Breaking News: George R.R. Martin Does It Again | The Winds of Winter is Doomed?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 พ.ค. 2024
- Welcome back for another Game of Thrones and A Song of Ice and Fire video. In this video, I will be talking about George R.R. Martin's new NotABlog update. According to George R.R. Martin, HBO is preparing to film their new Game of Thrones prequel series, A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms. This new series will chronicle the life and adventures of Ser Duncan the Tall and Aegon "Egg" Targaryen. A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms will be based on George R.R. Martin's three Dunk & Egg novellas, The Hedge Knight, The Sworn Sword, and the Mystery Knight. As of right now, this story doesn't have an ending. George said he needs to write roughly 7-12 more novellas before this story is finished. This is a major issue because HBO has already started making A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms, before George has written it's ending. He said he will not start writing anymore Dunk & Egg novellas until he's finished the Winds of Winter. This might not happen anytime soon, considering he's been writing the Winds of Winter for over a decade. This might be Game of Thrones all over again. A Knight of the Seven Kingdom's writers might catch up to George before he's ready to start writing more novellas. What will they do if that happens? Will he delay the Winds of Winter even longer, or will he allow the show's writers to create his ending again?
Images and video clips from Game of Thrones and House of the Dragon are property of their creators, used here under fair use.
Talking Thrones Patreon!
/ talkingthrones
Source: George RR Martin (NotABlog)
georgerrmartin.com/notablog/ - บันเทิง
I've made peace with the likelihood that George will never finish TSOIAF.
me too
I hadn't but seeing that you guys have, I better too. The publishers will make an AI write it though?
@@SlytherinsConspiracies For sure AI will finish it.
@@SlytherinsConspiracies AI is the only hope by now
The final two GRRM books will be completed by surrogates.
The man is 75 years old and loves doing the Hollywood thing. Doesn't seem like he's interested in writing...anything?
That's exactly what it is. Why rack your brain trying to write these difficult and complex stories when you can sit back and collect fat checks as an advisor for HBO? He's in retirement mode.
He can do whatever he wants he doesn’t owe us anything if he’s done writing then that’s it 😭
@@carlosarcosshe does owe us atleast winds of Winter After so many annoucmentd
@@carlosarcoss i agree but he needs to be honest about this with his fans. bro pretends like he is going to release a book which is never happening.
Stop licking his boots. He's not gonna thank you for white knighting for him.
He does owe the people that buy his countless number of books, novels shows etc. He owes everyone to at least finish the main series after going on 2 decades teasing how close he is and how he's gonna take it seriously after blah blah blah @@carlosarcoss
George seems to think he's gonna live forever.
He‘s probably very aware of not living forever and plans to die before people realize that he has no idea how to finish the story.
He is elderly and not healthy. We aren't getting Winds of Winter
Someone will absolutely finish Winds and Dream. But it may not be GRRM.
@@valleyscharping Well, more than half of winds is really made by him. He likes Tolkien so much that will die with unfinished stuff too
@@valleyscharpingThat's the only way it's getting done. I hope his heirs follow Robert Jordan's widow's example and find another Brandon Sanderson to finish the series, but it's unlikely to turn out as well as Wheel of Time. When he realized he was likely to died of an altra-rare blood disease before he could finish it, Jordan reportedly started mapping out the rest of the series, prepared a slew of notes, and wrote key scenes, including the final chapter of the series. He did all of that while actively dying.
I seriously doubt GRRM will do the same for ASOIAF because that would require he have a clue where the series is going and how it ends. Hopefully he has enough of his world building documented that someone can step in and at least create a plausible ending, even if it isn't GRRM's ending.
@@JoaoVitor-is4zb Except Tolkien finished LOTR.... What has GRRM Finished? Do not lump them in the same room that is a massive insult to authors that finish stuff.
i do think well get winds..at some point in the nezt 5 years crazy as that sounds but ADOS nah thats dead af at least TWOW is about 70% done he could honestly rush the rest and push it out if it REALLY came down to it
Winter is NOT coming.
By the time the last novel " a dream of spring" comes out, Prince William's son, George will become king of Britain and the Commonwealth.
Down with the monarchy.
@@nickhufflepuff9604 England hasn't been a true monarchy ever since the Hanover king George I took over. It's basically a new version of Venice , a metastasis of Venice. Read Webster g tarpley' a "Venice move north" papers
@@namelesswhocares8648still cringe ceremonial monarchy
@@nickhufflepuff9604 🤡🤡🤡
I started reading A Song of Fire and Ice in 1996. I refuse to buy any more of his books until he finishes this series.
damn. Im done with this guy and I started 9 yrs ago. I can only imagine how you feel. Thats longer than I have been alive.
If he even finishes which I highly doubt, we’ll be lucky to get Winds of Winter at this point considering it’s been over a decade since the previous book was released.
Fevre Dream is actually a great book by George but I understand your frustrations
Thats me. I gave up on him. And i loved his first books. But he had too many threads and he lost track of them.
By the time George finishes Winds of Winter the Kid playing Egg will be able to Play Egg as a grandfather and Die in Summerhall. :P
To claim he needs to stop writing TWOW for more Duncan & Egg would imply he’s been writing at all
You got bored after 500 words writing a text at school man. Give him a break.
Fair
@@marc-etiennemercier6584It's been *13 YEARS...*
@@marc-etiennemercier6584 Writing is literally his job and has made him both rich and famous
@@shaneriggs6678 It did. So what's the point of draining himself to death for some ungrateful audience now? When you're his age, you'll have been retired for 20 years.
You can bet that if the Dunk and Egg TV series is a hit George will quickly shift his focus on writing more in that series. It's clear the last thing he wants to do is finish the original series.
In fact it wouldn't surprise me if he has the next Dunk and Egg novella already written.
I can see this happening too
George's first love has always been tv script writing. They always told him he wrote too big. I think if Dunk n Egg takes off, he definitely will write it. Dunk n Egg is his favorite child ❤.
So I could see this happening too.
Back then, when I was a devout member of the German ASoIaF-community and we were in London to see George (I think it was 2012?), he talked about writing Dunk and Egg up to the North to Winterfell and the two of them being in Dorne. I believe he skipped Dorne but Winterfell and the Starks could still be a possibility.
I also think that since GOT is finished, he kind of is done with the story of 'asoiaf'.
he may be thinking that writing the last book will be the end of the world he created. in a way, he'd be killing his child so he's putting off as long as possible.
He's 75.... you'd think he'd want his series and legacy complete before he passes.
You are new to the writing scene, aren’t you? Frank Herbert never finished Dune, either.
Someone give George a clout in the ear to keep him focused on Winds of Winter.
Winds of winter isn’t coming thats just a fact but I don’t think he’ll even be able to get any dunk and egg novellas out in time for that show either. He’s literally going to do it again, let another show get ahead of his books. He really doesn’t learn his lesson at all. The man is insane.
I doubt he'll ever finish any of the books at this point.
He’s not even writing them. He. Has hired guns for that.
@@scubasteve3032 if he had hired someone to write it'd likely be done at this point
For a guy who wrote stories that he never intended to have translated into tv, he sure is writing a lot of stuff for tv. Just finish the story we’re all really invested in, please and thank you.
Duncan and Egg are really good reads. Winds is never coming out from George. Perhaps after he dies someone will edit what he has written and publish it.
He's mentioned that he has plans in place for all his works to be destroyed after his death because he doesn't want anyone else finishing HIS works.
Compared to Brandon Sanderson, he's lazy, selfish and petty.
@@Davitofrito Do you have a link of some kind of him saying that?
@@bjrnbrynemo9059he doesn’t because he never said it. It’s one of those myths that keep getting spread around.
@@nox4298 I don't think so either. Why would he give us the preview chapters for Winds, and then just stop there? Might as well release the 3/4 of the book he keeps boasting about (on his deathbed or whatever).
@@bjrnbrynemo9059there's a video on this very TH-cam channel where he tells an interviewer that he doesn't want anyone else finishing ASOIAF.
The sad part about this…we won’t get anymore dunk and egg until winds of winter comes out
I saw 'breaking news' and I thought George had finished Winds of Winter and forwarded to his publisher! Don't care about Dunk & Egg.
Lol😂
Meeee toooooo
Right?
Sweet summer child
At this point, I need him to hire writers to finish The Winds of Winter. His involvement in the creative process and writing of the adaptated series is slowing him down and it’s not like he is super young either. 🙁
You should make peace with the fact that the book is never going to be finished unfortunately.
Same of us want to live long enough to experience the culmination of the Song of Ice and Fire as a literary adventure.
We just want him to finish the story though 😡😡😡
He’s said many times he pinned himself into a corner with how to end game of thrones that he truly doesn’t know what to write to tie it the ending. The fact that he was doing side story writing is because he has writers block on the main story. He’s old fat and rich who hasn’t finished writing the next book over the last 15 or whatever years. He’s never finishing it let’s just accept it.
I gave up hoping years ago.
@@israymervalentin-arias6313yup
Waaahhhahaha I'm a baby and I want my toys!
@@ichigen511 you sound like you need your meds…
The Dunk and Egg series would be perfect to engage with a writing partner. I get not wanting to do that with ASOIAF but for that more episodic and adventurous series getting a talented cowriter would be perfect
Just imagine how nicely things would've fallen into place if he could just finish writing in time.
The books will 100% be released.
Probably just unfinished versions after he has passed away.
100% someone will have to finish wind's and dream after he gone.
I’ve already accepted the fact that he’s old rich and fat who hasn’t finished writing the winds of winter even after 15 or whatever years. I have accepted that he will never finish it even if he lives another 25 years.
I've tried reading every other GRR story besides Thrones. Including Sworn Sword and the rest of them. Some are fair, some are awful, none of them are in the same class as Thrones by a long shot. Everything he's written besides song of ice and fire is pure mediocrity. When you develop them into a TV show, the TV show is pure mediocrity. HOT D was a fair effort but who literally GAF about Targaryens? Their story is not interesting, except for the dragons, it's completely forgettable.
@@robertmaybeth3434 Thats a hot take
@@robertmaybeth3434 lead shots fired
@@robertmaybeth3434 you're in a minority of one.
@@robertmaybeth3434 who cares about Targaryens is the wildest thing I’ve heard in a while lmao
gta vi before twow is crazy
the "no one is safe" rule has been out of the window since about season 5 or something.
I genuinely think he doesn't know HOW to finish a song of ice and fire and I think it's because he's created to many plotlines and instead of closing them his mind just keeps making more. I once read somewhere that a dream of spring could actually end up being 2 books. He's right when he says he's like a gardener, he's a gardener with an infinite amount of land that he keeps expanding into instead of fencing it and being like now I have to actually tend to the garden that I've already created. I definitely think that both the show and book fan's strong reaction to the ending of GOT also has something to do with him being unable to conclude his story because amongst all those lies there were some specks of truth spinkled in (e.g. Bran becomes king). Also hink him waiting this long has added to the pressure because how much fans expect - the fact that there are fan theories that have resulted in people making videos spanning 20+ hours tells you that much. So in conclusion, what's keeping him from finishing the books? 1. wanting to expand the plot when now is the time to bring it all together 2. too much ground to cover in terms of addressing and concluding already existing plotlines 3. increased expectation/ hype from the fandom on the actual ending of the books from having to wait 10+ years leading to added pressure. I think Winds of Winter is his big hurdle, if he's able to actually finish it and put it out there (and people like it) then I think he will be able to write spring faster. As a procrastinator myself, there's a sort of guilt that comes from delaying the work you knew had to be finished already which then results in you procrastinating even more.
Completely agree. People forget that GRRM himself said when he writes, he doesn’t do an ending because it makes him lose interest and creative flow because he ends up restricting his creative process to the point that he stops writing.
He gave GOT his ending and now has backed himself into a corner as he saw the backlash and can’t change it without causing contractual issues with HBO as he has promised that the book ending will be the same as the show.
I suspect he is dragging his feet because he hopes the vitriol will die down by the time his last book comes out and he can figure out how to tweak things to make the ending more palatable.
@@march1242 wait omg he has a contract with hbo that says that he’ll keep the show ending???? I didn’t know that! Thats crazy that they can dictate the terms of HIS books
I didn’t read all of this but I read enough. I’ve never even read the books and know that this guy has written himself into a maze he cannot solve or written himself into a corner in dark room that he cannot escape.
Ask Sanderson. He already did it once. Why not twice?
I was hopeful we were going to get at least winds of winter but seems like not even that book we will get. I really wish he was open to get help to write the book, there are authors who are open to collabolators. Thanks for the video. Lol the update from 2014.
I sure hope he is almost finished his Winds of Winter Cause I really love the Dunkin egg story too I'm sure he will have it worked out with someone
Tbf he did say he knew what he would write the next DandE novel about and it was supposed to be based at winterfell. He's even dropped some hints in brans visions. So I think he'll write it pretty quickly but there's probably some hints about the main storyline in the novellas
I believe his vision for game of thrones ending was the same as how to show ended but with the backlash of the show he scared to admit it and cant think of new ending so he stuck in
Nah, because George will actually write it well with proper build up if his ending is the same. But I'm certain Georges ending isn't identical, because D&D made up Arya killing the Night King etc.
Even with the same ending, he would know how to execute it. I don’t think he envisioned Arya killing the NK, nor Jaime and Cersei dying together happily? I do think he probably had Bran as the King, which many people hated as well. But with Bran, I think it’s more about how poorly he was written in the last 2 seasons. I don’t mind him being King if it’s done right.
He's just to rich to bother writing now
Woah I haven’t watched a video of yours in years, when I used to watch all the time. Thanks season 8 and DAN & DAVE!
Dunk and Egg have the luxary of being able to jump around in time. It starts when Egg is a child and ends with him a man grown. Maybe George doesn't "finish" Dunk and Egg. But we can at least tell the writers what happened at Summerhall if they want to end if that way.
Also they have the world book to help guide them.
@@kjellduteweert9262 exactly. It would be all that different from how house of the dragon is being developed. They have the broad strokes, they would just need to fill in the details. Also, they could just end the show after 2 or 3 seasons. They don't have to move past the written material.
We know of at least 2 novellas that exist in some form:
The Village Hero which is likely to be about events of Pennytree & how it became a royal fief. It exists on the border of Stone Hedge & Raventree hall lands for context (Bracken & Blackwood disputed area).
The other is The She Wolves of Winterfell - a working title but dealing with a succession crisis in the North when multiple Stark lords have died in rapid succession.
George has started a 4th novela Shewolves of Winterfell.
I'm totally keeping the faith in George. Alot going on and hid dreams of dunk n egg are coming together and truly i cannot wait...want winds of winter as well however this is his dream from 50+ yrs ago ❤
Worst part is that there are still two books left for the song of ice and fire. Winds of Winter is just the first. He needs to write a whole book after. He probably wont make it
Oh dear. Great video, thank you.
Martin should reach out to Brandon Sanderson, LOL. Pay Sanderson big bucks to finish one of these two projects. Sanderson could pump one out in record time.
With Sanderson we would have had dreams of spring and a trilogy of Roberts rebellion, already.
"Where was Sanderson when Martin fell? Where was Sanderson when heart disease closed in around GRRM? Where was San- ... No my Lord, we are alone"
13 years waiting for this book and now it might not even be completed. 😩🤦🏾♂️
Really hope he does because of how they ended GOT
As much as I love HOTD I wished they had started with Aegon and his sisters.
You do know HBO is already working on it right?
@@Moreanolc Yes! Hope I’m still alive when it come out 🙄
@@kimmie_kimm_kimm House of the Dragon is doing pretty well so they will likely release it this decade
Winds of Winter not happening
He still deserves massive respect for the worlds and stories he created
Yea people are so ungrateful man. He wrote so many books and his work really came to light when he was past retirement age.
He does, he has an incredible mind
People do respect him and his work, that’s why they’re all angry to see this amazing series go unfinished.
That kid is adorable. I can't wait to see him as Aegon V.
I have to say. I have come to accept he will never write anything again.
Winter is never coming, and spring will remain a dream.
We're never getting the winds of winter
That kid is so cute. I would love to see a complete Dunk and Egg, but I know that's not coming, just like the Winds of Winter.
Seems like George needs a long vacation at Cauldron Lake to get over his writers block.
I don't think he will get out the whole series of any of his books
Not to mention that there are no dragons or direwolves in the Dunk and Egg series, mostly about medieval knights, no magic, which means the show is significantly cheaper to make and was therefore chosen over other stories, like the GOT sequel for instance they cancelled.
I hope he lives long enough to finish what he would like. I'm scared to think of it too much.
he needs to get someone to help him with winds of winter or itll never get done. i have lost all faith in him ever finishing that book let alone a dream of spring
as you've said , he doesn't do any writing ... so why would anybody asume that he'll finish GoT or he will write any new material ?
These winds have blown too cold, everything has iced over, including his progress.
Will we never see spring?
Is there no hope this long, long, long night will end?
This will end up like Tolkien’s Silmarillion and Unfinished Tales - him dead and them incomplete.
Its sad but i think we all know to give up on winds of winter who really cares about dunk and egg
I can't believe this guy :(
I do think we will get Winds of Winter within the next year or two but feeling more and more like Dreams of Spring is something that will never come out or someone else will have to write it. Also I have a feeling that fan reception to Winds of Winter will be very mixed even if it is a good book, as the expectations are just through the roof at this point. (probably part of the reason he's taking so long).
I think everyone realizes at this point DoS is a bad joke
He needs someone to help him, period, and there's nothing wrong with that.
Sometimes when you're working on something and get into a rut, working on something else for a while helps you when you go back to the first project. Maybe he should work on some Dunk and Egg novellas to give his mind a break from Winds of Winter and when he goes back he might see the path he needs to take.
I’m currently on a Storm of Swords and I’m excited to “finish” the books, however it weighs on me that there may not be a prize at the end and Gurm may never finish. Sad.
7-12 more novellas is the wildest things! 😂😂😂
Perhaps he needs a co-writer? Or someone to help him keep track of the many storylines that are happening? I can imagine that it must get very complex at some point.
In his mind, he knows how asoiaf ends and what happens to the people in the story. I would be happy even if he would finish the story 'sloppy' and shorten it, as in cut some pov's.
GRRM hot & cold moments are providing us with content from you so I can’t complain
George is a habitual "carrot dangler".
He wants to build a world like Tolkien did but with less wrinkles ..it's not ez to maintain a true lure that is over a few centuries
Its getting so absurd my mind went full circle and I am just hopefully imagining everyone eating their hats when winds of winter unexpectedly hits the shelves :-D
It’s funny to think that we are talking like the TWOW is the end of TSOIAF story… there is still one more book slated, ADOS… that book will never ever see George’s hand.
I don't keep up with the book info as much as u guys but is there a chance he'll let someone else finish it and just take a percentage since he's gotten so old
Thanks for the update as always
How many years have half the fanbase said "its never coming out" and the other half said "later this year"
If any of you have ever written a novel, it’s hard work. The hardest part is getting started.
I would also like to see more Dunk and Egg over all of the rest
Also think Dunk and Egg should be a R rated cartoon
We just need to accept the fact that Winds of Winter is just a pipe dream..
There are so many other books, fantasy or not, that are great, you guys should explore your horizons. This channel, for example, could give a chance and make content related to other authors.
Perhaps his books 6 and 7 are nearly along the line as the series ending. And GRRM saw how people hated hated that. I hope I'm wrong and some days we'd have the complete series, whether by George or another author.
This guy will snuff it before he finishes The Winds of Winter.
His publisher and HBO never forced a ghost writer upon him. Considering that millions are at stake, that baffles me.
It has an ending they died at Summerhall end of story
The gardener got lost in his overgrown garden.
I just wish he'd let someone else write it. It's going to happen eventually after he dies. Might as well pass to torch to someone he picks and approves of and not some distant relatives that just see $$. (Looking at you Rings of P...). I understand it's his "baby" but the man is obviously done with writing. I almost wish this could happen sooner than later.... I ain't getting younger myself.
Thank you my good man
I honestly don’t care who finishes the story as long as it’s a dope show
We actually have a better chance seeing Conor in the Octagon than ever knowing the true ending to ASoIaF.
I aint ready for Baelor Breakspear 😢
HBO needs to eff off with the speed running of the content. There's no reason for why they kept cutting down episode length and coverage. More and more each season.
I have this feeling that that Words of Wisdom post he did back in March was saying more than it did at first glance
The best, and most GRRM thing, that could happen is that he’s already written WoW and ADoS and they’ll be published posthumously to avoid any backlash, because they diverge significantly from the TV show.
I've had a theory for a long time he's got the whole asoif done but it won't release until after his passing. That way he doesn't have to hear a word of backlash of the ending.
He should give his notes to the publisher and let a ghostwriter finish his Song of Ice and Fire story.
I wonder if the pressure has just been too much and he just keeps rewriting sections over and over again, never happy with the plot?
I’m convinced that he’ll never finish ASOIAF because then it’ll go down in history as his “great unfinished work” and he doesn’t risk fumbling the ending and leaving people disappointed.
He literally said after he finishes The Winds of Winter... so how is it doomed? And they could very well have screenwriters finish the Novellas, they're not exactly A Song Of Ice and Fire so it could never be botched on the level D&D did GoT.
Ain't nothing going to get finished 😢😢
What is the date for his last newly published book?
HBO should have just done the spin off of jon Snow..
HBO never wanted to do something like this! Why would they? What to see, Jon Snow hunting? There is so much material in the A Song of Ice and Fire universe! Why waste time inventing hunting stories when you can adapt from what is already written?
@alinvoica937 because these stories are never finished in the book. How long have we been waiting for winds of winter? Or is the writer gonna be able to write more of this upcoming series? At least with the jon snow story, it would be straightforward without worrying about an ending. Let's face it. The writer is 75 years old yeah he a great writer, but he slowed down as he aged. At least with the jon snow series, it would have been something to redeem the end of the Game of Thrones series.
@@endc3043 K, to make a series with Jon Snow!!! And what do you want to see? How do they hunt deer or rabbits? What's left for JonSnow to do? Ah, maybe he finds a wild one and makes about 10 children because he has his whole life ahead of him! And then do it in the far north? There are no more wars to fight, I remind you that the army of the dead has been destroyed! I agree that it is difficult to write at the age of 75 and we will probably never have the last two books completed, but there are still stories to adapt! I want to see the story of Aegon the Conqueror, I want to see Robert's Rebellion...I don't want to see what Jon Snow is doing in the North!
@@endc3043, Nothing could redeem the ending to GoT. Just forgetting about it and moving on is the best course of action.
I wonder if him seeing the horrible reaction to the TV ending is making him hesitant to finish the books