The One Thing that Never Dies in Star Wars
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ก.ค. 2023
- Get the Darth Malgus Saber here: ownasaber.com/collections/eli...
All Lightsabers 30% off + Free shipping until end of July
Use our promo code "EWOK" for additional $15 off
Empires rise and fall, Republics grow and collapse... this is the nature of the Star Wars galaxy. But through it all one ancient profession continues to survive as long as sentient beings have property to protect and enemies to fight.
2nd Channel: / @generationtechshorts
Follow Generation Tech on Instagram: / generationtechofficial
Follow Generation Tech on Facebook: bit.ly/GenerationTechFB
Latest Videos: bit.ly/LatestGT
Popular Videos: bit.ly/GTPopular
Please help our channel by becoming a Patron: bit.ly/GTPatreon
Follow our Host
ALLEN XIE
TH-cam / @thebeardedasianman
INSTAGRAM AXIEFILMS
TIKTOK AXIEFILMS
FACEBOOK / axiefilms - บันเทิง
Get the Darth Malgus Saber here: ownasaber.com/collections/elitesabers/products/malgus
All Lightsabers 30% off + Free shipping until end of July
Use our promo code "EWOK" for additional $15 off
Meh 😑
Allan, with all due respect to you, what do you say about those who complain about what they see as false equivalence between two factions in politics? Take leftists for instance. They constantly keep saying that stuff like fake news is mostly the fault of conservatives, that they’re doing most of the lying. I mean, leftists like socialists paint conservatism and capitalism as just being outright horrible with no redeeming qualities. They seem to make plenty of good points and few bad ones. I mean, plenty of conflicts nowadays are black and white with usually the leftists being the good guys and the conservatives being the bad guys. Sure, it does sound hypocritical how leftists point out the extremities of the conservatives while it looks like they’ve given up on half of the country, but then it feels like the Galactic Civil War between the Rebel Alliance and the Galactic Empire. Whatever complexities and gray zones there are in that war, it still comes down to the Rebels fighting for freedom and a better future while the Empire fights for a totalitarian order.
I guess what I’m asking is, what complexities or gray zones are there between the left-wing politicians/activists and their right-wing counterparts in your opinion?
@@pyeitme508 Did he just call his sponsor a cockroach lol?
Trying to fob off your hot merchandise? The Royal Security Forces getting wind of your illicit arms deals?
@@JB-yb4wn First off, what planetary defense force are you referring to? Secondly, if we did live in Star Wars do you think Allan would be jailed? I mean, I don’t know if during the Republic Era whether or not the Jedi made it illegal for anyone to have Kyber Crystals outside of them. If it was the Imperial Era, no doubt Allan would get arrested since that’s relics of the Jedi Order he’s advertising. What about in the New Republic though? It’ll probably be bad taste given the purge of the Jedi being one of the Empire’s worst crimes, but actually illegal?
And on a fun note, would you buy a lightsaber? I mean, it’s bound to be expensive given the Kyber Crystal, but it would be a boost to your reputation. Though, enemies of the Jedi might mistake you for one. And, who would train you in how to fight with it?
How dare anyone call R2d2 a "cockroach" He is more like an immortal being.
He’s been through a lot: getting blown up on a Star Destroyer and getting shot by his former Master.
@@isaackim7675- life is a b**ch
I could get behind the Church of Artoo.
So, yeah. A cucaracha.
And hasnt even been updated with that new salenium drive like BB-8 lol
Hope. Hope never dies.
That and Palpatine. Somehow, he returns.
Yeah I am gonna say it; Palpatine returning was dumb back then when they did it in the novels and it is just as dumb now.
Palpatine returning undermines the entirety of Return of the Jedi.
@@user-ox3mj2sr8nBy having another villain. :)
@@zeratul____1228 You mean Return of the Jedi?
@@KaiHung-wv3ul yes I had 1am brain
@@zeratul____1228at least it was scary and a bit funny the first time. After, it was just ‘again?’
The Hutts will always be around even when republics and empires rise and fall.
@@user-ox3mj2sr8n Hmmmm....I'd say Chiss maybe? Do they count? Or maybe Gen'dai, since they're ridiculously OP.
@@KaiHung-wv3ulI'd say it depends on my mood. If I feel like being a rich asshole, then probably Hutt. And if I'm feeling masochistic, then a Twi'lek. _(seriously, man or woman, the Twi'leks have it rough ALL the time)_
I think the chiss get too much credit because of thrawn. They are quite petty and irrational as a species in their own way and thrawn is definitely an outlier.
@@GenerationTech True. I wish we could see more of the Chiss society. Particularly their nobility and aristocracy. If nothing else, to showcase how different and amasing Thrawn was compared to them.
@@user-ox3mj2sr8n If I can't be my own thing, then Togruta cuz their ladies are hot.
Alan using memes and Star Wars to explain economic regulations better than many of my profs.
Lol legit.
Alan has an honorary doctorate on galactic affairs.
12:17 There's always profit when selling weapons to any faction that can afford them during war.
As a 'scumbag' arms dealer, allow me to offer my perspective, not one of greed but of principle. A weapon is a tool. One built for the purpose of violence but still a mere tool. Tools can allow one to do what is simply impossible for them to do otherwise, for better or for worse. The slicer spoke of the unknown dealer selling to "the bad guys, and the good" but that is a matter of perspective in many cases. It is also largely impossible to be certain who will be the good guy and who will be the bad guy. We can use statistics and stereotypes and personal biases to make a judgement call, and over a long enough time scale there might even be a clear outcome that is statistically greater than chance that the 'right' choice was made, but there is always a price. Deal indiscriminately and more bad people are likely to become armed, since they are striving to do so to have better tools to use against their intended victims. Deal carefully (or not at all) and more good folk that only wanted the tools to protect themselves will be left at the mercy of those that would do them harm, who being most inclined either arm themselves in other ways or make do without, targeting those least able to defend themselves. In both cases innocent people(s) suffer. Do we pick a point between the two? How does one begin to decide what amount of potential anguish is a reasonable cost for peace of mind? And how do we decide which of the yearning masses begging for our help we should empower, and which do we send helplessly into the endless night? It is an impossible question. But, when in doubt, I tend to think more freedom is better. Most people are not bad. I would not go so far as to say most people are good but there is a range of negative behavior that people are comfortable with and most are not in the super bad range for most of their lives. If as many people, factions, nations, worlds, are as armed as possible then everyone worthy of the means to defend themselves will have as much of a chance as possible, and the likelihood of armed resistance grows exponentially. As the ratio between deterrence and incentive shifts the pool of those that would still aim to do harm shrinks. As armed conflict results in the elimination of an increasing portion of those that would prey on the well defended, the amount of wronged in the universe decreases. This solution scales. As bad governments tighten their grip the more painful even a small blade of resistance can be... and there are more of us.
Mad respect for this. I wish there was some way to get people to understand even the most basic fundamentals you go over here. Very powerful insight
As a person of practical and now academic experience, I'm amazed at how well you articulate the central themes, hope and goodness for rising all boats with the opportunity. With this commentary you've given us a virtuoso performance of rationality. Thank you for your wonderfully shared insights.
Came for star wars
Stayed for years for the intelligent and considered points of view in life
One of the most impressive aspects of your content is the seamless way you connect it to real-life situations. You have a remarkable ability to draw parallels between the intricate governmental structures depicted in Star Wars and their relevance to our own world. Your content explores lesser-known details of governmental operations, which often escape the awareness of the average citizen, adding a distinct sense of intellectual curiosity to your work.
Great appreciation for your incorporation of canonical content, which brings an element of enjoyment and authenticity to your discussions. By including established and validated information, you elevate the credibility of your analyses, further enhancing the overall merit of your content.
Your content's unique ability to intertwine fictional portrayals of government in Star Wars with the realities of our own sociopolitical landscape is truly commendable. This approach not only fosters a deeper understanding of both fictional narratives and their reflections in contemporary governance but also captivates audiences with a fluid and engaging presentation. Your appreciation for canonical material further adds to the fluidity and coherence of your work, making it a pleasure to explore. In other words- great content!
Nicely written today, I had to go back and listen a second time. Bravo.
Thanks for your insightful commentary on Star Wars, our real-world society, and the dolphin menace
I love the star-wars/ real world philosophical cross-overs! Many people could learn a lot from what you have to say. It's a shame that our world primarily focuses on drama and judgement, it almost feels like school playground politics sometimes. I just think of how much further we could go if we encouraged balance and reason among each other and co-operated rather than competed...
Sadly it’ll take something to get all of them to see that and I don't think it’ll happen in our life times.
"Co-operated rather than competed", I'm sorry bro but that sounds really playground politics to me lmao
@@zewps9502what?
Arms dealers. They would prosper in the Star Wars galaxy
yup...because a movie called "Star Peace" won't get butts in seats.
@@BryceByerley that sounds like an interesting movie title
That was far more insightful that I would have thought, very well put.
Bold of you to think that the problem is a weak central government and not corrupt legislators whose idea of honesty is remaining bought.
A stronger central government (and believe you me, ours is _strong,_ much stronger than intended) would not resolve that issue because the source of the problem is the average voter's unwillingness to hold their favorite politicians accountable.
Liberty demands responsibility.
I think there is another spectrum to consider and it’s not big or small government… but competent and incompetent government. While the former might seem impossible to create. I think it’s also self defeating to adopt that as a political belief, especially when it’s obvious we do need some form of government.
Then the greatest villains of star wars are not sith, nor the empire, but corporations. And you are right as well in the ending part of the video, it is all about balance.
Related to this, the sheer likelihood that you’ll be born into slavery in starwars is astounding in all galactic eras. From the rakatans to the new republic, there’s a statistically significant chance that you’ll spend your life in servitude.
Pretty much any character in recent Star Wars media
I think trusting people with wealth can be risky. Especially im a hyper or crony capitalist society. Trusting people with knowledge, Im more comfortable with, but still has it's pitfalls. What I think any world needs is trusting people with empathy.
That is, almost literally, how we got the Soviet Union.
@@stevenschnepp576lmao what?
How?
12:16 This reminds me a bit of Gundam's Anaheim Electronics, who are infamous for making military hardware for both sides of a war on more than one occasion.
Anaheim Electronics isn't even subtle about it either. All of the weapons and armor they produce are standardized across both sides. Zeon and the Federation all used the same guns for their mobile suits.
@@akakaze1364 Doesn't Zeon have its own mobile suit production companies before they got absorbed by Anaheim post-One Year War?
@@TheWarmachine375 Yes. I believe they were Zeonic, Zimmad and MIP.
@@wolfgangervin2582 Those companies and they were known for creating one off or limited production mobile suits.
With Zeon's industrial capacity stretched too thin as a result.
Before M'Quve implemented the United Maintenance Plan which was too late to matter when Zeon lost the One Year War.
Came for the Star Wars, stayed for the philosophy lesson
Very well said , love your work .👍
Holy balls I've been watching this channel since I was 10 and I turn 17 this week
Whoa that’s crazy and humbling have a wonderful birthday week 🎂
@@GenerationTech thanks man
Your analysis of politics, power, and intelligence is spot on. 👏
War, war never changes
If he says War I'm gonna lose it.
War....in the stars🤣🤣🤣
Star Wars fans when Star Peace walks in
@@user-ox3mj2sr8n
Bang. The end.
We live interesting times when a Star Wars Lore channel is one of the few sound sources of advice in coming to sound political and economic stances
Little droid companions; in order to sell more toys
Whoa, Allen!!! Philosophically speaking, these videos have a tendency to incite a deeper type of inner reflection... Kudos to you,Sir .
Always fantastic insight. Thank you.
Falling from heights
This video is pure gold.
You're becoming quite the philosopher. Far cry from some of your earlier videos. I don't agree with everything you say, but this was very good indeed. Well done.
3:20 In EU Legends, New Republic managed to keep itself together and not disarm its 90% of military power at all.
Don't remind me that, somehow, Borsk Fey'lya is a more competent leader of the NR than Mon Mothma.
Yeah i feel that
To be fair, I don't think a few extra warships was going to stop the capitol from getting evaporated by a Nicoll Dyson Laser
@@user-ox3mj2sr8n We could always do as in Deadpool 2, go back in time....and KILL all those awful writers!😂
@@user-ox3mj2sr8n I see you haven't read a single post-Endor book.
In your conclusion… so true. I absolutely love your videos for explaining Star Wars and the real world. I don’t always expect advice on how to be a more open minded person from a Star Wars lore video!
Several things that "never" seem to die not just in THIS franchise but anywhere...
Plot an anyone in it's favor
Wilhelm screaming... No one's ever managed to exterminate the species yet
An for shows an movies, camera people, they're practically indestructible and immortal. Better equipped with protection rivalled by none.
That really wasn’t where I thought this episode was going but I thoroughly enjoyed it
Thank you for another intelligent video. 👍🏻👍🏻
I love your videos. Favorite channel.
Well said.
Come for Star Wars. Leave with food for thought. Gotta love Generation Tech.
Cockroaches of star wars... Literally geonosians.
@@user-ox3mj2sr8n And one of those little critters STILL survived!
@@user-ox3mj2sr8n Have you played Republic Commando?
"Does he know?"
Come for the Star Wars lore and stay for the life lessons
Cringe comments about sand are what will truly never die. You can't escape them, they will spread like a zombie plague. The only solution is to get rid of all sand in the galaxy and erase all memory of it existing.
I dunno, Alan, I think you may be pretty darn naive about real-world business-owners/rich people in terms of competence or good will or them necessarily having any intention of working anything out with the rest of society that 'misunderstands' them when they can just pay people to say that liberal arts education and professors are the ones that don't know the real world when in fact that kind of education used to keep people in all walks of life from knowing only their specialty within the machine, even if that specialty is only money and how to cover for taking or scamming more of it.
The only way to keep the greedy in balance is to make *them* work very very hard at doing something productive for society, say, by implementing pre-Reagan top marginal tax rates instead of shovelling more money to the already rich and expecting them to somehow get better or fix anything. They blame 'regulation' for their antisocial behavior and grift but when those regulations are in face taken away or they get what they want, no, nothing gets better, no promises are kept..... They just take more cause they have the power to do that instead of building anything.
Alan, I'm you didn't push for the "invisible hand" theory by Adam Smith. Bravo.
u guy uploaded this about 1 minute ago and here i am ^^
I wasn't expecting this video to get so deep.
"Let me tell you what's going to happen, so you can prepare yourself. First, there'll be a knock at the door. On the other side of the door will be a man who outranks you. He's going to tell you that you're doing a fine job and that you're a credit to your department, and maybe that you're to be promoted. Then, he's going to tell you that I'm to be released. You'll protest, but that protest will be in vain. Because the reason I'm to be released is the same reason you seek to lock me up. I am evil, but I am a necessary evil."
-(probably a bit misquoted, but for the most part, the correct/intended message is there.)
Weird quest and one you might what to team up with someone for, has there ever been a Sith that got to the top and then just quit the Sith order and left?
Well balanced, and said. We are ultimately human and are all growing.
Your client was a smart man getting you guys on the case. Hopefully a lawsuit will help him pay for your services.
@generationtech can you do a video about thet6 ion disrupter please?
It's all about business.
Based on the thumbnail I thought this would be about Jawa's. I was surprised when I saw the actual video.
The more you know 🌠
But, of course, Lovecraft nailed it with:
“The most merciful thing in the world, I think, is the inability of the human mind to correlate all its contents. We live on a placid island of ignorance in the midst of black seas of infinity, and it was not meant that we should voyage far. The sciences, each straining in its own direction, have hitherto harmed us little; but some day the piecing together of dissociated knowledge will open up such terrifying vistas of reality, and of our frightful position therein, that we shall either go mad from the revelation or flee from the light into the peace and safety of a new dark age.”
We waste so much time and resources in the struggle, when we already know the basics of what we all need to survive and thrive as a civilization. There's the starting point of that common ground.
The next great mind could be some child dying in a 3rd world country from famine, disease, or war. Imagine the "second coming" failing because of such tragedy.
The message from Bill and Ted "be excellent to each other", leading to a utopian future is impractical when there's always someone who wants to be in control of the resources (energy, materials, people, etc.).
Is there any information of documentary on Star Wars Railroading industries?
A couple truths nobody's right when everybody is wrong. If an argument lasts more than 5 minutes? Both are wrong (fits about 80% the time)
He be spittin. Idk how many hear him tho…
Republic technology...Imperial technology...ALL MADE ON NAL HUTTA!
Great POV on the emotional outbursts concerning political views.
Well said.
How does being a criminal not count in galactic economics? it's based on crime.
I would LOVE to buy a lightsaber. But I'd have to win the lottery to be able to afford it, lol.
🔥🔥🔥
Humans are key to flaws no matter what.
No matter what political or religious beliefs we have, we will make mistakes till we die as humans.
RREMEMBER YOUR HUMANS we make mistakes.
What does meaning even mean?
Right on, force sensitive you might be. . . .
I think we as a people are to blame for somewhat by our nature we fear and push away and fight against what we don't like, and in witch hampers our ability to grow as a species and a people
I hope that real alien societies haven't even conceived of War and destruction of each other !!!
Another wonderful delivery of philoresophy Prof Allen 👏
I'd say if the Galaxy were to be united, it would be closer to the European Union. Putting issues aside, the way the European Union is meant to work on paper is that laws generally require unanimity. Power flows from the member-states rather than the European government and members are free to join and leave by referendum. There are certain criteria for members to join (at a certain economic development and have a functional democracy). The European Common Security and Defence Policy allows members to maintain their own militaries and are free to conduct their own foreign policies (within reason), but should the need arise, the EU can call upon the militaries of the member-states for collective action.
Honestly, given how it went from a republic which may not have had an emperor but definitely had an empire, to an official autocratic empire, to a provisional republic that was trying to grow an ideal state in chaotic times, to another even more autocratic empire, to a collection of ruined worlds trying to rebuild from the ashes from half a century of almost constant war, it's not hard to imagine looking at it as German states> German Empire> Weimar Republic> Nazi Germany> post-WW2 Europe. So an EU-like future of a reunited galaxy might not be unrealistic
It is the best interests of true capitalists to work to lift up others. Those who are lifted up, have the resources to participate in the economy, thusly providing for more economic activity and potential wealth for all, including the true capitalists. It is those who claim capitalism, but adhere to greed and corporatism that are a danger to an economy and a society.
Everything in life is because of a transactional process. There is nothing out there that doesn’t have a price to be bartered for services rendered. Sadly, this also includes every human interaction that you’ve ever, or will ever have.
Our history is well documented in bloody atrocities committed towards one another to prove just how malicious, & greedy we are as a species.
Its not sith and Jedi which Pendelum back and forth.
its the Galactic Republic+ Jedi and the Sith Empries which do.
strong anti-monopoly laws, UBI, universal health, no law exemptions for the rich, strong social safety net, &c &c &c.
Now, Jedi adding economic advice and consultation, along with Receptive Telepathy for nogotiations.
If God is Omnipotent, can he create an object so large that He Himself could not lift?
anyone else get the feeling that Alan just found himself in a higher tax bracket? joking aside, yes, the majority of college professors, unless they work in career and technical education, do not actually have any real world experience in the discipline they are supposedly experts in. also you can tell that star wars writers, especially the ones involved in the more recent series have no idea how business executives and the wealthy think.
Subsidiary.
👍
Well done treading the real world issues while using Star Wars as the mirror.
subsidary...xD
I absolutely believe that a large majority of wealthy businesspeople want to give back to society. Unfortunately the ways they're predisposed to thinking of doing so at best don't really accomplish anything and at worst actively do the opposite, unbeknownst to them.
I choose to believe you knew what it sounded like when you chose to say the equivalent of "be thankful to your colonizers" and did it anyway because you thought it was worth considering. For the record I think you're not _entirely_ wrong but the thought desperately needs further development.
I hope it's true that dislikes count as engagement for the algorithm because that was my intent in leaving one.
P.S.
Also for the record, I think blaming social media for the political division of society is another form of that emotional outburst reaction you're talking about. We've always been this way, all the internet did was expose it.
self-reflection.....
Yo
Ah i worked for Walmart for over 25 years and I remember how city's were putting up regulations and building limit sizes saying that Walmart has destroyed mainstreet America then comes along Amazon and goes hold my beer you haven't seen nothing yet 😂
"You know who's going to inherit the earth? Arms dealers. Everyone else is too busy killing each other." -Yuri Orlov, Lord of War
"Never go to war, especially with yourself".
Me: Same person.
Lol 😆
9:44 that's misunderstanding on what a monopoly is that even the FTC makes... Amazon has no small brick and mortar businesses and barely have brick and mortar at all besides Fresh market that is and the only why one could think it's an monopoly in anything is online retail which like Nintendo, Apple, Windows, Fortnight, Game's workshop and Wizards of the coast are all industry leaders in their spaces they are far from monopolies. Which the FTC figured out when it moved to block the Microsoft buyout of Activision/Blizzard. And found they were about to trust bust the loser just trying to hang in there not the winner of the 3 horse race that is game consoles. So yes while Amazon is big they are far from an monopoly even in the online retail space where you have everyone and anyone competing much like video games where Fortnight is not a monopoly. Which that whole industry was crushed by all of Online retail not Amazon by it's self.
Life is a constant balancing act, there is no "pick one side and hold you position against a tide of opposition." It's an ever moving target of stepping over the dividing line, back and forth, forever to keep things from tipping. Light and dark in constant opposition if one "wins" we all eventually lose, which seems depressing, I prefer the "We all do better when we all do better." mentality but even that seems a little one sided sometimes.
C3P0, R2D2 and money.
The more you know, the less you understand.
13:36 "What is the meaning of life?" Has an objective answer. 42!!!
R2-D2, the cockroach god! I'm sure the dolphins are behind Palpatine's continued rebirths.
Rian Johnson did indeed have a far better understanding of star wars lore than JJ Abrams. He just wasn't as good at telling a fun story.
Day 100
PLEASE DO MORE TACTICS VIDEOS
(Angry Beep Boops)
I thought that this was going to be about Kathleen Kennedy
Is inequality such bad thing if not for Envy but a lot of petty things actually turn out have important use
Solidarism anyone?