ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 พ.ย. 2024
- Saudi Arabia has restricted the volume of loudspeakers at mosque.
The move has been met with both applause & resentment. But what led to this decision?
#Gravitas #SaudiArabia #WION
About Channel:
WION -The World is One News, examines global issues with in-depth analysis. We provide much more than the news of the day. Our aim to empower people to explore their world. With our Global headquarters in New Delhi, we bring you news on the hour, by the hour. We deliver information that is not biased. We are journalists who are neutral to the core and non-partisan when it comes to the politics of the world. People are tired of biased reportage and we stand for a globalised united world. So for us the World is truly One.
Please keep discussions on this channel clean and respectful and refrain from using racist or sexist slurs as well as personal insults.
Subscribe to our channel at goo.gl/JfY3NI
Check out our website: www.wionews.com
Connect with us on our social media handles:
Facebook: / wionews
Twitter: / wionews
Follow us on Google News for latest updates
Zee News:- bit.ly/2Ac5G60
Zee Bussiness:- bit.ly/36vI2xa
DNA India:- bit.ly/2ZDuLRY
WION: bit.ly/3gnDb5J
Zee News Apps : bit.ly/ZeeNews...
![ละลาย (LALALYE) - DAOU PITTAYA ต้าห์อู๋ พิทยา [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wo6r9TgausI/mqdefault.jpg)
The originals are always progressive. The rip offs never improve.
Converts would be more appropriate.
God, why is this so true. There are reasons for this, but nevertheless true
In Arab World Arab Muslims are not secular Islam instead they follow Conservative Wahabism-based Islam but they are the creators of Islamist fundamentals that nurtured Turkey, India, and Pakistan to make them conservative rather than pure liberal Islamic practice and belief. India, Pakistan, and Turkey are students of Arab Wahabist teachers in Western Asia.
@@akifalislam but they have the potential to change, cause they don't have to prove anything to anyone, they are indeed what they are ......same freedom, not everyone has
absolutely... so well said
In Singapore, loudspeakers at the mosque was completely banned. The Muslim community was awarded 2 frequencies on the radio that cannot be used for anything except the call to prayer. If you want to hear the call to prayer, set your radio and leave it on. It only makes a sound when the call to prayer comes on and then goes quite again. If you don't want to hear it, don't set your radio.
Wow!! This is really innovative!!
Good plan
this is genius
Super thought!!
Not only radio frequencies can be used, in North America, we receive Amber Alert on our cellphones when a child is abducted. The same can be used to announce Islamic calls for prayers. When I was in Malaysia on a business trip, I got waken up at 3:00 a.m. by a mosque loudspeaker near my company's sleeping quarters playing Islamic music/sermon! I went, "Are you serious, waking up all the residents at 3 a.m.? Do people even have to work during the day in Malaysia if you get awaken at wee hours every night?"
Here in India Sonu Nigan first put forth this opinion. He was Threatened.
Judged is a very weak word. The word you are looking for is death threats my man.
@@shaieqkhan3685 Abe to tum log unko batate kyo nahi ,kyo unke khilaf fatwa nikalte ,kyo protest nahi karte aise logo k khilaf ,unko batao na ki ye Islam nahi h ,yaha ake bhalai mat loot ,kitni ko thread doge tum log ,ek din pani Sur k uper se nikal jayega
JAI SHRI RAM
@AK Petition won't do, a Civil War should break and these Jihadi people should be killed!
Of course converted shanti doots obeys only their shaikh abbu jaan
Similar law must be enacted in India to restrict volume of loudspeakers to the premises in churches, mosques, temples and marriage functions.
Best ever thought.. sir
I think best way is that there should be a loudspeaker but not multiple at a single place you should hear only one i mean in such a way
Yes ,it should be. It is need of the hour
Your name sounds Christian and dont add fuel to fire by naming christians for loud Speakers or may be you are so ignorant to know the difference between Cabinet Speakers and Horn Speakers this is just to educate u a bit and churches use cabinet speakers for the 4 Walls only unlike the other Religions .
And near hospitals and schools
When a monarch is more secular then a democracy, irony 😂
👀 A monarch doesn’t mean democracy in fact it’s the opposite with regards to governance. Saudi Arabia (where the system of government is Absolute monarch) + and its citizens are extremely ultra conservative. There is no country in the world except KSA that has this kind of arrangement and unique alimony. Hope you learned something.
Soo true 😅😂
@@cheerbozz r/woosh
@@cheerbozz indeed it amazes me, this man need to rule Israel, Palestine and gaza, he would do wonders and bring peace in few days
Buthan ?
If we say the same we'll be called out for Islamophobia.
What an irony.
@Adi Sen like i cnt tolerate ur ringing of bells and chanting mantras 24/7🤤🤤and Playing converted bhojouri songs
@@_iamsrs you live in hindustan not pakistan 😂
@@abhishekkumar-tj8kc yes of course and u live in a democracy so dnt dream of it🤣
@Adi Senbtw we dnt ring bells..and ringing of bells is done whole day 🤣during navrat and durgapuja whole night even playing of djs
@Adi Sen kya pata konsa fayda hota ha adha se adha se kar ye poverty me rhte h
In India louder the loud speaker for mosques means India is secular. This is written in Constitution which only Congress can see
@John Hanley hoping you are not INDIAN.Your opposition party Congress does Muslim appeasement politics
@John Hanley Y is extra there I mean to say our congress
@John Hanley in first comment instead of your it should have been our.
Yup
@@jaygadhari7458 we know tht🤦🤦
This step was long overdue, especially in the mornings.
Now everyone has mobile phones with Alarm settings.
I m a Muslim myself, but i have always opposed this, because some ppl overdid it and its a nuisance.
And you call yourself muslim
@@nasarhussain7125
Ppl criticised me for supporting the restrictions on loud mosque speakers. They are asking me, if really i m a Muslim.
The answer is YES, because the conditions for being a Muslim is Shahada, and not loud speakers. OK?
Moreover, i m of the opinion that if the Holy Prophet himself had been physically alive today, he may have also done the same.
Islam is a religion that has consideration for all and everybody, including non Muslims. We have no right to disturb their sleep and rest.
If a muslim is serious about praying on time, in today's time...there are many ways of doing so, almost all have some type of alarm devices. Use those.
When you are travelling, without a call of reminder, if one can reach airport 3 hours before as reporting time, i don't see why can't do the same for prayers.
@@mpesmail1834 woow..impressive! Thanks for putting other into consideration
@@mpesmail1834 you write good. haha.
@@mpesmail1834 so agree with you. and pretty much sure prophet mohammad or followers of him in the past dont use loudspeaker
Now Swara Bhasker will tweet that Saudi Crown Prince is an Rss member
😂😂😂
😂🤣
Lol educated person. You made my day bro.
@@NikhilDr hello Mr. dick!
@@vishalkumarsingh5817 😂😂😂
Let's blame the man who invented loud speaker. When mosque was built there was no loud speaker.funny people
loud speakers wasnt made to spread bullshit
It's not the man who invented it but the ppl who are using it.
Who told u follow that man who invented it?
@@aditya_saha But it looks like TH-cam has been invented to spread bullshit..
Loud speakers are used everywhere? In homes, temples, during marriages? Muslims k piche himpar gae ho sb 😂 Like wohi use krte srf. Parties men use nhi krte ho kya? Tb ksi ko neighbours ka khyal nhi aata.
indian leftists about to call the saudi prince a modi bhakt and rss member
🤣😂
HAHAAHA
"Sanghi"
😂😂😂
We got to know that you are a rightist and andhbhakt
@@MohammedAsif-cc2no and you r andhanamazi
I think this is good. Because if someone is so devoted to his/her religion, the person doesn't need a loudspeaker to remind him/her to pray. 🙏🙏
They haven't band loudspeakers for adhan and khutbha they just have set an volume limit and all muslims are ok with that adhan shouldn't be too loud.
LOl , so true.
What about church bells
Yah... that's what we are saying...god should be in our heart and prayers..
and its not a remindingg of prayerr its alsoo a cultural thing of islam that has done from the time of starting of islam and it should be there
In India if this happens...
Congress+liberandus+media all together will be rattled 🤣🤣🤣
Nobody likes it. Not everything has to be political.
@@lalalhmar6118 yes simply portraying himself as a fool , regardless of religion and politics , loudspeakers are real nuisance . They are hated by people with sense all over the world .
They did when Sonu Nigam and others voiced against
That being said, loud speakers should be banned during all religious festivals.
Yrs as if they are first custodians of islam
When Sonu Nigam commented about Azan on loudspeaker disturbing his sleep ... The grief Muslims gave him was shocking 😢😭
He got threatening calls from our peace loving brothers.....
@@rajendranardekar1090 Rofl 😅😃😁
Yeh decision nimaz k liye hai na ki azan k liye wahan namaz padhte wakt bhi speaker ON hota hai
Allah is deaf..you have to make noise.
@@lakhibhangra4 this is not for Allah bt for people and this news is not abt azan bt prayer bcoz in Saudi speakers are on in prayer time also
I still hear Azan from 3 mosques 5 times a day here in my neighbourhood in Saudi. Sometimes, some Imams and trustees of mosques may be misusing and overusing the loudspeakers. That's why the restrictions have come to effect. This is a very sensible decision.
Yes , as a muslim I dont think this is Islamaphobic . You can still here Azan nonetheless. Since saudi has a lot of mosques i think it is wise for them to do this.
good decision.
@@rajaain888 yeah it's not.... Cos it happens I your country... But the same happens in India its non secular and subjugation right?
@@rajareddy3104 double standard 😁😀
only one decision is sensible and that is that loudspeakers are outlawed and banned from ever being erected.
they serve one purpose and that is to terrorise the community.
This especially since in our modern times everyone has the benefit of phone apps, radios and other electronic devices to prompt them within the privacy of their own homes. this is simple basic commons sense and decency.
I do not care what religion is in question.
i do not understand how this even required debate.
As someone from Turkey, I never thought that one day I’d become jealous of Saudi Arabia. Nobody would even dare talk about this in public, let alone asking the authorities to turn the volume down. If you’re vocal about this around Turkish people, I guarantee you’ll get severely beaten up. Love and respect to Saudi Arabia for making this happen.
I thought turkey is a secular country
@@adeshsingh4381 on paper, maybe yes. But in reality, most people, even the ones who’re deemed secular, are conservative af on the inside
Indian should learn from this should also include non Muslims.
46.sun and moon each has specific law and from God and they both follow rule of God (surah39,verse5)
If these happens then our courts will start lecturing about rule of law, lauda, lassun 😂
@AA YA kinda funny how these 2 you mentioned are the most hated ones in the Arab world (Egyptian here) for being traitors and fighting Islam and Muslims all around the world
@@krunalbhatt110 many courts have ordered to ban the loudspeakers already, implementation has not been done by the local governments
@@ahmedmahmoud-tw8di they are rich nations that's why you hate them
Arabic Muslim are more developed and progressive compared with converted ones in Indian subcontinent
Absolutely. We need to support the originals from the Arab world rather than the fakes from Turkey, Pakistan and India.
The others are just hypocrites.
Islam means to submit aint gat nothing to do with race or certain people its universal unlike ur caste religion
Indian Muslim are converted muslims
@@naveenkumar5501 better way to say it is indian muslims are indian and Arabs are arabs. Converts are people who change the religion they’re born in.
Soon Kerala state Assembly would pass a resolution seeking removal of King Mohammed bin Salman.
Cmon gobar u can make better jokes than this
@@prajodcp7145 no they can't thats why they keep throwing comedians in jails
@@prajodcp7145 ,jali na teri
@@prajodcp7145kerala is gone case...Leave it.
Onnu poda
As an undergraduate I used to wait till 12 am at night before I could read, just because of a church close to my residence..loud speakers should be prohibited from any religious house...
Loud speakers used inside the premises,not outside and blaring to the sky, is okey and not nuisance.
Churches don't use loudspeakers till 12 am. 😃😃
@@joycejam9198 Churches use them once a week, mosques 5X a day
@@joycejam9198 same idk which church remains open till 12 midnight except on Easter and Christmas , and they don't blast it on speaker.
But recently i have noticed that they are getting more elaborate with their festival/religious processions. Which disgusts me
As the reason we pray is to seek forgiveness and be a better person not put up a show and disturb people . religion is being misused .
@@akkafietje137 mosque less then one minute
Same thing in South Africa, Loud mosques speakers are banned.
Wow great
GIVING A EXAMPLE FROM THE MOST RACIST APARTHEID COUNTRY IS VERY LOGICAL
@jay bharat Because they want a Worldwide Caliphate.
@jay bharat why need ghanti in mandir. I live next to it. It bothers me. Fire in mandir is also a fire risk. Ban fire and bell.
@jay bharat tum hindutva ka akhand bharat bana lo. Dusta caliphate na banai. Ghazwai hind se itna phat rahi hai?
MBS: am banning loud speakers for azaan!
C0nvrtd mull las: kaphir kaphir MBS kaphir...fatwas incoming!!
😂😂😂 Phoren Minister
😂😂😂😂
Qureshi saab are you a Punjabi or Turkic descent ?
@islamirastroBangladesh not all some pakisthanis called him puppet of US and all
Hahahahaha 😂😂 kaphir
Kudos to the reformist Crown Prince
@Sabah Zarid not really he is a reformist , he is even thinking to throw out the Hadith as it promotes violence.
@Sabah Zarid he is a reformist. He knows oil money wont be around beyond 2050 hence trying to make saudi more liberal so that he can make it like uae which is an economy based on foreign investors, tourism and basically everything modern yet still connected to the religion.
@Sabah Zarid an economy cannot run on gold reserves alone 😀 you need constant flow of cash, investments, and wht not!
@Sabah Zarid any country should diversify its source of income. Look at Venezuela now which ran on Oil for many years.
Sabah Zarid deven sharma is highly educated whatsapp university Phd holder dude... no point in telling him anything... you understand right. he doesnt know currency can be hedged against the gold reserves.....
This should be done all over the world. I live near a mosque OMG, it's troubling when they turn on their loudspeakers.
@Happy GARDEN TV It's time for Phillipines to ban as other countries are doing so
@@irwan3064 it's not banned at all just lowering the volume that's all.
but i can smell the hate in your tone that's what you wanted.... sorry will never happen
@@FG-md6ls even if that’s true, people will not hate for no reason. Nobody else is using a loudspeaker at least five times a day to call the wrong people for prayers: not all of us are muslims. Early morning when people are still sleeping, noon when people are having zoom meetings, at night when people are resting/studying, and if you’re unlucky you get to hear them shouting for an hour before the call even happens, every single day.
@@undying406 in my town Queens NYC, I hear church bell every hour it doesn't disturb me at all. I'm a Muslim and when I travel to Sarajevo Bosnia I hear the azan from mosques it's a beautiful feeling. But I agree it shouldn't be to laud.
Cannot agree more.
We Indian's also facing this issue.
Government of India should also need to strict the loudspeakers.
Except the welfare of people This Modi gov needs to do all those things that target muslims.....hypocrites and morons
@@fatimahasan7710 can you point out, what are the things government did against muslims??
@@fatimahasan7710 we want govt to restrict loudspeakers in temples, churches, gurdwaras n even marraige baraats too. it is utter nuisance
@@pennadapavankumar Before I answer you that...just tell me what he did for Hindus...except the Ram Mandir... If I am not mistaken .. today that ram Mandir didn't come to save millions of people who died due to shortage of oxygen
@@fatimahasan7710 Are you blind. I think so. Do you know anything about constitution. Anything about subjects of central, state, or concurrent lists?? "Health" is the subject of state. Its not in the central list. If you have any doubt go through the constitution or else even go through std 9 civics tb of cbse. All central govt can do is provide the cash. And what did states like delhi did. Wasted it upon advertisements and he hasn't built a single oxygen plant even after the govt warned about the second wave. And simply blaming the central govt and white washing the faults of state govt without knowing a shit. Dont be a f*cking Hypocrite. And i would like to know the source from where you got "millions of people"!!!. Don't simply spit some random bullshits.
I have too agree with this, one doesn't need too praise God, at great volume to be heard. Because praise in soft voice will be heard in great volume, AMEN.
SURA31VERSE9 ALLAH HAD A HEARING PROBLEM.😂😂😂😂
God sees prayer in heart too.
@Sabah Zarid I respect your religion and beliefs, but that is a lame excuse. Why do they need to remind you to pray?
@Sabah Zarid there are so many ways to remember that
phone alarms, tv channels, even social media channels
It's a call to people to gather for congregational prayer, not a prayer itself.
from adding mahabharat to banning loudspeakers saudi arabia is doing all the right things without being radical. Good going Saudi from Nepal.
May the adhan be heard around the world
True
@@fastinious1761 u r extremist ?
@@aggressive9999 beqeause my opinion im a extremist?
@@aggressive9999 what is a extremist? Somebody who love go after huis desires and that be number 1 and the rest like God is a maybe done thing..this is good for others for his Desire.
Wullahi you, me and everyone Will die and then others Will see the truth but IT is then too late. If IT was possible then you as person will die the adhan on street 24/7 if God had gaven you to go back to the earth.
The sinners are good and who wants good is a extremist?
Setting the volume to 1/3rd is too vague. So the mosque is incentivized to upgrade it's speakers from 500W to 10,000W. Now when it runs at 1/3rd volume it is more than 3x louder than it was before.
I was thinking exactly this. They should base it on decibels heard outside the mosque.
If the country which holds the holy shrine can reduce volume of the loud speakers..,
then India which is a Hindu Majority country and many western countries, can completely ban the loud speakers...
I’m not sure if shrine is the right word though.
@@TheBengalDragon it is a shrine to the pagan moon God Hubal known today as Allah
@@stanleydouge2803 you must be grossly and horribly mistaken. Maybe it used to be a shrine of a religion that is no longer practiced, but today it is definitely not a shrine
@@TheBengalDragon lol thé pedos God is still worshiped there so it’s a shrine to Mohameds delusions
@@stanleydouge2803 God is worshiped everywhere, most recently even in space, so once again that place is maybe a holy site but not a SHRINE.
singapore has been banning mosque and church speakers long long time ago. that is why its so quiet and peaceful there.
@@hy6113 atleast no sound pollution right
@@hy6113 All of us will eventually be in a grave.
Hmmm to me religious freedom.. free to express yourself
But of course where there is high rise building people staying near or beside religious places. You must tune down the volume. Give and take.
They also bound Hindu Temple bells
While here in India, they're getting louder and louder and are being set up even in small lanes and by lanes, also in remote villages in the countryside.
Maybe they thought God not heard clearly their prayers
Boot those people out,send them to Pakistan
Shut up
If every other religion start to do it , there loud speaker will feel as whisper for them , better to regulate the noise pollution , else one day every religion will put on loud speakers then they wont hear their prayers also
It's The BEAST
All over the world must follow this policy especially India & srilanka!!
It's right decision, it has to be adopted in the entire world.
No
@@RealSaudiExplorer why?
@@RealSaudiExplorer you are in lover with loud speaker 😂
@@badlav120 lmao "lover"😂😂😂don't comment when you can't spell
Diwali: once every year. Noise pollution.
Mosque speakers, literally 5 times everyday:... no, that's absolutely fine.
Sickularism
Because we Hindus are peaceful we forgive all of our enemies.
Ganduism by peacefool religion
@@soumyadipmukherjee6627 😁
@@oscaarexports2494 it's very beautiful to listen actually
Great decision.kudyos. Even India should ban the use of loud speakers immediately
India lo ban chesthe Muslimsla pai ukku padam ani headlines ye
@@saikiranreddy4788 correct Anna
42. protection of earth by magnetosphere(surah21,verse32);(surah2,verse22)theory of van Allen belt expresses earth is protected by magnetosphere or a strong magnetic field which protects earth from all inappropriate things coming from universe and gives permission to all beneficial thing for earth.Besides, Ozonsphere helps by protecting us from ultra-violet ray.There are also stratosphere, troposphere which is also protector of earth and necessary for all living creature.
rejesh jaliwala you're such a barbarous element
@@ravireddy8985your comment just show how useless you are
Sound pollution is one of the most challenging environmental pollution nowadays. Sounds should be restricted to permissible level at all places whether religious or non-religious. And where there is no necessity of amplifying sound, that should be totally banned. Science says about sound pollution and if you want to make a scientific society then you should keep religion confined in your personal zone or you should be an atheist.
Loudspeakers do not cause disturbance, really, ask those, whose house is near any Mosque. So irritating.
Me apne tamaam bharti sanatani bhai ko ye kehta ho key murti puja chhodo aur ek ishwar ke puja karey.
Jis trah Indonesia Malaysia maldives key sanatani bhaio ne murti puja ko reject kiya aur islam apnaya.
So that hamari matrbhoomi Bharat mai bhi peace aajae jis trah Indonesia Malaysia maldives mey peace hey.
Indonesia Malaysia maldives ke sanatanio nai islam apna liya tha
Jab unlogo nai islam ko padha..
Indonesia Malaysia maldives mai koi islamic akraman bhi nhi Hua tha.
Aur ek baat me ne suna he.
Indonesia ke school mai history ke kuch lesson mahabhart ke hai.
Lekin woh sirf aur sirf ek Allah kee puja krtey he.
And prophet Mohammed saab ko aakhri ishwardoot maan te he.
Ham bhi muslim reh saktai he aur mahabhart ko (as a history) padh saktey he.
Lekin is waqt ishwar kaa sirf ek dharm Sahi hey aur woh hey islam.
Jab mobile ka version purana hojata he aur mobile me kadbad hojati he tu insaan new mobile kharidta he.
Usi trah jab logo ne ishwar ke sab se purane dharm (may be sanatan dharm) ko manipulate kr diya .
Sanatan dharm ke scripture ko change kr diya tu.
Ishwar ne islam bheja jo iss waqt ishwar ka satya dharm he.
"WORSHIP ONLY CREATOR, NOT CREATION"
"Bhakti sirf Allah kee"
..
I have 5 mosks near to my house and all 5 doing the Adzan very loud while only one with a lower volume can do easy this...
@@Between_The_Line_ Ja n literally agar koi Muslim Aadmi kisi young ladke ko bole ki islam khatre mai he wo terrorists ban jayega lol Lula
@@flyingdutchman9729
Bro Do u know the actual meaning of complete azaan
Also ask those whose houses are near mandirs....
Sonu Nigam will be the happiest man today..😂😂
I hope Sonu Nigam sings a song after so many years
But he had complaint with azan which will still be played I wonder how he was ok with it during his luxurious stay in dubai
@@Raishah28
He stayed in a Five star hotel and was adequately sound proofed😎
Ok of cozy
Time to ban loud speaker in religious centers in India, regardless of any religion.
I totally agree with you
It should be allowed occasionally
Yes
Interior speaker is needed for any religion. But Islam puts their speakers outside. It's a nuisance for other people.
Poda,,patti
The problem in India is that these loudspeakers are being misused ( more than the azzan ) at odd times to announce loudly to their community to assemble at one particular venue to create trouble also they loudly preach hatread misusing the loudspeakers
Azan itself is offensive. Seems u are not aware of the meaning of the azan ?
@@prajkta123 meaning?
Hate preaching and religion mocking in sermons,meetings ... should be ban in Indian mosques to preserve peace and security
Cry loudly..
@@prajkta123 Can you please give the translation here.. Foolish Sanghi
Saudi Arabia will turn out to be stellar Economic Giant in the Middle East, A Big salute to MBS....... This guy has Balls of Steel
And oils
guys we need this here even , its okay on some festivals but everyday its not okay
Exactly
Then stop early Bhajan loud speaker also why they play so loud I think you need to clean your ears.
you have no guts to ask modi any question but hate only thing you can do what a shame targeting only one religion is this hinduium i don't think so all hate in hindus.
@@sims9226 hindus dont use loudspeakers everyday, so stop your moronic appeasement and justification
@@sims9226 Hindus temple don't use it too loud 5 times a day 365 days
Your constitutional rights are valid only till you don't harm the constitutional right of other people around you
Even real Muslims turn to be more civillzed.
But converted ones in Paxstan & India creating more trouble & havoc. Lol 😝😁👌
True
@@aakhilmajid2465 so u agree that Hinduism every where
@@aakhilmajid2465 What he wants to say is... you are following the religion they invented.
@@lifearoundwesternghats its not hinduism but sanatan dharm everywhere but MOHAMMAD has to rule so he made himself as a prophet
indonesia is much freer than saudi
In Indonesia, mosque loudspeakers compete with each other to be the loudest. we can't even hear the person next to us talking and it lasts more than half an hour because of the time difference
The first original muslim country becoming one of the most secular muslim one. 😅
they ceased being muslims long ago anyway
@@matsikorashid8295 no
Can you plz provide evidence that Saudi is the first original Muslim country ? Saudi didn't existed as a country so how it can be first original Muslim country ? Half knowledge is very dangerous dude.
@@suryanag4336 do you follow up the things they do?? do you think a true muslim does that??
@@matsikorashid8295 the point all muslim are true but the point to reduce mosque loudspeaker
In india must be banned loudspeaker on mosques..in my city there are more than 15 mosques in 500 m square makes too much noise ... unfortunately no one goes against it fearing....
@Abh Sriv dear bhajans not makes such noise ..in my city no temples sounds cones from its court...no loudspeaker have so much sound...
A day for Sonu Nigam ❤️🙏🏻
14 centuries back there were no loudspeakers, so it doesn't make any sense whether we took off 📣📣📣 or keep them.
As a Muslim i keep track of my local prayer timings and go along.
I support no loud speaker policy for any purpose other than disaster management
@Abou Ayoub I'm a student and I find it very disturbing. Not just mosque but temples and churches too! Religion should be a private affair, especially in a secular country like India
@Abou Ayoub I agree religion is beautiful. Infact all religions are, they preach peace ☮️. But sadly there isn't any. My point is you'd appreciate your religion and it's practices and I'd appreciate mine. And we'll respect each others. But all religious institutions in India are unnecessarily using loud speakers with high decibels. These are things that religious followers introduced, god never asked anyone to do that! Pray peacefully without disturbing anyone and co-exist happily :)
Peace brother ❤️
@@amalgovind3080 I'm a Christian and I agreed with u👍👍👍
@@mattgarey9315 Thankyou my friend ☺️ I'm glad you do. Where are u from?
@@amalgovind3080 agreed a 💯%
When SAUDIs can't bear the noise why should other countries have to hear to someone shouting ??
Yeah. We should be asking the same question for bhajan in temples. Why should we hear someone shouting?
Bhajans are played only during festivals and special occasions. Whereas the mosque play azaan 5 times a day. I dont have problem with azaan and using loudspeaker during festivals but daily use is one which I am against of.
@@farazahmad3959 Who shouts in a Bhajan ??
Whereas you people just shout ....
@@TR4008 we don't shout in Azaan. Its a call to our God. If you guys can't respect our culture then don't expect us to do the same
@@farazahmad3959 I respect too🌼
I have a mosque near my home. I can't even have sound sleep due to their early morning adhan. I use earplugs to sleep daily becoz of their loud sounds. I agree that other religious people do use loud speaker but that is only in some special occasions; not 5 times a day disturbing the tranquility of twilight both morning and evening. They should be sensitive to other religious people's sentiment and right to leave in peace. I wonder why don't they use alarm 5 times a day to go to adhan as we know now a days even a labour on the roadside as a mobile with him.India should ban using adhan during early morning hours and if possible restrict it's usage altogether and allowing only during special occasions with minimal volume.
like in oxford no parking every where like 5 times a day road blocked with 2 rows of cars from end to only wants an emergency sorry mate come back in 2 hours then you will have 20 mins to put the fire out if you stay youll get blocked in for the next 2 hours,
Wow what a pain. So ridiculous.
@@raypitts4880 That's just too sad man. I mean how far gone and brainwashed do you have to be to display such lack of human empathy.
5 times 360 days a year
It’s not necessary that you stay in a place where there is a Masjid. You can move around where there are no any Masajid. You stay in a Muslim populated area and complain? It’s like you are eating chilli raw and complaining it’s so spicy. 😂 grow up man. Azans will be played and the skies will be filled with it.
Wish there were restrictions on this in my country too. I was at one stage able to hear one mosque many kilometres away from source. Who knows how far away the other 4 were. We do not hear churches with such loud speakers. If you can hear a church a block away, it would be something for the books. Never hear synagogues either, but only once lived near one of those.
Which country?
@@tejaswikovelapaty5744 South Africa. Cape Town
@@BrendonSchaferCT Never knew south africa had such problems.
@@tejaswikovelapaty5744 Not all over. There are large Muslim communities in Cape Town. I lived in or near one for a while. I often woke up when the mosques started shouting. Walking to work back then, I frequently heard one mosque that was quite some distance away.
@@BrendonSchaferCT the same is the problem with my country, India, where the muslim population is more than 20 crores and number of mosques exceeding 700000 across the country. They not just built mosques but also destroyed temples and built over them.
Luckily the present govt is destroying the mosques built on hindu temples.
"A high decibel debate has begun"
Excellent. Alliteration, topicality, and comedy.
Keep 'em coming.
This lady always comes well prepared. She gathers a lot of information before she starts talking.
Indeed in this video But. The a Sad think. Is. Many muslim. Countries. Ban. Laud speaker. Still. They attacking . Saudis. Wonder why
They should be asking abaut Saudy and ..I mean what abaut Church bells ?? Saudy have right on muslim lend , and Prear , is firist praority to them in life ..so they have right
@@iimaanabdulle467 there should be rallies organized in Pakistan against MBS,
If no opposition then tomorrow he will allow building of Churches in Saudi
If allowed in Saudi then whole of middle east the Churches will grow. Western countries are sitting with full cash to start building. Their lobby is increasing
She reads off a teleprompter
Indeed very smart and capable
What a gigantic reformer MBS is turning out to be. He'll be remembered as a great leader.
Dont worry.......For the king thrown many murders have took place in KSA and the decisions which he is taking is against his family members his .....so the possibility is that by his own family members he can get assassinated
well to be honest the saudi royal family have never really given a precedence to their religion when it comes to money. Otherwise they would have thrown the US out as soon as they started pissing the general saudi public off. One reason osama loathed america was the modernization saudi royal family allowed by the US.
@@routinelylazy8682 i am not talking about religion.......his decision like to normalise relations with israel ....these type of decision were against his family members.......cuz their familyhave bitter relations with israel from decades.....and majority of his family members were against him cuz of his these type of decision......so asassinating him is not a big deal for them cuz they have done these things earlier also......and one more thing what makes his life more risky is he is sitting in some one esle's thrown....the thrown actually goes to Salmans brother Nayef......and for thrown they can do anything
@Saurav Singh Rawat You can't copy paste reforms.
@@zaheerpewekar4907 relations between Israel and arabs countries were unofficially established in 80s but it were close and secret behind the door up until now when finally Donald Trump made efforts to embark in to strengthen this tie official by bringing abraham accord almost all muslims countries have similar relation with Israel but the only one Turkey has had very good relationship with Israel although Erdogan is playing emotional and political game with Muslim all across the by pretends to be solely voice of Palestinian and also disguise only hope remains who would bring the peace among region which is lies as of 2021 Turkey is Israel's 4th biggest trading partner. there's a lot that I can write up about this on going debate but it takes almost hours to note down but last but not least I'd just say one thing nothing is happen over one night there's discussion on it behind the door which only few knows and geopolitics decision always keeps emotion and affection aside.
I am Muslim But Similar laws must be implemented in the world to restrict the volume of loudspeakers on the premises of any religious places and any functions. We have so much modern tech so anyone can remember anyway.
Thank you, finally a muslim with some sanity and sense.
Foundation of Islam in India is Loud Speaker in mosques. If not this is not Secularism.
Secularism = Islam only religion
Democracy = Islamic rule
☝️☝️☝️
Watch the above link
To believe god is only one
You are crazy.
@@mohammedraazi4943 shut up according to your religion God is mullah mohammad
@@pranavraheja
Watch the link I'm here to tell only the truth revealed by god
@@mohammedraazi4943 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤭
Really they are dismissing the abuses of the muslim society. Definitely they will grow!
Astaghfirullah. Me as a convert living in Brussels, Belgium 🇧🇪 I Just can wish for hearing the call for prayer here where I live. Its so beautiful and it softeness your heart.
It is a disgusting religion
Coming from a ex muslim from Saudi Arabia
@@LVE-xr5or Congratulations to Saudi Citizens. You can sleep well in the morning now.
@@LVE-xr5or lol 😂 you say your an ex Muslim can you tell me why Muslims pray 5 times and how many rakats are there in each rakat? Don't even think about googling it
@@LVE-xr5or yes and its soooooooo tiring to read rakaat fatihah! When we have to sujood!
@@rajaain888 yeah totally...🙄🖕
For every 1 person who is praying there are 100 in the vicinity who are cursing those people praying due to sound pollution, so how would their prayers work?
True It gives a lot of disturbance. We hate it.
Only shaitan has problems with hearing azaan. Are you one of them if not I wouldn't worry about it.
@@aktharislam3503 Any sane person would have problem with loudspeaker at odd hours. Who is shaitaan BTW? Who told you that people who have problem with Azaan on loudspeakers are shaitaan? If that is true then there must be 7 billion people out of 8.5 billion people who are shaitaan. What kind of stupid person told you such things? What is your IQ level to have believed such things?
The world is changing and we’re going through crazy times
Hanso xabi💋💌
Al mahdi time is real soon
It’s the loudspeaker which is kept outside is restricted .. that is only for prayer and not for adhaan and iqama .. there are loudspeaker for adhaan and iqama.. both outside the masjid and inside the masjid… it’s due to some other cause which is given in the statement … plz get a proper story and then comment on it … half knowledge brain is a devils room
That's mark iman Mahdi will appear soon
@@nasywaarlintang9784 in my toilet
Loudspeakers should only be used for emergency purposes and/or announcements. (Anything other than that is kinda pointless)
No
When is the festival for eating cow 💩 poop?
And I think you shouldn't worry about Islam
@@muslims_are_brothers not to worry about islam is like telling not to worry about time bomb in your pocket.
Yeh decision nimaz k liye hai na ki azan k liye wahan namaz padhte wakt bhi speaker ON hota hai
@d3monMnk3y 🥴 really you took your time and best thoughts just for this
the 4-5am preacher always gets me when living in Jakarta
it's beatiful sound though
I don't think loudspeakers were there a hundred years back. Stick to tradition as most religions are fond of it. Most religions can be progressive where it is not required.
The same could be said about, easter eggs, and Christmas trees, santa??
Now liberandos will say that Saudi prince is a sanghi from RSS 😂
lol
Well not me stop generalising silly.He doesn't even know RSS properly and even if he did he wont take any instruction from other countries.Why will they?
Palki ji!! You seem to be genuinely happy about this news. The smile on your face gave in.
@Naftali Bennett , Respect even in words is the most basic of human courtesy. Bigots despise it... I hope you're not a bigot Mr. Bennet.
Sounds kind of progressive and modern for a religious absolute monarchy
@وحد الله : I agree. It’s inherently a shitty authoritarian regime.
This is amazing. I hope we Hindus also learn from this and stop using loud speakers for prayers . Religions should not be allowed to cause loud noises past 10 pm
Why only hindhus…..they follow rules properly..unlike others, no need to tutor them, Hindus by birth and practice we are responsible
First stop those Azan noises that we all hear everyday. Its headache.. Have not Heard temples with loudspeakers.
You r right...even in my side, temples n mosques put loudspeakers......prayers can even be done in silence too. ....
Hindus use loud speakers until 5 am
While original Muslims are opening up their mind, converted/second grade(as Saudis say) Muslims in Pak/India are becoming more backward, orthodox, and "lakeer ke fakeer"
when you celebrated your relagion where is yr open mind concept
Well said..👍👍
Girish there are no first or second class for Muslims like Hindus have brahmin and so on... Every one is Muslim.
U don't understand..our holy sites are in Saudi..we don't follow Saudi..what's more they are absolute monarch..their 'religion' is power and money.. especially the young n evil MBS..Never equates Saudis with all other Muslims..n Never say converts or duplicate..Islam is for mankind NOT LIMITED TO ANY RACE, ETHNICITY OR COUNTRY..
@@maisaranadhira6834 absolutely... Not everything of about Saudi rulers follow Islam
This Prince🤴 got brain I have to say
Great news. I just love the way she puts the facts without any noise and exaggeration
THE CROWN PRINCE IS REALLY A MODERN MAN
AZAN should call without a loudspeaker. The era has been changed, now majority of people have alarm
if you know the value of azan then you will not say rubbish
@@upoma6444 Azan doesn't need loudspeakers to be beautiful
@@upoma6444 the contents of azaan itself is non-secular.
@@mohammedzaid9806 but it needs loudspeakers to be heard
@@jonty3awal secularism doesn't mean believing in every religion , so content of azaan doesn't have anything that goes against secularism
Neither there were loud speakers 1400 years ago, nor it is compulsory according to the scripture to have one
So you want to teach us our history of Islam. When our prophet said that when you hear each sentence in azan repeat after the imam. So what do you conclude from this?
@@atiqmir6092 Well, obviously they did not mention about the loudspeakers. The issue is about loudspeakers, not anything else
@@atiqmir6092
If u want to listen, go to mosque, why they need a loud speaker to disturb
@@atiqmir6092 well here lies the real problem…..repeat after the imam. When the imam said loudspeakers the whole pack follow suit. Brilliant.
Same with Bars nightclubs restaurants….
The ritual started when most people did not have a clock and had to be called for the prayer to start.
Every religion has its own way of this ritual of calling people to pray.
Very True
@@udanis66 Not really, mostly because not every religion require everyone to prey at the same time.
but they have clocks now....dont they?
@@debasishraychawdhuri Maybe because I do not know about the Hindu religion but a long time ago, some religions call for prayers by bell or trumpet in certain countries. So, Islam is unique because it calls all the people to pray together at the same time. So, maybe it is also unique to call the prayers by azan. The clock cannot call the prayers. Maybe that is the difference.
I am travelling to Saudi Arabia every few month.I go to Makka, Madina, Riyadh, Jeddah etc....
Up to date February 2024 I was in Saudi 🇸🇦 the speakers 🔊 are used so loudly to call for prayer everywhere in the country.
I wonder from where you get those news?????
In Mosques, churches temples, volume/ sound of prayer must be restricted to those who attend it, not to be used to challenge or disturb another individual irrespective of their religion.
If your spirit is alive, there’s no need to shout about it.
If yours is why have you commented.
True at the end of the day it is between me and God only.
Yo!! Very well said🙌🏼🔥
Probably the most profound comment here
The purpose of the Adhnan is to alert Muslims that it is the prayer time. Loudspeaker is unnecessarily loud though.
After spreading radical Islam all over world Saudi is reforming 😂
@christine holly there's no such thing such as 'radical' hinduism
@christine holly 😂 substantiate please
@christine holly 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂I can understand your allegations being unfounded, but calling yourself out for being barren of logic. That's some level of honesty, that's both appreciable yet hilarious. I retract my statement and laughter if you have failed to understand my previous comment.
Islam doesn't need to reform itself. it's made once and finished, that's it. people might change it but Islam never changes. the so called "islamist" extremist groups have too changed Islam so that they can justify their wrongdoings. the prophet of Islam never said to give the azaan from the loud speaker . so no problem if loud speaker is used or not. simple as that!
religion is nothing but big business, you will all see, slowly but surely, how about if people stop paying donations and doing hajj, see how long it will last, it will not
Listening to Azan gives me sense of harmony and relaxation.
Azan it's okay, though there's no guarantee of people misusing the loudspeaker for other purpose outside the Azan
To you bro but corporate people like us don't need to be disturbed at 5 am when we just complete our work at 1 .
Let us sleep
I am a Buddhist living near a large airport. I was in Turkey for a holiday and the Muslim prayers were music to my ears.
They were not in Holiday like you!!
Oh..at Turkey..I thought at India..
Palki is easily one of the best anchors we have in recent times, putting across the point with language and punctuation and tone. And not just loud debates.
Loud debates were an outcome of nationalistic fervor and was the need of the hour
Just admit that she is🤩 damn good looking also.
AT THE TIME OF THEIR PROPHET THERE WERE NO LOUD SPEAKERS.
Hehehe
There was a significantly smaller population D’Souza 🙄
@@easynow7801 What u talking about? In Malaysia, there will be 3-4 loudspeakers around my place during azan, each trying to outdo the other in volume. And some imam really have terrible voice. And we know of mosques adjusting their volume little by little daily and some sermons are very loud. And I thought the govt. allowed prayers with loudspeakers and not sermons.
@@telfordlee4896 POOR ALLAH IS DEAF
This should be done in Malaysia too for putting loudspeaker in every mosque
I appreciate this decision of saudi government. this must be implemented everywhere across the world.
Finally a forcefully converted Indian muslim with a brain , thank you
people with low iman should not speak on religious issues!
Asif is right.
@@genejohnson8631 so he being more modern and with nice mindset is problem to your islam?
Right brother ,aur jo chutiye bakwas kar rhe h unko ignore karo🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳
If we do the same in India, *they* will start crying.
You know who.
It should be done here in India also. Loudspeaker call to prayer is harrasment to others at odd hours. In this modern world alarm clock can be set on mobiles.
Swara Bhaskar, Rana Ayub, Dia Mirza, Shekhar Gupta, Pallavi Ghosh, NDTV, TMC 🤪 etc.
your mother for saudi father
@Abh Sriv saale jahil
Allah hu akhbar.🤣🤣 sounds so disgusting
I lived in Indonesia for the last 5 years and they are very loud! They have not stopped at all. Or turned down.
In fact, an ethnic Chinese Buddhist woman was sentenced to 1.5 years in prison for complaining about the volume of the azan, repeated five times a day, near her house
Ziezie wow, I’m an Indonesian and this comment makes me disgusted. It’s not about ‘dont like it dont visit, get out of the country ‘. It’s about tolerance and living in diversity and harmony. Sometimes the noise it too loud. You aren’t the only one living in that area, you know. I was once sick and needed rest, but the noise was too loud to rest properly. It’s about respecting each other’s religious freedom and rights cause we have the same rights and freedom under the constitution.
Rod & Staff true. And last year a family was mobbed for having an online Sunday Service at home due to the pandemic. The protesters said they were disturbing the neighborhood. Now imagine hearing the loudspeakers every single day for many times.
@Ziezie same goes with the malay weddings there. The noise starts from early morning till late afternoon on some weekends. That's tolerance. And let's face it, if a minority write in to complain/feedback about noise stemming from the majority in the country you are living in now, NO ONE is going to jail.
Speaking of expecting majority to bend their culture as you argued, yes what an irony, tons of middle eastern and north african 'refugees' are doing exactly that in europe. And when things go against their expectations, islamophobia accusations flung from every direction.
Ban loudspeaker everywhere not only in religious place.
Finally someone have some sense,, I hope this will cross all borders n stop that high sound. To pray in calmness connects u better with your creator.
i hope u mean creator from any religion
@@apnafavorite Yeah he does
@@apnafavorite There is only one God The creator of all. Religions are devices of men becoz of our misunderstandings. All that God wants is a relationship with his children not some organizations becoz of division.
loudspeakers should be Banned everywhere, weather its mosque, temple, a party or wedding.
Your sounds are so fluent and melodious ❤️❤️
We highly need this in India
When this step will be taken Indian government 🧐🧐🧐🧐?????
Never....❤❤❤❤Allahu Akbar❤❤❤ Love ISLAM ❤❤❤
I think you did not hear the whole video properly. She said there are 94,000 mosques there. Therefore, it's okay to reduce the volume. However, in India the case is different. If the volumes are reduced, not everyone will be able to hear the azaan.
@@killerhunk1 illiterate...
I love how WION analyzes news. My favorite news channel of all time!
You mean they tell you what you want to hear.
@@Private-rm5dy Exactly, while telling you what stings your ears.
@@Bijoubix I am glad channels like these exist for they allow the world to see people like you for what you are.
@@Private-rm5dy cognitive dissonance on social media will never feed your ego.
Yeh decision nimaz k liye hai na ki azan k liye wahan namaz padhte wakt bhi speaker ON hota hai
Has to be audible comfortably at the premises, Without disturbing the neighbors. That will be
sensible.
and look at India no ban nothing
Supporting the wise man
FINALLY. Hopefully Malaysia will follow suit
Liberals called called he is RSS member 😂😂😂
Real Muslims are the Real heroes ❤️
Converted ones need to be taught 'TOLERANCE'
ALL YOU PRINCESS ARE THE SAME SCARED TO BE DETHRONE GREED AND CORRUPTION IS YOUR FOOD WION LOVES THIS
@@mahomedakoon8363 khana kya chahte ho?😂😂
All Muslims are converted. Islam is not an ethnic religion everyone is equal
@@randomdude1998 I guess that guy is scared to know his own reality
@@Nihaar2121warrior There is No "ethnic religion".
In Britain the church’s don’t bother to ring the bells, because it upsets other religions, 😤😤😤😤😤
Fucking rite mate 🇬🇧🏴✝️
Do the mosque,observe the same
Thats traditional bell , not loud speakers..
Sorry i dont believe it, there has been a decline in church going for decades now. The Church bells ringing was a symbol of calling people to church. As for the poor language used in the comments. It just shows the character of People. In all my years in UK i have never heard Complaints about church bells from any faith because people are not stupid becuase they are foreign. Everyone respects the people and place they live in, it's actually human nature but i guess even though so basic it shows its lacking because of the type of mindset people choose to have.
@@syusuf63 what has a decline in congregation got to do with church going? I already said that the church bell rings 15 min prior to the start of the service. I never said that the public complained about the bells ringing. What r u on about. People of your kind r sensitive to every little thing that is said about your religion. .
MBS and Saudi are doing a good job...Saudi is truly a disciplined country...