I love how you ain't doing the same story and events with the more serious Sonic. Putting your own twists on things makes the stories really stands out.
Well, Sonic will be disappointed but proud of what Tails has done in his stead. Shadow just woke up and gets his butt whoopes by a Fox Kid who is 8 to 11 years old, how embarrassing. XD Poor Knuckles tho, at least he has some company.
Idc if it becomes less and less like the game. The whole point of reading, watching, or writing AU fanfictions is to tell a different story with those characters. That's what makes the story stands out.
I hate cliffhangers. So, in this timeline, Sonic gets the Shadow treatment and Shadow remains a villain. I do like what happened with Knuckles and Tikal, I think this would be the end of their storyline since I don't see why Knuckles would want to get involved willingly with the Sonic-Eggman cycle again. Hope you continue this series since this is like the only good sonic what if out so far (that I've seen)
@@TheRealMightyEmperor Oh yeahhhh. I've already seen the Frontiers and What if Sonic died series, both are really good. Will you ever continue the Dead Sonic scenerio or do you have other stuff planned? Loved where you were going with that one.
I enjoyed the story, I definitely would like to see more content of the theory; But so far, I think it's a proper time to conclude it, Of course, An epilogue would be needed but for now, The story was very thrilling and probably one of the best theories I've seen thanks to it's narrative and how original the story was, Nice video.
This new Episode came at the perfect time since during that time My little brother graduated from high school and just finished his big game on Sunday. So this is a nice treat as well As excited to see the different decisions, that character is what makes now that's the Optimism and Free spirit Nonshalantness has been toned down By the growing psychological weight of responsibility and hard choices.
@@TheRealMightyEmperor : We did ,Thank You! I have three ideas that you can choose from after you've done with this: #1. What if the Freedom Fighters of Alice Acorn was part of the game timeline and and teamed up with Sonic all the way to Sonic Forces? #2. What if the Soul Dimension and Mobius merged and stabilized ( This would have long term Consequences to many characters, The environments, & The timeline itself including other villains like Mephyllis, Dark Giya, Chaos, The Nocturnis Clan, Eggman Nega, Dr.Starline, & The End? #3. What if Zeena Stumbled by a warp ring and was in Sonic Mania 🤔
PLEASE MORE!! MORE MORE MORE!!! 6:11 who made that drawing? Also I like this. Maybe consider getting VAs to do their lines. (I could try helping you, I never tried Amy's voice, but I could try Tikal or any other female. Tails is originally VA'd by a female so I could try that too but I ain't that good)
Thanks for enjoying! Please see my other what ifs for more of my style. As for Voice Acting, I cannot afford to pay other people, so I have to work with what I got. And the image was on google.
An awesome conclusion to a very fun What if! Funnily enough, even though this series is completely different and unrelated to "What if Sonic died" , in some strange head cannon sort of way one could see this series as a prequel to that. It wouldn't make any sense, but hey just a random thought.
Can't wait for Sonic Heroes to happen in this timeline. I wonder if Eggman will still make Neo Metal, since Metal wasn't ever created in CD because of Sonic's time travel mischief.
Here's how I would continue this scenario. I'll say for the sake of this story that Sonic ultimately dies from his wounds, leaving Tails to become the world's new main hero. Knuckles is also a backup. So, let's get to it: Sonic Advance 1: Pretty much the same except for the fact that Tails is the only one on the adventure. When he reaches the second to last zone, he has to fight Shadow. Luckily, Tails had gathered all the chaos emeralds, so he transforms into his super form and defeats Shadow. However, he doesn’t kill him because that's not the kind of person he is. After knocking Shadow unconcious, he defeats Robotnik the same as Sonic did in canon. Sonic Advance 2: Tails once again takes Sonic's place, keeping the chaos emeralds by him at all times to keep them away from Robotnik and Shadow. However, Robotnik doesn’t try to capture Knuckles, knowing of the power of the Master emerald locked inside him, so he instead carries on as normal. When Tails saves Cream and Cheese and Cream asks to come with him, Tails is initially reluctant but sees a lot of himself in her, so he agrees to let her come with him as long as she didn’t get herself hurt. The 2 eventually encounter Shadow once again, who is once again defeated by Super Tails, much to his frustration. Afterwards, Tails and Cream defeat Robotnik and save Vanilla like Sonic did in canon, and afterwards Tails agrees to let Cream become his unofficial sidekick. Afterwards, Shadow is left frustrated by their continual failures, but Robotnik tells him that these last 2 attacks had been for the purpose of collecting data on Tails, and tells him that he will now turn him into a machine like him and Knuckles, and he will have free will. Robotnik still believes Shadow to be firmly on his side, and Shadow agrees. However, once the modifications are complete, Mecha Shadow declares that he has no further use for Robotnik, killing him and oblitarating the remains of the death egg still on Angel Island, which is where the surgery took place. Sonic Heroes: Planning to gather all of the Chaos emeralds in one spot, Mecha Shadow, who has all the same powers as Neo Metal so is currently posing as Robotnik, recruits Fang the Sniper (who never met the other Hooligans due to Sonic the Fighters never happening) and recruits Chaos as himself, planning to betray him once he got the emeralds. He then sends a note as Robotnik to Tails, telling him that he would destroy the world in 3 days and challenging him to stop him. Seeing this, Tails tells Cream and Knuckles about Robotnik's threat, and they agree to help him, although Knuckles has to be convinced by Tikal. This is one of the only teams in the game since Team Dark was never formed for obvious reasons, and Amy and Big never became part of the cast. Also, with Robotnik already dead, the Chaotix are never hired by him. The only other team is the alternate Team Hooligan, consisting of Fang, Chaos, and Omega, who won't betray Shadow. The 2 teams fight over the emeralds constantly, with Chaos absorbing every one his team got. Eventually the 2 teams converge at the Final Fortress, and Mecha Shadow steals team hero's emeralds from them. He tries to do the same to Chaos, but the water monster fights back and absorbs the emeralds Shadow was holding, transforming into Perfect Chaos once again. Shadow transforms into a version of the metal overlord to fight him, and team hero all proceed to use the positive power of the emeralds to transform into their super forms. Fang flees from the Final Fortress on the Marvelous Queen as the 2 factions fight, and the battle ends with Shadow being defeated and Chaos's anger finally being quelled as he ascends to the afterlife with Tikal. Afterwards, Shadow is left on the ground defeated. Omega attempts to sneak attack the heroes, but Knuckles then destroys both him and Shadow, putting an end to the threat.
@@TheRealMightyEmperor Thanks, but we still have the Black Arms to deal with. Here goes: Shadow the Hedgehog: In this timeline since Shadow's dead, when Black Doom finds out he gets enraged that the Earthlings broke their promise and orders the Black Arms to lay waste to the world and find the chaos emeralds, which were scattered after Mecha Shadow and Perfect Chaos's defeats. With only Knuckles, Tails and Cream to defend Earth and the Black Arms being far more aggressive than in canon, there are many more casualties than in canon. However, GUN is still fighting the Black Arms as well, and eventually contact team hero for a meeting. The 3 heroes agree and meet up with Abraham Tower (The GUN commander from Shadow the Hedgehog) who explains what he and GUN know of the Black Arms, including their involvement in Shadow's creation. They conclude that they have to get to the Eclipse Cannon to stop the Black Arms, but they also need the Chaos Emeralds. So, they launch a plan where Knuckles, Cream, Rouge (who's making her debut here) and Commander Tower piloting Diabalon distract the Black Arms and Black Doom while Tails gets the Chaos Emeralds from Black Doom. The plan goes into action, but when they arrive their shocked to find what looks like multiple Shadows fighting the Black Arms. Questioning how this is possible, the heroes decide screw it and begin fighting alongside the Shadows. As they do so, Tails manages to sneak up on Black Doom and knocks him down using some sort of device, managing to take the emeralds he had stolen and then retreating with the rest of Team Hero and GUN. They all then storm the Black Comet, but Black Doom finds them and uses the paralyzing gas on all of them, then using the emeralds to Chaos Control the Black comet to Earth. However, Knuckles is unaffected by the paralyzing gas due to his robotization, and so he seizes the chaos emeralds and uses them to transform into Mecha Hyper Knuckles. Mecha Hyper Knuckles then fights Devil Doom and defeats him the same way Shadow did. He then flies down to the surface and attempts to mimic Black Doom's Chaos Control to teleport the Black Comet into space. It isn't perfect, but he manages to succeed and teleports it in front of the Ark, where the Chaotix (who were still hired by their mysterious benefactor) destroy it with the Eclispe cannon. But that still leaves the question of who built the Shadow Androids. Pre-Sonic Battle: I'm gonna say it right here, the one who sent out the new Shadow Androids is Dr Starline. (Hey, IDW IS canon) He's apparently been an Eggman (or Robotnik in this timeline) fanboy since he started his conquest, so once he learns of Robotnik's death at the hands of Mecha-Shadow, he vows to avenge him and destroy Robotnik's enemies once and for all. So, he manages to track down the remains of Robotnik's death egg facility on Angel Island, leaving with all of Robotnik's remaining work before Knuckles could notice he was there. He then transferred the remenents of Robotnik's technology to another base and created the Neo Eggman Empire in secret, finishing Robotnik's work on the Shadow Androids. However, he still remains in the shadows. Sonic Battle: Using Gerald Robotnik's journals that his grandson was holding onto, Starline manages to find Emerl. When he attempts to activate him, he is still unable to find a way to get him to obey him, but unlike Eggman in canon, he doesn't throw Emerl in the sea. Instead he shuts him down and begins working on a way to make Emerl obey him. He ultimately manages to find the answer by modifying Emerl into Gemerl, basically meaning that we skip Battle. Sonic Advance 3: This game starts the same, with Starline splitting the Earth into 7 pockets of reality with the Chaos emeralds, forcing Tails, Knuckles and Cream into action. However, Starline has also rebuilt the unused Mecha-Sonic mark 3 and upgraded him immensely. So, when Tails fights Gemerl on Route 99, he barely manages to escape with his life. Similarly, when Knuckles fights Mecha-Sonic Mark 3, he is defeated but manages to escape as well. It becomes a cat and mouse game between the 2 sides to try to get the emeralds, which eventually culminates in a final battle at the Master Emerald's altar like in canon. Out of desperation, Knuckles and Tails use the master emerald to turn into their hyper and super forms respectively. They manage to overpower the villians, but Starline manages to escape with both his machines. I'll save 06 onwards for another time.
@@TheRealMightyEmperor Not Archie but I am a fan of the IDW comics. Ok, here we go: Sonic 06: Starline learns of the Flames of Disaster at the same time as Eggman in canon, but decides to hire the Babylon Rogues to kidnap Elise for him, promising to pay them handsomely for their services. The Babylon Rogues agree, and manage to kidnap Elise without a hitch since there's no Sonic attending the sun festival to save her. Upon learning of this from the news, Tails decides to do what Sonic would do and goes to save Elise. He manages to track her down and rescues her from Starline's base in Dusty Desert, managing to defeat Mecha-Sonic Mark III using his super form (as he still had the chaos emeralds from advance 3) and takes Elise back to Soleanna. However, he is then ambushed by Silver, whose story had gone pretty much the same until this point. (In this timeline, the Duke of Soleanna is the one who sealed Mephiles away, so he doesn't look like Shadow. Silver also believes Tails to be the Iblis trigger.) Silver attacks Tails, who at this point has reverted to base form, but since Tails has been training fairly hard since Advance 3, he is able to match Silver in combat. However, Gemerl soon arrives and snatches Elise, distracting Tails long enough for Silver to get the upper hand. However, as the Silver hedgehog is about to finish Tails off, he is stopped by Amy. Amy had still helped Silver find who he was looking for, but refuses to allow him to kill a child. Silver tries to argue with her, but ultimately leaves, beginning to doubt his mission. As for what would have been Team Dark's story, Rouge is still a captive of Starline, and while GUN had tried to save her, they stood no chance against Gemerl and Mecha-Sonic. So, Mephiles had ordered Silver and Blaze to find the Scepter of Darkness and release him before going after the Iblis Trigger, which they did. From there, Starline sends Tails the same note that Eggman did in canon telling him to come to White Acropolis. Suspecting this to be a trap, Tails gets Cream and Knuckles to come with him. However, Starline was much more calculating than his idol, and knew that Tails would suspect something. So, once team hero arrives at White Acropolis, he sends the Shadow Androids after them alongside Gemerl and Mecha-Sonic Mark III. The 3 are overwhelmed and the chaos emeralds are taken before Tails could go super. Team hero is then dragged to the time travel room and sent to Silver's future, Starline keeping the chaos emeralds for himself. And this is where everything starts to unravel. With Shadow dead, Silver never goes to the past and never learns the truth about Mephiles, and team hero has no way back to the present. Starline would then begin torturing Elise to try to get the Flames of Disaster out of her, eventually causing her to cry and releasing Iblis. Sensing the arrival of Iblis, Mephiles travels to White Acropolis and kills Starline before using the Chaos Emeralds to merge with Iblis, becoming Solaris and causing the time space rift. Luckily, all those involved in the events are transported to the same area, those being Team Hero, Amy, Silver and Blaze. While Knuckles wants to charge in and fight Solaris head on, due to being more used to having the fate of the world on his shoulders, Tails reccomends they gather the Chaos Emeralds before doing anything rash. They do so, and Tails, Knuckles and Silver all transform into their super forms. Unfortunately, there is no Eggman to inform them all on the true nature of Solaris, so the Super heroes all try to fight him in the present. The battle lasts for hours, but ultimately, Solaris cannot be beaten in only the present, and he ultimately triumphs. All of time and space are eradicated, and our story ends here. Sorry for the downer ending, but this really goes to show the importance of Sonic's friends, as without the majority of them (especially Shadow), the entire universe would have been doomed.
@@TheRealMightyEmperorso that probably why what if sonic lost his memory won’t go all the way up to frontier’s because it would be very difficult to know what would happen
Ok, I feel you really undersold Super Sonic's power. He was capable of hurting and taking hits from not 1, but 2 beings that were literally destroying time and space itself. (Solaris and the Time Eater) He should be able to tank a blast from a beam that only took out half the moon. Maybe if you specified that the eclipse cannon was stronger than in canon thanks to the master emerald, it would make more sense.
@@TheRealMightyEmperor I'm pretty sure that Knuckles was using the power of the master emerald to dull the emeralds from there. Also, Sonic was caught off guard.
Well, if you liked this more grounded approach I recommend checking out my what if Sonic Frontiers had a Tournament or What if Sonic Died. Both are written like this.
So Robot Knuckles just imagine kind of like Cassia the Pronghorn did the Cassia she was ill if you learn Cassia and Clove this from Archie Sonic universe. The Eggman lying Clove and Cassia after join Eggman empire this so sad story. 😔 Man I wish Clove and Cassia join G.U.N. or join freedom fighter if she had join freedom fighter the uncle Chuck he will help Cassia to get rid of them a ill the Uncle Chuck is he the best doctor he is True man of right. I wonder will Sonic & Clove going to happen after Sally and Sonic broke up ?
Geez Sonic Heroes probably won’t happen because things would being different No Team Rose No Team Sonic No Team Dark Since Rouge didn’t Appear and shadow didn’t Die
@@TheRealMightyEmperor Team Chaotix Heroes Team Chaotixs Team Eggman (Eggman and Shadow) Team Echidna (Knuckles and Tikal) Team Sonic (Sonic and Tails The Villain: Metal Sonic
The Master Emerald is the strongest thing to ever exist . So if it powered the Eclipse cannon then we would get a weapon that can be used to conquer dimensions .
@@PeterOkoye-dc2sc In Sonic 3&K the reason Knuckles was able to knock out Sonic out of his Super Form is because Sonic didn't have his guard up . The second reason is because Knuckles is the guardian of Master Emerald which grants him his own chaos abilties , Sonic and Shadow when they have any amount of Chaos Emeralds were shown to do offensive chaos powers , so we can say Knuckles has defensive chaos powers from the Master Emerald . When Knuckles heard Robotnik's side of the story about the events of Sonic 2 he most likely absorbed some power of the Master Emerald and when he ambushed Sonic he used that energy to fully extract the Chaos Emeralds out of him by manipulating Chaos Energy .
I love how you ain't doing the same story and events with the more serious Sonic. Putting your own twists on things makes the stories really stands out.
Thanks, this is how all my What If's are written
I like that since this is a more serious universe, Dr. Robotnik never got his name changed to Eggman as sonic never really kept mocking him here
I think in pt2, he does call him Eggman, before Robotnik reveals Chaos to him
Nahhh, this dtory is heat man, im liking that Tails is getting that mc attention in this part
An unexpected turn
Shadow just woke up to get his ass kicked 💀
Imagine the last thing you remember was Maria getting shot, then some kid beats you up at home
Well, Sonic will be disappointed but proud of what Tails has done in his stead.
Shadow just woke up and gets his butt whoopes by a Fox Kid who is 8 to 11 years old, how embarrassing. XD
Poor Knuckles tho, at least he has some company.
Knuckles just can't catch a break in these
Idc if it becomes less and less like the game. The whole point of reading, watching, or writing AU fanfictions is to tell a different story with those characters. That's what makes the story stands out.
I agree.
Also, stand out is grammatically correct. English is weird.
Not gonna lie. I thought Sonic had going to get amnesia when he hit the ground.
Lol, been there done that
Oh man can't wait for part 4 and what happens with shadow
Let's go a new episode of what if.
Am going to enjoy this 🥳
please keep this story going
I hate cliffhangers.
So, in this timeline, Sonic gets the Shadow treatment and Shadow remains a villain. I do like what happened with Knuckles and Tikal, I think this would be the end of their storyline since I don't see why Knuckles would want to get involved willingly with the Sonic-Eggman cycle again.
Hope you continue this series since this is like the only good sonic what if out so far (that I've seen)
I do have other and longer what if's that follow my writing style already out
@@TheRealMightyEmperor Oh yeahhhh. I've already seen the Frontiers and What if Sonic died series, both are really good. Will you ever continue the Dead Sonic scenerio or do you have other stuff planned? Loved where you were going with that one.
I enjoyed the story, I definitely would like to see more content of the theory; But so far, I think it's a proper time to conclude it, Of course, An epilogue would be needed but for now, The story was very thrilling and probably one of the best theories I've seen thanks to it's narrative and how original the story was, Nice video.
Thank you very much
please continue this series
I would love to see more of this & see how Sonic Heroes goes & see the return of metal Sonic
It's already set up for sonic to be the one with amnesia during the events of heroes...
just like with shadow when he fell during the original SA2
This new Episode came at the perfect time since during that time My little brother graduated from high school and just finished his big game on Sunday. So this is a nice treat as well As excited to see the different decisions, that character is what makes now that's the Optimism and Free spirit Nonshalantness has been toned down By the growing psychological weight of responsibility and hard choices.
Aw that is great to hear! I hope you both enjoyed it.
@@TheRealMightyEmperor : We did ,Thank You! I have three ideas that you can choose from after you've done with this:
#1. What if the Freedom Fighters of Alice Acorn was part of the game timeline and and teamed up with Sonic all the way to Sonic Forces?
#2. What if the Soul Dimension and Mobius merged and stabilized ( This would have long term Consequences to many characters, The environments, & The timeline itself including other villains like Mephyllis, Dark Giya, Chaos, The Nocturnis Clan, Eggman Nega, Dr.Starline, & The End?
#3. What if Zeena Stumbled by a warp ring and was in Sonic Mania 🤔
PLEASE MORE!! MORE MORE MORE!!!
6:11 who made that drawing?
Also I like this. Maybe consider getting VAs to do their lines. (I could try helping you, I never tried Amy's voice, but I could try Tikal or any other female. Tails is originally VA'd by a female so I could try that too but I ain't that good)
Thanks for enjoying! Please see my other what ifs for more of my style. As for Voice Acting, I cannot afford to pay other people, so I have to work with what I got.
And the image was on google.
@@TheRealMightyEmperor There are people out there who do it for free, LIKE ME, even though I'm no pro
An awesome conclusion to a very fun What if! Funnily enough, even though this series is completely different and unrelated to "What if Sonic died" , in some strange head cannon sort of way one could see this series as a prequel to that. It wouldn't make any sense, but hey just a random thought.
In that instance I doubt Shadow would step up to save the world
Ok but how does shadow get his character arc against round two with Chaos?
Not sure he can look at himself after loosing to Tails...
Great vid. What if shadow was released early could be a interesting story.
Yeah, although I think many others have done that one
@@TheRealMightyEmperor true but by looking at your what if sonic died series you can take a what if people have done before and spice it up.
I think this was a great and very creative video keep up the good work ❤
Thank you! Will do!
Beautifully done. I loved it
Thank you.
And with Shadow's butt kicked!
really good story
Thank you
what happened to shadow
Still on the ark
will you see the other comments I write about amy
I hope you will one day make a story about her being both a bad girl and a serious anti hero too
beacase I saw one the sonic fans write a story about she become a anti hero after death of sonic
also can you please in your story give her a double headed axe instead of hammer beacase I saw some of the fans give that to her
Poor Knuckles
Can't wait for Sonic Heroes to happen in this timeline.
I wonder if Eggman will still make Neo Metal, since Metal wasn't ever created in CD because of Sonic's time travel mischief.
From memory, Eggman never made Neo. Metal programmed that upgrade on his own which is how he surprised Eggman.
@@TheRealMightyEmperor Huh, I never knew that!
Thanks for telling me.
Robotnik is like senator armstrong from metal gear rising in this
Haha, I can see it
Here's how I would continue this scenario. I'll say for the sake of this story that Sonic ultimately dies from his wounds, leaving Tails to become the world's new main hero. Knuckles is also a backup. So, let's get to it:
Sonic Advance 1: Pretty much the same except for the fact that Tails is the only one on the adventure. When he reaches the second to last zone, he has to fight Shadow.
Luckily, Tails had gathered all the chaos emeralds, so he transforms into his super form and defeats Shadow. However, he doesn’t kill him because that's not the kind of person he is. After knocking Shadow unconcious, he defeats Robotnik the same as Sonic did in canon.
Sonic Advance 2: Tails once again takes Sonic's place, keeping the chaos emeralds by him at all times to keep them away from Robotnik and Shadow. However, Robotnik doesn’t try to capture Knuckles, knowing of the power of the Master emerald locked inside him, so he instead carries on as normal.
When Tails saves Cream and Cheese and Cream asks to come with him, Tails is initially reluctant but sees a lot of himself in her, so he agrees to let her come with him as long as she didn’t get herself hurt.
The 2 eventually encounter Shadow once again, who is once again defeated by Super Tails, much to his frustration. Afterwards, Tails and Cream defeat Robotnik and save Vanilla like Sonic did in canon, and afterwards Tails agrees to let Cream become his unofficial sidekick.
Afterwards, Shadow is left frustrated by their continual failures, but Robotnik tells him that these last 2 attacks had been for the purpose of collecting data on Tails, and tells him that he will now turn him into a machine like him and Knuckles, and he will have free will.
Robotnik still believes Shadow to be firmly on his side, and Shadow agrees. However, once the modifications are complete, Mecha Shadow declares that he has no further use for Robotnik, killing him and oblitarating the remains of the death egg still on Angel Island, which is where the surgery took place.
Sonic Heroes: Planning to gather all of the Chaos emeralds in one spot, Mecha Shadow, who has all the same powers as Neo Metal so is currently posing as Robotnik, recruits Fang the Sniper (who never met the other Hooligans due to Sonic the Fighters never happening) and recruits Chaos as himself, planning to betray him once he got the emeralds.
He then sends a note as Robotnik to Tails, telling him that he would destroy the world in 3 days and challenging him to stop him. Seeing this, Tails tells Cream and Knuckles about Robotnik's threat, and they agree to help him, although Knuckles has to be convinced by Tikal.
This is one of the only teams in the game since Team Dark was never formed for obvious reasons, and Amy and Big never became part of the cast.
Also, with Robotnik already dead, the Chaotix are never hired by him. The only other team is the alternate Team Hooligan, consisting of Fang, Chaos, and Omega, who won't betray Shadow.
The 2 teams fight over the emeralds constantly, with Chaos absorbing every one his team got. Eventually the 2 teams converge at the Final Fortress, and Mecha Shadow steals team hero's emeralds from them.
He tries to do the same to Chaos, but the water monster fights back and absorbs the emeralds Shadow was holding, transforming into Perfect Chaos once again.
Shadow transforms into a version of the metal overlord to fight him, and team hero all proceed to use the positive power of the emeralds to transform into their super forms.
Fang flees from the Final Fortress on the Marvelous Queen as the 2 factions fight, and the battle ends with Shadow being defeated and Chaos's anger finally being quelled as he ascends to the afterlife with Tikal.
Afterwards, Shadow is left on the ground defeated. Omega attempts to sneak attack the heroes, but Knuckles then destroys both him and Shadow, putting an end to the threat.
A very interesting way to take it. By heroes in your version the world is safe. Thank you for sharing.
@@TheRealMightyEmperor Thanks, but we still have the Black Arms to deal with.
Here goes:
Shadow the Hedgehog: In this timeline since Shadow's dead, when Black Doom finds out he gets enraged that the Earthlings broke their promise and orders the Black Arms to lay waste to the world and find the chaos emeralds, which were scattered after Mecha Shadow and Perfect Chaos's defeats.
With only Knuckles, Tails and Cream to defend Earth and the Black Arms being far more aggressive than in canon, there are many more casualties than in canon. However, GUN is still fighting the Black Arms as well, and eventually contact team hero for a meeting.
The 3 heroes agree and meet up with Abraham Tower (The GUN commander from Shadow the Hedgehog) who explains what he and GUN know of the Black Arms, including their involvement in Shadow's creation.
They conclude that they have to get to the Eclipse Cannon to stop the Black Arms, but they also need the Chaos Emeralds. So, they launch a plan where Knuckles, Cream, Rouge (who's making her debut here) and Commander Tower piloting Diabalon distract the Black Arms and Black Doom while Tails gets the Chaos Emeralds from Black Doom.
The plan goes into action, but when they arrive their shocked to find what looks like multiple Shadows fighting the Black Arms. Questioning how this is possible, the heroes decide screw it and begin fighting alongside the Shadows.
As they do so, Tails manages to sneak up on Black Doom and knocks him down using some sort of device, managing to take the emeralds he had stolen and then retreating with the rest of Team Hero and GUN.
They all then storm the Black Comet, but Black Doom finds them and uses the paralyzing gas on all of them, then using the emeralds to Chaos Control the Black comet to Earth.
However, Knuckles is unaffected by the paralyzing gas due to his robotization, and so he seizes the chaos emeralds and uses them to transform into Mecha Hyper Knuckles. Mecha Hyper Knuckles then fights Devil Doom and defeats him the same way Shadow did.
He then flies down to the surface and attempts to mimic Black Doom's Chaos Control to teleport the Black Comet into space. It isn't perfect, but he manages to succeed and teleports it in front of the Ark, where the Chaotix (who were still hired by their mysterious benefactor) destroy it with the Eclispe cannon.
But that still leaves the question of who built the Shadow Androids.
Pre-Sonic Battle: I'm gonna say it right here, the one who sent out the new Shadow Androids is Dr Starline. (Hey, IDW IS canon) He's apparently been an Eggman (or Robotnik in this timeline) fanboy since he started his conquest, so once he learns of Robotnik's death at the hands of Mecha-Shadow, he vows to avenge him and destroy Robotnik's enemies once and for all.
So, he manages to track down the remains of Robotnik's death egg facility on Angel Island, leaving with all of Robotnik's remaining work before Knuckles could notice he was there.
He then transferred the remenents of Robotnik's technology to another base and created the Neo Eggman Empire in secret, finishing Robotnik's work on the Shadow Androids. However, he still remains in the shadows.
Sonic Battle: Using Gerald Robotnik's journals that his grandson was holding onto, Starline manages to find Emerl. When he attempts to activate him, he is still unable to find a way to get him to obey him, but unlike Eggman in canon, he doesn't throw Emerl in the sea.
Instead he shuts him down and begins working on a way to make Emerl obey him. He ultimately manages to find the answer by modifying Emerl into Gemerl, basically meaning that we skip Battle.
Sonic Advance 3: This game starts the same, with Starline splitting the Earth into 7 pockets of reality with the Chaos emeralds, forcing Tails, Knuckles and Cream into action. However, Starline has also rebuilt the unused Mecha-Sonic mark 3 and upgraded him immensely.
So, when Tails fights Gemerl on Route 99, he barely manages to escape with his life. Similarly, when Knuckles fights Mecha-Sonic Mark 3, he is defeated but manages to escape as well.
It becomes a cat and mouse game between the 2 sides to try to get the emeralds, which eventually culminates in a final battle at the Master Emerald's altar like in canon.
Out of desperation, Knuckles and Tails use the master emerald to turn into their hyper and super forms respectively. They manage to overpower the villians, but Starline manages to escape with both his machines.
I'll save 06 onwards for another time.
@@theultimatememelord5494 A fun story so far! I can see you are a fan of both Archie and IDW.
@@TheRealMightyEmperor Not Archie but I am a fan of the IDW comics.
Ok, here we go:
Sonic 06: Starline learns of the Flames of Disaster at the same time as Eggman in canon, but decides to hire the Babylon Rogues to kidnap Elise for him, promising to pay them handsomely for their services.
The Babylon Rogues agree, and manage to kidnap Elise without a hitch since there's no Sonic attending the sun festival to save her.
Upon learning of this from the news, Tails decides to do what Sonic would do and goes to save Elise. He manages to track her down and rescues her from Starline's base in Dusty Desert, managing to defeat Mecha-Sonic Mark III using his super form (as he still had the chaos emeralds from advance 3) and takes Elise back to Soleanna.
However, he is then ambushed by Silver, whose story had gone pretty much the same until this point. (In this timeline, the Duke of Soleanna is the one who sealed Mephiles away, so he doesn't look like Shadow. Silver also believes Tails to be the Iblis trigger.)
Silver attacks Tails, who at this point has reverted to base form, but since Tails has been training fairly hard since Advance 3, he is able to match Silver in combat.
However, Gemerl soon arrives and snatches Elise, distracting Tails long enough for Silver to get the upper hand. However, as the Silver hedgehog is about to finish Tails off, he is stopped by Amy.
Amy had still helped Silver find who he was looking for, but refuses to allow him to kill a child. Silver tries to argue with her, but ultimately leaves, beginning to doubt his mission.
As for what would have been Team Dark's story, Rouge is still a captive of Starline, and while GUN had tried to save her, they stood no chance against Gemerl and Mecha-Sonic.
So, Mephiles had ordered Silver and Blaze to find the Scepter of Darkness and release him before going after the Iblis Trigger, which they did.
From there, Starline sends Tails the same note that Eggman did in canon telling him to come to White Acropolis. Suspecting this to be a trap, Tails gets Cream and Knuckles to come with him.
However, Starline was much more calculating than his idol, and knew that Tails would suspect something. So, once team hero arrives at White Acropolis, he sends the Shadow Androids after them alongside Gemerl and Mecha-Sonic Mark III.
The 3 are overwhelmed and the chaos emeralds are taken before Tails could go super. Team hero is then dragged to the time travel room and sent to Silver's future, Starline keeping the chaos emeralds for himself.
And this is where everything starts to unravel. With Shadow dead, Silver never goes to the past and never learns the truth about Mephiles, and team hero has no way back to the present. Starline would then begin torturing Elise to try to get the Flames of Disaster out of her, eventually causing her to cry and releasing Iblis.
Sensing the arrival of Iblis, Mephiles travels to White Acropolis and kills Starline before using the Chaos Emeralds to merge with Iblis, becoming Solaris and causing the time space rift.
Luckily, all those involved in the events are transported to the same area, those being Team Hero, Amy, Silver and Blaze. While Knuckles wants to charge in and fight Solaris head on, due to being more used to having the fate of the world on his shoulders, Tails reccomends they gather the Chaos Emeralds before doing anything rash.
They do so, and Tails, Knuckles and Silver all transform into their super forms. Unfortunately, there is no Eggman to inform them all on the true nature of Solaris, so the Super heroes all try to fight him in the present.
The battle lasts for hours, but ultimately, Solaris cannot be beaten in only the present, and he ultimately triumphs. All of time and space are eradicated, and our story ends here.
Sorry for the downer ending, but this really goes to show the importance of Sonic's friends, as without the majority of them (especially Shadow), the entire universe would have been doomed.
Looks like are fox standing on all business
Please do not end it and instead continue it i would love to see more of it plus you can't just end it like this
It is a fitting ending, for now at least.
@@TheRealMightyEmperor So you are going to continue it at some point
@@alexanderwoodcock9477 If it still sounds good
@@TheRealMightyEmperor it sounds fantastic
Shadow would've punched the emeralds out of Tails in 1, 2, 3
hopefully enough people will want to see this continue all the way past Frontiers.
If it did go for that long, I doubt Frontiers would even happen. Events would have changed so much.
@@TheRealMightyEmperormaybe he'd activate the starfall protocol just the forcibly rip the emeralds off of sonic
@@TheRealMightyEmperorso that probably why what if sonic lost his memory won’t go all the way up to frontier’s because it would be very difficult to know what would happen
I want Sonic to be "sleeping beauty" for a while. lol
Rest in peace???
@@TheRealMightyEmperor 😂
Are you still gonna continue your “what if sonic died?” Story? Really love that one and am hyped for the next episode❤
The main issue is the production for that series has become so insanely high for one person
Alternate title: what if power scalers wrote the series?
Not actually a power scaler
it was just a joke about how sonic is working at Peke efficiency instead of being limited by the plot
What if Sonic was in the DC Universe
This was great
But what happened to shadow after words?
Shadow is on the Ark, not dead
"WITH PLEASER" !!! tu es entrain de construire un nouveau sénario vraiment incroyable mais je me demande comment tu vas faire pour la suite
Thank you, time will tell
@@TheRealMightyEmperor ou si tu feras un " si Browser était sérieux " ( il est staté comme ayant un IQ de 3000)
@@vavadadeur150 Bowser is as smart as a Goomba
Algorithm fuel ⛽
I can put an end to this, not a bad story.
Ok, I feel you really undersold Super Sonic's power. He was capable of hurting and taking hits from not 1, but 2 beings that were literally destroying time and space itself. (Solaris and the Time Eater) He should be able to tank a blast from a beam that only took out half the moon. Maybe if you specified that the eclipse cannon was stronger than in canon thanks to the master emerald, it would make more sense.
Knuckles one hit super sonic
@@TheRealMightyEmperor I'm pretty sure that Knuckles was using the power of the master emerald to dull the emeralds from there. Also, Sonic was caught off guard.
@theultimatememelord5494 And here Sonic got shot by the Master Emerald and I doubt he expected the laser
@@TheRealMightyEmperor Noted.
What a cliffhanger, man: you are definitely not pulling your punches, and I can appreciate it.
Do you plan to introduce Blaze at any point?
If it gets to rush's point on the timeline, the merger would still happen
@@TheRealMightyEmperor Awesome 😎
I would like to see more of this story as its far more creative than usual what if Goku/Naruto/Izuku become most overpowered god stories.
Well, if you liked this more grounded approach I recommend checking out my what if Sonic Frontiers had a Tournament or What if Sonic Died. Both are written like this.
@@TheRealMightyEmperor Oh thanks. i'll check them out. you're quite amazing in storywriting.
Sounds like sonic written by ken penders 😂
Give us more pls
Where is what if sonic died part 14 omg I will never stop asking 😤😤😤😤
💀 ☠️ 💀
More
yes it's back
Are you going to continue what if sonic die
Maybe one day. That series is a lot of work.
No Rouge? 😢
Zero time for Rouge to get involved, Eggman went from freeing Shadow to firing the Eclipse Canon
Is it okay if I can make fanart of this au
By all means, go ahead!
You could have made Shadow an free-spirited annoying optimist, just for the lols
True
Is that metal robotnik art your own? Or is it from Archie?
I wish I could draw that good
Sonic x Shadow Generations video?
What would it say that's worth being a video? Besides, my viewer base has made it very clear if I am not uploading a What If they don't want to see it
@@TheRealMightyEmperorWell, can you say what you think of it here? Cause I love those videos of yours the most and it’s got Kingdom Freaking Valley!
@bunsmasterbunny Now that I have seen more of the game I think I will make a video
So Robot Knuckles just imagine kind of like Cassia the Pronghorn did the Cassia she was ill if you learn Cassia and Clove this from Archie Sonic universe. The Eggman lying Clove and Cassia after join Eggman empire this so sad story. 😔 Man I wish Clove and Cassia join G.U.N. or join freedom fighter if she had join freedom fighter the uncle Chuck he will help Cassia to get rid of them a ill the Uncle Chuck is he the best doctor he is True man of right. I wonder will Sonic & Clove going to happen after Sally and Sonic broke up ?
Geez Sonic Heroes probably won’t happen because things would being different
No Team Rose
No Team Sonic
No Team Dark Since Rouge didn’t Appear and shadow didn’t Die
Team Chaotix solo game lets go!!!!
@@TheRealMightyEmperor Team Chaotix Heroes
Team Chaotixs
Team Eggman (Eggman and Shadow)
Team Echidna (Knuckles and Tikal)
Team Sonic (Sonic and Tails
The Villain: Metal Sonic
Sonic millenium
Supersonic Could easily taken that he can fight gods
The Master Emerald is the strongest thing to ever exist .
So if it powered the Eclipse cannon then we would get a weapon that can be used to conquer dimensions .
@@Vrabsher_-Supreme_Perhinther- I will talk about the cannon So sonic could easily Took that with no damage Especially in his super form
@@PeterOkoye-dc2sc In Sonic 3&K the reason Knuckles was able to knock out Sonic out of his Super Form is because Sonic didn't have his guard up .
The second reason is because Knuckles is the guardian of Master Emerald which grants him his own chaos abilties ,
Sonic and Shadow when they have any amount of Chaos Emeralds were shown to do offensive chaos powers , so we can say Knuckles has defensive chaos powers from the Master Emerald .
When Knuckles heard Robotnik's side of the story about the events of Sonic 2 he most likely absorbed some power of the
Master Emerald and when he ambushed Sonic he used that energy to fully extract the Chaos Emeralds out of him by manipulating Chaos Energy .
Sonic millenium