What if Sonic was the villain and Dr. Eggman was the hero? Can the doctor’s smarts and mechanical tinkering put a stop to a chaotic, rebellious, destructive thrill seeker that only cares for himself? And what if the other characters? Would tails be corrupted and be Sonic’s right hand mischief maker? Or will he admire the doctor’s massive army of robotic peacekeepers and environmental protection facilities to make the world a happier place?
If Eggman releases Shadow from Prison Island: ARK will crash into Earth, destroying it. Unless Amy (or anyone else) gets some courage without Sonic's influence... assuming she survived Eggman's conquest. There will be no winners.
Video Request: “What If AOSTH Robotnik Wins?” It's basically the same as this video, but in each episode (including the Christmas special), Robotnik has only won due to some changes in the events that have resulted in his down fall, wether if it’s small, minor, and/or unnoticeable; big, major, and/or crucial; soon as the very beginning, or at the end of the episode. (The only exception that would make my idea not only different but also unique, is to not have any and all changes that eventually resulted in Robotnik winning affect any other episodes in the show.)
What if Enerjak was never gone to begin with? He could live in a certain echidna's shadow as an alter ego. Kinda like sukuna, when that same echidna get's exposed to chaos energy.
Nice Also got a Sonic What if Idea What if Sonic Movies Were Canon? like With Satam Sonic Remain Sonic Tails is Movie Tails Knuckles is Movie Knuckles Robotnik/Eggman is Movie Robotnik Tom and Maddie are in it
@TheRealMightyEmperor He's a character who is a villain that was introduced in Breath Of The Wild. And he appeared again in Tears Of The Kingdom. And in Age Of Calamity. He uses machines just like Eggman.
Awesome stuff as always! The Freedom Fighters going up against an elite Eggman robot isn't even remotely fair lol, but I guess they wouldn't stand much of a chance against Eggman's army if you were to pull from the games. That being said, does this story include characters from only the Archie comics and the games, or other Sonic media as well? Because if the later is true, my mind is racing right now, thinking which (if any ) character, team or faction in the series, without Sonic's help, can step up and have the best chance to take on a triumphant Eggman. A few fun match ups come to mind, but I'll wait and see what you have planned for this What if.
@@TheRealMightyEmperor The games being the main universe the story takes place makes sense, and just better any way for this What if. But now that the gates are open, things just got a little more interesting 😁. Not to say this story haven't been great, cause it has, I just really like surprises.
@@TheRealMightyEmperor fr you unknowingly had it out for knuckles if i didn’t tell you this you were gonna make a what if called What if knuckles died in hidden palace zone
What would happend if in Forces Sonic actually did die? I was originally thinking what would happen if Maria never got shot but then nothing would of happened. YES! I would like to see a part 2.
It's hard to say with forces because all the other characters are... Out of character. Nothing Sonic did in Forces was something Shadow, Silver, Knuckles etc couldn't also do whilst working together.
Tails' great intellect and ability to construct, the manus to create, is no doubt noticed by Eggman. He becomes his assitant, with a bone to pick with this world that stomped over him over and over again.
User engagement dictates what I do. Look at the last episode in both series and compare to the first ones. There is no point working on things most my viewers ignore.
Eggman did try what I believe to be a Sonic-inspired design already in Sonic 1 - The Roller So if Sonic made it to the Final Zone I think Eggman would be more impressed than he was already, but not enough to create a Metal Sonic in his image So perhaps he would improve on his first idea implementing the technology he would have used on his copycat series, a "Metal Roll" maybe?
It still comes back to big Jet for me. Those Rollers were made before he killed Sonic. Obviously Sonic wasn't all that, so developing the copycat further is pointless compared to using his own genius to improve the concept of speed.
I think a better way to phrase it would be "If Sonic defeated Eggman for good in Sonic 1" and then go from there with someone else going after the Chaos Emeralds in absence of the Doctor and stuff like Shadow's awakening being triggered by other events like the Black Arms coming to Earth
What if Sonic was the villain and Dr. Eggman was the hero? Can the doctor’s smarts and mechanical tinkering put a stop to a chaotic, rebellious, destructive thrill seeker that only cares for himself? And what if the other characters? Would tails be corrupted and be Sonic’s right hand mischief maker? Or will he admire the doctor’s massive army of robotic peacekeepers and environmental protection facilities to make the world a happier place?
If Eggman releases Shadow from Prison Island: ARK will crash into Earth, destroying it.
Unless Amy (or anyone else) gets some courage without Sonic's influence... assuming she survived Eggman's conquest. There will be no winners.
It all comes down to the choices Eggster makes
@@TheRealMightyEmperorGerald Robotnik :🎉
Knuckles is cooked💀
Oh No
OH NO
This is basically if New Yolk City Was Canon In The Sonic Games
well apparently sonic prime is canon to the games so technically it is canon
Except in this timeline the main cast does not make it out alive the only one still alive is knuckles
For now
Video Request: “What If AOSTH Robotnik Wins?”
It's basically the same as this video, but in each episode (including the Christmas special), Robotnik has only won due to some changes in the events that have resulted in his down fall, wether if it’s small, minor, and/or unnoticeable; big, major, and/or crucial; soon as the very beginning, or at the end of the episode. (The only exception that would make my idea not only different but also unique, is to not have any and all changes that eventually resulted in Robotnik winning affect any other episodes in the show.)
So, basically, what if Eggman was Frieza from Dragon Ball, but on a smaller scale.
Talk about alternate history + Sonic.
Can his friends pick up the mantle?
What if Archie Sonic characters were Canon to the games
Waaaayyyyyy to many characters, and the freedom fighters from SatAM have already been covered so not much point
Simple
Archie comics are canon
@@TheRealMightyEmperorwill you do an what if eggman was good from the games
What if Enerjak was never gone to begin with? He could live in a certain echidna's shadow as an alter ego. Kinda like sukuna, when that same echidna get's exposed to chaos energy.
I don't know enough about him to write that
Why do i feel like silver will come to save the future ealier?
He may not even have been born.
@@charmyzard we don't know for sure
Nice Also got a Sonic What if Idea
What if Sonic Movies Were Canon? like With Satam
Sonic Remain Sonic
Tails is Movie Tails
Knuckles is Movie Knuckles
Robotnik/Eggman is Movie Robotnik
Tom and Maddie are in it
Cool video glad to see someone sees the full glorious might of the Eggman empire and what he has to offer the world
In Eggman we trust
I hope you make a part 2 to this scenario soon😊😊😊
Cool video.
Thank you
No problem. You know that question is like asking what if Master Kohga never lost? That's his Nintendo Counterpart.
@@fatalwaffle1715 No clue who that is
@TheRealMightyEmperor He's a character who is a villain that was introduced in Breath Of The Wild. And he appeared again in Tears Of The Kingdom. And in Age Of Calamity. He uses machines just like Eggman.
Awesome stuff as always! The Freedom Fighters going up against an elite Eggman robot isn't even remotely fair lol, but I guess they wouldn't stand much of a chance against Eggman's army if you were to pull from the games.
That being said, does this story include characters from only the Archie comics and the games, or other Sonic media as well? Because if the later is true, my mind is racing right now, thinking which (if any ) character, team or faction in the series, without Sonic's help, can step up and have the best chance to take on a triumphant Eggman.
A few fun match ups come to mind, but I'll wait and see what you have planned for this What if.
@nanayawdanso4817 It is open to many possibilities at the moment. I don't want to lock anything out. The only rule is the games must remain important
@@TheRealMightyEmperor The games being the main universe the story takes place makes sense, and just better any way for this What if. But now that the gates are open, things just got a little more interesting 😁. Not to say this story haven't been great, cause it has, I just really like surprises.
Can’t wait to see what happens with Knuckles and Shadow in the future!
Knuckles might appear if I make a part 2
I feel like this is another story in which knuckles is gonna get cooked honestly only shadow can save us now by ending the whole planet
The more of these I make, the more I realise how lucky Knuckles had gotten in the main timeline.
@@TheRealMightyEmperor fr you unknowingly had it out for knuckles if i didn’t tell you this you were gonna make a what if called
What if knuckles died in hidden palace zone
@SparklingJam What If Knuckles was betrayed and locked inside the time chamber
@@TheRealMightyEmperor dang I didn’t know you were aware of those what ifs 🤝
When you said Big jet, I instantly pictured the one from little Einstein. Did he build that one? Great video by the way.
I am not familiar with that
@@TheRealMightyEmperoroh it’s like some kids show, kinda old, not the most popular. Big jets the villain in it.
Please part 3 of what if Sonic SatAM was canon
What would happend if in Forces Sonic actually did die? I was originally thinking what would happen if Maria never got shot but then nothing would of happened. YES! I would like to see a part 2.
It's hard to say with forces because all the other characters are... Out of character. Nothing Sonic did in Forces was something Shadow, Silver, Knuckles etc couldn't also do whilst working together.
I want this to get a part 2, now
I would love to see tails survive what happened and take sonic,s place to try and deafeat eggman
Tails' great intellect and ability to construct, the manus to create, is no doubt noticed by Eggman. He becomes his assitant, with a bone to pick with this world that stomped over him over and over again.
What if the emperor wasnt mighty?
Then the world is over :(
if Eggman beats sonic, then wouldn't Eggman Negative would beat blaze too
Sure if you want
@@TheRealMightyEmperor i would like to see make that one day
did you use ai generated images? that's seriously disappointing if so
Why? It's an illustrative tool.
Are you making Part 2?
Depends on how well it does
@@TheRealMightyEmperorThis is doing pretty well.
After this do you plan on getting back to some of your other what ifs?
Like what if sonic died or if sonic was serious?
User engagement dictates what I do. Look at the last episode in both series and compare to the first ones. There is no point working on things most my viewers ignore.
Eggman did try what I believe to be a Sonic-inspired design already in Sonic 1 - The Roller
So if Sonic made it to the Final Zone I think Eggman would be more impressed than he was already, but not enough to create a Metal Sonic in his image
So perhaps he would improve on his first idea implementing the technology he would have used on his copycat series, a "Metal Roll" maybe?
It still comes back to big Jet for me. Those Rollers were made before he killed Sonic. Obviously Sonic wasn't all that, so developing the copycat further is pointless compared to using his own genius to improve the concept of speed.
@@TheRealMightyEmperor
I'd say he'd be less impressed at their failure to kill Sonic when he did that so easily, so I definitely think your idea works
Series is good so far. 👍
Thanks
Heres a idea what if the biolozard destroyed the earth
What If Sonia & Manic Were Canon?
What if Nocturnus Clan is be good?
now do what if sonic never lost
That's just the normal games
I think a better way to phrase it would be "If Sonic defeated Eggman for good in Sonic 1" and then go from there with someone else going after the Chaos Emeralds in absence of the Doctor and stuff like Shadow's awakening being triggered by other events like the Black Arms coming to Earth
What if knuckles's tribe survived
Could be interesting
Like all of it as in they beat Chaos, or some of them hid away and survived Chaos?
@@polocatfan both of those
So when's the next video?
PART 2 PLEASE!
4:46 sounds exactly like eggman
and 11:10
Thank you :)
Whare is what if satam was Canon part 3?
Is this a re-upload? I swear you made a video exactly like this
Not a re upload. That was if Eggman was Serious. This is where Eggman killed Sonic on his first try.
11:05 Who drew that sexy picture of Sally?
What if Game gear Silver sonic Was the robot sonic eggman kept bringing back
What if Sonic meets Fiona the Fox in Sonic CD and Soniona happened?
I think Amy she is still here in Sonic adventure 2