I’m a non denominational muslim. In the video, the speaker makes a simple statement: you have to pick a reality, Hazrat Abu Bakr or Hazrat Ali. My question is, what happens if I don’t? I still love and respect both Hazrat Abu Bakr and Hazrat Ali. But if I don’t agree upon a reality, will that invalidate my prayers and fasts in the month of Ramadan? As far as praying is concerned, as long as the intentions are pure it doesn’t matter if you’re praying with your hands on the sides or front
Salam Alaikom "We worship God the way He wants, and doing so will give value to our deeds and prayers. If God has appointed a representative, and I have been commanded to follow and love that representative, and if there is another figure who opposed that representative, then how can I accept them both? This means that I am rejecting God’s command". Thanks
@@Alashtar_Ar the representative he appointed was the Holy Prophet (PBUH). I follow his teachings i.e Sunnah and Hadis. Sectarianism is way too overrated and... completely unnecessary, in my opinion...
The only condition for acceptance of deeds in Allah's court is taqwa. إنما يتقبل الله من المتقين Indeed, Allah only accepts from the righteous [who fear Him]. [5: 27] The characteristics of the متقين and the conditions of تقوى have been clearly stated in Allah's book: _Righteousness is not that you turn your faces toward the east or the west, but [true] righteousness is [in] one who believes in Allah, the Last Day, the angels, the Book, and the prophets and gives wealth, in spite of love for it, to relatives, orphans, the needy, the traveler, those who ask [for help], and for freeing slaves; [and who] establishes prayer and gives zakah; [those who] fulfill their promise when they promise; and [those who] are patient in poverty and hardship and during battle. Those are the ones who have been true, and it is _*_those who are the righteous._*_ (وأولئك هم المتقون)_ [2: 177] Neither Abu Bakr nor Imam Ali [a] are from amongst the conditions of salvation mentioned in Allah's book. Even if the Prophet [S] appointed someone as his "successor" in Ghadir (Shia view) or asked someone to lead the prayer (Sunni vew)-that has nothing to do with Allah's laws of accepting the deeds of the believers. Allah doesn't shy away from [mentioning] the truth. والله لا يستحيي من الحق If accepting the Imamah of Ali [a] or the caliphate of Abu Bakr was part of the deen, then Allah could have mentioned it wherever He [swt] talks of salvation, acceptance of deeds, taqwa, righteousness, etc-just like Allah mentions that the belief in prophets or messengers or the day of judgment is a requirement for you to be considered a believer or a righteous person (muttaqi). Let's not impose our own sectarian interpretations of 4: 59 or 5: 55 or 17: 71 upon others as "Asl of Deen". That would give us license to make anything from our sect's beliefs as a condition for salvation. Your deeds are only rendered worthless if you do kufr, or avert people from the path of Allah, opposing the Messenger [S], just like the kuffar and mushrikin of Makkah did: _Indeed, those who disbelieved and averted [people] from the path of Allah and opposed the Messenger after guidance had become clear to them - never will they harm Allah at all, and He will render worthless their deeds. O you who have believed, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and do not invalidate your deeds._ [47: 32] _Those who denied Our signs and the meeting of the Hereafter - their deeds have become worthless. Are they recompensed except for what they used to do?_ [7: 146] It's clear from the above verses that the only requirement for the acceptance of deeds is what Allah has made part of the package of "iman" or "taqwa" or salvation, for the lack of a better word.
I'm Non-Denominational Muslims from Pakistan, i was Hanfi but after the Quran reading, "Hold fast the roop of Allah, and don not divide". Alhamdulilah i'm Just Muslim.
To add up: the Prophet ﷺ didn't divide into sects nor the sahaba. Sects also didn't exist at the time and this guy in the vid is just spitting non sense.
you re just being dishonest or just being confused. if you re consider Imam Ali Ra had higher status than Sayyid Abu Bakr Ra, you re probably a shia or if it worse, you hate Abu Bakr, Lady Aisha, Umar, Uthman Zubair, Talha R. Anhuma you re a rafhidi. and if you dont, youre a sunni
@@Hamzah.315 we re not dividing ourselfes. its about condition. for example, we re called as "sunni" to distinguish us from people who disrespect Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman , Aisha and other companions
@@Hamzah.315 what do you mean by "intolerant"? I didnt say that they re right or wrong by disrespecting sahaba, my emphasize is not about right wrong I said about definition. what is shia and what is sunni.
Islam's greatest weakness these man-made sects. Shaikh sa id you can't pray unless you follow a school which is like saying you can't read unless going to a school. Many kids are home-schooled. You pray according to what you think is the most authentic practice,and since no school has absolute proof of how the Prophet prayed,it would be permissible to pray according to qabd (hands on chest or stomach) or sadl (hands at side). Surely, a rational God as Allah is in Quran, is concerned about your intention much more than where your arms rest in prayer? Nor do we need to follow only sunni or shia schools. Ibadhi school is older. The roots of Ibadism go back to the 7th century, 20 years after Prophet Muhammad’s death in 632. As such, Ibadism is distinct from either Sunni and Shia Islam and emerged before the Shia-Sunni schism. Ibadhi hadith collection is also older than Bukhari and kulayni etc. Its a simple islam, in tune with a simple Prophet: Muhammad is no more than an Apostle. Apostles before him have passed away. If he dies or is slain, will ye then turn on your heels?",says Quran (3,144)
@@itsblitz4437 Buddhism too. Honest disagreement is a good sign of progress providing the fists are kept in the pocket and bombs defused and the Pope a decent, if not a Christian man ( in Saint Patrick's sense).
U can't pray until u follow a school means u can't be a knowledgeable person until someone guide u and the guider can be teacher or parent anyone but should be real or true guider(follow right path). So please understand the words deepely and then say anything. Haq hai allah Sach hai allah. Ok thanks
what if s person takes from some shia hadith ,some sunni hadith ,some ibadi ??and you let the quran be the final judge over all of it If I coming into islam.I wont choose sect
many took this channel Salam we shia muslims also compare all of narrations from all sects with Quran if any hadith has contradiction with Quran we reject that Hadith but if it is very fixed by Islam we accept it even from non shia sources
Look what is he trying to emphasize here is he didn't saw how prophet Muhammad (PBUH) used to pray. That is why he has to follow the imam like Abu Bakr (RA) & Ali (RA). Now, did he saw how Abu Bakr (RA) or Ali (RA) used to pray? Look brother and sister we don't need to call ourselves Sunni, Shia, or anything else. We need to call ourselves Muslims. We don't need to follow the imam. We need to follow the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). By saying, we didn't saw how Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) used to pray, we are saying sahabas telling lie about his prayer.
There's something called the ijma which clearly our brother does not know. Me as a nondenominational Muslim follow the sunnah which has always been unshakable and non contradictory.
Sir I am not a Muslim. But always interested about other religions. From what I heard one sect prays one way and another sect prays a different way. Can I ask humbly what way did Muhammad pray hands in one direction /hands across chest or another way?
lol he is just saying nonsense. we literally pray in the same way. just one folds the hand and the other doesn't fold. and the ones that fold the hands have multiple variations for the hand folding HAHAHHAH.
There are Authentic Hadiths for both Sunni and Shiah that both groups have rejected because the other group believes in them. The bottom line accept both Hadith that are authentic that align with the Quran.
I reverted to Islam through the Mouridiyya (Sunni - Maliki) of Senegal and later took initiation into the Bektashiyya (Imami Shi'a - Alevi) or Turkiye. I regard myself simply as Muslim and I desire knowledge from Shiekhs, Murshids, and Pirs from anyone more knowledgeable than myself. Allah Alim.
What about the one who follows a particular sect but also believes there should be unity among all sects or the one who prays sometimes in hanafi and sometimes in ahle hadees masjid?
Imagine Allah sending us the hood news of the afterlife and his mercy and to worship him alone to only fight over what way to stand in His worship. 2020 is here and we need an update.
Poor people, I try to help you, you may think about religion but don't you see that there is a difference between reality and all the stuff they filled you with from your birth ? Don't loose hope, go further and you will evolute but without hurting your nafs be smart and free yourself from all this poor people, they may impress you but their self they understand nothing
@@Alashtar_Ar speaking of things which you have very little information about or know nothing about is against the Quran and dividing your religion into sects is also against the quran. He is both speaking about things he knows extremely little about and he is pushing the division of religion into sects. He is spreading false information.
@@mohammadkhamseh5881 he didnt divide islam into sects none divide islam into sects. its not his fault Islam is divided by history, deal with it. there s a clear line that divide sunni and shia its either you re a sunni or shia you re not "just a muslim"
Pray the way that seems right according to the quran and Allah SWT will guide you InshaAllah and if you are wrong Allah SWT will tell you and you will be rewarded for your ignorance and teached the right way here or in the here after insha'allah subhanallah
![ผัวเถื่อน - ยูริ โตเกียวมิวสิค [ OFFICIAL MUSIC VIDEO ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/P08ORRVDGl8/mqdefault.jpg)
I’m a non denominational muslim. In the video, the speaker makes a simple statement: you have to pick a reality, Hazrat Abu Bakr or Hazrat Ali. My question is, what happens if I don’t? I still love and respect both Hazrat Abu Bakr and Hazrat Ali. But if I don’t agree upon a reality, will that invalidate my prayers and fasts in the month of Ramadan? As far as praying is concerned, as long as the intentions are pure it doesn’t matter if you’re praying with your hands on the sides or front
Salam Alaikom
"We worship God the way He wants, and doing so will give value to our deeds and prayers. If God has appointed a representative, and I have been commanded to follow and love that representative, and if there is another figure who opposed that representative, then how can I accept them both? This means that I am rejecting God’s command". Thanks
@@Alashtar_Ar the representative he appointed was the Holy Prophet (PBUH). I follow his teachings i.e Sunnah and Hadis. Sectarianism is way too overrated and... completely unnecessary, in my opinion...
if you respect Abu Bakr and other companions.
you re a sunni, period
@@user-od5uu7ug2r
you re a sunni, embrace it.
just be honest with yourself.
The only condition for acceptance of deeds in Allah's court is taqwa.
إنما يتقبل الله من المتقين
Indeed, Allah only accepts from the righteous [who fear Him].
[5: 27]
The characteristics of the متقين and the conditions of تقوى have been clearly stated in Allah's book:
_Righteousness is not that you turn your faces toward the east or the west, but [true] righteousness is [in] one who believes in Allah, the Last Day, the angels, the Book, and the prophets and gives wealth, in spite of love for it, to relatives, orphans, the needy, the traveler, those who ask [for help], and for freeing slaves; [and who] establishes prayer and gives zakah; [those who] fulfill their promise when they promise; and [those who] are patient in poverty and hardship and during battle. Those are the ones who have been true, and it is _*_those who are the righteous._*_ (وأولئك هم المتقون)_
[2: 177]
Neither Abu Bakr nor Imam Ali [a] are from amongst the conditions of salvation mentioned in Allah's book. Even if the Prophet [S] appointed someone as his "successor" in Ghadir (Shia view) or asked someone to lead the prayer (Sunni vew)-that has nothing to do with Allah's laws of accepting the deeds of the believers.
Allah doesn't shy away from [mentioning] the truth. والله لا يستحيي من الحق
If accepting the Imamah of Ali [a] or the caliphate of Abu Bakr was part of the deen, then Allah could have mentioned it wherever He [swt] talks of salvation, acceptance of deeds, taqwa, righteousness, etc-just like Allah mentions that the belief in prophets or messengers or the day of judgment is a requirement for you to be considered a believer or a righteous person (muttaqi).
Let's not impose our own sectarian interpretations of 4: 59 or 5: 55 or 17: 71 upon others as "Asl of Deen". That would give us license to make anything from our sect's beliefs as a condition for salvation.
Your deeds are only rendered worthless if you do kufr, or avert people from the path of Allah, opposing the Messenger [S], just like the kuffar and mushrikin of Makkah did:
_Indeed, those who disbelieved and averted [people] from the path of Allah and opposed the Messenger after guidance had become clear to them - never will they harm Allah at all, and He will render worthless their deeds. O you who have believed, obey Allah and obey the Messenger and do not invalidate your deeds._
[47: 32]
_Those who denied Our signs and the meeting of the Hereafter - their deeds have become worthless. Are they recompensed except for what they used to do?_
[7: 146]
It's clear from the above verses that the only requirement for the acceptance of deeds is what Allah has made part of the package of "iman" or "taqwa" or salvation, for the lack of a better word.
I'm Non-Denominational Muslims from Pakistan, i was Hanfi but after the Quran reading, "Hold fast the roop of Allah, and don not divide".
Alhamdulilah i'm Just Muslim.
To add up: the Prophet ﷺ didn't divide into sects nor the sahaba. Sects also didn't exist at the time and this guy in the vid is just spitting non sense.
you re just being dishonest or just being confused.
if you re consider Imam Ali Ra had higher status than Sayyid Abu Bakr Ra, you re probably a shia
or if it worse, you hate Abu Bakr, Lady Aisha, Umar, Uthman Zubair, Talha R. Anhuma you re a rafhidi.
and if you dont, youre a sunni
@@Hamzah.315
we re not dividing ourselfes.
its about condition.
for example, we re called as "sunni" to distinguish us from people who disrespect Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman , Aisha and other companions
@@namakubento9276 That's very intolerant, I see you are indirectly targeting Shias.
@@Hamzah.315
what do you mean by "intolerant"?
I didnt say that they re right or wrong by disrespecting sahaba,
my emphasize is not about right wrong
I said about definition.
what is shia and what is sunni.
There is no way of the sunni or the shi it os only the way of Allah amd his messenger.
Islam's greatest weakness these man-made sects. Shaikh sa
id you can't pray unless you follow a school which is like saying you can't read unless going to a school. Many kids are home-schooled. You pray according to what you think is the most authentic practice,and since no school has absolute proof of how the Prophet prayed,it would be permissible to pray according to qabd (hands on chest or stomach) or sadl (hands at side). Surely, a rational God as Allah is in Quran, is concerned about your intention much more than where your arms rest in prayer? Nor do we need to follow only sunni or shia schools. Ibadhi school is older. The roots of Ibadism go back to the 7th century, 20 years after Prophet Muhammad’s death in 632. As such, Ibadism is distinct from either Sunni and Shia Islam and emerged before the Shia-Sunni schism. Ibadhi hadith collection is also older than Bukhari and kulayni etc. Its a simple islam, in tune with a simple Prophet: Muhammad is no more than an Apostle. Apostles before him have passed away. If he dies or is slain, will ye then turn on your heels?",says Quran (3,144)
Well Christianity has also man made sects such as Roman Catholicism, Protestantism, Eastern Orthodox has become much easier around secularism.
@@itsblitz4437 Buddhism too. Honest disagreement is a good sign of progress providing the fists are kept in the pocket and bombs defused and the Pope a decent, if not a Christian man ( in Saint Patrick's sense).
U can't pray until u follow a school means u can't be a knowledgeable person until someone guide u and the guider can be teacher or parent anyone but should be real or true guider(follow right path).
So please understand the words deepely and then say anything.
Haq hai allah
Sach hai allah.
Ok thanks
@@arxmemeszone1526 peace friend. But guides,like parents,are different. Some are no good.
Whatsapp no. Please🙏🙏
“My ummah will split into seventy-three sects, all of whom will be in Hell except one group.” Al-Tirmidhi
(2641)
Allah guides if someone wanted to be guided
some sunnies pray with there arms at there sides
what if s person takes from some shia hadith ,some sunni hadith ,some ibadi ??and you let the quran be the final judge over all of it If I coming into islam.I wont choose sect
many took this channel Salam we shia muslims also compare all of narrations from all sects with Quran if any hadith has contradiction with Quran we reject that Hadith but if it is very fixed by Islam we accept it even from non shia sources
Look what is he trying to emphasize here is he didn't saw how prophet Muhammad (PBUH) used to pray. That is why he has to follow the imam like Abu Bakr (RA) & Ali (RA). Now, did he saw how Abu Bakr (RA) or Ali (RA) used to pray? Look brother and sister we don't need to call ourselves Sunni, Shia, or anything else. We need to call ourselves Muslims. We don't need to follow the imam. We need to follow the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). By saying, we didn't saw how Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) used to pray, we are saying sahabas telling lie about his prayer.
There's something called the ijma which clearly our brother does not know. Me as a nondenominational Muslim follow the sunnah which has always been unshakable and non contradictory.
can u tell me how u pray cause I wanna be a no denominational Muslim
I am a Non-Denominational Muslim, too, ex-Shia.
@Abu Mustafa I'm happy for you all. Happy Ramadan🙏🙏🙏🙏
@Abu Mustafa wa iyyak, akhi
If you follow sunnah then you are sunni even if you don't call yourself sunni
How about that I follow different things from different sects according to my understanding because not only 1 sect can be entirely correct!
Sir I am not a Muslim. But always interested about other religions. From what I heard one sect prays one way and another sect prays a different way. Can I ask humbly what way did Muhammad pray hands in one direction /hands across chest or another way?
lol he is just saying nonsense. we literally pray in the same way. just one folds the hand and the other doesn't fold. and the ones that fold the hands have multiple variations for the hand folding HAHAHHAH.
There are Authentic Hadiths for both Sunni and Shiah that both groups have rejected because the other group believes in them. The bottom line accept both Hadith that are authentic that align with the Quran.
it is easy. start somehere, and then start sorting out
I reverted to Islam through the Mouridiyya (Sunni - Maliki) of Senegal and later took initiation into the Bektashiyya (Imami Shi'a - Alevi) or Turkiye. I regard myself simply as Muslim and I desire knowledge from Shiekhs, Murshids, and Pirs from anyone more knowledgeable than myself. Allah Alim.
At the time of Muhammad(PBUH).There was no Shia or Sunni.Non Denominational Muslim are more closed to Mohammad and his family.
And if someone believes that Imam Ali was the True successor of Prophet Muhamamd (s) but He did not in any Sectarism of Islam then?
What about the one who follows a particular sect but also believes there should be unity among all sects or the one who prays sometimes in hanafi and sometimes in ahle hadees masjid?
Imagine Allah sending us the hood news of the afterlife and his mercy and to worship him alone to only fight over what way to stand in His worship. 2020 is here and we need an update.
I’m just Muslim, I pray with my arms down but I’m not Shia lol
Poor people, I try to help you, you may think about religion but don't you see that there is a difference between reality and all the stuff they filled you with from your birth ? Don't loose hope, go further and you will evolute but without hurting your nafs be smart and free yourself from all this poor people, they may impress you but their self they understand nothing
U can't give knowledge to anyone until u have some knowledge.
U can understand this sentence as ur comment's answer
this guy is so wrong lol what he is saying is against the quran
What's against the holy Quran?
@@Alashtar_Ar speaking of things which you have very little information about or know nothing about is against the Quran and dividing your religion into sects is also against the quran. He is both speaking about things he knows extremely little about and he is pushing the division of religion into sects. He is spreading false information.
@@mohammadkhamseh5881
he didnt divide islam into sects
none divide islam into sects.
its not his fault
Islam is divided by history,
deal with it.
there s a clear line that divide sunni and shia
its either you re a sunni or shia
you re not "just a muslim"
@@namakubento9276 but Allah Subhana wa ta ala said to not divide into sects, Will you follow what others say or follow Allah SWT
Pray the way that seems right according to the quran and Allah SWT will guide you InshaAllah and if you are wrong Allah SWT will tell you and you will be rewarded for your ignorance and teached the right way here or in the here after insha'allah subhanallah