Is Andor the Best Star Wars Ever? - The Nerd Soup Podcast!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ก.ย. 2024
- Visit factormeals.co... and use promo code NERDSOUP50 for 50% off your first order!
Head to TryFum.com and use code NERDSOUP to save 10% off when you get the Journey pack today!
Beau & Aaron review season one of ANDOR & rank it amongst other STAR WARS projects!
FOLLOW US ON TWITTER, INSTAGRAM & FACEBOOK!
TWITTER! - NerdSoup
Aaron Twitter: @nerdsoupmonkey
Beau Twitter: @beausoup
Teddy Twitter: @TeddyNerdSoup
Nash Twitter: @AnthonyJQNash
Marissa Twitter: @purplegirlns
INSTAGRAM - nerdsoup
FACEBOOK! - NerdSoup
Visit our Patreon page here - patreon.com/nerdsoup
You dont even need to like Star Wars to enjoy this masterpiece. Such briliant writing and acting
I'd go further and say that you have to not be a Star Wars super fan (and maybe even kinda dislike Star Wars) to enjoy it.
@@iliaponomarev1624I kinda wanted to disagree, but then my favourite Star Wars media before Andor was KOTOR 2 which felt like a critique of the Star Wars universe and a love letter at the same time.
@@iliaponomarev1624I’m one of those people. I never hated Star Wars but I just thought the og movies were boring. I watched Andor and it made me want to give the og movies another try.
I like how in Andor, the Empire felt scary again -- they were not buffoons. Also, there wasn't a lightsaber battle every 10 minutes. Just good writing.
Give us a show without plot armor and we will see how scary the Empire is. It was great to have tense moments with the Empire.
I totally agree👍
Absolutely one of the smartest and well done TV series of last year. Criminally under watched.
Is it because it is smart that it is under watched?
@@theranchokid I would argue that it is under watched because people were so put off by the poorly written crap-tastic parade of Star Wars shows Disney released before it. Mando season 1 was reasonably good. but 2 and 3 were... meh. Kenobi was borderline awful, and Boba Fett was a side character in his own show. people dropped most Star Wars shows in general at that point because most of them were not good. So, when something actually worth their time came along, they had already jumped ship.
Easy question for me to answer, somehow, absolutely yes Andor is the best media from the Star Wars universe I’ve seen. I sincerely hope they stick with the direction this show is going in. It blows my mind that this is something Disney would allow to be made and it gives me hope.
Whether season 2 will be good or not, it is the final one, because Rogue One follows season 2. So if they get it right just one more time, it's a good, complete, Star Wars live action tv show. So I really hope they do.
@@anderpot I have no doubts that season 2 will be very good. I would be surprised if it’s better than season 1 but I have full faith in them to make something truly special. Whether they acknowledge the critical acclaim this show has brought, who knows. I’d really like for them to continue making shows and movies of this quality
My only gripe about "Andor" is that it ruined all other recent Star Wars content by comparison. It's so much more well written and acted compared to anything else we've seen .
That is a genuine problem, harch take but I think the Mandalorian got so pupular because it wasn't bad after the films f-ed up and not because in was of amazing quality.
It is not bad and it has some really great parts but it don't hold a candle to something like Andor.
@@TFAricI think season 1 is legitimately good. Small stakes, all new characters, very little connection to the greater universe. It’s not as good as Andor, but it’s good.
@@chazzerous good but maybe not great?
I liked it so I am not dissing it as something bad.
@@TFAric totally fair
That’s not Andor’s fault if any shows after it is good or bad, that’s on them to produce good content.
Pretty much Andor and Rogue One are peak modern SW for me. I'd love a "Gilmore-verse" for SW
Gilroy
Yo, Gareth Edwards as well, he cast Diego Luna as Cassian Andor in R1, and he also wrote R1 agreed to the rewrites and even filmed the rewrites e.g. the Vader scene.
I'd take Gilmore Girls in Space.
Can we just replace kathleen Kennedy with Tony Gilroy, and enjoy a REALLY GREAT future for star wars? With less "content", but soooo much more story ...
@@arneczool6614Yeah, please. I want more scenes of Mon Mothmas daughter going later to school and who in the team is right- or left-handed. Just give me more of that.
Saying that Kino's line about not being able to swim was funny was a wild take I was not ready for. If I laughed at that line, it was definitely to keep from crying. The cast of this show was so stacked. Andy Serkis and Stellan Skarsgård both deserve Emmy noms, IMO. Great review, as always!
Yeah it was at heartbreaking to me. 😢
It definitely was a sick joke 😂😢
Yeh - and exactly that is what excells in this show aswell. Humor isn't presented in a way that takes away from the story, makes fun out of a character thats meant to be scary - instead, it makes you go "ooooh shit", and start to use your brain to think about what just happened ... "Was it a joke?!?" "Can't be!" ... "Kinda makes sense that after years in prison isolation, he just didn't think about this ... detail" ... "does it make sense?" ... "Let me rewind ...."
Yep. Wild take. It was heartbreaking not funny except perhaps in the laughing to keep from crying "I can't fucking believe they'd do that to us" kind of way. I usually don't count those as comedy though.
As a child I fell in love with the universe watching the prequels, but I’d moved on as an adult. Andor reignited that love again like nothing else had.
Andor is definitely the most profound Star Wars has ever been. It is a great dystopian story tackling complex themes that could work completely independently of the Star Wars IP.
Writing, acting, directing we’re all better in Andor so yes it’s the best
Easily the best, IMO.
Not just for Star Wars, but it stands out as purely exquisite television.
The world fleshed out, the politics of the Empire and the Rebellion (especially the notion about all the forces working in the Rebellion all having their own agenda), the philosophy of Nemik and the Rebellion, the Empire's spy network and easily displayed as the most competent here, etc, etc.
Not only that, the level of acting and the details here are juat phenomenal. Everyone will point to Serkis monologue or Skarsgard's, but Nemik's OOC or Mon Mothma's "if you've done nothing wrong you've nothing to fear" --- "I'm fearing your definition of wrong " schtick were jaw dropping.
Absolutely adored it. Especially that it had no sodding Jedi.
Andor writing team is so sharp, i get chills and remeber sooo many good lines from the show.
This is what happens when you hire quality. You get quality content. I really like everything that Tony Gilroy has done from Michael Clayton to his writing credits on The Bourne series. He does political thrillers well.
Michael Clayton is the most underrated movie of all time. It deserves so much more praise than it gets.
Andor is my favorite star wars content. It is masterful in every way 💖
In my opinion:
1. A New Hope & The Empire Strikes Back
2. Andor
3. Rogue One
Utter bollocks. That's nostalgia talking. Andor wipes the floor with A New Hope & The Empire Strikes Back in every way.
No it doesn't. Andor didn't have half the amount of views as A New Hope or Empire. If Andor was the first Star Wars introduced, Star Wars wouldn't be a household name.@@EyeQue62 A New Hope changed cinema forever, Empire is often considered one of the best sequels ever. Andor is a great show but it seems like you are just living in the moment, no one outside of Star Wars diehards talk about Andor.
@@Ronfost89yeah but if you’re talking quality, Andor is so much better than the original trilogy. Better dialogue, better acting, more nuanced characters, perfectly woven stories- og trilogy is just beloved because it came first. It’s just Kurosawa/Shakespeare in space.
@@Ronfost89I think your comparison is apples to oranges but just in a different way. Yeah, of course Andor couldn't be the opening to a new series. It's a spin off show by design. Also, Those films came out back when there were like 5 channels and almost anything worth watching always came out in the cinema. It wasn't that far removed from the days they'd show the news in the cinema FFS lol. Comparing raw views is completely inappropriate. And yeah, the originals were operating in an era where revolutionary leaps in tech and film making were more common. The science of film making using special effects and rapid editing is now a VERY mature medium, so nothing is going to be that ground breaking anymore.
In the CONTEXT of their respective formats, genres, and release eras, I'd say there's a solid argument for Andor to be considered better than those original films. The originals don't always have to be the best part of a franchise.
“I can’t swim” was not a joke you psychopaths.
To Make The Empire Look Terrifying and Explore the The Emotions of People Living at That Time Has Never Been Done Before! Andor is #1
A note: Andor is not confused for someone else, getting arrested.
The empire and the ISB have established DETENTION QUOTAS, so the troops and judicial system can invent reasons to arrest anyone they think it's not important.
This is established in a conversation i think in episode 3, where the ISB director compliments Dedra Meero on surpassing her detention quotas in one sector under her responsibility
That's what brilliant writing is. Everything written had a reason to be, and no contradictions
And the writing brilliantly pushed the story along, with escalation, as Andor was arrested for nothing and given a 6 year sentence for nothing, because the heist on Aldhani pushed the Empire to tighten its grip - which led to an increase in desperation and rebellion.
Yes it is, as a matter of fact Andor is so good that it gave Tony Gilroy absolution for having writing credits on Armaggedon.
I just started watching the series this week thanks to the Disney subscription discount, and then my favorite nerd podcast drops a 45 minute deep dive out of the blue. Nerd Soup never fails to disappoint!
Andor is a brilliant show. I think it is definitely the best Star Wars content since ESB.
I can see why some wouldn’t like it though. It’s doesn’t have lightsabers, Jedi or Sith, things that make Star Wars Star Wars.
Andor honestly could have been set in any universe/time period. It would have been the same show if it had taken place on earth, 1938. Andor could have walked into a strip club in Germany, looking for his sister, killed two nazi officers and off you go…
It is a brilliant show, but I don't feel like I am watching star wars.
@@aprilnewell5434which is good because Andor is soooooo much better than rest of the nowadays sw crap.
I was just talking about the show. Imo it’s by far the best Star Wars spinoff.
Andor is hands down my favorite Star Wars media released by Disney as a whole. Before S3 of Mando I would have said that but S3 was such a dud. Andor is also the only show that met what I expected out of Disney Plus shows as a whole. It felt like it was written as a show.
The thing is the fan base isn’t united. Andor is objectively the best Star Wars show by miles but there are so many fans who hate it because they just want lightsabers and flashy action and don’t have the brain to understand a complex plot
You are right. The strange part is ... they were given that in the sequel trilogy and then they complained about the poor writing and character development. Andor is a great show, people who want flashy action and lightsabers can stick to Dave' s work.
I wish I’d seen the reaction you guys did. Andor is fantastic and the best SW since R1, but I’ve seen more comments like; “It’s boring”, “No action”, “Too much dialog”, etc. Ahsoka, which I wanted to like, but thought was poorly scripted, rushed plot-wise, and just marginal at best, is getting praised because (I think); lightsabers, Stormtroopers, and battle scenes.
It’s a sad commentary and I think of Ahsoka as Star Wars for the TikTok generation - quickly moved along to keep people from getting “bored” with things that make great drama like character development and plot building. I cared more for the old man in their prison team in Andor than I did for anyone on Ahsoka (and those were characters I came in knowing).
Yep everytime i see Death Star blowup i am like, wait Cassian, Ulaf and others were building it and it killed them. Great storytelling.
I hate TikTok, but love Ahsoka, so what does that make me?
Yes. Yes it is. Rogue One is my third favorite SW film and Andor is my favorite SW series.
andor ruined my expectations for Ahsoka
I mean watch Andor and then Ahsoka trailers, u can tell where money and time went.
In my mind it's equal to Star Wars (1977) and The Empire Strikes Back (1980), so technically yes since they are all tied at least in terms of live action versions of Star Wars.
Completely agree!! Love this show and wish Obi-Wan got the same attention
Its the best star wars in 40 years
Quality of writing, acting, cinematography wise it's right up there with the first 3-4 seasons of Game of Thrones! The prison arc basically had nothing to do with Star Wars yet it was incredible incredible television. I'll be rewatching that arc the rest of my life. I doubt i ever rewatch Ahsoka, Obi One, Boba Fett episodes.
I rewatched Kenobi a little over a month ago and had a blast watching it. I literally watched it again to see if I was actually wrong and just blinded by the dopamine, that comes with first viewing, but I honestly still love it.
I also rewatched Andor (for the third time, mind you) and I tried so hard to give it a chance again. But I felt as much as the first two viewings. Nothing, absolutely nothing.
Just my honest thoughts. I wish I could, but I really don't know what people have with that series.
I absolutely need more of the Partisans. Saw and Two Tubes are so damn cool and interesting i cant even get enough of them
It definitely has the best characters in all of star wars
Andor is objectively the best Star Wars content. However, because of the groundbreaking effects and story from the original trilogy, they will always rank higher.
Andor was written without fanfare or Kathleen Kennedy I mind and it shows- SO well done. Star Wars without any of the bullshit or cameos etc
So damn good!!
The best way I would describe Andor is that it's thrilling and entertaining without the need to resort to flashy spectacle or having any sort of juvenile humour. Usually the spectacle is an easy low-hanging fruit for Star Wars, i.e. just have the lightsabers and space battles and people generally won't care even if the writing/acting is bad. The Prequel Trilogy is proof of this.
What Andor did was show what good acting/writing can look like in Star Wars. I remember the penultimate season of Mandalorian Season 2 where Bill Burr gave an amazing performance in that once scene with the imperial officer. Andor is like a whole season of stuff like that.
To be clear, I'm not saying that spectacle and silly/comedic tones are inherently bad, it's just a different flavour of entertainment. One way to look at it is Andor vs rest of Star Wars is kind of like comparing "The Batman" to "Batman and Robin". The latter gets flak for its silliness but is still a generally fun to watch movie, in the same way that Star Wars also gets flak for occasional silly elements like Ewoks or Jar Jar but is still fun to watch. The point is that both the serious and silly can co-exist and people can enjoy both. If you learn the wrong sort of lessons from Andor and think that Star Wars has to ditch the goofy stormtroopers and ewoks shift its tone to become super serious and gritty you'll just end up doing to Star Wars what Zack Snyder did to the DCEU.
It is one of the best. It is my favorite Star Wars TV show.
Andor was a great break from all the super sci fi elements of the series i hope to get more media like that in the future
Answer: yes
Rogue One and Empire Strikes Back are runner ups and an argument can be made for the original because it's the original. 2003 Clone Wars is also in the discussion. Everything else in this franchise needs the viewer to be extraordinary apologetic and nostalgic. Mandalorian used to be up there, but Filoni and Lucas Film fucked that up as well.
I just rewatched it. Andor is soooo much better than all other SW shows including Ashoka.
Yes and it's not even close
This show made me really interested in Star Wars politics for the first time
Dan gilroy and his brother are both great guys. Dan has some really underrated movies. My ex's God mother was rene russo-dan's wife and they are both great humans and so humble.
Slow burn - cooked to PERFECTION.
Syril was a foil to Andor. He grew up without unconditional love; a mother that put him down, invalidated him, and emasculated him. Which made him naturally drawn to the powerful empire; if he could be a part of that he could finally have a little power and be validated.
Andor’s mother on the other hand validated him at every turn and even in death: her note to Andor as told through brasso - “tell him I’ll love him more than anything he can do wrong”. Andor therefore has agency, and is allergic to control and oppression.
Syril’s character is an example how some weak men are drawn to the empire. Not the only way, but one of them.
Andor was brilliant to bad it did not get the ratings it deserved.
I think the problem is that Andor don't appeal to much to the casual audience. I don't say that just to be a dick but I know a few people watching the Mandalorian because "Baby Yoda is so cute" and who otherwise don't really care about Star Wars what so ever.
The people saying this isn't Star Wars I genuinely don't understand, Star Wars is not just lightsabers and jedi, if you pick up a Star Wars book or game you will soon see that they are all not about jedi and the force. I love jedi, sith and the force too, I have a full freaking Vader suit and a couple of lightsabers but that doesn't mean I don't want other stuff too, a big galaxy with unlimited possibilities.
Yes. The answer is yes
Andor was my favorite show from 2022. Ahsoka so far is my favorite of 2023
The difference though is that Andor makes me want to know more about ALL the characters. Ahsoka does NOT make me want to go back and watch Rebels.
@@Rocco1332true. After watching Ahsoka I lost any interest in watching the animated series
I love everything Star Wars, but yes, Andor is top tier for sure!
I wonder if the final numbers of Andor were really do bad. It was the only Disney series that increased in viewership as time passed, as word if mouth spread.
I know few people who watched it and all of them absolutely love it, i love it, it seems like many people do, Andor S2 is my last hope for starwars and i think it will be strong season as well and even more watched.
Woof, they missed all the YT Andor traffic.
Not because I'm in it , but yes.... It is
It's not the best Star Wars, since best implies an objective fact which needs to be true whether a human is there to witness it or not. If a human is there, it's subjective. It's plenty of people's favourite though, and for good reason. People use 'Best' when 'Favourite' is more accurate. It's missing so much much of the elemental DNA of ANH and ESB (Chosen one narrative, samurai, and western influences, mysticism, Arthurian legend, family orientated space adventure) It's certainly the most mature Disney+ SW show, and easily as good as the first 2 seasons of Mando (which has the DNA elements of SW Andor is missing), I like them both equally for different reasons.
The prison scene wasnt random or messy. It was very intent in the story and writing. After Luthen was bold enough to organize the attack and heist on the imperial base the Empire tightened its grip and started to increase its tyrannical authoritarianism. Lathan even explains the heist was meant to push the Empire, instead of choking the galaxy slowly he forced their hand by resisting and attacking and it led to the increase in tyrannical behavior - which in turn put Cassian in the position to be arrested for nothing and given a 6 year sentence. It even pushed the prison break as they began increasing sentences and not releasing prisoners. It pushed everyone into a corner and revealed the true intent of the Empire.
You should talk about Pantheon, the best animated show of last year. Just criminal how AMC murdered it
answer to title is yes
YES.
It’s on the high ground!
I've said this quite a few times now , Star wars for grown folks, writing matters, acting matters, even proper set building matters.
Yes, Andor is the best Star Wars to date. The entire season was filled with tension and dialog that was never felt and heard in any Star Wars anything. Empire was good but there was never a moment where I felt the main characters were in trouble. Rogue One was great but still I don't know. Andor was near perfect.
Just a reminder, this was Gilroys show originally, he parted ways during development and then returned when it was struggling and got to tell his show
Once Diego shot that guard in the 1st episode 9min in I knew it was something special and different than the rest of Disney's junk
Yep, i hate disney, i hate crappy disney Filoniverse that used to be starwars, but Andor man, that show is EPIC, and season 2 is the last thing i am hyped for.
To be fair.. he basically did the same thing in Rogue One to open that movie...
4 years will be condensed in season 2. Because Tony Gilroy didn't want to spend a decade of his life with Star Wars. He doesn't need to. So don't the other telents like Serkis, Luna, Skaarsgard etc. If you let fanboys do it you get fanfiction.
Yes it is! Quality writing, acting, and cinematography. Sure it has slow parts but it kicks like a mule when it does.
Good early point about Empire - lots of people really freaked out about it.
At the beginning you make a good point, that Andor is what it was like when Empire came out. Then the other one of you said some people didn't like Empire when it came out. Actually, I was around when Empire came out, and it was more like you said a moment later about Andor. It wasn't that people didn't LIKE Empire, it's just that they felt it wasn't "Star Wars," because Star Wars, to them was more like the old serials of Buck Rogers and the like. But this was more mature than that. It's always funny to me when I hear people who praise Empire say they didn't like Andor because it's "not Star Wars", because they are echoing those people who said the same thing about Empire.
Yes
I'll answer your question. Is Andor the best Star Wars ever? Outside of the original Star Wars film in 1977 which started everything, yes. Andor is not just the best STar Wars, its among the best series of all time in my view.
Yes!!! Yes it is.
“Everyone on his planet talks this” that is not how accents or planets work. Planets are huge and people would have many different languages as well as many different accents!
Yes. Yes it is.
Yes it is
Yes, yes it is
its the best tv show of all time in my book. LOVE ANDOR ❤ LAST HOPE FOR FUTURE OF SW ❤
Yes, absolutely.
While I respect Filoni and all he has done for SW over the decades, I think many fans have developed such a lore-centric sycophancy towards him that they fail to see why a show like Andor is also needed in this universe.
The Death Star made sense for the story! It was done to appease fans!
Yes.
Now I'll watch your video.
The most predictable thing in the show was that they were making fastening kits for the Death Star in the prison- but that's ok, it's too obvious a thing not to have I guess.
Yall should review mad men
Yup
Nothing else needed
Just yes
Crazy to think a guy who doesn't even like Star Wars wrote the greatest SW story since 1980.
yes - its the best star wars ever made. in any era book or game.
Who are the people who think TLJ is the best Star Wars? Crazy. It could have been good if it was a standalone movie without the original characters or pre established characters
Andor isn't great Star Wars, Andor is great drama period. I can't believe we got SW content that's actually beating HBO dramas for most critics and most publications. It's crazy.
_utopian city picture meme_
Society when humans learn the difference between 'Best' and 'Favourite'.
Yes. Yes it is the best Star Wars yet
Tremendous
The Star Wars shows have all been very good.
Ahsoka being the new pinnacle
I will say it took me a very long time to watch this I want to say it was out for four maybe five months till I watched it and I'm like I got nothing better to do I guess I'll give it a go and I was extremely reluctant and kind of didn't want to but I was slightly intrigued but at the same time just like I don't need more prequel shit. But I'm like after the first episode oh this isn't terrible I'm intrigued and then I just kept watching and it sucked me in and by the end of it I enjoyed it I liked it 10 times better than I thought I would I was really surprised by that. I will say that much. Can't say much more cuz I don't remember anything lol
Its better than Empire because its on a deeper level.
We’ll take it! Haha
Simple answer : yes.
Knights of the Old Republic 2 is the best Star Wars ever, and Kriea is my favorite fictional character of all time. She wants the death of the force, and Im pretty sure thats the route theyre about to go with Baylon in 'Ahsoka' (or based off some things he's said, it sound more like he wants the death of the prophecy). If Filoni rips that games series off AGAIN without crediting the Bioware or Obsidian Devs, then I hope his cowboy hat is carried away by a gust of wind. But the Mandalorian Wars, the Jedi Civil Wars that lead to the first jedi extinction, and the destruction of Malachor V are all way more interesting than Ahsoka crossing her arms in front of The Volume stage.
Andor is really good too though lol.
It was a different kind of "Star Wars"
How is this even a debate? Has there ever been a piece of Star Wars media better than Andor? Is it fair to compare movies and series? I can agree with that argument. Even if you group Original Trilogy, Prequels, and Sequels, the writing and acting alone make Andor untouchable.
Now cultural impact, the Original Trilogy is by far the best of them all. There is no question that A New Hope was inspirational. But remember, Empire wasn’t that accepted and Return of the Jedi has its own detractors.
Was Andor perfect? No of course not. But is it the best SW media? Yes. Writing, acting, story it’s all there… even bricks. 🙄
Besides Rogue One, Solo, Kenobi, The Mandalorian (literal all 3 seasons), The 2008 Clone Wars, Jedi: Fallen Order and Survivor, Visions, Tales of the Jedi and the Bad Batch, which are my favourites, but still just count as the on-screen-material, I could give another entire list of things inherently better than Andor.
Let me begin:
Star Wars Uprising (best game ever, bring it back, now Lucasfilm!)
Rise of the Resistance and Flight of the Falcon (had the time of my life doing it)
Both of the new Thrawn-trilogies
Pretty much everything related to the High Republic-Era
Master and Apprentice
Dooku: Jedi Lost
Lost Stars
Battlefront: Twilight Company
Bloodline
The Galaxy's Edge-novels (they're great fun)
A New Dawn
Leia: Princess of Alderaan
Tarkin
Lords of the Sith
Catalyst
Species Volume 1
Brotherhood
The Alphabet-Squadron-Trilogy
Inquisitor: Rise of the Red Blade
Dark Disciple
Rebel Rising
The Princess and the Scoundrel
Ahsoka (the novel, not the show)
Battlefront: Inferno-Squad
Servant of the Empire
Phasma
Vader: Immortal
Both the 2015 and 2017-Darth Vader Comics
The Doctor Aphra-comics
War of the Bounty Hunters, Crimson Reign and Hidden Empire
The 2020-Star Wars Comic Run
The Bounty Hunters-Comics
The Obi-Wan Comic-Series
The Yoda-Comic Series
The Han Solo and Chewbacca-comic
The Kanan-comic
Weapon of a Jedi
Smuggler's Run (Both Junior Novel and comic strip)
Shattered Empire
Heck, even Young Jedi Adventures captured me a million times more than Andor.
@@Lr.Laecro.Lirus3445 lol
I needed this after watching Ahsoka...cleanse the palate. Even if you're not a fan of the story, the acting and directing in Andor is lightyears beyond the rest, to a point that it's laughable. Mando S1 (and even S2) was enjoyable, but the rest are trash.
For tv, yes. For sure. But the original trilogy, nothing beats it. and rogue one is the same.
Disney wise maybe.
There is one scene i just don't accept as realistic in the show:
When they escape, IDC if you can't swim there's obviously plenty of other people who do.
You can obviously be carried by those who can.
If you know you'll be "ded" if you stay, you will jump.
Have you tried saving someone in water? It's hard. Diamond hard. Stop being an idiot. Saving Kino would have been monumentally hard.
Who exactly is going to be carrying you to shore when the prison you’re escaping from is miles away from land
Any of the other 1,000 prisoners that can swim. Now that you mention it, why not take a floatation anything along?
Also, it's really easy to teach someone to float on their back.
@@chazzerous
We don't know if he made it or not. At the point we hear Kino say "I can't swim", Cassian gets shoved off the platform in the rush of prisoners and because this story is about Andor, we as viewers don't know what the ultimate fate of Kino really is. It was a beautifully crafted scene. Heart breaking yet not without a small amount of hope.
Really? I thought they went back inside. I will have to rewatch now. Thank you. I like this ending much better.
*Edit: Did the rewatch. I was right. You are correct though.
I stand by my original comment also though.
Let's hope they do make it out of the facility.
Probly get tediously tortured for a few episodes though. Meh. 😎@@timothychapman269
The way they are complaining about having Star Wats characters or the Death Star in a Star Wars show. I am going guess they did not like Ahsoka very much.