100%. I recommend this channel to all my friends. And I genuinely believe we all should. This man is doing work that literally no one else is doing. I have looked hard for other content creators that put out similar content and I’ve never found any. Truly a blessing, this man is.
Your content is great, some days ago I received my Hallpi TMR PS5 joysticks and I finally changed both thumb sticks, you didn't lie a single bit, they're so good!! I would even dare to say that they feel smoother than the originals, perfect for small adjustments!! Thank you! 🙏💙
On Xbox controllers, with Hall Effect sticks the left joystick would deflect slightly when pulling the left trigger since the triggers are Hall effect also and the magnet in the trigger comes close to the board, and the left stick since it is in that upper location. TMR sticks happily don't have this problem!
Look at how thick the rubbers on those are! You would probably have to physically abuse your controllers to misalign mess up its center point. They look pretty tough and durable
Is there a way we can help you get a stronger magnet setup or whatever it is you need to more accurately test TMR joysticks? Especially since that’s looking like the future. I know id be willing to throw in a little money
Pointless. If it is too fast for his equipment to measure, it will be actually impossible for you to tell a difference. In fact in practice there won’t be one. People are so beyond focused on “I want the absolute fastest.” That they don’t stop to consider that the real factors are usually your own reaction speed as well as your connection.
Would all these tmr joysticks you've tested work as good in the xbox controller? I find your tmr vids very helpful but I can't find vids on xbox version, only the gulikit. I've already ordered hallpi ones after your video and soldering equipment. Any advice on soldering would be helpful as well since it is my first time soldering 😬
Make sure the iron you got is good. I made the mistake of not getting a good one (paid $15 for a full kit that included iron, solder, flux, copper braid, pump, and several tips) and I just ended up getting a better one anyway. I’d say get one that is around the $35 or more. Otherwise you’ll take about 4 hours to do a 45 minute job. Second, get a good pump. Third, it’s easiest if you cut the modules at the corners and snap off each of the 4 walls. This will let you remove the leads in parts as opposed to one full joystick which will require you to perfectly de solder every single lead.
Okay but if the halls have higher resolution, and tmrs are even better, where can I find and how do I install a mcu that actually detects and uses that higher resolution
If you watched the video you’d know that he tested this and found that they’re too fast for him to get an accurate reading. Stop buying so much into the “input lag” bs. I’m not throwing shade at you btw. But for some reason there’s this massive shift into people thinking that a .003 second difference will give them a competitive edge. The real truth is that it won’t. Not even close. So for your needs, this is a far superior joystick than alps potentiometer ones. Will last you about 10 times as long, and perform admirably.
Okay but if the halls have higher resolution, and tmrs are even better, where can I find and how do I install a mcu that actually detects and uses that higher resolution
This is should be a Million sub channel at least, please keep doing this amazing videos. My controllers are amazing thanks to your videos.
100%. I recommend this channel to all my friends. And I genuinely believe we all should. This man is doing work that literally no one else is doing. I have looked hard for other content creators that put out similar content and I’ve never found any. Truly a blessing, this man is.
Your content is great, some days ago I received my Hallpi TMR PS5 joysticks and I finally changed both thumb sticks, you didn't lie a single bit, they're so good!!
I would even dare to say that they feel smoother than the originals, perfect for small adjustments!!
Thank you! 🙏💙
The originals aren't lubed, I think those are.
Finally the Ginfull video 🙌🏽
Another great video, thank you for doing this testing. My controllers are amazing because of your videos!
I love watching your videos. I’m passing this on. Amazing.
I am amazed how professional and well prepared are your tests and your channel in general. Wish you success and satisfaction from your work
On Xbox controllers, with Hall Effect sticks the left joystick would deflect slightly when pulling the left trigger since the triggers are Hall effect also and the magnet in the trigger comes close to the board, and the left stick since it is in that upper location. TMR sticks happily don't have this problem!
Thank you for the video!!
Look at how thick the rubbers on those are! You would probably have to physically abuse your controllers to misalign mess up its center point. They look pretty tough and durable
First, congratulations on the video. In your opinion, which one did better, these or v5s? I bought v5s this week.
Probably a combination of both. The mechanics of the v5s get you a really good return to center
Idk if you have an Xbox or not but would you try out the Hall effect sticks for the elite series 2 controllers specifically? Thanks in advance!
Is there a way we can help you get a stronger magnet setup or whatever it is you need to more accurately test TMR joysticks? Especially since that’s looking like the future. I know id be willing to throw in a little money
Pointless. If it is too fast for his equipment to measure, it will be actually impossible for you to tell a difference. In fact in practice there won’t be one. People are so beyond focused on “I want the absolute fastest.” That they don’t stop to consider that the real factors are usually your own reaction speed as well as your connection.
Would all these tmr joysticks you've tested work as good in the xbox controller? I find your tmr vids very helpful but I can't find vids on xbox version, only the gulikit. I've already ordered hallpi ones after your video and soldering equipment. Any advice on soldering would be helpful as well since it is my first time soldering 😬
Make sure the iron you got is good. I made the mistake of not getting a good one (paid $15 for a full kit that included iron, solder, flux, copper braid, pump, and several tips) and I just ended up getting a better one anyway. I’d say get one that is around the $35 or more. Otherwise you’ll take about 4 hours to do a 45 minute job.
Second, get a good pump. Third, it’s easiest if you cut the modules at the corners and snap off each of the 4 walls. This will let you remove the leads in parts as opposed to one full joystick which will require you to perfectly de solder every single lead.
Okay but if the halls have higher resolution, and tmrs are even better, where can I find and how do I install a mcu that actually detects and uses that higher resolution
Could you repair my dualsense edge and update with hall effect?
Also, the ali link seems to be broken
Do these tmr analog sticks have a bigger input lag than the normal alps analog sticks?
If you watched the video you’d know that he tested this and found that they’re too fast for him to get an accurate reading. Stop buying so much into the “input lag” bs.
I’m not throwing shade at you btw. But for some reason there’s this massive shift into people thinking that a .003 second difference will give them a competitive edge. The real truth is that it won’t. Not even close. So for your needs, this is a far superior joystick than alps potentiometer ones. Will last you about 10 times as long, and perform admirably.
Should we really trust the mechanical durability of those cheapies?
I dont disagree, but do you trust the reliability of the official sony joysticks?
Аналоги от сони тоже китайское 💩 они могут прослужит и пол года а могут сломаться через месяца два или три все берут в китае
Yes, way more than Alps, it will last way longer then your average potentiometer drift
Okay but if the halls have higher resolution, and tmrs are even better, where can I find and how do I install a mcu that actually detects and uses that higher resolution