People like Irfan Junejo also promote crypto without proper disclaimers and without even realizing that it's the biggest scam of the 20th century. Ducky to wese b thora jaahil hai... Pese k aagay sab blind hn...
Yes and few other things as well. Roasting culture isn't good for young consumers as well. We need to speak about it rather than having this ultra modern mindset ' let everybody do whatever they want ' aur ' ye moral policing band kro'... 🤦
Bahi agr ap aj sy 5 6 saal phly dekhein tu bachon ko galiyan nhi ati thi balkey wesi galiyan ati hi nhi thi ksi ko lkn jb sy ye in Vlogers ny dena suro ki tu 6 class ka bacha bi wo dena suro ho gya ab bachon ko kiya smj k ye kiya ha wo tu isy normal bat smj k kr detey
No hate towards Ducky Bhai or similar vloggers, but their content isn't for me. I feel uncomfortable with the trend of showing family, especially wives, on social media. It seems like viewers are more interested in seeing the females rather than the content itself. I believe a wife is incredibly valuable and should be protected, not used as a tool for attention or profit. While they may have their reasons and perspectives, this is just my personal viewpoint. I'm open to hearing different opinions on this.
Yeah you are right if ducky bhai stops uploading vlogs the millions of people will watch other peoples vlogs so the problem is to change the mind of people, to make them stop watching this type of content
Yes but sadly many people try to act like they are modern and use certain phrases like ' live and let live ' , ' stop moral policing' etc etc. this is weird mindset and blind following of trends and that too based on individualism. Such individualism isn't encouraged in Muslim culture and what they call ' moral policing ' - (as something negative) is actually our responsibility when we see something bad or questionable out there in public we have to stop it and question it instead of following baseless concept ' live and let live , let anyone do whatever he/she wants '.
Sir I think so you have are very offended with Pakistani vloger because I have seen you in Razasamo video's comment section Where you are sharing that opinion and about that you are true
🤚 My content is purely educational. Started TH-cam with this exact anger, that why dont we make educational content. Why are we only doing fashion, makeup, and pranks. A few years back, I started homeschooling and saw American Moms with homeschooling channels and got really angry when I saw none of Pakistani Moms in the area. So, I started my own! 🎉
@shivang_kumar Urdu doesn't have Sanskrit words , Urdu is pre dominantly a Muslim language while Hindi isn't. Urdu is A national language of Pakistan. Urdu and Hindi aren't same. We don't use Hindi.
The viewers will see whatever is shown in the media... Just like Ducky Bhai, In the UK, there is also the Hanby family and many others who are getting views by doing funny pranks with their wives/girlfriend.
Indeed dhruv is one of the exceptional content creators and I have been following him since 2020, but here the thing is he was running a biased campaign, which we don't mark as wrong considering the freedom of speech, he has the right to speak whatever he wants.
@@allaboutplanes5132 cringe/entertainment is not a that big of a problem. The main issue is that he is going against Islamic principles just for attention and money gains, showing off his wife for views (who does not even cover herself to begin with), promoting gambling/betting sites, im pretty sure he would have such basic knowledge and sense to know that most of his audience is younger than 18 and knows how his cheap videos are affecting his audience. Still he doesnt care because money is way precious to your favorite youtuber whom you're defending so hard
Tareefing Standalone 4:26 Muzammil I started watching your videos long time back when you and your friends made revolutionary educational videos mostly outdoors and on your campus, and I must say that I have been so proud of you. If our education system has managed to produce such brilliant gems like you, with so much vision, sanity and conscience to contribute towards the betterment of society through creating constructive narratives then all is not lost and I have big hopes that things will be okay in the future IA. You give us hope!! Plz keep shining and sharing!!
I have followed him since the start of his channel. I find him biased towards Imran Khan. I think he lacks substance in his argument. Previously for a long time, he tows the establishment agenda consciously or unconsciously..
Put a drop of water into a pot of ink. You wont notice any difference. But put of drop of ink into a pot of water, and its clearly visible. We should def acknowledge good, but pointing out the ills of society isn't morally wrong but sometimes actually necessary. It also creates a space for debate which is necessary for intellectual growth. But I do agree that one should target the action and not the person and that there is a certain way of communicating your pov.
I agree, that’s a balanced approach. Giving others space is important, but there also needs to be someone who keeps them in check. Unfortunately, some people are extremely emotional driven, and they tend to go to either extreme. Balance and wisdom is a must. And yes, all of us are learning at the end of the day…
One of India's highest subscribed channels from the family vlog is from the southern part and is totally different language the mainstream hindi/urdu audience. 😅😅 I am sure very few pakistanis know about that. They only know hindi/urdu youtubers. You can't imagine the millions of subscribers from regional indian languages way bigger than Ducky or any youtubers. 😅😅
@@awais-pk I like how Pakistanis think that India is just the North-Indian Hindi speaking people who actually forms just 35 to 40% of the Entire Indian population 😂
I totally agree with you, my mother started watching TH-cam a few years back, she started watching Maaz Safdar's daily vlogs and then after a few months, she started watching some podcasts. The point is she as an audience evolves. She now knows what is podcast and she got to know the different varieties of content. She is still not in an infotainment phase but she is 59 years old and she is evolving and she will be in this phase soon. We have to give time to our nation. And sistorology, ducky and everyone do waste time because as a content creator, they should also evolve and change their pattern after 1 year, they should also grow. If my mother is growing from one stage to another then the creators should also analyze this and update their content accordingly or they can create a variety of content (some videos of entertainment and some of infotainment or educational or whatever) but they need to grow with time as well. If Maaz Safdar is not creating a video on business education like after gaining some experience on business then I think he is not growing. If Ducky is not creating content on AI and frauds and leaked videos (totally educational) then he is not growing. Also, the thing that I don't like is that Dukcy was invited to a Binance session in Turkey and he didn't even explain the crypto or information about Binance. He wasted an opportunity. I have a lot of similar examples. You are right there are types of consumers and consumers will evolve but similarly, vloggers need to grow as well.
bro simple demand and supply ka khail ha jab tak 1 cheez ki demand rahaygi tu agla uski supply kyu band kerayga jab demand khatum hogi tu khudhi change kerdaygay wah log. or shoud change ka scene nhi hota bhai jo unkay liya feasible ha wah unko apsay behter pata ha.
Pakistan is lucky to have content creators like faisal warraich, shahzad sheikh, tariq munir saab, talha ahad n both syed muzzamil. Junaid akram as well. Taimur rehman saab.
As Pakistanis, we have a strange mindset that has led to family vlogging becoming very popular, which is terrible. Why have we forgotten Islam? halal haram
@muzamilhasan India is not only hindi speaking belt north India. If you look at whole India you saw that India and pakistan are not same. There are huge different.
One problem in Pakistani TH-cam is that we don't have basic educational channels jo hmare course outine ko cover kre .. meri nazar se srf ek channel hi guzra Hassan Fareed jo physics parhate henn .. as compared to india , they have so many channels Ashu sir is everyone's fav !
Agree with you! The influencers and bloggers need to talk more about concerns circulating Pakistanis as humans and their character as humans above all so they promote kindness, tolerance, co-existence and questioning the wrong.
Agr ap aj sy 6 7 saal phly k k waqt ko yaad krein tu us waqt galiyun ka culture nhi tha wesi galiyan ksi ko ati bi nhi thi lkn Ducky bahi jesy TH-camr ny galiyan dy dy kr pesa kamaya or aj ye hal ha k 6 class ka bacha bi wo gali dena amm bat smjta inhain dekh dekh k ya tu Ducky bahi ko apna chanel 18+ k liye rkhna chahiye ya wo sari videos delete krni chahiye jin mei galiyan hain or ahinda deni bi nhi chahiyein
Bilkul bhai kasam se wo be kya din the jab log tareke se ik dosre se bat karte the. Ajj kal ke har 12 sal ke bache ke pass galiyon ke puri dictionary he.
Here's the problem Muzammil. We are an islamic country. Mein jb apne newphews aur nieces ko prophets ki stories sunata hun ya unhen islam ka btata hun and then they watch shit like sistrology and get influenced by them and 7 8 years old girl want to put their dancing video on youtube just because sistrology is doing it and they are so called very successful. This creates a contrast with the core islamic teachings which leads to depression or in worst case suicide or athiesm. Ya to islam chorh do ya ye muzammil shah wali munafiat chorh do. 2 exact opposite philosophies sirf aik munafiq dil mein jgah paa sakti hain
Bhai zara yeh bataiye ki akhir dance karne mei aur video blogging mei dikkat kya hai ? Dance seekhna aur ache videos banana toh ek achi baat hai. Haan, 7-8 saal ke bacho ke liye yeh munasib nahi, magar isse bilkul hi bekar bol dena, ya sire se khaarij kar dene mei toh samajhdari nahi hai.
@@AmeyVikram16 bro i am assuming you're from india and a non Muslim. You will not understand it. Ye woman ko objectify karta hai aur ye haya k khilaf jata hai jo hmari religion ki core requirement hai
@@anisulrehman7216 then you should leave it if you have such narrow mind you should not do this Its not about hindu muslim india have many muslim influencers with 20 million followers they are just dancing making reels if you can't grow up then don't complain
@@kju-dja213 btw in your open mind, growing up is getting 20M followers or its about dancing? I don't care what other muslims or hindus doing but i have all the rights to get concerned about my family. All these new shitty ideologies are brainwashed in your mind and labeled as openness and freedom. Recent addition is LGBTQ. Now don't start telling me couple of muslim influencers who are into this lol 😂 We both live in different worlds and even if you don't care, i care about my ideology, message, Prophet and my GOD and i stand and die for it
In general, I feel that people in Pakistan feel good by belittling others. They don't try to focus on getting better and acknowledging others' right to do whatever they want.
Being parha likha 'educated' doesn't mean you can't criticize people for making bad content. This is the most stupid and illogical argument that if you don't like something don't watch it but you don't have the right to criticize it. If the youtubers exercise their freedom of expression while making these content than viewers also have the freedom of expression to comment their content is bad or vulgar. It is as simple as that.
Dhruv rathee is from India but runs the channel from Germany. He doesn't belong to any political party he just didi the job of the journalists. So correct your mistake 😶
Tumhe usko nahi jante matlab ye nahinki baki log bhi nahi jante .....agar vo Banda famous nhi hota to carryminati se jyada subscribers nahi leta @@Muz_ammil
I don't know why we want to brush every new menace under the carpet and don't want to talk about It. Right Moral policing is always needed and it's encouraged in islam as well. We have maligned this term sadly
Now because that d.bhai is getting famous every other young kid wants to do the same . We need to realize where will it take the society in some years if it keeps on happening, we can try to pretend everything is fine and ' let everybody do whatever they want ' , ' stop moral policing ' but when problems will become complicated and more there will be people looking clueless asking for solutions. So instead of staying neutral we need to call out whats wrong ,or the negative impact any actions/content could have in near future , sensibly, in an educated and nice manner.
میں پروفیسر ہوں اور میں ذاتی طور پر آپ کے کام کو پسند کرتا ہوں نوجوان نسل سے رابطہ ہے میرا ، آپ کو کھل کر بولنا چاہیے کہ ایسی تفریح ہمارے گھریلو نظام کو متاثر کر رہی ہے بچے جو دیکھتے ہیں چند سال بعد اس کے اثرات ان میں نظر آتے ہیں
Brilliant analysis ☺️ Love the series and love your efforts to change the narrative and mindset. Still when you come to comment sections, it feels poeole have not watched (or understood) the video and mesaage. It's sad.
Great analysis! I have been through all these 3 stages of Internet and the relatability is huge. Plus, One thing that I learned after this video is 'Har cheez apne apne waqt par hoti hai'❤
@@ahmad_fed No.. I was a PTI supporter 3 years ago but now I do not support any of these mainstream parties. I was just curious after seeing your channels list because I had followed the same kind of channels... Except TBT which I still follow because I like Muzammil's analytical approach towards IT, Business and Social talk but not agree with his political views... i think he should dive deep into Politics, History and Philosophy to enrich his political ideas or viewpoint...
Sir Muzamilhasan. I am learning Python and would like your suggestion on whether I should pursue a career in data analysis/data science or focus on web frameworks like Django or Flask. I do not have an IT background, and I am currently working to support my family's finances. I am 25 years old and come from a village. Your guidance would be greatly appreciated.
Whatever comes more naturally to you bro, pehle kuch time khud pr lagao, coming from personal experience, changed careers when I was 24, Alhamdulillah all good now, took some time 2-3 months to figure what I want and what I have and how can I get there. good luck
If you understand and take a lot of interest in probability and statistics then go for data science else go for web. But before venturing into anyone of the career develop a learning path by consulting an expert of either of the field and then stay on it while you progress. Its common to get distracted or lose hope while you are learning but make sure you remain disciplined
Aj kal k daily youtubers ki videos informarive nahi hotin jis tarhan Irfan junejo ki hote han jaise k videography ,cinematography and color grading.aj kal youtubers khanay penay ki videos bana rahe han.
To the people worried about the influence of content on children - thats your own fault. You have to get a grip on the number of screens in your house. If you put televisions in your childrens rooms, if you put phones in their hands, if you put their laptops behind closed doors, don't be surprised when they are influenced by content you don't agree with. As parents you have a responsbility to filter/vet what content your children are engaging with. You wouldn't be comfortable if your child was talking to random people in the streets regularly, but you're okay to let the TV and the internet fill their minds with ideas you aren't aware of. Inside the home, interaction with social media, mobile phones etc should be limited, and you have to lead by example. The TV should be a tool to pass time if you have nothing better to do, not the centre peice of our drawing rooms. Engage with your families, talk to each other, do activities together, read together, discuss what you are reading - even watch content online together, let different family members pick, but have some insight into what your kids are watching and challenge the views if you feel the need to.
Muzamil bhai you are only guiding the audience but not telling the influence of vloggers who were manipulating the thinking pattern of children. Kids don't know that there 10 minute videos are all scripted in real life they were different people or you can say like us. Not everything and every day is cool and positive with happiness they just follow it but a 12 year old thinks that there life is ruined because of poverty or family problems that make them feel inferior. . This can be very dangerous.
I believe it is the parents' responsibility to monitor what their children are watching. For example, I see my cousin's kids, who are under 7, and they don't have any restrictions on the content they consume. These kids are scrolling through reels and videos that may not be appropriate for their age. It's unreasonable to expect every content creator to cater to all age groups, especially when platforms provide tools for parental control. Ultimately, parents need to be vigilant and proactive in setting boundaries. They should be aware of what their children are accessing online and take steps to ensure it's suitable for their age. Another point is the argument over the productivity of certain types of content. Some people compare different creators, such as Muzzamil Hassan, with others and argue that some content is not productive. However, individuals have the freedom to choose what they want to consume on TH-cam. It's not fair to expect all creators to conform to a single standard or to criticize them for producing content that doesn’t fit someone’s idea of what’s valuable. Each creator has their own style and audience, and it’s up to the viewers to decide what they want to watch.
@@AhmadAzzam-nh7guit's about the perspective also .. I mean Meri Chachi , she always keeps an eye on her daughter what she is watching but in her view , sistrology is ok to watch instead of watching songs/films .. SB ka apna apna Sahi or ghalat hota h .
today you are talking about ducky bhai etc..if ducky stops making his videos from now on..I am 100 percent sure people will start watching someone else who creates such type of content..its not the problem of ducky,sistrology..its we the people who watches it...TH-cam is evolving day by day with new vloggers..I think the title should be "THE PROBLEM WITH PAKISTANI VIEWERS".😁
This was an excellent video! I watch your videos off and on and enjoy most of them. But this one was exceptional and the analysis of the evolution of internet in India and Pakistan is extremely informative! Thanks Muzammil! Best wishes from India!
All people are blaming govt of Pakistan for their poor growth but why can't anyone see these types of cringe velogers I request all Pakistani citizens to lets unite and boycott such contentI know Pakistani audience is way mature and can understand what I am saying just look at the example of india which is growing constantly just because they are unite their government is strong because they choose right person but in Pakistan there is nothing like that. Pakistan's worst condition could only be solved by Pakistani people itself!!❤ Love all Pakistanis and best wishes for their growth!!😊
Only idiots are saying Dhruv Rathee made an impact. His impact was 0. The maths is simple. The followers of Dhruv Rathee have never voted for BJP. This is not the first time where he had built his propaganda against BJPs propaganda machine. He did it in 2019. The result, BJPs massive victory. How many followers does he have ? 2.2 Cr. How many views does his video gather ? Max 1.5-2 Cr. That’s less viewership than Indian Soap operas. Indian population is 150Cr. By what percentage did his viewership increase in 2024 from 2019 (where he was way more active). It’s not a big increase. Meanwhile, I have not factored in the troll army who subscribe to his videos just to put in negative comments, nor have I factored in the age group (only 18+ can vote). Not to forget that most people who watch his videos are from urban centres where the BJP has done brilliantly. Indian elections are way too complicated. Pakistanis with their reductionist approach cannot grasp it. BJP was reduced due to a gamut of local issues and politics and not because of a TH-camr. India is a vibrant democracy. People don’t vote because of a TH-camr. They vote for their own issues even if they are vanilla or mundane. Moreover BJP was reduced in the rural centres of UP, Bihar and Maharashtra. That’s where they lost their majority seats. Hardly anyone watches his videos in those areas. Numbers and stats don’t lie.
@usamayousuf6871 I don’t have a bone to pick up with either Muzammil or Dhruv. They are entitled to their opinion and business model. My point is that TH-camrs don’t shape the political landscape in a diverse country like India. It is the local issues which do. BJP has been losing and winning continuously in the state elections. Also, BJP does not govern India. It’s the state, central government, municipal bodies, rural bodies along with a completely independent judicial structure which do. There are more than a dozen of parties which govern India. The centre can’t meddle in the affairs of the state. If they want, it is a laborious route which the centre always avoids. India is a federation with unitary bias with very strong grassroot level democratic institutions. The society where my house in India is located, has a governing body which is recognised by the constitution and it functions independently as an independent democratic governing body. It has elections and what not. Same is the case with thousands other urban and rural bodies. The problem is that people put TH-camrs on a pedestal and turn a blind eye towards pragmatism. People are entitled to listen to whosoever they want to. Criticise whoever they want to. But in doing so must recognise the right of the other party as well, which Muzammil has highlighted. He wants to save his business, I support it. My point is that he is just a TH-camr like Dhruv and many others with limited influence. The issues which he highlights are structural and should be viewed by the intelligentsia of Pakistan in that light. He is not the problem, the society is the problem.
The reason their vlogs are not worth is because, some people might bot have the privileges and luxuries that these vloggers show. This could cause a social anxiety or complexes in the society.
Solid move with the course. The market needs it. People are ready and super happy that you'll be sharing what you know. Lives will be changed. More impact will be created. More power to you.
I onced came to view ducky bhai video n i was absolutely surprised to hear below the belt creepy language n garbage on the name of content n entertainment 🤮
All good but India and Pak same ? No bhai it is not, For example Indian army is India's army but yours ? India is secular & we had Muslim president, Sikh PM & Christian defense minister something which would never happen in your Pakistan and i can go on and on ...
Well done Muzammil. I am myself trying to change the content uptake in the Pakistani space. Trying my best to come up with fresh content different from what we see at the moment. Your help is appreciated. Let the change begin!
Well explained the concept of internet consumers, appreciate that you are thoroughly researched and educate your audience based on true figures and facts. I appreciate that this video was more than just bashing and sorting content creators as bad or good.
I used to watch ducky vlogs they were funny but then I got bored. I started watching rajab family vlogs they were fun new content daily but after a while I felt He is just showing his money off but still i used to watch his mother is really nice. Breaking point for me was when he celebrated his sisters bday took her inlaws her family friends cousins in her bedroom where she was sleeping or acting i dont know but it was so awkward like why would u show that ? No respect really.
I love your vlogs but not sure why you selected this topic? It appears to me that you got distracted by some negative comments. I suggest you keep doing your work and stop worrying about negative comments
I like daily vloggers because it makes me updated on Pakistani trends and daily life. Both in cities and in villages. But also I like the educational and political content. That also keeeps me updated on Pakistani life. What I do not like is haters and gali wali roasting. As a Pakistani living in Europe, I have seen that Pakistani content is gettig better day by day.
Bade bhai, pakistani youtubers ke bhi maximum 'intellectual' subscribers Indians hain. This is apparent if toy go through the comments section. The number could be anything from 20% to 70%, depending on the channel.
I do not totally agree with your perspective but respect you, you analyzed brilliantly on content consumers, you're well educated, productive person, and an educated TH-camr. 🙌
Muzammil Bhai, You are doing an incredible job by making this series, It's really teaching me to view things from the different persective, I REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR EFFORTS
Ducky bhai promotes gambling which is haram and he hasnt speak a single thing about Palestinians btw not just ducky bhai but every pakistani so called influencer hasnt said a single thing about palestine or boycotted any product instead they are shamlessly promoting them. I think nobody should sell thier conscience for money and fame. Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Hey, Muzamil u were spot on relating to the evolution of the content, I 100% can relate with you ,now I am in that face were I want to extract something from the content and I found you❤
Some correction: in india there are 6 unicorns edtech company(byju not included)...and more than 27+ educational base individual content creater (not including podcaster) whose subscriber more than average 10m+...mostly indian hi Pakistani podcast dekte haii...u checked Pakistani seminar , conclave etc 90% indian viewership meligee....unfortunately Pakistan me education ka seen tumhari economy se bi bahut bura haiiii.....
10M + subscribers is also because of the large population.But I agree education system is not in a good state in Pakistan. I have seen top daily Vloggers who are wealthy and live in cities like Karachi or Lahore. One can easily deduce that they did'nt go to good schools. However the education is system in India also has it's share of flaws.
Do you have a cognitive issue that prevented you from understanding this video, or is it your deep-seated animosity towards Pakistan that compelled you to post such an absurdly ignorant comment to relieve your life stress? In either case, let me repeat and rephrase what the key point mentioned in this video which you have failed to comprehend. A Pakistani internet user is at least 5 years younger compared to an Indian internet user, so this evolution is Moreover, did you factor in the fact that your population is 6 times as much as of Pakistan? Milestones of million are less valuable when your population is in billion. Thirdly, If Indians are consuming Pakistani educational content, there are also Pakistanis consuming Indian educational videos. Lastly, this video was made by a data analyst who has facts and figures, while your horrendously written statement is based on emotions.
Do you have a cognitive issue that prevented you from understanding this video, or is it your deep-seated animosity towards Pakistan that compelled you to post such an absurdly ignorant comment to relieve your life stress? In either case, let me repeat and rephrase what the key point mentioned in this video which you have failed to comprehend. A Pakistani internet user is at least 5 years younger compared to an Indian internet user, so this evolution is Moreover, did you factor in the fact that your population is 6 times as much as of Pakistan? Milestones of million are less valuable when your population is in billion. Thirdly, If Indians are consuming Pakistani educational content, there are also Pakistanis consuming Indian educational videos. Lastly, this video was made by a data analyst who has facts and figures, while your horrendously written statement is based on emotions.
@@Vanillevirus Pakistan's Education system is comparable to Afghanistan's (not India's). Please don't try to degread India by comparing with Pakistan, Afghanistan type countries
I don't hate the success of these vloggers. Their promotion of western ideology, western way of living and secularism is what I hate. Why can't you promote your own traditons, culture and religion. Why do you have to be so influenced by the west.
the thing about overnight is not true....a big chunk of his audience is pakistani from a very long time... personally along with me 'i have found my many friends and people around me knowing him... his topics are not only politics based... so saying that its a overnight success and fame would be wrong statement... he is making videos for quite a long time which are well researched and edited.. straight to point to bs... this is absolutely true that ducky bhai and other vloggers in pakistan are setting unrealistic expections for their young viewers .. most of their audience is youth and kids , who hav;nt faced the reai world.. who think that making pranks vedios and vloges can make them earn this type of living which is shownn by their vloggers .. and that;s destroying young minds. so the critisizm is right in my opinon... the critisizm is right but the camparision with india is absolutely wrong.
Yes but druv rathee said alot of negative things against Pakistan and In typical Hindustani style if Pakistani viewers become aware of that they might start to unsubscribe him quicker than we think. Also those new followers who are Liking him now might be from Imran khan's cult followers , and as soon as that guy speaks again their Messiah Imran khan they gonna leave him. Lol. So these things shouldn't be taken seriously. Everyone is biased and majority of people especially in young generation doesn't have any ideology or have their own mindset.
@@goals27 absolutely. Everyone is biased in some way so is druv. But beside politics that man has done a great job. Discussing different topics how different things work and the knowledge about the world. I think we owe him an appreciation. He has been working for a long time now and I'm definitely a big fan .
@@AdAstra-x9m personally I Don't become a fan of Indians that easily especially those who try to be over smart and take digs at Pakistan which Pakistanis usually don't understand. We need to be smart enough to know who we should be fan of and who we should ignore. So yes I disagree.
It's an excellent analysis bruh ~ a very macro perspective discussion. One advice for everyone who is watching, try to really understand the video and look at 2026 or 2027 instead of right now. Listen to 30:30 onwards, that's the crux of the whole video.
Once i passed my curiosity stage and i was in my entertainment stage and suddenly i saw a short video of Azad Chaiwala he was promoting Their institute and then i research about Azad Chaiwala and my educational journey was started and at the end of 2023 i am watching this channel...
There isn't any reflection on anyone by disliking someone. There is an equal freedom of expression. As much as people are free to like "there" content without being labelled anything, equally, people have full right to criticise "there" content without being told that they have "inferiority complex". If you come infront of a camera in public to earn money, then be ready to face both sides of the society, simple.
Its hard to give out my opinions when everything that I wanted to say was already said in such a uniform and informative manner that there was nothing else left to be added. Amazing job
I'm feeling proud that.. finally people are recognising dhruv rathee.. though I'm following him from past 6 years Like druve rathee I'm following jihad also from past 6 years but i see that he's still not have much recognition.. And I'm following you since you make Facebook videos with your few friends where you share educational content.. much respect for all of them who share quality content ❤️
One major issue with Ducky that people don't point is he promotes gambling app, which is even worse for younger audience...
People like Irfan Junejo also promote crypto without proper disclaimers and without even realizing that it's the biggest scam of the 20th century. Ducky to wese b thora jaahil hai... Pese k aagay sab blind hn...
Yes and few other things as well. Roasting culture isn't good for young consumers as well. We need to speak about it rather than having this ultra modern mindset ' let everybody do whatever they want ' aur ' ye moral policing band kro'... 🤦
@@shahbazakhtar101 jahil tu hai bro , crypto ko scam bolne wala jahil hai 😂, thora education lele
Bahi agr ap aj sy 5 6 saal phly dekhein tu bachon ko galiyan nhi ati thi balkey wesi galiyan ati hi nhi thi ksi ko lkn jb sy ye in Vlogers ny dena suro ki tu 6 class ka bacha bi wo dena suro ho gya ab bachon ko kiya smj k ye kiya ha wo tu isy normal bat smj k kr detey
@@shahbazakhtar101 it's what aboutism
Dhruv Rathee agar pakistan me hota to missing persons ki list me hota.
Sadly
Hardly true 😊
You said 1000 percent truth. I totally agree with you
Wo india mai hota to bhe yehi haal hota, he lives in Germany.
@@Mahrooshay abe wo india mai hi tha election k time mai usne video bhi dala tha Delhi ka india Gate k pass.
No hate towards Ducky Bhai or similar vloggers, but their content isn't for me. I feel uncomfortable with the trend of showing family, especially wives, on social media. It seems like viewers are more interested in seeing the females rather than the content itself. I believe a wife is incredibly valuable and should be protected, not used as a tool for attention or profit. While they may have their reasons and perspectives, this is just my personal viewpoint. I'm open to hearing different opinions on this.
totally agreed 👍
Duckey destroy people mind wash and not educational video only tharki video.
Yeah you are right if ducky bhai stops uploading vlogs the millions of people will watch other peoples vlogs so the problem is to change the mind of people, to make them stop watching this type of content
Well spoken, its not just your personal opinion, this is literally the Muslim belief
Yes but sadly many people try to act like they are modern and use certain phrases like ' live and let live ' , ' stop moral policing' etc etc. this is weird mindset and blind following of trends and that too based on individualism. Such individualism isn't encouraged in Muslim culture and what they call ' moral policing ' - (as something negative) is actually our responsibility when we see something bad or questionable out there in public we have to stop it and question it instead of following baseless concept ' live and let live , let anyone do whatever he/she wants '.
Always wanted to talk about this topic but you did it very wisely! Wonderful analysis. and us se bhi zyada, beautiful light setup
Sir I think so you have are very offended with Pakistani vloger because I have seen you in Razasamo video's comment section Where you are sharing that opinion and about that you are true
Jo Indian content yahan pr share krta h us channel KO ban hojana chahye immediately
@@goals27 wasif bhai wesy comment to light k liy hi tha. Ha k nai😁
@@Saifullah-kc9vm g Bhai ..theek SE likhh do...Jo b Likha h....Meri baat shyd aap smjhy ni....ya me apka comment ni smjha
Which video ? @@svsahab4785
🤚 My content is purely educational.
Started TH-cam with this exact anger, that why dont we make educational content. Why are we only doing fashion, makeup, and pranks.
A few years back, I started homeschooling and saw American Moms with homeschooling channels and got really angry when I saw none of Pakistani Moms in the area. So, I started my own! 🎉
Your content looks great. Subbed
Well-done baji
@shivang_kumar it's urdu. Not Hindi. Please stay away
@shivang_kumar Urdu doesn't have Sanskrit words , Urdu is pre dominantly a Muslim language while Hindi isn't. Urdu is A national language of Pakistan. Urdu and Hindi aren't same. We don't use Hindi.
@shivang_kumar plus I have seen your comments against islam and Muslims in the comment section. So don't pretend here.
I can't believe you're uploading all this content for free, it's like a content creation masterclass
How is it free? He makes money
Seeing Awam with intellectual comments gave me hope, instead of saying that he is spreading hate, you understand his point of view.
Dhaki chupi baat mai Muzamil is saying "Issue content ka nai, consumer ka hai"
With which I definitely agree :P
and that consumer is also going to be a sensible man soon so its just a matter of time but the Audience that watch such content will still exist...
The viewers will see whatever is shown in the media... Just like Ducky Bhai, In the UK, there is also the Hanby family and many others who are getting views by doing funny pranks with their wives/girlfriend.
We need to produce good content and support by Sharing them . TBT, Dekho Suno, The wide side and many more.
Yara Issue content ka kese he. Bache to jo ai ga dekhen ge youtube pe. Ducky bhai jo ik adult he is ko zaida responsible hona chahye na.
no chutiya sab. he is actually saying there is no issue.
Dhruv Rathee ki Indian elections sy pehly hi 17m subscribers thy and he is very intelligent. He makes more educational videos then political videos.
Right 👍👍👍👍
Indeed dhruv is one of the exceptional content creators and I have been following him since 2020, but here the thing is he was running a biased campaign, which we don't mark as wrong considering the freedom of speech, he has the right to speak whatever he wants.
You’re right bro. Completely agreed.
The irony is you have to apologize for a 'padhi likhi' video 😢
'padhi' Kia hota h?
@@syedabdulraffay7354 educational*
He had to apologise for this?
@@ReggieMisFit I am referring to the way he was saying sorry multiple times just because he's speaking the truth and a critical analysis.
@@bilalazhar5707 He did not said sorry for making this video, he said it for using a click-bait title, which is unethical.
There is a difference between entertaining and cringe.
What's cringe to you is entertainment to someone else..
Grow up, sir/ma'am
@@allaboutplanes5132pendu taste
@@allaboutplanes5132 cringe/entertainment is not a that big of a problem. The main issue is that he is going against Islamic principles just for attention and money gains, showing off his wife for views (who does not even cover herself to begin with), promoting gambling/betting sites, im pretty sure he would have such basic knowledge and sense to know that most of his audience is younger than 18 and knows how his cheap videos are affecting his audience. Still he doesnt care because money is way precious to your favorite youtuber whom you're defending so hard
20:00
@@uk4490 I'm sorry but true asf
Tareefing Standalone 4:26 Muzammil I started watching your videos long time back when you and your friends made revolutionary educational videos mostly outdoors and on your campus, and I must say that I have been so proud of you. If our education system has managed to produce such brilliant gems like you, with so much vision, sanity and conscience to contribute towards the betterment of society through creating constructive narratives then all is not lost and I have big hopes that things will be okay in the future IA. You give us hope!! Plz keep shining and sharing!!
Watching not because of the title but it's the person who is doing it...well done
WIDE SIDE is an underrated great channel.
Great Guy
I have followed him since the start of his channel. I find him biased towards Imran Khan. I think he lacks substance in his argument. Previously for a long time, he tows the establishment agenda consciously or unconsciously..
True
Great bnda hai❤
Overrated
Put a drop of water into a pot of ink. You wont notice any difference.
But put of drop of ink into a pot of water, and its clearly visible.
We should def acknowledge good, but pointing out the ills of society isn't morally wrong but sometimes actually necessary. It also creates a space for debate which is necessary for intellectual growth. But I do agree that one should target the action and not the person and that there is a certain way of communicating your pov.
I agree, that’s a balanced approach.
Giving others space is important, but there also needs to be someone who keeps them in check.
Unfortunately, some people are extremely emotional driven, and they tend to go to either extreme.
Balance and wisdom is a must.
And yes, all of us are learning at the end of the day…
Sahi kaha
Very well said. But sadly it is the person doing the action. So the person is the horse and action is the cart .
One of India's highest subscribed channels from the family vlog is from the southern part and is totally different language the mainstream hindi/urdu audience. 😅😅 I am sure very few pakistanis know about that. They only know hindi/urdu youtubers. You can't imagine the millions of subscribers from regional indian languages way bigger than Ducky or any youtubers. 😅😅
you're missing the whole point.
@@awais-pk I like how Pakistanis think that India is just the North-Indian Hindi speaking people who actually forms just 35 to 40% of the Entire Indian population 😂
I totally agree with you, my mother started watching TH-cam a few years back, she started watching Maaz Safdar's daily vlogs and then after a few months, she started watching some podcasts. The point is she as an audience evolves. She now knows what is podcast and she got to know the different varieties of content.
She is still not in an infotainment phase but she is 59 years old and she is evolving and she will be in this phase soon.
We have to give time to our nation.
And sistorology, ducky and everyone do waste time because as a content creator, they should also evolve and change their pattern after 1 year, they should also grow. If my mother is growing from one stage to another then the creators should also analyze this and update their content accordingly or they can create a variety of content (some videos of entertainment and some of infotainment or educational or whatever) but they need to grow with time as well.
If Maaz Safdar is not creating a video on business education like after gaining some experience on business then I think he is not growing.
If Ducky is not creating content on AI and frauds and leaked videos (totally educational) then he is not growing.
Also, the thing that I don't like is that Dukcy was invited to a Binance session in Turkey and he didn't even explain the crypto or information about Binance. He wasted an opportunity. I have a lot of similar examples.
You are right there are types of consumers and consumers will evolve but similarly, vloggers need to grow as well.
bro simple demand and supply ka khail ha jab tak 1 cheez ki demand rahaygi tu agla uski supply kyu band kerayga jab demand khatum hogi tu khudhi change kerdaygay wah log. or shoud change ka scene nhi hota bhai jo unkay liya feasible ha wah unko apsay behter pata ha.
Pakistan is lucky to have content creators like faisal warraich, shahzad sheikh, tariq munir saab, talha ahad n both syed muzzamil. Junaid akram as well. Taimur rehman saab.
Also Furqan Qureshi
Wildlife with dr waseem and Aashir Azim also
Nd mooro also
Asad Ali Toor, Matih ullah Jan.
As Pakistanis, we have a strange mindset that has led to family vlogging becoming very popular, which is terrible. Why have we forgotten Islam? halal haram
@muzamilhasan India is not only hindi speaking belt north India. If you look at whole India you saw that India and pakistan are not same. There are huge different.
Exactly.
These people think India is just the North-Indian Hindi belt people
One problem in Pakistani TH-cam is that we don't have basic educational channels jo hmare course outine ko cover kre .. meri nazar se srf ek channel hi guzra Hassan Fareed jo physics parhate henn .. as compared to india , they have so many channels Ashu sir is everyone's fav !
Bhai mene programming PerfectWebSoultions seseekhi hai or woh banda JEhlum Pakistan se hai 😍
Agree with you! The influencers and bloggers need to talk more about concerns circulating Pakistanis as humans and their character as humans above all so they promote kindness, tolerance, co-existence and questioning the wrong.
Co existence in what sense
Agr ap aj sy 6 7 saal phly k k waqt ko yaad krein tu us waqt galiyun ka culture nhi tha wesi galiyan ksi ko ati bi nhi thi lkn Ducky bahi jesy TH-camr ny galiyan dy dy kr pesa kamaya or aj ye hal ha k 6 class ka bacha bi wo gali dena amm bat smjta inhain dekh dekh k ya tu Ducky bahi ko apna chanel 18+ k liye rkhna chahiye ya wo sari videos delete krni chahiye jin mei galiyan hain or ahinda deni bi nhi chahiyein
Bilkul bhai kasam se wo be kya din the jab log tareke se ik dosre se bat karte the. Ajj kal ke har 12 sal ke bache ke pass galiyon ke puri dictionary he.
Here's the problem Muzammil. We are an islamic country.
Mein jb apne newphews aur nieces ko prophets ki stories sunata hun ya unhen islam ka btata hun
and then they watch shit like sistrology and get influenced by them and 7 8 years old girl want to put their dancing video on youtube just because sistrology is doing it and they are so called very successful.
This creates a contrast with the core islamic teachings which leads to depression or in worst case suicide or athiesm.
Ya to islam chorh do ya ye muzammil shah wali munafiat chorh do. 2 exact opposite philosophies sirf aik munafiq dil mein jgah paa sakti hain
Bhai zara yeh bataiye ki akhir dance karne mei aur video blogging mei dikkat kya hai ? Dance seekhna aur ache videos banana toh ek achi baat hai. Haan, 7-8 saal ke bacho ke liye yeh munasib nahi, magar isse bilkul hi bekar bol dena, ya sire se khaarij kar dene mei toh samajhdari nahi hai.
@@AmeyVikram16 bro i am assuming you're from india and a non Muslim. You will not understand it. Ye woman ko objectify karta hai aur ye haya k khilaf jata hai jo hmari religion ki core requirement hai
@@anisulrehman7216 then you should leave it if you have such narrow mind you should not do this Its not about hindu muslim india have many muslim influencers with 20 million followers they are just dancing making reels if you can't grow up then don't complain
@@kju-dja213 btw in your open mind, growing up is getting 20M followers or its about dancing?
I don't care what other muslims or hindus doing but i have all the rights to get concerned about my family.
All these new shitty ideologies are brainwashed in your mind and labeled as openness and freedom. Recent addition is LGBTQ.
Now don't start telling me couple of muslim influencers who are into this lol 😂
We both live in different worlds and even if you don't care, i care about my ideology, message, Prophet and my GOD and i stand and die for it
Baluchistan's missing person
Baluchistan's missing person
Baluchistan's missing person
In general, I feel that people in Pakistan feel good by belittling others. They don't try to focus on getting better and acknowledging others' right to do whatever they want.
Im glad that I haven’t seen a single vlog of ducky and maaz
You cant say he is biased. He talked against congress as well. In Pakistan no one can talk against army. No one, not easy
Aam admi party😂😂😂
@@hinduknight2193 zeyada hasny ki zaroorat ni hy. angrizoh ny hindu muslim ko divida karky india ko tor dia. bacha huva india modi tor raha hy.
Being parha likha 'educated' doesn't mean you can't criticize people for making bad content.
This is the most stupid and illogical argument that if you don't like something don't watch it but you don't have the right to criticize it.
If the youtubers exercise their freedom of expression while making these content than viewers also have the freedom of expression to comment their content is bad or vulgar. It is as simple as that.
Dhruv rathee is from India but runs the channel from Germany. He doesn't belong to any political party he just didi the job of the journalists. So correct your mistake 😶
He is with AAP aadmi party....😂😂
He's Totally one-sided.. he doesn't say anything about opposition's nonsense..
He is totally pro aap/indi.alliance
Gangadhar hi Shaktimaam hai
AAP AAP AAP
@@anomalous94 bewakoof Insan Ruling Party is responsible for the decisions taking place in the country
The problem is not of parha likha tabqa in case of Dhruv Rathee, It's More About Standing For Principles
I would like to correct one thing, that top TH-camr of India is acharya prashant, and not CARRIMINATY..
Haan vahi mai bhi keh raha tha. Factual inaccuracy hai iss video mei, to push a certain narrative perhaps.
LKN fact yeah h kay log carryminati ko zyda jantay hain fame uskay pass zyda h mai ajj pehli baar naam suna Acharya kaa !!
Tumhe usko nahi jante matlab ye nahinki baki log bhi nahi jante
.....agar vo Banda famous nhi hota to carryminati se jyada subscribers nahi leta @@Muz_ammil
good video but... you didnt exposed ducky bhai you CLICKBAIT the title
The only educated TH-cam in Pakistan ❤
Faisal Warraich also
Bhai youtuber hota ha
He won't like you comparing him 😂😅
I don't know why we want to brush every new menace under the carpet and don't want to talk about It.
Right Moral policing is always needed and it's encouraged in islam as well. We have maligned this term sadly
Now because that d.bhai is getting famous every other young kid wants to do the same . We need to realize where will it take the society in some years if it keeps on happening, we can try to pretend everything is fine and ' let everybody do whatever they want ' , ' stop moral policing ' but when problems will become complicated and more there will be people looking clueless asking for solutions. So instead of staying neutral we need to call out whats wrong ,or the negative impact any actions/content could have in near future , sensibly, in an educated and nice manner.
میں پروفیسر ہوں اور میں ذاتی طور پر آپ کے کام کو پسند کرتا ہوں نوجوان نسل سے رابطہ ہے میرا ، آپ کو کھل کر بولنا چاہیے کہ ایسی تفریح ہمارے گھریلو نظام کو متاثر کر رہی ہے بچے جو دیکھتے ہیں چند سال بعد اس کے اثرات ان میں نظر آتے ہیں
Brilliant analysis ☺️ Love the series and love your efforts to change the narrative and mindset. Still when you come to comment sections, it feels poeole have not watched (or understood) the video and mesaage. It's sad.
👏
BRO NOW YOU ARE INSPIRING ME TO BECOME DATA ANALYST
Very well defined .
Pakistan has a lot of morality policemen, we don’t need more of them anymore.
Great analysis!
I have been through all these 3 stages of Internet and the relatability is huge. Plus, One thing that I learned after this video is 'Har cheez apne apne waqt par hoti hai'❤
Hasi tv
Furqan qureshi blogs
Tbt podcast
Moeed pirzada
Wajahat saeed
All are educated channels
It seems like you are Imran Khan supporter. Am I right?
(Just analyzing my analytical skills, no judgements)
@@minhajraza6740 yes I am are you Nawaz Sharif supporter bro
@@ahmad_fed No..
I was a PTI supporter 3 years ago but now I do not support any of these mainstream parties.
I was just curious after seeing your channels list because I had followed the same kind of channels...
Except TBT which I still follow because I like Muzammil's analytical approach towards IT, Business and Social talk but not agree with his political views... i think he should dive deep into Politics, History and Philosophy to enrich his political ideas or viewpoint...
The Pakistan experience
Syed muzammil shah
Taimoor Rahman
@@UzairAshrafj 💯
You could have been the best vlogger in Pakistan, but you have never been neutral; instead, you've been an integral part of PTI.
Sir Muzamilhasan. I am learning Python and would like your suggestion on whether I should pursue a career in data analysis/data science or focus on web frameworks like Django or Flask. I do not have an IT background, and I am currently working to support my family's finances. I am 25 years old and come from a village. Your guidance would be greatly appreciated.
Depends on what you enjoy more. Lot of opportunities in both fields!
Whatever comes more naturally to you bro, pehle kuch time khud pr lagao, coming from personal experience, changed careers when I was 24, Alhamdulillah all good now, took some time 2-3 months to figure what I want and what I have and how can I get there. good luck
If you understand and take a lot of interest in probability and statistics then go for data science else go for web. But before venturing into anyone of the career develop a learning path by consulting an expert of either of the field and then stay on it while you progress. Its common to get distracted or lose hope while you are learning but make sure you remain disciplined
What disagreement do you have with Syed Muzammil Shah and Shehzad Ghias?
Aj kal k daily youtubers ki videos informarive nahi hotin jis tarhan Irfan junejo ki hote han jaise k videography ,cinematography and color grading.aj kal youtubers khanay penay ki videos bana rahe han.
I don't know why I am loving this series.
This guy never disappoints , amazing Analysis, muzammil bhai podcasts ab nhi aen gi ?
To the people worried about the influence of content on children - thats your own fault. You have to get a grip on the number of screens in your house. If you put televisions in your childrens rooms, if you put phones in their hands, if you put their laptops behind closed doors, don't be surprised when they are influenced by content you don't agree with. As parents you have a responsbility to filter/vet what content your children are engaging with. You wouldn't be comfortable if your child was talking to random people in the streets regularly, but you're okay to let the TV and the internet fill their minds with ideas you aren't aware of.
Inside the home, interaction with social media, mobile phones etc should be limited, and you have to lead by example. The TV should be a tool to pass time if you have nothing better to do, not the centre peice of our drawing rooms. Engage with your families, talk to each other, do activities together, read together, discuss what you are reading - even watch content online together, let different family members pick, but have some insight into what your kids are watching and challenge the views if you feel the need to.
The issue is not that there is no educational content in Pakistan but the problem is that the viewership of educational content is very low
Thakti
Raftar
Jesy chanels hai Deko tou
I really don't know you. Only reason why I clicked on this videos is Rathee's photo in your thaumbnail.
Muzamil bhai you are only guiding the audience but not telling the influence of vloggers who were manipulating the thinking pattern of children. Kids don't know that there 10 minute videos are all scripted in real life they were different people or you can say like us. Not everything and every day is cool and positive with happiness they just follow it but a 12 year old thinks that there life is ruined because of poverty or family problems that make them feel inferior. . This can be very dangerous.
Strongly agree.
I believe it is the parents' responsibility to monitor what their children are watching. For example, I see my cousin's kids, who are under 7, and they don't have any restrictions on the content they consume. These kids are scrolling through reels and videos that may not be appropriate for their age. It's unreasonable to expect every content creator to cater to all age groups, especially when platforms provide tools for parental control.
Ultimately, parents need to be vigilant and proactive in setting boundaries. They should be aware of what their children are accessing online and take steps to ensure it's suitable for their age.
Another point is the argument over the productivity of certain types of content. Some people compare different creators, such as Muzzamil Hassan, with others and argue that some content is not productive. However, individuals have the freedom to choose what they want to consume on TH-cam. It's not fair to expect all creators to conform to a single standard or to criticize them for producing content that doesn’t fit someone’s idea of what’s valuable. Each creator has their own style and audience, and it’s up to the viewers to decide what they want to watch.
That's a great point!
@@AhmadAzzam-nh7guit's about the perspective also .. I mean Meri Chachi , she always keeps an eye on her daughter what she is watching but in her view , sistrology is ok to watch instead of watching songs/films .. SB ka apna apna Sahi or ghalat hota h .
@Zayan yes you're right.
today you are talking about ducky bhai etc..if ducky stops making his videos from now on..I am 100 percent sure people will start watching someone else who creates such type of content..its not the problem of ducky,sistrology..its we the people who watches it...TH-cam is evolving day by day with new vloggers..I think the title should be "THE PROBLEM WITH PAKISTANI VIEWERS".😁
People appreciating dhruv are the same ones who criticize those who criticize IK 😂
Hypocrites
Or you may say they are same who appreciated those who on the basis of principle bases criticize Nawaz n Zardari
@@hanikhan9192😂jab jawab Nahin hota aur sach kadwa hota hai tou youthia apne baap Nawaz sharif zardari ko lekar ajate hain
Nicely explained every aspect.....
I think no harm in family blogging if some decency is there....
This was an excellent video! I watch your videos off and on and enjoy most of them. But this one was exceptional and the analysis of the evolution of internet in India and Pakistan is extremely informative! Thanks Muzammil! Best wishes from India!
All people are blaming govt of Pakistan for their poor growth but why can't anyone see these types of cringe velogers I request all Pakistani citizens to lets unite and boycott such contentI know Pakistani audience is way mature and can understand what I am saying just look at the example of india which is growing constantly just because they are unite their government is strong because they choose right person but in Pakistan there is nothing like that. Pakistan's worst condition could only be solved by Pakistani people itself!!❤ Love all Pakistanis and best wishes for their growth!!😊
Ducky Bhai exposed likhdeta hu shayad relevant hojau.
I don't watch ducky Bhai btw 😭
Only idiots are saying Dhruv Rathee made an impact. His impact was 0. The maths is simple. The followers of Dhruv Rathee have never voted for BJP. This is not the first time where he had built his propaganda against BJPs propaganda machine. He did it in 2019. The result, BJPs massive victory. How many followers does he have ? 2.2 Cr. How many views does his video gather ? Max 1.5-2 Cr. That’s less viewership than Indian Soap operas. Indian population is 150Cr.
By what percentage did his viewership increase in 2024 from 2019 (where he was way more active). It’s not a big increase. Meanwhile, I have not factored in the troll army who subscribe to his videos just to put in negative comments, nor have I factored in the age group (only 18+ can vote). Not to forget that most people who watch his videos are from urban centres where the BJP has done brilliantly.
Indian elections are way too complicated. Pakistanis with their reductionist approach cannot grasp it. BJP was reduced due to a gamut of local issues and politics and not because of a TH-camr. India is a vibrant democracy. People don’t vote because of a TH-camr. They vote for their own issues even if they are vanilla or mundane. Moreover BJP was reduced in the rural centres of UP, Bihar and Maharashtra. That’s where they lost their majority seats. Hardly anyone watches his videos in those areas.
Numbers and stats don’t lie.
Absolutely on point.
@usamayousuf6871 I don’t have a bone to pick up with either Muzammil or Dhruv. They are entitled to their opinion and business model. My point is that TH-camrs don’t shape the political landscape in a diverse country like India. It is the local issues which do. BJP has been losing and winning continuously in the state elections. Also, BJP does not govern India. It’s the state, central government, municipal bodies, rural bodies along with a completely independent judicial structure which do. There are more than a dozen of parties which govern India. The centre can’t meddle in the affairs of the state. If they want, it is a laborious route which the centre always avoids. India is a federation with unitary bias with very strong grassroot level democratic institutions. The society where my house in India is located, has a governing body which is recognised by the constitution and it functions independently as an independent democratic governing body. It has elections and what not. Same is the case with thousands other urban and rural bodies.
The problem is that people put TH-camrs on a pedestal and turn a blind eye towards pragmatism. People are entitled to listen to whosoever they want to. Criticise whoever they want to. But in doing so must recognise the right of the other party as well, which Muzammil has highlighted. He wants to save his business, I support it. My point is that he is just a TH-camr like Dhruv and many others with limited influence. The issues which he highlights are structural and should be viewed by the intelligentsia of Pakistan in that light. He is not the problem, the society is the problem.
The reason their vlogs are not worth is because, some people might bot have the privileges and luxuries that these vloggers show. This could cause a social anxiety or complexes in the society.
آپ نے چاہت علی خان کو مشہور کرنے والے جہلاء کا نام بھی نہیں لیا۔۔۔انٹرٹینمنٹ اور جہالت میں فرق ہے
भाई, उस बेकार आदमी को आखिर क्यो प्रसिद्धी मिलती है यह मै आजतक नही समझ पाया।
Mr. Falex and Zia Zulfiqar are doing a great job on TH-cam.
@TBT Podcast thank you for this video.
Three Steps Evolution is very real. I would be very Happy if you share more of your Data Analysis like this.
Correction, please, top Indian youtuber is Acharya Prashant with 48.7 million subscribers.
Solid move with the course. The market needs it. People are ready and super happy that you'll be sharing what you know. Lives will be changed. More impact will be created. More power to you.
I onced came to view ducky bhai video n i was absolutely surprised to hear below the belt creepy language n garbage on the name of content n entertainment 🤮
All good but India and Pak same ?
No bhai it is not, For example Indian army is India's army but yours ? India is secular & we had Muslim president, Sikh PM & Christian defense minister something which would never happen in your Pakistan and i can go on and on ...
Chup k@fir
I think wider aspect Mai aik boht Bari problem literacy ka be Hai.
Well done Muzammil. I am myself trying to change the content uptake in the Pakistani space. Trying my best to come up with fresh content different from what we see at the moment. Your help is appreciated. Let the change begin!
Well explained the concept of internet consumers, appreciate that you are thoroughly researched and educate your audience based on true figures and facts. I appreciate that this video was more than just bashing and sorting content creators as bad or good.
A great example of this is PeeDiePie. You can see how his content looks so mature now. Because all of his viewers matured. Great analysis brother.
Irfan Junejo was not hurted at 3:33😂
Irfan never said anything about family vloging he just said I will not do it.. bs and i have nothing against them
I used to watch ducky vlogs they were funny but then I got bored. I started watching rajab family vlogs they were fun new content daily but after a while I felt He is just showing his money off but still i used to watch his mother is really nice. Breaking point for me was when he celebrated his sisters bday took her inlaws her family friends cousins in her bedroom where she was sleeping or acting i dont know but it was so awkward like why would u show that ? No respect really.
Wow! Stumped!! I learnt so much today from your framework theory!! Well done Muzamil🙌
I love your vlogs but not sure why you selected this topic? It appears to me that you got distracted by some negative comments. I suggest you keep doing your work and stop worrying about negative comments
I like daily vloggers because it makes me updated on Pakistani trends and daily life. Both in cities and in villages. But also I like the educational and political content. That also keeeps me updated on Pakistani life. What I do not like is haters and gali wali roasting. As a Pakistani living in Europe, I have seen that Pakistani content is gettig better day by day.
Bade bhai, pakistani youtubers ke bhi maximum 'intellectual' subscribers Indians hain. This is apparent if toy go through the comments section. The number could be anything from 20% to 70%, depending on the channel.
Bro is a philosopher. I love you to the core of my heart.
Family vlogging with fake pranks and useless topics are the worst things on youtube. Jahalat jahalat jahalat.
Babe wake up TBT just dropped an info-loaded banger 🔥
What exactly was the point of this Podcast?
Such an excellent framework and analysis. Really appreciated your efforts.
I do not totally agree with your perspective but respect you, you analyzed brilliantly on content consumers, you're well educated, productive person, and an educated TH-camr. 🙌
Muzammil Bhai, You are doing an incredible job by making this series, It's really teaching me to view things from the different persective, I REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR EFFORTS
Ducky bhai promotes gambling which is haram and he hasnt speak a single thing about Palestinians btw not just ducky bhai but every pakistani so called influencer hasnt said a single thing about palestine or boycotted any product instead they are shamlessly promoting them. I think nobody should sell thier conscience for money and fame.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Fr
Hey, Muzamil u were spot on relating to the evolution of the content, I 100% can relate with you ,now I am in that face were I want to extract something from the content and I found you❤
You’re just jealous of him. He’s showing his family not yours. If you dont like him then don’t watch.
Some correction: in india there are 6 unicorns edtech company(byju not included)...and more than 27+ educational base individual content creater (not including podcaster) whose subscriber more than average 10m+...mostly indian hi Pakistani podcast dekte haii...u checked Pakistani seminar , conclave etc 90% indian viewership meligee....unfortunately Pakistan me education ka seen tumhari economy se bi bahut bura haiiii.....
haha Bhai appp pakistan mai reh chokay hai .... apko kaisay pata hai pakistan education ka
10M + subscribers is also because of the large population.But I agree education system is not in a good state in Pakistan. I have seen top daily Vloggers who are wealthy and live in cities like Karachi or Lahore. One can easily deduce that they did'nt go to good schools.
However the education is system in India also has it's share of flaws.
Do you have a cognitive issue that prevented you from understanding this video, or is it your deep-seated animosity towards Pakistan that compelled you to post such an absurdly ignorant comment to relieve your life stress? In either case, let me repeat and rephrase what the key point mentioned in this video which you have failed to comprehend. A Pakistani internet user is at least 5 years younger compared to an Indian internet user, so this evolution is
Moreover, did you factor in the fact that your population is 6 times as much as of Pakistan? Milestones of million are less valuable when your population is in billion. Thirdly, If Indians are consuming Pakistani educational content, there are also Pakistanis consuming Indian educational videos.
Lastly, this video was made by a data analyst who has facts and figures, while your horrendously written statement is based on emotions.
Do you have a cognitive issue that prevented you from understanding this video, or is it your deep-seated animosity towards Pakistan that compelled you to post such an absurdly ignorant comment to relieve your life stress? In either case, let me repeat and rephrase what the key point mentioned in this video which you have failed to comprehend. A Pakistani internet user is at least 5 years younger compared to an Indian internet user, so this evolution is
Moreover, did you factor in the fact that your population is 6 times as much as of Pakistan? Milestones of million are less valuable when your population is in billion. Thirdly, If Indians are consuming Pakistani educational content, there are also Pakistanis consuming Indian educational videos.
Lastly, this video was made by a data analyst who has facts and figures, while your horrendously written statement is based on emotions.
@@Vanillevirus Pakistan's Education system is comparable to Afghanistan's (not India's).
Please don't try to degread India by comparing with Pakistan, Afghanistan type countries
I don't hate the success of these vloggers. Their promotion of western ideology, western way of living and secularism is what I hate. Why can't you promote your own traditons, culture and religion. Why do you have to be so influenced by the west.
Freedom of choice.
their choice whether they want to follow western or eastern culture
the thing about overnight is not true....a big chunk of his audience is pakistani from a very long time... personally along with me 'i have found my many friends and people around me knowing him... his topics are not only politics based... so saying that its a overnight success and fame would be wrong statement... he is making videos for quite a long time which are well researched and edited.. straight to point to bs... this is absolutely true that ducky bhai and other vloggers in pakistan are setting unrealistic expections for their young viewers .. most of their audience is youth and kids , who hav;nt faced the reai world.. who think that making pranks vedios and vloges can make them earn this type of living which is shownn by their vloggers .. and that;s destroying young minds. so the critisizm is right in my opinon... the critisizm is right but the camparision with india is absolutely wrong.
Yes but druv rathee said alot of negative things against Pakistan and In typical Hindustani style if Pakistani viewers become aware of that they might start to unsubscribe him quicker than we think.
Also those new followers who are Liking him now might be from Imran khan's cult followers , and as soon as that guy speaks again their Messiah Imran khan they gonna leave him. Lol. So these things shouldn't be taken seriously. Everyone is biased and majority of people especially in young generation doesn't have any ideology or have their own mindset.
agree
@@goals27 absolutely. Everyone is biased in some way so is druv. But beside politics that man has done a great job. Discussing different topics how different things work and the knowledge about the world. I think we owe him an appreciation. He has been working for a long time now and I'm definitely a big fan .
Dhruvs audience is 90% indian, he showed his stats in his latest video.
@@AdAstra-x9m personally I Don't become a fan of Indians that easily especially those who try to be over smart and take digs at Pakistan which Pakistanis usually don't understand. We need to be smart enough to know who we should be fan of and who we should ignore. So yes I disagree.
It's an excellent analysis bruh ~ a very macro perspective discussion. One advice for everyone who is watching, try to really understand the video and look at 2026 or 2027 instead of right now. Listen to 30:30 onwards, that's the crux of the whole video.
Such a wholistic view Muzzamil bhai. Mashallah you really do work very hard for your vlogs
Once i passed my curiosity stage and i was in my entertainment stage and suddenly i saw a short video of Azad Chaiwala he was promoting Their institute and then i research about Azad Chaiwala and my educational journey was started and at the end of 2023 i am watching this channel...
Lol
Now I understand why my 15 year old brother who used to watch Ducky is now watching Kohistani 😂 btw you have covered all necessary points.
kohistani ❤❤
There isn't any reflection on anyone by disliking someone. There is an equal freedom of expression. As much as people are free to like "there" content without being labelled anything, equally, people have full right to criticise "there" content without being told that they have "inferiority complex". If you come infront of a camera in public to earn money, then be ready to face both sides of the society, simple.
Humay toh abhi tak wohi yaad hai " hum middle class the, meri pehli foreign trip lee mainay in class 9th, ek he gaari the humare pass 😢😢😢" 😁😁😁
Just a suggestion. This could be much more interactive with infographics, some reference images, and a bit more editing.
Thank you for the disclaimer. I now know bohat sugar coated criticism ho ga
Mazrat, leaving
Its hard to give out my opinions when everything that I wanted to say was already said in such a uniform and informative manner that there was nothing else left to be added. Amazing job
I'm feeling proud that.. finally people are recognising dhruv rathee.. though I'm following him from past 6 years
Like druve rathee I'm following jihad also from past 6 years but i see that he's still not have much recognition..
And I'm following you since you make Facebook videos with your few friends where you share educational content.. much respect for all of them who share quality content ❤️