have still had an incredible arm, but if he wound up on say, the Texans, I'm sure his decision making would be a fraction of what it is now
And if Brady wound up on any other team he would almost definitely be a nobody
Andrew Luck not being drafted by the colts might have save his career lol
put russel wilson on those cplts teams and see whay happens awful repick
Regardless, Luck is still the only correct option
Luck is the only pick, horrible take.
That Justin Tucker take was absolutely insane. Idk if that was engagement farming but it definitely worked on me😂 great video
It's insane yes, but if you look at how many times tucker has saved the ravens ass, it's not as insane
@@kayfabejunkiesstill not worth taking a kicker #1 overall lol
That was a hilarious take, but if you think about it…. Justin Tucker has 1649 career points, that’s equivalent to 274 touchdowns… not too shabby
@@JB-1996 you'd still need to consider value over replacement, so how much more points would he score than a FA kicker and how many more would a great receiver score than an average FA receiver
@@davidshatto7604 What's even more insane about the take is for another 6 seasons the colts had the literal kicking GOAT Adam Vinetari still, and he didn't even get a mention in that take.
11:00 this aged horribly
@@mike_nobody8512 exactly what I was coming to say
hes 35 its not even his fault
@@gold_is_the_best that's a dumb argument lol
@@ethanyuki2654 it is. do you know how hard it is to play football at 35? tomorrow brady did it, yes, but for most people its hard
@gold_is_the_best it's not that playing at 35 is an issue. It's that he talked about him not showing any signs of slowing down then he immediately regressed. The reason why doesn't matter, it's just the fact that it happened.
I'm from the future. It wasn't the Cowboys year.
Dang. Worst part is I already knew.
But this information won't change the fact that I will insist it is to every other fan
next year?
This is the year they got zeke back
@@romeomartinez4183 from the future, I highly doubt this is the cowboys year
What sucks about the 49ers picks is that TWICE they passed on Hall of Fame QBs who grew up loving them... Tom Brady and Aaron Rogers. Either of those guys would have given their souls to wear the Crimsin and Gold, but they let them slip away.
Assuming they still get all the other players they had in the early 2010’s (and assuming Rodgers developed the same way), we could’ve seen prime Aaron Rodgers and the 49er defense of the early 2010’s on one team
You have to take systems into consideration and sitting behind Bledsoe and Favre...Rogers or Brady anywhere else,would they be the Qbs they ended up being?
And the Niners also got Trey Lance, who has a good shot at being the worst bust in NFL history. The only reason this team isn't totally irrelevant is because they hit on a pick who was supposed to be just that.
Wtf is ur profile pic lol
Aaron Rodgers has at least six championship rings if he's on the 49ers his whole career.. since he's been drafted they have not won a single Super Bowl. It's safe to say his assertion on draft day turned out correct- the 49ers absolutely regret not drafting Aaron Rodgers
Justin tucker has number 1 overall had me dying for som reason 😂😂😂
Edit: if ur looking for that part it’s: 10:27
He's won more games for the ravens than any other player in the team's history, and arguably more than any other player on any team of all time. Man sent us to a super bowl, multiple playoffs, and has the records for most accurate kicker in NFL history and also has the longest kick in NFL history. JT deserves it
@@swimmer8585 I get it! 😳 it’s so long I stoped reading it in the first half but ok…..
Tbh he WAS top 3 best players of the entire draft so I can't even say I disagree. Also I just don't want Russell to have gone anywhere other than Seattle
I honestly think if you can guarantee the most accurate kicker in history, that's worthy of number one overall. It's such a huge part of the game. Compare if closing pitchers and kickers are still more important
The only thing I’d argue with this pick is that they already had Adam vinitieri who may only be slightly worse given that he doesn’t have as big of a leg. Otherwise I love this take!!
You got me with the 2020, my jaw dropped, great comedy timing. 2007, I expected you to say "Instead of Jamarcus Russell, the Raiders pick... literally anyone else.
Calvin, AP, Revis, Thomas. 07 was loaded.
Really. Anyone all the way through the end of round 7 would have been a better pick than the number 1 overall. Insane.
As a cowboys fan, I appreciate you giving Tony some credit for the 2003 pick. Dude had a good career, despite not having playoff success
Lol, that's all on Romo though. Dude choked when it really mattered.
You know the only difference between Romo and Mr Omaha is the superbowls.
@@davidparkes7741Romo didn’t have an offensive line for 95% of his career
@@StonedApe93 as a lifelong cowboys fine, this is patently false. Defense, for sure. but O line? Dude had one of the best lines in the league at least 5 seasons
@@davidparkes7741 Jesus loves you and everyone
16:02 sit down when I tell you this…
10:29 yes it would be insane to draft Justin Tucker #1 overall while Adam Vinatieri is on roster
This was such a refreshing "redraft" video. You didn't just pick the best player, but also looked into the context (taking them away from division rival, previous redraft, etc). Well done!
And probably wanted Brady to get murdered behind the Browns' line as well.
It's pretty clever.
@@iamhungey12345 He's actually a Patriots' fan. I don't think he would want that.
Larry Fitzgerald finished his career with more tackles than drops. Amazing.
And the margin is surprisingly high in that regard. He had like 10 more tackles than pass drops.
Sorry bran, the browns would have 1000% made mahomes a bust. Remember, his couch in college was Kliff Kingsbury
Oh, and while I have you, so would Tom Brady and Josh Allen. A great concept as a QB would not stop the inevitable problem of bad coaching. It took Josh three years to be good, meanwhile Baker was pretty good off the bat when we wasn't coached by 1-32 McGee
@@cybercrasherstv I think Lamar is probably the only other QB the browns could have picked at 1
Kliff Kingsbury was his couch? Kinda inhumane
@@cybercrasherstv And then Mayfield stunk.
The fact that only a few picks stayed the same says all you need to know about how hard it is evaluating talent. Cool video tho
I have never gone from chill to raging to chill within 3 seconds like I did when you crossed off Burrow before saying "nah I'm just kidding, it's still Joe Burrow". I tip my hat you sir, well played!
personally I would wait a few years to see how the young players turn out but Burrow is a solid pick
Lol for real. I had a borderline spit take.
In 2014, The Browns also had the opportunity to select QB Bo Callahan at #1.
Nah, I am sure he was a bust. It's a character thing for me.
Jesus loves you so so so much
I don’t care
@@coop_dawg207gaming2 “I don’t care”
WHAT EVER
Their GM made some interesting moves during that draft.
I would argue that for 2012 draft, the Colts select Luke Kuechly. I understand your choice as it's a much needed position for the Colts, but Kuechly made every offense tremble with how well he could read the field. Dude was the QB of defense.
AND the Colts wouldn't have needed to draft a QB because they still had Peyton. Bolstering the defense so that Peyton could've retired a Colt 😭
AND the colts ende up With a top 3 kicker of all time anyway with Adam Vinatieri so
Should've taken Luck. Just messed up building around him.
That was a horrible suggestion. If Luck wasn't able to survive the mess of a system in Indy how would a dude half his size survive it? Lmao
We just gonna act like vinateri wasn’t the best kicker of all time ?
Drew Brees is just a beast. Accurate as hell, not much drama either.
That Goff take did not age well 😂
2000- Browns: Brian Urlacher (Just cuz Tom Brady wasn’t known yet)
2001- Falcons: Drew Brees
2002- Texans: Ed Reed
2003: Bengals: Carson Palmer
2004: Chargers: Big Ben
2005- 49ers: Aaron Rodgers
2006-Texans: Vince Young
2007- Raiders: Calvin Johnson
2008- Dolphins: Matt Ryan
2009- Lions: Matthew Stafford
2010- Rams: Dez Bryant
2011- Panthers: Cam Newton
2012- Colts: Andrew Luck
2013- Chiefs: Eric Fisher
2014- Texans: Aaron Donald
2015- Buccaneers: Todd Gurley
2016: Rams: Dak Prescott
2017: Browns: Patrick Mahomes
2018- Browns: Nick Chubb
2019- Cardinals: Nick Bosa
2020- Bengals: Joe Burrow
2021- Jaguars: Trevor Lawrence
2022- Jaguars: Aiden Hutchinson
😮 u put some thought into this
I disagree with 2019
This is dumb, brady either goes number 1 with hindsight or 199 because he wasn’t known.
@@danielzhao5823I'm pretty sure that's why they decided to go with Urlacher in his list
Why would you have the Colts still select Andrew Luck after knowing what you know now?😂
The 2013 Chiefs pick was hilarious. Well done sir!
I think what you said about the Texans is hilarious seeing how demeco Ryan’s is now the head coach of the Texans. Being a rams fan living in New Hampshire I would have to see them draft someone other then Bradford in 2010 but another reason why he had so many problems is the fact that their head coach Jeff fisher was trying to turn Bradford into another McNair
I forgot how STACKED that Jamarcus Russel draft was. That’s got to hurt even more for Raiders lol
@3:42 As a Steeler fan, when you said the Bengals would pick Troy Polamalu, I literally yelled out "Nooooo!" to your video. LOL
I was with you until 2012...yes i know this is done in hindsight but being a Russell Wilson hater no way i'm taking him over Luck even in hindsight...and Justin Tucker is a stud but the Colts had Vinneteri at the time..i think he was pretty good too.
Hi! Colts fan here!
Adam V was an absolute legend for years with both the Pats and the Colts. He was the best in the league for a long time!
Luck was killed by his lack of an O-line. Russell Wilson would have faced the same situation. Wilson is, or at least was, good, but he's no Andrew Luck. Luck should have gone down as one of the best QBs of all time, instead he'll be looked back as one of the great what-ifs of 2000's football.
@James A Clouder do people just choose to forget that Russ dealt with poor offensive line play almost his entire career in Seattle?
@@SeahawkGinger the Colts OL was one of the worst in NFL history. It's still awful 11 years later. Wilson had Lynch to help take some of the beatings. Luck never had a RB. Taylor didn't come along until after he retired.
Love the channel bro
@aukatieboo Jesus loves everyone God bless
“Hey why was 19 scared of 20?” “Because 28 3” 😂😂😂😂😂😂
I thought this was a serious video until you made Dak the number one overall pick, lol
I truly believe history will show that Brock Purdy should have been a 1st round pick in 2022.
I understand people still have their doubts, but its just insane how productive he has been where Jimmy G and Trey Lance couldn't.
Jimmy G was meaninglessly less productive in 5 games with CMac, Purdy isn't that guy
@@andrewkelly1337yea after watching Prudy get repeatedly T Bagged against the Eagles in the 2023 NFC Championship game and against the Ravens in that regular season game yea dude isn't it he's literally gonna be another Ryan Tannehill it's a real shame the 49ers are fucking loaded and frankly I think Rodgers regrets not getting picked by them dead ass he would have at least 4 Rings with them
So I'm speculating he reaches
2012 Superbowl
2013 Superbowl
2014 Superbowl
2020 Superbowl
2022 Superbowl
2023 Superbowl
So yea I'm speculating he reaches 6 Superbowls and wins ?
Holy shit he goes 6-0 Brady is stuck on 6 rings not 7 and due to Rodgers beating him in 2012 he's viewed as the Goat
Crazy how different that would be
What am I basing this on ? You look at those narrow defeats the 49ers had in those 2 superbowls and 4 NFC Championship games they win all of those with Rodgers and seeing how eli Manning beat Brady
Kaepernick almost beat Flacco
Peyton got shitted on by Russell Wilson
Wouldn't have blown a 10 point lead the way Jimmy G did against Mahomes
And wouldn't have given up that fumble the Chiefs scored on that hurts did
So yea 6x Superbowl Champion in just 12 years
Couldn't agree more
@@andrewkelly1337 OK
picking dak prescott over jared goff is like picking jared goff over dak prescott. cue the "they are the same picture" meme
also, trust me, raw qb prospect like mahomes and allen would not have survived the hue jackson browns. they needed to land in the right spots to blossom, and luckily for them tgey did
I gotta disagree with 2013. Kelce is great, but Lane Johnson is equally as good at the Tackle spot
Idk about that one
@@Sup_303 The man hasn't given up a sack in 3 YEARS
@@BigMattXXL but Travis Kelce is Travis Kelce
@@Sup_303 But Lane Johnson is Lane Johnson
@@BigMattXXL2 years. Gave up 1 in 2020, but I understand your argument
The Josh Allen over Lamar Jackson decision couldn’t have aged more poorly 😂
Exactly. It was still a bad take 8 months ago.
Allen is better than Lamar.
@@andrewlamprecht-carson6142 Meanwhile Allen got put out of the Playoffs
@@Epapp42 So Jared Goff is better than Josh Allen, Justin Herbert, Dak Prescott, and Jalen Hurts? Interesting take.
Lamar Jackson will be out of the NFL in 2-3 years. What do you think will happen when he can't run anymore? Use your head
Trent Williams
* Large
I was watching this feeling really sick and I still couldn't stop laughing. Trent is a massive man.
Aaron Rodgers had great weapons most of his seasons. Driver, Jennings, Nelson, Cobb and Adam's over his career. Good TEs, solid RBs and elite pass blocking most seasons too. This narrative needs to die.
Comparing Kirk Cousins to a trailer park is casual as hell lmao
I was about to lose my shit when it looked like you were about to say my Bengals shouldn't have drafted Burrow. 🤣
I suppose at the end of this upcoming season you might be able to have an argument for Jalen Hurts over Burrow if he goes back to the super bowl and the Bengals fizzle out again
Heeeeey, congrats on the sponsorship! More to come, you deserve it man. Keep up the good work
It’s obviously way to early to make the call but I gotta think the panthers would like a re-do for CJ Stroud right now
Haha you had me with the Joe Burrow fake out in 2020. I was like, sure Herbert could end up having a better career than Joe when all is said and done, but at this point nobody from that draft has had more success than Joey Franchise.
In the 2023 NFL Draft, instead of selected Bryce Young, the Carolina Panthers select, CJ Stroud.
The panthers would be a bit better but still suck, Panthers was just a sorry team. I won’t call Bryce young a bust yet, panthers just hired a good coach, I think Bryce improves next year like Trevor Lawrence did in his second year
Taking a safety at #1 overall would be hilarious 😂
two years in a row!
Not when they're the best FS and SS in NFL history it's not hilarious. It's what you should do, if you think otherwise you don't know ball
@@litaf4889 nah it's hilarious
Dude he suggested taking a kicker #1…
I think the rams still should’ve picked Jarrett Goff because Dak Prescott always chokes in the playoffs every year
Somewhat realistic picks:
2000 - Brian Urlacher
2001 - Drew Brees
2002 - Julius Peppers
2003 - Carson Palmer
2004 - Manning Rivers Switch a roo
2005 - Aaron Rodgers
2006 - Mario Williams
2007 - Calvin Johnson
2008 - Matt Ryan
2009 - Matthew Stafford
2010 - Ndamukong Suh
2011 - Cam Newton
2012 - Andrew Luck
2013 - Lane Johnson
2014 - Aaron Donald
2015 - Amari Cooper?
2016 - Joey Bosa
2017 - Patrick Mahomes
2018 - Josh Allen
2019 - Nick Bosa
2020 - Joe Burrow
Dak Prescott over Goff is wild
As a Rams fan I would take Goff over Prescott any day of the week
I’d really like your opinion on if Jamarcus Russel was more of a bust that Ryan Leaf.
That being said, Leaf has become a real nice story as of late, being a guest analyst on NFL Network
When you said the rams take Trent Williams over Bradford it made me think of when we had both of them playing on our team
Edit:
I am a Oklahoma fan to help clear this up
I will say it's kinda funny watching what you said about the 06 draft not having any crazy elite talent, especially as a bears fan considering that Devin Hester completely changed how people viewed punt returns and how he's in the hall of fame.
Though you seem to be addressing team needs more so I get it, but still, gave me a lil chuckle. Love your content!
I think if we drafted Justin Tucker 1st overall after losing Manning and already having arguably the greatest kicker ever, the Irsays would’ve been chased out of Indy by an angry mob
I can see the “logic” on paper but with context it would probably be the most brain dead move in the history of sports
Bran is underrated as heck
15:41 "WIDE MARGIN" ARE YOU KIDDING ME. Not saying sauce is not great, not even saying he should not have one the award, but c'mon you're saying that Hutchinson who somehow had MORE INTs as an EDGE and still recorded 9.5 sacks and also immediately became a team leader and ancore was a wide margin behind sauce for real? Pls tell me I'm not just being a double homer here as a U of M fan and lions fan.
I’m literally just talking about the voting. It wasn’t close 😂
learn how to spell correctly and then you can correct our king benchwarmerbran :)
@@jaydenragsdale120 bro this was like a year and a half ago. and obviously as brandon corrected me he was simply talking about voting where as i was talking about on the field.
Thanks for putting in all the work that you do for us!
9:21 what do you mean by under center?
Quarterbacks
Devin Hester was generational as a return man lol.
"Hear me out"
You JUST told me Wilson over Luck 💀
Yeah Wilson is still in the league and won a Super Bowl, so his career turned out better than Luck’s. Pretty obvious
@@LevelSkip well if the colts ever gave a damn about protecting luck, he’d still be in the league atm
@@LevelSkip Wilson wouldn't have been in the league this long if the Colts had drafted him. Had nothing to do with Luck and everything to do with the Colts protecting him. Andrew Luck was obviously the better quarterback.
Just had to do a 28-3 joke didn't you, haven't we Falcons fans suffered enough 😢😢
Your only hope for redemption at this point is making another Superbowl, and winning 28-3, or making a comeback down 28-3. This is your bed, you must lay in it now, lol
No
Run the clock
I think we have at this point. Yeah, we did still get in the playoffs in 2017, but aside from that, we have never recovered from that loss. We haven’t had any more than 7 wins in these last 6 seasons, lost at least 10 times 4 seasons, and we no longer have a QB.
This punishment has gone on for far too long.
I’m a carolina gamecocks fan and it hurt my heart when you said that clowny is only known for one hit he made 😂
As a colts fan I wouldn’t take Wilson over luck any day. I know Wilson won a sb but that was more so because he had a top RB, and the best d for 2 straight years. Wilson was a system qb hence his struggles with the broncos. He wouldn’t have been nearly “as good” as he was with Seattle.
Taking Wilson over Luck is silly. Luck was a far better individual player.
Awesome video. Regarding the 2000 Draft, as we could never know what Brady would have achieved in Cleveland, another possible player that could have been picked instead was Brian Urlacher.
Absolutely. I don't think that the Browns would give up on Tim Couch after one year.
I’m a lifelong Browns fan, Brady would’ve been a nobody backup in Cleveland. They came back in 1999…they were an expansion team, not the NE Patriots with Bill and a defense that had all pro and pro bowl talent everywhere and a pro bowl QB in Drew Bledsoe for him to sit behind and learn from for a year because Tim Couch did in fact go down in 01 and 02 so it’s possible if the Browns took Brady instead of Spergon Wynn that he would’ve seen playing time in Cleveland and there wouldn’t be some miracle run he goes on that sparks his legend, he’d be just another name on that famous Browns QB jersey
@@semp36445yea as a Jets fan once again I'm sorry what Mo Lewis did
Point is people forget how insanely lucky Brady entire career was not only almost going undrafted
He only played because Bledsoe got hurt dude would have been an irrelevant backup if that didn't happen and would have disappeared years tops but 1 freak injury set everything into motion that probably doesn't happen at the Cleveland Brown's
Oof, Kirk Cousins catching strays he doesn’t deserve.
Yeah, not sure if he's unaware of just how trash Glennon was or how solid Cousins is, but dayum!
Fun fact: the Seahawks kicked off the legion of boom in the 2010 draft by picking Earl Thomas 14th overall. Sometimes it’s about picking the right player, not just the best.
8:53 I don't think there was any player at Nebraska on the Defensive Line that was as good as Ndamukong Suh.
Even given how dominant Nebraska was in the past.
2019 didn't age so well ... Murray is looking still like the better pick now.
its funny to cause he used the reverse logic for stafford/newton. so he was straight hating...
Ya know watching this video I was constantly thinking bran was gonna pull something on Joe Burrow's pick and I was right. 😂
“Best right end of all time”
*Tony Gonzalez staring at him in the background shocked and appalled*
Gronk too
Tony G himself said Travis is better. I guess you know better than Tony.
Travis could easily become that
@@LetThisUsernameNotBeTaken I’m. It saying he doesn’t have the potential, I’m saying he’s not there yet. But I do see the potential and it is very possible for this to happen.
Honestly I think Jameis will be remembered for "Eat That W" even more than for the 30TD/30INT season.
david carr should have sued his offensive line for depraved indifference
I wonder if he’d still pick Prescott over Goff after that Lions/Cowboys game last weekend 47-9 Lions haha
Goff is much better than dak
Petition for Bran to legally adopt me…👇
Her
Okay bet
💀
Bet
Yes
Bran this is cool but I have to disagree on the 2003 Bengals move. Yes Troy Polamalu was technically better but if Cincy took troy then they would have had to keep relying on Jon Kitna as a QB who at best was a joke. So I think they were better off with Carson Palmer and went 8-8 in 2004 and 11-5 in 2005, no way Kitna would have done that.
Yeah, I feel like he sometimes ignored the context of the team and sometimes considered it, also did it with the Browns in 2000
Factual, who dey
@@teen_laqueefa 2005 is a year that my dislike for the Steelers turned into complete and utter hatred, dirty scabby garbage team and franchise, then several years later when in an interview the DL Kimo Oelhoffen admitted he was directed to hit low and take Palmer out of the game. "who dey" indeed
@@hommie789 to make it worse Kimo was a former Bengal, we were running it up on those guys all year, and poof Kitna stood NO chance... that was OUR year
If Vick never gets into dogfighting, I think he's worth the number 1 pick. Even when he came back to Philly, he was a great QB. Didn't have the full longevity of Brees, but would've been the franchise QB for an entire decade at least.
I found out today I still have Vick’s Jersey! It’s awkward looking at it now though because I got that jersey literally right before he got thrown in jail for the dogfighting. This also made me glad that Matt Ryan came to Atlanta because boy was I nervous someone else was gonna scoop him up!
Michael Vick was always a bigger threat as a runner than passing. Drew Brees was the more accurate passer their rookie year; he just didn't make highlights in college being on a lousy Perdue team compared to Virginia Tech which Vick took to the BCS national championship game. In the NFL great pocket passers always beat run first quarterbacks in the playoffs.
i think it's hilarious that people now tend to think that aaron rogers wasn't surrounded by weapons basically his entire career. he had probably 2 season where he didn't have a top weapons in the league. dude played with Greg Jennings, Randall Cobb, Jordy Nelson, Davante Adams, Jermichael Finley, along with some really good RB's over the years.
Great video my man!!! I'd like to see the same type of video only using the top picks from later rounds. Late round gems who became diamonds.
Dead wrong on K1
16:01 aged like milk
I wish this would happened for bad teams sake
I am by no means a Texans fan, but the issue with the 2002 Texans was they had a horrific O-Line. David Carr probably would have worked out to be a good staring QB at the very least if he had gone to almost any other team. Carr was sacked 76 times during that season, which set a league record. I don't have a problem with the new pick being Ed Reed, but Carr never stood a chance on that team.
14:53 Is it possible that a QB class finally surpasses 1983?
With the first pick in the 2024 NFL draft, instead of Caleb Williams, the Chicago Bears select Jayden Daniels.
This is my prediction after 5 regular season games but there's still time so I might change the comment later.
The Kirk disrespect is crazy, he's way better than Mike Glennon
crazy that the Raiders' head coach at the time repeatedly tried to convince the GM to draft Calvin Johnson instead of Jamarcus Russell, including literally on draft night, and the GM then proceeded to not only draft Russell, but blame the coach for Russell's failures
And with this season ending, Love proved it wasn’t the receivers that were the problem in GB AND the 9ers still haven’t won a super bowl in 30 years
JJ Watt and Aaron Donald on the same D Line in Houston would have been cheat code central
Dak #1 overall is wild. Give me Tyreek, Ramsey, or even Chris Jones any day of the week. Yes, Dak gives you more than Rams-era Goff, no doubt, but you simply can't call him the best player from that draft -- and if the point of a re-draft isn't to get the #1 guy, then why bother?
That Dak pick over Goff is crazy with bosa nem in that draft 😂