Was Khaie Ending Justified? | Jaan E Jahan | Shiddat | KMBK
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ก.ค. 2024
- 00:00 Introduction
12:43 Khushbo Mein Basay Khat
17:39 Shiddat
30:38 Jaan e Jahan
48:27 Khaie
Was Khaie Ending Justified? | Jaan E Jahan | Shiddat | KMBK
Something Haute is Pakistan’s leading content creating platform the most credible opinion on Pakistan’s beauty, fashion & style, movies & TV scene.
Subscribe for the latest news and reviews on beauty products and Pakistani dramas & movies and exclusive celebrity interviews.
Something Haute’s TH-cam channel is managed by Dot Republic Media. All Copyright Rights Reserved.
Subscribe to our TH-cam channel:
bit.ly/somethinghaute
Follow us on Instagram:
/ somethinghauteofficial
Hassan's Instagram: / hchoudaryy
Aamna's Instagram: / thisisaamna
Visit our website:
www.somethinghaute.com/ - บันเทิง
Be A Bridge; Don't Be An Underpass:
th-cam.com/video/pzUwJS2Fo6o/w-d-xo.htmlsi=m8LxpYnJw_eqkIfS
Please Hassan, upload your reaction video of Radd ost as Ary Digital has upload the ost on their TH-cam channel. Really looking forward..
@@harischeema15 as week Ana taaa reaction kidr gy wo video
Underpass is equally good as a bridge; depending upon the ground situation.
People may not agree with me but I honestly think Durre needs to take acting classes. She had a dream role in Khaie but she couldn’t do justice to it. She lacked that aggression needed for this role. She had the same expression throughout the series.
True... But again amna and hassan seems to be so ignorant they re not even bothered to address this particular feedback by so Many people in the comment section regarding durre acting as if they have gone blind or have decided hell bent on praising her otherwise they always go like " bht logo nay yeah bola woh bola" like if majority are saying something the least they can do is explain to us how they differ in the opinion of her acting skills and why most of us are not able to see what they can😅
Right..though I haven't seen her other dramas but here I just recall her heavily done eyes n same sly smirk.No range in emotions no voice modulation.Sajal /Yumna would have killed this role.I can't help myself imagining them as Zamda
Agreed. Her acting is not impressive in Khaie
I agree with you
@@AAH1996😂
Dur-e-fishan is very average ordinary actress. She is just lucky that she got such good projects with amazing co-actors. Durre's facial expressions and dialogue delivery is literally same in every drama. She is just good looking nothing else.
i agree
She sailed through Jaise Apki Marzi with the same one expression. Not a single variation was seen. 😂😂
' Good looking'??!!
She is gorgeous and acting ok ,a treat to watch
Khaie's ending was too idealistic. I can't imagine a kid being ao mentally sound after seeing all his family be so brutally wiped off, no matter what the reason. To top it off, being so considerate to your step mother, of all people, who was the focal point of all the mess. His own mother died due to the trauma and he is all happy with "choti ammi". Very unbelievable.
How zamda was so mentally stable after all of this was also unbelievable.
And please stop with this extra praise of durre. How was her acting comparable to any of the other actors that you people are always giving her flying kisses?? Her voice seemed to be coming out of a cave in so many scenes, crying without a single tear, no depth of emotions at badal's death or any remorse or fear at anyone else's death.
I found her performance mediocre too. Don't know why they over praise her.
Durre had 3 expressions throughout the series. Where did Aamna see the subtle nuances and different emotions overplayed? I feel they need to watch good acting and pause the guilty pleasures for a while so their taste in dramas and acting improves.
The fact they themselves admitted that Zamda-Duraab scene was underwhelming despite him being a veteran and giving his best, is itself telling. The Barlas death had more impact thanks to Faysal and Uzma saving the day.
Yes the first few episodes seemed to give her a lot of margin but then she became a side character. The villains- channar and duraab khan seemed more central. In no way did durre go a fantastic job at all. Just disappointing. I thought that too regarding Aizaz. I really thought he will kill her at the end on the bridge. Just a bit sad.
Dure is an average actress. She is lucky that she always gets comparably good projects and good co actors also.
Hassan is Anupamaa from Film Companion. Instead of her “genuine effort” & “sincerity”, he uses “I have to say”, “has to be the best”, “not of their best” even if the performer is new. I respect his opinions but sometimes his generosity for his favourites overshadows his critiquing abilities.
In the last episode of Khaie, I only felt for Badal. She did not thought for a second for him. The other women vanished suddenly, even in the scene where Badal's mother came with Zamda's mom but there was no scene for her that where her son went.
What happened to Zamda and Badals dream of making a school?did he just die for nothing? Zamda didn't even seem to care about him dying? Ending should've atleast had a school where Zamda takes Aizaz or they run but they ended it with showing Chanar Khan where he's saying she loves him that was so weird because she never loved Chanar so that scene doesn't make sense.
Badal gave his life for zamda but she didn't miss her for a second, how strange
I think it fine in context. This was never a romatic drama. So i think it is fine.
She used him as a tissue paper😂
it still isnt realistic . she WAS in love with him and they were litrlly going to get married 😭 its hard to believe they didnt even show a SINGLE scene of her mourning him . how did she dream abt channar but not even THINK abt badal . it conpletely bastardised badal’s character and his relationship w zamda 😭
Truee
Khaie - Big disservice to Badal's character. He should be in the last scene with Zambda .
Nhi aska yehi end bnta taaa
What even was that last scene though? Did they show that she fell in love with Chanaar? What was the point even? Boht he fazool.
True... they should have shown kay zamda asks aizaz to stop the car and secretly goes to badals grave for Fatiha and also builds a school like they planned... but AJEEB
Zamda remembering Chanar in last scene is so disturbing..instead of Chanar she must have thought of Badal it was shown that she was getting married to badal, planned a happy life together had dreams of opening a school, both loved each other. But she used Badal for her revenge and eventually he got killed because of her and zamda ko koi afsos nhi bataya.. So strange..A big fault of writer and Director...highly disappointed and not A satisfactory ending.
Exactly my thoughts 👍🏻
He,was her husband whatever he did to her..he loved also zamda.... True❤
Forced marriages are not valid. He was nothing but her abuser and r*pist. @@mr.mars2.138
I generally agree to all aamna says as hasan most of the time is biased and try to please his industry's "colleagues"".Sorry hasan most of the time you talk sense but sometimes you keep on harping on a particular thing which make your talk so tedious which I most of the time enjoy. As for khaie drama you people were praising faisal and durre so much.Durre as most of the people pointed out had the same expression throughout but as always hasan go all gaga over her. She's a beautiful girl and has lot of potential but not suited for this role. Faisal in the last scene was so irritating. Writer and director of the show totally ruined the drama by making him the hero in the end which aamna and hasan also agreed. But sorry to say his acting was pathetic in the last scene though I enjoyed his performance throughout. But then everyone has a right to his or her views.
Only flaw in the ending was they shouldn't have shown zamda reminiscing channar's love for her. Makes it seem like she is missing his love. And also Aizaz shouldn't have seen her pointing a gun at him. He should've been facing the other side. A child of his age can't forgive or forget their step mom pointing a gun at him and killing off his father ever. He should've never known zamda's truth if they wanted to show he lives and grows with her.
Exactly..the bridge scene at the end I was literally thinking that Aizaz will now point gun at Zamda when he got out of the car to take pictures. I thought he would kill Zamda for whatever she had done to his whole family. Aizaz ko is sab k bary me kuch b pata nahi chalna chahye tha. Wo kesy uske sath reh skta hai sab kuch janny k bad?
@@ayshcandy7155exactly! Aur Zamda itna sab karne k baad aik normal life kaise guzar sakti hai? Such an unnatural ending.
True... they should have shown kay zamda asks aizaz to stop the car and secretly goes to badals grave for Fatiha and also builds a school like they planned... but AJEEB
True dont like at all… zamdah was no different thn channar n her father in law n she also did in justice by killing innocents slobg with killers so how that ends up khaei???
Hamza Ali Abbasi has made Shehram so likeable and easy to watch. I can't imagine anyone else as Shehram. He is so fitting in this character. While I always love HamYeza's chemistry. Their soft, pure and natural chemistry is highlight of JEJ. And those poetic words from Hamza about his Jane Jahan were so beautiful
Hamza is the best thing that happened in jane jahan... what a marvellous and one of the best performance of his career... janejahan is janejahan just because of him....
He is literally the Jaan n Ayeza the Jahan of the serial
I liked that Zamda wasn't shown pregnant with Chanar's child but I did not like how Chanar popped up at the end
To make Faisal Qureshi's character likable and romantic, they ruined the whole essence of this drama. Probably, Faisal Qureshi forced the director to keep him a hero. I was expecting, the little kid running away with anger in his eyes in the end. This could've given a chance of Season 2.
@@sabrinakhan8217 they tried their hardest to make channar a hero. The way he never lashed out at zamda after finding out the truth, only wanted to hear her declaration of love in his final moments and that scene on the bridge. The only thing left was to show zamda pregnant with his child telling him how great his father was 😂
Khaie: As much as i would appreciate the direction and acting, both were phenomenal, i can't shake off my concerns on how it ended.
Seems like they were trying to serve us with a happy ending, instead it was a flawed one. How could aizaz grow up to love a woman who murdered his entire family infront of his eyes? It's unreal that he seems to be all happy and chirpy about it just because she didn't kill him and raised him as her own.
Also, Zumda wasn't supposed to come off as all goody good at the end. It wasn't a " justice served right" story. It was a " 2 families wiped off of the face of planet in hatred and revenge" story. It wasn't normal. How is she living normally with all of this is beyond me.
Plus, what on earth was that flashback of Channar at the bridge? Matlab k this girl killed even some of the innocent ones and then fell in love with the main culprit? Wow.
👏👏👏👏
Exactly my analysis!
Specially Badshah Khan who was already in so much anguish😢
Alternate ending to khaie- id rather have seen zamda push chinar in the grave and bury him alive rather than shooting him and hear the long pyar ka pujari monologue. She cudnt kill the boy but she just leaves with her mother .. cut short next 20 years .. we see a very vicious gulvareen who has raised another chinar in that boy awaiting revenge.. we also see that apana also has a son with similar upbringing.. and then we see zamda in bahrain with her family of two boys and a girl and a husband living happily planning to make a visit to zamdas home town.. we also throw in a scene leavjnv us confused if whether zamdas first born is actually chinars son . The end
@@juvsobham Woah that was dark haha. Lkn very netflixyyy i must say💯
Hamza acted the emotional heart broken scenes so well 👏🏻👏🏻and equally powerful aggression from him for that thappar scene…..he is so so convincingly good 👍🏻
Khaie: I was honestly expecting that Aizaz will do a Gangs of Wasseypur-ish end by shooting Zamda when he stepped out of the car leaving her inside. But it was possibly avoided to give a happy end.
Aizaz wasn't a baby when this happened. It was really unbelievable that he got over this. There could have been atleast one scene where Zamda lies to him to save him from agony. There was also no closure given to Badshah Khan's wife Bakhtawar, but I think the makers truly forgot about her in the end.
There was also no portrayal of Zamda regretting or trying to cope with the murders she planned. The last shot of her hallucinating Chanar Khan was not enough to depict residual trauma.
I too had the same thought that Aizaz will shoot Zamda on the bridge.
True... they should have shown kay zamda asks aizaz to stop the car and secretly goes to badals grave for Fatiha and also builds a school like they planned... but AJEEB
Jaan e Jahan: How come you guys are forgetting tha Tabrez is a murderer and murderers are not supposed to have happy endings.
For sure he will die leaving Gulzeb pregnant
I can't understand how Zamda is fine after all these murders. It wasn't possible. And then the flashback of chanar was so disturbing which was implying she might have fallen in love with him. There was no logic and depth in khaie. The story was different but it lacked clarity. The direction was impeccable and took the experience to another level.Khalid Butt sb, FQ, Shuja, Uzma, Laila, Hina, all the brothers of Chanar their acting was what made this drama so wholesome. While Dure again couldn't bring the emotions in last episode which were needed to be shown by zamda.
I find it disgusting watching chanar khan as some sort of lover boy... Throughout the drama, not once has anyone seen her love for chanar khan, but as usual It's a disease in ptv makers to somehow show the love angle between leads ... they tried too hard to show stockholm syndrome symptoms in zamda... which is clearly not the scene... and i don't know how aizaz is so comfortable living with a person who literally killed his whole family... even his mother died because of her... i was thinking what happened to those loyal servants of durab Baba... why didn't they try to kill zamda after knowing her reality... so you are right there was no depth in the story.... overall, despite its many flaws, it was a very engaging drama... That's why it became a massive hit.
@@samrahmumtaz9469 yes I second your opinion
Right from the moment she was married to him, I was wishing it wouldn’t end with her forgiving and loving channar khan 💀 also I wish they had cast someone else for zamda. She just can’t act at all
@@samrahmumtaz9469yeah lol there’s no way in hell a person could be sane after causing so much bloodshed, no matter the reason
@anjalik1136 Seriously, one incident can change your whole life ... and here zamda is chilling after killing the whole family... I understand her situation, but again, you can't be living such a comfortable life after killing so many people
I think we all should appreciate Qasim ali mureed for such wonderful direction in Jaan e Jahan he has literary made it a classic masterpiece. Now a days as we see dramas getting dragged, discordinated scenes and poor direction . I am gald we have a director like him
The thing about Jaan e Jahan is that only is the writing superb and the acting amazing. But it looks so aesthetically pleasing and EXPENSIVE. I feel like I’m watching a really high budget drama whenever I watch JeJ. And that really matters in today’s day and age
The ideal ending of Khei should have been Zamda Killed Gulwarin and Aizaz by poison them. After that, when Channar totally dependent on her then take him to the Graveyard as she did in the drama and killed him. Some time later found out that she is pregnant and later on haunted (PTSD) by all the innocent people she killed or involved in their killing. I don't think this story needed happy ending.
Jan e Jahan is hitting all the right spots at the moment. Sheraam’s eyes are saying more than his words in this episode. Watching him and Noor Banu both reminded me of the song koi faryad by Jagjit Singh!
Excellent watch throughout.
It is always a pleasure to watch two polite, refined, courteous heroes showing respect in relationships in Jaan e Jahan. The relief efforts, humanitarian work in flood shown in the episode gave an added good feeling. The rain scenes were well shot. Only the Tabraiz Gulzeb track is cringe.
The way Gulzeb was blushing I actually liked their chemistry🤣
@@seemalhasan2931 I find Tabraiz similar to channar khan killing her husband ( mohabbat ke liye as CK kept telling Zamda😃), to marry her.
I swear i cringed so hard after watching tabreez and gulzaib romance... i feel so annoyed after watching their rain romance... like, dude, we fans are praying for our cuties to be together so we can have their romance, and here what we are getting is gulzaib and tabraiz romance, and nobody even asked for it
Khaie- I just hated the last episode
1. I hated where the makers tried their level best to glorifie Channar Khan. Like he is some kind of supreme lover. I felt like they tried to prove the point "Everything is fair in love and war" so whatever Channar did was fair.
2. I hated when the makers in the last scene depicted that zamda was also started secretly loving channar. Uhhh.. in the last scenes there was no mention of Badal which also depicts the mindset of the makers that no matter what happens, a wife will always remember her husband only.
Instead of remembering channar, they could have shown her remembering Badal. After all he died for her
@@anjalik1136 yeah right....
In JJ, the rainy night scene at the school was aesthetically pleasing and wonderfully done. I could actually feel the rain and later heat from the diyas. There should have been more awkward moments from the leading couple while assisting the villagers.
For Gulzeb and Tabraiz plot, it could be she trying to lure him into a relationship to get his confession about the dead husband's murder.
I am Agree with you 💯 on the Gulzeb and Tabrez situation 👍
Khaie: A very flawed and rushed ending. Zamda, who mercilessly killed off every member and showed no signs of tiredness or remorse, suddenly became so emotional, weakened, a whimpering woman when killing Chanar. Durre’s performance there wasn’t strong: she showed only the emotional part instead of the strength and cold-bloodedness. There wasn’t enough conflict of emotions. Second, the graveyard scene was too long and repetitive of Chanar’s love and what not. Third, the ending was so convenient with Gul Wareen miraculously dying, Apana getting remarried and the other two widows just no more. Fourth, how was Aizaz’s disappearance not questioned and how was he so chill with Zamda murdering his whole family.
Zamda becoming a saint after killing many people including Pameer and the wives (apart from Gul) was so unnatural. In any revenge or murder story, there is always a morality crisis like Crime & Punishment but here there wasn’t any. Both the director and writer and the actor is to be blamed for not showing that crucial aspect. Her hint of loving Chanar was so disturbing and contradictory to what she had done so along. Chanar’s lover boy was irritating. Her not even remembering Badal was absurd a fault of the writer & director.
FQ & Khalid Butt were absolutely amazing as the delicious villains. Durre was good and is her best performance but the role could’ve been elevated to another level but I hope more such dramss are made so that our underrated talents shine.
Badał was supposed to be Zamia’s hero who fought for her while chanar was a villain but unfortunately our drama’s writers love to portray toxic characters as heroes
Very valid point.
Khaie: They conveniently killed both wives of Channar Khan leaving Zamda alone with the youngest son.☺️ Although the story had flukes but overall it was an extremely engaging drama with a different premises of a girl taking brutal revenge, instead of showing the usual Stockholm Syndrome. Set in a beautiful location there were some very impactful scenes with good direction , good make up and impeccable performances, specially by Khalid Butt Sahab, Faisal Qureshi and Uzma Hassan. Some scenes stayed with me for a long time:
--Jindul Khan tied to a tree with his hands cut off. Realistic make up, well directed. There was not only sound of pistol shots but actual flashes were shown during firing.
--Barlas Khan death. Again very realistic make up of cuts on his neck.
--Duraab Khan death( although the thoughts of real actor and his demise clouded it).
Zamda never had any symptoms of stockholm syndrome, but in the end, they tried to show that zamda had some sort of feeling for chanar khan, which is disgusting ... but as i said in the other comment, it's a disease of the ptv maker to somehow show some sort of love angle between leads no matter if it makes sense or not, but they will show ... and i completely agree with you. It was such an engaging drama... even though they stretched the drama as much as they could still, this drama managed to grab their audience's attention
The thehrao, softness, subtleness in JEJ is so refreshing. Hamza and Ayeza have beautiful chemistry. One of best drama running right now
Khaie ending, I took from Channar standing is how delusional channar is and that he still haunts her with his own selflessness and justifies it. It just made him look more cruel. Zamda will forever be haunted by him. I didn’t think it made Zamda weak in any sense. She tolerated his madness and survived it.
Exactly my point...
That’s an interesting interpretation. But they could have shown him to haunt her without the implication that she misses him or didn’t hate him. Like Amna said, it sounds more like her fantasy shown through her subconscious than a sinister kind of haunting
Love Love Love for Jaan e Jahan’s whole team! That’s one drama that I watch with a 😊 on my face and when Shehram comes on screen even my ❤ smiles 😊
And that one scene when he was looking at Mahnoor and Taimoor with so much sadness and pain hayeeeee kasam se dil muu mey aa Gaya!
Taimoor tenu Allah da Wasta na krein please!
Shehram and Mahnoor are
just ❤🔥❤🔥❤️ together
Allah jori salamat rakhein 🤩
JeJ gave us a beautiful episode!! Hamza and Ayeza raw chemistry took it to next level!! ❤Everything portrayed through expressions without heavy dialogues❤
Gulzaib and Tabraiz are the spice element of the play…Tabraiz is playing his character so well of a pervert lover 👏🏻
Khaie team should have shown in the last scene Zamda struggling with mental health and PTSD because humanely it's not possible to not struggle mentally after killing that many people. They should have shown or talking about therapy in a voiceover. I think it was a lost opportunity.
I completely agree with Amna. All her points are so valid. There was no tribute or any remembrance for Badal who she loved and who did so much for her by helping her kill Channar’s family, all out of love for her. She didn’t weep very much for him, maybe because she was just so emotionless by then. She had killed and had experienced such heartbreak. And not showing any of the rest of the characters after all the deaths and everything else, it was just too fast. I think instead of filling all the previous episodes with so many flashbacks, they should’ve used that time to have some character development and maybe had one more episode to show the consequence of killing all of these people. It wasn’t completely fulfilling but it was great acting. Not completely unsatisfactory, but just enough.
Oo god !! I m simply out of words to explain the beauty of this episode of Jaan-e-jhan,one in decades ,i mean it was a stellar episode,in loveee with it ...words can't justify its grandiosity 👏❤️🔥
#Hameza#shehnoor #jaanejhan 🌟
Anmols acting was really good in the walima episodes. Uff, the entire time she was holding back her tears in the party hall. She just wasn't able to feel happy from the inside...you could actually feel for her. Very realistically played. Natural.
Khaie: I dont think it was realistic that you gun down several people in a frenzy and there's no accountability, no police, no jirga...Durre's acting was very ordinary, very expressionless, bland.
The story was between two tribes they don’t have law enforcement agencies in tribal areas
@@aishamahmood4678 I dont think the tribal areas operate like a jungle. They have their systems of accountability. You dont go on a killing rampage whenever u like.
7:00
Yes you are right. The community of something haute is literate and sophisticated. I am also a member of your community and I am a PhD holder and also a writer of kid's stories. 😊
Zamda only killed two, Sara revenge to Badal nay liya tha 😂, she used him like a tissue paper.😂😂😂
She killed all except too yes used him
@@sab-ali instead of her imagining Chinar in the end she should have imagined Badal.
@@nkhan8933 i saw writers interview... it's so brutal to watch their views... saying people crying for that character no
Zamda ne badal ko q yaad nhi kia😢not a single time after his death ….last main Faisal ki jagah badal ko yaad krti zamda car main bethi hue ….
1:01:21 In deewangi hiba never said to danish that she loved him at end. She said she hates him n killed him. In last scene it was shown she is happy with her husband
You forget to talk about the bgm in this week's Jaan e Jahan... it was so painfully beautiful... ❤
JJ: how satisfying were the Chapairs by Shehram. Slap slap slap.
Standupgirl Girl - One request... please interview its cast and its creative team...want to listen them...and understand the process how they created this masterpiece....
I literally felt for all the women of Khaie . They went through so much loss when it was never their fault
its so unreal n impossible that a kid would grow up to love a stepmother who killed his father n whole family infront of him (no matter what the reason, khaie or revenge whatever) so aizaz all lovey dovey with zamda doesnt make sense.. that undid a good ending
June jahan is a masterpiece my favorite drama and ayera hamaza phenomenal performers ❤❤❤❤❤
Completely agree with your review about Khaie! Zamda shouldn’t have left. And she shouldn’t have had Channar’s flashback.
Also raising the boy herself and telling him everything was too far fetched. She could have sent him to the city and that’s it.
Poor Badal was all words and hardly any action and his death was just so casual. Zamda didn’t even think about him for once. Kahan itne flashbacks thy wahan aik uss bechare ka bhi daal dete.
Anyways overall a great effort 😅😂 fantastic performances by everyone
That chanar's scene was just her thought and we don't have control on our thoughts. The thought could could be anything. Zamda hate chanar till the end and why she didn't kill aziz because she wanted to give lesson to all people who do kahie including chanars' son.
I think!
But this is a drama it could be a thought about poor badal who lost his life for that girl
He didn’t even think about her own mother who would be all alone without him
@@toobaather9600 his grave was near his family I think, so when she visits her family's graves she also remember badal.
Sidra Niazi was phenomenal in this episode.
We need to appreciate supporting performances
Thank u Aamna for the detailed review of jaan e jahan I just love ur review ❤❤I watch something haute only becoz of u
I don’t think chanar khan was glorified. His dialogues portrayed who he was.
Last scene: after killing so many ppl of course she’ll be haunted by his visuals ( her imagination)
BADAL should have been mentioned in last episode
Your review on jaane jahan was just awesome ❤❤❤❤ always love ur discussion
Honestly the ending for Khaie fell flat at many points and then was rushed. The long ass speech before chanaar dies... why? He should have been shocked and angry when she told him but too weak to do anything even when he tried. Also Zamda should have made a point of saying how a "lowly" "weak" woman stood up to evil and avenged the men of her family. Also she should have more forcefully countered his claims of love. For a second i thought he was trying to distract her and was going to lunge at her to try to grab the gun. No dice there either. Love means to sacrifice oneself for the happiness of the one you love NOT to destroy and possess. The final scene could have been better positioned as PTSD initially and then her finally letting go and overcoming her residual trauma after so many years. That her act of kindness in the end "killed khaie" itself, made her whole and brought her the peace that the eye for an eye revenge couldn't have. But no, they suggest she kinda sorta did fall for him, coz his love was so strong and true. The voice-over to try and tie up loose ends was like a rushed checklist that didn't make much sense. One died, other one eventually died, third remarried. Chalo the end, Khair sallah. Essentially "gonglu tay mitti" and mitti pao .. the end... what the?!?!?
Haris is a phenomenal Actor ,his acting has made a character like Tabrez really likeable and viewers are even rooting for Tabrez and gulzeb ,plsss appreciate him more ,he actually needs lead role in a big drama for big3
Tbh drawing, coloring or sketching really feels good when you want to release stress and anger.. don't know how many of you agree but long drives also makes me stress free
The last ep of khaie was disappointing.. Zamda loves chanar 🤐
They should ve worked more on the ending.. Apana or Gulvareen should ve done something.. Didn’t even show apana.. And zamda ending also doesn’t add up.. It could ve been just 18 ep drama
Channar khan is a toxic psycho sadist and they made him the love of her life?!? The guy who killed her family and kidnapped her & forced her to marry him..totally agree that Pakistani dramas are romanticising horrible male characters..and made badal khan, the guy who loved her, educated & saviour, was forgotten & she didn’t even mention him.
U guys are absolutely right, Faisal Qureshi dramas are mostly about terrible guys becoming the heroes. Horrible precedent being set by these damn dramas
Both interviews of Uzma and the writer of Ishq murshid were brilliant loved the sincerity of both of them the questions and answers were great well done guys ❤👍👍
Literally, we fall short for words when it comes to Faisal Qureshi. Hatts off, Mic drop, thumbs up, Sir.
With regards to Hassan's interview with ishq Murshid's writer....I must say that it truly depicted the helplessness of writers in Pakistani drama industry. That dude didn't utter a single thing against Farooq Rind despite his script being severly butchered. It is such a hopeless state and so demotivating for anyone who wants to pursue writing for Pakistani dramas....first it was JJ who conveniently claimed in Aamna's interview that the dramas' quality has improved over the years, however we all know how insanely the content quality has gone down the hill specially in the last 5 or so years.
Just pathetic excuses to cover up their shitty objectives and hence the garbage that is put up on mainstream channels and that also during prime time.
So disappointing......
JEJ - Amazing ayeza and hamza nailed it beautifully directed and written🎉
Sigh...again Aamna starts to talk about her interview with Uzma H and Hasan doesn't appreciate it or asks questions about it. Sidetracks to something else. He doesn't take interest in a good way for any of her solo projects. Whereas she does.
I agreed
agreed. i feel like he hypes up his interviews and podcasts so much and when aamna starts talking about hers he changes the topic (maybe unintentionally) which is kinda annoying
@@amnashhad7884absolutely. I've commented before when she did the rampant transmission, and he didn't congratulate or praise her at all. He may do it off camera, but when we don't see this, it looks dismissive and a sore loser.
*ramzan
@@akramuzma07 yeah exactly. i know he doesnt probably mean it like that and its just him moving on to other topics or the drama reviews but hassan should be a little more mindful to not come across as self obsessed. plus its not like aamna minds, its just we viewers want to hear her as well thats all #onthespot
I always wait for your review of Jaan e Jahan.
Harry Potter spotted in last episode of Khaie at the end 😅😊
Blkul Pakistani Harry potter
Aho Same Thinking thi Meri us Waqt 😂
The last scene of khai was really disappointing. Badal was brutally ignored by zamda
⭐️ Haute Gold suggestion : Review Shehr e zaat if this ramadan you guys aren't reviewing Ramzan dramas its a great opportunity to discuss a drama which talks about spirituality in depth knowing yourself and connection with Allah , umera ahmed has beautifully penned down this storyline leaving entire audience in awe it is a remarkable journey and Oh , the way mahira khan has portryaed falak you guys need to give this underrated gem a haute gold
Uff the dialogues are next level. So much depth
Beautiful reviews for #JaaneJahan from both of you..❤️ I'm loving episode 27 very much.. Even my tears pouring likes the rains watching it..Just love it so much. #HamzaAliAbbasi #AyezaKhan #ShehNoor ❤❤❤
Pyari Amna, for Khae I think that ending was the trauma she (Zamda) still feels when she saw chinaar. I thought it it as PTSD. Like he still haunts her. I don't think it was portrayal of love.
I love the way you both do the interviews. Jamat was so open and honest in her interview that it was a pleasure to sit back and listen to her. Because she was so open and comfortable to talk, her authenticity came through and touched me. I really enjoyed her interview
I was not happy with the ending of Khaie.
1. It was all about Chanar and his love. It should have been about Zamada and her struggles throughout.
2. She took way too long to shoot him.
3. The running to the kid with the gun pointing at him and then not killing him is weird and off. It doesn’t make sense but even if you go with it, why did she ‘adopt’ him? Wouldn’t she see his family in him? And apparently she told him everything but he didn’t hate her? At the end of the day, that’s his family that she literally KILLED!
4. They should’ve shown everyone’s ‘ending’ even for a few seconds.
5. The very last scene made it seem like she loved Chanar; which is really weird. She used to shudder at his touch throughout the drama and then all of a sudden she’s thinking about him? It would’ve made more sense for her to see her family and Badal at the bridge.
You guys are too good.Channel subscribe kar doya first episode pe hi.
Your reviews makes a great difference and gives us clarity to watching the dramas
Love you both ❤
I actually want to take this moment to appreciate your professionalism and ethics you’ve maintained throughout your journey. It is commendable to see such decorum being mainatained. I only watch this channel only because of the educated opinions you both share keeping banter humour irony. Truly delightful. ⭐️⭐️I wish you both happiness success and so much more. Sorry to say unlike other channels it’s doesn’t feel like being forced upon and cringe. 🌚
After reading comments n review here r my 2 cents 1)Zamda’s father was ready to forgive durrab khan, similarly aizaz could also forgive zamda.
2)by not killing gulwareen , zamda made d right decision. It was not needed as gulwareen didn’t kill any of her family members
3)last scene of chanar showed that zamda is still recovering from what had happened.what chanar said was who he was.
4) I’m extremely happy that they didn’t show zamda pregnant. Why take that route👍🏽
BTW, Not just Shiddat, Noorji is doing really great job in Tere Mere sapnay... His punches & sarcasms are really funny! ... BTW, This show has relatively picked up well after 5-6 episodes and for a change has funny moments & also some sensitive & sensible moments that the writer surprised me with! Saqib & the character playing his daughter Honey are also playing their character so well and are funny to the core!
Give it a shot!
KMBK: Kinza was looking a beautiful in the engagement scene. That's a very engaging plot with amazing performances from everyone. KMBK deserve more recognition
*Khaie* - Umm, I don’t mind DEVIL’s Last sermon in the face of Channar Khan…. But that last scene of Channar coming across Zamda’s subconscious was not necessary. Zamda should have been sounded “the Conqueror, the Victorious.”
•And yeah Duraab’s funeral was an other essential missing point, He was the bone of contention, who sow the poisonous seeds, who was the ultimate Villain, the destruction he had cultivated,remember the killing of Jundol Khan-I feel Durab’s funeral should have been Celebrated with thaaaat intensity if not less.
Plus, the closure of other characters i.e., Apana and Gul Wareen should have been made to Tv screens.
I think they all writer and directors can’t make Faisal villain because he is playing these roles where he is kind of hero so they wrote this last scene to make him happy only they don’t care what the hell was story and how annoying that was for audiences
he is playing her in shiddat he will take the car. he is just playing the good guy. HE IS MANIPULATIVE
The last 5 minutes killed the whole narrative developed over 25 weeks.
1. They made Chinnar Khan a Hero (sacrificed in Love)
2. Zamda in her Khaie was almost lunatic, how could she be okay with so many murders. There should have been a mention of Therapy to help her cope with the aftermaths of everything.
3. Last scene was again an indication of Stockholm syndrome. It completely ruined Zamdas character arch
Khaie: Thank you Aamna for saying everything I was thinking regarding Channar Khan. They glorified him. The comments under the video were fawning over his 'mohabbat'. FQs popularity is this, people love his 'mohabbat' style in show after show. It's disturbing. Channar khan only had hawas for Zamda, what a regressive depiction of Mohabbat. Aamnas point he shouldn't have been given all that time to act the martyr for love is correct. Zamda should have been the one talking saying 'you killed, you kidnapped, you raped, I hated every minute, every minute with you was torture, I was disgusted when you came near me etc". That should have been the last speech. Instead they indulged FQs ego and stardom. Disgusted. I'd never recomend Khaie now to anyone.
Please suggest any recent good drama after khaie
58:51 zamda ne kyun nahi bola k muhabbat tu badal ne ki ya mai us se karti ho
Totally agree with Amna k Canar Khan ko romeo dikahne ki kya zaroorat thi
Last scene of khaie was so disappointed
51:35 at that point i also thought she would give poison to gulwareen bareera ka badla lene k lye
Khaie: The story and the performances were phenomenal.
I can understand the attachment of Zamda with Chanar Khan and the Kid. In case of Chanar it was clearly a sign of Stockholm Syndrome and for Aizaz it was purely selfless love for an innocent kid plus the motive with which her father originally came back to end Khaie once and for all. Also her revenge is over now! Got what she wanted.
Slight difference should have been made in ending..it should have been left on cliff hanger regarding Aizaz's feelings (He recognises that his family was a cold blooded murderer but also how could he forgive this women..murderer..Zamda Ami so easily)
this episode of jaan e jahan was fav ❤❤ truly
3:24 not as a hobby, but I’m really enjoying coming to the gym as self-care. And of course, watching Netflix has certainly become a hobby.
I wouldn’t say watching you guys is a hobby because I take you guys very seriously, and that is a dominant part of my day . 😊😊❤
I can't imagine how zamda became a saint after killing this many people only by raising a child of her enemy family
Yeah Channar was Dark but Zamda was never meant to be a White Angel as well. Her character was always of a Grey character. But Grey is always lighter tha Dark 😏😏
she killed bad cruel people. dont act like they were nice innocent people who did nothing to her. she chose to break the cycle of hate by raising the only child of her enemy. she did.
What was she supposed to do? Spend life with her family's killers?? That would have sufficed you then?
@@annestudiezbadshah khan pameer barlas were not cruel people aghar chanar aur durab ne inoccent bando ko Mara to unko unki saza mili lakin zamda ko be milni chaiya thi usne be kafi innocent bando ko mara
If you yearn so badly for stockholm syndrome, you can watch every other pakistani drama, that was released after bashar momin that started this trend. This was something that wasnt a run of the mill drama and you guys are leaving no stone unturned to criticise the victim here. Slow claps for people like you. Now we know why dramas like kaisi teri khudgarzi are appreciated while dramas like khaie where for once the victim has taken her revenge gets bashed. This proves why there are many dramas like kaisi teri khudgarzi while khaie was something groundbreaking for pakistani drama standards. Shame on you and people like you who are normalising victims falling in love with their harassers
Khai: How could aizaz live with the woman who brutally killed his all family...his father his brothers...And how could zamda after taking so many lives get away with it easily....
Remember zamda’s father also forgave durrab too so it makes sense if aizaz forgives zamda specially since he is raised by her n heard the story how zamda narrated it
@@msmehmood Forgiving and let them go....and living happily with them....are two completely different things....I think....If a person hurts you badly...You forgive him but also expect not to see him again...
@@Fkhan29 again she raised him n told him her version. If she had left him with his mother that would have been a completely different scenario
I completely agree with Amna about Khaie, there was no need for the last scene, it should not have been added anyway, this entire episode should have been about Zamda. Zamda’s dialogues should have been more than Chinar Khan's. Zamda should have said to Chinar Khan what a painful time I have spent with you during the days I have been in your house as she used to mention her pain to Badal khan.She should have told that Badal used to love me who sacrificed his life for my love, but Badal Khan's name was not mentioned even once. It is a pity🤦♀️
Khae: Idk why people are sympathizing with Durab and clan but not with Zamda. Her whole family was killed and she avenged them rightfully so! As far as Aizaz is concerned, Zamda was not inhumane or sadistic, all she wanted was revenge and she took it with Channar. Aizaz was too young to remember everything this clearly, she could have told that child anything to make sure he understands her stance
All in all, Khae had the potential to be the next big thing only if they hadn't dragged the drama so much that People lost sight of Zamda's real mission.
Who sympathised with Durrab and his family? They were hated by everyone throughout the series. I haven’t heard anyone sympathising with them.
I have just started watching chand nagar. It is a nice drama different than other Ramazan drama. Different story.
Khaie was a great project overall!! But I agree with you guys about the last episode review!! Your points were all valid
I would disagree and say a piece of fiction does not have to reflect ideals or what we wish the real world was like. It can have aspects that make you feel uncomfortable and uneasy. The whole point of art is to invoke a reaction. If we isolate khaie from societal narratives and sensibilities and just take it for what it is. The ending did not ruin it at all. It was an unconventional ending that invokes a reaction.
It did not take away from Zamda’s glory, her bravery and grit.
I think people can theorize and bring out many reasons for that last scene. Whether it’s an intrusive thought, or she really began developing a soft spot for chanaar after spending time with him. Whatever it is, I think it made the story better and took nothing away from it.
I do wish Badal was addressed though.
Khaie ending makes no sense. It was rushed, dull and incoherent. Badal did everything for Zamda and yet her hallucinations are that of Channar Khan mansplaining her that she didn't hate him 😂. Aijaz is completely ok with fondly calling the murderer of his whole family, ammi. Like what? And what's with romanticizing Channar Khan's wrongdoings as if he did nothing wrong before he saw Zamda? Another flaw in this drama is that the govt officials are worried about wood smuggling but they don't bat an eye on such mass murdering even when they know the perpetrator was a woman with no political backing to stop them.
I tell you amnna we both are soul sisters!! I have taken up on adult coloring since my diagnosis…i used to color with kids but now its my own thing!! You should share your final product.
Hamza sir ki acting very real and heart touching and his pain ful scenes and the pain feel in his eyes 💔 and the Shayeri made by Shehram is so heart touching and heart broken 💔❤hamza ki acting give me gosbombes ❤and hamza na jo Ayeza ki tharf dikha it was very pain ful us ki ankho say lag raha tha ka wo pain ma hai hamza sir ka ilawa kio ni karsakta tha is character ko he is perfect by this Shehram character and he give his 💯
I think the dialogues at Chanar's death were fine because it was chanar's pov and in his head he probably thinks all that. Also because zambda did deny him. The problem lies in the last scene insinuating that zamda fell in love with chanar as well.
Also, I loved this episode of jaan e jahan. One of my favorite episodes that I've seen in recent times.
Wholeheartedly agree with Aamna about Khaie doing a disservice to its story by ending it with Channar Khan like that... I was hoping someone would point this out and nobody could have worded it better!