When Chapter 907 dropped, I had figured Blackbeard was the certain pirate the so-called Shanks was referring to. Also, when the Shanks Twin theory started gaining traction, I believed it instantly because it would be just like Oda to use Shanks’s voice actor for that particular scene, just to keep the secret.
It's a shonen so obviously characters get stronger as the story progresses. It's for a reason why for now the only thing that Dragon and Imu do is to see who's better at saying "..." cuz they're for the final arc
I can't see shanks being cloned. Shanks as is would be hard enough to get around without being noticed. If that would be the case then THE ONLY thing that works is lafiette works with the gov. Its shanks
Genetics has nothing to do with talent, Talent is achieved through hard work and dedication. As for Shanks twin just because they are siblings doesnt mean they will have the same talent.
I’m all for a Shanks twin, but I’m also on board with it being Shanks himself unwillingly working for Garling. If he has something Garling can exploit, then that’s Luffy’s personal stake in actually toppling the World Government - freeing his mentor from whatever Garling is binding him with.
The bowl that Whitebeard has is located at the spot of the scar on his middle chest. I believe it's possible that he does have it. He also had this scar in Chapter Zero, which takes place not long after his final meeting with Roger. The anime depicts him with this middle chest scar, and it is the only scar he has. So, I think it’s possible that he did have it at that time, possibly given to him by Roger.
But my though is that Roger only fought white beard in the oden flashback but there was no damage and also it was the final meaning that the damage taken was from the shanks clone, it would make more sense why whitebeard felt the scars huritng where he was looking at shanks because it was the clone he fought before . Just a theory
@ I get that but there’s really nothing to suggest Roger and white beard didn’t fight one last time just for the heck of it before Roger turns himself in And he has one at the time of chapter zero which is not too long after Roger turned himself in White beard as a total of 4 scars one of them could be from Roger before he turned himself in The first scar is definitely not from shanks brother as he would only be 16 years old
9:34 Big Mom uses her df abilities to not be affected by age. She gets stronger when she drains her or other’s lifespan 10:00 5 years ago would still be a Whitebeard significantly weaker than his prime. It still wouldn’t be a feat to injure him. Ace challenged WB 4 years ago and managed to burn him 10:35 His strongest man title comes from even way before God Valley. You would know that if you read his Vivre Card. It most likely refers to his df which is known to be the most powerful paramecia in the world 10:56 Manga chapters aren’t always 100% accurate regarding small details. We’ve litteraly seen Zoro once with Luffy’s scar. The fact that that person was speculated to be Roger in a One Piece magazine means that he had some scars from back then. Therefore, it’s most likely Garling Nothing in the current story can indicate how strong that Shanks lookalike actually. This is all headcanon based on no actual proof
bro in anime it showed whitebeard got scar after roger find one piece [whitebeard reading newspaper about roger, there was scar] maybe he got his scar in his prim
If we assume he indeed has Shanks talent combined with both arms he would have reached Yonko level around the same time as Shanks who was 33years old which was 6years then Stabs/Bhanks(twin) would have scarred a 68 year old whitebeard who much healthier and younger therefore closer to his prime implying relativity but not equal. On of him showcosibg gorosei abilities he will be a monster.
Really hope it’s a relative/twin. I’m so worried that with the existence of a Stella clone now that any character could be a clone… such as Shanks and Stabs are just perfect clones of Garling… so I just really want the cloning to stop or for Oda to put a cap number of how many “perfect” clones were created like Stussy.
He scarred him only like a decade ago when he was like 30 at least. Whitebeard had no scars in the Oden flashback. Which also means if he did fight garling, it wasn't at God Valley.
It’s hard to say how strong he’ll be. I doubt the Holy Knights are Yonko Level or above because like… why didn’t they just eliminate the emporers then if they were xD The only character who should be stronger than anyone right now is Imu.
Its honestly a coin flip as we dont know much about the holy knight training and if its comprable to shanks lifestyle but that 2 arm buff could put evil shanks close to Mihawk
@@CCC-V3ofc. Why would the government have their dna? The only reason seraphim exists is because warlords was on the government’s side so they were able to make clones.
It’s kind of odd to obscure it twice, though. It can, it would just make a lot less sense unless there’s a side to Shanks we don’t know yet. I’m still personally on board that this is a clone/ brother
Because there is an obstruction of his scar and missing arm. So either this is the real shanks and he has been in ties with the Gorosei (very unlikely imo) or it’s a clone or family member.
No it doesn’t. We saw Shanks in the sea and in the same day he went to the elders? It doesn’t make any sense. And there was no scar. (Oda drew Shanks from the side and there was still a scar on his forehead) but this character did not have the scar
Garp, it's your family again!
Oh wait, it's Shanks this time.
I remember saying Shanks had a twin brother and got a bunch of replies saying i was dumb and incorrect. Vindication
I'm going to be vindicated af when Law and Kid make their comeback lol
Nice winning
Its still not confirmed fully if thats a twin, a clone, or something else but it likely is.
That's not shanks twins That's shanks himself. Rat haired
When Chapter 907 dropped, I had figured Blackbeard was the certain pirate the so-called Shanks was referring to. Also, when the Shanks Twin theory started gaining traction, I believed it instantly because it would be just like Oda to use Shanks’s voice actor for that particular scene, just to keep the secret.
It's a shonen so obviously characters get stronger as the story progresses. It's for a reason why for now the only thing that Dragon and Imu do is to see who's better at saying "..." cuz they're for the final arc
Fax 🤣
Shanks beats stabs
Stabs will be used to upscale shanks even more
we don't even know if shanks has a twin and we powerscaling him 😭
Facts
He does
@shay_3859it literally could just be shanks y'all trippin
@ where? Delusional
@@Re-Bourne Before jumping to defense, you could just ask...
It’s not Shanks’s twin. It’s a clone (most likely on of Saturn’s experiments) and the two people who appeared on Elbaf are God’s Knights.
What if he is shanks?
@@raistath4528 Shanks a rat theory??
@@theempoleon78 I still think it might just be shanks, it’s hard to see whether he has the scar or not
I can see Saturn having cloned the Emperors at some point.
I can't see shanks being cloned. Shanks as is would be hard enough to get around without being noticed. If that would be the case then THE ONLY thing that works is lafiette works with the gov. Its shanks
This is the best One Piece youtube channel hands down
Genetics has nothing to do with talent, Talent is achieved through hard work and dedication. As for Shanks twin just because they are siblings doesnt mean they will have the same talent.
I’m all for a Shanks twin, but I’m also on board with it being Shanks himself unwillingly working for Garling. If he has something Garling can exploit, then that’s Luffy’s personal stake in actually toppling the World Government - freeing his mentor from whatever Garling is binding him with.
The bowl that Whitebeard has is located at the spot of the scar on his middle chest. I believe it's possible that he does have it. He also had this scar in Chapter Zero, which takes place not long after his final meeting with Roger. The anime depicts him with this middle chest scar, and it is the only scar he has. So, I think it’s possible that he did have it at that time, possibly given to him by Roger.
But my though is that Roger only fought white beard in the oden flashback but there was no damage and also it was the final meaning that the damage taken was from the shanks clone, it would make more sense why whitebeard felt the scars huritng where he was looking at shanks because it was the clone he fought before . Just a theory
@ I get that but there’s really nothing to suggest Roger and white beard didn’t fight one last time just for the heck of it before Roger turns himself in
And he has one at the time of chapter zero which is not too long after Roger turned himself in
White beard as a total of 4 scars one of them could be from Roger before he turned himself in
The first scar is definitely not from shanks brother as he would only be 16 years old
It could be from Figarland who was on God Valley
@@MarlicJr did you watch the video before making this comment?
9:34 Big Mom uses her df abilities to not be affected by age. She gets stronger when she drains her or other’s lifespan
10:00 5 years ago would still be a Whitebeard significantly weaker than his prime. It still wouldn’t be a feat to injure him. Ace challenged WB 4 years ago and managed to burn him
10:35 His strongest man title comes from even way before God Valley. You would know that if you read his Vivre Card. It most likely refers to his df which is known to be the most powerful paramecia in the world
10:56 Manga chapters aren’t always 100% accurate regarding small details. We’ve litteraly seen Zoro once with Luffy’s scar. The fact that that person was speculated to be Roger in a One Piece magazine means that he had some scars from back then. Therefore, it’s most likely Garling
Nothing in the current story can indicate how strong that Shanks lookalike actually. This is all headcanon based on no actual proof
That last sentence is incredibly ironic
I remembered watching the episode where shanks twin went in to gorosei while tripping and i already knew it was shanks brother😂😂😂
What if roger got illness from garling and whitebeard got his illness from encounter with shanks brother
lol people that were powerscaling shanks based on portayal need to remember to remove the feat of meeting the gorosei/being respected by them
I'm still in doubt that oda would write the twin stuff with the most hype character (shanks), what if he is shanks all this time 🤔
Extra arm?
bro in anime it showed whitebeard got scar after roger find one piece [whitebeard reading newspaper about roger, there was scar] maybe he got his scar in his prim
You forgot to mention goatBEARD as one that reached the levels to compare to shanks
If we assume he indeed has Shanks talent combined with both arms he would have reached Yonko level around the same time as Shanks who was 33years old which was 6years then Stabs/Bhanks(twin) would have scarred a 68 year old whitebeard who much healthier and younger therefore closer to his prime implying relativity but not equal. On of him showcosibg gorosei abilities he will be a monster.
If he’s the holy knight commander which i expect, he’s gonna be at minimum on Law and Kidd level.
Kidd?? Be for real
Really hope it’s a relative/twin. I’m so worried that with the existence of a Stella clone now that any character could be a clone… such as Shanks and Stabs are just perfect clones of Garling… so I just really want the cloning to stop or for Oda to put a cap number of how many “perfect” clones were created like Stussy.
I'm trying to get a video out later today about this, why everything is pointing towards this not being a clone.
How the hell could he have scarred Whitebeard? He would be 5 years old? Garling Figarland is much more reasonable candidate.
He scarred him only like a decade ago when he was like 30 at least. Whitebeard had no scars in the Oden flashback. Which also means if he did fight garling, it wasn't at God Valley.
It’s hard to say how strong he’ll be. I doubt the Holy Knights are Yonko Level or above because like… why didn’t they just eliminate the emporers then if they were xD
The only character who should be stronger than anyone right now is Imu.
Its honestly a coin flip as we dont know much about the holy knight training and if its comprable to shanks lifestyle but that 2 arm buff could put evil shanks close to Mihawk
I mean his twin would certainly probably definitely has 2 arms so yeah, stronger than shanks and by default fraudhawk.
Its actually wild the same chapter vegapunk literally talks about CLONES people are talking about twins. Really?
The next video I'm working on is why it's basically impossible for this character to be a clone
Is it unreasonable to think that there are Holy Knight clones for each of the Yonko?
@@CCC-V3ofc. Why would the government have their dna? The only reason seraphim exists is because warlords was on the government’s side so they were able to make clones.
oda did the prestige
You don’t see the left side of his face so it could be shanks himself could it not?
It’s kind of odd to obscure it twice, though. It can, it would just make a lot less sense unless there’s a side to Shanks we don’t know yet.
I’m still personally on board that this is a clone/ brother
How can you, This character is not Shanks. To me he just looks like shanks.
Because there is an obstruction of his scar and missing arm. So either this is the real shanks and he has been in ties with the Gorosei (very unlikely imo) or it’s a clone or family member.
No doubt full of cruelty
Garling scar ed Prime WB not shanks twin bruh 💀
I got hare from chatgtp lol
If he hss 2 hands then he's twice as strong
I mean assuming he has 2 arms
Yeah, the story could still pull the rug out from under me.
This plot point is so stupid 😭
Can you like uh just let it play out first before calling it stupid 🤷🏾
I feel like the girl could be shanks sister
We only see his right side, how do we know it’s a twin???
If he’s as strong as shanks then yes
Watch the whole video before you respond 😂
Before you say “I did wtf” this video came out 10 minutes ago and it’s a 19 minute video and you’re posting 😂
He’s prolly a bit weaker then shanks, I don’t see him losing in this arc though
shanks twin? im sorry but this is so boring and stupid, ruins shanks charcter also, wtf oda?
No it doesn’t. We saw Shanks in the sea and in the same day he went to the elders? It doesn’t make any sense. And there was no scar. (Oda drew Shanks from the side and there was still a scar on his forehead) but this character did not have the scar
Zhanks