He speaks more from Muslim history then what Islam is. This is a better playlist to show you what Islam is. th-cam.com/play/PLLWosYrkNwE9_IdtxX_sI2BuOdmr8P8xQ.html
@@3-Kashmirit's sad today there's a lot ignorant Muslim who radical and really closed minded. And more sad is lot of them is grew up in West country. Khawarij already take over Islam and change what prophet Muhammad actually taught
@@3-Kashmir this playlist only teaches you what traditionalist islam is. most people already have an general understanding of what tradiotionalist islam entails. understanding history of the rationalist movement in islamic history is also extremely important to understanding of islam and for most westerners, more important
@@3-Kashmiryou should surely check the rest of that series ... where they DO talk about islamic philosophy or philosophy in the islamic world .... th-cam.com/video/viJc5754IH4/w-d-xo.htmlsi=TXg8IjSFbqxUq-Lt ...... also the Hamza Yusuf video about Ihsan in your link talks about Ibn Rushd and Imam Al Ghazali ....... so there ....
I wanna say that I really appreciate how you as a European and non-Muslim have a very nuanced view of our faith. I feel like both Western academics and our own scholars possess view that rationalism, science, philosophy, etc are incompatible with religion, that Islam can only be one set of beliefs, and the Orthodoxy is infallible, even though for our entire history up this has never been the case Perhaps it is due to your European and non-Muslim upbringing. There was a man in the 20th century named Leopold Weiss aka Muhammad Asad, who was born a secular European Jew who later become a devout Muslim and scholar. When he visited Al-Azhar University, he noticed that the students would sit all day reciting and learning the works of great medieval theologians and philosophers to be taught Islamic law. However this was all they did, and were hardly allowed to become theologians and philosophers for themselves. Asad wondered why these students were being taught this way and could not get a decent answer from the people there. He wrote extensively about how crazy it was to say, in what was once the greatest places of thinking in the world, that only these specific medieval thinkers ideas were correct and that thinking in the modern era was heavily discouraged for seemingly no good reason. Though this problem still is an issue among many Muslims today, but I am glad many people like you, Muslim or not, are still able to see Islam for what it really is
Oh my God thank you for bringing up Leopold (Asad). Road to Mecca and his interpretation of the Quran (+ the very first english translation of sahih bukhari) are AMAZING. His translations are particularly niche because he 'felt' the language of arabic after spending a decade with bedouins. There's an immense difference between learning a language for scholastic reasons and learning a language's 'soul' which can primarily be achieved through experience.
Also this is also the reason why I like this channel. I would still trust a non muslim's interpretation more since the current muslim world largely propagates the same teachings without any independent thinking ( you'll be declared a heretic lol )
@@soulreaper1945 simping for non-Muslims and lying about Muslims calling you a heretic doesn’t make you smart lol. If you’re being called a heretic by all muslims, chances are that you are one 👍🏾
He was one of the brilliant minds of the Islamic Golden Age. Often dubbed as the 'Founding Father of western thought', his works left a profound & ever lasting effect on names like Voltaire & Rene Descartes.
i will be very careful of calling him that. a lot of what we call "western thought" often contradict the teachings of Islam. yes we can all agree he laid the seeds for the Renaissance and Enlightenment age but i don't think he would have agree with "West's" conclusion which is liberalism and secularism.
@@rethabilefeni4694At that time, secularism stay in his roots for anti ignorance and tyranny in religion name like happen in dark age, unlike today where secularism is hostility towards religion. In renaissance and enlightenment there are lot intellectual of West who strict religious. Funny enough, that stuff which happening in dark age of medieval Europe is happening in Muslim country today. And in West, a secular already start to hostile towards any religion and theology especially abrahamic one
@@rethabilefeni4694 He's feminist and favorable towards music since he argue some women play better in melodies. He definitely will side with liberalism, if he the reason of islam contradict of islam, then islam is unreasonable
@@truthboom no he is not. labelling him more as a proto-feminist accurate. yes, he thought women in the Muslim world were treated badly and thought women deserved equal right but there's more to feminism than that. a lot of what feminism teaches contradicts the Quran and what it teaches. and no he wouldn't. sorry to break it to you, the guy was a devout Muslim. read his books. just because he agreed some parts of what we know as modernity and liberalism today doesn't mean he would agree with what it whole hearted stands for. AGAIN, read his books and biography.
Human being is no different from an animal if has no contribution in the development of this world, Ibn Rushd translated the books of Aristotle who is the biggest fan of Plato and so on .. but what make Ibn Ruchd very special that he contributed not only in philosophy but also in many other practocal fields. Congrats for your contribution 👏🏼(comments)
Aristotle was the main student of Plato. Both Plato and Aristotle have in their philosophical views have in common, yet in many places where they differ greatly. You can Observe this in Aristotle’s Metaphysics. And many other books of the Philosophiser. @@MedAlaoui099
"Just because you have a biased view of Islam as being irrational and can't imagine a rationalist like Ibn Rushd being a devout Muslim, doesn't make it true."
@@saqibsheikh2790 well it depends, like not everything he said would go against traditional ideas but his views about resurrection are suspicious to say the least
I'm an Aussie Anglo-Scot and in my youth/uni i loved my art history esp the European Renaissance and have long sought to understand the Ancients, near Ancients and deep ones alike. I'm into that which presaged the Sumerians and set the scene for all the derivatives! So much came from those excellent Islamic scholars. I 'love' Averroes (Ibn Rusd.) He was/is so astute, sensitive, firm and gentle and keenly balanced especially clearly so in his understanding of the non-duality of gender. Hip hip hooray! There were so many fine chaps in all the traditions. Nuance nuance nuance! THANK YOU FOR YOU SUPERB VIDEO FORMAT AND CONTENT.
I love how you compare the intellectual battle between al-Ghazali and Averroes as "a medieval rap battle". We have to ask the youtube channel Rap Battles of history to actually translate these discussions into a rap battle.
Thank you for this. I am middle aged and not a scholar, I am semi retired and enjoy travelling (predominantly long distance mountain hikes). These travels have piqued my curiosity about the histories of our societies that are symbiotice with our geographical world. I will never be a scholar, but having hiked through the mountains of Andalucia for multiple weeks at a time, visiting the archeolological sites, the seats of learning such as Córdoba and Toledo amongst many others, learning about figures such as Averroes ignites my mind and inspires me to read more and walk further. A second month-long coast to coast hike across the mountains of Andalucia will start soon, and I hope to carry Averroes and his thoughts with me. Life is good at such times! Good for the body, soul and mind.
I have been searching for a video like this. As an Spaniard, I feel sad because we usually tend to reject, or to at least forget, what Al-Andalus meant for the whole country, and how it went to model our society. It is usually seen as something from 'abroad', and we do not really get to know much of it, and generally from a biased perspective. Of course, views might differ from mine, and other Spanish may have a different impression, but I really feel like we lost a lot when the Catholic Kings expeled all Muslims... They had no right to do so; they claimed being descendents from the Visigoths, and the Moors, invadors. But what were the Visigoths, if not the same? What were the Romans, then, who came before them, and thus the Carthanigians, the Celts, the Greeks, the Iberians, and all those who came before? Islam is seen today as a religion of hate, and that does not seem fair. And I myself am a convinced atheist, I would not change that for anything, but we should learn to see other cultures as having depth, different points of view within them, just like our societies. Spain was once half Muslim, and although we might tend to forget that part of our national history, at least in our language remain a notable amount of words from Arabic; ojalá que la albóndiga esté en la alhacena junto a la almohada.
The Andalucian culture was a huge influence on the entire Mediterranean region, they had arts and sciences and discoveries that are still very impressive nowadays... I find it sad that not only it's been forsaken by its people but that actual foreigners to it like the ottomans claimed portions of it as their own while they made no contributions to its prosperity
You spoke about those who came before the civilization of Islam in Andalusia, Spain today, and I tell you before the Romans, the Arabs in Mesopotamia and Syria lived in a civilization that Europe did not witness in their time, even before the Romans. Humanity shared with each other in civilization, as for this hatred of Islam The issue of politics because Christianity and Judaism do not say terrorism and the terrorism of these two religions is terrorism of states and not terrorism of groups or individuals as it is in Islam, which is represented by terrorists such as “De Gaulle” who killed humanity in Africa, Syria and Lebanon, Churchill and today, for example, George Bush Who destroyed Iraq, and Putin who destroyed Syria under the pretext of protecting Christianity
I am a traditional Roman Catholic and even a seminarian for my diocese, but I am grateful to this man for the intellectual contribution in the discipline of reason.
I’m a Coptic seminarian who is interested in studying scholasticism and philosophical theology with our Catholic brothers after my current course of study. Might you be interested in connecting?
“If Scripture conflicts with science or common sense, that means you have to read Scripture as an allegory.” How much mess and suffering could be prevented if more people took that to heart!
@@Jade22Roller You're preaching to the choir, mate ;-) Still, stuff such as 'turn the other cheek' or 'hate the sin, love the sinner' *do* make sense. The first is the basis of passive resistance, the latter _the_ survival recipe for folks such as teachers to survive and perhaps even tackle bad behaviour.
@@Jade22Roller that's a misrepresentation of Ibn Rushd's works. It means "if scripture conflicts with science or reasoning then you are most likely interpreting the scripture wrong"
i always love learning religion and philosophy, great video. and contrary to popular belief among the non-muslim word. Islam focuses on rationality alot!
I would love you to make a podcast or something like that discussing philosophical treaties in depth. I love your videos, they are very useful for a student of arabic philology.
I like to think Ibn Rushd IS the reason why Christianity became more accepting of scientific and philosophical ideas over time. Not the direct reason, of course, but the people his work influenced.
@@silveryuno im referring to classical liberalism, which grew out of renaissance humanism iirc, i think yhat led to christianity accepting for different ideas
@@forgetful9845 A good point. A fair point. But Ibn Rushd was know and studied in Christian Europe even before that, as Saint Thomas Aquinas can attest.
Thank you for an interesting and very informative presentation of ibn Rushd, his influence on European philosophy and his eminent position in his own time and place. Your style was direct and most eloquent!
Thank you very much for introducing personalities of past. You way of narration is wonderful, and your grip on topic is remarkable and unbiased. Thanks again.
@Amperoar Qw As mentioned in the video, it is a mistake to use modern labels on people in the past. Also, I am uncertain that he would classify as an atheist even so. Just because you are capable of thinking for yourself, and not fall pray to established dogma, it does not mean you are not religious at all. I know those who consider themselves christian altho they believe in reincarnation. People are complicated and so is religion. Dont get me wrong. I am quite in favor for atheism, but we must view this from an unbiased perspective (as far as that is possible) in order to get closer to the truth.
you are younger to me by age. but I admire you as one of my teachers in knowing, understanding and contextualizing different streams of ancient knowledge across the civilizations. you are making a great contribution to bridging religious traditions, philosophical schools of antiquity and medieval periods to our contemporary consciousness beyond the rational irrational binary. in this days of postmodern xenophobia, Islamophobia in particular and hatred of lesser known or understood cultures and traditions, it has huge value for immediate learning as well as illumination of our darkened souls. Indeed you are offering us, a conference of birds in in search of a common sky for the divided humanity. Kudos.
I am from India a retired journalist and seeker of knowledge. your videos on Dara shiko and dialogue between Hindu and Sufi traditions in my country enriched me greatly. As I cannot afford anymore to buy those books you refer, you are introduction to the treasure tropes only enhances the quest for better social cultural synthesis in my troubled land as well as longing for harmony between our inner selves and external realities. thank you again.❤
This channel has a special place in my heart ❤️ thank you for such scholarly videos essays. Truly inspiring! It is always a pleasure to learn and benefit from your knowledge. May Allah be pleased with you.
Thankyou for this video! I love the quality of this information and production of the video. Normally history is very boring for me and you held my attention for 30 minutes 🙌🏼👏🏼 May God bless you and your efforts. Thankyou so much!
I really love your videos, and I thank you for your truthfulness about religion. Am a Muslim from the Caribbean, who knew is muslims from my country, but nothing about Islam 😍 as did most of the muslims in my Country at that time. But when I migrated to the USA I started listening to African Americans giving dua, and I became very interested in Islam.
Dude, your content is so great. Youre sharing some knowledge that is ommited on modern western society. Appreciate the research and you sharing it with us. I fucking love youtube creators.
Few people in the modern West realise that Thomas Aquinas' religious philosophy came directly from Ibn Rushd's reading and interpretation of Aristotle. Personally I don't like Aristotle but it amuses me and annoys me in equal measure how Aquinas is cited as a very important figure in the development of "Western thought" without understanding the role of Rushd and Islamic civilisation in that development. Ibn Rushd's attitude to women is heartening especially considering he was a student of Aristotle who had decidedly reactionary views on female emancipation. It is remarkable to think about the high level of philosophical debate that Rushd was engaged in Al Andalus at that time, especially if we contrast it to the limited intellectual life of the rest of Europe at the same period. Today people cite Oxford, Cambridge and Bologna as the first "European" universities without ever considering that of Cordoba, or the fact that those first educational institutions in Christendom were based on an Islamic model and filled (in terms of the curriculum) with Islamic learning.
@@zayan6284 OMG how intellectually dishonest you are! Anything to downgrade you minimise the importance of medieval Islamic learning! And his wasn't Averroes!
@@rafthejaf8789 How do you know what I think about the contribution of the Islamic world to Philosophy is when I have only ever interacted with you through a single TH-cam comment?
Finally we see recognition from them ! It is a consideration of history , and a consideration of the peoples as well..... Yes , it's the universality of thought and creativity.
in the 8th century, the Islamic world, the Middle East, the concept of a round earth research, Geleleo was punished by Greja 'Greja thinks the earth is flat
Superb and engaging, highly informative, well-summarized ( a great skill), as are all your lectures. Love the images, the notes, dates, names of books, terminology, very helpful for students. I use your videos in the courses I teach.
I pray for you brother, what a great service you are doing. I don’t have money now, but I invite you to my house in Andalusia when all of this pandemic finishes God willing. And I show you some secrets of Al-Andalus. There is a beautiful Sufi community in here. We have also people from Sweden living amongst us. You’ll love it 😊
@Moose The Goose Sufis are innovators who practice Shirk. The only true Islam is in Saudi Arabia with all the Skyscrapers and gold microphones in the mosques, this is the true Sunnah. Thank you for the warning I will be more careful. I only follow Shayck Albani Aqida, he lived in the 20th century a true Sahaba I only repeat what he says and call other Muslims Kafirs, if they don’t agree with me. Thank you for warning me. I entered Islam for Sufism, but I was misguided, only true Salafs like Abdul Wahhab that lived in the 18th century are well guided, the rest were innovators. Keep the good work you’re comments are very enlightening.
@Moose The Goose I’m glad that you see this about the Saudis. But you didn’t get my irony. Sufis are many branches and many have donde crazy thinks, but don’t say Sufis are not Muslims brother, don’t judge people this is Allah’s job. There are Hadith that proof Sufism. The Prophet PBUH praised and predicted Sultat Mehmet al Fatih, the opener of Istanbul and he was Sufi. The Prophet ﷺ is reported to have said, ‘Verily you shall conquer Constantinople. What a wonderful leader will her leader be, and what a wonderful army will that army be!’ [Musnad Ahmad, Al Hakim, al Jami’ al Saghir] They were from the Tariqat Naqshbandi a Sufi order, and the Prophet PBUH praised them. th-cam.com/video/Gxa63o8rs_w/w-d-xo.html Have a look. Brother don’t call Sufis non Muslim, you could be committing a big sin 1733. Abu Dharr (May Allah be pleased with him) said: I heard the Messenger of Allah pbuh saying, "If somebody accuses another of disbelief or calls him the enemy of Allah, such an accusation will revert to him (the accuser) if the accused is innocent.'' [Al-Bukhari and Muslim].
Thank you very much for short and concise explanation! I think many people need to watch your channel if they want to understand Salman Rushdie's books, in particular his "Two Years Eight Months and Twenty-Eight Nights".
But it took me a few years before I started gravitating more and more toward Islam. Am Muslim today and am very very happy with my conversion, and that decision. And listening to you I have learned soooo much more about the religion and am very happy with your teachings. I saying thank you very very much for your truthfulness and dedication. But I really will like to know something about Africans and Islam, all of your study is based on Arab people, and nothing on The African Preasants and input in Islam. Don't we have some history in the Islamic world, did we not play a part in the time of the Prophet Muhammad. Was Arabia all people of olive skin ? It's very hard to believe that the people of Africa had not real important role at the time of the Prophet Muhammad, except the call to pray, and the first woman who died for her belief in The oneness of Allah/God. PLEASE I will love for you to elaborate on my questions. And again I thank you very much for for all your videos. Peace always love always 😍❤
But in reality today Muslim really extremely closed minded. That's why most of them became radical. It's sad honestly. Islam just God messages. By small view some will called that's Arab religion but it's universal message
Thank you for the Video. Can you do a video of Abdul Qadir Jilani, I’m especially interested in his views on Hannafis. Your videos are great. Keep it up 👍
This channel is an absolute gem of a channel and I'm LOVING it. I cannot go back to my courses and studies, I'm really addicted to your videos!!! Thanks a lot to you wonderful people. I have a suggestion, could you dig deeper into "Mansour Hallaj"? He is a legendary sufi who has a famous story in one of Attar's works. He is a kind of symbol of searching for the truth in our culture. Thanks a lot again!
Ibn rushd was still very influential in the islamicate world as a scholar of jurisprudence. His bidayatul mujthahid was a standard text to many of the usulul fiqh students in many madrasas across the eastern World if I'm not mistaken.
@@abdallaosman5268 what? It still is. Same guy who wrote Bidayat al Mujtahid wrote the rebuttal to Imam Ghazali. Ibn Rushd. It's still the go-to book on Islamic jurisprudence.
@@imgguru1277 you’re right, I’m wrong, I assumed it was cuz his grandfather (who has the exact same name) was a great Maliki Jurist who wrote multiple intros to fiqh and fiqh comparisons but apparently Ibn Rushd the grandson wrote an intro book of fiqh like his grandfather even though it wasn’t his domain. www.uop.edu.jo/download/research/members/65_1737_Haro.doc
@@abdallaosman5268 how was it not his domain? He was a qadi "judge" which means he was very well aware of usul al fiqh otherwise he couldn't become a judge ( or Islamic judge).
You guys comment usul fiqh non muslim when read their reaction..what is that thou..even syariah they confuse..they thought its a bad thing🤣while it came from same source al quran,hadith,and sunnah..it creep them..they didnt know the meaning of islam way of life..it cover ALL FIELD..if they know they suprised😃
It’s time now bro...you’ve covered Ibn rushd and hardcore rationalism. Your audience wants it, and you’ve seen them ask and ask over again that I know it has annoyed you to death. You have to make that highly anticipated video about salafism now. You know you got to do it, now is the perfect time! Cmon man, it will be fun!
Let's Talk Religion yeah why are there so few views on it right now? Did you not mean to make this video public already? The al ghazali video had a lot more views! I just scrolled down your channel list last night and it said that a video about Ibn rushd was released nine hours ago, so if u didn’t mean to release it so soon idk how I even came across it😂😂
Nice video and quite informative. However I personally find the clash of thoughts and ideas between Ibn Sina and Ibn Rushd (averrose) very refreshing and interesting. The fact that their attitudes towards each other with all that passionate scientific responses ( regardless if we do agree with both of them on every single detail of their philosophy or not) prove that they had no respect to the status quo when it comes to delivering real knowledge and a solid scientific ground” from their perspective” to their followers, students, and all those who have been influencing down the road.It is something in history we don’t get to see a lot. Especially people of their caliber just being fiercely passionate to that awesome meaningful philosophy without caring that it might just provoke a counter attack on their side that might affect their credentials, or taint their reputation but nope they just didn’t care. Which give us a hint to what they were actually loyal toward representing and what side of success they stood for, True and integral science. actually they gave mankind their best and with no fear of risking their fame and that frankly worked as a brainstorming sessions for intellectuals throughout history. And that all what it matters
Averroes (Ibn Rushd) was so admired as an Aristotle commentator in the latin Europe that they didn't even have to mention his name.. they just said "the commentators says" and they knew you are referring to Averroes
Ibn taymiyeh was just an ignorant salafi takfiri terrorist. No brains only hate. You Can't compare him to free thinkers and scholars like ibn rushed and ibn khaldoun.
@@goldenphoenix4475 hahaha ! Seriously!! Have you read any of his works? Especially in the realm of philosophy? It sounds that you just making an emotional judgement rather than solid critical one 😅
@@tompoiambs7562 by your comment i can see you know nothing about Ibn Taymmiyyah With all due respect , and let me tell you how, first of all "muslims hate Ibn Taymmiyaah " is a general statement that means nothing, given that most muslims wouldn't make such a statement, except some Shiaa or Sufi , sometimes new platonic Muslims, and those are minorities in the realm of Islam and we can't trust their word regarding Ibn Taymmiyyah because he criticize them a lot. second of all, Ibn Taymmiyah was not a supporter of school of thought which says The reason takes precedence over transmission. obviously you haven't read his masterpiece"Statement of reasonable express consent to properly transferred fend off a conflict of reason and transport" or something closer to this if i try to translate the book title. which is clear from it's title even if you haven't read it (and i am sure you haven't coz it hasn't yet translated to english) but he made a solid Thesis about the conflict of our reason with what has been transferred to us (revelation)
@@tompoiambs7562 you are Sunni and you hate Ibn Taymmiyyah 🤔? Regardless hate or love, Can you explain rationally where do you agree or disagree with his thesises?
Thanks for sharing such informative videos. Keep it up. I also love those arguments/counter arguments between Ghazali and Ibn e Rushd and you can agree or disagree with their ideas but the most important thing is that they are trying to convey their ideas with arguments, logic and references which brings up the question that where did that all went wrong as a society and culture and I really don’t have any answer for that but as a Muslim I really appreciate those people who lived and did such great work many centuries ago. Stay blessed. P.S: You have grown a beard which suits you very well and you also have a good “Talafuz” :)
Ah you just had to put Al-Ghazali and Ibn Rushd next to each other, I am sure they appreciate the company :). Great Minds, very different outlook and perspective. Fascinating!
Al-Ghazali has actually turned out to be correct. Early in the twentieth century, the anti-philosophy philosophers finally buried philosophy by acknowledging, like al-Ghazali, that problems of philosophy are actually problems of language, and language by itself cannot unlock mysteries of nature or reality. Science was made the only criterion to ascertain the veracity of facts or fiction. And, thus, philosophy died. This is why you don't hear about new philosophers coming to light. Philosophy we read today are simply ruminations of the past.
So glad I found this channel. Anyways my take is that this person reminds me of Thomas Jefferson. In school I fell in love with his ideas and writings, only to be dismayed that in all practicality he was largely ignored when it came to how the USA ended up being structured. We revere him as a founder but have strayed so far from his vision.
True but We can see the consequences of that irrational censorship in the Islamic philosophy since the 12 th century ghazali was more traditional then ibn rushed true but he stil had rational thoughts and critical thinking compared to IBN Tiamiya,dschauziya and Al wahab till today it got even worst with the growing influence of wahabi Islam in the last 200 years. They destroyed 90% of all pre Islamic and islamic shrines, graves,historical buildings,libraries and even mosques. And till today archeology around these historical places is forbidden, same as in mekka, they destroyed most historical monuments and graves and replaced them with skyscrapers. And they spread there censored wahabi Islam around the world by social media and by financing thousands of mosques worldwide.
@Amperoar Qw wahabism leads to terror and divided totalitarian society's. And is not compatible with the theology of most Islamic and universal scholars of the golden age between the 7th and 13th century. The wahabi sauds destroyed most of the pre Islamic and Islamic shrines,graves,mosques,churches and temples from the last 3000 years to redefine the history on the Arab peninsula by there wahab narrative and They don't allow archeologists from all over the world to do scientific research in mekka,medina,Petra etc.
@Amperoar Qw stay ignorant and follow the wahab sect not my problem...Do you even live in a country with Islamic laws or you just idealised something that you have never experienced in real life as a social order ?
@Amperoar Qw I did and I disagree and I don't see any arguments against these important rational arab,persian universal scholars who made the so called golden age of " Islam " what it was. And it didn't came back since the 13th century and was mostly destroyed by wahabi,salafi,deobandic radical ideas.
People today forget how progressive and important to western thought Islam was especially during this time in history. Without them keeping classical thought alive and vibrant, it's unlikely that there would have been a Renaissance.
4:00 Meeting Ibn Tufayl in Marrakesh Discussion with Abu Yakub Yusuf (Almohad Caliph) 5:21 Becoming a Qadhi in Cordoba & later becoming court physicians to Abu Yakub Yusuf & Abu Yusuf Yakub Championing Aristotle 9:51 *Philosophy & Religion* 20:04 Forced to flee Marrakesh (returned two years later)
![ร้อยพ่อพันแม่ - WanMai [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XY2pNYASEbg/mqdefault.jpg)
Your Arabic pronunciation is on point
From an Englishman who knows very little of Islam in general..TY ,you've widened my knowledge and opinion...
He speaks more from Muslim history then what Islam is.
This is a better playlist to show you what Islam is.
th-cam.com/play/PLLWosYrkNwE9_IdtxX_sI2BuOdmr8P8xQ.html
@@3-Kashmirit's sad today there's a lot ignorant Muslim who radical and really closed minded. And more sad is lot of them is grew up in West country. Khawarij already take over Islam and change what prophet Muhammad actually taught
@@3-Kashmir this playlist only teaches you what traditionalist islam is. most people already have an general understanding of what tradiotionalist islam entails. understanding history of the rationalist movement in islamic history is also extremely important to understanding of islam and for most westerners, more important
@@3-Kashmiryou should surely check the rest of that series ... where they DO talk about islamic philosophy or philosophy in the islamic world .... th-cam.com/video/viJc5754IH4/w-d-xo.htmlsi=TXg8IjSFbqxUq-Lt ...... also the Hamza Yusuf video about Ihsan in your link talks about Ibn Rushd and Imam Al Ghazali ....... so there ....
I wanna say that I really appreciate how you as a European and non-Muslim have a very nuanced view of our faith. I feel like both Western academics and our own scholars possess view that rationalism, science, philosophy, etc are incompatible with religion, that Islam can only be one set of beliefs, and the Orthodoxy is infallible, even though for our entire history up this has never been the case
Perhaps it is due to your European and non-Muslim upbringing. There was a man in the 20th century named Leopold Weiss aka Muhammad Asad, who was born a secular European Jew who later become a devout Muslim and scholar. When he visited Al-Azhar University, he noticed that the students would sit all day reciting and learning the works of great medieval theologians and philosophers to be taught Islamic law. However this was all they did, and were hardly allowed to become theologians and philosophers for themselves. Asad wondered why these students were being taught this way and could not get a decent answer from the people there. He wrote extensively about how crazy it was to say, in what was once the greatest places of thinking in the world, that only these specific medieval thinkers ideas were correct and that thinking in the modern era was heavily discouraged for seemingly no good reason. Though this problem still is an issue among many Muslims today, but I am glad many people like you, Muslim or not, are still able to see Islam for what it really is
Oh my God thank you for bringing up Leopold (Asad). Road to Mecca and his interpretation of the Quran (+ the very first english translation of sahih bukhari) are AMAZING. His translations are particularly niche because he 'felt' the language of arabic after spending a decade with bedouins. There's an immense difference between learning a language for scholastic reasons and learning a language's 'soul' which can primarily be achieved through experience.
Also this is also the reason why I like this channel. I would still trust a non muslim's interpretation more since the current muslim world largely propagates the same teachings without any independent thinking ( you'll be declared a heretic lol )
@@selloutplayer that is just a ridiculous belief to hold
Very well said dortoka
@@soulreaper1945 simping for non-Muslims and lying about Muslims calling you a heretic doesn’t make you smart lol. If you’re being called a heretic by all muslims, chances are that you are one 👍🏾
He was one of the brilliant minds of the Islamic Golden Age. Often dubbed as the 'Founding Father of western thought', his works left a profound & ever lasting effect on names like Voltaire & Rene Descartes.
i will be very careful of calling him that.
a lot of what we call "western thought" often contradict the teachings of Islam. yes we can all agree he laid the seeds for the Renaissance and Enlightenment age but i don't think he would have agree with "West's" conclusion which is liberalism and secularism.
@@rethabilefeni4694At that time, secularism stay in his roots for anti ignorance and tyranny in religion name like happen in dark age, unlike today where secularism is hostility towards religion. In renaissance and enlightenment there are lot intellectual of West who strict religious. Funny enough, that stuff which happening in dark age of medieval Europe is happening in Muslim country today. And in West, a secular already start to hostile towards any religion and theology especially abrahamic one
@@rethabilefeni4694 He's feminist and favorable towards music since he argue some women play better in melodies.
He definitely will side with liberalism, if he the reason of islam contradict of islam, then islam is unreasonable
@@truthboom
no he is not. labelling him more as a proto-feminist accurate. yes, he thought women in the Muslim world were treated badly and thought women deserved equal right but there's more to feminism than that. a lot of what feminism teaches contradicts the Quran and what it teaches.
and no he wouldn't. sorry to break it to you, the guy was a devout Muslim.
read his books.
just because he agreed some parts of what we know as modernity and liberalism today doesn't mean he would agree with what it whole hearted stands for.
AGAIN, read his books and biography.
@@rethabilefeni4694 Voltaire himself won't agree with liberalism, but you don't have any problem with Voltaire. What is your point ?
Ibn "I'm the biggest fan of Aristotle" Rushd
He just a commentator. Btw, Europeans are the biggest fan of Jesus, a Jew from Middle East. And many still worship him.
@@ndorobei4391 THEY WORSHIP A MAN!!!! even tho he never claimed to be god nor did he ever say they should worship him.....
@@ndorobei4391 chill bro
Human being is no different from an animal if has no contribution in the development of this world, Ibn Rushd translated the books of Aristotle who is the biggest fan of Plato and so on .. but what make Ibn Ruchd very special that he contributed not only in philosophy but also in many other practocal fields.
Congrats for your contribution 👏🏼(comments)
Aristotle was the main student of Plato. Both Plato and Aristotle have in their philosophical views have in common, yet in many places where they differ greatly. You can Observe this in Aristotle’s Metaphysics. And many other books of the Philosophiser. @@MedAlaoui099
"Just because you have a biased view of Islam as being irrational and can't imagine a rationalist like Ibn Rushd being a devout Muslim, doesn't make it true."
I love this
@@MrChi31 me too ;)
I adooooored this
Nowadays, it is mostly traditional Muslims who would reject Ibn Rushd
@@saqibsheikh2790 well it depends, like not everything he said would go against traditional ideas but his views about resurrection are suspicious to say the least
I'm an Aussie Anglo-Scot and in my youth/uni i loved my art history esp the European Renaissance and have long sought to understand the Ancients, near Ancients and deep ones alike. I'm into that which presaged the Sumerians and set the scene for all the derivatives! So much came from those excellent Islamic scholars. I 'love' Averroes (Ibn Rusd.) He was/is so astute, sensitive, firm and gentle and keenly balanced especially clearly so in his understanding of the non-duality of gender. Hip hip hooray! There were so many fine chaps in all the traditions. Nuance nuance nuance! THANK YOU FOR YOU SUPERB VIDEO FORMAT AND CONTENT.
If it weren't for the Islamic Golden age the Renaissance wouldn't happen, yet many europeans see themselves as a superior race
Can you give a source for his understanding of the non duality of gender please.
@@prammar1951 minute 21:00
@@abdullahelwan405 Factually false.
What you mean by Gender Non-Duality?
I love how you compare the intellectual battle between al-Ghazali and Averroes as "a medieval rap battle". We have to ask the youtube channel Rap Battles of history to actually translate these discussions into a rap battle.
Hell yes!
I'd be down to help write it... though it would too much research XD
Epic Rap Battles did that with Socrates, Nietzsche, and Voltaire vs Sun Tzu, Confucius, and Lao Tzu
@@srash8854 yes but not Al-Ghazali vs Averroes
@@srash8854 haha i see you are a man of culture as well 😌
Thank you for this. I am middle aged and not a scholar, I am semi retired and enjoy travelling (predominantly long distance mountain hikes). These travels have piqued my curiosity about the histories of our societies that are symbiotice with our geographical world. I will never be a scholar, but having hiked through the mountains of Andalucia for multiple weeks at a time, visiting the archeolological sites, the seats of learning such as Córdoba and Toledo amongst many others, learning about figures such as Averroes ignites my mind and inspires me to read more and walk further. A second month-long coast to coast hike across the mountains of Andalucia will start soon, and I hope to carry Averroes and his thoughts with me. Life is good at such times! Good for the body, soul and mind.
I have been searching for a video like this. As an Spaniard, I feel sad because we usually tend to reject, or to at least forget, what Al-Andalus meant for the whole country, and how it went to model our society. It is usually seen as something from 'abroad', and we do not really get to know much of it, and generally from a biased perspective. Of course, views might differ from mine, and other Spanish may have a different impression, but I really feel like we lost a lot when the Catholic Kings expeled all Muslims... They had no right to do so; they claimed being descendents from the Visigoths, and the Moors, invadors. But what were the Visigoths, if not the same? What were the Romans, then, who came before them, and thus the Carthanigians, the Celts, the Greeks, the Iberians, and all those who came before?
Islam is seen today as a religion of hate, and that does not seem fair. And I myself am a convinced atheist, I would not change that for anything, but we should learn to see other cultures as having depth, different points of view within them, just like our societies. Spain was once half Muslim, and although we might tend to forget that part of our national history, at least in our language remain a notable amount of words from Arabic; ojalá que la albóndiga esté en la alhacena junto a la almohada.
The Andalucian culture was a huge influence on the entire Mediterranean region, they had arts and sciences and discoveries that are still very impressive nowadays... I find it sad that not only it's been forsaken by its people but that actual foreigners to it like the ottomans claimed portions of it as their own while they made no contributions to its prosperity
You spoke about those who came before the civilization of Islam in Andalusia, Spain today, and I tell you before the Romans, the Arabs in Mesopotamia and Syria lived in a civilization that Europe did not witness in their time, even before the Romans. Humanity shared with each other in civilization, as for this hatred of Islam The issue of politics because Christianity and Judaism do not say terrorism and the terrorism of these two religions is terrorism of states and not terrorism of groups or individuals as it is in Islam, which is represented by terrorists such as “De Gaulle” who killed humanity in Africa, Syria and Lebanon, Churchill and today, for example, George Bush Who destroyed Iraq, and Putin who destroyed Syria under the pretext of protecting Christianity
Viva Hispanidad! And Viva Cristo Rey! 🇪🇦✝️
@@odanobunaga7584 ?
@@pablodiazmellado3208 I'm a Spanish-American Catholic and I'm proud of my Spanish Catholic history.
I am a traditional Roman Catholic and even a seminarian for my diocese, but I am grateful to this man for the intellectual contribution in the discipline of reason.
I’m a Coptic seminarian who is interested in studying scholasticism and philosophical theology with our Catholic brothers after my current course of study. Might you be interested in connecting?
The saint Thomas Aquinas respected him
Much appreciated.. May God bless you more with knowledge, wisdom and success.
@ALEX HECTOR the God of Abraham.
@ALEX HECTOR all you can do is slander. May the light of god find you some day.
@ALEX HECTOR if my god is a god of idols, your god is a god of pigs, clearly, if he brought you into this world
@ALEX HECTOR Ah! A keyboard ninja Islamophobe. Have mercy on yourself and leave this comment section. Period.
@@turkialsul7847 What else is there you think of?
These videos are genuinely so amazing, excellent work.
EYYYY
Hakimmm!!!!
The most unexpected crossover
Hello Hakim
No need for a tankie
“If Scripture conflicts with science or common sense, that means you have to read Scripture as an allegory.” How much mess and suffering could be prevented if more people took that to heart!
That means that the religion is wrong and you shouldn't follow it if you find yourself smarter than "god"
@@Jade22Roller You're preaching to the choir, mate ;-)
Still, stuff such as 'turn the other cheek' or 'hate the sin, love the sinner' *do* make sense. The first is the basis of passive resistance, the latter _the_ survival recipe for folks such as teachers to survive and perhaps even tackle bad behaviour.
@@Jade22Rollerhe mean that people fail in translate what the holy book actually mean
@@Jade22Roller that's a misrepresentation of Ibn Rushd's works.
It means "if scripture conflicts with science or reasoning then you are most likely interpreting the scripture wrong"
Ibn-Rushd,John Locke,Rousseau and Socrates are my favourite philosophers,they changed my life!
John Locke was pretty great
@@gunchawaseem4440 100%
I just finished spinoza's ethics last month,and its my favourite book now
if today's scientists read Locke what a different world we would be living in
@@averagesauceenjoyer7209 yeap, btw i finished death note yesterday,and it was dopee!! Good to see it on ur dp
Bro, your channel is a gem and I’m so thankful I found it. Keep up the great work!
In Morocco we have many places in his name, a very famous philosopher, I love his theories, they wronged him when they burned his books 🥺🥺
And that doomed the Islamic world to 1000 year of dark age. I hope, the islamic world will champion his thoughts now and become a partner of europe.
i always love learning religion and philosophy, great video.
and contrary to popular belief among the non-muslim word. Islam focuses on rationality alot!
sadly not anymore. I hope i can see the time when muslim back to free and rational thinker.
I would love you to make a podcast or something like that discussing philosophical treaties in depth. I love your videos, they are very useful for a student of arabic philology.
That would be incredibly useful!
Islamic Philosophy actually. Many many races contributed to philosophy under Islam and not the Arab ethnicity in particular
I enjoy learning about Ibn Rushd. Thank you for giving us such a simple yet informative video about this great philosopher.
U gotta appreate the level of research that has gone into this vid
@Richard Blake and, what's your point?
@Richard Blake continue your barking
Absolutely. Excellent research.
Good level of research for sure. Although some of the personal inputs are rather bias
I like to think Ibn Rushd IS the reason why Christianity became more accepting of scientific and philosophical ideas over time. Not the direct reason, of course, but the people his work influenced.
I feel like thats more because of liberalism
@@forgetful9845 I am not sure if society was very "liberal" back then...
@Okbuddy Retrad Damn right!
@@silveryuno im referring to classical liberalism, which grew out of renaissance humanism iirc, i think yhat led to christianity accepting for different ideas
@@forgetful9845 A good point. A fair point.
But Ibn Rushd was know and studied in Christian Europe even before that, as Saint Thomas Aquinas can attest.
Thank you for an interesting and very informative presentation of ibn Rushd, his influence on European philosophy and his eminent position in his own time and place. Your style was direct and most eloquent!
Thank you very much for introducing personalities of past. You way of narration is wonderful, and your grip on topic is remarkable and unbiased. Thanks again.
What an awesome guy!
Would like to see more like him in our age.
@Amperoar Qw As mentioned in the video, it is a mistake to use modern labels on people in the past. Also, I am uncertain that he would classify as an atheist even so. Just because you are capable of thinking for yourself, and not fall pray to established dogma, it does not mean you are not religious at all. I know those who consider themselves christian altho they believe in reincarnation. People are complicated and so is religion.
Dont get me wrong. I am quite in favor for atheism, but we must view this from an unbiased perspective (as far as that is possible) in order to get closer to the truth.
you are younger to me by age. but I admire you as one of my teachers in knowing, understanding and contextualizing different streams of ancient knowledge across the civilizations. you are making a great contribution to bridging religious traditions, philosophical schools of antiquity and medieval periods to our contemporary consciousness beyond the rational irrational binary. in this days of postmodern xenophobia, Islamophobia in particular and hatred of lesser known or understood cultures and traditions, it has huge value for immediate learning as well as illumination of our darkened souls. Indeed you are offering us, a conference of birds in in search of a common sky for the divided humanity. Kudos.
I am from India a retired journalist and seeker of knowledge. your videos on Dara shiko and dialogue between Hindu and Sufi traditions in my country enriched me greatly. As I cannot afford anymore to buy those books you refer, you are introduction to the treasure tropes only enhances the quest for better social cultural synthesis in my troubled land as well as longing for harmony between our inner selves and external realities. thank you again.❤
Your channel is a gem ❤️.. from a Naqshbandi brother..
Brilliant !
Thank you so much for this remarquable work.
I am Arabic and Muslim and I appreciate how you pronounce the names! 👍🏽
This channel has a special place in my heart ❤️ thank you for such scholarly videos essays. Truly inspiring! It is always a pleasure to learn and benefit from your knowledge. May Allah be pleased with you.
I was patiently waiting for this one
Same with me?
Found your channel recently.. absolutely love it . Keep up the good work
Here to compliment your perfect pronounciation of the names ^-^
Thankyou for this video! I love the quality of this information and production of the video. Normally history is very boring for me and you held my attention for 30 minutes 🙌🏼👏🏼
May God bless you and your efforts. Thankyou so much!
Thank You Everybody for All that you are doing for our Planet Earth....
Peace.. Shalom.. Salam.. Namaste
🙏🏻 😊 ✌ ☮ ❤
I really love your videos, and I thank you for your truthfulness about religion. Am a Muslim from the Caribbean, who knew is muslims from my country, but nothing about Islam 😍 as did most of the muslims in my Country at that time. But when I migrated to the USA I started listening to African Americans giving dua, and I became very interested in Islam.
Great!
Dude, your content is so great. Youre sharing some knowledge that is ommited on modern western society. Appreciate the research and you sharing it with us. I fucking love youtube creators.
Exceptionally well done 🌹
Thank you so much for sharing.
don't mind me, just commenting for the algorithm
Thank you for your service!
Few people in the modern West realise that Thomas Aquinas' religious philosophy came directly from Ibn Rushd's reading and interpretation of Aristotle. Personally I don't like Aristotle but it amuses me and annoys me in equal measure how Aquinas is cited as a very important figure in the development of "Western thought" without understanding the role of Rushd and Islamic civilisation in that development. Ibn Rushd's attitude to women is heartening especially considering he was a student of Aristotle who had decidedly reactionary views on female emancipation. It is remarkable to think about the high level of philosophical debate that Rushd was engaged in Al Andalus at that time, especially if we contrast it to the limited intellectual life of the rest of Europe at the same period. Today people cite Oxford, Cambridge and Bologna as the first "European" universities without ever considering that of Cordoba, or the fact that those first educational institutions in Christendom were based on an Islamic model and filled (in terms of the curriculum) with Islamic learning.
Averroes was only one of Thomas' many sources, he was not his sole source for Aristotelianism
@@zayan6284 OMG how intellectually dishonest you are! Anything to downgrade you minimise the importance of medieval Islamic learning! And his wasn't Averroes!
@@rafthejaf8789 How do you know what I think about the contribution of the Islamic world to Philosophy is when I have only ever interacted with you through a single TH-cam comment?
@@zayan6284 My comment was based on yours. So apart from Ibn Rushd who were Aquinas' other sources on Aristotle then?
@@rafthejaf8789 Blessed Boethius, Saint Augustine and Cicero.
Finally we see recognition from them !
It is a consideration of history , and a consideration of the peoples as well.....
Yes , it's the universality of thought and creativity.
Ibn Rushd was Galileo 400 years before.
Galileo and ibn rushd🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂 oye shut up
@@Leezeo wut
in the 8th century, the Islamic world, the Middle East, the concept of a round earth research, Geleleo was punished by Greja 'Greja thinks the earth is flat
Superb and engaging, highly informative, well-summarized ( a great skill), as are all your lectures. Love the images, the notes, dates, names of books, terminology, very helpful for students. I use your videos in the courses I teach.
Another great teaching Brother Holm!
Definitely have been waiting for this but you should do a video on Muslim alchemy it has vary mysterious
I pray for you brother, what a great service you are doing. I don’t have money now, but I invite you to my house in Andalusia when all of this pandemic finishes God willing. And I show you some secrets of Al-Andalus. There is a beautiful Sufi community in here. We have also people from Sweden living amongst us. You’ll love it 😊
@Moose The Goose Sufis are innovators who practice Shirk. The only true Islam is in Saudi Arabia with all the Skyscrapers and gold microphones in the mosques, this is the true Sunnah. Thank you for the warning I will be more careful. I only follow Shayck Albani Aqida, he lived in the 20th century a true Sahaba I only repeat what he says and call other Muslims Kafirs, if they don’t agree with me. Thank you for warning me. I entered Islam for Sufism, but I was misguided, only true Salafs like Abdul Wahhab that lived in the 18th century are well guided, the rest were innovators. Keep the good work you’re comments are very enlightening.
@Moose The Goose I’m glad that you see this about the Saudis. But you didn’t get my irony. Sufis are many branches and many have donde crazy thinks, but don’t say Sufis are not Muslims brother, don’t judge people this is Allah’s job. There are Hadith that proof Sufism.
The Prophet PBUH praised and predicted Sultat Mehmet al Fatih, the opener of Istanbul and he was Sufi.
The Prophet ﷺ is reported to have said, ‘Verily you shall conquer Constantinople. What a wonderful leader will her leader be, and what a wonderful army will that army be!’ [Musnad Ahmad, Al Hakim, al Jami’ al Saghir]
They were from the Tariqat Naqshbandi a Sufi order, and the Prophet PBUH praised them.
th-cam.com/video/Gxa63o8rs_w/w-d-xo.html
Have a look.
Brother don’t call Sufis non Muslim, you could be committing a big sin
1733. Abu Dharr (May Allah be pleased with him) said: I heard the Messenger of Allah pbuh saying, "If somebody accuses another of disbelief or calls him the enemy of Allah, such an accusation will revert to him (the accuser) if the accused is innocent.''
[Al-Bukhari and Muslim].
You Live In spain?
@@alexmaurilewis There is no mention of sultan mohammad fatih in any hadith you are lying sufism is pure evil it has nothing to do with islam.
Thank you for creating this great video. Also, your narration is of good quality. Thanks again.🌹
Thank you very much for short and concise explanation!
I think many people need to watch your channel if they want to understand Salman Rushdie's books, in particular his "Two Years Eight Months and Twenty-Eight Nights".
2years8months and 28nights
Thanks for the video. He very much sounds like Thomas Aquinas
Amazing work. Thank you for sharing!
Subscribed at 9.73k
This is such an under rated channel. Awesome content 👌
Outstanding commentary excellently explained Ibn e Rushd
The beef is on! 🛎️
Thank you for the lovely video please don't ever stop! 😍🙏🏼
Mashallah, your channel has grown
always a pleasure to consult you on any topic you choose
I really enjoyed this very educational video. Thank you for sharing some knowledge.
Great work so informative , keep up the great work.
Your Arabic pronunciation is super good!
Excellent yet again as we all expect it to be a big thank you and keep it up 👍🏼
Excellent material.
Great video, It has helped me to understand who this great philosopher was and his contribution to history.
But it took me a few years before I started gravitating more and more toward Islam. Am Muslim today and am very very happy with my conversion, and that decision. And listening to you I have learned soooo much more about the religion and am very happy with your teachings. I saying thank you very very much for your truthfulness and dedication. But I really will like to know something about Africans and Islam, all of your study is based on Arab people, and nothing on The African Preasants and input in Islam. Don't we have some history in the Islamic world, did we not play a part in the time of the Prophet Muhammad. Was Arabia all people of olive skin ? It's very hard to believe that the people of Africa had not real important role at the time of the Prophet Muhammad, except the call to pray, and the first woman who died for her belief in The oneness of Allah/God. PLEASE I will love for you to elaborate on my questions. And again I thank you very much for for all your videos. Peace always love always 😍❤
But in reality today Muslim really extremely closed minded. That's why most of them became radical. It's sad honestly. Islam just God messages. By small view some will called that's Arab religion but it's universal message
Thank you for the Video. Can you do a video of Abdul Qadir Jilani, I’m especially interested in his views on Hannafis. Your videos are great. Keep it up 👍
The most informative 27 minutes of my life I've spent watching a TH-cam video
Allegoricaly speaking, substance over form, any sound is good enough!
I aver the brilliance and genius of this fine work :)
This is amazing, real gems on your channel. Love it
How greatly did Thomas Aquinas incorporste this thought in his Summa,s!!!!
My sincere respect and support from Nigeria
Taking a medieval philosophy final today… gonna tell my prof I wish I had more time “Ibn Rushd!”
Wow you explain videos in-depth and accurate information.
It would be great to hear you talk about Imam Abu Hanifa.
i have an exam on islamic philosophy tomorrow, you saved my life thank you so much !
U study it where ?
This channel is an absolute gem of a channel and I'm LOVING it. I cannot go back to my courses and studies, I'm really addicted to your videos!!! Thanks a lot to you wonderful people.
I have a suggestion, could you dig deeper into "Mansour Hallaj"? He is a legendary sufi who has a famous story in one of Attar's works. He is a kind of symbol of searching for the truth in our culture.
Thanks a lot again!
Ibn rushd was still very influential in the islamicate world as a scholar of jurisprudence. His bidayatul mujthahid was a standard text to many of the usulul fiqh students in many madrasas across the eastern World if I'm not mistaken.
That’s Ibn Rushd the grandfather not the grandson (the grandson is the philosopher)
@@abdallaosman5268 what? It still is. Same guy who wrote Bidayat al Mujtahid wrote the rebuttal to Imam Ghazali. Ibn Rushd. It's still the go-to book on Islamic jurisprudence.
@@imgguru1277 you’re right, I’m wrong, I assumed it was cuz his grandfather (who has the exact same name) was a great Maliki Jurist who wrote multiple intros to fiqh and fiqh comparisons but apparently Ibn Rushd the grandson wrote an intro book of fiqh like his grandfather even though it wasn’t his domain.
www.uop.edu.jo/download/research/members/65_1737_Haro.doc
@@abdallaosman5268 how was it not his domain? He was a qadi "judge" which means he was very well aware of usul al fiqh otherwise he couldn't become a judge ( or Islamic judge).
You guys comment usul fiqh non muslim when read their reaction..what is that thou..even syariah they confuse..they thought its a bad thing🤣while it came from same source al quran,hadith,and sunnah..it creep them..they didnt know the meaning of islam way of life..it cover ALL FIELD..if they know they suprised😃
With Ibn Rushd went the passing of the baton of philosophy from the Muslim to the Western world, what a historical tragedy.
@Hamza Our education system was ruined by colonialism.
Great job please keep it continue. God bless you.
I love this work and will love it if you do videos about the sufis like Sheikh Tidjani and Sheikh Ibrahim Nyass and the like😘
It’s time now bro...you’ve covered Ibn rushd and hardcore rationalism. Your audience wants it, and you’ve seen them ask and ask over again that I know it has annoyed you to death. You have to make that highly anticipated video about salafism now. You know you got to do it, now is the perfect time! Cmon man, it will be fun!
How did you even access this video already haha?
Let's Talk Religion yeah why are there so few views on it right now? Did you not mean to make this video public already? The al ghazali video had a lot more views! I just scrolled down your channel list last night and it said that a video about Ibn rushd was released nine hours ago, so if u didn’t mean to release it so soon idk how I even came across it😂😂
@@parchment543 No this video is not public at the moment, it comes out on Sunday. Must have been some bug that allowed only you to see it!
Let's Talk Religion haha it’s really good though!!!!! Keep up the great work
Thank you! 😊
Very interesting, insightful and informative video. Thanks!!
Very comprehensible talk n found none like u on this topic. Blessings
Very very nice tribute to Ibn e Rushid
Nice video and quite informative. However I personally find the clash of thoughts and ideas between Ibn Sina and Ibn Rushd (averrose) very refreshing and interesting. The fact that their attitudes towards each other with all that passionate scientific responses ( regardless if we do agree with both of them on every single detail of their philosophy or not) prove that they had no respect to the status quo when it comes to delivering real knowledge and a solid scientific ground” from their perspective” to their followers, students, and all those who have been influencing down the road.It is something in history we don’t get to see a lot. Especially people of their caliber just being fiercely passionate to that awesome meaningful philosophy without caring that it might just provoke a counter attack on their side that might affect their credentials, or taint their reputation but nope they just didn’t care. Which give us a hint to what they were actually loyal toward representing and what side of success they stood for, True and integral science. actually they gave mankind their best and with no fear of risking their fame and that frankly worked as a brainstorming sessions for intellectuals throughout history. And that all what it matters
Huge fan of your work. I'll will be donating
Averroes (Ibn Rushd) was so admired as an Aristotle commentator in the latin Europe that they didn't even have to mention his name.. they just said "the commentators says" and they knew you are referring to Averroes
Need this comment for Algorithm!
Great narrative and Thank you
Great video. Thank you!
Great video as usual! Would love to see your introduction of Ibn Taymiyyah
Ibn taymiyeh was just an ignorant salafi takfiri terrorist. No brains only hate. You Can't compare him to free thinkers and scholars like ibn rushed and ibn khaldoun.
@@goldenphoenix4475 hahaha ! Seriously!! Have you read any of his works? Especially in the realm of philosophy? It sounds that you just making an emotional judgement rather than solid critical one 😅
@@tompoiambs7562 by your comment i can see you know nothing about Ibn Taymmiyyah With all due respect , and let me tell you how, first of all "muslims hate Ibn Taymmiyaah " is a general statement that means nothing, given that most muslims wouldn't make such a statement, except some Shiaa or Sufi , sometimes new platonic Muslims, and those are minorities in the realm of Islam and we can't trust their word regarding Ibn Taymmiyyah because he criticize them a lot.
second of all, Ibn Taymmiyah was not a supporter of school of thought which says The reason takes precedence over transmission. obviously you haven't read his masterpiece"Statement of reasonable express consent to properly transferred fend off a conflict of reason and transport" or something closer to this if i try to translate the book title. which is clear from it's title even if you haven't read it (and i am sure you haven't coz it hasn't yet translated to english) but he made a solid Thesis about the conflict of our reason with what has been transferred to us (revelation)
@@tompoiambs7562 you are Sunni and you hate Ibn Taymmiyyah 🤔? Regardless hate or love, Can you explain rationally where do you agree or disagree with his thesises?
@@kamalsaqer9407 I deleted my comment, like you said i no nothing bout ibn taymiyyah
Thanks for sharing such informative videos. Keep it up. I also love those arguments/counter arguments between Ghazali and Ibn e Rushd and you can agree or disagree with their ideas but the most important thing is that they are trying to convey their ideas with arguments, logic and references which brings up the question that where did that all went wrong
as a society and culture and I really don’t have any answer for that but as a Muslim I really appreciate those people who lived and did such great work many centuries ago. Stay blessed.
P.S: You have grown a beard which suits you very well and you also have a good “Talafuz” :)
Quality content right there. I am proud to be a new subscriber.
Ah you just had to put Al-Ghazali and Ibn Rushd next to each other, I am sure they appreciate the company :). Great Minds, very different outlook and perspective. Fascinating!
Al-Ghazali has actually turned out to be correct. Early in the twentieth century, the anti-philosophy philosophers finally buried philosophy by acknowledging, like al-Ghazali, that problems of philosophy are actually problems of language, and language by itself cannot unlock mysteries of nature or reality. Science was made the only criterion to ascertain the veracity of facts or fiction. And, thus, philosophy died. This is why you don't hear about new philosophers coming to light. Philosophy we read today are simply ruminations of the past.
Great talk. Much appreciated
So glad I found this channel. Anyways my take is that this person reminds me of Thomas Jefferson. In school I fell in love with his ideas and writings, only to be dismayed that in all practicality he was largely ignored when it came to how the USA ended up being structured. We revere him as a founder but have strayed so far from his vision.
Ibn Rushd's argument and rationalization of Islam derived from his understanding of the Maqasid Shariah of the Noble Qur'an.
At the end of the day, the way Islam is taught in the Muslim world is the ghazali way and it has been so for centuries. He won.
True but We can see the consequences of that irrational censorship in the Islamic philosophy since the 12 th century ghazali was more traditional then ibn rushed true but he stil had rational thoughts and critical thinking compared to IBN Tiamiya,dschauziya and Al wahab till today it got even worst with the growing influence of wahabi Islam in the last 200 years. They destroyed 90% of all pre Islamic and islamic shrines, graves,historical buildings,libraries and even mosques. And till today archeology around these historical places is forbidden, same as in mekka, they destroyed most historical monuments and graves and replaced them with skyscrapers.
And they spread there censored wahabi Islam around the world by social media and by financing thousands of mosques worldwide.
@Amperoar Qw wahabism leads to terror and divided totalitarian society's. And is not compatible with the theology of most Islamic and universal scholars of the golden age between the 7th and 13th century.
The wahabi sauds destroyed most of the pre Islamic and Islamic shrines,graves,mosques,churches and temples from the last 3000 years to redefine the history on the Arab peninsula by there wahab narrative and They don't allow archeologists from all over the world to do scientific research in mekka,medina,Petra etc.
@Amperoar Qw stay ignorant and follow the wahab sect not my problem...Do you even live in a country with Islamic laws or you just idealised something that you have never experienced in real life as a social order ?
@Amperoar Qw I did and I disagree and I don't see any arguments against these important rational arab,persian universal scholars who made the so called golden age of " Islam " what it was. And it didn't came back since the 13th century and was mostly destroyed by wahabi,salafi,deobandic radical ideas.
@Amperoar Qw ignorance is always wrong.
It would be great if you could make a gist of your videos in the description (like life span, famous works, quotes etc)
Great work anyway. Thanks
People today forget how progressive and important to western thought Islam was especially during this time in history. Without them keeping classical thought alive and vibrant, it's unlikely that there would have been a Renaissance.
Subscribed after seeing you put both orientalist and wahabist tropes in their place at 5:49 !
Great video, I am eagerly waiting for your video on Imaam Malik
4:00 Meeting Ibn Tufayl in Marrakesh
Discussion with Abu Yakub Yusuf (Almohad Caliph)
5:21 Becoming a Qadhi in Cordoba & later becoming court physicians to Abu Yakub Yusuf & Abu Yusuf Yakub
Championing Aristotle
9:51 *Philosophy & Religion*
20:04 Forced to flee Marrakesh (returned two years later)
Love this content keep it up