I used to hear several versions of this piece " Rheinische". This is phenomenal. Paavo inspired the orchestra to be full of drive. Hidden master piece in youtube! Wolfgang Sawallisch loved this orchestra.
MGH cnsGABA I have just listened to Giulini conducting this with Mahler's orchestration. You don't need only Mahler but also a good conductor. Giulini was so violent on the emphasised bass notes in the first. I thought there was something wrong with me, but I tried the next best Rhenisch, this one Takes the bass emphases normally and doesn't beat heel out of the earth with them. Clara insisted that fortes in her husbands music should never be crass unless a very special Sforfzando was required Am I wong? Maybe I'm getting a bit old and feeble for the bang,bang, bang stuff.
Felix de Villiers I appreciate for your comment. I wrote to applaud Jarvi's excellent leadership to motivate and inspire the orchestra. In this performance,someone may feel the river Rhein flows with too much of vigour. Like or dislike,it's a matter of taste. I respect your comment,and I should say that I can't answer whether you are wrong. I am merely a music fan. Thank you.
The opening is breathtaking! The best I have ever heard actually, it breaths and there is no confusion, nothing timid or forceful. I might even say this is the first time I have heard it done "right".
I am not a man readily prone to tears, but for some reason the ascending horn octaves in the finale make me tear. More a comment on the piece; I jusr find it curious that such an upbeat movement is the saddest and most moving part of the Symphony to me.
+Jackson Witmer Couldn't agree more. I love Schumann and I have never understood the critics who trivialize his symphonies. This interpretation reveals the great depths of Schumann's musical genius.
It is likely that Järvi combined Schumann's original score and Mahler's reorchestration because horns play both notes of original score and Mahler's arrangement.
Paavo Jarvi will be the top conductor of the NHK symphony orchestra in autumn 2015.His concert program in Feb.13&14th,2015 with NHK symphony orchestra. !.Sibelius' violin concerto with Sayaka Shoji. 2.Shostakovich's 5th.symphony. I used to love to see and hear his DVD of Beethoven's 3rd.and 5th.piano concerto with Ikuyo Nakamichi and Die Deutsche Kammerphilharmonie Bremen.
The momentum is persistent from the beginning to the end. Magnificent. It reminds me of the landscapes of snow mountains, deep valleys, and rivers I saw on multiday hikes!
マーラー版かと思ったけどよく聴くと所々シューマンの原稿に戻してるとこもありますね
9:40
この演奏とっても好きなんですか、どこで入手できるんでしょう？探してもないです〜（泣）
This recording is perhaps better than that of Tilson Thomas. This is is so good. The strings and the winds are i
この曲の演奏で、最も素晴らしいものの１つだと思います。この曲は、今ひとつ解らないところがありましたが、この演奏で氷解した気がします。
It`s a symphony , not a song !!!
@@nigelmorley5414 maybe your google translation is misunderstanding. 曲 has meaning of piece and work not only a song😅
ＮＨＫ交響楽団もいい演奏してるね
N響の演奏も、味わい深い､素晴らしいですね。今後の活動に、期待出来ますね。
I didn't know putin could conduct
I used to hear several versions of this piece " Rheinische". This is phenomenal.
Paavo inspired the orchestra to be full of drive.
Hidden master piece in youtube! Wolfgang Sawallisch loved this orchestra.
MGH cnsGABA I have just listened to Giulini conducting this with Mahler's orchestration. You don't need only Mahler but also a good conductor. Giulini was so violent on the emphasised bass notes in the first. I thought there was something wrong with me, but I tried the next best Rhenisch, this one Takes the bass emphases normally and doesn't beat heel out of the earth with them. Clara insisted that fortes in her husbands music should never be crass unless a very special Sforfzando was required Am I wong? Maybe I'm getting a bit old and feeble for the bang,bang, bang stuff.
Felix de Villiers
I appreciate for your comment.
I wrote to applaud Jarvi's excellent leadership to motivate and inspire the orchestra. In this performance,someone may feel the river Rhein flows with too much of vigour. Like or dislike,it's a matter of taste.
I respect your comment,and I should say that I can't answer whether you are wrong. I am merely a music fan. Thank you.
The opening is breathtaking! The best I have ever heard actually, it breaths and there is no confusion, nothing timid or forceful. I might even say this is the first time I have heard it done "right".
I am not a man readily prone to tears, but for some reason the ascending horn octaves in the finale make me tear. More a comment on the piece; I jusr find it curious that such an upbeat movement is the saddest and most moving part of the Symphony to me.
+Jackson Witmer Couldn't agree more. I love Schumann and I have never understood the critics who trivialize his symphonies. This interpretation reveals the great depths of Schumann's musical genius.
It is a master conducting work!!!. How he let the horns sing in 0:57 !!!!
In fact he changed the orchestration. For sure he took the idea in Mahler's reorchestration of this symphony.
Is it Mahler´s reorchestration or Järvi did himself another reorchestration of the original work of Schumann?. Thanks in advance.
It is likely that Järvi combined Schumann's original score and Mahler's reorchestration because horns play both notes of original score and Mahler's arrangement.
The beauty of the 4th movement is not surpassed in all of music.
Paavo seems to do everything so well and this Schumann 3 is no exception
My favorite Schumann symphony. Nice recording. I can just hear the festivities in the Rhine...
マーラー版だ！ドイツカンマーとのレコーディングでは違ってたのに
in pertfection. Thanks you and Parvo!!
Brawo Paavo!
Paavo Jarvi will be the top conductor of the NHK symphony orchestra in autumn 2015.His concert program in Feb.13&14th,2015 with NHK symphony orchestra.
!.Sibelius' violin concerto with Sayaka Shoji.
2.Shostakovich's 5th.symphony.
I used to love to see and hear his DVD of Beethoven's 3rd.and 5th.piano concerto with Ikuyo Nakamichi and Die Deutsche Kammerphilharmonie Bremen.
At 32.42 The horn choir bursts forth like the final seconds of s fireworks display !
Excellent job by the basses for their power.
Maravilhoso poder ouvir uma Symphony de Robert Schumann e conduzida por P.Järvi....Amei
Wow. Just wow.
The feierlich is probably the deepest expression of sorrow I have ever heard for it illuminates the most unsuspected arcanes of our being
A monumental performance.
The momentum is persistent from the beginning to the end. Magnificent. It reminds me of the landscapes of snow mountains, deep valleys, and rivers I saw on multiday hikes!
+Walter Lee Magnificent indeed! This performance brings out the towering genius of Schumann. A great interpretation superbly backed by the orchestra.
Bravo!!!!
28:10 fifth movement 29:45 flute solo
0:00
0:52
4:00
5:55
7:39
8:09
9:20
9:45
13:30
16:41
19:30
24:30
26:11
28:19
32:00から最後まで
Malher`s Version？
unfortunately, yes it is
yes, that's right.
Is Paavo Järvi the long lost half-brother of Vladimir Putin?