The Truth Behind Fake Primitive Videos! - MoistCr1TiKaL Reacts
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 พ.ค. 2024
- MoistCr1TiKaL dives deep into the fascinating yet deceptive world showcased in Sunny V2’s revealing documentary, "How Primitive Building Videos Are Staged."
In this reaction video, we uncover the layers of deceit that many TH-cam channels employ, straying far from the authenticity that John Plant's original Primitive Technology channel is renowned for. We'll explore how these channels from Southeast Asia often mislead viewers by hiding the true number of people involved in their projects, using modern machinery, and fabricating the authenticity of their impressive-looking constructions.
What started as a simple and genuine showcase of primitive building techniques has turned into a widespread genre full of exaggerations and falsehoods.
Watch as MoistCr1TiKaL reacts, critiques, and provides his unique insights on these staged creations. Don't miss out on the discussion-drop your opinions and any experiences you’ve had with these types of videos in the comments below!
Original Video - • How Primitive Building...
SunnyV2 Channel - / @sunnyv2
Penguinz0 Channel - / @penguinz0
Subscribe to the channel - / @moistmoments
#moistcritikal #primitivebuilding #sunnyv2
![คบซ้อน - วงL.กฮ. [ Official MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5MtesqJ0I1c/mqdefault.jpg)
As Always, Thanks For Watching!
Thanks you totally destroyed the realistic feel of this video. 😂
Your welcome and thank you for the video and entertainment
Thanks for shedding light on the serious issue of feral front-loaders! Americans need high capacity, anti material rifles to protect their land!
my mum said hi back
Dude the whining was kind of annoying
I actually came here concerned the OG primitive technology channel was going to be debunked. Glad to know he’s on the level
Yeah that guy is a legit primitive techno engineer!
This is from over a year ago, even if that was the case this is old news. I hate when these clip channels post year old clips as if they’re new.
That was my exact thought! I love falling asleep to his channel!
It would be hard for him to fake his videos, you see literally all of the work he does on screen. He needs a hole? You see him dig it with a stick. He needs to make shingles for his storage shed? You see him make every single one, even if just in Timelapse.
Primitive technology is goated 😭😭
Those tracks are made by feral tractors...they occasionally escape their farms and end up breeding in the wild. They're one of the only domestic farming machines capable of surviving without human assistance...
I've never heard of those before. I have seen the wild boars that have tires for feet though. Real nasty specimen
@@LeeroyDankin420 I've seen evidence that shows it may be Man-Bear Pig making cybernetic enhancements...Al Gore tried to warn us, now we may have half man-bear, half tractor-pigs running amok! *Our imaginations are absolutely out of control!
@@LeeroyDankin420 My God...The Man-Bear Pig has started cybernetically altering itself! It's now half man-bear, half pig-tractor...we should've listened when we had the chance!
Our imaginations are running wild again!
they aren't feral, they are stray tractors
Be a good pet owner and adopt a tractor.
i honestly don’t get how anyone wasn’t suspicious of this tbh. like primitive technology blows up and then all of a sudden a bunch of copycats appear with more complicated structures and nobody questions it? the naivety of most people is genuinely surprising
The vast majority of people at least suspected they were fake, in my experience
Naïveté*
And u didnt either
I suspected they were fake also, done in their back yards etc on their spare time and the materials came from probably the local building supply. Especially the bricks and mortar.
I think is mostly that nobody cares, the same as a lot of people acting like TV shows like undercover boss are real, they just want something entertaining, and don't think if it's real or not, if properly asking, most people would end up on the same conclusion, most of this things are fake, but it doesn't matter, it's just a video to spend 30 min watching for fun.
okay, 'naturally occurring jungle tire tracks' made me lol for realz
Lmao xd for reàlz
Me too.
Even the vehicle associated with them watch close by
Charlie over there getting proven right like "VINDICATION!!!!" - Captain Holt 😂
"Oh my God. Wunch sounds exactly like lunch"
Man I can’t believe they found a excavator in its natural environment. Such a amazing and rare find. Nature is beautiful.
I didn't even know that they were indigenous to that area. The more I live the more I learn.
@@ironassbrownthey're not. Their only natural spawn point is Germany.
they do not look strong enough to do the big projects, the amount of labor needed to actually do it is crazy.
They really don’t. Construction workers look stronger than they do.
These guys are the pro wrestlers of Primitive Building. You know it's fake, they're not doing a very good job of hiding that it's fake, but you're gonna watch anyway.
i 1000% love how upset charlie gets about this. fuck all the doubters, that shit is so obvious holy fuck.
Makes you realize how moronic most of the people are in the world.
big tru
good thing the camera-man isn’t working for boeing, yikes
trapping all that water and leaving it will be a hive of mysqtos
Not to mention a death-trap for local wildlife. Especially once the forest starts growing back and makes them all but invisible.
Criminally irresponsible.
Never seen ‘mosquitos’ spelled so eloquently before
@@RoIIingStoned sory i have alot of trouble with spelling and not the greatest typer either i know its hard to even guess what the words are. i do try my best. its the reason i dont commet alot.my grammer is just as bad. again im very sorry to anyone who were confused
@@BullDogBreed75true
@@RoIIingStoned you mean elegantly? geez louise
Primative Tech is the only channel I can watch making these shelters and other tools, he shows the work and doesn't milk 20 min just rambling.
Bros turned on creative mode for their Minecraft builds 😂
I have 22 acres so I thought if they could do it, I could. Was going to try the one with the garden in the middle of the pond. That is hard af with a shovel. I felt so defeated until I read everything they do is fake lol
Lmfaoo thats funny
No shit, right. I spent the last two weeks hand-digging trenches to bury utility lines. It is ridiculously grueling work and I am only digging down a couple feet. I should have hired two guys with sticks to do it for me in one day.
Lmao man that is so dumb😂 dang dude
I would've believed you Charlie! I be coming to your channel for all the news.
Good call, bro. I like when you said that part in the middle. Also the start was good, ended well too. So, yeah good job.
Subscribed!
15:16 Going to go in my backyard and build a water park with a stick, I'll get back to you when I'm done.
what progress have you made? 😂
yeah keep us updated, haha
@@trashicity he made a gravel path
it's the accent that makes it more believable, lmao.
sunny also is more reputable than moist. sunny sticks to the facts, where charlie will show the facts but will also add his over exaggerated joke opinion
Primitive Skills is my favorite to watch. Guy's been working on his videos for about five years now in the same location.
And he is pretty progressive with his builds
Primitive skills is legit he said he was directly inspired to learn from primitive technology
Yeah he is a good one, been watching him a long time
With the Geo location. The US TH-cam tends to pay more per vews than most other countries. Also they are more likely to be seen if they say the US (something to do with the TH-cam algorithm)
That makes sense ngl.
More profit
You all should apologize to him.
i sure am glad that Sunny told us about the tracks! otherwise we would have never known!
Benefit of tagging the location in US is for dollar income from YT.
I caught my mom watching these videos and she was so fascinated and excited . I didn’t have the heart to tell her they are fake 😅
To you ending comments about 1 group owning all - funny they have a 10-12 man team, whilst there is 5 or 6 massive channels with 2 people working 'together' operating out of the same like 50 square km... numbers certainly add up and makes perfect sense to scale the 'business'
Sunny sounds like a 2024 male version of an 80's Valley Girl
LMAO people really thought 2 guys with sticks built these elaborate pools, slides, shelters, etc.? Common sense has gone and ignorance and naivety is flourishing, perfect for the TH-cam garbage heap lol.
People believe anything they see online
u would be surrised how brain-rotted most internet (especially young internet users) are these days.
@@scorpion0498you can forgive younger folks. They just lack information due to lack of exposure.
Its the 30+ YO that are scary how ignorant they are
I think most people just have a different problem, it's not that they're ignorant, is that they just didn't doubt it, didn't think about it, probably most of them id they thought about it, would end up with the same conclusión that is fake.
Same happens with shows like Undercover boss, I've seen people talking as if it was real, until you tell them, well, do you really think, that if a new worker came up to work with a full camera crew following their every move, no one would notice something is up? And that no one would recognice the CEO of their own company? And after that, they just have the realization, just because they never stopped to question if it was fake or not.
@@boogit9979 it’s always funny how hard people are on literal children (not you im agreeing w you) as if the adults around them aren’t to blame
I tried replicating one of these builds step by step. In the first 5 minutes, I managed to bang my hand against a rock and poop my pants. I decided to go to bed instead.
I would've taken off my poop pants and hit the shower instead, I guess we all do things differently, and that's okay.
Yea I definitely remember you debunking this. People are cappin
Really sums up, most of the time that chat is stoopid.
It's believable to people who have never used a shovel to dig a hole. 😂
Basically anyone who hasn't used their hands working outside.
I thought the Mr. Tifu was the OG of those pool builder channels. But I never really paid much attention. They had me on the first video, but by the second video, it was obvious they weren't doing it all by hand as there was some very obvious excavator marks on one of the walls. I feel like after the second video, I never saw them again unless I went looking
12:50 thats such a gpod idea, like, just come clean but take it up 5 notches
This is from over a year ago 😂
I get why they lie and fake it, but that's stupid. They still do cool work with great outcomes and their honesty would probably work more to their advantage.
reminds me of when I was working on a movie set in the Hoh rainforest. There was a scene that took place in a modern public bathroom, so to fit it into their filming schedule they built a "realistic" looking facade of a bathroom right in the middle of the rainforest. It looked great on camera you would never know it was just some plywood with tiles and fixtures stuck on them.
I was in the USMC. I was given a pair of scissors to cut the grass, a toothbrush to deck scrub the floor and we played multiple rounds of dig the hole, fill the hole.
It would take decades.
Same with a ton of the bushcraft channels too.
Favorite TH-camr 💯💯💯
All being connected makes sense that way they can all share the same excavator
haha, true
I watched those 2 kids build those structures for a long time and it’s so obviously dug with an escalator😂 I didn’t know it was up for debate🤦🏻♂️
Seeing charlie so pressed is a beautiful thing😂 charlie i believed🙌
8:07 😂😂 “a small, private jungle in California”.
I came here for the warframe shout out, stayed for the savage commentary
Sunny V2 nailed it with the excavator tracks - thanks for posting! :P
They were clearly fake when they first came out…. More like how did you not know
same way people get away with faking cooking or other videos. Some people have genuinely zero idea how building works so they have no common sense on the subject to see red flags.
The builds were too outrageous to be real
They should really do set design for movies tbh.
Im actually glad they have experts to keep em safe, they dont deserve to get badly hurt, as much as i hate these fakers ❤
Video: Try it yourself and see if it works.
Charlie: "Zero people are going to do that" hahaha
Primitive technology always the goat. He genuinely uses rocks and sticks and progresses without the use of tools. Thanks for good content
word
Charlie, I watch you so I can chill. I watch sunnyv for facts 😂
I’ve seen those feral tractors I thought I was seeing things
i thought this was about the skate team but still watched lol
This is legit just the show Gold Rush but it’s “Primitive Living” lmfao
Tbf I feel the majority of people knew there wern't 100% legit, but the videos are pretty entertaining lol
ya exactly, plus let them make money. poor guys
The amazing thing about this is that I would find these videos really cool even if they did it with machinery but I refuse to watch them because they are lying about how they've constructed them.
I normally just don't care, mostly because I will watch a ton of them in a row, and never go back to the channel again, it's cool, but it also gets old pretty fast, since it's the same thing every single video.
@@Acuas yea it's pretty cool no matter how they made them but if you watch 3 or 4 they will fill up TH-cam's entire recommended, the algorithm is so bad
@@Tre_Vor194 Yes, it pretty much did, for like 2h, until I watched something else, it was years ago, so it could be worse now, who knows
I don’t like the deforestation part especially because they are simply cutting woods for the videos it’s a waste of resources
I didn't think that people actually believed these videos were genuine in the first place.
Voice cracked because he almost fell out of character 😂😂😂 I would’ve laughed after saying that fr
SunnyV never lies 😂
Lol "naturally occurring jungle tire tracks" 😂
I don't mind the fact they use heavy equipment or extra help. I genuinely don't. They're making content, it make sense to make content at a faster speed. The digging is an insanely long process. However, the bamboo's being cut, the 'concrete', the over the top builds. They are supposed to be primitive. Yeah--use an excavator, make the hole. Then do the rest by hand. Don't lie about it. I don't even mind them pumping water in, as to do this you'd need your own land with a water supply... which won't happen easily. There's just... It should still be *primitive* and be actually doable without equipment or extra help. For the content machine? Yeah, use the skidsteers or whatever. Hire a team That makes sense as a business. More content, more money. But atleast build something that is actually buildable. And don't lie.
It is the lie, but also the wastefulness that is the issue. I mean they put all these materials and resources, and the destruction of habitat, just so they can quickly film the results before it all falls apart and becomes a blight. I mean a gingerbread house may look cozy, but it's going to crumble the first time it rains.
Damn, charlie seemed really hurt they didnt believe him lmao
Today on the menu... Salty penguin 😂❤
In defense of the river cement I say this. When I was a youngling there was a large empty field next to the apartment complex we lived in. My sisters and I played in that field often, and one of our favorite things to do was to make mud pies. One year, around Easter, we found a plank of wood and decided to use it as a base for a big mud pie. This thing was probably 2 feet long and almost foot high, just a big ol' slab of mud. When we were done we just left it there to sit and bake under the California sun. When we went and checked on it a month or two later it looked like a block of cement and had cracked practically clean in half. And that was just whatever kind of dirt is in that field and water from the nearby canal.
Still isn’t concrete/cement, so what’s your point?
@@nnnjh8372 I never said it WAS cement, just that it looked LIKE cement when dry. And my point was that if WE could mix up something that dried to look like cement with naught but dirt from a random field in Nowhere, California, then it's not outside the realm of possibility that these people could have done something similar. None of this is to defend these people and their fake content. People who farm view with this fake ish are a scourge. I just wanted to point out that that one occurrence of "regular mud drying to look like cement" isn't as outlandish as you might initially think. How do I know, cause I've seen it happen with my own 2 eyes.
They need to start uncovered hidden caves filled with treasure, monsters, mummies, whatever, and start copying ghost hunter videos
Almost like we never built huts back in the day
Even if you've never worked in construction or landscaping, you gotta know what happens when you hit the ground with a stick 💀this is insane
Good one
I would've liked to see how chat ate their words
The most likely reason why the account is US bases while the video took place in SE Asia is because during that time, Google took many countries off the monetization list. Meaning, you cannot earn money from some of the countries listed in the video.
8:45 dude has a lighteàrin his hand😂😂😂
I believed you Charlie. When no one believed, I believed Charlie.
i believe in charlie
Anyone fooled by these also enjoyed 5 minute crafts.
If you want to see how to really survive in the wild, watch the Survivorman serries with Les Stroud. He's a Canadian survival expert who filmed his own wilderness survival show, as in filmed it while surviving largely with no crew. It's all on TH-cam on his channel because he kept the show right 👍
I didn't even see the excavator, is it cuz I'm on my phone using a browser with ad block?
half of this video is just Charlie complaining that chat didn't believe him 😭
reminds me of a song by Flight of the Concords, called " I got hurt feelings."
A really easy way for thes echannels to prove themselves real, would just be to upload the unedited footage. The HOURS AND HOURS of manual labor it would actually take. But instead they just make it look like they did the work and then cut the cameras and bring in the backhoe
Being as in the USA as a location it helps with views but most of all with money as US TH-cam pays the most per view than other countries and in some countries they don't pay per view hardly anything
Nice Odesza song at the end :) love that artist.
Years and years from know others will wounder what all these builds were
Before my Mom passed, we used to watch one of these YT videos of just one woman creating an entire set up by herself. At first, I was amazed but then I thought there is no way one woman by herself can do all this! So, yeah.
A year later, there was a young couple with a baby, doing the exact same thing as the woman from the previous videos.! 😂😂
8:50 the flash means there were fuel fumes in the air
Who said they are collecting cement? It may as well be clay
Idk why i love hearing Charlie talk shit to people when he was right all along 😂
tbh, I would probably watch something similar if they were just honest.
I remember him debunking this... I believed it
Sorry your watches didn't believe me... it was fun, thank you.
It’s the same area that have those fake animal rescue videos. Where they purposely drown of injure animals then act like they are saving them. So frustrating ready comments of god bless these ppl for helping that (animal in danger situation) even when it’s obvious by video start snd how many diffeeent angles and close ups that they were filming for ages befor the ‘hero’ comes in.
I had a gut feeling it was fake. I had to replace a water pipe by my bros house and that was hard work. Spent 4 hours and barely made a tiny hole. Just enough to see the pipe and patch it.
I am almost certain Primitive Skills is legit but the impractical builders that make underground bs and pools are just making the real guys look bad
Anyone who has installed fence posts or dug foundation trenches by hand will know it takes ages is literally backbreakingly exhausting. Without tools and plant machinery there is no way these guys could dig holes like that as it would take them months. And that would be with a metal spade! With a piece of wood they would need like 50 guys working day and night. Or just use an excavator?! Job done!
You can get clay from a river but you can’t get concrete…
It's too bad they have to lie about whether it's primitive or not, because some of those sculptures are actually very impressive, like the giant dragon. Just being honest, they would likely have even more views.
I thought the first two primitive building videos I watched were cool, but stopped believing it soon after when multiple structures were built that would normally take (at minimum) a year.
Primitive Technology does things the way you would expect to see in a primitive set-up. The other channels just make pretty stuff that you wouldn't care to make in a primitive setting.
You should have taken a screencap of all the people who doubted you, and then name and shame them at this video.
This should be a salty moment because moist be salty. 🤣.
The Bear Grylls of primitive building.
I look at these videos like anything.. entertainment...