Nazi Terror at the End of The Third Reich - War Against Humanity 133
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.ย. 2024
- Prominent Nazis flee the retribution that they have provoked. Meanwhile, they deploy greater levels of violence than ever before against the German people. With nothing left to lose, just how depraved will Nazi "justice" become? The regime's final farewell to its people will be a bloody one indeed.
Join us on Patreon: / timeghosthistory
Or join the TimeGhost Army directly at: timeghost.tv/s...
Check out our TimeGhost History TH-cam channel: / timeghost
Between 2 Wars: • Between 2 Wars
Follow WW2 Day by Day on Instagram: @ww2_day_by_day
Follow TimeGhost History on Instagram: @timeghosthistory
Like us on Facebook: / timeghosthistory
Hosted by: Spartacus Olsson
Director: Astrid Deinhard
Producers: Astrid Deinhard and Spartacus Olsson
Executive Producers: Astrid Deinhard, Indy Neidell, Spartacus Olsson
Creative Producer: Marek Kamiński
Community Management: Jake McCluskey
Written by: Spartacus Olsson & James Newman
Research by: Spartacus Olsson & James Newman
Map animations by: Daniel Weiss
Map research by: Sietse Kenter
Edited by: Karolina Dołęga
Artwork and color grading by: Mikołaj Uchman
Sound design by: Marek Kamiński
Colorizations by:
Mikołaj Uchman
Spartacus Olsson
Daniel Weiss
Carlos Ortega Pereira, BlauColorizations, / blaucolorizations
Cassowary Colorizations
Source literature list: bit.ly/SourcesWW2
Archive footage: Screenocean/Reuters - www.screenocea...
Image sources:
Bundesarchiv
National Archives
Picture of Volksturm soldiers surrendering courtesy of mil.ru
German Order picture: en.wikipedia.o...
Soundtracks from Epidemic Sound
A TimeGhost chronological documentary produced by OnLion Entertainment GmbH.
These crimes against the German people are but the dying scream of a demon. Our recent video covering the liberation of the Nazi camps exemplify the inhumane depths that the regime could truly sink to. If you wish to know more, you may view that video here th-cam.com/video/yolqCuR7LaU/w-d-xo.html. And if you like what we do, please consider joining the TimeGhost Army at timeghost.tv/signup/ or www.patreon.com/TimeGhostHistory.
Thank you for your support.
Angloid moustache man, Nutsi terror was at home in Germany since 1933, when they violenty opressed all legal opposition and killed thousands of Social democrats, communists, liberals and organized christians and ge nozided ten thousands of disabled people
Franz Halder was not executed. He lived until 1972.
Good riddance to the Third Reich
You basically demonize all germans and justify atrocities against them... with this statement.
"dying scream of a demon" = german people? How cruel.
Schörner sounds like the original seagull manager -- flies in, makes a lot of noise, craps all over everything, then flies away.
literally tried to fly away 🙂
Also he ate 6 pervitin tablets a day and drank coffee I dont know how he survived till The 60's 😄
I've never heard the phrase "seagull manager" before but I am in love with it
@@samuelkatz1124 It has been around but I guess the Pointy Haired Boss has been trying to ban it. At least real seagulls are mostly just in stealing your sandwhich. I heard it10 years ago and loved it ever since! Hope you liked the Vid
@@marcston His name should have been Schnorrer.
"It is curious that physical courage should be so common in the world and moral courage so rare."
Mark Twain
Mark Twain's quotes apply so well to today's politicians and many of the leaders of the WW2 era.
@@jerryw6699 Sadly, yes.
Him and Will Rodgers are two of the best American philosophers. Both are very good reading.
@@sidgarrett7247 I'm currently reading "The Innocents Abroad". Despite having been written in the 1860s, many of Twain's observations about Europe and the Middle East remain timely and humorous. I haven't read nearly as much by Will Rogers. Is there a particular book you recommend?
@@sidgarrett7247I like both of them, because they are able to make fun of mankind, while teaching us very serious flaws of the human's nature.
Of course, most of the Allied military executions were for sexual assault or murder. The Americans only executed one man for desertion, and no one for mutiny/dereliction/etc to my knowledge.
Those Americans executed for SA were statistically over-represented by Black soldiers and often picked at random. Never forget.
@@jayfrank1913 Sadly, yes. Many of those men were likely innocent, and some of them suffered as a result of botched executions by that fraud, John Wood.
Incidents like that are the main reason why I oppose capital punishment in almost all cases (I make an exception for war crimes/crimes against humanity, in the most severe cases)
Private Eddie Slovak ? As depicted by a very young Martin Sheen…
The Brits outlawed the death penalty for desertion in 1930. They executed no one for that. After letting the Brits execute some of our soldiers in World War I and the world was some to our fucking shame - NZ did not execute any soldiers in World War II. And those World War I soldiers were pardoned in 2000 - better late than never I suppose.
Imagine you and some buddies are trying to figure out what to do, cuz nobody told you anything and then you're executed for standing around
On the Nazi Racial Heirarchy - my grandmother was an 'Ostarbeiter' and during allied air raids her employers made room for their dog in the shelter, but didn't have room for her; she got to stay in the house.
How much you wanna bet at the end of the war they claimed there weren't nazis
Glad she made it. That's a horrific story.
-TimeGhost Ambassador
@@WorldWarTwo Yes. And it's not even the worst.
@@clasdauskas My own grandmother was in a similar situation. She said during the raids she lay on her cot in the attic with the other war slaves and prayed a bomb would hit the house and kill her and destroy the families house.
During the Hamburg bombing of 1943, a female Polish worker later described how her factory supervisor, a woman Nazi Party member, locked her and others in after the air raid siren went. They banged on the door and finally a male German worker opened the door and they managed to make it to the air raid shelter in time. She was not sure whether the male worker realised they were Poles. I remember mentioning this incident on an Internet discussion site where there were more than a few Wehraboos, and they professed to disbelieve the story - "Allied propaganda". Uh-huh.
Himmler, "No mercy to shirkers, cowards or weaklings!"
Also Himmler, abandoned his post to try and sell a peace to the Allies, never went near a front line combat zone, was completely incapable of managing the front he was put in charge of briefly and caved in under pressure.
Himmler thinking that he was a main figure to make a separate peace with the allies was one of the most ironic things i read today.
@@heitorm He had been sending out peace feelers since 1943. He got away with it, because he was in charge of the people tasked with investigating such cases, but how could they investigate their superior?
true
He was also captured this week, trying to pass a British checkpoint using the absolutely foolproof pseudonym of 'Heinrich Hitzinger'. 😅
@@davidschaftenaar6530 Sometimes pseudonyms close to the real name are selected because they are easier to remember, but they are also a little transparent...
how stupid someone must feel after carrying out an order to execute someone for cowardess, meanwhile the guy who gave you the order just fled.
'cowardice'
I like how you mock the cowardly German officers and other Nazis who left their soldiers to be captured or killed by enemies while they themselves fled or committed suicide rather than face capture or justice for any war crimes. Thank you for this eye-opening video of WW2 history.
Schoerner, the ultimate "Do as I say, not as I do" commander.
when German Homefront become so brutal that it took Sparty instead of Astrid to explain it
The analogy between the Gauleiter and rats is especially ironic given how Nazi propaganda often portrayed Jews.
There is no analogy: among themselves rats are remarkably honourable and social: they take care of each other and have been observed taking care of those who have difficulty taking care of themselves. But I see your point.
All of this is because of a huge projection. Those men were insecure and used this as a means to get their anger out by projecting those insecurities on innocents. They were fighting themselves the whole time, why they didn’t just end themselves instead of organizing an entire war on behalf of millions is beyond me.
@@mcfahk Its weird that them and mice get this massive reputation for scurrying away as soon as a human surprises them or turns on a light. Is that not what almost every single non-domesticated animal does in the same situation?
I imagine their negative stereotyping came from the plague and has just been a cultural remnant of that societal trauma.
@@extragoogleaccount6061
In part yes because of the plague but also because they live in sewers and filth that most other creatures don’t go near.
Also they will attack humans in some situations eg the trenches in WW1 and they have been known for centuries to carry diseases other than plague.
Personally I like domesticated mice and rats they can make great pets. But in the wild it’s best to stay clear of them
OK let’s clear some things up here:
1. I’m actually a fan of rats. They’re fascinating animals. Like pointed out elsewhere; social, caring, adaptable, resourceful, and relatively intelligent creatures. In my youth I had rats as pets and loved them very much.
2. That said, in human habitations they can become pests and a health hazard, hence their reputation.
3. The analogy here is not the same as the Nazi against the Jews (but yes I see the irony too). The analogy here is to how rats on a ship behave if the ship is going down, they skedaddle into the drink and try to swim away. The image of rats as vermin does add color to that analogy though.
Friend of ours. Who survived holocaust at the end of the war. She’s messianic Jew. Her camp was forced to walk some distance to a train. That was taking all of them to death camp. During the disorderly walk, she decided to walk other way. She hears one of the guards yell at her to stop, she ignores it. She hears guard cocking his rifle, but it malfunction multiple times. He grabs his pistol to shoot her. It malfunctions also. This time guard’s commandant comes over and they start arguing among themselves. While she keeps walking away to freedom. Few days later was saved by allied troops, and lives in Oregon.
That's a hell of a story to tell!
@@gabrielmontenegro9476 .so true. If this would be a scene in a movie, all would say "soo unrealistic ".
"First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out - Because I was not a socialist.
Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out - Because I was not a trade unionist.
Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out- Because I was not a Jew.
Then they came for me-and there was no one left to speak for me." - Martin Niemöller
Except Hitler was a socialist and supported the creation of the DAF (trade union in nazi germany)
Sigismund Best, the British spy kidnapped by the SS at Venlo in 199 and held at Dachau, who spoke German, asked the Austrian Wermacht officer who the columun of SS and prisoners being transported to the Tirol for execution had run into on the road, pointing to former Austrian nationalist leader Kurt Schuschnigg standing with his best friend from his imprisonment at Dachau, the former French leader Leon Blum, and asked, do you know who that is? Yes, replied the young Austrian officer. He then told the Austrian officer that all of Himmler's hostages, including Schuschnigg, Blum, and those implicated in the Hitler plot, like Schecht, and even Stauffenburg's brother, were all to be shot by the SS. Then he purportedly asked the young Austrian officer, "do you know your duty to Austria?"... The Wermacht officer offered the SS "help" to guard the prisoners, while they had lunch. After the SS had sat down to lunch, the Wermacht soldiers disarmed the SS, and freed the prisoners...
Kurt Schuschnigg and Leon Blum becoming besties is something I didn't know. That's absolutely fascinating.
These men who debased themselves in every way possible, their thirst for power, eventually shows they were never in it for "The Folk." It was vanity and their feelings of inadequacy that drove them mad.
How quickly die hard fanaticism on an individual level is extinguished when faced with unavoidable retribution….
it's so frustrating that people have to be reminded of the crimes that happened in the past and yet some still go on to commit the same crimes again and again supported by the manipulated masses. It's like watching a movie you've seen many times - you know what happens but no matter what you do (even if you stop watching or kill yourself) you can't change anything and the film still goes on to its' horrific conclusion. And then it starts all over again.
Right history repeats itself
Well these crimes were never committed again to such an extent, and a world war hasn’t happened yet
I've watched this from day one, thank you for teaching me more than what I learnt at school.
At school we only really covered the Holocaust and it was not all that in depth. I learnt more from this series than I ever learnt in a classroom.
Keep up the good work Sparty and may you continue teaching from that pulpit.
The wholesale feeling of Nazis when things got rough isn't surprising. To a person they were always about self-interest and self-enrichment. Goering probably illustrates this more than most, with his Carinhall estate stuffed full of stolen art.
At least Goering had some sort of class. Probably was rotten to the core like the others, and a junkie psycho, but he is more enjoyable to learn about than the little rats like Himmler or Schörner.
Or Himmler trying to desperately cut a deal with the Western Allies to save his own skin.
Sounds much like the British Empire!
His closing statements are VERY applicable to current events!
There is a movie "Der Hauptman" the English translation "The Captain". It's a drama based on a true story. The storyline parallels what had occurred in the final weeks of WWII. I recommend this movie, but know this is graphic and brutal.
Thank you for sharing !
The film is worth a watch. It is definitely dark, though. It gives a good portrayal of the insanity of the Nazi party.
Very good one, I concurr. Great recommandation.
I've heard both that Willi Herald was and was not real. The real camp has a photo of supposedly the real guy. Not sure what to believe.
@@TankJockey38 I do believe that the movie does depict the desperate and deprived actions in the closing days inside of Nazi Germany. That being said, I have watched a documentary where I had learned about the movie. Unfortunately, I can't remember who produced the documentary.
The Allies kicked in the door and the whole rotten thing came tumbling down.
LMAO
Thank you for the commentary.
Himmler giving an order to execute deserters is bit ironic.
The movie Herr Hauptmann (The Captain) brutally presents this period and the brutal decay of morality almost beyond any recovery.
I'm beginning to believe that Sparty isn't fond of the Nazis.
Brilliantly written & well documented. Thanks.
Thank you for watching!
My friends uncle was murdered by the Nazis for declining to fight at wars end
Spartacus, You are my hero! Your fight for humanity and decency is truly inspiring. We live in an age where the horrors of WW2 if not forgotten are disregarded or treated like some sort of video game. It’s so important nowadays to be reminded of the sources and perpetrators of evil. Thank you!
Surprise surprise, Schoerner deserted his troops in Bohemia and fled to surrender to the Americans.Partial justice was 15 years in Soviet, DDR and BRD prisons. He died in obscurity in Munich in 973
The fear of being captured by the Soviets was real, though it was a fate that millions of German service personnel could not escape. The Nazi elite often led the stampede west, and it is telling that of those put on trial at Nuremberg, only two (Erich Raeder and Hans Fritzsche) were captured in the Soviet zone. Raeder was initially treated well by the Soviets, who seemed interested in what he could tell them about the functioning of the Kriegsmarine in WW2. Then, perhaps following orders from Moscow, he was suddenly detained and then sent to Nuremberg under guard. Fritzsche was involved in surrender negotiations in Berlin and was detained by the Soviets there. He was imprisoned in Moscow under harsh conditions, according to his later account, and then sent to Nuremberg.
Great episode! It would be interesting to have a well documented episode dedicated to "fleeing nazi crime perpretators" in 1945: a closer look at the ratlines, at how the Operation Heydrich operators met their end in Slovenia, how some were never found, how some ended up flying across ennemy territory to Spain, including the fate of some of the Nazis' worst foreign collaborators
All of that coming soon on a WW2 in Real Time channel near you…
As always, a very moving conclusion, Spartacus! Thank you and the entire Time Ghost team. The excellent research done by your staff is incredibly detailed and precise. This episode makes me think of the actions of Nazi murderers and cowards at the end of the European war as that of rats deserting a sinking ship. NEVER FORGET!.
Thank you for such a warm comment, and thank you for watching. Never forget.
Astonishingly craven. Your ending, as always, is masterful.
It feels especially relevant to our contemporary leaders who beckon their followers to fight, fight, fight for "our" country and at the same time troll them for funds to stay out of the courtrooms and face accountability.
Thank you.
The Depth Of Human Madness.
Far beyond the reach of sunlight.
A realm where only the most ancient and depraved creatures of shadow dwell in hell’s crawl-space.
@@SHAd0Eheart And this inhumane monstrosity was spawned in "civilized society of Goethe and Beethoven" nonetheless, ironic.
And now it is finally over. At least in Europe.
th-cam.com/video/Whqws6PSgY0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=jB30Pa9ltkpqTGSz&t=52
@@thanos_6.0putin is trying to do the same now
16:08 I remember how surprised I was when you mentioned on your weekly episodes that Franz Halder joined the resistance, since he was a certified Nazi and responsible for the Wehrmachts genocidal war in the east till mid 1942.
Yep. Same with Erich Hoepner and Von Stulpnagel too...
I think many nazis joined resistance
It's wild to think that people who should have known they could be dead at almost any time would then decide to spend their last days shooting civilians, and then trying to run at practically the worst possible time.
I guess there's something to be said for making terrible decisions consistently and to the bitter end, though...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feldj%C3%A4gerkorps
Some executions were carried out by them - they were set up as a way of supplementing the work of the Feldgendarmerie or military police. After the surrender, many if not all were allowed to retain arms in POW camps, certainly in the US zone, to maintain order. It is interesting to me anyway that the military police of the current German Army are also called Feldjäger.
I remember when I studied the Endphaseverbrechen when I was in High school back in 2015. Horrific but yet interesting.
My grandpa was sentenced to death for appropriating an abandoned officers supply cart for himself and his unit. Luckily one of the officers on the tribunal was a friend of his father. 🤷♂️
Every school in the world needs to watch both World War2 and Crimes against Humanity, but especially Crimes against Humanity because we are starting to head down this road again and its terrifying. Never Forget!!
"It's not that we have a bad organization that's rotten to the core - it's that you aren't willing to sacrifice enough to save it."
Your summary at the end was well said and point on.... there are a lot of folks today who need to heed the warning...
It's easy talk about fighting to the death when somebody else is doing the fighting. Sad that so many had to die for a lost cause. Thank you for making this excellent video. 😢
Most people think (or hope), that they would have been an Oscar Schindler Type, or at least someone who resisted the nuts-ie regime actively, if they had lived in that era. The truth is that most people (60-80%) would watch scared as heck from the sidelines and try to keep their head down and sit everything out.
Even Schindler was an ambiguous figure in the early part of the war, hard to distinguish from all the other Germans seeking to make a fortune in an occupied country, the General Government or "Gangster Ground".
If any one of your truly excellent videos were to be shown to every schoolchild, every college student, every working adult and senior citizen on Earth, it should be this one. Future generations of humanity should always remember the depths to which we can sink, when we Forget.
that thumbnail is an absolute meme
I know the Holocaust has ended, but the plight of the Jewish Survivors was far from over. Many Jews who tried to return to the towns and cities where they had lived faced death. Many family friends endured this awful treatment. I was wondering if you will be covering the plight of these and other displaced persons, as well as the ethnic cleansing that the Soviets engaged in postwar Eastern Europe in this series?
It is worth pointing out that, in spite of Stalin's well publicised order, the reality for Soviet soldiers was something very different. Most soviet soldiers really did not face serious consequences for retreating, it was the junior comisars who were so regularly made example of.
I don't have the figures at hand for the "Fall Blau" campaign and the subsequent Stalingrad operations, but I'm pretty sure that the vast majoity of those executed for desertion by Stalin's regime were actually the junior officers tasked with ensuring hat desertions didn't become rife.
I’m not sure that it being junior officers lessens the number… or are you saying that 158,000 executed junior officers is not so bad as 158,000 executed privates? How many Junior officers do you value a private at? Two? Three? Ten? I don’t have the going exchange rates myself…
@@spartacus-olsson Where are you getting those numbers from? That number is very suspiciously the exact same as the number of Soviet soldiers executed for desertion during the entire war! Order 227 was in force for 3 months (July 28, 1942 - October, 1942).
Official effect of this order:
- Detained solders who attempted to flee battles: 140,750
of these:
- executed: 1,189 (0.8%)
- sent to penal battalions: 2,961 (2.1%)
- returned to duty 131,094 (93.2%)
@@alanywalany6460 yes that is the number for the entire war. The comment I replied to didn’t refer to the order itself, but to execution for desertion in general.
@@spartacus-olsson The comment you replied to is talking about consequences for retreating though, which is what Order 227 is about, and therefore I'd argue that the comment is too. Deserting and retreating are not, and were not considered, the same. Plus. as outlined in other comments the order was aimed at officers ordering unauthorised withdrawals.
While I now get that your actual point is that executing someone for deserting is wrong, I didn't get that impression at all from the video and neither did many others.
@@alanywalany6460 i think mangos are poisonous and many people agree with me.
OK… admittedly it is unclear how many many are, and my impression of both mangos and how many many is, might be colored by the fact that I don’t like mangos. I say; might…
I wasn’t making any argument about the appropriate punishment for desertion, I’m just inquiring why it’s better to execute junior officers than regular soldiers… I might be stupid, but I’m confused by that idea.
Franz Halder died in 1972
The true heroes ….
Remember the title of one of Roger Water’s songs: THE BRAVERY OF BEING OUT OF RANGE.
Thank you again for a powerful video, Sparty. Incredibly powerful.
Your speeches at the end of these episodes really hit home. You and the team do a great job writing them and you do a perfect job delivering them.
❤ thank you
So what Placard should have Joseph Goebbles worn as he couldn't protect his 6 children from his wife.
Spartacus' final words in this video gave me the shivers.
I had a history professor that had been a slave at Keil.
friendly reminder the german people never rose up against nazi rule, not even in the end
make of that what you will
Ahh, the famous crime of standing around without orders... can relate.
Brilliant as always, thank you Spartacus and the team.
A brilliant summing-up by Sparty, as ever!
The last 2 minutes of that was... very specific.
Well Said. "Never Forget" Bravo Sir.
"In every age it has been the tyrant, the oppressor and the exploiter who has wrapped himself in the cloak of patriotism, or religion, or both to deceive and overawe the People." Eugene V. Debs
Evil exists and it walks the face of the Earth.
Well, I may as well finish my stories of pythonesque idiocy here . My grandfather fought in the Battle of East Prussia in the Volksturm (aged 40) delivering uniforms to the front. He eventually literally got hit in the ass by a Russian shell fragment (they referred to the Soviets as Russians; it''s what they did). I remember he walked with a cane when he had the operation to remove the final fragment around 1970. He was evacuated by medical boat from Danzig/Gdansk. I always pictured a converted cargo hold full of stretchers, but I may be wrong. The boat came under attack; I picture strafing fire from a Soviet fighter, but again I could be wrong. One fanatic Nazis admonished the injured soldiers for being cowards and not fighting the attack. He picked up a rifle climbed up the ladder to the porthole and plopped back to the ground dead before he could climb to the deck. The whole boat just looked at his body silently lying there, and my Grandfather thought to himself "Yes, you wished that on yourself".
One example of this mentality was a story told to me by a chap captured at Arnhem. Along with two others they escaped on their transit to Germany and were recaptured a couple of days later. They were then force marched for two or three days to catch up with the other prisoners. Once they crossed into Germany and in a very disheveled state they were passing through a small village. Here an old lady came forward with water and some food for the bedraggled men. A German escorting them (an SS man) shot the woman out of hand. `Rats biting at their own wounds` springs to mind.
Excellent episode, sparty! Your closing words hit me hard, very much on point.
Thank you Spartacus. Your warning is a prediction of the future of our leadership today.
I don't know why it's taken me so long, I finally figured out why Sparty ends these the way he does. It's so that I can hit the Like button with a clear conscience. Who wants to like all this death and destruction, the war against humanity? Not me! But after that rousing speech at the end, I hit the button immediately.
Shirking is actually regular practice in the military
Just plain fantastic! I have to re-watch this.
Yes, wonderful monologue at the end!
The UK abolished execution for military offences including desertion in 1930. British servicemen executed during WWII had all committed murder.
Some prominent politicians/individuals that were marched to tyrol and narrowly avoided being shot include:
- Kurt Schuschnigg, the pre-anschluss chancellor of austria
- President Leon Blum of France (truly a miracle he survived given he was both jewish and a socialis)
- the Duke of Parma, also known as the pretender of the Carlist dynasty for the spanish throne
- fritz Thyssen, senior industrialist who initially supported hitler but objected to war and Kristallnacht
- hjalmar schacht, former head of DDP and brains behind hitler's economic "miracle"
- martin niemoller
- Alexandros Papagos, future PM of Greece
- Georg Thomas ( man who came up with the "hunger plan")
- miklos horthy's son, as well as the "moderate" PM installed to try and gain some independence from berlin
One of those Germans who disappeared in May 1945, presumably killed in the fighting, was Felix Hartlaub. Born in 1913, he trained as a historian and with the outbreak of WW2 he was called up. He was posted to Hitler's headquarters to help maintain a sort of operational diary. He kept his own diary and wrote down his impressions of what he saw around him, rather close to the centre of the vortex though he was low-ranking, only an Obergefreiter. He was sent off to fight the approaching Red Army in the Spandau area at the start of May 1945 and after that all trace of him was lost. He was officially declared dead in 1955 - his sister published his diary and loose-leaf notes he made about Hitler's HQ. He may have been hoping to work them into a more developed form if he survived the war.
Excellent monologue at the end.
The last paragraphs stand true for nearly all modern politicians. !
Brilliant script writing and presentation!
Never forget.
He's the sexy one.
Thank you for this great series. Might I suggest that you do a series about the aftermath of the war to include the Nuremberg Trials
Your closing statements are always so powerful
Spartakus articulates amazingly.
Great video, tons of information unknown to me previously. Have subscribed. Keep up the awesome work 👏 👍 👌
What is the source for the number of 150k dead Soviet soldiers due to order 227? All I can find is that during the three months where it was seriously in effect 1000 were shot
When did I say that this was the effect of that specific order? The number is the total executed for a number of orders to the same or similar effect.
@@spartacus-olsson You said:
"Order number 227 of the people's commissar for defense of 28th of July 1942. This was the order that anyone fleeing the enemy would be shot for cowardice. It cost over 150,000 Soviet soldiers their lives."
By "it" I assumed you meant just this one order. But if it's multiple orders could you please list them? I'm just interested in reading more about them.
@@gaoHNQstart with Order of the Supreme Command of the Red Army on August 16, 1941, No. 270; "On the responsibility of the military for surrender and leaving weapons to the enemy"
This preceded Order 227 and set the standard for a number of subsequent orders. So, although 227 is the one that has become infamous, it’s really this order that is the basis for the prosecution and execution of Red Army personnel during the war.
Hence, start reading up on Order 270 and the rest will follow.
I remember reading that by 1944 one family in three either had a family member or aclose friend taken by the gestapo. These were german citizens living in Germany.
Man alive... i feel like I've gotten almost used to the senseless murders by the German army over the course of this series, but shooting over twenty people for "standing around?" Sheesh....
Another excellent summation.
Thank you.
Thanks for watching.
Gee, wonder who that last paragraph was referring to?
Spartacus, magnificent as always.!
Your closing comments are as relevant today as they would have been 70 years ago.
Yes!! That ending! Brilliantly put! ❤
What drives me kinda wild is how many of these people faced little punishment for things they did.
Wow, needing too reward this again right away, power packed, intense and unapologetically clear on morals.
This reminds me of 'The Great Terror', that which happened toward the end of 'The Terror' that the French revolution caused and only stopped when it's creator Robespierre was put to death.
Great analysis - still applicable. Who says history does not repeat itself?
Great episode. Can someone clarify the spelling of the place on March 29th where the women tore down tank barriers and were arrested? The transcript says Oxenfort in vburg but I’m not sure that’s correct. I found Oxenfurt, but no luck finding more info about this. Is there a further source for this incident?
I wish those of us voting in this year's elections, wherever they are, would heed your words on populism Spartacus, yet, by the looks of it, it would seem we've learned absolutely nothing from the past.
As a species, indeed did we learn few.
Thank you for this excellent presentation. Do take care all.
Outstanding video👍👍
Thank you very much for the comment and thanks for watching..
Great Info, Thanks!!
So true, the loudest coward playing on the ignorance/insecurities of many - igniting actions that are unimaginable. When the consequences of their cowardly actions are eliminated, the leaders quickly deny and distance themselves from their actions/words. This is repeating itself throughout the free world....again..PLEASE, NEVER FORGET, VOTE, BECOME ACTIVE, POSITIVELY, WHEREVER YOU LIVE.
I love this channel. Thank you, so much.
Thank you. Never forget.
Spartacus: "...don't listen to the bullying bloated screamers bloviating about how they are fighting for you..." - he's not just talking about old nazi leadership.