These guys had no idea how truly lucky they were. 1. A beautiful song 2. Maynard in front 3. Paz on violin 4. Freese on drums 5. Danny lohner playing bass Just amazing performance all around!
@@drdoodoo1284 Yes, but billy is always there, he's the key to APC. To have an early performance with Maynard front and center, Freese who is a great drummer there, Danny who is a great musician and character, to have Paz there, a great musician playing violin, those little things that aren't very regular are special I think. All in all, a great performance.
A 14 year old black girl from the ghetto of Brooklyn….this album helped me understand myself so much more back then…I love this band and Tool so much. I’m in tears right now remembering how this music empowered me
Yes!! Exactly!!....so much natural talent..when this song and many other apc circle songs cams out At first I heard on out radio stations in ohio...I went n bought their cd's and I can't tell u how much these guys helped me through stuff in my 20's n I'm here still reminiscing....still helps me thru hard times to this day
+herostatus My thoughts exactly!!! Maynard is NEVER front and center and looking into the audience at ANY shows I've been to! Those people were lucky and I sure wish I was there...this is my most favorite version of this song...pure perfection all the way around!!!
Yeah really! I had tickets to see Tool then at The Ritz in Raleigh NC with my boyfriend but we couldn't go...I'm still pissed off that we didn't go!!!!! :(
***** you learn control before you let it go. Always. First step: control. Second step: throw it all out the window and wail. Never mix them up or go to step two first. First and foremost, Maynard had wonderful control. He uses that control to go gaga and make us melt.
The weird thing for me is how everyone doesn't appreciate songs the same way - this is so perfect. Others don't get chills while listening to music, and I feel bad for them.
I first heard this song in 6th grade when this performance aired and I was shook up! I had to do all kinds of research to finally find the band and eventually this song, in those days without smart phones📱 and having to use☎️ dial up 💻if I was lucky!🤩🤣. It still gives me chills. 😎🧠🔊🎶💯
When you put this song on repeat, you create a flawless shape that smoothly brings you back to where you started. It's like some kinda, dare I say, perfect circle.
around this time I was a teenager experimenting with shrooms and going out to the mountains to hike while listening to this song took me to a heavenly out of body place.
I like the fact that you are a black man but has good taste in music and not stuck in the attitude that this is white people's music. I listen to all music. Well almost all. Love it when I see one of my black brothers listens to tool or a perfect circle. Much love and respect
This song is one of my all time faves. This isn't like other songs that you get tired of after you hear it so many times....whenever this song comes on, I drop everything, close my eyes and sing along lol.
Maynard is one of those artist that sounds amazing... but even better live. I love that about him. Also just the passion he always has, its apparent he still enjoys and appreciates being able to do what he does.
Agreed he is unbelievably amazing and my appreciation for him sharing all this amazing music for so many yrs. Just hearing any tool song can take me right to exact moments and memories just like they were yesterday's. and over 20 yrs. Of just kicking ass all over this world
This was exactly the performance that pulled me in forever.. Was at a friend's house, tv was on, this came on, and I was HOOKED forever! 2000.... Very nostalgic.
I cant get enough watching this.. the heartbreak in his voice gets me every time.. his performance was flawless.. I can die now hearing the greatest song I ever heard. I found this recording online and it is now on my ipod on repeat.. the violin is so beautiful and I love how his voice echos.. I just found something perfect in an imperfect world. wow
LYRICS: Threw you the obvious And you flew with it on your back A name in your recollection Down among a million same Difficult not to feel a little bit Disappointed and passed over When I look right through To see you naked but oblivious And you don't see me But I threw you the obvious Just to see if there's more behind The eyes of a fallen angel Eyes of a tragedy Here I am expecting Just a little bit too much from the wounded but I see, see through it all See through, see you 'Cause I threw you the obvious to see what occurs behind the Eyes of a fallen angel Eyes of a tragedy Oh well, oh well Apparently nothing Apparently nothing at all You don't, you don't, you don't see me You don't, you don't, you don't see me You don't, you don't, you don't see me You don't, you don't, you don't see me You don't see me You don't, you don't You don't see me at all
Better than the studio recording? To me it's a toss up, I like the louder violin in this version, the louder/heavier guitar in the studio version. But both versions are great. But as far as a live performance of the song goes, I couldn't ask for any better. Both are certainly better than the god awful remix they've been playing live for years now.
That cameraman has to be a fan of this song! Notice how right on cue they kept switching between Maynard and the drummer at the perfect drumming and vocal point in the beginning of the song.
April Davalos you must not know much about tv production. these shows are taped and aired later in the evening (they have to edit things out all the time). most all musical acts will have rehearsal time. each camera is assigned a number. oh just go watch a video on behind the scenes stuff. not trying to be rude, just informative.
J Davis along with getting licenses to play the song on air. Wether standard tv production went into editing sometimes you can tell extra attention went into editing this video.
I shit you not I've watched this video at least 5 times in a row. Takes me back. I fell deeply in love with the most beautiful women I have ever known while listening to this. We were so passionate and so young. Didn't work out but the memories remain. I'll always love this song
you are 100% accurate. NO one can match him artistically or vocally in my opinion. there are no words for it really... he's that f'n man through and through.
I come back to this beautiful performance with my father in palliative care and not showing one ounce of remorse or contrition for the wrongs he has done to many people. Life sucks sometimes but hearing this reminds me of the beauty of life.
My father died last night..... “Here I am expecting just a little bit too much From the wounded but I see through it all and see you” Getting no closure sucks!
This performance is the most incredible thing musically that listened. To in my life is 36 y/O and nothing passes it do far ive watched his voice makes me wanna cry and thats last time thats happend I was a baby. This is special and its the best virsion of this song in my opinion. Maynard is something eles !
Ever since Sean Yseult on bass for White Zombie I've become a huge fan of women in Rock. Paz is by far my favorite. Even if she played a cowbell with a drumstick or shook a pot of beans!
Band looks amazing, sounds amazing, the stage setup, the voice echo synthesis... all came together to create a mind-blowing atmosphere. The song itself is absolutely heart breaking, and I'm sure everyone that was familiar was bawling with a strange mixture of sadness and joy that only a perfect circle can produce.
You just know that when this aired that whoever had never known of A Perfect Circle or of Maynard, they were immediately thinking, "What the hell. Who are these guys? This is epic." within 10 seconds of Maynard's first note. This particular song is so geared and designed for both the commercial market and a composer's appreciation.
4/3/24 and this performance still holds up. I’ve seen APC live but they didn’t play the original version, just the one you hear on Stone and Echo. These people got an intimate performance and probably didn’t realize how lucky they were.
Over the past 2 years I've been looking after my dad. I've also watched Dementia slowly take him from me. This song has been and always will be a source of great inspiration to me. Because there were days when I could genuinely say "You don't see me at all".
What a beautiful song!!! Got to love how they play such a masterpiece like this. This one will never be replicated. I’ve never seen a song that fits so perfectly. From the guitars to Paz’s violin. This is perfect
I had the album when I was in high school back in 2000 around 17. So much sad6 and raw emotion. A great album for us who know what it like to feel past over and that nobody sees us and who we are.
These guys had no idea how truly lucky they were.
1. A beautiful song
2. Maynard in front
3. Paz on violin
4. Freese on drums
5. Danny lohner playing bass
Just amazing performance all around!
Josh kills it. I know this is two years old but noone really gives him the props he deserves.
@@knogface To add to an old comment, Troy Van fucking Leeuwen up there too deserves some shoutout. A genius in his own right.
agree
they also had billy howerdel who is also a great guitarist and the creator of this band
@@drdoodoo1284 Yes, but billy is always there, he's the key to APC. To have an early performance with Maynard front and center, Freese who is a great drummer there, Danny who is a great musician and character, to have Paz there, a great musician playing violin, those little things that aren't very regular are special I think. All in all, a great performance.
A 14 year old black girl from the ghetto of Brooklyn….this album helped me understand myself so much more back then…I love this band and Tool so much. I’m in tears right now remembering how this music empowered me
❤❤ old white man in Kentucky wishing you well
And a 58 year old white guy in New york.
From an old white guy in China, you stay strong dear. Don't let this nasty world cut you down.
So many ways I am impressed with your comment.
Another old white man in Kentucky ....wishing you well.
a female from FL, listening since the late 90s...I feel you
2024, anybody here? 👀
I Keep Comin back
Yup
At least once a month bruh.
@@deltaunder1872 it’s easy a top 10 musical performances of all time clip
I'm around
No autotune, just talent 🔥
For real. A real example of how music should be made.
Yes!! Exactly!!....so much natural talent..when this song and many other apc circle songs cams out
At first I heard on out radio stations in ohio...I went n bought their cd's and I can't tell u how much these guys helped me through stuff in my 20's n I'm here still reminiscing....still helps me thru hard times to this day
LOL remember ppl saying this on every rock song. vs rap
Maynard at the front of the stage.. and sometimes looking straight into the audience? This crowd got a very rare gift.
+herostatus My thoughts exactly!!! Maynard is NEVER front and center and looking into the audience at ANY shows I've been to! Those people were lucky and I sure wish I was there...this is my most favorite version of this song...pure perfection all the way around!!!
Yeah he has been off the spotlight for 15 years now (give or take), must have been awesome to see Tool concerts in the 90s.
Yeah really! I had tickets to see Tool then at The Ritz in Raleigh NC with my boyfriend but we couldn't go...I'm still pissed off that we didn't go!!!!! :(
i got to see tool on 9/14/01 in Ohio. Maynard talked ALOT. it was awe inspiring
@ Robby S You are lucky. I seen once in Charlotte, NC in 2013 I think and then Puscifer in Raleigh, NC this year. His voice is pure perfection!
2023 and still gives me chills. I remember the exact smell in the air when this gem came on my tv. Literally.
the man has perfect control over his voice.
***** you learn control before you let it go. Always. First step: control. Second step: throw it all out the window and wail. Never mix them up or go to step two first. First and foremost, Maynard had wonderful control. He uses that control to go gaga and make us melt.
ooberduh is correct, hawtchick69. Learn control and structure first, then bombard that with all of your energy.
Therefore naming a perfect circle
So well said
Yeah Leno has funny voice but not that good settle down
2024 anyone?
If this song isn't played at my funeral, i will haunt everyone who knew me.
Anyone else obsessing/crying over this still in 2023 ? Just me ?😅
2024... still there
2024 presente
It’s 2020 and this gives me nostalgic feelings.
Jason H same and same in 2021 and after that
same..
Yep!
This was 20 years ago. Let that sink for a minute
👍
Can we just recognize how beautiful Maynards voice is live?
Absolutely 👍👍👍
"Difficult not to feel a little bit disappointed and passed over"
To anyone who knows that pain. Just so beautifully and simply put.
Today...I know....feel
👌
Felt that for a 12 year marriage
💔
My life story bro 😔
Miss the times when this song was out. Had a great relationship and my parents were still alive. Life sucks. But music is beautiful.
one of the best vocals out there...
+ava adore agreed but with all the vocal effects, most people would sound angelic..
+Jimmy Stabler Don't think you know much about Maynard.
I dont think Maynard resort to vocal effects because 1)theyre not pop and 2)this was during 90s.
+roozbehbey I know more than you buddy!!!
+ava adore actually he is using vocal effects and this isn't the 90's.. 3 libras wasn't even released until 2001
The violin is the element that makes this song godly and gives it a beautiful/sick/tragic tone at the same time
Yes, your Stewship, it takes it above and beyonce'on.
Lol *beyond
Paz is truly great
@@tylersims6937 The beyonce typo 😂
This song takes my breath away every single time.
Lizzy Ari
Absolutely
The weird thing for me is how everyone doesn't appreciate songs the same way - this is so perfect. Others don't get chills while listening to music, and I feel bad for them.
It's an amazing song!!
+ Dh Ldvn
I've experienced ASMR listening to music decades before there was a scientific name for "chicken skin!"
I first heard this song in 6th grade when this performance aired and I was shook up! I had to do all kinds of research to finally find the band and eventually this song, in those days without smart phones📱 and having to use☎️ dial up 💻if I was lucky!🤩🤣. It still gives me chills. 😎🧠🔊🎶💯
Like when someone else in 2019 has watched. 2024 LFG!!!!
Screw you, fatass!
I see you
No
SiLLy GooSe I’ll feed you your parents in a nice fresh bowl of chili if you don’t
This wasn't in 2019?
I was 18 ...am 35 now!!!...nostalgia
Me 2
Me too lol
chrly martinez me too
Time flies, doesn't it?
Damn me too
That crowd didn't appreciate what they heard that day
this song is perfect because it makes you wanna listen to it over and over again
Damian Delfino absolutely
I know, I've listened to it 5 times already before looking up a live version..
Damian Delfino you are right broh
When you put this song on repeat, you create a flawless shape that smoothly brings you back to where you started. It's like some kinda, dare I say, perfect circle.
And I do.
Most underappreciated bands of all time.
His voice literally makes me cry.
Its the violin, son.
Both ❤
This song just took me back a couple of decades, this song is so beautiful and haunting.Paz looks beautiful.
I still remember buying this album as a teenager. Amazing talent, this song takes you to a different place mentally.
around this time I was a teenager experimenting with shrooms and going out to the mountains to hike while listening to this song took me to a heavenly out of body place.
I drop a tear everytime I hear this live one. It hurts. It brings up memory of a lover.
Wow! This performance of "3 Libras" has my eyes watery. All the emotion pouring from the band, especially from Maynard was powerful.
Mark Stewart-Sims amen brother
Mark Stewart-Sims viva chile!
I feel you bro
I like the fact that you are a black man but has good taste in music and not stuck in the attitude that this is white people's music. I listen to all music. Well almost all. Love it when I see one of my black brothers listens to tool or a perfect circle. Much love and respect
Steven Huckabay WE created Rock & Roll!!!
🤦🏾♂️
2023 and this song still haunts me. So beautiful and nostalgic. ❤
This song is one of my all time faves. This isn't like other songs that you get tired of after you hear it so many times....whenever this song comes on, I drop everything, close my eyes and sing along lol.
Somewhere there exists a high quality version of this and goddamnit it needs to be released.
FarFromTheTrees there is, found after I watched this
@@LittleBirdsings1 Care to share where you found that?
@@Stoitism th-cam.com/video/odln4cuddq0/w-d-xo.html
Maynard is one of those artist that sounds amazing... but even better live. I love that about him. Also just the passion he always has, its apparent he still enjoys and appreciates being able to do what he does.
Agreed he is unbelievably amazing and my appreciation for him sharing all this amazing music for so many yrs. Just hearing any tool song can take me right to exact moments and memories just like they were yesterday's. and over 20 yrs. Of just kicking ass all over this world
th-cam.com/video/WalMA7D67rs/w-d-xo.html
Try Devin Townsend kingdom and deadhead live equally mind blowing
This was exactly the performance that pulled me in forever.. Was at a friend's house, tv was on, this came on, and I was HOOKED forever! 2000.... Very nostalgic.
they threw you the obvious to see
@@chadrat39 hahaha! Indeed!
And I flew with it on my back....
I was too ! Just amazing !
I cant get enough watching this.. the heartbreak in his voice gets me every time.. his performance was flawless.. I can die now hearing the greatest song I ever heard. I found this recording online and it is now on my ipod on repeat.. the violin is so beautiful and I love how his voice echos.. I just found something perfect in an imperfect world. wow
Where did you find it?
Can you share a link to this audio pls 😁😁
I love everything about this song.. The violin..the lyrics... His vocals..
1:05 Paz is SO beautiful and inspired.
ChronoPhoenix exactly!!
Paz playing violin 🎻 is a whole vibe ✨️
Tenía 16 años y hoy 35 wow 20 años y sigue siendo mi banda favorita.
Marzo 2020.
LYRICS:
Threw you the obvious
And you flew with it on your back
A name in your recollection
Down among a million same
Difficult not to feel a little bit
Disappointed and passed over
When I look right through
To see you naked but oblivious
And you don't see me
But I threw you the obvious
Just to see if there's more behind
The eyes of a fallen angel
Eyes of a tragedy
Here I am expecting
Just a little bit too much from the wounded
but I see, see through it all
See through, see you
'Cause I threw you the obvious
to see what occurs behind
the Eyes of a fallen angel
Eyes of a tragedy
Oh well, oh well
Apparently nothing
Apparently nothing at all
You don't, you don't, you don't see me
You don't, you don't, you don't see me
You don't, you don't, you don't see me
You don't, you don't, you don't see me
You don't see me
You don't, you don't
You don't see me at all
I just want to cry because he's just so beautiful 😭
Tara K I just did!
How has it been 20 years since I first got into apc? Time flies and I can still relate to their music so much 😢
2:03 and the chills. Damn, this song is perfect.
Still goosebumps after all these years...just beautiful.
These gotta be one of the best vocals live.
And incubus...Brandon boyd
La voz de Maynard, el violín de Paz y la guitarra de Howerdel hacen magia! ✨💫🖤
What a genius. Thank you, Lord, for giving us Maynard’s gifts and his wonderful generosity to share it with us.
It’s amazing how good they are live, actually better than the studio recording.
Better than the studio recording? To me it's a toss up, I like the louder violin in this version, the louder/heavier guitar in the studio version. But both versions are great. But as far as a live performance of the song goes, I couldn't ask for any better.
Both are certainly better than the god awful remix they've been playing live for years now.
"Oh well..."
Light, that breaks my heart.
That cameraman has to be a fan of this song! Notice how right on cue they kept switching between Maynard and the drummer at the perfect drumming and vocal point in the beginning of the song.
April Davalos you must not know much about tv production. these shows are taped and aired later in the evening (they have to edit things out all the time). most all musical acts will have rehearsal time. each camera is assigned a number. oh just go watch a video on behind the scenes stuff. not trying to be rude, just informative.
My 3rd time in a row replaying. I see what you mean
J Davis along with getting licenses to play the song on air. Wether standard tv production went into editing sometimes you can tell extra attention went into editing this video.
The video editor would be the one making those decisions, not the cameraman
The director
One of my favorite songs by them. It's like a breath of fresh air.
get goosebumps every time...love Paz!
Agree
Can’t get enough in 2024. They were ahead of their time. Still relevant today. 🤘🏻🤘🏻
I shit you not I've watched this video at least 5 times in a row. Takes me back. I fell deeply in love with the most beautiful women I have ever known while listening to this. We were so passionate and so young. Didn't work out but the memories remain. I'll always love this song
I stole your girl
My husband and I fell in love listening to this...here we are so many years later and still very much in love.💙💙💙
Holy shit, this performance is 10 out of 10 :D
Jesus...he can sing! How can anyone not like Maynard, APC, TOOL, and Puscifer?
Pft. Tool is just the worst band. I'd rather listen to disco at a nursing home birthday party
@@MaynardOwns ez bait
Even the deaf think Maynard is a great singer.
@@MaynardOwns Gr8 b8 m8, I r8 8/8.
Even his wine kicks ass.😜
Watching this in 2018 still one of the best live performance evah!!!!
Marksman Pomade yes
th-cam.com/video/WalMA7D67rs/w-d-xo.html
@@joeyberndt th-cam.com/video/WalMA7D67rs/w-d-xo.html
A truly beautiful performance. 👏
I love this song. It transports me back.
And jesus...Josh Freese Rocks! I cant get enough of his drumming.
Can we take a moment to appreciate the drummers sweater?
He wanted to look nice at PF Chang’s after.
Maynard truly has a gift his vocals and performances are mesmerizing
I always liked his voice. He's a very good singer and the violin... everything sounds really good together. Their music rocks.. smoothly lol :)
One of the records of my life
Man, by far... One of the best performances' I've ever seen live, but then again, It's APC. What do you expect???
Leno “A perfect circle. Thank you guy.” LOL
THE BEST SINGER IN THE WORLD!!!!
you are 100% accurate. NO one can match him artistically or vocally in my opinion. there are no words for it really... he's that f'n man through and through.
Maynard is truly a treasure. But let's not forget about Devin Townsend. Easily a peer of MJK.
If not his superior......... \m/
@@3rdiopen934
Corey Taylor? Mike Patton? Layne?
@@danielkelly2777
One of the widest vocal ranges in history after mike Patton but yeah man he ain't good.
Besides chris cornell
I was 17 when this album came out, to this day 3 Libras gives me shivers down my spine!
I come back to this beautiful performance with my father in palliative care and not showing one ounce of remorse or contrition for the wrongs he has done to many people. Life sucks sometimes but hearing this reminds me of the beauty of life.
My father died last night.....
“Here I am expecting just a little bit too much
From the wounded but I see through it all and see you”
Getting no closure sucks!
Yes
I know what you mean. Been there.
Perfect time to resuscitate this... Today is April the 29th of 2023.
Watching today on April 29th of 2024, now you've gotta get next year
That was an amazing performance. Maynard is king!
Sometimes in the world we live in today.I feel at peace with my higher power.. just my favorite 3 Libras.. because I was born on the 7th of October.
When I was obsessed with APC 15 years ago I loved the little smile on Paz after she hits the high note on her violin :,)
The 'o, well' at 2:20 is jawdroppingly beautiful!
This performance is the most incredible thing musically that listened. To in my life is 36 y/O and nothing passes it do far ive watched his voice makes me wanna cry and thats last time thats happend I was a baby. This is special and its the best virsion of this song in my opinion. Maynard is something eles !
One of the best performances of my favorite song
5 years later and I sit here applauding in front of my computer by myself.
This way older than 5 years right.
@@colins1358 I think the CD was released in '99 or 2000 but I was referencing the publish date of the video. Glad I could clear that up for you.
THAT's a good live vocalist. Flawless.
This gives me shivers such a great performance.
In My Opinion, this was the best APC Line Up
+Nicolás Riveros Josh is awesome, but Tim Alexander is the best.
Ever since Sean Yseult on bass for White Zombie I've become a huge fan of women in Rock. Paz is by far my favorite. Even if she played a cowbell with a drumstick or shook a pot of beans!
Charles Moore paz was really good. Too bad she left.
Troy FTW
pax was the Shit in apc
A voice that cuts through steel with no heat or friction...cold and apathetic while somehow just overflowing with emotion. It is ethereal...
Band looks amazing, sounds amazing, the stage setup, the voice echo synthesis... all came together to create a mind-blowing atmosphere. The song itself is absolutely heart breaking, and I'm sure everyone that was familiar was bawling with a strange mixture of sadness and joy that only a perfect circle can produce.
I remember when this was released and instantly fell in love. Now, my sons share the love along with me!
When your voice is on point!
Jesus Christ...this is on point. Perfect!
You just know that when this aired that whoever had never known of A Perfect Circle or of Maynard, they were immediately thinking, "What the hell. Who are these guys? This is epic." within 10 seconds of Maynard's first note.
This particular song is so geared and designed for both the commercial market and a composer's appreciation.
Ryan Fairchild rarified
Idk man i think you need to be intelligent to realize how beautiful this song truly is....
Ryan Fairchild Fucking truth....brought down network television in minutes
My goodness... what an absolutely beautiful performance
God goddess his voice in this song is too much to bear. “Oh well.”
Such an amazing singer songwriter
His voice is beautiful cant get enough of it
Layers and soundscape to perfection. Goosebumps
The best Perfect Circle album and song.. Love it in 2019..
I've heard this song live numerous times and I this is by far the best version
preludepatrick agreed by far his voice is pretty deep and amazing the whole band came through
Best live performance I've ever been to.
You lucky MoFo!
you were actually there wow
4/3/24 and this performance still holds up. I’ve seen APC live but they didn’t play the original version, just the one you hear on Stone and Echo. These people got an intimate performance and probably didn’t realize how lucky they were.
Over the past 2 years I've been looking after my dad. I've also watched Dementia slowly take him from me. This song has been and always will be a source of great inspiration to me. Because there were days when I could genuinely say "You don't see me at all".
There goes Maynard with his Queen Ant costume 😂 love this song!!! APC is so freakin awesome
Al 2019 que brutal voz en vivo. Sin mas palabras que talento.
Un Maestro total
Pd: que bueno encontrar comentarios en Español
2023, had no idea then, that these would be albums and songs that would accompany throughout the rest of my life 🫡
What a beautiful song!!! Got to love how they play such a masterpiece like this. This one will never be replicated. I’ve never seen a song that fits so perfectly. From the guitars to Paz’s violin. This is perfect
I had the album when I was in high school back in 2000 around 17. So much sad6 and raw emotion. A great album for us who know what it like to feel past over and that nobody sees us and who we are.
This performance is my absolute favorite. The last minute of it, I always end up holding my breath. So intense! This man is a master.
that voice. so emotionally powerful.