The moment you love a song so much, you start listening to it so much, that you get bored of it, so you come listen to the demo so you feel like you're watching it all over again.
@@FrostBitey10 No it’s worse than champagne supernova in every way tbh, everything from the lead guitar to the solo to the vocals to the chorus. Champagne supernova has a lot more meaning to people than Roll It Over believe you me. The line ‘How many special people change’ is more profound than anything in this song. Tbh, I think this this song is decent but the only thing that sells it is liam’s vocal
Fucking beautiful. I remember listening to this in high school in my car on a rainy day. Drove home only listening to it. Then the whole night. Love OASIS
Probably my favourite song from Standing on the shoulders of giants. Something very sad, but somehow deeply moving about this one. It's definitely my favourite Oasis album. I like the psychedelic vibe about it, particularly this song.
Doesn't get half the credit it deserves, I love it. It's honestly one of the best sounding records on vinyl you'll ever hear, it's mixed outrageously good.
It is the closest they came to the Fabs and that wasn't an accident, Noel was deep into the bootlegs and Beatles oddities at the time, nothing wrong with that. Weller must have been spitting feathers as he never came this close to extending the Beatles, despite ripping Taxman and Dear Prudence.
@@KyTaundry and it captures the epic feel of the Dar Side of the Moon album. I dont know why he and this song dont get more credit for it. Its a great song and performance. Liam nails it though, still: th-cam.com/video/sheCuKXPsnQ/w-d-xo.html
I can give a hundred million reasons To build a barricade I blame it on the changing of the seasons The thoughts that I've conveyed Does it make it all right? It doesn't make it all right To roll it over my soul and leave me here Roll it over my soul and leave me here Look around at all the plastic people Who live without a care Try to sit with me around my table But never bring a chair
I’m glad you enjoyed that feeling. I did too, at 100mph on a bike powerful motorbike. Nothing like that exists for me. But, here in 2022, that’s been extinguished by the evil globalists.
Absolutely Magical tune!! I get the strangest feeling when I hear this song. It's melancholy, bittersweet and cosmic catharsis all in one (if you'll pardon the pretentious choice of words). Fuckin' masterpiece this. Thank you, Noel. You make all our lives so much better with your beautiful music. :)
What's so amazing is this is just a demo (although it pretty much is the same as the finished track that just has Liam singing it and the guitars tidied up a tad) imagine churning these demos out as prolifically as Noel has
Creo recordar que era 1997 o 1998y en casa habían contratado televisión por cable y comenzaba a ver MTV y recuerdo una noche que pasaron un concierto de Oasis ( en el escenario había un enorme Reloj ) Yo nunca los había escuchado antes, y fue increíble como con solo ver ese concierto quedé enamorada de su música y desde ahí me volví una fan mexicana 😍, sus canciones han Sido el Soundtrack de mi vida ❤️ Los extraño 😭😭😭😅
Love this, love Noel (I mean, he can sing it with more emotion because he is the one who wrote it and knows what it's about) but honestly I think Liam's voice works way better for this.
This song, for me, is an absolute “hook monster”. So much of it sticks in my mind & heart for days after listening to this fairly bare version. One of the very many simple-sounding songs Noel’s penned, that are definitely not simple. There are many unexpected chord changes, unusual sounds compared with much of his canon of music, and it’s really heartfelt. Not very rock & roll, more like heartbreak. It’s also got a persistent ethereal, somewhat psychedelic vibe about it.
How have I only heard this demo in 2022?! Jesus wept! I absolutely adore Roll it Over but I absolutely love this version. It just feels more rock n roll when it's stripped back like this. Although I do prefer Liam's main vocal.
On the Album version as the chorus kick in, "Roll It over"... could Of sworn that was Noel's voice! But for a few seconds into the chorus, you can hear Its Liam, However I wonder if they Are both singing the chorus together and Noel's Voice just cut though THE MIX a bit louder ? Liams just Has that Type of Tone that can just turn an average song into A Really Great Song. Noel really pulls off this song and Yes I know he wrote it.
LYRICS HERE !!! I can give a hundred million reasons To build a barricade I blame it on the changing of the seasons The thoughts that I've conveyed Does it make it all right? It doesn't make it all right To roll it over my soul and leave me here Roll it over my soul and leave me here Look around at all the plastic people Who live without a care Try to sit with me around my table But never bring a chair Does it make it all right? It doesn't make it all right To roll it over my soul and leave me here Roll it over my soul and leave me here To roll it over my soul and leave me here Roll it over my soul and leave me here To roll it over my soul and leave me here Roll it over my soul and leave me here
I sort of wish Noel had originally sung this one ,, then I heard Liam doing a version of it and that would of absolutely blew me away. Hope this make sense to anyone
This song. Makes me feel good. I like noel Gallagher version. Slightly more than Liam it reminds me playing in the big gardens in the 70s.with my brother and mum. Near the swings outside. Great tune. Forever
Más que excelente interpretación, he escuchado las canciones que noel ha sacado ya sin liam y de pronto me pongo ha imaginarlas en voz de liam, se escuchan bastante genial. Que triste, ¡ya son más de 10 años!
One of the very few Noel's vocals that equals Liam's original performance. The guitar solo has a bit of harmonic chord resolution from the album cut missing from it however
Both great versions. I quite like a lot of Noel’s versions of things. A bit more emotion but Liam’s got the grit. It’s so great that we get the gift of so many hidden gems! Can’t say that for every band
Appart from Liam's voice, this demo also lacks the female chorus that elevates the choruses, the rolls on the drumming and a more melodic bass. The gem is there but when polished escalated on another level.
This so such a Liam song. Some songs are best with Noel but this is one of those songs that proofs that Oasis wouldn't not have been anything without Liam.
Es cierto que liam le pone toda su potencia y feling bocal , Pero es Noel el protagonista de esta cancion es por eso que suena mejor el demo , es el mismo Noel desgarrandose por dentro ,
@vinchenzo19 Mustard?! hahahaha Is that a good thing? I love language and that one caught my eye. Never heard the word used in that context before. I'm pretty sure I love it, though. =P And I totally agree that Noel's solo work is going to be tops. Can't fookin wait!
Liam added a sense of anger to this song with his voice. Noel brings out the weary melancholy in it. Both are great versions.
Mate, fair comment. Both are on different planes.
👏👏👏👏👌👌
Liam turned it into the anthem-like song that it deserves to be.
Defo think it suits Noel’s voice better
@@xyzxyz997 I don't think so. The chorus sounds very flat when noel sings it.
The moment you love a song so much, you start listening to it so much, that you get bored of it, so you come listen to the demo so you feel like you're watching it all over again.
I do that the opposite way I listen to Noel's version first except I never get bored of it
Amen brother
Since I love this Song so much, I'm careful not to overplay it so it remains fresh to me
No demo version for me. Liam gives this song more feeling than noel
Not only is Oasis the best band of their generation, but also the best ever B-sides band and the best ever demos band.
Definately
@@whatsthestory09Maybe
Magic or Heathen Chemistry ?
When Standing On The Shoulder Of Giants came out, one reviewer called this song a poor man's Champagne Supernova, which I think is very unfair.
It's fucking amazing actually like whole album
Said by someone who's never written one song close to this....who cares of the fckn journalists...
You can't have read my comment properly.
It's actually a more sophisticated man's Champagne Supernova as the lyrics actually have some meaning.
@@FrostBitey10 No it’s worse than champagne supernova in every way tbh, everything from the lead guitar to the solo to the vocals to the chorus. Champagne supernova has a lot more meaning to people than Roll It Over believe you me. The line ‘How many special people change’ is more profound than anything in this song. Tbh, I think this this song is decent but the only thing that sells it is liam’s vocal
always thought this was one of the most underrated Oasis songs.
It’s 2/3 there but needs a better chorus.
@@EOTA564 Ha, erm no. The chorus is excellent
Same, almost enough to redeem the whole album
@094_Athalla Zachari Go let it out
Hace poco la escuché después de tantos años que salió, actualmente Liam la incluye en sus últimos setlist, espero venga a México
Fucking beautiful. I remember listening to this in high school in my car on a rainy day. Drove home only listening to it. Then the whole night. Love OASIS
This sounds so Year 2000, and I think that's a good thing. 👽
Good because it was in fact the year 2000
@@lebigfin5251 sounds like james blunt was inspired by some of the guitar elements of this, at least the acoustic parts. or maybe its just very 2000s
The whole album is the sounds of the year 2000
Probably my favourite song from Standing on the shoulders of giants. Something very sad, but somehow deeply moving about this one. It's definitely my favourite Oasis album. I like the psychedelic vibe about it, particularly this song.
Doesn't get half the credit it deserves, I love it. It's honestly one of the best sounding records on vinyl you'll ever hear, it's mixed outrageously good.
Isn’t it about their dad ?
It is the closest they came to the Fabs and that wasn't an accident, Noel was deep into the bootlegs and Beatles oddities at the time, nothing wrong with that. Weller must have been spitting feathers as he never came this close to extending the Beatles, despite ripping Taxman and Dear Prudence.
Rolon, amo esa canción, gas panic también
this freakin open string sound during the chorus kills me the coolest possible way
Similar chord to Led Zeppelin “no quarter” opening riff
The entire atmosphere is unbelievable. Noel Gallagher is a genius, feeling like a mix of Velvet Underground and Pink Floyd.
Like your analogy…
Totally get the Pink Floyd vibe from this, even more so with the solo that's played on the studio version, the reverby, washy drums etc.
@@KyTaundry and it captures the epic feel of the Dar Side of the Moon album. I dont know why he and this song dont get more credit for it. Its a great song and performance.
Liam nails it though, still: th-cam.com/video/sheCuKXPsnQ/w-d-xo.html
So underrated
I can give a hundred million reasons
To build a barricade
I blame it on the changing of the seasons
The thoughts that I've conveyed
Does it make it all right?
It doesn't make it all right
To roll it over my soul and leave me here
Roll it over my soul and leave me here
Look around at all the plastic people
Who live without a care
Try to sit with me around my table
But never bring a chair
Makes my life feel a little better. Noel is celebrated as a songwriter yet still underrated somehow.
speeding down the motorway at 90+ mph on a sunny day singing the "roll it over my soul" bit....immense!
The best feeling on this planet
Glad I'm not the only one!
I’m glad you enjoyed that feeling. I did too, at 100mph on a bike powerful motorbike.
Nothing like that exists for me.
But, here in 2022, that’s been extinguished by the evil globalists.
bro i want to do this, im gonna work to do this
This song is so underrated, instantly one of my favorite Oasis songs...wished they played it life.
Knebworth 2022 👀
Was special
this is such an unnoticed song on the album
noel has taken it to a whole new level
amazing!!
Absolutely Magical tune!! I get the strangest feeling when I hear this song. It's melancholy, bittersweet and cosmic catharsis all in one (if you'll pardon the pretentious choice of words). Fuckin' masterpiece this. Thank you, Noel. You make all our lives so much better with your beautiful music. :)
One of the most beautiful songs.
Oh my Gosh! His voice is SO GREAT on the SOTSOG demos. . I'm so in love with this man and his beautiful voice!!! Noel Gallagher is incredible!
la cancion me hace sentir que no quiero cargar solo el peso que llevo en esta vida , ,, gracias Oasis.,por existir
The guitar solo is a sort of homage to Come Together. At least, I've always felt it that way. Great tune
Thinking the same thing
Yeah I always thought that too
100% it is, it's note for note 👍🏻
当然カムトゥゲザーを知っているけど、この曲のギターソロに聞こえる。ピッタリなギターソロだ。最高。
Noel you're genius
great voice noel so emotional
Wow the voice of Noel is perfect! But in this song I prefer Liam's voice, is more "emotional" for me.. I love this song! :)
I think the same
What's so amazing is this is just a demo (although it pretty much is the same as the finished track that just has Liam singing it and the guitars tidied up a tad) imagine churning these demos out as prolifically as Noel has
Noel can hold those notes! Like Noel said, He's the better singer but Liam's got the better voice
I mean Liam held the notes in this song just as well
Liam was actually bang on the money vocally for the first few years.. it’s just tragic that no one saw or cared he was struggling vocally.
@@lebigfin5251 Not at all. Noel sustained the notes wayyyy longer, Liam ran out of breath relatively quickly with the long notes during the chorus.
I think Liam has a more noticeable voice. Noel has a better voice
Es de esas canciones que no importa cuantos años pasen siempre regresas a escucharla !!
i love your pfp :)
Noel is definetly the best songwriter ever ... at least from the last hundred years
Not just he wrote extremely high quality songs, their sheer number is stunning, the songs not ending!
Creo recordar que era 1997 o 1998y en casa habían contratado televisión por cable y comenzaba a ver MTV y recuerdo una noche que pasaron un concierto de Oasis ( en el escenario había un enorme Reloj )
Yo nunca los había escuchado antes, y fue increíble como con solo ver ese concierto quedé enamorada de su música y desde ahí me volví una fan mexicana 😍, sus canciones han Sido el Soundtrack de mi vida ❤️
Los extraño 😭😭😭😅
th-cam.com/video/I5qUjae_So8/w-d-xo.html
I think you’re talking about GMEX 1997
For me, the best band ever. Not even in their top 20 yet it's so freaking good it's in their top 20. Every Oasis tune is like that.
Liam lifts this song to far greater heights
What a piece of rock and roll!!! I love this tune!
WTF, why we don't hear it on repeat on the radio?😊
Love this, love Noel (I mean, he can sing it with more emotion because he is the one who wrote it and knows what it's about) but honestly I think Liam's voice works way better for this.
This song, for me, is an absolute “hook monster”. So much of it sticks in my mind & heart for days after listening to this fairly bare version.
One of the very many simple-sounding songs Noel’s penned, that are definitely not simple. There are many unexpected chord changes, unusual sounds compared with much of his canon of music, and it’s really heartfelt. Not very rock & roll, more like heartbreak.
It’s also got a persistent ethereal, somewhat psychedelic vibe about it.
2:40 Noel is a whole another level and vibe
Woow beautiful!
Always loved this song. Well underrated!
Noel's solo stuff is going to be mustard!
And it has been.
Jesus Christ this is perfect!!!
I was in Cheshire as a young child. And this song makes the good times flood back. When I dident have a care in the world. Everything was so easy.
How have I only heard this demo in 2022?! Jesus wept! I absolutely adore Roll it Over but I absolutely love this version. It just feels more rock n roll when it's stripped back like this. Although I do prefer Liam's main vocal.
Real cool! Went for a walk this mornin and listened to his version non stop!
Noel owns the song. End of discussion. Fuckin' brilliant!
I have a few good Demo's. Lyla, Let there be love, Importance of being idle. All relaxing to listen. Noel is a genius.
On the Album version as the chorus kick in,
"Roll It over"...
could Of sworn that was Noel's voice!
But for a few seconds into the chorus, you can hear Its Liam,
However I wonder if they Are both singing the chorus together and Noel's Voice just cut though THE MIX a bit louder ?
Liams just Has that Type of Tone that can just turn an average song into A Really Great Song.
Noel really pulls off this song and Yes I know he wrote it.
God I love this
The best most mature song he wrote. From their best album. It's abit like pink Floyd in its sound world but doesn't matter. It's an inspired song.
I love this song and noel made it to a whole nother level, this is so emotional, I can feel it really....
Thanks for this Joy Noel
LYRICS HERE !!!
I can give a hundred million reasons
To build a barricade
I blame it on the changing of the seasons
The thoughts that I've conveyed
Does it make it all right?
It doesn't make it all right
To roll it over my soul and leave me here
Roll it over my soul and leave me here
Look around at all the plastic people
Who live without a care
Try to sit with me around my table
But never bring a chair
Does it make it all right?
It doesn't make it all right
To roll it over my soul and leave me here
Roll it over my soul and leave me here
To roll it over my soul and leave me here
Roll it over my soul and leave me here
To roll it over my soul and leave me here
Roll it over my soul and leave me here
liam smashed this out live solo at knebworth 22 , 🤩🤩
i can't say which version is better. if i had to decide i would put them both on one album :D
Noel has a great voice. I actually prefer this version
I sort of wish Noel had originally sung this one ,, then I heard Liam doing a version of it and that would of absolutely blew me away. Hope this make sense to anyone
This song. Makes me feel good. I like noel Gallagher version. Slightly more than Liam it reminds me playing in the big gardens in the 70s.with my brother and mum. Near the swings outside. Great tune. Forever
damn beautiful...❤️
Another masterpiece
this song is good on both versions were either noel or liam singing it. Wonderful!
spectacular oasis demo!
Other than Put Yer Money Where Yer Mouth Is, this is an excellent album.
Roll it Over and Sunday Morning Call are so Beatles-esque.
that bridge is glorious
❤
Man I wish he would play this with the his High Flying Birds....they would make this track sound even more bad-ass!! Fuckin epic tune
The best versión
The thing is Oasis wouldnt be without the brilliant voice of Liam
Liam voice much more power
This song sums up the year 2020 just get this over
STUNNING
INSANE
HOLY SHEEEIT
Class ❤
Más que excelente interpretación, he escuchado las canciones que noel ha sacado ya sin liam y de pronto me pongo ha imaginarlas en voz de liam, se escuchan bastante genial. Que triste, ¡ya son más de 10 años!
Very nice. Liam's version of this song at Knebworrh was amazing.
✊ Beautiful
No way. I thought Liam wrote that for beady eye. Well you learn something new everyday
I like it
Nice One. Cheers
Thank you! Cheers!
A good album is 'Standing On The Shoulder of Giants'.
leonardoboy2 and still so underated
Great album*
A good album it is
One of my Oasis favourites,has to be Liam’s vocals,a very emotional song if you really listen ✌️
For those who say Noel was the better singer, listen to this and then the isolated vocals of Liam. No contest in my opinion
Nothing like driving with this song on, and singing like a parrot, but from the heart...😅
Unlucky Champagne Superenova
Amazing
So nice version using the doble track!!!
One of the very few Noel's vocals that equals Liam's original performance. The guitar solo has a bit of harmonic chord resolution from the album cut missing from it however
Both great versions. I quite like a lot of Noel’s versions of things. A bit more emotion but Liam’s got the grit.
It’s so great that we get the gift of so many hidden gems! Can’t say that for every band
gr8 tune noel!!!!
More emotion in Noel's voice
+Sam Hoxley but Liam version is amzing in the Album
+maulana bayu nah
Sam Hoxley He wrote it, so it makes sense
They're both fine.
Sam Hoxley for sure beautiful singer
Baita som! É uma gênio!
Awesome. Noel should strip back to this style for the next Flying Birds album.
legend
I always think that Noel is better in the delivery. Of course Liam has great voice, but the delivery? Absolutely Noel.....
Peter Jones Liam is a much better singer I think anyone that knows anything about music realises that
Peter Jones
Depends what song is sung - but 99% of the time Liam delivers with far more presence.
T P lol
S Todd depends what "Presence" you are talking about, Liam can't make people cry like Noel, Noel can't make people jump up an down like Liam
It's like Noel is one hell of a good musician but in singing, Liam is just one of the millions.
Appart from Liam's voice, this demo also lacks the female chorus that elevates the choruses, the rolls on the drumming and a more melodic bass. The gem is there but when polished escalated on another level.
one of the most underrated Oasis songs!
I think they had a pink floyd sound on this perticular album . Every band needs inspiration.
nice
So much better than the album version
+Fredo THIS IS high flying bird i think
No it's the demo made by Noel around 1999/2000 for the Standing on the Shoulders of Giants album
Fredo it's nowhere near as good as the album version
Oasis was the complementary color of the Beatles
Does it make it all right? It doesn’t make it all right, To roll it over my soul and leave me heeere ;(
This so such a Liam song. Some songs are best with Noel but this is one of those songs that proofs that Oasis wouldn't not have been anything without Liam.
FACT
Mejor que la versión del disco.
Es cierto que liam le pone toda su potencia y feling bocal ,
Pero es Noel el protagonista de esta cancion es por eso que suena mejor el demo , es el mismo Noel desgarrandose por dentro ,
@vinchenzo19 Mustard?! hahahaha Is that a good thing? I love language and that one caught my eye. Never heard the word used in that context before. I'm pretty sure I love it, though. =P
And I totally agree that Noel's solo work is going to be tops. Can't fookin wait!