I love the fact that we can't even verify that the singer is the orginal person. I really enjoyed this song, and the Mandela Cataloge never failes to intrest
omg I think it's the first of the TryHardNinja songs that left me in shock, it's incredible, the editing, the voices, the instrumental, the rhythm, even the animation, I love this work, your songs will mark a great trajectory, successes to you Igor🥺✌🏻❤🙊
“Familiar stranger” Only just realised the juxtaposition in that🤔 fits with the doppelgänger context as well when I think about it, keep up the great work dude
@@deltagamer9754 it is an analog horror made by Alex Krister (look for his channel either in the comments, the description, or just use the search function
This song is probably this far one of my (if not) my favorite songs you have made! I love the break from the usual indie horror game/FNAF inspired game shtick and dabbling into something new like Mandela Catalog. I love all the references to stuff in the universe like the T.H.I.N.K protocol and M.A.D, I like how eerie some of the SFX is giving a real sense of hopelessness much like the situation in lore. Overall the song is a banger and really fits the source perfectly!
This was absolutely incredible, easily in my top 5 THN songs now. I don't really have words to describe how much of a banger this one is lol, fantastic work Igor
Woah, this is pretty grand. The song sets some high expectations for possible future Mandela Catalog songs to live up to. I like when you try new things, because it ends up giving us gems like this. The shear production and music/singing accompaniment behind this really is rewarding even if this song doesn't reach people the same way FNaF does.
Having been looking through so much analog horror lately, seeing this has made me very happy! I would have never imagined that The Mandela Catalogue could have been a song, yet, here it is!
I'd really like to point out , that the song is almost 3:33 long (Ik 2 seconds more but its whatever) 333 Is a number which is present a lot of times in the Mandela Catalogue series , representing the number of angels.
The "That me is not me" being interrupted with "LIES" perfectly so it says "That me is not Lies" therefore saying that the "me" in question is the true person and not a alternate implies that the song is being tampered with by alternates just like the recordings in mandela catalogue
Okay, I think now is time to think of how I think you can tell if a person is a Alternate via their voice. If I remember correctly, a Alternate cannot perfectly mimic a human voice, and usually use things its victims have said and manipulate them to their needs. So I think that things like -incorrect sentence structure (due to the lack of knowledge of human language rules like the Maxims of conversation) -cracking voice tones -might sound like bad sentence mixing as alternates use the same property -repeting words/phrases -over use of common words or phrases And probably plenty more are signs of alternates speaking [God that was a lot to write] thanks for reading my tangent
actually, they can, if u consider the fact AltCeasar was able to deceive mark. low experienced ones might not know proper english, but they CAN perfectly mimic is a person.
I’m so glad you went with a different style for this one. The visuals were incredible, the vocals were awesomely put together, the instrumental was a perfect blend. Everything about this just hits differently and I love it
I must say, I really like the song, your voice, everything as always, but this time I don't even know what I feel, it's like nerves, but other than that, I don't even have a way to express myself! Really impressed with the song!
I saw this when it came out and now I am replying 50 minutes after, but anyways this was a great song and I am glad you used a lot of references to The Mandela Catalogue and the fact that you used your animated self and made it all distorted and deformed just like the alternates in series.
You need to make a song for the macabre experiment… it’s honestly my favorite current analog horror. It recreates old creepypastas and the story is that they were all failed experiments by a lab. It’s really cool and the lore goes even deeper than that. I’ve been a fan for years and would love to see this!!
I'm not even familiar with the Mandela catalogue and I love this. It's absolutely amazing, the vocals and the rhythm and the instrumentation and the harmony and everything is fantastic
I hope many other YT singers will follow your example and make a fan song of the Mandela Catalogue. Each of you always brings something unique about the same subject, so when one of you makes content about something I like, I always hope the others follow, too!!!
To be honest, you’ve improved, your doing wonderful like always, and always will be wonderful with your songs, this probably appeared in my recommended because I was watching too much Mandela catalogue-
This is amazing... I have never heard a musical production from TryHardNinja that is as good at this. This was a pleasant surprise! Keep up the amazing work 😁
I love how the scenes change very quickly and the fast paced tone of the song creates a feeling of actual anxiety. 11/10 Edit: Should I make this into a GCMV-
I love how many subtle references and quotes are in this! Each time I listen, I find a new one, and it's amazing to see and hear how much attention to detail you've put into the song and conjoining video. Thanks for this, it's a masterpiece!
God, your absolutely prolific music writing is such a BLESSING. I love pretty much all of your music and the amount you've created means I can seriously listen to it every day. This is also a banger, even if the thumbnail keeps creeping me out hahaha.
This is very incredible and phenomenal and adds onto the feel and aesthetic of Mandela Catalogue, Phenomenal Mandela Catalogue song TryHardNinja have a fantastic day
Please do a song of the macabre experiment! It’s honestly my favorite current analog horror series… the idea of remaking classic creepypastas in a new way and linking them together so they all contribute to the lore is amazing (your art is incredible)
I don't know why, but this song doesn't feel nor sounds completly like ninja's to me, which I think is actually a pretty cool detail, when talking about the alternates and don't even being sure about who the real singer is. If Ninja, or his doppleganger.
I still wonder if Alternates Can actually be killed, Probably not actually relevant to the story Kister is telling but still something I wonder, and if so How hard would it be? Anyway Great song as Usual.
I feel like the power required to kill Alternates would ultimately have costs that outweigh the benefits. I imagine most WMDs/nuclear weapons could probably dispose of one, but anything less isn't even worth trying.
Fun fact:if you are not scared of an alternate you can actually kill it whit hand to hand combat because as said in vol 1 they kill you by getting you to kill yourself
Me putting my headphones into my phone to listen to music. TH-cam- "Don't turn the volume up too much or your ears may suffer some damage!" Me- *turns the volume to max*
It's seriously one of the this sickest and excellent mandela catalogue song that you really done TryHardNinja you're really amazing when it comes to songs like this TryHardNinja but still marvelous work man
this changed the vibe i feel when i see anything about mandela catalogue. it’s like when you just learned about fnaf and listened to the first song. then you’re just like… “wow.” just me? can’t be
Since it's not FNaF people won't look at it that much and that's sad cuz oh boi that song was something else, TryHardNinja got us with another masterpiece
The idea of this is cool. We don’t actually know who is singing. In reality, it could be a deliberate trick. One of them could be the actual one singing, tricking us into thinking they are a real human. My brain hurts.
![(SFM) FNAF 4 SONG "Bringing Us Home" [OFFICIAL ANIMATION]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hTnfwPdFeY8/mqdefault.jpg)
WOW this is amazing!! I never thought I would get to a level where fan songs would be made. Thank you!!
Ayo alex is here
I am surprised this the first one
@@reignponce7946 not quite
Hey alex!!
Wow
I love the fact that we can't even verify that the singer is the orginal person. I really enjoyed this song, and the Mandela Cataloge never failes to intrest
Alex Kister made the Mandela Catalogue
Change your pfp to the new mark pic
Acualy he is an alternate this is proven at 2:33
Pause the video and then check the time stamp
@@f-o-oxib-b-oi1367 ok
the fact that his "character" shows up distressed sometimes is so cool
I really loved the subtle detail of a white stickman slightly warping his proportions. Great song as always!
omg I think it's the first of the TryHardNinja songs that left me in shock, it's incredible, the editing, the voices, the instrumental, the rhythm, even the animation, I love this work, your songs will mark a great trajectory, successes to you Igor🥺✌🏻❤🙊
:3
ok
interesting
+
@@Cat_Garfield a
“Familiar stranger”
Only just realised the juxtaposition in that🤔
fits with the doppelgänger context as well when I think about it, keep up the great work dude
That’s my face why do you have my f̷̧̡̢̨̗̪͖͖̱͇̝͉̼̖̼̯̽̔̀̏̓̂͑̀̇͐̚͝͝͝a̷̧͖̦̝̳̘̝͎̰̦͓͓̘̓͂̀́̐͌̃̌c̶̼̪͔̉̍́̎͂̿̎̎́͂̾̅̚͜͝ę̴̧̧̛͈̣̪̖̝̘̰̤̫̞̺͎̱̓͂̄͜
Yo that "Doppelganger demon in disguise" line was smooth
yea
"A familiar stranger in your room" was really smooth too
1:31
Was not expecting a Mandela catalog song. But safe to say it’s still an absolute banger!
🤔
Same here.
Am what is the catalog mandela?
@@deltagamer9754 it is an analog horror made by Alex Krister (look for his channel either in the comments, the description, or just use the search function
@@deltagamer9754 also note I was paranoid for 3 days after watching it so be warned
This song is probably this far one of my (if not) my favorite songs you have made!
I love the break from the usual indie horror game/FNAF inspired game shtick and dabbling into something new like Mandela Catalog.
I love all the references to stuff in the universe like the T.H.I.N.K protocol and M.A.D, I like how eerie some of the SFX is giving a real sense of hopelessness much like the situation in lore. Overall the song is a banger and really fits the source perfectly!
I 100% agree with you, keep up the amazing work as always tryhardninja
I read dabbling into something new as dabbing into something new
@@xxpromlggamerproxx YES
This was absolutely incredible, easily in my top 5 THN songs now. I don't really have words to describe how much of a banger this one is lol, fantastic work Igor
Terrifying (but fun) fact: Most of the unusual pictures are actual drawings made from cops
Yes you're right. Most of those pictures are actually either police sketches or computer generated pictures of criminals (Intruder as an example)
Yep! (Except for the images of the victims)
Now im even more scared of MC
Yeah, One is in the mr incredible becoming uncanny meme. It's really weird and questionable to pick for anything
@@mcribby2659 *YOU ARE NOW PARANOID FOR 5 YEARS*
Woah, this is pretty grand.
The song sets some high expectations for possible future Mandela Catalog songs to live up to. I like when you try new things, because it ends up giving us gems like this. The shear production and music/singing accompaniment behind this really is rewarding even if this song doesn't reach people the same way FNaF does.
I recommend "Oh funny!" If you heard that Mandala Catalogue song!
@@zacklee4851 Good recommendation(!)
I never expected to hear a Mendela Catalogue song but this absolutely rocks!
theres another one called "oh, funny" if you havent seen that one
It's called Mandela not mendella
@@yeetyeet1003 have you heard of a typo
@@yeetyeet1003 ironic how you mistyped his mistype
@@right_jar lol
EVEN IF IT WAS 8 MONTHS AGO ITS STILL A BANGER U CANT CHANGE MY MIND.
Edit: dayum it's one year old now???😨
even though it was 9 MONTHS ago-
I wont even try to change your opinion, it's a fact
@@addicted_to_coffee yeah
"Even if" bro since when did age make songs bad??
Having been looking through so much analog horror lately, seeing this has made me very happy! I would have never imagined that The Mandela Catalogue could have been a song, yet, here it is!
"Those discord screen shots are not me" gonna go hard 🔥
Ain't no way you come back to comment this bruh 💀
Shut it.
@@mrcoffi3439 Na
i swear it was just an alternate /s
I'd really like to point out , that the song is almost 3:33 long (Ik 2 seconds more but its whatever) 333 Is a number which is present a lot of times in the Mandela Catalogue series , representing the number of angels.
Oh wow
The "That me is not me" being interrupted with "LIES" perfectly so it says "That me is not Lies" therefore saying that the "me" in question is the true person and not a alternate implies that the song is being tampered with by alternates just like the recordings in mandela catalogue
Okay, I think now is time to think of how I think you can tell if a person is a Alternate via their voice. If I remember correctly, a Alternate cannot perfectly mimic a human voice, and usually use things its victims have said and manipulate them to their needs. So I think that things like
-incorrect sentence structure (due to the lack of knowledge of human language rules like the Maxims of conversation)
-cracking voice tones
-might sound like bad sentence mixing as alternates use the same property
-repeting words/phrases
-over use of common words or phrases
And probably plenty more are signs of alternates speaking
[God that was a lot to write] thanks for reading my tangent
Interesting so the second part of the song is a alternate signing
actually, they can, if u consider the fact AltCeasar was able to deceive mark. low experienced ones might not know proper english, but they CAN perfectly mimic is a person.
@@S2piditysFinest I like how how you make it so you $EEM like a human.
My obsession with Mandela catalogue is getting worse by the minute.
You and me both-
Especially with that Alt Gabriel
All 3 of us
yep, me too
I relate to your comment
@@yamaadu YES SAMEE
bro, it's been two years and this song is still so great, so much so that it gives me chills!!!
I’m so glad you went with a different style for this one. The visuals were incredible, the vocals were awesomely put together, the instrumental was a perfect blend. Everything about this just hits differently and I love it
"Evil never dies, it multiplies" WOWWWW
InTrEsTiNg
out of all things, mandela catalogue fan songs are one of the best pieces of music.
2:15 the melody after ,,it's gone"
This is why I'm wondering what the instrumental would be like
I love this song.
It fit The Mandela Catalogue perfectly ! Amazing work guys ! I love the lyrics and the music !
0:22 is my favorite part by far, i've been singing to myself constantly just because its so catchy
yea bro me too
Woahhh this is sick!!! Such a cool mix :)
I must say, I really like the song, your voice, everything as always, but this time I don't even know what I feel, it's like nerves, but other than that, I don't even have a way to express myself! Really impressed with the song!
I saw this when it came out and now I am replying 50 minutes after, but anyways this was a great song and I am glad you used a lot of references to The Mandela Catalogue and the fact that you used your animated self and made it all distorted and deformed just like the alternates in series.
I would love a concert of you singing this song. It sounds so amazing and I honestly would love seeing you sing
Imagine people suddenly disappearing in the concert
Then some deformed figures are in the crowd
@@Dave-nu4tt then you just turn your back to see people smiling at you
You need to make a song for the macabre experiment… it’s honestly my favorite current analog horror. It recreates old creepypastas and the story is that they were all failed experiments by a lab. It’s really cool and the lore goes even deeper than that. I’ve been a fan for years and would love to see this!!
This is for not a creepy pasta but for a horror series
I'm not even familiar with the Mandela catalogue and I love this. It's absolutely amazing, the vocals and the rhythm and the instrumentation and the harmony and everything is fantastic
Insert The Fact That I Am Also Not Knowing Of Mandela Catalogue
"Each time we defeat an enemy, they join our ranks." The Raven.
Coming Soon
Kilroy was here
I love how you make songs of things that no one was expecting!
2:10 I just can't take this part seriously.
Props to anyone who can figure out why
The frowning man at 2:15. Is it that
Sussy face
@@TheDragonFur About four seconds before that.
When the impostor is
When the imposter is sus.
One word...
amazing.
OK, I'm still stunned. Tryhardninja's songs are always really good, but this one it's just incredible
2:15 when TryHardNinja kept getting asked for More FNAF Songs
I hope many other YT singers will follow your example and make a fan song of the Mandela Catalogue. Each of you always brings something unique about the same subject, so when one of you makes content about something I like, I always hope the others follow, too!!!
To be honest, you’ve improved, your doing wonderful like always, and always will be wonderful with your songs, this probably appeared in my recommended because I was watching too much Mandela catalogue-
Surprising that the songs we don't expect always become the best
I just can't get over how 1:22 sounds
Me too
This was an unexpected surprise, but a very welcomed one. Loved the song. Definitely one of your best works!
despite my fear of Analog Horror this song is now my favorite..
The atmosphere of this song and just the attention to detail fits perfectly with the disturbing vibe. Excellent work as always!
This is amazing... I have never heard a musical production from TryHardNinja that is as good at this. This was a pleasant surprise! Keep up the amazing work 😁
I love how the scenes change very quickly and the fast paced tone of the song creates a feeling of actual anxiety. 11/10
Edit: Should I make this into a GCMV-
That's actually exactly what I was going for when I edited the video! I wanted the feeling to be a lil uneasy & anxious. I'm glad people like it 🥺💖
no, don't ruin a good song
@@KSKY2012 Understood
sure! i would like to see!
I love how many subtle references and quotes are in this! Each time I listen, I find a new one, and it's amazing to see and hear how much attention to detail you've put into the song and conjoining video. Thanks for this, it's a masterpiece!
friendly reminder
if you see someone identical to you
RUN away and HIDE
Twins: *there only room for one us*
HOLY THIS IS SO CATCHY! THE EDITING MAKES IT EVEN MORE ENJOYABLE GREAT WORK!
The part "That me is not me" Is the best!! Amazing video and animation too!
I like how it said familiar instead of you know because a type three alternate is very weird so you might not even know that it was supposed to be you
Don’t delete this
@@trumpgaming6783 no
@@trumpgaming6783 just because the creator is bad doesn’t mean that the whole series deserves to be forgotten
@@trumpgaming6783 separate creation from the creator.
@@tamsuemomwife what did they said?
@@BobTomato.Alex kister (Mandela catalogue creator) was accused of being a groomer but it was proven false
God, your absolutely prolific music writing is such a BLESSING. I love pretty much all of your music and the amount you've created means I can seriously listen to it every day. This is also a banger, even if the thumbnail keeps creeping me out hahaha.
I'm literally obsessed with this song. It's just so good thank you for this.
Wait what- a heart from Tryhardninja? Wow this is an honor...
One of my favorite analog series plus one of my favorite musicians = one of the greatest fan songs I’ve heard.
''that me is not me'' if someone told me this i would be freaking out, what a banger!
These are some of the best visuals I've seen come out of your music videos!
I completely forgot about this song. Im happy i found this again, it's still a Banger!
This is very incredible and phenomenal and adds onto the feel and aesthetic of Mandela Catalogue, Phenomenal Mandela Catalogue song TryHardNinja have a fantastic day
This man never fails to make us happy. Thank You.
Это слишком идеально, я хочу это пересматривать снова и снова, что и буду делать. ЭТО ШИКАРНО!!!!!!!(•̀ᴗ•́)
Здорово
Нифига даже русские есть!
@@chilsea_sm1le А как же? Конечно есть
@@chilsea_sm1le а ты чо думал нет
я каса н7а стриме по какой то игре заказал эту песню
согласна дорогуша
Bet! You finally made a Mandela catalogue song? Can you make a Walten Files song next?
Please do a song of the macabre experiment! It’s honestly my favorite current analog horror series… the idea of remaking classic creepypastas in a new way and linking them together so they all contribute to the lore is amazing (your art is incredible)
My mom forbade me to watch The Mandela Catalog and I still watched it in its entirety.
By the way, excellent, very good song.
No words can describe how incredible this song was! Well done everyone involved👏!
It’s been like a year and I still love this one
The beginning part of the chorus is really good! 1:22
This is awesome Igor! I’m sure the creator will be ecstatic :D
I don't know why, but this song doesn't feel nor sounds completly like ninja's to me, which I think is actually a pretty cool detail, when talking about the alternates and don't even being sure about who the real singer is. If Ninja, or his doppleganger.
To be honest, I didn't enjoyed it as much as the rest, but I certainly admire the amount of information, detail and effort, in it.
Yhis is honestly one of my favorite songs now
Can we take a second to admire how amazing the video looks
I still wonder if Alternates Can actually be killed, Probably not actually relevant to the story Kister is telling but still something I wonder, and if so How hard would it be? Anyway Great song as Usual.
no. dont even try. (im not an alternate wdym nobody questioned me? what? im trustworthy! i swear!)
I feel like the power required to kill Alternates would ultimately have costs that outweigh the benefits. I imagine most WMDs/nuclear weapons could probably dispose of one, but anything less isn't even worth trying.
T- Thrash them
H- Hit them in the jaw
I- Incapacitate them
N- Neutralize the enemy
K- Knock the mf out
they're a schrödinger type situation
they exist yet they don't at the same time so they are technically not even alive
Fun fact:if you are not scared of an alternate you can actually kill it whit hand to hand combat because as said in vol 1 they kill you by getting you to kill yourself
Happy 2nd Anniversary "That Me Is Not Me"
Me putting my headphones into my phone to listen to music. TH-cam- "Don't turn the volume up too much or your ears may suffer some damage!" Me- *turns the volume to max*
Me and the intruder vibing to this song at 5am:
It's seriously one of the this sickest and excellent mandela catalogue song that you really done TryHardNinja you're really amazing when it comes to songs like this TryHardNinja but still marvelous work man
"nice video, one small issue,im inside your home"
2:15 me seeing that YT recomended this to me 2 days later
Dude the editing is so cool can you teach me how to do that?
This man is the only one who make the best songs ever about horror...
TryHardNinja speed running through the Mandela Catalog like:
this changed the vibe i feel when i see anything about mandela catalogue. it’s like when you just learned about fnaf and listened to the first song. then you’re just like… “wow.” just me? can’t be
No one is lurking in your room's ceiling
Me: Thinking Tryhardninja can't make a better song than Salvaged Rage.
TryHardNinja: Releases "That Me Is Not Me"
Ninja, only about a week left until it’s 10 years since you sang “Used to Ruuuuule the World” are you excited? 💔
Masterpiece, I would actually have fewer problems reading the lyrics if there weren't so many edits tho!
I never expected to hear a Mendela Catalogue song but this absolutely rocks!😊
Where is the lyric guy for the mobil users?
*Ugh, really? a freaking [[TryHardNinja]] alternate?*
0:21 - 0:38 ...best part in this song, and there is no debate.
Since it's not FNaF people won't look at it that much and that's sad cuz oh boi that song was something else, TryHardNinja got us with another masterpiece
The editing is top tier dope
The idea of this is cool. We don’t actually know who is singing. In reality, it could be a deliberate trick. One of them could be the actual one singing, tricking us into thinking they are a real human. My brain hurts.
yeah, sick.
I don't know why, but every time you release a new song it adds bad to me, but after a while I love the song and I find it really good.
same!
New favourite!! Thank u for this bop
QUE PERFEITO! eu como uma viciada em catalogo mandela so digo que isso e uma perfeição ♡
Great. You are the best song creator from MANDELA CATALOGUE songs!