Leo Gardiner he says he took Arthur in like a son when Arthur was 15 when Dutch was only like 20 himself So realistically Dutch is more of an older brother to Arthur than a father
Yeah. Literally plot points out there that Dutch raised Arthur starting at 13.. an 18 year old raising a 13 year old doesn't seem anything like they described in game. I'm calling it bs. Even if it is canon, I use my headcanon. Same for heights, I refuse to believe Arthur is anything under 6'
Arthur was 16 when Dutch and Hosea found him. Dutch was 21 and Hosea was 35. (According to this list and Arthur says in game he’s been with them 20 years) Edit: Both this video and I am wrong. Please disregard this comment and move on.
@@redvice6210 I've met people who were no more than 4-5 years older than me and I could've seen them as my father figures. Being young and wise is truly something.
Wow Sadie was only 25?! Jeez her deep voice and dgaf attitude made me think she must have been in her early 30s or sth, just a few year younger than Arthur not 11 🤯🤯
I was expecting Sadie to be around 29-30 but I have a feeling if she’d been older than 25 she’d likely have children by then which wouldn’t work out as well with the narrative
I believe the the story takes place within a year, Jack is 4 years old and doesn't age until the Epilogue when he says he's 12. So the main story is about a year, then a 8 year time skip in the Epilogue. There's no indication that the main story took place within a few years, it's 1899 through out the entire campaign
@@mrbelarabo3367 Uncle is a cosmic deity that somehow ended up on Earth, where he took the form of a frail lazy old man with lumbago to hide his true power
It’s even sadder if you find the letter from his dad in the camp just outside of Rhodes, it says a bunch of stuff about how his dads dream was for Lenny to become a lawyer and live an honest life, he goes on about how he feels sorry about how he must seem more like a tutor than a father but he did it so he can live a better life than his dad and the generations before him (Lennys family were slaves), but that obviously never happened as he joined the gang and rather than living his dads dream of him being a lawyer and helping others, living an honest, wealthy life, he became and outlaw and died at 19...
the life expectancy in the year 1900 was 46 years old. i think some movies and games intentionally use older actors or make them look older than they are to show maturaty as well as the showing they have been through alot and that age has nothing to do with who you are
EDIT: As I started to replay RDR2 yesterday i come to one thing, at the beggining of the game arthur says that he rides for about 20 years with the gang, and that he joined them while hew was about 13, so he must be no older than 34 or 35
@@jaydenbailey5480 Arthur was 16 when Dutch and Hosea found him. Dutch was 21 and Hosea was 35. (According to this list at least and what Arthur says in game he’s been with them 20 years) Edit: Not only am I wrong but so is this list. Majority of these ages aren’t even confirmed please ignore my comment.
@@redvice6210 thanks I was basing it around what Charles said about being 14 and leaving and hosea said thats around the time Arthur joined I appreciate the correction
@@mr.picklejar yeah I agree as much as I dont like it they're all going to hell they've killed, robbed, etc. but in the end Arthur is going the same place as lenny
@@cb41503 I'm 34, spend my whole life so far riding horses and teaching riding outside rain and shine, and people think I'm 28 at most. They just look old af
Why everyone thinks they are older what they really are? Don't you understand back then living conditions were tough and people looked older (bad food, smoking, alcohol, sicknesses and so on)
It’s mad crazy that Uncle lived until he was 73 and even then he was still active. Most men in 1911 would’ve died a lot sooner, but I guess it takes a lot to kill the one shot kid.
Well, even if the life expectancy of this time was around 50 yrs old, people did live old, hell there are records of people dying at 90 yrs old in the ancient world so...
@@s8theninjawarrior916 I’m not just talking about dying of old age. He’s been in hundreds of gunfights in his time and he’s come out on top in each and every one. It’s a miracle he wasn’t shot to death when he was half his age.
Its sad, I never realized how young so many characters died....and got brought into this shit storm. A lot of them could still be in school!! (college ofc)
@@Revil0999 19 years old Dutch surely was more like adult, 14 years old Arthur no doubt was a boy. See? It make sense. Not to mention the info about their ages were released by rockstar themselves and they have never said they made something wrong.
Going by old pictures, I think it's just that everyone in the late 1800s looked a decade older than they were. Probably from all the exposure to the Lumbago.
Life in general was harder back then. People has less access to nutrition and vitamins; they were subject to hard labor due to the technological limitations sometimes lack thereof, medicine and vaccinations were also less developed which meant diseases that are rate today are much morch common then. All this combined wears a person down real quick especially if they are not careful.
ValleyoftheKings64 yup now Since we are pampered with so much better stuff everyone looks younger than their age, 21 I am and people still think I’m 17-18
That was the norm back then. Get the women young while they're still fertile and make as many babies as you can. That's what I've been finding out by doing the family tree. Farther back I go, the more babies they were popping out.
If I had to give a more fitting call for what each member should be based on their appearance, I'd say: Arthur (36) - About right ✅ Dutch (41) - Late 40s (47-49) Hosea (55) - Early 60s (60-63) John (26) - Early 30s (30-33) Abigail (22) - Late 20s (27-29) Jack (4) - (6 or 7) Micah 39 - About right ✅ Bill 33 - Mid 30s (34-36) Javier (26) - Early 30s (30-33) Lenny (19) - About right ✅ Stauss (53) - About right ✅ Charles (24) - Late 20s (27-29) Swanson (46) - About right ✅ Sean (21) - About right ✅ Karen (25) - About right ✅ Tilly (21) - About right ✅ Mary-Beth (21) - About right ✅ Pearson (48) - Mid 40s (44-46) Grimshaw (43) - Early 50s (50-53) Uncle (61) - About right ✅ Molly (25) - About right ✅ Sadie (25) - Late 20s (27-29) Pearson is the only one who I think looks younger than he actually is, not much, but I've pinned him a few years younger. Sadie only looks a little older than than she actually is, I think it's her rough voice that makes her seem older. Swanson looks a few years older than his actual age, but I think you chalk it up to his morphine addiction. I'd say Grimshaw looks like she's in her mid-50s even, but similar to Swanson, she's lived a tough life which probably makes her look a lot rougher.
John is 38 in RDR 1, so knowing that RDR 2 takes place 12 years before, we can confirm that he was 26 during the main game (34 in the epilogue). Same logic applies to Abigail and Jack, who were 34 and 16 in RDR 1, respectively. Abigail was 22 in RDR 2 (30 in the epilogue) and Jack was 4 (12 in the epilogue).
Kane SC The law is the good guys in society’s eyes. Though some use that authority to do whatever they want. Like Milton and Ross. So not really good guys, but still considered good in society. Which is bs, to be honest. Also, the gang aren’t the good guys either. They killed a lot of people, some of them, maybe a lot of them were innocent. Like Dutch killing that girl in Blackwater, and Arthur and Micah having a shootout in Strawberry. Fucking Micah and his fucking guns, I wish we can leave him in that jail cell to rot like the rat shit he is!
I still can't forget that one time when Arthur nearly gets stabbed in the chest and Dutch does nothing and leaves him behind or when Abigail was kidnapped by the Pinkertons and Micah said they should leave her behind because she is just a girl and Dutch agreed. Dutch really lost his mind after the Saint-Denis bank robbery. Losing Hosea was when he lost his mind but without him, Micah started playing with his mind
Yes dutch lost his mind Cause I did the helping john And there you fight with micah No stabbing Arthur dies naturally but still Dutch does not let arthur to pick up pistol and micah goes angry when Dutch does not listen to him But most importantly Rockstar failed to play us as Arthur even after epilogues. Damn. The reason now I am not playing story missiins is to play most with Arthur
@@captainAOG Well when I said he nearly got stabbed in the chest I was talking about that mission where the gang together with the Indians attack the Heartland oil fields when Eagle Flies saves Arthur but gets shot and later dies at Wapiti
@@janitor_arya9011 yeah , when he's antagonizing him. hes just teasing kinda maliciously when he says that line, lmfao, since it only plays when you hit antagonize.. its a running joke or theory that jack is not john's son, but its more than likely that he is. however anybody is free to theorize how they please. i personally believe he's john's son. but regardless they didn't adopt jack, he was 100% born to abigail.
@@romeo-delta1954 Herr Strauss looks like he is in his 60’s. I know life was a bit different back then, but Rockstar are taking the piss with their ages lol, and they are known for taking the piss, also a bit like they do with collision detection in this game and GTA.
I was surprised a lot of them were so young but I suppose it sort of makes sense: weather-beaten cowboys that have spent most of their lives outdoors - they're bound to look old
@@jackj9816 Exactly, kids had more responsibility thrust upon them at an early age. Families really had to work together. I mean, in order to understand what it was like, we need only look to the various minorities and vulnerable groups of people around the world. If you had a friend, growing up, who was from a tougher neighbourhood or something like that - perhaps you yourself have that background? - you know exactly what I'm talking about. They see certain sides of life at an earlier age, and grow tougher, quicker.
@@TheOneWithTheSling well considering fast and junk food didn't exist then that might be true xD but still people were poor asf back then and they would suffer from starvation
@@TheOneWithTheSling Not true. Average life expectancy was about 46-48 in the United States around that time. Sure, process food and fast food was uncommon to entirely non existent, but advances in healthcare over the last century has extended people’s lives. A diseases like tuberculosis is easy to treat now and no one dies from it, but I guess you can argue that people overall ate healthier and were much more active which is true, just didn’t live as long due to lack of technology and access to healthcare. Also, things like lead were unregulated and was everywhere.
@@zerosorigin8387 He was my 3rd favourite character in read dead 2.. 2nd was Arthur.. coz well I dont need to explain. And then 1st no surprise.. DUTCH. He is a great antagonist but he kinda made some stupid and weird decisions. Like leaving Abigail to get killed or arrested,and making jack a ORPHAN? Then leaving John to die? Anyway hes a fantastic antagonist along with Micah.
Would of been cooler if Lenny, Charles and Sadie were in the Epilogue. If Lenny survived i could see him becoming a lawyer or a Doctor, Lenny was very smart
How tf is Bill only 33 he looks and sounds like he's at least 50 Edit: to everyone literally answering my question, please stop.. it was obviously rhetorical
JamBamRam It really depends on what your appearance is. If you make him have a light beard and long hair, he looks 36. It’s because some people make him be homeless Santa lol
Don’t forget this is a long time ago... almost everybody looked older than they were due to well almost no sun protection not to mention most of the gang lived outdoors and on the run for a long ass time.
Famous quotes: “You miss 100 percent of the shots you don’t take”. “Whether you think you can or you can’t, your right”. “That which does not kill us makes us stronger”. “Did you catch the bad guys”.
Nah my favorites lived.. Sadie and Charles (thought Charles was going to die just because he is native American and black.. Games like horror movies love killing off POC)
It's better. Everyone thinks that main character can't die because of plot armor and then boom, main character dies and it hits you more than anything.
@@ousou78 Jack wouldn't be entirely white if he was a son of Javier and I don't think he looks like dutch at all meaning that John is the most logical choice
@@judithnoname140 the story is already complete so there probably won’t be a third one unless they do the same thing they do in gta with new characters each game
Am I the only one who's troubled by how young Dutch is here? He's shown as a father figure for Arthur (like Hosea), who taught him everything, and who Arthur looked up to all his childhood and youth, and he's only 5 years older than him?
Same. She's definitely the most underrated one in terms of beauty and personality compared to the rest of the bunch. I'd pick her any day over Mary Beth.
@@neo187420 Yeah I liked tilly too. I also always thought she was the more naturally beautiful one to me besides her nice personality in the gang regardless of what anyone said.
The reason i liked and subscribe was because you didn't force us to like and subscribe like literally EVERY OTHER TH-camR! This made my day! Just the touch of " if you want to" thank you so much (i loved the vid too)
I kinda think the ages are inaccurate cause rockstar didn’t say that’s there age the Arthur Karen and Mary Beth is right though I think some of them are older
@@bailey7926 The ages are correct, they look older because in the 19th century life was much harder and people had to grow quickly to survive, unlike nowadays
@@muelesariocontra but think about it okey so they said john joined like 15 years ago and he would have only been 11 and rockstar did not say that tho seas there ages I know aurthor is 36 but some dosnt add up I played this game over and over again it doesn’t add up
@@NoOne-ju8fi but Arthur says he grew up with John and that John teached him some stuff the ages are off cause rockstar did not say that was there ages
If Uncle is 61 in RDR2 then by RDR he is a 73 year old that is able to care for a ranch and take on the military with LUMBAGO.
What if Uncle is actually:
JACK SWIFT AND HE DIDN'T DIED IN THE ASSAULT OF GRIFFON'S MANSION?
@@yaboyjohnny5389 Liar.
Lumbago ain’t stopping him from doin the hard work. Well, I mean... it did, but it didn’t stop him from helping John save his ranch.
Hes 69 years old in the epilogue. Nice
Maybe he was saving energy for those years ? 🙂🙂
Dutch calls Arthur his son, even though he's only 5 years older.
Leo Gardiner he says he took Arthur in like a son when Arthur was 15 when Dutch was only like 20 himself
So realistically Dutch is more of an older brother to Arthur than a father
Don’t forget he was pretty dumb and acted like a child when he was 15 then later on goes to become almost if not more wiser than hosea
Leo Gardiner ArThUr My BoY
Wasn’t Arthur around 13/14 when dutch met him
Also, it’s a term of endearment- not a title
Micah: calls Arthur old
Micah: is 39
36 year old Arthur: am I a joke to you?
And also Arthur isn't old he's not even 40 so he's basically still young
@@smoker5989 Being 30ish back then was old af.
But rats only live for like 4 years?
@@roflc0re No it wasn't
Did corey give you his mask
Charles was 24?! Hella mature for his age, even if he didn't stood so well after the separation until John.
Yeah, and Sean 21.
I think there are other people saying he is 27 and dutch is 44 but who knows
I feel like most people should be mature at 24 g
@@ATX-js1to mature as in responsible, yes, but Charles was mature in a wise way. Very rare to see at that age honestly.
@@augustoalvarez6766 probaly matured because of everything he went through. He wasn't your average 24 he was alone at 13 I believe
Dutch literally talks to Arthur like he’s 20 years older than him but he’s only like five
Yeah. Literally plot points out there that Dutch raised Arthur starting at 13.. an 18 year old raising a 13 year old doesn't seem anything like they described in game. I'm calling it bs. Even if it is canon, I use my headcanon. Same for heights, I refuse to believe Arthur is anything under 6'
Arthur was 16 when Dutch and Hosea found him. Dutch was 21 and Hosea was 35. (According to this list and Arthur says in game he’s been with them 20 years)
Edit: Both this video and I am wrong. Please disregard this comment and move on.
@@redvice6210 I've met people who were no more than 4-5 years older than me and I could've seen them as my father figures. Being young and wise is truly something.
@@redvice6210 it says in game that he was 13 tho
@@mothman6378 he’s probably 5’ 8 because people were a lot lot lot shorter back then
There no way John 26, he sounds like he’s been smoking cigarettes for over 30 years.
I thought he was like the same age as Arthur, and I thought Arthur was like 40.
if u have the balls to say that at least @ me ;)
@@BabyBunny-rd5pl LMAO
Yeah
RUDE
Let's be honest, I looked good for my age.
Hell yeah
No
Hosea Matthews in fact you do
@Eftinoiu Eduard well back on the day he does but if your talking about the modern day no
Hosea Matthews I thought you’re 67
The fact lennney was 19 makes even sadder
Why
@@zeep6969 he died so young
@@zeep6969 a life cut too short
Him and Sean hit me hard because they are both just a bit younger than me. So young to die.
Meh I never liked him anyway
When you see Lenny’s age and it makes you cry more
I'm sure Arthur and Lenney are having a good drink in heaven while you read my comment
Gustavo De Oliveira Arthur:(finds Lenny)
Haha found ya Lenny.
Lenny:Arthur!
It makes *you* cry more
@Hayden Rhead that's sad, I really liked Sean
Is it bad that I don't care about Lenny at all lmao
So nobody is gonna talk about the fact that Bill is younger than Arthur
In Arthur's words, "he was dealt a bad hand". Guess that included early balding and terminal Obnoxious Twat disease
Or Strauss being younger than Hosea?
@@sharquimetal nah craziest thing is Pearson being older than Swanson
@@sharquimetal strauss looked like a sixtier
Uncle 🤤🤤🤤
Charles's age surprised me the most. He acts way older than he is.
Jeffrey S. His quote is fucking badass
Had to grow up faster with his upbringing.
Agreed
Maturity is dependent on the individual. I imagine he's been as level-headed and introverted since his mid teens, given his upbringing.
He's like or back in my day then Arthur's like come on boahhhhhh!
Wow Sadie was only 25?!
Jeez her deep voice and dgaf attitude made me think she must have been in her early 30s or sth, just a few year younger than Arthur not 11 🤯🤯
Sadie is REALLY good looking ngl
Saide should be around 30 and Charles between 28 - 30 years old.
@@ВладиславБулаев-л3э True
Sadie's been through some real shit, that ages you
I was expecting Sadie to be around 29-30 but I have a feeling if she’d been older than 25 she’d likely have children by then which wouldn’t work out as well with the narrative
Abigail looks like a godess in the thumbnail.
John Redd yeah too bad in the games she’s a major bitch. Always nagging.
John Redd john was a lucky man
John Redd Deadass
Fuck u
suddenly everybody has this profile pic
How is it that Uncle did basically nothing, had a large impact on the story and still outlived everyone else by a good 25 years?
Because uncle is god
Mr. Soup he just doesn’t like working that’s how he said out of all the trouble
cause he got lumbago
By doing exactly what you just said lol doing nothing
Actually now that i think about it, the one time Uncle led a job it went completely fucked and made things bad for them in Lemoyne.
Lenny being only 19 makes his death even more sad 😭
Agreed
But it’s Still sad he’d died so young
@Finn Spooner I didn't no that, I thought maybe a few month but not a few years, at least not until the time jump at the end
Finn Spooner no it doesn’t, it all happens in 1899
I believe the the story takes place within a year, Jack is 4 years old and doesn't age until the Epilogue when he says he's 12. So the main story is about a year, then a 8 year time skip in the Epilogue. There's no indication that the main story took place within a few years, it's 1899 through out the entire campaign
When you realize that Arthur would be 158 years old by now.
He can me inmortal with american Ginseng
@@thunder3149 Anyone got some G I N S E N G ?
If anyone gonna live that long from rdr then it should be uncle
@@mrbelarabo3367 Uncle is a cosmic deity that somehow ended up on Earth, where he took the form of a frail lazy old man with lumbago to hide his true power
R.I.P. King.
jack: “did you catch the bad guys”
*words of wisdom*
Hey Arthur
Charles Smith hi, how you doin Charles
@@arthurmorgan8016 good arthur. Would you help me get eagle flies out if trouble again
Charles Smith hell yeah, hopefully he doesn’t get caught by the u.s army again
Words to live by
Mr.BossFTW would've made this video 10 minutes long
True lol
He always does
His videos are pointless he buts in the rdr2 cutscenes and thats what makes the videos long
Nah I think 20
and comment the title
Lenny's death pisses me off even more now that I know his age
@Marcach acording to the story his death was inevitable but the way he died tho smh...
It’s even sadder if you find the letter from his dad in the camp just outside of Rhodes, it says a bunch of stuff about how his dads dream was for Lenny to become a lawyer and live an honest life, he goes on about how he feels sorry about how he must seem more like a tutor than a father but he did it so he can live a better life than his dad and the generations before him (Lennys family were slaves), but that obviously never happened as he joined the gang and rather than living his dads dream of him being a lawyer and helping others, living an honest, wealthy life, he became and outlaw and died at 19...
I thought lenny was 15 guess hes 19
@@mysteriousgamer1066 u thought Lenny was 15 ??? U good ???
Just dont get into a sketchy looking group of adults that have revolvers
Man Arthur, John, Sean, and Lenny all died so young. I only mention these because they were the best four the bunch
*sad Hosea noises*
He meant young but yes Hosea was a better one
best!? arthur was on the low honor cover of the album lol if thats best for you then well idk
I think we can all agree that Micah was actually the best of the gang.
The best at being a low-down, useless, selfish parasite sack of trash! 😂👍
@@some.randomdudeonYT aint funny
I'm 27 years old and most characters in their 20s look like they could be my parents.
I don’t understand how John is 26...
Pineapplerito I thought Arthur and John were really close in age... I was wrong
the life expectancy in the year 1900 was 46 years old. i think some movies and games intentionally use older actors or make them look older than they are to show maturaty as well as the showing they have been through alot and that age has nothing to do with who you are
@@RubiaAndroidZ
You’ve replied to two different comments if also commented on, good job.
@@rochambeau7197 the scars gives him an older look.
Is no one gonna point out how gorgeous Abigail is in thr thumbnail?
@@decetutt true
@@decetutt
Sigh....still tho
Oh, she bad alright
Shes in a game u fucking Virgin
I thought she was an online custom character
EDIT: As I started to replay RDR2 yesterday i come to one thing, at the beggining of the game arthur says that he rides for about 20 years with the gang, and that he joined them while hew was about 13, so he must be no older than 34 or 35
Me too Dutch is described as like a father figure. Arthur joined the gang around 14 so Dutch was only 19 when the gang was created
@@jaydenbailey5480 ye Dutch is more like a older brother
@@jaydenbailey5480 Arthur was 16 when Dutch and Hosea found him. Dutch was 21 and Hosea was 35. (According to this list at least and what Arthur says in game he’s been with them 20 years)
Edit: Not only am I wrong but so is this list. Majority of these ages aren’t even confirmed please ignore my comment.
@@redvice6210 thanks I was basing it around what Charles said about being 14 and leaving and hosea said thats around the time Arthur joined I appreciate the correction
Dutch be like look son
Arthur be like Dutch I'm 5 years less your my brother
I thought they were all older than this. Like Arthur in his 40s. Dutch is his 50s and Hosea 60s.
John 35 at least 😱
John looks young tho, besides his voice.
Blogs Bilto - he has deep wrinkles and looks weather beat. I’ve never seen someone in their 20s with jowls.
I thought youre profile was abigail
@@cosmic-creepers9207 People aged more back then. Look at history, all the famous outlaws and cowboys were in their early 20s.
GeneralPing999 I suppose so, it was a harder life back then and skin care wasn’t high on the agenda 😂
Sean was 21 and got his head blasted. Lenny was only 19 when he was gunned down.
That was very sad 😢
The first thing Arthur said when he made it to heaven...
“Ha, found you Lenny!”
Honesty, good honor or not, for the things hes done, hes probably going to hell
@@mr.picklejar what the hell leve him along everyone has there apoping
@@cookingwithcaiden7887 Im not hating im just saying what i think will happen
@@mr.picklejar yeah I agree as much as I dont like it they're all going to hell they've killed, robbed, etc. but in the end Arthur is going the same place as lenny
@@mr.picklejar Then can I make a question? If they are going to he'll because they killed then soldiers of ww2 will go to hell also
I feel like most of them should be about 10 years older.
you right...my thought exactly
Maybe it's because their outside so much? I read somewhere that prolonged exposure to sunlight can make you look older than you are.
they live rough and their lives are stressful. makes sense
@@cb41503 I'm 34, spend my whole life so far riding horses and teaching riding outside rain and shine, and people think I'm 28 at most. They just look old af
Yeah true, google said that dutch was 44
I thought Dutch was in his 50’s, Hosea in his 60’s and Abigail in her 30’s.
They couldve at least made dutch 50 sum and hosea in his mid to late 60s
Abigail's birth year was written in her grave in RDR1, she was canonically born in 1877, so she's 22 in RDR2
@@Dalt1n999 There is no way she is 22. Rockstar got most of these ages way wrong. Lol
@@torakka2ow640 They are not wrong, lol. Look at her tombstone. It proves that she was born in 1877.
@@2quick4u54 You idiot. I am talking about Rockstar having the ages wrong not this video.
It's so weird to think about it that Jack could've lived to around 1975 maybe 1985 .The world had changed so much.
He could have died in 1.WW
@@lukasrenezeder3651 maybe he dodged the draft
@@NoOne-ju8fi Or survived.
@@nightmaremono7363 yeah, that too
He became a writer, u can find books in Gta 5 of his authorship. They are in Franklin's house i believe
Uncle and Hosea are the only ones who could have served in the civil war
you are not the real Arthur Morgan SMH😤
Uncle did nothing but chill 😂😂
Jonas it’s the lumabago
@@germancowboy6099 hahahah
@@germancowboy6099 did he became it at his birth or what? 😂
Why everyone thinks they are older what they really are? Don't you understand back then living conditions were tough and people looked older (bad food, smoking, alcohol, sicknesses and so on)
and not to mention always moving and hard graff
And no sissies tbh
Damn Lenny is more than 19
I personally thought Dutch would be younger than what he is. I assumed he was Arthur's age.
Well Micah called Arthur old
I get that arthur is in his 30’s and stuff but how the hell is john’s 26
he met arthur and dutch in like 1883 or close to that
@TheLee i’m not questioning i’m just supersized cause he looks like he would be 30 or something
I thought Arthur was 43
@TheLee indeed I didn’t
@TheLee i'm the one who asked how the hell John was 23
I’m so handsome.
@@sombrasemp3515 ?
@@sombrasemp3515 weirdo
you’re actually hot
Bro how u got 72 subs with ONE vid
And yes I agree with you
We need RDR3 with a story about Uncle in his prime and how did he get Lumbago.
He got it cause he's a lazy ass
That needs to be a dlc
We don’t need a red dead revolver remake 😒
Auxibus 2147 oh you also think that he’s Red Harlow
First mission objective: find a drink
It’s mad crazy that Uncle lived until he was 73 and even then he was still active. Most men in 1911 would’ve died a lot sooner, but I guess it takes a lot to kill the one shot kid.
🤣🤣
Especially crazy that he could do it with lumbago
Well, even if the life expectancy of this time was around 50 yrs old, people did live old, hell there are records of people dying at 90 yrs old in the ancient world so...
@@s8theninjawarrior916 I’m not just talking about dying of old age. He’s been in hundreds of gunfights in his time and he’s come out on top in each and every one. It’s a miracle he wasn’t shot to death when he was half his age.
@@Maiq_The_Liar2 yeah probably lol
Arthur Morgan: 36
John Marston: 26
Dutch Van der Linde: 44
Abigail: 22
Jack: 4
Hosea Matthews: 55
Micah Bell: 39
Susan Grimshaw: 42
Molly O’Shea: 25
Sadie Adler: 25
Lenny Summers: 19
Sean Maguire: 21
Bill Williamson: 33
Javier Escuella: 26
Charles Smith: 27
Tilly Jackson: 21
Karen Jones: 25
Simon Pearson: 48
Uncle: 61
Leopold Strauss: 53
Reverendo Swanson: 46
Josiah Trelawny: 45
Kieran: 21
Edgar Ross: 48
Andrew Milton: 42
Colm O’Driscoll: 45
Leviticus Cornwall: 51
Colonel Henry Favours: 63
Eagle Flies: 19
Captain Monroe: 34
Alberto Fussar: 45
Hercule Fontaine: 27
Sheriff Gray: 39
Archibald MacGregor: 35
Joe: 34
Cleet: 32
Jim “Boy” Calloway: 52
Black Belle: 41
Catherine Braithwaite: 54
Penelope Braithwaite: 17
Beau Gray: 17
Anthony Foreman: 32
Mary Linton: 28
Jamie Gillis: 18
Sheriff Curtis Malloy: 48
Archie Downes: 16
Tom Davies: 47
Sheriff Freeman: 38
Angelo Bronte: 55
Mayor Lemieux: 56
David Geddes (1907): 46
Abe (1907): 21
Tom Dickens (1907): 55
Vampire: 452
Scheisse!
Tbh I feel as though Micah should’ve been slightly younger than Arthur to as I feel it would’ve suited the story a touch better.
Marry Linton 26??? Wait what?? I thought she would be a same age as Arthur, maybe a little bit but damn...
@@hehexd48yearsago11 28
@@Gabriel-rp2pc guessing she was between 16-18 when she met Artie. Ew lol
4:30
"people call me lazy, i'm not lazy, just don't like working, there's a difference"
Same uncle.
Uncle is lazy
So you telling me that I'm lazy.
That makes me hurt.
He is not lazy
He got lumbago
He has lumbago
@@matteomanglaviti6074 it’s very serious too
Sadie looks and sounds like she's in her mid-thirties at least. In fact most of them seem older than their actual ages.
Living conditions can do that.
People thought I sounded 40 when I'm only 18.
Experience changes a person drastically in the right way.
I thought most of the men were in their thirties, save Lenny, Sean and Kieran
I think its just the times. Even one generation can show that. My dad looks a lot older in his picture where he is 19 years old.
@mini Wanton Yeah, but they use make up. It can make you look younger, but also older.
Some look younger (sadie) some older (Dutch, Bill) than their actual ages
Poor lenny was practically still a kid😭
Just a teen.... F
Rylan Hathaway yes a young adult teen. He was adorable. He looks 22 tho
Not even 20 😥
Same as sean... :"(
@@queteimportacomomellamo18 at least he didn't die virgin he f karen
Its sad, I never realized how young so many characters died....and got brought into this shit storm. A lot of them could still be in school!! (college ofc)
Molly O'Shea
Age: 25
*"I've seen you lock at her Dotch!"*
ye molly is 25 amd is in a sexual relationship with a 41 year old outlaw
And she says im getting to old for you am i. Lol she 25! xD
*Kinky*
Lol!
My mind automatically read it molly's voice.
@KVNG JAY not a good BoAh
I love how Dutch constantly calls Arthur "son" but if fact it is incredibly strange considering that their age gap is only 5 years.
D A D D Y I S S U E S
This must be wrong because arthur says that he joined dutchs gang when he was a boy and that dutch taught him reading if I remember correctly.
@@Revil0999 19 years old Dutch surely was more like adult, 14 years old Arthur no doubt was a boy. See? It make sense. Not to mention the info about their ages were released by rockstar themselves and they have never said they made something wrong.
@@sorrowgrief7045 still kinda weird that a 19 year old is like a father for a 14 year old imo but I guess if Rockstar said so.
@@sorrowgrief7045 considering the position Arthur was in he probably would look up to Dutch even if he was only 19
Arthur Morgan - 36
Dutch Van Der Linde - 41
Hosea Matthews - 55
John Marston - 26
Abigail Roberts/Marston - 22
Jack Marston - 4
Micah Bell - 39
Bill Williamson - 33
Javier Escuella - 26
Lenny Summers - 19
Leopold Strauss - 53
Charles Smith - 24
Reverend Swanson - 46
Sean McGuire - 21
Karen Jones - 25
Tilly Jackson - 21
Mary Beth Gaskill - 21
Simon Pearson - 48
Susan Grimshaw - 42
Uncle - 61
Molly O’Shea - 25
Sadie Adler - 25
Kieran Duffy - 21
Josiah Trewlany - ?
How old is/was Colm?
So I thougt Dutch was 44 and Hosea 75?
I always felt like Hosea was to old, but where did you get this new information?
@@thepopestar9135 He must be more than 65 Hosea
@@imdepresedbyclickbait39 and bill must be atleast late 40s
Dutch and molly had 16 year difference as lovers
Everyone looks exactly 10 years older than they are claimed to be
Wild west life
Jack looks 14
@@matthew9714-u9b What? he looks & is a little boy.
Except for the young maidens, Tilly/Karen/Mary-Beth/Abigail. they look their ages.
Abigail doesn't, and most women in camp guess from stress or something
They all look older than they actually are. Must be the rough life they live.
Going by old pictures, I think it's just that everyone in the late 1800s looked a decade older than they were. Probably from all the exposure to the Lumbago.
Its because back then hygiene wasnt great and all the stress and hardships they had took a toll on them
Life in general was harder back then. People has less access to nutrition and vitamins; they were subject to hard labor due to the technological limitations sometimes lack thereof, medicine and vaccinations were also less developed which meant diseases that are rate today are much morch common then. All this combined wears a person down real quick especially if they are not careful.
@@ValleyoftheKings64 yep its really sad tbh
ValleyoftheKings64 yup now
Since we are pampered with so much better stuff everyone looks younger than their age, 21 I am and people still think I’m 17-18
When you realize Mollys 25 and Dutch is 41 lmao
Sweet home alabama
That was the norm back then. Get the women young while they're still fertile and make as many babies as you can. That's what I've been finding out by doing the family tree. Farther back I go, the more babies they were popping out.
@@Skiller478 How is this alabama
Dutch is actually 44.
@@Skiller478 tell me how that’s Alabama Alabama is when your dating someone that is a sibling or a blood Related how how and go back to lanky box kid
we gotta have a backstory to Arthur when he’s in his prime, like 21-26
@Bobby Papoutsis yeah, he is a dead man
@k a thats pretty old back then.
@Bobby Papoutsis but the TB weekend him towards the end
@Bobby Papoutsis @k a bro it’s the 1890’s, 36 is pre old, the average life expectancy in that time was 40-50 years old
He was in his prime when he didnt have tuberculosis. I want to see hosea or uncle prime
Damn Arthur, John and Abigail, Micah, Bill, Javier, Charles look much older than their ages.
Sean died at the ripe old age of 21
KingGamer 06 Lot of em’ died young. Lenny especially.
Hayden LeBlanc yup Lenny at 19
Lenny tho
Dont worry 'bout me, I didn't think I'd live past 10
Shaun McGuire you spelled Shaun wrong it is Sean
I loved Charles, and I loved the Native American levels. Best of both worlds when you get to do a mission with Charles
Me too brother! Charles is a really unique and special character like rain falls and Arthur
the native american missions were so emotional for me
Charles was a good man
@@nlrenzo9432 he was not.
@@Ghost12314 towards arthur he was
*Arthur Morgan*
Age: 36 [☆1863]
*"LEEEEEENNNNNYYYYYY!"*
*Dutch Van Der Linde*
Age: 41 [☆1858]
*"I had a god damn PLAN!!!"*
HAVE FAITH ALMAS
*Uncle*
Age:61 [☆1838]
"LuMbAgO"
Or “we need mUnEY” 😒
@Milan Rasschaert "LEENEHH MAH BOAH"
HAHAAAH LENNEEEH MA BOAH FOUNT YAAH HAH!
If I had to give a more fitting call for what each member should be based on their appearance, I'd say:
Arthur (36) - About right ✅
Dutch (41) - Late 40s (47-49)
Hosea (55) - Early 60s (60-63)
John (26) - Early 30s (30-33)
Abigail (22) - Late 20s (27-29)
Jack (4) - (6 or 7)
Micah 39 - About right ✅
Bill 33 - Mid 30s (34-36)
Javier (26) - Early 30s (30-33)
Lenny (19) - About right ✅
Stauss (53) - About right ✅
Charles (24) - Late 20s (27-29)
Swanson (46) - About right ✅
Sean (21) - About right ✅
Karen (25) - About right ✅
Tilly (21) - About right ✅
Mary-Beth (21) - About right ✅
Pearson (48) - Mid 40s (44-46)
Grimshaw (43) - Early 50s (50-53)
Uncle (61) - About right ✅
Molly (25) - About right ✅
Sadie (25) - Late 20s (27-29)
Pearson is the only one who I think looks younger than he actually is, not much, but I've pinned him a few years younger.
Sadie only looks a little older than than she actually is, I think it's her rough voice that makes her seem older. Swanson looks a few years older than his actual age, but I think you chalk it up to his morphine addiction. I'd say Grimshaw looks like she's in her mid-50s even, but similar to Swanson, she's lived a tough life which probably makes her look a lot rougher.
John is 38 in RDR 1, so knowing that RDR 2 takes place 12 years before, we can confirm that he was 26 during the main game (34 in the epilogue).
Same logic applies to Abigail and Jack, who were 34 and 16 in RDR 1, respectively. Abigail was 22 in RDR 2 (30 in the epilogue) and Jack was 4 (12 in the epilogue).
bill looks like at least early 40s for sure, same for molly, she does not look like 25
Damn.. Most of these folks are 10 years younger than what I thought they were.
no one thought the same thing and Strauss looks 67 years old
I thought Arthur was 46
the kingdome of wolfs fr
@@napoleondynamite4148 *SHOAR*
Everyone: badass sentence
Jack: did you catch the bad guys?
Tt Bb he is fucking 4
Tt Bb still the best sentence tbh
Still the best, and it goes to show how young and innocent he is. He doesn't know that they're the bad guys running from the good guys.
@@KaneSC01 the good guys, in the eyes of the law.
Kane SC The law is the good guys in society’s eyes. Though some use that authority to do whatever they want. Like Milton and Ross. So not really good guys, but still considered good in society. Which is bs, to be honest.
Also, the gang aren’t the good guys either. They killed a lot of people, some of them, maybe a lot of them were innocent. Like Dutch killing that girl in Blackwater, and Arthur and Micah having a shootout in Strawberry. Fucking Micah and his fucking guns, I wish we can leave him in that jail cell to rot like the rat shit he is!
I still can't forget that one time when Arthur nearly gets stabbed in the chest and Dutch does nothing and leaves him behind or when Abigail was kidnapped by the Pinkertons and Micah said they should leave her behind because she is just a girl and Dutch agreed.
Dutch really lost his mind after the Saint-Denis bank robbery. Losing Hosea was when he lost his mind but without him, Micah started playing with his mind
Yeah he also hit his head on concrete when the trolly crashed in the angelo bronte setup job
Yes dutch lost his mind
Cause I did the helping john And there you fight with micah
No stabbing Arthur dies naturally but still
Dutch does not let arthur to pick up pistol and micah goes angry when Dutch does not listen to him
But most importantly Rockstar failed to play us as Arthur even after epilogues. Damn. The reason now I am not playing story missiins is to play most with Arthur
@@captainAOG Well when I said he nearly got stabbed in the chest I was talking about that mission where the gang together with the Indians attack the Heartland oil fields when Eagle Flies saves Arthur but gets shot and later dies at Wapiti
Oh yes and I forgot when John was shot on the train and Dutch left him to die
@@cristi.5 oh i see yes I misunderstood
So abigail was barely legal when John & her had jack 😂😬
They adopted Jack
@@janitor_arya9011 jack is there son
@@janitor_arya9011 where did you hear that?
@@christopherorozco1021 dude Abigail has slept with many people on the camp, even Arthur said that jack doesnt look like Marston, more like Escuela
@@janitor_arya9011 yeah , when he's antagonizing him. hes just teasing kinda maliciously when he says that line, lmfao, since it only plays when you hit antagonize..
its a running joke or theory that jack is not john's son, but its more than likely that he is. however anybody is free to theorize how they please. i personally believe he's john's son. but regardless they didn't adopt jack, he was 100% born to abigail.
GrimShaw is 42 she looks 60
That blew me away too like wtf 42?! I thought she was in her 60's as well.....
TheReal Ghost I can see u liked your own comment
@@zBPS so ?
Tommy The Shoe Shiner so I’m saying a comment if u don’t care get your lazy a** out of here pice of s***
@@zBPS you liked it
No way is Bill Williamson 33 years old, more like 53.
So he's as old as Herr Strauss?
@@romeo-delta1954 Herr Strauss looks like he is in his 60’s. I know life was a bit different back then, but Rockstar are taking the piss with their ages lol, and they are known for taking the piss, also a bit like they do with collision detection in this game and GTA.
don’t they mention in the story he served in the war as well? being born in 66 would’ve obviously meant he wasn’t able to serve
Back then the life expectancy was short and they drank, smoked and were stressed and all that can mess with your aging
Yeha he seems older but 53??
I was surprised a lot of them were so young but I suppose it sort of makes sense: weather-beaten cowboys that have spent most of their lives outdoors - they're bound to look old
Also, let's face it, people probably grew up quicker back then, they had to. Life was harder, or at least a little more urgent, than today.
@@ethanfrederiksen4327 especially on the frontier a lot of there parents died younger
@@jackj9816 Exactly, kids had more responsibility thrust upon them at an early age. Families really had to work together. I mean, in order to understand what it was like, we need only look to the various minorities and vulnerable groups of people around the world. If you had a friend, growing up, who was from a tougher neighbourhood or something like that - perhaps you yourself have that background? - you know exactly what I'm talking about. They see certain sides of life at an earlier age, and grow tougher, quicker.
@@ethanfrederiksen4327 not me but I have friends who pretty much had to look after themselves and siblings and they were way ahead then I was
"I RAISED YOU AS SONS"
- Dutch being 5 years older than Oarturd
I'm gonna name my horse with that.
Lenny was only 19
*NNOO*
WHY SO YOUNG
WHY TAKE MA BOA SO EARLY
That's why Arthur called him young Lenny
Leeennnnny
The youngest (cos jacks gay) and the coolest
Man when there quotes are there Arthur Morgan’s should of been OUT OF THE DAMN WAY
Or “hai there mista!”
Or found you Lenny
Or you have a kind face, the kind i like to PUNCH
"Calm down I'm just needling ya"
Ya god damn maggot
R* did so great making everyone look old for their age since living conditions were tough asf back then
People had a better health back then actually.
@@TheOneWithTheSling well considering fast and junk food didn't exist then that might be true xD but still people were poor asf back then and they would suffer from starvation
@@TheOneWithTheSling Not true. Average life expectancy was about 46-48 in the United States around that time. Sure, process food and fast food was uncommon to entirely non existent, but advances in healthcare over the last century has extended people’s lives. A diseases like tuberculosis is easy to treat now and no one dies from it, but I guess you can argue that people overall ate healthier and were much more active which is true, just didn’t live as long due to lack of technology and access to healthcare. Also, things like lead were unregulated and was everywhere.
@@TheOneWithTheSling wtf are you smoking "People had better health back then"
@@TheOneWithTheSling What the fuck? Are you serious?
John’s voice is like he has been smoking for 50 years
Everyone: has some kind of story to their quotes and they all mean something, and they're all pretty cool
Sean: I cAn TaLk A dOg OfF a MeAt WaGoN!
Gotta love Sean🤣
@@zerosorigin8387 He was my 3rd favourite character in read dead 2.. 2nd was Arthur.. coz well I dont need to explain. And then 1st no surprise.. DUTCH. He is a great antagonist but he kinda made some stupid and weird decisions. Like leaving Abigail to get killed or arrested,and making jack a ORPHAN? Then leaving John to die?
Anyway hes a fantastic antagonist along with Micah.
@ChipsBuzz Cool
You guys forgot about the strongest, bravest, and greatest gang member :
Uncle
@@PolishGod1234 Shrek should be in the next rdr.
Crazy that Charles is 24... I imagine him being somewhere between John and arthur
Charles is 32. The ages in this video are fake.
Hamza Khaliq Arthur is said to be 42
@@turbohead5612 na he is either in his late 20s or early 30s
Hamza Khaliq you sir are dumb, Charles is young when you play as Arthur
@@turbohead5612 arthur is not 42
Lenny didn't deserve to die😭
Ahmed Ayman thats just fucked up that epic games did that they could save him like sadie and charles
Would of been cooler if
Lenny, Charles and Sadie were in the Epilogue. If Lenny survived i could see him becoming a lawyer or a Doctor, Lenny was very smart
@@KrissyGabagool Rockstar* haha
@@NeoShineLP bruh i am stupid i dont know why i said epic games lmao im not gonna edit that omg im so stupid
@@NeoShineLP +1 sub for seing that lmao
00:28 the wisest thing dutch said was TAHITI
I have a god damn plan
*4:32** let me fix that quote*
*"People call me lazy I'm not lazy, it's just I HAVE LUMBAGO"*
I’m surprised jack remembered the old gang then but it makes sense because it would be quite traumatic
He saw a decapitated Kieran no many people die I mean I would be traumatized for life
@@subpain4257 I have a memory of when I was 3 and I went to a beach so idk?
@@subpain4257 yeah
I know right I don't remember SHIT from when I was 4
@@carolinag2106 I remember things far back as the age of 3 it's far from impossible, some people memories are just better than others.
How tf is Bill only 33 he looks and sounds like he's at least 50
Edit: to everyone literally answering my question, please stop.. it was obviously rhetorical
He has an alcohol addiction by the looks of it, a shitty liver does wonders to your appearance.
@O K and that
GrinspoonPhD
We’re talking about the 1800s, people used to die earlier than now
I fought bill was 40 but never mind
Finn Spooner not at all, average age for a male in America in 1900 was 46, now 79 so by about 33 years
Lenny was 19, and Sean was 21, this makes their deaths even sadder
I actually expected Arthur to be in his early forties, he's still quite young for only 36
The conditions back then were pretty terrible, and I assume being an outlaw all your life takes a toll on your appearance
Simon Ridgewell I’m shocked Strauss is only 53
He looks like he’s in his mid 60’s
JamBamRam
It really depends on what your appearance is. If you make him have a light beard and long hair, he looks 36. It’s because some people make him be homeless Santa lol
LP Cobra I can’t see him with a beard that long, not only that but it looks itchy too.
@@pears8445 no he looks like he's in his forties
They dropped the ball with Miss Grimshaw, she's only 42?!
My 58 year old aunt looks younger than her!
They all live running and outdoors, this is why they look older then they are, hosea is only 55 and looks like 70
That was 120 years ago
Bruno Vaz hosea looked fine for 55 are you joking? Lmao the fuck.
Don’t forget this is a long time ago... almost everybody looked older than they were due to well almost no sun protection not to mention most of the gang lived outdoors and on the run for a long ass time.
Also, how the hell is Hosea in his mid 50's? He looks 70 at least.
Nobody:
Tilly: 😳
Dead joke
zarrowthenorse No one cares
@@explo7962 what’s the reference?
JayTCU that’s just what she looks like no reference
@@explo7962 hey back off Tilly she cute
Famous quotes:
“You miss 100 percent of the shots you don’t take”.
“Whether you think you can or you can’t, your right”.
“That which does not kill us makes us stronger”.
“Did you catch the bad guys”.
Nobody:
Rockstar: hey let’s kill everybody’s favourite character
Edit: wow 700 likes the most I’ve ever gotten tysm
JakeJBO they do it in so many of there games
A real bisexual petrol-head he never said only rockstar does it its just that they are notorious for doing it in the past few years
Nah my favorites lived.. Sadie and Charles (thought Charles was going to die just because he is native American and black.. Games like horror movies love killing off POC)
A real bisexual petrol-head I know just I said rockstar because that’s the theme of the vid
It's better. Everyone thinks that main character can't die because of plot armor and then boom, main character dies and it hits you more than anything.
Making a mental note that Abigail got knocked up when she was 18, and presumably was still a call girl before that.
@William Anderson no jack is abigails blood son however john might not actually be his father
@@itscaffeine70 Nah Jack looks like John. In red dead redemption he just looked like a younger version of John.
@@psychopunk8817 I don't know Jack also looks like Javier and Dutch (but certainly not Bill).
@@ousou78 Jack wouldn't be entirely white if he was a son of Javier and I don't think he looks like dutch at all meaning that John is the most logical choice
Bro think about that 30+ year old dudes are just taking turns railing a 15-17 year old LMAOOOO
"You're like a son to me, Arthur."
*I'm only 5 years younger than you, Dutch...*
Grimlock85 Arthur is almost a decade younger than Dutch. Video is wrong
Arthur was 35 in chapter 1 then somehow he 36
@@sieieueieiduysuwuw7380 maybe his birthday passed?
@@sieieueieiduysuwuw7380 It WAS basically months in between chapter 1 and chapter 6
You can tell Arthur didn't like hearing Dutch say that in Chapter 3...its almost condescending in a way
I thought dutch's quote would be "I have a plan" or "we just need more money"
Charles is such a badass, I would enjoy playing as him. Also Sadie.
RDR3 please please please please DO WANT.
@@judithnoname140 rdr3 will be protagonist by mac callander i haven't proof but no doubts
@@judithnoname140 the story is already complete so there probably won’t be a third one unless they do the same thing they do in gta with new characters each game
Sadie’s honestly kinda scary
@@mr.chlorine7101 Honestly dude Sadie has a high temper but she's a pretty cool character
4:36 wow looks like I got a new crush🥵
Uncle.The god
Careful you don’t want to catch the lumbago it’s very serious
ITS THE LUMBAGO
Lumbago spreads really fast, watch out to not get it
And you also got _L U M B A G O_
Am I the only one who's troubled by how young Dutch is here? He's shown as a father figure for Arthur (like Hosea), who taught him everything, and who Arthur looked up to all his childhood and youth, and he's only 5 years older than him?
he is older for sure
I know, but Dutch sees Arthur as a younger brother and Hosea more father type.
This list is not true in my opinion,Dutch is about 55 and Hosea is supposedly 70 by other source.
Agree. I always thought that. I mean he looks basically the same Agent like Arthur and John...
Dutch was 5 years older than Arthur
Dutch to Arthur : you are my son
Now that I think about it
Dutch is more like a sassy big daddy
Jack: Did you catch the bad boys?
Me: WE are the bad boys..
Jack: oh...
Watcha gon do when they come for you
Bruh
tilly is gorgeous and looks so realistic idk if it’s just the lighting but
Same. She's definitely the most underrated one in terms of beauty and personality compared to the rest of the bunch. I'd pick her any day over Mary Beth.
Nova Cat right!
rubbish Abigail looks better tho
@@neo187420 Yeah I liked tilly too. I also always thought she was the more naturally beautiful one to me besides her nice personality in the gang regardless of what anyone said.
So everyone is going to sleep on Miss Grimshaw who looked good for a woman in her 40?
But yeah I can't choose between Tilly and Mary Beth.
Arthur (36): writing in his book that Abigail is a damn good woman and that he wished, he took her before John did.
Abigail beeing 14 years younger: 😐
wait thats illegal
that’s literally how it was back then. Still weird, but different times
Yeah well In Niger the age of consent is fucking 11 so let’s bum a bunch of Nigerian year 4s
@@bigman2890 ?
@@bigman2890 your now on a list.
The reason i liked and subscribe was because you didn't force us to like and subscribe like literally EVERY OTHER TH-camR! This made my day! Just the touch of " if you want to" thank you so much (i loved the vid too)
Wait Charles is 24?? I thought He's in early 30s
They all look older it's because their life is tough
BLitz x Snype Their skin gets weathered and makes them look a whole lot older.
Yeah and matured.
Hayden LeBlanc and they didn’t have stuff back then to take care of skin
Commander Shank All I use for my face is water and my skin is fine. *Shrug*
I feel like they’re all older.
@@ShadowHawk24Real 7 or 8 wtf kid looks 3 mabey 4 do you live with pigmies wtf😂
Indeed. Only characters to me that look their age are Hosea, Sean and Tilly.
Tilly looks younger
John is not that young he sounds and coughs like he's older than Uncle
He smokes a lot, that’s why he’s got a raspy voice
Same Sadie
He also got attacked by the animal(can't remember what) so it could've damaged his throat
@@_onlyrackz_ A Wolf, and he would’ve been fucking dead if that wolf came anywhere near his throat.
yeah that's just his voice tho. its his voice actor's natural voice (i do not know if rob wiethoff smokes though)
man you really start to feel old when you realize you're older than like 75% of the gang
Pretty sure Sadie is pretty much Arthur’s age same with Charles
I thought this too
I agree but sadie doesn’t look old but her voice definitely sounds waaay older at least late 20s for her
lol you are an idiot if you think that.
they seemed the same age as John to me. I thought Arthur was in his late twenties, he looks good for 36
I think Charles is 27 and Sadie is 31 that’s my guess
I thought Sadie was in her 30’s
Same
She got a smoker voice
@@anthonylomeli9272 I can't stand her voice. I really didn't even like her character all that much lol
@@chad_b blasphemy
@@Caught_Slipn she was ok at some points but drove me crazy at others. More so just her voice more than anything
Damn Sean died so young
yeah :(
So did Lenny
Not Lenny?
Lenny: Am I a joke for you?
khe verga and Kieran :( he was a good boah. Despite that he was in the O’Drsicolls gang
Dutch was dating someone half his age
Not uncommon then.
He only had Mary Beth in there for him
2:10 I'd kill for that hairstyle in online
agree
I think I'd rather have John's
4:29
Uncle's quote fits me so well lmao
Me too lol
😂
Tbh i like the QOUTE KF INTERNET ENJOY IT FUNNY QOUTE YUMMY QOUTE
The quote was fall of 49' not 38 though so his age would actually be 50
They're all hell of a lot younger than I thought, Micah is probably the only one who looks like he's that age
I kinda think the ages are inaccurate cause rockstar didn’t say that’s there age the Arthur Karen and Mary Beth is right though I think some of them are older
@@bailey7926 The ages are correct, they look older because in the 19th century life was much harder and people had to grow quickly to survive, unlike nowadays
@@muelesariocontra but think about it okey so they said john joined like 15 years ago and he would have only been 11 and rockstar did not say that tho seas there ages I know aurthor is 36 but some dosnt add up I played this game over and over again it doesn’t add up
@@bailey7926 John did say he joined when he was a child, because I think his parents died and he ran from the orphanage
@@NoOne-ju8fi but Arthur says he grew up with John and that John teached him some stuff the ages are off cause rockstar did not say that was there ages
I think Dutch is at least 45. He wouldn’t liken Arthur to his son if there was only 5 years between them.