Ce geant du temps passé étonne toujours sa voix sa son style la composition musicale que dire d autres que même si je ne comprends pas assez l anglais une attirance particulière s empare de moi et mes copains Des années d or surtout lors du passage du film last waltz sur les écrans du ciné à rabat on a été épris d un bonheur unique ce était extra
They the Rolling Thunder performed 2 shows in Rochester NY 75 ,I was near Albany NY at school, Someone was trying to sell Dave Mansfield octave mandolin online I said keep it or give it to a museum, Scarlet Rivera on Violin, please listen to The Lonesome Death Of Haddie Carol from Harvard Square Theater, Rolling Thunder live Boston,1975.Old Chris, a retired fiddler of Albuquerque NM D tuned
Its inconceivable where Hendrix took this song. Jimi was usually more undisciplined, just wild man improv, because it was still coming from some place none of the other guys had access to. But with this song he labored on the production, maybe out of massive respect for Dylan. And so with that attention to detail, the reverence for the material, he trasformed it to the ride on the Mystery Train it always cried out to be. His vision and vocal, his perfect choices instrumentally, give his version a majesty Dylan heard and knew he could never match. And he humbly said so. Gone at 27, his version is the most fully realized thing he ever did. But....what might have been....
It's also inconceivable where SRV took Little Wing. SRV was usually more undisciplined, just wild man improv, because it was still coming from some place none of the other guys had access to. But with little wing he labored on the production, maybe out of massive respect for Jimi. And so with that attention to detail, the reference for the material, he transformed it to the ride on the mystery train it always cried out to be. His vision, his perfect choices instrumentally give his version a majesty Jimi never heard and could never match. And he humbly didnt say so. Gone at 35, his version is the most fully realised thing he ever did. But....what might have been....
without bob writing it, you don't have jimi's version and people have criticized bob's songs and singing forever and luckily he goes on giving people criticizing him something to do. anybody criticizing bob's singing in 1974 of this song may or may not get the chance to hear how he does it in 2024 in what could be his final year of touring. i'm thrilled he bothers. i know he has rent money!
Some of the best guitar playing by Robbie I have ever heard. I think this version is a bit too fast but still love it. Why compare it to Jimi's version? They are both great.
@@roseblake5803 ... how is my comment stupid? He is famous for being one of the worst vocalists to ever become famous. Terrible pitch, flat, monotonic, speaking or yelling rather than singing. If you know anything about a good vocal performance you know he is not it. But he deserves credit for being a superb songwriter. Some people should just be back room, not front of stage.
I love almost every version done of this song, but my favorite is Dave Mason's. A great guitar player, and he sings miles better than Dylan or Hendrix.
Yes sir. Mine also. Plus a street singer did a fantastic version. Mason played and jammed many times with Hendrix. In fact mason played acoustic guitar on Hendrix studio version cover.
@@tommythevenow3476 well said, i get people liking hendrix's version more but i think Bob does it better in every rendition. Hendrix's music is more revolved around his guitarplaying. The passion in the words goes lost in his version, especially in his live versions, although they are all great listening-experiences. Bob's articulation is unbeatable, and although Hendrix could play the guitar like nobody else, Robbie Robertson sure is one hell of a guitarist!
Yes, Dylan is in the music key of Am, Hendrix in C# m,and Dave Mason s also excellent version is in Bm,and Dave Mason recorded it with Jim Hendrix it's on Electric Ladyland, Michael Fairchild a world Scholar of Hendrix I knew him many years ago in Rochester NY, and we enjoyed tapes with board mixs of that album as yet unheard or released widely.Old Chris, a retired fiddler of Albuquerque NM D tuned
R.I.P. Robbie Robertson
That was the best All Along the Watchtower I've ever heard in my 69 years
One of Dylan’s best, The Band, one of the best groups ever, Dylan and the Band, what could be better
Dylan always has great musicians around him. The Band was great and a perfect fit at that time. Who doesn't want to back him up.
2 Dylans and 2 Bands
love how it's a direct hendrix cover here.... Dylan once said something like 'that's Jimi's song, i just wrote it'
Yeah, very few songs where I like the cover better but Jimii does thisn best
Many people have done this song.
I'm just loving it 🤟🏿
For fuck's sake! Cant you just listen to dylan for dylan? All of a sudden the man cant even play his own song??
@@THO743 He is stealing a song from a person of color. That's appropriation and it's wrong.
Dylan and The Band. Seriously - who could be better?
The Jimi Hendrix Experience
Band of gypsies.
Wow, unbelievably stirring, they said audiences booed him when he went electric. Inconceivable.
I was at that concert. Great to see Dylan and the Band !!
Thank You! I love The Band!
Robbie nails it
What a Line up. Brilliant. Thank you.
RIP Robbie
Robbie is a National Treasure.RIP
Bob and these guys just related to each other from the moment he chose them to take a big turn in the road with him.They were fearless together.
Maybe Hendrix has done its best version but this Is the awesome original in a stunnin live performance..Wow
Wow the song writer with a kick as band! Thanks for posting!
Ce geant du temps passé étonne toujours sa voix sa son style la composition musicale que dire d autres que même si je ne comprends pas assez l anglais une attirance particulière s empare de moi et mes copains Des années d or surtout lors du passage du film last waltz sur les écrans du ciné à rabat on a été épris d un bonheur unique ce était extra
Saw this show a few days earlier at Maple Leaf Gardens in Toronto
What were your memories.? I was too young in 74,my first dylan show was 87..just interested ..
i would give my 3rd grandchild to see this concert live.
Richard on drums. It’s great how they kept it short and sweet. The best of the best of the best. Before the. Days of quantisizing.
Good God! This is an explosion!!
Wishing the ALWAYS SUPREMEi🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 ARTIST, Bob Dylan : A REALLY FABULOUS NEW YEAR -- 2023!---- love Evelyn O'Connor
Was lucky to see Dylan & the Band at the Forum, LA 1974..Was awesome! Never got a chance to see The Rolling Thunder Revue in 1975...if only!
Me too. I purchased "St Valentine's Day Massacre", recorded at the Forum, shortly thereafter. The album is worth $250 on Ebay.
They the Rolling Thunder performed 2 shows in Rochester NY 75 ,I was near Albany NY at school, Someone was trying to sell Dave Mansfield octave mandolin online I said keep it or give it to a museum, Scarlet Rivera on Violin, please listen to The Lonesome Death Of Haddie Carol from Harvard Square Theater, Rolling Thunder live Boston,1975.Old Chris, a retired fiddler of Albuquerque NM D tuned
Robbie !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
In 1974, my guitar-playing friend Geoff and I were impressed by Robbie's obvious "homage" to Hendrix in his execution.
Its inconceivable where Hendrix took this song. Jimi was usually more undisciplined, just wild man improv, because it was still coming from some place none of the other guys had access to. But with this song he labored on the production, maybe out of massive respect for Dylan. And so with that attention to detail, the reverence for the material, he trasformed it to the ride on the Mystery Train it always cried out to be. His vision and vocal, his perfect choices instrumentally, give his version a majesty Dylan heard and knew he could never match. And he humbly said so. Gone at 27, his version is the most fully realized thing he ever did. But....what might have been....
What?
Gave his life for music
And after Dylan heard Jimi's version, he said he could never play it acoustically, again.
Majesty is swell and all but it don't mean a thing if it ain't got that swing.
It's also inconceivable where SRV took Little Wing. SRV was usually more undisciplined, just wild man improv, because it was still coming from some place none of the other guys had access to. But with little wing he labored on the production, maybe out of massive respect for Jimi. And so with that attention to detail, the reference for the material, he transformed it to the ride on the mystery train it always cried out to be. His vision, his perfect choices instrumentally give his version a majesty Jimi never heard and could never match. And he humbly didnt say so. Gone at 35, his version is the most fully realised thing he ever did. But....what might have been....
without bob writing it, you don't have jimi's version and people have criticized bob's songs and singing forever and luckily he goes on giving people criticizing him something to do. anybody criticizing bob's singing in 1974 of this song may or may not get the chance to hear how he does it in 2024 in what could be his final year of touring. i'm thrilled he bothers. i know he has rent money!
Great performance !! Robbie and Bob = Jimi 😂😂😂❤❤❤!!
Sencillamente Genial !!
Aún me sigue emocionando cuando escucho este tema con The Band
Great version. (Thx JMH)
Love to see this live
Damn Robbie is killing the lead .
Always does.
Some of the best guitar playing by Robbie I have ever heard. I think this version is a bit too fast but still love it. Why compare it to Jimi's version? They are both great.
yeah a bit too fast what the hell did they all amp up on bennies or something. ??
no lying Robbie ripped it up
That’s the most dynamic Robertson lead I’ve heard. He usually holds back, to complement the song, not stand out.
✨🤗I love it
Magic together
Just brilliant
Love this song and all the versions but this is my favorite.
This is fantastic! D Dorian Mode.. #improvnotes..., This is thrilling.. You still own this song. Wow !
The 74 tour should have been called The Punk Rock tour, very fast and aggressive
🎉THE BEST 🎉
名曲ですね
before the flood- ABSOLUTELY GREAT
Top..grazie✌️🥺
great
in 1974 Dylan was God!!!!
ROCK n ROLL DADDY-O ! ✌
Mis respetos🍏🍏🍏🍏🍏🍎🍎🍎🍎😃😀😇😇😉😉😉😉🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍🤍
Smashing
Play it loud.
Jay
Almost as good as the version of Hendrix. Praise indeed.
Tell me again that rap is music. Incredible.
Tell me again that you are not a racist.
@@richardgray8593 So --- only racists don't like Hip Hop? What a racist thing to say.
the inspired song that Jimi took too outa space.....
English, please.
Thanks for that. 🙂
One of the world's most talented songwriters, and most untalented vocalist.
Like when kids say they don’t like whisky
@@NomadOutOfAfrica .. lol so you are saying his vocals are actually GOOD, but some people are too immature to appreciate how good his vocals are? 🤣🤣🤣
Compared to the Woodstock 94 performance:th-cam.com/video/jd3iytj9SDQ/w-d-xo.html, he sounds great here lol.
Some people just make stupid comments like our friend named WIZ 😂
@@roseblake5803 ... how is my comment stupid? He is famous for being one of the worst vocalists to ever become famous. Terrible pitch, flat, monotonic, speaking or yelling rather than singing. If you know anything about a good vocal performance you know he is not it.
But he deserves credit for being a superb songwriter.
Some people should just be back room, not front of stage.
great in slowed down mode (0,75)
thanks, you're right
It does sound rushed, doesn't it?
wheres the video?
Geez Robbie lay off the blow...
you were a rock guitar immortal then as well as today and always, RR.
Bob channeling Jimi
Peerless &unparalleled vocalist (Dylan)&the bands that attached to him
Your so right, Roy Orbison couldn't hold a candle to Dylan.
I prefer Jimi Hendrix 's version . Great song though and The Band were a great band .
Same here.
Sounds too much like Hurricane
ロビーはあなたに差し上げます。二人でやっててください・・・バンドは別行動で・・・
I love almost every version done of this song, but my favorite is Dave Mason's. A great guitar player, and he sings miles better than Dylan or Hendrix.
Yes sir. Mine also. Plus a street singer did a fantastic version. Mason played and jammed many times with Hendrix. In fact mason played acoustic guitar on Hendrix studio version cover.
@@larryrubin5150 Absolutely right. Hendrix and Mason were huge fans of each other.
Without his singing it's a great live rendition.
Had to listen to Jimi's masterpiece.
He wrote it, he can sing it however he wants.
@@tommythevenow3476 well said, i get people liking hendrix's version more but i think Bob does it better in every rendition. Hendrix's music is more revolved around his guitarplaying. The passion in the words goes lost in his version, especially in his live versions, although they are all great listening-experiences. Bob's articulation is unbeatable, and although Hendrix could play the guitar like nobody else, Robbie Robertson sure is one hell of a guitarist!
yeah, Jimi made this song his own, can't be touched. Jimi was the best singer.
hé there this song was writen by Bob Dylan for hendrix, so the masterpiece praise goes to Bob! ;)
nothing like hendrix version
good.why should it be?
Too fast
his song his way
It does sound sped up by the poster.
@@LDixon007 maybe I think it does sound like they were just playing fast at the same time though
i love it....its urgent
Sorry I like Jimi Hendrix's version a lot better
why apologize?
This live version is much better than any of the live versions done by Hendrix.
Bob Dylan wrote the song for Jimi Hendrix. But Yeah Jimi put a twist on it with his hard voice.
Dylan's version from the live Budokan double-album stands up with any Hendrix version ...
It is actually quite simple. It's Dylan's song. You think Jim knew what he was singing? Perhaps Dylan explained it to him.
Good performance, but i prefer the 1969th.
ディラン御大の エレクトリックバーション。 しかし やはり 最高のパフォーマンスは ジミ・ヘンドリックスの バージョンか
Yes, Dylan is in the music key of Am, Hendrix in C# m,and Dave Mason s also excellent version is in Bm,and Dave Mason recorded it with Jim Hendrix it's on Electric Ladyland, Michael Fairchild a world Scholar of Hendrix I knew him many years ago in Rochester NY, and we enjoyed tapes with board mixs of that album as yet unheard or released widely.Old Chris, a retired fiddler of Albuquerque NM D tuned